Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010216592025
2026:GAU-AS:9046
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT AT GUWAHATI
(The High Court of Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh)
PRINCIPAL SEAT AT GUWAHATI
WP(C) No. 5788/2025
1.
SNOWFALL AGRO PRODUCTS PVT LIMITED
A private limited company duly incorporated under
the provisions of Indian Companies Act, 1956 and
having its registered office at Ekta Floral, Block-03,
Christopher Road, Kolkata-700046, West Bengal,
And its corporate office at House No. 17,
Gayatrikunj, Chitralekha Lane, Supermarket, Dispur,
Guwahati-781006, Assam.
……Petitioner
-Versus1.
THE STATE OF ASSAM, represented by the
Commissioner & Secretary, Department of Labour
Welfare and Employment, Dispur, Guwahati-781006.
2.
THE SECRETARY CUM COMMISSIONER, Board
of Trustees, Nidhi Bhawan, Basistha, Lalmati,
Guwahat-781029, Kamrup (M), Assam.
3.
THE RECOVERY OFFICER, Assam Tea Employees
Provident Fund Organization, Nidhi Bhawan,
Basistha, Lalmati, N.H. 37, Guwahati-781029, Kamrup
(M), Assam.
……Respondents.
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Deka, Adv.
……Advocate(s)
For the Respondent(s)
WP(C)/5788/2025
:
Mr. P. Nayak, Adv.
Mr. G. Bokolial, Adv.
……Advocate(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
Date(s) of Hearing
:-
27.03.2026
Date on which judgment is reserved
:-
27.03.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:-
23.06.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment?
:-
N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
:-
Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
(A.M. Kalita, J)
Heard Mr. P. Deka, the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. G. Bokolial, the learned Junior Government
Advocate for respondent No. 1 and Mr. P. Nayak, the learned counsel
appearing for respondent Nos. 2 and 3.
2.
The instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioner, i.e.,
Snowfall Agro Industries Private Limited, assailing the impugned letter
bearing No. PF/2025/Recovery/01, dated 11.06.2025, issued by the
respondent No. 3, i.e., the Recovery Officer, Assam Tea Employees
Provident Fund Organization, Assam, whereby the application filed by
the petitioner dated 08.04.2023 for recalling of the order dated
04.04.2023, issued by the respondent No. 3 was rejected.
3.
By filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for
the following reliefs:
WP(C)/5788/2025
(1) may be pleased to call for records, issue a rule calling upon
the respondent authorities to show cause as to why a writ in the
nature of mandamus be not issued directing the respondents to
cancel, recall, or otherwise forbear from giving effect to the
impugned letter bearing number PF/2025/Recovery/01 dated
11.06.2025, issued by the respondent No. 3 to the effect that the
respondent
authorities,
despite
acknowledging
that
the
petitioner is not a defaulter, refused to recall the order dated
04.04.2023 and give the possession of Fatemabad Tea Estate to
the petitioner, being the highest bidder in the auction process.
And/or
(2) why a writ in the nature of certiorari be not issued setting
aside and quashing the impugned letter bearing number
PF/2025/Recovery/01,
dated
11.6.2025,
issued
by
the
respondent No. 3, specially to the effect that "However, in view of
the sensitive nature of the matter and issuance of earlier
communication dated 04.04.2023 and as the EMD has already
been refunded, the order dated 04.04.2023 is not recalled."
And/or
(3) why a writ in the nature of certiorari shall not be issued to
set aside/quash the impugned communication bearing No.
PF/PG/2023/Rec.Off/10-11, dated 04.04.2023, issued by the
respondent No. 3 by way of which the bid of the petitioner was
illegally cancelled.
And/or
(4) why a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order
or direction commanding the respondent authorities to hand
over the management of the Fatemabad Tea Estate to the
WP(C)/5788/2025
petitioner, in view of the admission made in the impugned letter
bearing No. PF/2025/Recovery/01, dated 11.06.2025, issued by
the respondent No. 3 that the petitioner does not suffer from any
disqualification and is not a defaulter.
And/or
(5) hold the respondents' refusal to restore possession of
Fatemabad Tea Estate to the petitioner, despite acknowledging
that the petitioner is neither disqualified nor a defaulter, is
arbitrary, discriminatory, and in violation of fundamental rights.
And/or
(6)
pass such further order or other order(s) as Your
Lordships may deem fit and proper.
4.
The facts giving rise to the instant writ petition are summarized
herein below: The petitioner is a private limited company duly
incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956,
with its registered office located in Kolkata and its corporate
office situated in Guwahati, Assam.
In the district of Baksa, within the Bodoland Territorial
Autonomous Districts (BTAD), a tea estate, namely, Fatemabad
Tea Estate, owned by M/s. Choudhury Tea and Agro Industries
Private Limited, having defaulted grossly in payment of
provident fund (PF contributions), and other statutory dues, the
authorized officer acting under the provisions of the Assam Tea
Plantations Provident Fund Scheme Act, 1955, issued a
certificate declaring that a sum of Rs. 3,75,69,556.53/- (Rupees
Three Crores Seventy-Five Lakhs Sixty-Nine Thousand Five
WP(C)/5788/2025
Hundred Fifty-Six and Fifty-Three Paisa only) was outstanding as
arrears against the tea estate.
In consequence thereof, the Recovery Officer, i.e., the
respondent No. 3 herein, issued a notice of attachment dated
05.12.2017, thereby attaching the aforesaid tea estate.
In terms of the provisions of Assam Tea Plantations
Provident Fund, Pension Fund and Insurance Fund Scheme Act,
1955, (hereinafter referred to as the Act of 1955), the
respondent No. 3 appointed one Shri Yatendra Singh as manager
of the tea estate, vide an agreement dated 04.01.2020. However,
subsequently, Shri Rajesh Kumar Jalan was appointed as the
manager to manage the tea estate, vide an agreement dated
22.12.2021 and to facilitate the recovery of outstanding arrears,
including the provident fund dues.
Thereafter, in exercise of powers conferred under Section
15(B)(1) of the said Act of 1955, the respondent No. 3 issued an
e-auction sale notice dated 06.12.2022 for the sale of immovable
properties belonging to the Fatemabad Tea Estate. In the said
notice, the reserve price was fixed at Rs. 16,50,17,000/- (Rupees
Sixteen Crores Fifty Lakhs Seventeen Thousand only) and the
date and time for e-auction was scheduled on 09.01.2023
between 1:00 PM to 3:00 PM. However, subsequently, the
respondents extended the date of e-auction till 14.03.2023.
In response to the aforesaid e-auction sale notice dated
06.12.2022, the petitioner, being interested in purchasing the
aforesaid Fatemabad Tea Estate, submitted its bid through eauction platform, quoting an amount of Rs. 16,65,17,000/(Rupees Sixteen Crores Sixty-Five Lakhs Seventeen Thousand
WP(C)/5788/2025
only). Besides the petitioner, another party, namely, Panther
Dealcom Private Limited, had also submitted its bid by quoting
an amount of Rs. 16,63,17,000/- (Rupees Sixteen Crores SixtyThree Lakhs Seventeen Thousand only). On closure of the
bidding process, it was revealed that the petitioner and the
aforesaid company, i.e., Panther Dealcom Private Limited, were
the only two participants in the e-auction and the petitioner
emerged as the highest bidder, which could be evident from the
webpage containing the e-auction report and auction summary
as published by the respondents.
After the aforesaid process, the respondent No. 3, vide its
letter dated 15.03.2023, informed the petitioner that its bid in
respect of the e-auction for Fatemabad Tea Estate had been
evaluated as the highest bid at the quoted amount of Rs.
16,65,17,000/- and the petitioner was directed to deposit 25% of
the quoted amount, i.e., Rs. 4,16,29,250/- (Rupees Four Crores
Sixteen Lakhs Twenty-Nine Thousand Two Hundred Fifty only),
within a period of 48 hours.
In terms of the aforesaid letter dated 15.03.2023, the
petitioner, vide its communication dated 17.03.2023, deposited
an amount of Rs. 4,16,29,250/-, being 25% of the quoted bid
amount, through the following cheques: (i) Cheque No. 108056 dated 17.03.2023 drawn on Federal
Bank for Rs. 1,16,29,250/-;
(ii) Cheque No. 108057 dated 17.03.2023 drawn on
Federal Bank for Rs. 1,50,00,000/-;
(iii) Cheque No. 108058 dated 17.03.2023 drawn on
Federal Bank for Rs. 1,50,00,000/-.
WP(C)/5788/2025
However, on the very same date, i.e., 17.03.2023, the
respondent no. 3 informed the petitioner that the e-auction
process for the sale of the properties of Fatemabad Tea Estate
had been put on hold due to certain technical reasons and
advised the petitioner not to deposit the 25% of the quoted bid
amount. Thereafter, the petitioner approached the respondent
authorities with requests to finalize the sale of Fatemabad Tea
Estate in its favor since the petitioner had become the highest
bidder and also due to the fact that the petitioner had already
complied with the request made by the respondent No. 3 by his
letter dated 15.03.2023 and thereby, deposited the 25% of the
bid amount, i.e., Rs. 4,16,29,250/-. However, the respondent
authorities conveyed to the petitioner that the e-auction process
had been temporarily put on hold due to certain technical
reasons and the same will be resolved soon.
The respondent No. 3 issued the letter dated 04.04.2023
bearing number PF/PG/2023/Rec.Off/10-11, to the petitioner,
wherein it had been stated that upon scrutiny of the petitioner's
bid and other relevant documents, it was found that the
petitioner had failed to comply with the terms and conditions
laid down in Clause XIV of the e-auction notice dated 6.12.2022
and accordingly, the petitioner's bid had been treated as
canceled.
The petitioner was verbally informed that one of its
directors, Sri Rajesh Kumar Jalan, had entered into an agreement
with respondent No. 3 for the management of the tea estate on
22.12.2021, and he, being a defaulter in payment of provident
fund dues, the bid of the petitioner was canceled.
WP(C)/5788/2025
The petitioner, vide a representation dated 08.04.2023,
requested respondent No. 3 to reconsider and recall its decision
to cancel the petitioner's bid under Clause XIV of the e-auction
notice dated 06.12.2022 and to finalize the e-auction sale in
favor of the petitioner.
On 26.04.2023, the respondent authorities refunded the
earnest money to the petitioner through RTGS mode directly to
the petitioner's account, to which, on 28.04.2023, the petitioner
submitted an objection regarding the aforesaid refund as the
same being done without any intimation or communication to
the petitioner.
Since
no
response
was
received
as
against
the
representation dated 08.04.2023 filed by the petitioner from the
respondent authorities, the petitioner filed a writ petition before
the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court bearing W.P.(C) No. 2340 of
2023, praying for quashing and/or cancellation of the
communication dated 04.04.2023 and also prayed for a direction
to the respondent authorities to finalize the e-auction sale of
Fatemabad Tea Estate in favor of the petitioner.
The aforesaid writ petition was disposed of by the Hon’ble
Gauhati High Court on 10.05.2023, directing the respondent No.
3 to examine and take a reasoned decision on the petitioner's
representation dated 08.04.2023 within a period of one month
from the date of the order.
The Hon’ble Gauhati High Court further directed that till
such time a final decision is taken by respondent No. 3, the
auction sale of the Fatemabad Tea Estate shall not be finalized in
favor of any other party.
WP(C)/5788/2025
The petitioner had duly served the order dated 10.05.2023
upon respondent No. 3, which was duly received by respondent
No. 3 on 22.05.2023. However, respondent No. 3 did not take any
decision nor communicated any outcome to the petitioner till
date. The petitioner, in fact, had submitted several reminders to
respondent No. 3, urging compliance of the directions issued by
the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court. Some of the reminders
submitted by the petitioner were of 10.06.2023 and 10.12.2024.
Faced with the aforesaid indifferent attitude from the
respondent authorities, the petitioner approached the Hon’ble
Gauhati High Court again by way of filing W.P.(C) No.
2383/2025, seeking enforcement and appropriate direction in
respect to the representation/reminders made by the petitioner
between 10.06.2023 to 10.12.2024.
The Hon’ble Gauhati High Court, vide its order dated
14.05.2025, disposed of the W.P.(C) No. 2383/2025 once again
directing the respondent No. 3 to dispose of the petitioner's
representation dated 08.04.2023 within a period of three weeks
from the receipt of the said order.
The respondent No. 3, thereafter, disposed of the
petitioner's representation dated 08.04.2023, vide a letter
bearing No. PF/2025/Recovery/01, dated 11.06.2025, addressed
to the petitioner, whereby the respondent had chosen not to
recall the earlier cancellation order dated 04.04.2023 on the
alleged ground that the matter was sensitive in nature and the
Earnest Money Deposit (EMD) had already been refunded to the
petitioner.
WP(C)/5788/2025
The
petitioner,
being
aggrieved
by
the
aforesaid
communication dated 11.06.2025, has filed the instant writ
petition.
5.
This court, vide order dated 26.09.2025, issued notice to the
respondents, however, no interim order, as prayed for by the
petitioner, was passed in the instant case.
6.
An affidavit-in-opposition has been filed by respondent No. 2,
which has been replied to by the petitioner by filing an affidavit-inreply.
7.
Mr. P. Deka, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner,
submits that the impugned letter bearing No. PF/2025/Recovery/01,
dated
11.06.2025,
purportedly
disposing
the
petitioner's
representation, is not only arbitrary and perverse, but it appears to
have been issued with clear mala fide intent. He submits that, on one
hand, the respondent unequivocally admits that there is no conclusive
material to hold the petitioner disqualified under clause XIV of the eauction notice, and at the same time, on the other hand, despite such
admission, they refused to restore the allotment or recall the
cancellation solely on the ground that the EMD has been refunded. He
submits that such two different stands cannot stand together and be
legally sustained. He submits that the other ground taken by the
respondents about the sensitivity of the matter is untenable in law and
the same portrays a deliberate strategy to deprive the petitioner of its
rightful claim to the Fatemabad Tea Estate. He submits that no record
has been brought on by the respondents about any sensitivity in the
matter. He submits that mere arbitrary assumption of respondent No.
3 that the matter is sensitive cannot be used as a ground to deprive the
petitioner of its legitimate right to get the allotment of Fatemabad Tea
Estate. He submits that if the basis for cancellation, i.e., the alleged
WP(C)/5788/2025
disqualification, no longer survives, the cancellation order must
necessarily fall and the process must revert to its lawful culmination in
favor of the highest bidder, i.e., the petitioner. The learned counsel
submits that the refund of EMD was made on 26.04.2023 unilaterally
by the respondents immediately after issuing an illegal cancellation
order. He submits that the aforesaid refund was made through RTGS
mode directly to the petitioner's account without taking any consent or
communication from the petitioner. He submits that the petitioner
immediately objected to the aforesaid transaction through the
petitioner's letter dated 28.04.2023. He submits that such an unilateral
refund of EMD cannot be used as a ground to deny the petitioner of the
fruits of public auction, wherein the petitioner has been declared as the
highest bidder.
8.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that aforesaid
Rajesh Kumar Jalan, in his individual capacity, was entrusted with the
management of Fatemabad Tea Estate pursuant to an agreement dated
22.12.2021. As per Clause 18 of the said agreement, it was expressly
recorded that the aforesaid Rajesh Kumar Jalan or his sister concern,
having
invested
significant
capital
towards
the
revival
and
development of the garden, shall be treated as a secured creditor in the
event of any e-auction issued during the validity of the agreement. He
submits that the said agreement was valid for a period of three years
and was subsisting at the time of issuance of the e-auction notice dated
06.12.2022. He submits that the contractual agreement dated
22.12.2021 between the respondents and one of the directors of the
petitioner company, namely Rajesh Kumar Jalan, has nothing to do
with the action of the respondents in issuing the communication dated
04.04.2023, vide which the petitioner’s bid has been treated as
cancelled. He submits that said Rajesh Kumar Jalan had executed the
WP(C)/5788/2025
agreement in his personal capacity and as such, the petitioner and
Rajesh Kumar Jalan does not stand in the same platform. He further
submits that Rajesh Kumar Jalan had, in fact, filed a civil suit regarding
his rights arising from the contractual agreement dated 22.12.2021 in
his individual capacity, which is pending adjudication, and the same is
altogether a different matter.
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that instead of
finalizing the sale of the said Tea Estate in favor of the petitioner, the
respondent No. 3 had acted in a wholly arbitrary, mala fide, unfair,
unreasonable and capricious manner by issuing the communication
dated 04.04.2023, through which the respondent No. 3 stated that
upon scrutiny of the petitioner's bid and other relevant documents, it
was found that petitioner had failed to comply with the terms and
conditions laid down in Clause XIV of the e-auction notice dated
06.12.2022 and accordingly, the petitioner's bid had been treated as
cancelled. He submits that had the petitioner indeed failed to comply
with the said aforesaid clause, as mentioned in the letter dated
04.04.2023, the e-tendering platform would have automatically
disqualified the bid at the initial stage itself and the system would not
have permitted the petitioner to submit the bid up to the final stage.
The learned counsel submits that the petitioner was verbally informed
that one of its directors, Shri Rajesh Kumar Jalan, had entered into an
agreement with respondent No. 3 for management of the Tea Estate on
22.12.2021 and he is a defaulter in payment of provident fund dues
and based on the aforesaid, the petitioner's bid was cancelled. He
submits that such stand taken by the respondent authorities is
arbitrary, illegal and mala fide. He submits that the petitioner, being an
artificial legal entity with distinct independent rights and liabilities,
cannot be held accountable for the actions or inactions of one of its
WP(C)/5788/2025
directors in its individual capacity. He further submits that the
aforesaid Rajesh Kumar Jalan was, in fact, not a defaulter and all the
liabilities of provident fund had been cleared by the aforesaid Rajesh
Kumar Jalan. Therefore, neither the petitioner nor Shri Rajesh Kumar
Jalan can legally be treated as defaulter in respect of the provident
fund dues.
10.
In support of his submission that Rajesh Kumar Jalan, though a
director of the petitioner company, he is a different legal entity
altogether and he cannot be equated with the petitioner company, the
learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the following cases: 1.
Ram Chand & Sons Sugar Mills Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Kanhayalal
Bhargava, reported in AIR 1966 SC 1899/1966 O Supreme
(SC) 94.
2.
Sanjay Dutt Vs. State of Haryana, reported in 2025 O
Supreme (SC) 37.
3.
Salomon Vs. A. Salomon and Company, reported in
1897 AC 22 (HL).
11.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that unilateral
refund of EMD is not stipulated in the terms and conditions of the eauction and in fact, the refund implies that there is no default on the
part of the bidder, i.e., the petitioner. Therefore, refund of EMD by the
respondent authorities to the petitioner cannot be a ground for nonconsideration of the bid of the petitioner. In this connection, he has
relied on the case of Godrej Projects Development Ltd. Vs. Anil
Karlekar & Ors., reported in (2025) 4 SCC 259.
12.
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that it
is not disputed that the petitioner emerged as the highest bidder in the
e-auction held on 14.03.2023 and in terms of the request of the
WP(C)/5788/2025
respondent authorities, the petitioner within the time stipulated had
deposited 25% of the bid amount and the same was accepted by the
respondent. He submits that after such acceptance of the bid amount
which signifies acceptance of the petitioner's eligibility, the respondent
cannot deny the right of the petitioner in the bid and the respondent is
estopped from subsequently questioning the eligibility of the
petitioner.
13.
The learned counsel submits that a new ground has been taken
by the respondent authorities in their affidavit-in-opposition wherein
they have alleged a collusion or cartelization by the petitioner along
with the other bidder. The learned counsel submits that the aforesaid
allegation of cartelization or collusion is simply an afterthought which
has been raised by the respondents in their affidavit-in-opposition for
the first time. He submits that as far as the allegation of collusion and
cartelization is concerned, no opportunities have been afforded to the
petitioner to submit or explain its stand. Therefore, he submits that the
aforesaid new ground cannot be taken at a later stage by the respdnent
authorities deviating from its earlier stand as mentioned in the letter
dated 04.04.2023.
14.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that another new
ground which has been taken by the respondent authorities in their
affidavit-in-opposition is the so-called relevant date. Relevant date
whereby the respondent authorities have contended that Mr. Rajesh
Kumar Jalan, though had deposited the provident fund dues, the same
was not deposited before the date of e-auction that was held on
14.03.2023. He submits that this is also a new ground which has been
brought up by the respondent authorities in their affidavit-inopposition which cannot be allowed at such a later stage deviating
from its initial ground of refusal mentioned in the letter dated
WP(C)/5788/2025
04.04.2023. He submits that respondent No. 3 has specifically
acknowledged that there was no continuing disqualification on the
part of the aforesaid Rajesh Kumar Jalan. Therefore, the contention
that the petitioner stood automatically disqualified on the date of bid
submission or on the date of e-auction is wholly untenable, especially
due to the fact that when the official e-auction portal permitted
participation and the respondent authorities themselves acted upon
the bid. He submits that Clause XIV of e-auction notice pertains
exclusively to the eligibility of the bidder and does not contemplate the
disqualification of a company on account of the past administrative
role of one of its directors. Therefore, the attempt to pierce the
corporate veil without authority of law or factual foundation is
impermissible.
15.
In view of the aforesaid submissions, the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner has primarily contended that aforesaid
Rajesh Kumar Jalan who was working as a manager of the garden in
issue and the petitioner company are two different legal entities and
only because Sri Rajesh Kumar Jalan is a director of the petitioner
company, any deeds or activities of Rajesh Kumar Jalan done in
personal capacity cannot be equated with that of the petitioner
company.
16.
To be precise, the learned counsel has submitted that if there is
any default made by the aforesaid Rajesh Kumar Jalan, the same cannot
be said to have been committed by the petitioner company and
therefore, the petitioner company cannot be termed as a defaulter in
terms of Clause XIV of the e-auction notice. The other major point
which has been argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that
of taking new grounds by the respondent authorities in their affidavitin-opposition, i.e., the collusion or cartelization between the petitioner
WP(C)/5788/2025
company and the other bidder and that the relevant date whereon the
PF dues had been cleared by Rajesh Kumar Jalan was subsequent to
the e-auction held on 14.03.2023. The learned counsel has submitted
that these grounds were not mentioned in the impugned cancellation
order dated 04.04.2023 and these are afterthoughts which have been
brought in at a later stage by the respondents in their affidavit-inopposition and therefore, the same cannot be allowed to sustain.
17.
As far as the new grounds are concerned, in support of his
submission, the learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to the
case of T.P. Senkumar, IPS Vs. Union of India and others, reported
in 2017 (6) SCC 801.
18.
On the other hand, Mr. P. Nayak, the learned counsel appearing
for the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 submits that in terms of the e-auction
sale notice dated 06.12.2022, the auction was held on 14.03.2023,
wherein the petitioner company had emerged as the highest bidder
and the same was communicated to the petitioner, vide its letter dated
15.03.2023. He submits that only two numbers of bidders had
submitted their bids in the e-auction and along with the petitioner,
another bidder, namely, Panther Dealcom Private Limited had
participated and became the second highest bidder. He submits that no
other bidder had participated in the bidding process. He submits that
on further scrutiny of the relevant documents submitted by the second
highest bidder, i.e., Panther Dealcom Private Limited, it was found that
Panther Dealcom Private Limited had deposited the EMD for the eauction from the same bank belonging to the bidder number one, i.e.,
the petitioner, which is the same bank account used for depositing the
EMD by the petitioner. He submits that this aspect of the matter clearly
indicates that the two bidders, in collusion between them, deceived the
authorities in the ATEPFO and wrongfully tried to secure the
WP(C)/5788/2025
possession of Fatemabad Tea Estate, which is clearly in violation of
Section 11 (2)(a)(3) of the Assam Public Procurement Act, 2017. He
submits that after finding out the aforesaid collusion regarding
depositing of EMD of both the bidders from the same bank account, the
respondent No. 3, immediately communicated the said information to
the higher authority, i.e., the authorized officer, ATEPFO, vide letter No.
PF/IPG/2023/Rec.Off/452-453, dated 18.03.2023. He submits that on
receipt of such information, the bid of the second highest bidder, i.e.,
the Panther Dealcom Private Limited was immediately rejected and
canceled and same was communicated to Panther Dealcom Private
Limited,
vide
letter
No.
PF/IPG/2023/REC.OFF/08-09
dated
04.04.2023.
19.
The learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 submits
that upon scrutiny of the writ petitioner's bid and other relevant
documents, it was found that the writ petitioner had defaulted in
payment towards PF contribution amount payable for the period of
March, 2022 to December, 2022 and the aforesaid default dues were
cleared by the writ petitioner only on 22-03-2023, vide cheque dated
18-03-2023, which was subsequent to the date of e-auction dated 1403-2023. He submits that the last date of submission of bid was 09-032023 and the date of e-auction was 14-03-2023 and therefore, the
petitioner cleared his default due amount only on 22-03-2023, vide a
cheque dated 18-03-2023, which is surely subsequent to the date of eauction, i.e., 14-03-2023 and therefore, the petitioner was a defaulter
as he had not cleared his pending dues towards PF contribution for the
period of March, 2022 to December, 2022 and therefore, the petitioner
was in clear violation of the terms and conditions laid down in Clause
XIV of e-auction notice dated 06-12-2022. He submits that the
information regarding the defaulter status of the writ petitioner was
WP(C)/5788/2025
immediately communicated to the higher authority, vide letter No.
PF/IPC/2023/Rec.Off/452-453, dated 18-03-2023, by the respondent
no. 3. In view of the aforesaid facts, the learned counsel for the
respondents submits that the petitioner failed to comply with the
terms and conditions envisaged in Clause XIV of the e-auction dated
06-12-2022 and the petitioner being a defaulter on the last date of
submission of the bid, i.e., on 09-03-2023 as well as on the date of eauction, i.e., 14-03-2023, the petitioner's bid was rightly cancelled by
the Recovery Officer (the respondent no. 3), vide its letter dated 04-042023.
20.
He further submits that Shri Rajesh Kumar Jalan, who is one of
the directors of the petitioner company, was already the administrator
of Fatemabad Tea Estate by virtue of an agreement dated 22-12-2021
for a period of 3 years. He, in his capacity as the administrator of the
tea garden, had defaulted in his payment towards PF contribution and
his default was cleared only on 22-03-2023, which is subsequent to the
date of e-auction dated 14-03-2023. The learned counsel, while
referring to the cheque dated 18-03-2023, Annexure-D to the affidavitin-opposition, submits that the aforesaid default amount, which was
due by Shri Rajesh Kumar Jalan, was, in fact, paid by the petitioner
company itself, which is apparent from the cheque dated 18-03-2023.
In view of the aforesaid, though a director and a company are two
distinct and independent entities, from the fact that the cheque was
issued by the petitioner company, it is clear that Shri Rajesh Kumar
Jalan is in the helm of affairs of the petitioner company and though
legally both are distinct entities, it cannot be denied that both have in
fact, acted for each other and the default payment is made on being
authorized by the writ petitioner, i.e., the Snowfall Agro Products
Private Limited. He submits that, in such situations, the courts can take
WP(C)/5788/2025
into account the relevant facts and pierce the corporate veil and
thereby, find out actually who is behind such action. He submits that
the fact that the default PF due was paid from the account of the
company, i.e., the petitioner, makes it clear that the company and Shri
Rajesh Kumar Jalan acted in unison and not as different legal entities.
Therefore, in the instant case, he submits that the default committed by
Rajesh Kumar Jalan, who is the director of the petitioner company and
since the default was cleared by the petitioner company, the petitioner
can be very well be termed as a defaulter for the purpose of Clause XIV
of the e-auction notice. He submits that since the petitioner is a
defaulter in payment of PF dues, the petitioner's eligibility has been
rightly negated by the respondent authorities.
21.
The learned counsel for the respondent nos. 2 & 3 submits that
though the petitioner has contended that in the letter dated 11-062025, the respondent No. 3 had specifically stated that the office did
not
find
any
conclusive
material
to
suggest
a
continuing
disqualification on the part of the petitioner under Clause XIV of the eauction notice dated 14-03-2023, the same has been done due to the
fact that on the date of issuance of the letter dated 11-06-2025, there
was no continuing default by the petitioner or Shri Rajesh Kumar Jalan.
He submits that since the PF dues had been cleared by Shri Rajesh
Kumar Jalan on 22-03-2023, there was no continuing default and
therefore, there was no wrong committed by the respondent No. 3 by
stating so.
22.
The learned counsel further submits that no new ground has in
fact, been brought in by the respondents in its affidavit-in-opposition
filed by it. He submits that the clause for disqualification in the event of
default in payment of PF dues is already there in the e-auction notice.
He submits that since the disqualification clause is already there and
WP(C)/5788/2025
on the date of the e-auction, i.e., on 14.03.2023, the petitioner was in
default of payment of PF dues, the bid of the petitioner has been rightly
rejected by the respondent no. 3. He submits that only because that
ground was not mentioned in the letter dated 04.04.2023, the same
cannot be fatal and that cannot be termed as a new ground as the same
was there in the e-auction notice dated 06.12.2022. He submits that
immediately after getting notice of the fact that the bidder no. 2, i.e.,
Panther Dealcom Private Limited has also deposited the EMD from the
same bank account number as of the bidder no. 1, i.e., the petitioner,
the same was immediately communicated by the respondent no. 3 to
the higher authorities, vide its letter dated 18.03.2023 and
subsequently, on 04.04.2023, the bid of the aforesaid Panther Dealcom
Private Limited was also cancelled. Therefore, he submits that these
are not new grounds, but these facts were available at the time when
the impugned letter dated 04.04.2023 was issued to the petitioner.
Therefore, he submits that these cannot be termed as new grounds
brought in by way of an affidavit-in-opposition. He further submits that
such existing grounds which are already available, if they are not
mentioned in the impugned letter, that cannot be termed as fatal, as
these grounds can be taken into consideration by the respondent
authorities.
23.
In support of his submission, the learned counsel has referred to
the case of Assistant General Manager, SBI & Another Vs Tanya
Energy Enterprises, through its Managing Partner Shri Alluri
Lakshmi Narasimha Verma (Civil Appeal No. 11134 of 2025,
arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 2456 of 2025), decided by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court on September 15, 2025.
WP(C)/5788/2025
24.
This Court has heard the submissions made by the counsel
appearing for the respective parties and has also considered the cases
that have been relied on by the respective counsel.
25.
It is seen that an e-auction sale notice was issued by Assam Tea
Employees Provident Fund Organization on 06.12.2022 and as per the
terms and conditions mentioned therein, a specific condition, i.e.,
Clause XIV has been included which provides as follows: "The intending purchaser/bidder shall not be defaulter of any sort
with any Provident Fund Organization, and further, there shall not
be
any
criminal
case
pending
against
the
intending
purchaser/bidder of against his firm/company (declaration to be
furnished)."
26.
The date of bid submission was mentioned as 06.01.2023 up to
12:00 noon and the date and time of e-auction was mentioned as
09.01.2023, 1:00 PM to 3:00 PM. However, it is not disputed that the
auction was, in fact, held on 14.03.2023.
27.
In response to the aforesaid e-auction sale notice dated
06.12.2022, the petitioner, being interested in purchasing the
Fatemabad Tea Estate, submitted its bid through e-auction platform
quoting an amount of Rs. 16,65,17,000/-, whereas the other bidder,
namely, Panther Dealcom Private Limited, had also submitted its bid
quoting an amount of Rs. 16,63,17,000/- only. Therefore, it is not in
dispute that the petitioner became the highest bidder which is
apparent from the auction result which is available in the domain,
namely, property sale auctiontiger.net, which provided that the auction
was held on 14.03.2023 at 13:00 hours.
28.
It is also not in dispute that after the aforesaid e-auction, the
respondent No. 3, vide its letter dated 15.03.2023, bearing No.
WP(C)/5788/2025
PF/IPG/2023/Rec.Off/446-47, intimated the petitioner that it had
become the H1 bidder and in view of the above, the petitioner was
advised to deposit 25% of its quoted rate, i.e., Rs. 4,16,29,250/- into
ATEPFO Account No. 10821404315 with SBI, Dispur Branch, or
Account No. 0002050007510 with PNB, ATPPF Branch, Guwahati,
within 48 hours from that day, with due intimation to the undersigned.
It is also an admitted fact that a Deed of Agreement was entered into
between the Additional PF Commissioner, Head Office at Guwahati,
Assam Tea Employees Provident Fund Organization and Shri Rajesh
Kumar Jalan as Shri Rajesh Kumar Jalan was desirous to manage and
run the Fatemabad Tea Estate. As per the agreement, Shri Rajesh
Kumar Jalan was appointed for smooth running to the aforesaid Tea
Estate for a period of three years, w.e.f. 01.01.2022, subject to renewal
under such terms and conditions mutually agreed. As per the aforesaid
agreement, the PF, DLI, gratuity dues along with other statutory dues
shall be the liability of the manager, i.e., Rajesh Kumar Jalan.
29.
It is also seen from the records that Rajesh Kumar Jalan is also
one of the directors of the petitioner company who participated in the
e-auction sale and became the highest bidder. This fact is also not in
dispute that the aforesaid Rajesh Kumar Jalan had defaulted in
payment of PF contributions amount payable for the period of March,
2022 to December, 2022 and the said defaulting dues were cleared
only on 22.03.2023, vide a cheque dated 18.03.2023 which is
subsequent to the date of e-auction dated 14.03.2023.
30.
Now, the question comes herein whether Rajesh Kumar Jalan
being a director of the petitioner company being in default of payment
of PF dues can be stated as a default committed by the petitioner
company. In this connection, it may be relevant herein to refer to the
WP(C)/5788/2025
letter dated 17.03.2023, issued by the petitioner company to the
Recovery Officer, i.e., that is the respondent no. 3.
31.
It is seen from the aforesaid letter that the letter has been issued
in the letterhead of the petitioner company, which has been signed by
Rajesh Kumar Jalan as one of the directors of the company. The letter
also contained the profit and loss account of Fatemabad Tea Estate for
the period of 1st January, 2022 to 31st December, 2002 as well as from
1st January, 2023 to 14th March, 2023. It is also seen that the aforesaid
profit and loss account has been attested by a seal of the company, the
petitioner company. Along with the aforesaid letter, 3 cheques in favor
of ATEPFO have been issued by the petitioner company, signed by the
authorized signatory-cum-director, totaling to an amount of Rs.
4,16,29,250/- as that being the 25% of the quoted rate for the
Fatemabad Tea Estate quoted by the petitioner company. The contents
of the aforesaid letter dated 17.03.2023 being relevant are provided
herein below: “Snowfall Agro Products Private Limited
(CIN:UO1110WB2018PTC228685)
Corp.Office: House No. -17, Gayatri Kunj, Chitralekha Lane,
Supermarket, Dispur, Guwahati-781006.
To,
The Recovery Officer Α.Τ.Ρ.Ε.F.O Nidhi Bhawan,
Guwahati (Assam)
DATE: 17.03.2023
Ref: - Your Letter no. 1) PF/(R)/2023/K-008/6949-51 Dtd-14/03/2023
2) PF/1PG/2023/Rec.-Off./446-47 Dtd-15/03/2023.
Sub: E-Auction Dtd-14/03/2023 in regarding to immovable property of
Fatemabad Tea Estate
Sir,
With reference to above subject, we beg to inform you that as per our request
to reconcile the accounts of Fatemabad Tea Estate up to 14/03/2023 was
approved and CA Rajesh Poddar & Associates was appointed by your esteemed
WP(C)/5788/2025
organization to reconcile the accounts up to 14/03/2023 to ascertain the
adjustment and payment of other modilities with mutual understanding to
close all the issue related to Fatemabad Tea Estate as per our books of
account the following amount was invested by us, as per our enclosed account
details
1. Up to 31/12/2022-Rs. 17,49,35,696/-68 + Interest.
2. Up to 14/03/2023-Rs. 1,08,79,500/-24 + Interest.
Total Rs. 18,58,15,196/-68+ Interest
In this connection we are enclosing herewith the following cheques: 1. Cheque no. 108056, Rs. 1,16,29,250/-, Dtd- 17/03/2023
2. Cheque no. 108057, Rs. 1,50,00,000/-, Dtd-17/03/2023
3. Cheque no. 108058, Rs. 1,50,00,000/-, Dtd-17/03/2023
Total Rs. 4,16,29,250/Being the 25% of quoted rates,
But sir as per our accounts details our investment is more than the quoted
price for the above garden, Hence Audit of accounts which will take few days
so after the Audit we have to decide the further course of actions to come to a
conclusion that how we should move ahead with the Auction process as and
how our amount will be adjusted in the deal, till that time we request to hold
the cheque to lodge.
Therefore, we request your good self-kindly consider our abovementioned
request and oblige.
Thanking you,
Yours Faithfully.
Snowfall Agro Products Pvt Ltd
(RAJESH KUMAR JALAN)
DIRECTOR
Copy to: Commissioner/Secretary, A.T.E.P.F.P. Nidhi Bhawan
Enclosed: 1) Balance sheet (01.01.2022 to 31.12.2022)
2) Balance sheet (01.01.2023 to 14.03.2023)
3) 3 nos. cheque:- Ch. No. (1) 108056, (2) 108057, (3) 108057”
WP(C)/5788/2025
32.
By letter dated 14.07.2023, issued by the Recovery Officer, i.e.,
the respondent no. 3, to the Director, Snowfall Agro Products Private
Limited, it was intimated to the petitioner company that due to certain
technical grounds, the e-auction process for sale of the properties of
Fatemabad Tea Estate was kept on hold, and therefore, the petitioner
company was advised not to deposit 25% of its quoted rate that is Rs.
4,16,29,250 into ATEPFO account. It is seen that though the aforesaid
letter was written by the respondent No. 3 to the petitioner company
on 17.03.2023, the petitioner company had already deposited the
aforesaid 25% of the quoted rate, vide its letter dated 17.03.2023.
Subsequently, by the impugned letter dated 04.04.2023, issued by the
respondent No. 3 to Shri Rajesh Kumar Jalan, Director, Snowfall Agro
Products Private Limited, it was informed that on scrutiny of its bid
and other relevant documents, it was found that the petitioner had
failed to comply with the terms and conditions as envisaged in Clause
XIV of the e-auction notice as on date of the e-auction, and as such, its
bid for sale of the properties of Fatemabad Tea Estate held on
14.03.2023 had been treated as canceled on the aforesaid ground.
33.
Interestingly, on perusal of the letter dated 17.03.2023, issued by
the petitioner company on its letterhead, it is seen that reconciliation
of the accounts up to 14.03.2023 to ascertain the adjustment and
payment of other modalities with mutual understanding to close all the
issues related to Fatemabad Tea Estate as per the books of account of
the company, and therefore, the investment made by the company in
the Fatemabad Tea Estate has been mentioned in the letter. It is also
mentioned that as per their account details, their investment is more
than the quoted price for the above garden. It was also mentioned that
audit accounts will take few days to close. So, after the audit, they have
to decide the further course of actions to come to a conclusion that
WP(C)/5788/2025
how they should move ahead with the auction process and how their
account will be adjusted in the deal, till that time, they requested to
hold the check to lodge.
34.
From the aforesaid contents of the letter, it is very clear that
though the aforesaid Deed of Agreement dated 22nd December, 2021
was signed by Rajesh Kumar Jalan with the Additional PF
Commissioner, Assam Tea Employees Provident Fund Organization,
actually, the Fatemabad Tea Estate was looked after and managed by
the petitioner company itself.
35.
Since the petitioner company has been looking after and
managing the tea garden in the name of Rajesh Kumar Jalan, the
director of the petitioner company, this court is of no doubt that, in
fact, the petitioner company itself has been managing and looking after
the Fatemabad Tea Estate. Therefore, this court is of the considered
opinion that that since there was a default in payments of provident
fund to Assam Tea Employees Provident Fund Organization as on the
date of e-auction sale, the petitioner company cannot escape from
being termed as defaulter in terms of Clause XIV of the e-auction notice
dated 06.12.2022.
36.
In view of the aforesaid finding, there is no problem for this
court to negate the submission of the learned counsel of the petitioner
that Shri Rajesh Kumar Jalan and the petitioner company are two
different legal entities, and therefore, the default committed by Rajesh
Kumar Jalan cannot be termed as a default committed by the petitioner
company in the instant case.
37.
Now, the question comes as to whether the respondents have
taken any new grounds for rejection of the bid of the petitioner. It is
seen that in the letter dated 04.04.2023 itself, the petitioner company
WP(C)/5788/2025
was intimated by the respondent authorities about the violation of the
provisions of Clause XIV of the e-auction notice, and therefore, the
same was canceled. Since the petitioner company had approached this
court and this court had directed the respondent authorities to give a
reasoned order after consideration of the case of the petitioner
company, the respondent authorities, vide its letter dated 11.06.2025
disposed of its representation, in terms of the order or direction of the
Hon’ble Gauhati High Court, wherein it had mentioned that the office
had no conclusive material to suggest a continuing disqualification on
the petitioner's part under Clause XIV of the e-auction notice dated
14.03.2023. It had also mentioned that in view of the sensitive nature
of the matter, the issuance of earlier communication dated 04.04.2023
and as the EMD had already been refunded, the order dated
04.04.2023 was not recalled.
38.
From the above letter, it is seen that the order dated 04.04.2023
had not been recalled by the respondent authorities. However, it had
mentioned that there was no continuing disqualification on part of the
petitioner company and this was for the very reason that the petitioner
company had already cleared its PF dues by 22.03.2023, and therefore,
on the date of issuance of the letter dated 11.06.2025, there was no
continuing default. Therefore, taking into the entire aspects of the
matter and having found that there was a default committed by the
petitioner company in terms of Clause XIV of the e-auction sale notice
dated 06.12.2022, this court is of the considered opinion that though
the additional grounds of sensitivity of the matter and EMD already
being refunded, had been taken as additional grounds, the primary
ground of rejection, vide letter dated 04.04.2023 existed and which
seems to be a valid one to this Court.
WP(C)/5788/2025
39.
Coming back to the issue of the ground of collusion and
cartelization is concerned, that the aforesaid ground has been taken in
the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent No. 2. It is seen from
the letter dated 18.03.2023, vide No. PF/IPG/2023/Rec.Off/452-453,
that the respondent No. 3 had written to the Authorized Officer, ATEPF
Organization, wherein it had been specifically mentioned that on
scrutiny of relevant documents, the second highest bidder, it appeared
that they had also transferred the EMD from the same bank account
belonging to the Snowfall Agro Private Limited, the petitioner. It had
been specifically mentioned therein that the second highest bid could
not be accepted since they had also transferred the EMD from the
account of Snowfall Agro Private Limited. In that connection, the
account details and PAN card and other relevant of EMD submission
receipt have been annexed to the affidavit in opposition filed by the
respondent No. 2. Accordingly, vide letter dated 04.04.2023, the
respondent No. 3 had intimated the Director of Panther Dealcom
Private Limited about cancellation of their bid as the bidder No. 2.
40.
From the documents as aforesaid, which have been annexed in
the affidavit-in-opposition, it is apparent that the EMD amounts of both
the petitioner company and the bidder No. 2, i.e., Dealcom Private
Limited, had been deposited from the same bank account. Therefore,
the collusion between the two bidders cannot be ruled out and in fact,
the same is apparent on the face of the record which have been
submitted along with the affidavit-in-opposition.
41.
This Court has also gone through the affidavit-in-reply filed by
the petitioner and it is seen that as far as collusion or cartelization is
concerned, the petitioner, though has denied the allegation of collusion
or cartelization as an afterthought and raised for the first time in the
affidavit-in-opposition, however, did not deny the fact that the EMD
WP(C)/5788/2025
amounts for both the petitioner company and the bidder No. 2 were
deposited from the same bank account. Therefore, a collusion or
cartelization also seems to be involved in the instant case and
therefore, the respondent authorities have rightly rejected the bid of
the respondent bidder No. 2 as well as the petitioner company due to
the facts mentioned in the letter dated 04.04.2023 as well as due to the
apparent collusion that has come to the notice of this Court.
42.
As far as the contention of the petitioner that new facts have
been brought in the affidavit-in-opposition, the case of Assistant
General Manager, SBI & Anr. (supra) can be referred to, wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that where larger public interest is
involved and in such a situation, additional grounds can be looked into
to examine the validity of an order. In this connection, para 34, 36, and
38 being relevant are extracted herein below: “34.
A question would obviously arise for our answer, having regard
to the Constitution Bench decision in Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief
Election Commissioner and the larger Bench decisions of this Court
in Commissioner of Police v. Gordhandas Bhanji and Opto Circuits
(India) Ltd. v. Axis Bank, as to whether, a court can uphold an order
rejecting an applicant's claim based on a ground appearing from the
records of the case which could have been but has not been mentioned,
if the grounds mentioned in such order of rejection are not found to be
tenable?
36.
Mohinder Singh Gill (supra) has been considered by this Court
in All India Railway Recruitment Board v. K. Shyam Kumar. It has
been held there that the principle laid down in Mohinder Singh Gill
(supra) is not applicable where larger public interest is involved and in
such a situation, additional grounds can be looked into, to examine the
validity of an order. To the same effect is the decision in PRP Exports
v. State of Tamilnadu. However, K. Shyam Kumar (supra) and PRP
WP(C)/5788/2025
Exports (supra) have been considered in Moons Technologies Ltd. v.
Union of India where it has been held in paragraph 102 by a
coordinate Bench that there is no broad proposition that the law laid
down in Mohinder Singh Gill (supra) will not apply where larger
public interest is involved. The decisions in K. Shyam Kumar (supra)
and P.R.P. Exports (supra) were distinguished on the ground that the
coordinate Benches there had proceeded to consider subsequent
materials that emerged for the purpose of validating the order under
challenge.
38.
The respective Benches in Commissioner of Police (supra),
Mohinder Singh Gill (supra), Opto Circuits (India) Ltd. (supra) and
Moons Technologies Ltd. (supra), in our reading, while mandating
what has been noticed above was not required to and, as such, rightly
did not go that far in establishing the principle that, in all cases
coming before it, the court is necessarily bound to confine itself to the
grounds mentioned in the administrative order under challenge and
cannot look beyond such grounds at all. While the courts, in course of
reviewing administrative orders, may not permit additional grounds
not found within the four corners of the said order to be raised in an
affidavit or in oral arguments, we are Inclined to the view that the
factual narrative in such order and the documents referred to therein
can certainly be considered together with the case set up in the writ
petition, but in appropriate cases. Such cases could include a case, as
the present, where the mentioned grounds are found to be untenable
and, thus, unsustainable, but an alternative ground (appearing from
the factual narrative in the order itself and/or from the records
relevant thereto) is traceable which could have validly been mentioned
as a ground to support the impugned rejection had there been a
proper application of mind by the administrative authority. In all such
cases, it would be open to the court to uphold it on such alternative
ground subject, of course, to the affected party being put on notice and
WP(C)/5788/2025
an opportunity to respond. This approach, which would prioritize
fairness and justice over technicalities, does not run contrary to or
inconsistent with the law laid down in the afore referred precedents.”
43.
In view of the aforementioned principle laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, as well as taking into account of the fact that apparent
collusion in the bid has come to the fore, this court is of the considered
opinion that the same cannot be brushed aside as a ground which has
been taken at a later stage, though the aspect of collusion has been
already recorded in its letter dated 18.03.2023 by the respondent No.
3. Therefore, this is an existing fact that the ground has already been
there on record, but somehow, the same was not mentioned in the
letter dated 04.04.2023. This court is of the considered opinion that
the same cannot be termed as fatal taking into account of the fact that
there is a clear violation of Clause XIV of the e-auction notice dated
06.12.2022.
44.
It has been mentioned in the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondent No. 2 that that presently, the zimma of the Fatimabad Tea
Estate has been handed over to one Shri Om Prakash Singh, who is the
authorized representative of the original owner of the garden, i.e.,
Choudhury Tea Agro Industries Private Limited.
45.
After giving due consideration to the aforesaid facts and coming
to the aforesaid findings, this court doesn't find any merit in the instant
writ petition, and therefore, the same is dismissed.
46.
No order on costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
WP(C)/5788/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review