Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC040012042024
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/405/2024
Smti Tulsi Maya Bhujel
Wife of Late Ram Bahadur Bhujel, presently residing at Ruksin Town, PO and PS
Ruksin, East Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 4 Ors
represented by the Secretary, Department of Finance, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh,
Itanagar.
2:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Rural Works Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Director
Age: 0
Occupation :
Directorate of Audit and Pension
Naharlagun
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh.
4:The Chief Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Rural Work Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
5:The Executive Engineer
Age: 0
Page No.# 2/10
Occupation :
Rural Work Division
Pasighat
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner : Nikita Danggen, K Gao,Nyarum Tapu Tacho,Honi Tana Tara,Penjom
Siga,K Chotton,Oken Duggong
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), SC(RWD),Gimi Tarak
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
26.03.2026
Heard Mr. O. Duggong, learned counsel for the petitioner; Mr. Y. Riram,
learned Government Advocate for the State, being respondent Nos., 1 & 3; and
Mr. G. Tarak, learned Standing Counsel for the Rural Work Department (RWD
hereinafter), being respondent Nos. 2, 4 & 5.
2.
In this petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioner has challenged the letter No. Pen/AP/31472/19-20/302/907-09, dated
06.09.2019, issued by the Director of Audit and Pension. Further, the petitioner
has prayed for issuing direction to the respondent authorities to grant her
pensionary benefit of her deceased husband under the Old Pension Scheme
(OPS hereinafter).
3.
It is to be noted here that vide letter dated 06.09.2019, the Director of
Audit and Pension, being respondent No. 3, had rejected the claim of the
petitioner for granting pensionary benefit.
4.
Mr. Duggong, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the husband
Page No.# 3/10
of the petitioner was initially appointed as ALC,in the office of the Additional
Deputy Commissioner, Pasighat, vide order No. P-6000, dated 01.12.1976.
Thereafter, he had been transferred to Nari, vide order No. P-6010/131, dated
17.01.1977 and thereafter, he was appointed as a Chowkidar of Ruksin Rest
House, vide order No. RN/17/87-88, dated 19.09.1987 and he stayed at Ruksin
for around two years as Chowkidar. Thereafter, again he had been transferred to
Pasighat and subsequently, again he had been transferred back to Ruksin on the
same year, i.e. 1989 and he had been placed under disposal of RWD
Department, Ruksin, vide Memo No. RNP-1/89, dated 01.08.1989 and since
then, he was working as a Chowkidar and also in addition to the same, he was
working as Sweeper in the Rest House of Ruksin.
4.1. Mr. Duggon further submits that the Departmental Promotion Committee
had recommend the name of the late husband of the petitioner for being
appointed to the post of Sweeper in the year 2008 and accordingly, her late
husband had been appointed to the post of Sweeper, vide order No. RWD/Estt239/05, dated 26.11.2008, after serving the department as regular temporary
employee for 32 years.
4.2. Mr. Duggon also submits that many causal employees, who were junior to
the late husband of the petitioner, were regularized before introduction of New
Pension Scheme (NPS hereinafter). But, the service of her late husband was
regularized, after introduction of NPS. Mr. Duggon further submits that,
however, the respondent No. 5 had forwarded the service book along with the
pension papers of late husband of the petitioner to the Director of Audit and
Pension.
4.3. Mr. Duggon further submits that the service of the late husband of the
petitioner was regularized from his initial joining as casual Sweeper, w.e.f.
Page No.# 4/10
21.10.1983
to
25.11.2008,
vide
order
No.
RWC/Cord/Estt/WC(R)/410/2016/3190-93, dated 08.08.2018 (Annexure – 7, at
page No. 37) and conveying the above mentioned ‘date of regularization’, the
Executive Engineer, Pasighat, had written a letter to the Director of Audit and
Pension, vide letter No. PRWD/PF-163/2008, dated 19.06.2019 (Annexure – 10,
at page No. 43), stating that service of the petitioner's late husband had been
regularized, vide Government Order No. RWD/Sectt/18/2002, dated 16.12.2003
and necessary entries has been made in his service book as per Government
Appointment No. 20.12.2008, RWD/Estt-239, dated 26.11.2008.
4.4. Mr. Duggong also submits that in spite of the aforementioned letter of the
Executive Engineer, the pensions papers of the petitioner’s husband have not
been processed and consequently, she has been deprived of the benefit of the
same and being aggrieved, the petitioner has approached this Court by filing the
present petition.
5.
The respondent authorities have filed their affidavits-in-opposition denying
the statements and averments made by the petitioner in the petition. Their
stand is that the service of the late husband of the petitioner was regularized
only after coming into force of the NPS in the year 2008 and on such count, he
is not entitled to the benefit.
6.
Mr. Tarak, learned Standing Counsel for the respondents in RWD, referring
to the Annexure – 7, at page No. 37 and Annexure – 10, page No. 43 of the
petition fairly submits that in view of the regularization of the service of the late
husband of the petitioner, w.e.f. 21.10.1983 to 25.11.2008 and also in view of
the letter of the Executive Engineer, dated 19.06.2019, the petitioner is entitled
to regular pension.
Page No.# 5/10
6.1. Mr. Tarak further submits that he asked for the regularization information
from the department, but the department could not furnish any plausible
answer in respect of the page No. 37.
7.
On the other hand, Mr. Riram, learned Government Advocate for the State
respondents, has also subscribed the submission of Mr. Tarak, learned Standing
Counsel for the RWD.
8.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties, this
Court has carefully gone through the petition as well as the documents placed
on record and also perused the impugned letter dated 06.09.2019, which is
annexed with the petition as Annexure – 11 and its typed copy is at page No.
47.
9.
The impugned letter dated 06.09.2019, which is annexed with the petition
as Annexure – 11, at page No. 47, is extracted herein below for ready
reference:GOVERNMENT OF ARUNACHAL PRADESH
DIRECTORATE OF AUDIT AND PENSION
NAHARLAGUN
NO. Pen/AP/31472/19-20/302
Dated.....2019
TO
The Executive Engineer,
Rural Works Division, Pasighat,
District :- East Siang,
Arunachal Pradesh,
Sub: - Return of pension papers & Service Book of Late Ram Bdr. Bhujel, ExSweeper,
Ref:- Your letter No. PRWD/PF-163/2008/502-03 dtd 19.06.2019.
Sir,
The pension papers & service Book of Late Ram Bdr. Bhujel, Ex-service,
received with your letter cited above have been checked and the same are
Page No.# 6/10
returned in original with the following observations for your necessary
action.
1. It is clearly mentioned in the appointment order that Lt. Ram Bdr.
Bhujel was engaged as casual sweeper w.e.f. 21-10-1983 to 25-112008 vide order No.RWC/Coord/Estt/W/C (R)410/2016/319-93 Dated
Itanagar the 8th Aug 2018. But the provision of giving benefits of
pension/family pension and crediting of 50% casual service to the
length of qualifying service has stopped with the introduction of
NPS w.e.f 01-01-2008 in Arunachal Pradesh vide order No.
DA/NPS/12/2017-18 Dated 14" June 2018 (A copy enclosed). So, the
instant case is neither eligible for family pension nor provision
for crediting 50% of casual service into the total length of
qualifying service is available.
2. So, his total regular service comes to 8 years 9 months and 11 days
only and the excess drawal of death gratuity to the tune of Rs,
1,74,050/- only (Rupees one lakh seventy four thousand and fifty)
due to wrong calculation may please be recovered and deposited
into treasury under proper head of account.
After attending the above observation, the service Book and the
required pension papers may be resubmitted to this office for further
necessary action.
Enclo:- As started
Yours Sincerely,
Director of Audit and Pension,
Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
Naharlagun
10. Perusal of the Clause Nos. 1 & 2 of the impugned letter dated 06.09.2019,
reveals that NPS came into effect w.e.f. 01.01.2008, in Arunachal Pradesh and
the petitioner was engaged as casual sweeper vide order dated 25.11.2008 and
as such, he is neither eligible for family pension nor provision for crediting 50%
of casual service into the total length of qualifying service is available and that
total regular service comes to 8 years 9 months and 11 days only and the
excess drawal of death gratuity to the tune of Rs, 1,74,050/- due to wrong
calculation may be recovered and deposited into treasury under proper head of
account.
Page No.# 7/10
10.1. It appears that while the aforementioned letter was issued on
06.09.2019, the authority has failed to take into account of the order dated
26.06.2018 (Annexure – 7), whereby the service of the late husband of the
petitioner was regularized from the initial date of his joining as Casual Sweeper,
w.e.f. 21.10.1983 to 25.11.2008 and also the letter of the Executive Engineer,
dated 19.06.2019 (Annexure – 9), wherein it has been clearly mentioned that as
per regularization order dated 16.12.2003, the late husband of the petitioner is
entitled to get benefit for pension under OPS.
11. Further, it appears from the impugned letter dated 06.09.2019, the
Director of Audit and Pension has directed to recover a sum of Rs. 1,74,050/- as
excess drawal due to wrong calculation. But, in terms of law laid down by
Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of State of Punjab vs. Rafiq Masih
(White Washer), reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334, recovery of excess drawal is
illegal and impressible in respect of Group – ‘D’ employee and also in respect of
the employee who had already retired from service. Relevant paragraph is
reproduced herein below for ready reference:“18. It
is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship, which would govern employees on the issue of
recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made by
the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that
as it may, based on the decisions referred to herein
above, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the
following few situations, wherein recoveries by the
employers, would be impermissible in law:
(i)
Recovery from the employees belonging to Class
III and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D
service).
(ii)
Recovery
from
the
retired
employees,
or
the
Page No.# 8/10
employees who are due to retire within one year,
of the order of recovery.
(iii)
Recovery from the employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of
five years, before the order of recovery is
issued.
(iv)
Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of
a higher post, and has been paid accordingly,
even though he should have rightfully been
required to work against an inferior post.
(v)
In any other case, where the court arrives at
the conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far
outweigh the equitable balance of the employer's
right to recover.”
11.1. Recovery is also not permissible in view of the decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Thomas Deniel vs. State of Kerala and
Others, reported in 2022 SCC Online SC 536, when the employee is no way
responsible in fixation of the pay scale and when there is no fraud or
misrepresentation on the part of the employee. Relevant paragraph is
reproduced herein below for ready reference:“9.
This Court in a catena of decisions has consistently
held that if the excess amount was not paid on account
of any misrepresentation or fraud of the employee or
which is subsequently found to be erroneous, such
excess payment of emoluments or allowances are not
recoverable. This relief against the recovery is
granted not because of any right of the employees but
in equity, exercising judicial discretion to provide
relief to the employees from the hardship that will be
Page No.# 9/10
caused if the recovery is ordered. This Court has
further held that if in a given case, it is proved that
an employee had knowledge that the payment received was
in excess of what was due or wrongly paid, or in cases
where error is detected or corrected within a short
time of wrong payment, the matter being in the realm of
judicial discretion, the courts may on the facts and
circumstances of any particular case order for recovery
of amount paid in excess.”
12. Under the aforementioned facts and circumstances and as agreed upon by
learned counsel for both the parties, the impugned letter of the Director of Audit
and Pension, dated 06.09.2019, stands set aside and quashed. Now, the matter
is remanded to the Director of Audit and Pension to process the pension papers
of the late husband of the petitioner in the light of the order dated 26.06.2018
and also in the light of the letter of the Executive Engineer dated 19.06.2019
and to settle the pension papers and service book of the petitioner. Further, it is
provided that recovery is not permissible in view of the fact that the husband of
the petitioner was a Class – IV (Group – ‘D’) employee, also retired from service
and also suffered demise. His case falls under situation Nos. (i) & (ii) of
paragraph No. 18 of the decision in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra) and also
falls under paragraph No. 9 of the decision in the case of Thomas Daniel
(supra).
13. The aforementioned exercise has to be carried out within a period of 3
(three) months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order.
14. The petitioner shall obtain a certified copy of this order and place the
same before the respondent authorities, more particularly respondent No. 3,
within a period of one week from today.
Page No.# 10/10
15.
In terms of above, this writ petition stands disposed of, the parties have
to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review