Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010205342019
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6566/2019
SOBHA BISWAS @ SHOVA RANI SEN
D/O- LT BIRENDRA CHANDRA SEN, W/O- SRI BIMAL BISWAS, R/OSARUPATGAON, P.O. KHELMATI, P.S. CHARIDHAR, DIST- SONITPUR, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
THROUGH THE SECY., TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA, THE MINISTRY OF HOME
AFFAIRS, GRIHA MANTRALAYA, SHASTRI BHAWAN, TILAK MARG, NEW
DELHI- 110001
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
THROUGH- THE COMM. AND SECY.
TO THE GOVT.. OF ASSAM
HOME AND POLITICAL DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY-6
3:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
REP. BY THE CHIEF ELECTION COMMISSIONER OF INDIA
NIRVACHAN SADAN ASHOKA ROAD
NEW DELHI- 110001
4:THE STATE CO-ORDINATOR
NATIONAL REGISTRATION OF CITIZEN
ASSAM
BHANGAGARH
GHY-5
5:THE DY. COMMISSIONER
SONITPUR
P.O. TEZPUR
Page No.# 2/7
DIST- SONITPUR
ASSAM
PIN- 784001
6:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
SONITPUR
P.O. TEZPUR
DIST- SONITPUR
ASSAM
PIN- 78400
Advocate for the Petitioner
DAS,MS. S F MAITAI
: MR. S C BISWAS, MS P DIHINGIA,MR. F A HASSAN,MS A
Advocate for the Respondent : ASSTT.S.G.I., SC, NRC,SC, ELECTION COMMISSION.,SC, F.T
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND
ORDER
Date : 29.07.2026
(K.R. Surana, J)
Heard Mr. F.A. Hassan, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. I.
Borthakur, learned CGC; Mr. N. Kalita, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr.
A.I. Ali, learned standing counsel for the ECI; Ms. A. Verma, learned standing
counsel for the FT matters and NRC; and Mr. P. Sarmah, learned Additional
Senior Govt. Advocate for respondent.
2.
By filing this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
Page No.# 3/7
the petitioner, namely, Sobha Biswas @ Shova Rani Sen, has assailed the
impugned opinion dated 27.02.2019, passed by the learned Member, Foreigners’
Tribunal, 7th Sonitpur, Balipara, in. Case No. FTDC 664/16, arising out of Ref
TZP/(B)/1046/07, dated 28.03.07, by which the petitioner was declared as an
illegal migrant.
3.
Pursuant to receipt of notice the petitioner appeared before the learned
Tribunal and filed her written statement, where apart from usual denial, the
petitioner had stated that she was born and brought up at village-Lulukai, P.SDhekiajuli, in the district of Sonitpur, Assam and she had studied in Aurobindo
Bidya Niketan, Lulukai, No.2 Pirakata in the district of Sonitpur upto Class-VI and
left the school on 31.12.1971 and according to the admission register, her date of
birth is 04.05.1979 and the Head Master of the said school had issued her
transfer certificate vide Sl No.754 dated 09.06.2005, where her name was
recorded as Shoba Rani Sen and her father’s name was recorded as Birendra Ch.
Sen. She got married about 20 years back to Sri Bimal Biswas of villageSarupatgaon, P.S-Tezpur, in the district of Sonitpur, Assam and since her marriage
she has been residing at her matrimonial place of residence and permanently
using her paternal surname “Sen”. The Lat Gaonburah of village-Lulukai has
issued a certificate regarding her marriage. Her parents had casted their vote
and their names appeared in the voter list of 1965 of the same village under
No.76 Missamari LAC. Her father died about 30 years back and in his lifetime he
had purchased a plot of land and was paying land revenue for the same and her
mother is presently a voter of 72 No. Barchala LAC. Accordingly, the petitioner
claimed to be an Indian citizen and not a foreigner.
4.
In support of her defence, the petitioner had filed her evidence-on-
affidavit and while reiterating the statements made in the written statement, had
Page No.# 4/7
exhibited the school certificate dated 09.06.2005 as Ext.A; PAN Card as Ext.B;
her mother’s Elector Photo Identity Card as Ext.C and her mother’s PAN Card as
Ext.D and the voter detail of 1965 showing the name of her father (Ext.E). The
petitioner, while examining herself as DW-1, on the Tribunal’s query as to
whether her family had been proceeded in the Foreigners Tribunal, she replied in
the negative.
5.
The learned Tribunal, on appreciating the pleadings and evidence on
record rejected the school certificate (Ext.A) in light of the decision of the
Supreme Court of India in the case of Birad Mal Singhvi Vs. Anand Purohit, 1988
Supp SCC 604, by holding that the school certificate has no evidentiary value
unless the person who made the entry or gave the information relating to the
date of birth is examined. In this case the issuing authority had not been
examined along with the admission register to prove the entries. The PAN Card
of the petitioner (Ext.B) and her mother (Ext.D) were rejected as they were not
Income Tax payees and did not exhibit any Income Tax return and in this regard
reliance was placed in the case of Narmada Devi Gupta Vs. Birendra Kr. Jaiswal
(2003) 8 SCC 475. Accordingly, as the Elector Photo Identity Card has been held
to be not a sufficient supporting document for citizenship in the case of Babul
Islam Vs. State of Assam and Ors., WP(C)/3547/2016, decided on 09.05.2018, it
was held that the said identity card would not be a proof of citizenship.
Accordingly, the petitioner was held to be a foreigner of post 25.03.1971 stream.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioner had referred to the exhibited
documents and had submitted that as the petitioner would exhibit the voter list
of 1965 which contains the name of her father Birendra Ch. Sen son of Bijoy and
the link of the petitioner to her projected father can be proved through the
school certificate (Ext.A) and that the PAN Card containing the name of her
Page No.# 5/7
father (Ext.B) and submitted that the petitioner was not a foreigner of post
25.03.1971 stream.
7.
Opposing the challenge the learned standing counsel for the FT and
Border matters has made his submissions in support of the impugned opinion
and has stated that the petitioner has failed to establish her link with the persons
whose names appeared in the voter detail of 1965 (Ext.E).
8.
Considering the submission made at the bar and also perused the
records of the learned Tribunal, which was called for.
9.
On a perusal of the records, it appears that the documents which were
proved as Ext.E is the NRC voter detail, which the petitioner claims to be the
voter detail of the year 1965. It is well settled that the NRC voter detail is not
proof of citizenship. In this case the copy of Ext.E available in the record
disclosed that it has an image Id: 19206699 and it is further stated that the same
is generated by DLDD version 2.5, which is sufficient to indicate that this is a
computer print out from the voter detail available in the website of the State Coordinator of National Register of Citizens. Therefore, being a the computer
generated print out, the provision of Section 65-B of the Evidence Act, 1872 be
applicable and computer generated print out has to be proved in the manner
prescribed thereunder, which was not done. Therefore, Ext. E does not have any
evidentiary value.
10.
The learned Tribunal had rightly rejected the evidentiary value of the
school certificate (Ext.A) as the author of the certificate did not come and depose
along with the school admission register which is the primary evidence and the
transfer certificate would be secondary evidence.
11.
The PAN Card (Ext.B) and (Ext.D) as well as the Elector Photo Identity
Card of the petitioner’s mother (Ext.C) were all post 25.03.1971 documents and
Page No.# 6/7
in this case the petitioner has not disclosed anything which indicates that she or
her mother are an Income Tax Payees. Therefore, the entries in the PAN Card
were as per the disclosure made by the petitioner. This Court in the case of
Musstt. Rubiya Khautun Vs. Union of India and Ors., WP(C)/4986/2016, decided
on 09.02.2018, held that the PAN Card is not a trustworthy document for proof
of citizenship more so when the proceedee is not an Income Tax payee and it
was further held that the PAN Card was not proved by calling the Income Tax
Officials regarding the application for the PAN Card. It was further held that if the
PAN Card contains the date of birth, the petitioner should have mentioned it in
her written statement. In this case as per the entries contained in the school
certificate (Ext.A), the date of birth of the petitioner is recorded as 04.05.1979
whereas in the PAN Card (Ext.B) the date of birth of the petitioner is recorded as
04.09.1979. Thus, there appears to be a variation in the date of birth of the
petitioner.
12.
Be that as it may, the petitioner had not exhibited the voter list of 1965
wherein she claims that the name of her father is recorded. The existence of her
father and her mother is not disclosed in any documents produced by the
petitioner. The petitioner has not disclosed the date of death of her father and
about the continuous stay of the parents of the petitioner after 1965 and their
names continuously appearing in any voter list together after 1965. The
petitioner has also not disclosed anything regarding her grandparents, the
siblings of her father or her own siblings.
13.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered opinion that there is no
infirmity in the impugned opinion rendered by the learned Tribunal as the
exhibited documents could not link the petitioner to her projected parents.
14.
Resultantly, the challenge made in this writ petition fails and the writ
Page No.# 7/7
petition is dismissed.
15.
The consequences of the said opinion shall follow.
16.
The Registry shall return back the Tribunals records along with a copy of
this order to be made a part of record by the said learned Tribunal.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review