Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.09.17
18:18:51 +0530
CGHC010348212026
2026:CGHC:40295
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WP227 No. 1180 of 2026
1 - Sodhu Ram (Dead) Through Legal Representative Nil
1.1 - A. Tulsi Dewangan S/o Late Shri Sodhu Ram, Aged About 62 Years
R/o Champa, Hanuman Chowk, Dewangan Para, Rani Road, Champa,
Tah. Champa, Dist-Janjgir- Champa (C.G.)
1.2 - B.Chandrika @ Tarachand Dewangan S/o Late Shri Sodhu Ram, Aged
About 60 Years R/o Champa, Hanuman Chowk, Dewangan Para, Rani
Road, Champa, Tah. Champa, Dist-Janjgir- Champa (C.G.)
1.3 - C. Rajan Dewangan S/o Late Sodhu Ram Aged About 61 Years R/o
Champa, Hanuman Chowk, Dewangan Para, Rani Road, Champa, Tah.
Champa, Dist-Janjgir- Champa (C.G.)
1.4 - D. Mangalchand Dewangan, S/o Late Sodhu Ram, Aged About 58
Years R/o Champa, Hanuman Chowk, Dewangan Para, Rani Road,
Champa, Tah. Champa, Dist-Janjgir- Champa (C.G.)
1.5 - E. Indra Bai, D/o Late Shri Sodhu Ram, Aged About 62 Years R/o
Champa, Hanuman Chowk, Dewangan Para, Rani Road, Champa, Tah.
Champa, Dist-Janjgir- Champa (C.G.)
1.6 - F. Smt. Kamla Bai Dewangan, D/o Late Shri Sodhu Ram, W/o
Dhaneswar Dewangan Aged About 52 Years R/o Vill -Choriya, Sahu
Mohalla, Choriya, Tah. Champa, Dist -Janjgir -Champa (C.G.)
1.7 - G. Smt. Vimla Bai S/o Late Shri Sodhu Ram, W/o Mahadev
Dewangan, R/o Vill -Sothi, Tah. Champa, Dist -Janjgir -Champa (C.G.)
... Petitioners
versus
1 - Narayan Prasad S/o Dwarpal Dewangan Aged About 75 Years R/o
Champa, Hanuman Chowk, Dewangan Para, Rani Road, Champa, Tah,
Chama, Dist -Janjgir -Champa (C.G.)
2 - Horilal Dewangan, S/o Dwarpal Dewangan, Aged About 65 Years
Presently R/o In Front Of New Collge Building, Champa, Tah. Champa, Dist
-Janjgir -Champa (C.G.)
3 - Kamalchan Dewangan, S/o Late Shri Dwarpal Dewangan (Now Dead)
Through Legal Representative Nil
3.1 - A. Sushila Bai, W/o Late Shri Kamalchand Dewangan, Aged About 55
Years R/o Near Manjhali Talab, Beside Railway Line, Champa, Dist-Janjgir Champa (C.G.)
3.2 - B. Pappu, S/o Late Shri Kamalchand, Aged About 35 Years R/o Near
Manjhali Talab, Beside Railway Line, Champa, Dist-Janjgir -Champa (C.G.)
3.3 - C. Bali, S/o Late Shri Kamalchand Dewangan Aged About 35 Years
R/o Near Manjhali Talab, Beside Railway Line, Champa, Dist-Janjgir Champa (C.G.)
3.4 - D Ku. Puja, D/o Late Shri Kamalchan Dewangan Aged About 20 Years
R/o Near Manjhali Talab, Beside Railway Line, Champa, Dist-Janjgir Champa (C.G.)
4 - Rajni Bai, D/o Late Shri Dwarpal Dewangan, W/o Kaushal Prasad
Dewangan, Aged About 50 Years R/o Vill -Choriya, Tah. Champa, Dist Janjgir -Champa (C.G.)
5 - Smt. Radha Bai, D/o Late Shri Sodhu Ram,w/o Late Shri Vishram
Dewangan, Aged About 73 Years R/o Baigapara, Behind Police Station
Sakti, Tah Sakti, Now Dist -Sakti (C.G.)
6 - Shakun Bai, D/o Late Shri Sodhu Ramw/o Shri Domal Prasad
Dewangan, Aged About 70 Years R/o Vill- Suretha, Tah And Dist- Mungeli
(C.G.)
7 - Savitri Bai Dewangan D/o Late Shri Sodhu Ram, W/o Shri Beniram
Dewangan, Aged About 68 Years R/o Vill- Baloda, Near Halwai Chowk,
Baloda, Tah. Baloda, Dist -Janjgir -Champa (C.G.) (Cause Title As Per
Annexure P-11)
Respondents
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioners
:
Mr. Ravindra Sharma, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
15/09/2026
Heard.
1.
The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has
been preferred by the petitioners against the impugned order dated
30.07.2026, passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division,
Champa, District Janjgir-Champa, in Execution Case No. 72-A/1996,
whereby the learned Executing Court issued possession warrant in
execution of the judgment and decree dated 28.04.2001, passed in
civil suit No. 72-A/1996. The petitioners have claimed the following
reliefs in the writ petition:“10.1 That this Hon'ble court may kindly be
pleased to call the entire record of the Courts
below.
10.2 That this Hon'ble court may kindly be
pleased to issue a writ of CERTIORARI quashing
the order dated 30.07.2026 passed by Civil Judge
Senior Division Champa, Dist- Janjgir- Champa
(C.G.) in Execution Civil Suit No. 72-A/1996
(Annexure P-1).
10.3 That this Hon'ble court may kindly be
pleased to issue any writ or direction or order as
deem fit in the interest of justice.”
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that, earlier the
petitioners had challenged the order dated 24.06.2026 passed by
learned Executing Court, in Execution Case No. 5/2012 (Execution
Case No. 72-A/1996), which was dismissed by this Court on
17.07.2026, in WP(227) No. 846 of 2026, thereafter a report was
submitted by the Tehsildar, Champa on 30.07.2026 before the
learned Executing Court stating therein that on the spot there is no
Abadi Land found as per the map, which is the part of the decree for
its execution and there is difference in the map shown in the decree
as well as on the spot and therefore, without ascertaining the exact
location and identification of the disputed land, the possession
warrant cannot be issued. Yet the learned Executing Court issued
possession warrant for execution of the decree dated 28.04.2001. He
would refer the report dated 30.07.2026 (Annexure P/10), submitted
by the Tehsildar, Champa to the learned Executing Court. Since, the
disputed land as per the map annexed with the decree is not
available on the spot, the decree become inexecutable and the
possession warrant cannot be issued for the same, therefore, the
impugned order dated 30.07.2026 may be set aside.
3.
I have heard learned counsel for the petitioners and perused the
documents annexed with the petition.
4.
From perusal of the order dated 17.07.2026 passed by this Court in
WP(227) No. 846 of 2026, it transpires that the substantial objection
raised by the petitioners in the present writ petition with regard to the
identity of the subject land and execution of the decree has already
been raised by the petitioners and considered by this Court and the
same issue again raised by the petitioners in the present writ petition.
Though the present issue raised by the petitioners is based on the
report dated 30.07.2026 (Annexure P/10) submitted by the Tehsildar,
Champa, but the issue involved in the execution case appears to be
one and the same i.e. the identification of the subject land. The said
issue has already been considered in the said WP(227) No. 846 of
2026. It is necessary here to take note of the order dated 17.07.2026
passed in WP(227) No. 846 of 2026:“4. The petitioner could not dispute the fact that
the decree for possession of the suit property, as
shown in the plaint map, has been passed
against the defendants vide judgment and decree
dated 28.04.2001 passed by the learned trial
Court in Civil Suit No. 72-A/1996. The first Appeal
No. 5-A/2004 has also been dismissed by the first
appellate Court vide its judgment and decree
dated 23.08.2004, and then the Second Appeal
No. 446/2004 has also been dismissed by the
coordinate bench of this Court vide order dated
19.02.2007, and thus the judgment and decree
dated 28.04.2001 attains its finality. The plaintiff's
case before the learned trial court was that the
subject property of the plaint map ABCDEF part is
the Abadi land which was purchased by all three
brothers in the year 1948 and a memorandum of
partition
was
executed
on
16.03.1954.
Accordingly, the parties are in possession of their
respective share of the property. The subject
house was abundant since 2024-2025 years back
and then the defendant No. 1 tried to possess the
same, and a dispute arose between the parties,
and a suit has been filed. The defence of the
defendants was that the plaint map annexed by
the plaintiff is incorrect as the 0.02 acres of land
of Khasra Nos. 839 and 840 of the defendants
also come under the ABCDEF part of the map
annexed to the plaint, and the said land belongs
to the defendant. It was the case of the defendant
before the learned trial Court that, their part of the
land was also included in the suit land, and an
incorrect map had been presented by the plaintiff
in the suit.
5. The learned trial Court, after considering the
pleadings of the respective parties, has framed
13 issues and after providing opportunity to lead
evidence with respect to their pleadings and after
conclusion of the trial, decided the suit by
allowing the claim of the plaintiffs for delivery of
possession of the subject property. Despite the
clear defence of the defendants, the learned trial
Court considered that the plaintiffs are entitled to
possession of ABCDEF part of the property
shown in the plaint map. The said judgment and
decree have been upheld up to the High Court.
6. In the case of "Brakewel Automotive
Components (India) (P) Ltd. v. P.R. Selvam
Alagappan", 2017 (5) SCC 371, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has held that:"20. It is no longer res integra that an
executing court can neither travel behind
the decree nor sit in appeal over the same
or pass any order jeopardising the rights of
the parties thereunder. It is only in the
limited cases where the decree is by a
court lacking inherent jurisdiction or is a
nullity that the same is rendered non est
and is thus unexecutable. An erroneous
decree cannot be equalled with one which
is a nullity. There are no intervening
developments as well to render the decree
unexecutable.
21. As it is, Section 47 of the Code
mandates determination by an executing
court, questions arising between the parties
or their representatives relating to the
execution, discharge or satisfaction of the
decree and does not contemplate any
adjudication beyond the same. A decree of
court of law being sacrosanct in nature, the
execution thereof ought not to be thwarted
on mere asking and on untenable and
purported grounds having no bearing on
the validity or the executability thereof.
22. Judicial precedents to the effect that the
purview of scrutiny under Section 47 of the
Code qua a decree is limited to objections
to its executability on the ground of
jurisdictional
infirmity
or
voidness
are
plethoric. This Court, amongst others in
Vasudev Dhanjibhai Modi v. Rajabhai Abdul
Rehman, in essence enunciated that only a
decree which is a nullity can be the subjectmatter of objection under Section 47 of the
Code and not one which is erroneous either
in law or on facts. The following extract
from this decision seems apt: (SCC pp.
672-73, paras 6-7)"
"6. A court executing a decree cannot go
behind the decree: between the parties or
their representatives it must take the
decree according to its tenor, and cannot
entertain any objection that the decree was
incorrect in law or on facts. Until it is set
aside by an appropriate proceeding in
appeal or revision, a decree even if it be
erroneous is still binding between the
parties.
7. When a decree which is a nullity, for
instance,
where
it
is passed without
bringing the legal representative on the
record of a person who was dead at the
date of the decree, or against a ruling
prince without a certificate, is sought to be
executed an objection in that behalf may be
raised in a proceeding for execution. Again,
when the decree is made by a court which
has no inherent jurisdiction to make it,
objection as to its validity may be raised in
an execution proceeding if the objection
appears on the face of the record: where
the objection as to the jurisdiction of the
court to pass the decree does not appear
on the face of the record and requires
examination of the questions raised and
decided at the trial or which could have
been but have not been raised, the
executing court will have no jurisdiction to
entertain an objection as to the validity of
the decree even on the ground of absence
of jurisdiction."
7. When the judgment and decree have been
passed by the learned trial Court and upheld up
to the High Court with respect to the delivery of
possession of ABCDEF part shown in the plaint
map, the decree is required to be executed in its
terms for delivery of possession of the property
shown in the plaint map. The petitioners tried to
demonstrate from the document Annexure P/10
that ABCDEF part of the subject property is not in
existence in its four corners on the spot, and
therefore, the decree could not be executed, but
considering the report submitted by the Revenue
Authorities, the learned Executing Court passed
an order on 20.04.2026 that before proceeding
further,
the
subject
property
should
be
ascertained first and then only proceed for
execution. The suit was filed in the year 1999,
and the report was submitted by the Revenue
Authorities in the year 2026. In the long gap of 27
years, the four corners of the subject land might
have some discrepancy, but the decree is still in
force for possession of the subject property of
ABCDEF part of the plaint map.
8. It is well settled that an executing Court is
bound to execute the decree as it stands and
cannot travel beyond its terms or reopen issues
which have already attained finality in the original
proceedings. The executing Court is competent to
interpret the decree only to the extent necessary
for its implementation, but it cannot question its
correctness, modify its scope or adjudicate afresh
upon matters that were or could have been
decided by the trial Court. In the present case,
the plea now raised by the petitioners that the
plaint map is incorrect, that the suit property is not
identifiable on the spot, or that part of their land
has been wrongly included in the ABCDEF
portion of the map, was not a new issue arising
during execution. The record reveals that the
defendants had specifically taken the same
defence before the trial Court, contending that the
plaint map incorrectly included a portion of their
land comprised in Khasra Nos. 839 and 840. The
said objection was considered during the trial,
and despite such defence, the suit for possession
of the ABCDEF portion shown in the plaint map
was decreed. The decree has thereafter been
affirmed in the first appeal as well as the second
appeal and has thus attained finality. Once the
identity of the suit property, as described in the
decree read with the plaint map, has been finally
adjudicated, the same issue cannot be permitted
to be reagitated under the guise of an objection in
execution. The executing Court has rightly
confined itself to implementing the decree and,
after obtaining the report of the Revenue
Authorities for facilitating execution, rejected the
objection. Merely because, after a lapse of
several years, some variation is alleged on the
spot
regarding
the
physical
features
or
boundaries of the property, the decree does not
become
inexecutable,
particularly
when
its
identity has already been conclusively determined
by the competent civil court.
9. From the overall consideration of the facts and
circumstances of the case and the documents
annexed with the petition, I do not find any
palpable infirmity or jurisdictional error in the
impugned order passed by the learned Executing
Court, which warrants interference in the present
writ petition.”
5.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds that the judgment
and decree dated 28.04.2001 passed in Civil Suit No. 72-A/1996,
having been affirmed in appeal and second appeal, has attained
finality and continues to remain operative. The objection raised by the
petitioners regarding the identity and identification of the subject
property, including the alleged discrepancy between the plaint map
and the physical features existing at the spot, had already been
considered in the earlier proceedings and cannot be permitted to be
reagitated in the present petition. The subsequent report of the
Tehsildar dated 30.07.2026 does not render the decree inexecutable,
nor does it disclose any jurisdictional infirmity or nullity in the decree.
The learned Executing Court, while proceeding to execute the decree
in terms thereof, has not travelled beyond the scope of the decree.
6.
Consequently, this Court does not find any palpable infirmity, illegality
or jurisdictional error in the impugned order dated 30.07.2026 passed
by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Champa, District JanjgirChampa, warranting interference under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India.
7.
The present writ petition, being devoid of merit, is accordingly
dismissed.
8.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review