The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
RSA No.30 of 2023 Smti Renubala Nath wife of Shri Shib Charan Nath, a resident of Panisagar, P.S. Panisagar, Dharmanagar, P.O. Panisagar, District North Tripura, PIN ……… Appellant(s) –Versus– (1) Shri Bikash Ranjan Dutta son of late Amarendra Kumar Dutta (2) Shri Ajoy Dutta son of late Amarendra Kumar Dutta (3) Shri Ashim Dutta son of late Amarendra Kumar Dutta All are resident of Panisagar, P.S Panisagar, Dharmanagar, P.O. Panisagar, District North Tripura, PIN 799260 …….. Respondent(s) For the Appellant(s) : Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate. Ms. A. Pal, Advocate. For the Respondent(s) : None. Date of hearing : 5th September, 2024. Date of delivery of Judgment & order : 17th December, 2024. Whether fit for reporting : √ HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA JUDGMENT & ORDER The appeal arises out of the judgment dated 16.09.2023 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar in Title Appeal No.28 of 2016 by dismissing the appeal. [2] The appellant (hereinafter referred to as the plaintiff) instituted Title Suit No.24 of 2014 in the Court of the Civil Judge (Jr. Division), Dharmanagar against the respondents (hereinafter referred to as the defendants) praying for a perpetual injunction for restraining the defendants, their men and agents from entering into the suit land and from disturbing the possession of the plaintiff therein in respect of th…
25. 03.2017 by setting aside the judgment and decree of the learned trial court and simultaneously, restrained the defendants, their men and agents from entering into the suit land by issuing perpetual injunction. At that time, before the learned First Appellate Court, one corrected Khatian No.743 was also submitted by the plaintiff, in which necessary correction was made by the Revenue Authority by indicating the plaintiff’s land on the northern side of the suit land by deleting the name of said Bichitra therefrom. Based on said document, though not proved into evidence, learned First Appellate Court decreed the suit. [10] The defendants, thereafter, filed second appeal bearing RSA No.20 of 2017 before this Court and this Court vide judgment dated 26.04.2021 allowed the appeal and remanded the matter for fresh decision by the learned First Appellate Court with the following observations: “The first appellate court shall first afford an opportunity to the appellants to file their response to the petition for accepting additional evidence [Khatian No. 743, as corrected] and thereafter, on hearing, whether the said document would be accepted in the record of evidence, will be decided by the first appellate court. On affording opportunities of hearing to the parties, the first appellate court [District judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar] shall deicide the appeal, preferably within a pe…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.30 of 2023
Smti Renubala Nath
wife of Shri Shib Charan Nath, a resident of Panisagar, P.S.
Panisagar, Dharmanagar, P.O. Panisagar, District North Tripura, PIN
799260
……… Appellant(s)
–Versus–
(1)
Shri Bikash Ranjan Dutta
son of late Amarendra Kumar Dutta
(2)
Shri Ajoy Dutta
son of late Amarendra Kumar Dutta
(3)
Shri Ashim Dutta
son of late Amarendra Kumar Dutta
All are resident of Panisagar, P.S Panisagar, Dharmanagar, P.O.
Panisagar, District North Tripura, PIN 799260
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. A. Pal, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
None.
Date of hearing
:
5th September, 2024.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
17th December, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The appeal arises out of the judgment dated 16.09.2023
passed by the learned Additional District Judge, North Tripura,
Dharmanagar in Title Appeal No.28 of 2016 by dismissing the appeal.
[2]
The appellant (hereinafter referred to as the plaintiff)
instituted Title Suit No.24 of 2014 in the Court of the Civil Judge (Jr.
Division), Dharmanagar against the respondents (hereinafter referred
to as the defendants) praying for a perpetual injunction for restraining
the defendants, their men and agents from entering into the suit land
and from disturbing the possession of the plaintiff therein in respect of
the land measuring 0.04 acres of Class-Nal recorded in the Khatian
No.743
of
Mouja-
Panisagar
falling
within
R.S.
Plot
No.1331,
corresponding to old CS Plot No.531/1008(P) with the following
boundaries:
[3]
North
: Self (plaintiff)
South
: Foot track of village.
East
: Biresh Das known as Biresh Sen
West
: Assam-Agartala Road
The claim of the plaintiff is that she purchased the suit
land from one Smt. Basana Rani Nath and others vide registered sale
Deed No.1-3033 dated 15.12.2007 [Exbt.1 series] and since purchase
she has been possessing the suit land peacefully. Khatian has also
been mutated in her name. But on 15.05.2014, in the morning, the
defendants threatened her not to cultivate the suit land and that they
would cultivate the same after taking possession thereof. Similar
incident, according to the plaintiff, occurred again on 26.05.2014 and
therefore, she instituted the suit to protect her possession.
[4]
The defendants contested the suit and according to them,
the plaintiff did not purchase the suit land from Basana Rani Nath by
above said sale deed. According to them, the suit land is not
identifiable, for, in the trace map RS Plot No.1333 is situated at the
adjacent North of suit plot as per Khatian but as per trace map, RS
plot No.9823 is situated at the adjacent North. They also contended
that the purchased plot of the plaintiff bearing R.S. Plot No.1331 as
per the map was situated far away from plot No.1330 and 1332
keeping so many plots existent in between without any basis, which
further creates doubt about correctness of location of these plots in
the trace map. It is also stated that the suit land was ancestral
property of the defendants along with the co-sharers and they have
been jointly possessing the suit land with other lands without any
interruption from any corner. Their predecessor sold out 0.21 acres of
land to one Bimal Sen which is situated adjacent eastern boundary of
the suit land appertaining to plot No.9300. Accordingly, the land
measuring 0.10 acres including the suit land which is situated
adjacent west to the land of said Bimal Sen is still recorded in the
name of the predecessor of the defendants.
[5]
It is also contended by the defendants that the vendor of
plaintiff has no right, title and possession in the land wrongly shown in
the trace map as against plot No.1331. In this regard, the defendants
have also submitted a petition to the SDM, Panisagar for correction of
trace map which is still pending.
[6]
During trial, the plaintiff examined herself as PW-1 and
also examined other 2[two] witnesses, namely Sri Arabinda Debnath
and Sri Anathbandhu Das as PW-2 and PW-3 respectively and also
proved few documents into the evidence, such as, her title deed,
Khatian No.743 and certified copy of trace map.
[7]
The defendant No.1, Sri Bikash Ranjan Dutta examined
himself as DW-1 and other two witnesses, namely Sri Dayamay Datta
and Sri Manna Dey as DW-2 and DW-3 respectively. He also proved
the copy of his application dated 30.05.2014 submitted before the
SDM,
Panisagar
for
correction
of
the
map,
certified
copy
of
demarcation report dated 14.02.2014 and another enquiry report
dated 06.04.2015 submitted by DCM, Panisagar.
The plaintiff noted
her objection regarding proving of said documents.
[8]
The learned trial court thereafter, dismissed the suit vide
judgment dated 13.06.2016 though the said court held that the suit
was maintainable with a valid cause of action. The main reason for
dismissing the suit by the learned trial court was that as per her
purchased deed as well as the description of the suit land given in
plaint schedule, on the northern side of the suit land, her own land
was reflected whereas in her mutated Khatian No.743[Exbt.2], name
of one Bichitra was shown on the northern side of the suit land as
against Plot No.1333 and in the trace map on the northern side of the
suit land, Plot No.9823 was mentioned. Therefore, according to the
learned trial court, there was a serious error committed by the
Revenue Authority in preparing the said Khatian and the trace map
and therefore the purchased land of the plaintiff has become virtually
non-existent.
[9]
The plaintiff, thereafter, preferred Title Appeal bearing
No.28 of 2016 and the Learned First Appellate Court allowed the said
appeal
vide judgment
dated
25.03.2017
by setting aside the
judgment and decree of the learned trial court and simultaneously,
restrained the defendants, their men and agents from entering into
the suit land by issuing perpetual injunction. At that time, before the
learned First Appellate Court, one corrected Khatian No.743 was also
submitted by the plaintiff, in which necessary correction was made by
the Revenue Authority by indicating the plaintiff’s land on the northern
side of the suit land by deleting the name of said Bichitra therefrom.
Based on said document, though not proved into evidence, learned
First Appellate Court decreed the suit.
[10]
The defendants, thereafter, filed second appeal bearing
RSA No.20 of 2017 before this Court and this Court vide judgment
dated 26.04.2021 allowed the appeal and remanded the matter for
fresh decision by the learned First Appellate Court with the following
observations:
“The first appellate court shall first afford an opportunity to the
appellants to file their response to the petition for accepting
additional evidence [Khatian No. 743, as corrected] and
thereafter, on hearing, whether the said document would be
accepted in the record of evidence, will be decided by the first
appellate court. On affording opportunities of hearing to the
parties, the first appellate court [District judge, North Tripura,
Dharmanagar] shall deicide the appeal, preferably within a
period of 6 months from the date of receiving the records.
The respondent herein is given liberty to amend the petition
filed under Order XLI Rule 27 of the CPC, if it is so required.
In terms of the above, this appeal stands allowed with the
order of remand.”
[11]
In terms of the judgment of this Court, learned First
Appellate Court allowed the petition of the plaintiff for adducing
additional evidence and thereafter one certified copy of corrected
Khatian No.743 and another certified copy of the Khatian No.2406
were proved into evidence as Exbt.1-1 and Exbt.2-1 respectively.
[12]
The learned First Appellate Court, thereafter, heard the
parties afresh and by the impugned judgment dismissed the appeal as
stated above. One of the grounds for such dismissal of the appeal is
that as per the purchased deed of the plaintiff, she purchased 0.04
acres of land from CS Plot No.1008 corresponding to RS Plot No.1331
whereas in her mutated Khatian her purchased land has been shown
against CS Plot No.531/1008 and not CS Plot No.1008 alone. The
learned First Appellate Court also took exception of the fact that the
plaintiff purchased a part of RS Plot No.1331 as per her deed whereas
in her mutated Khatian, the whole of said RS Plot No.1331 was
maintained without making any butted plot therefrom. The learned
First Appellate Court also observed that as per the original mutated
Khatian of the plaintiff, name of one Bichitra was existent on the
northern side but later on it was deleted by incorporating the name of
plaintiff herself but she could not show any document as to how and
why such changes were made by the Revenue Authority. The learned
First Appellate Court also noted that the plaintiff had failed to identify
her purchased land with any reliable and convincing evidence and also
expressed his doubt about correctness of the trace map. Learned First
Appellate Court also even proceeded to hold that the defendants were
the owners of the suit land and the executants of the sale deed of the
plaintiff had no title or possession in the suit land. Learned First
Appellate Court also observed that the suit for injunction simpliciter
was not maintainable as in the written statement the defendants
denied the right, title and interest and possession of the plaintiff in
respect of the suit land and they in their evidence were able to show
defects and to create cloud on the title of plaintiff in respect of the suit
land and for all these reasons, the judgment of the trial court was
affirmed by dismissing the appeal.
[13]
Before this Court, the defendants despite service of notice
did not appear to contest.
[14]
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel appearing for
the appellant argues that the defendants did not challenge the
purchased deed of the plaintiff and nor even challenged the Khatian
standing in her name and therefore, the defendants practically had no
claim on the purchased land of the plaintiff but despite the same, the
suit of the plaintiff was dismissed and such dismissal was affirmed by
the Learned First Appellate Court. Learned senior counsel further
contends that the issue of maintainability was decided by the learned
trial court in favour of the plaintiff, but despite no appeal was
preferred by the defendants regarding said decision, learned First
Appellate Court most illegally held that the suit was not maintainable.
According to Mr. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel, nowhere the
defendants asserted that the boundary description of the purchased
land of the plaintiff was wrong but despite the same, no decree was
passed in her favour by the courts below. Even though it is settled
position that even a rent trespasser is entitled to maintain the
possession in the suit land unless evicted in due process of law,
learned senior counsel argues, but in the present case despite the
plaintiff having her supportive deed of title and the mutated ROR, her
suit was dismissed.
Learned senior counsel further contends that if
there is any mistake in the trace map, the Revenue Authority is
responsible for the same and it is their duty to rectify the defect but
for that reason, the plaintiff cannot be deprived of her own property.
[15]
Learned senior counsel in support of his contention, relies
on a decision of the Apex Court rendered in A. Subramanian and
another vs. R. Pannerselvam, AIR 2021 SC 821 wherein it was
observed that even a trespasser, who is in established possession of
the property could obtain injunction. However, the matter would be
different, if the plaintiff himself elaborates in the plaint about the title
dispute and fails to make a prayer for declaration of title along with
injunction.
[16]
The plaintiff has claimed the suit land of 0.04 acre by way
of purchase from one Smt. Basana Rani Nath vide registered sale
deed No.1-3033 dated 15.12.2007 (Exbt.1/1). As per the said
purchase deed, she purchased land of CS plot No.1008 corresponding
to RS plot No.1331 (part), Class-Nal of Mouja and Tehsil Panisagar
with specific boundary which is as follows:
North-plaintiff
South-Village path/foot track
East- Biresh Das
West-Assam-Agartala road.
That
boundary
description
completely
tally
with
the
boundary description of the suit land as given in the plaint. Based on
said purchase, her name was mutated in Khatian No.743 (Exbt.2)
wherein RS plot No.1331 was maintained against 0.04 acre of land in
the name of the plaintiff. Learned courts below took exception of the
same as to why a butted plot was not created from said RS plot
No.1331 while mutating the name of the plaintiff. Similarly, as per the
said purchase deed, RS plot No.1331 corresponds to CS plot No.1008
but in said mutated Khatian, a butted plot bearing No.531/1008 (part)
was reflected. Both the courts below also took exception of creation of
a butted plot with reference to such CS plots. Though no specific
challenge was made by the defendants as to the ownership of the
vendor Basana Rani Nath and others in respect of said plot, and even
if there would be challenge of the defendants regarding such creation
or non-creation of butted plots, proper forum for verifying the same is
the Revenue Authority. The civil courts does not act as an Appellate
forum of such Revenue Authority to verify the correctness of
endorsing survey plot numbers of different lands.
[17]
The main grievance of the defendants, as it appears from
the pleading, is that the suit land was not identifiable in the trace map
and the map was contradicting with the Khatian of the plaintiff with
reference to Northern boundary land. According to them, as indicated
earlier, as per the mutated Khatian No.743 (Exbt.2) at the northern
side of purchase land of the plaintiff, RS plot No.1333 under
possession of one Bichitra is reflected whereas as per the map of plot
No.9823 it is shown on the northern side of said suit plot No.1331.
Learned courts below were also impressed with such defence of the
defendants while dismissing the suit. Before the First Appellate Court,
one corrected Khatian bearing No.743 (Exbt.1-1) was also proved
which manifests that said northern side of the suit plot was corrected
and by deleting plot No.1333 standing in the name of Bichitra, same
was substituted by plot No.9823 of the plaintiff. Learned First
Appellate Court again took exception of the same as to why or on
what basis such correction was made, though no document was
placed by the defendants to show that against such correction made
by the Revenue Authority they had challenged same in higher revenue
forum. Nowhere the defendants in specific words have claimed that
they are the owner of the said suit plot No.1331 rather they proved a
letter of one DCM, Panisagar addressed to Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Panisagar (Exbt.C) wherein after scrutiny of the record, said Revenue
Officer has mentioned that during revisional survey and settlement
operation, the plotting of land of vendors of the plaintiff namely, Smt.
Basana Rani Nath and others were done wrongly on CS plot
No.1093/6199 (part) which was supposed to be done on CS plot
No.1008 and as such presently Renu Bala Nath is the owner of 0.04
acre of land as per her record against RS plot No.1331 (corresponding
CS plot No.1008 of Khatian No.743) but in the map, said RS plot
No.1331 has been plotted against CS plot No.1093/6199. Said
Revenue Officer has also mentioned that the plaintiff is in physical
possession of 0.04 acre of land which is part of said CS plot No.1008
and finally, he has suggested correction of the map. Said document
has been relied on by the defendants themselves. Therefore, this
Court is in agreement with the submission of Mr. Chakraborty, learned
senior counsel that if any mistake has been committed by the
Revenue Authority while drawing the map, the plaintiff, an innocent
purchaser for valuable consideration, cannot be made sufferer for it.
[18]
Both the Courts below have committed serious error
in holding the land of the plaintiff as non-existent on the ground of
such defect in the revenue map. As stated above, when the
defendants have not in specific terms challenged such ownership of
plaintiff in the suit land having derived by way of said purchase nor
they have challenged the ownership of the vendors of the plaintiff in
said suit plot No.1331, learned First Appellate Court has committed
mistake in observing that a cloud has been created in the title of the
plaintiff in respect of the suit land and therefore, the suit for
injunction simpliciter is not maintainable.
[19]
dated
The defendants have also proved one of their petition
30.05.2014
(Exbt.A)
addressed
to
SDM,
Panisagar
for
correction of the map which is still pending for decision by SDM,
Panisagar. In such a situation, plaintiff has her right to protect
possession of her purchased land which contains specific boundary
and plot number. But, in view of wrong recording in the map, she
cannot be allowed to identify her land based on said map unless same
is corrected by the Revenue Authority. Law is no longer res integra
that suit land can be identified either by plot number or by its
boundary and in the instant case, as stated earlier, there is no specific
challenge regarding the correctness of boundary description of the
purchased land of the plaintiff.
[20]
In view of above, the appeal is allowed. Both the impugned
judgments and decrees passed by learned First Appellate Court and
by learned trial Court are set aside.
[21]
The suit of the plaintiff is decreed with cost throughout in
her favour.
The defendants and their men and agent are perpetually
restrained from entering into the suit land and from disturbing
peaceful possession of the plaintiff therein. However, identification of
the suit land based on its survey plot number will not be effective
unless the same is corrected by the Revenue Authority in due course.
The defendants may approach the Revenue Authority for early
correction of the same.
The appeal is accordingly disposed of.
Registry is to prepare decree accordingly.
Return the records of both learned First Appellate Court
and learned Trial Court with copy of this judgment and decree.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Sujay /Rudradeep
signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally
Date: 2024.12.17 17:25:36 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review