The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. 11.2021. It is submitted by Mr. Lodh, learned Advocate that the petitioner has been suffering from acute abdominal pain and therefore, urgent surgical intervention is required. Counsel also contends that petitioner does not have any remote link with the suicide of Rajasree Deb because she used to live at a faraway place from the house of the deceased. Counsel argues that, the charge of abetment against her to the commission of suicide is absolutely unacceptable. Counsel therefore, urges the Court for granting pre arrest bail to the petitioner. [5] Mr.Ratan Datta, learned PP on the other hand has produced the CD and opposed the bail application on the ground that this court after consideration of the matter on merit rejected the bail application of the petitioner relying on the suicidal note of the deceased and the statements of her mother and brother. Counsel submits that there is no change in the situation except the medical ground of the petitioner and in view of the role played by the petitioner in the commission of suicide by Ms.Rajasree Deb, her bail application cannot be entertained. Counsel therefore, urges the Court for rejecting her bail application. [6] Her application for pre arrest bail in AB No.76 of 2021 was rejected by this Court by the following order: “[4] Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned advocate appearing for the applicants along with Mr. Kishalay Roy, advocate. Al…
29. 09.2021 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge of Agartala in Bail Application No.181 of 2021 whereby bail was granted to Smt. Panna Deb under Section 439 Cr. P.C after 25 days of her detention in custody. Counsel submits that other than Smt. Panna Deb another accused namely, Biswajit Deb has also been released on pre-arrest bail by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Agartala by his order dated 24.09.2021 (Annexure-2 to the application) in Bail Application No.178 of 2021. Counsel submits that the present applicants namely, Sri Ashish Das and Smt. Putul Deb are also entitled to bail on the ground of parity as the other two accused of this case who were booked under same charges have been granted bail. In support of his contention Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has relied on an order dated 11.07.2005 of the Apex Court in Kamaljit Singh Vrs. State of Punjab and another; reported in (2005) 7 anticipatory bail applying the principle of parity observing as under: “Heard the counsel for the parties. In the facts and circumstances of the case we are of the view that it is an appropriate case in which the application of the appellant for grant of anticipatory bail ought to have been allowed, particularly when on similar allegations the remaining two accused have been granted the benefit of anticipatory bail. In these circumstances the appeal is allowed and the appellant is directed to b…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
AB No.80 of 2021
Smti. Putul Deb, wife of
Sri Asish Das, resident of Kalibarir
Paschimpara,
Bikramnagar,
Sekerkote,
P.S-Amtali,
P.OSekerkote,Pin-799130, District-West Tripura, Tripura.
…………… Petitioner(s).
Vs.
The State of Tripura.
…………… Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s) :
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
For Respondent(s):
Mr. Ratan Datta, Public Prosecutor,
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. Public Prosecutor.
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
ORDER
12/01/2022
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner who urges the Court for confirmation of pre-arrest bail
which has been granted to the petitioner namely, Smt. Putul Deb
under Section 438 Cr. P.C for an interim period. Also heard Mr. S.
Debnath, learned Additional Public Prosecutor who appears for the
State-respondent.
[2]
Initially the bail application of the petitioner for her
release on pre-arrest bail was rejected by this court by an order
dated 8.10.2021 in AB No. 76 of 2021 while her accused husband
Ashish Das was granted pre-arrest bail. Subsequently, she
approached this Court by filing a fresh application under Section
438 Cr. P.C on medical ground which was allowed by this Court by
order dated 17.11.2021 which reads as under:
“17.11.2021
[1]
This is an application for granting pre-arrest
bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C filed by the accused
applicant namely Putul Rani Deb who is apprehending
arrest in East Agartala Women Police Station Case
No.2021 WEA 048 registered for offence punishable
under Section 306 read with Section 34 IPC. Similar
application filed on behalf of the petitioner was
considered by this court on 08.10.2021 in AB No.76
of 2021 and after considering the matter on merit,
the petition was rejected by this Court.
[2]
The facts of the case may be reproduced from
the order dated 08.10.2021 passed by this court in
AB No.76 of 2021 which reads as under:
“2.
.........................
Smt.
Bijoy
Laxmi
Debbarma, woman Assistant Sub Inspector of
police lodged a suo-motu complaint with the
Officerin-Charge of her police station on
04.09.2021 alleging, inter alia, that the
present petitioners who are husband and wife
along with accused Smt. Panna Deb and
Biswajit Deb treated Ms. Rajashree Deb with
cruelty which caused severe mental distress
to her and to get rid of such mental distress
Ms. Rajashree Deb committed suicide. A
suicidal note was recovered from the pocket
of her trouser which she was wearing at the
time of committing suicide and in her suicidal
note the deceased held Smt. Panna Deb, Smt.
Putul Deb, Sri Biswajit Deb and Ashish Das
responsible for death. The complainant police
officer also alleged in her suo-motu FIR that
the said accused persons used to harass the
deceased for not getting married which
caused her depression and led her to finish
her life by committing suicide. Said complaint
was registered as East Agartala Women P.S
Case No. 2021 WEA 048 and investigation of
the case was taken up by police.”
[3]
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Ratan Datta, learned
PP representing the State respondent.
[4]
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has annexed a
clinical document as Annexure-9 to the petition which
is dated 23.10.2021. The said document has been
issued from the Rabindranath Tagore International
Institute
of
Cardiac
Science,
Kolkata
which
demonstrates that petitioner has been diagnosed with
calculus in her Gall Bladder and she has been advised
to take admission in the hospital on 19.11.2021 and
undergo surgery on the following day i.e. on
20.11.2021. It is submitted by Mr. Lodh, learned
Advocate that the petitioner has been suffering from
acute abdominal pain and therefore, urgent surgical
intervention is required. Counsel also contends that
petitioner does not have any remote link with the
suicide of Rajasree Deb because she used to live at a
faraway place from the house of the deceased.
Counsel argues that, the charge of abetment against
her to the commission of suicide is absolutely
unacceptable. Counsel therefore, urges the Court for
granting pre arrest bail to the petitioner.
[5]
Mr.Ratan Datta, learned PP on the other hand
has produced the CD and opposed the bail application
on the ground that this court after consideration of
the matter on merit rejected the bail application of
the petitioner relying on the suicidal note of the
deceased and the statements of her mother and
brother. Counsel submits that there is no change in
the situation except the medical ground of the
petitioner and in view of the role played by the
petitioner in the commission of suicide by
Ms.Rajasree Deb, her bail application cannot be
entertained. Counsel therefore, urges the Court for
rejecting her bail application.
[6]
Her application for pre arrest bail in AB No.76
of 2021 was rejected by this Court by the following
order:
“[4] Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned advocate
appearing for the applicants along with Mr.
Kishalay Roy, advocate. Also heard Mr. S.
Debnath, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor
representing the State respondent.
[5] Mr. Lodh, learned counsel of the
petitioners has taken me to the order dated
29.09.2021 passed by the Additional
Sessions
Judge
of
Agartala
in
Bail
Application No.181 of 2021 whereby bail
was granted to Smt. Panna Deb under
Section 439 Cr. P.C after 25 days of her
detention in custody. Counsel submits that
other than Smt. Panna Deb another accused
namely, Biswajit Deb has also been
released on pre-arrest bail by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, Agartala by his
order dated 24.09.2021 (Annexure-2 to the
application) in Bail Application No.178 of
2021. Counsel submits that the present
applicants namely, Sri Ashish Das and Smt.
Putul Deb are also entitled to bail on the
ground of parity as the other two accused
of this case who were booked under same
charges have been granted bail. In support
of his contention Mr. Lodh, learned counsel
has relied on an order dated 11.07.2005 of
the Apex Court in Kamaljit Singh Vrs. State
of Punjab and another; reported in (2005) 7
SCC 226 wherein the Court granted
anticipatory bail applying the principle of
parity observing as under:
“Heard the counsel for the parties. In
the facts and circumstances of the
case we are of the view that it is an
appropriate
case
in
which
the
application of the appellant for grant
of anticipatory bail ought to have been
allowed, particularly when on similar
allegations the remaining two accused
have been granted the benefit of
anticipatory
bail.
In
these
circumstances the appeal is allowed
and the appellant is directed to be
released on bail in the event of arrest
or surrender on his furnishing bail
bonds to the satisfaction of the
arresting officer or the Court, as the
case may be, subject to the condition
laid down in Section 438 Cr. P.C.”
[6] Counsel submits that even though the
applicants are close relatives of the
deceased, they never lived together with
her. They used to visit her occasionally.
They were very affectionate to the
deceased and in no manner they could be
connected with the commission of her
suicide. Rather, they always helped to come
out of her depression.
[7] Relying on the medical prescriptions of
a consultant psychiatrist and several
prescriptions issued from Tripura Medical
College and Dr. B. R. Ambedkar Memorial
Teaching Hospital counsel submits that the
deceased
was
a
patient
of
chronic
depression and mental illness. Counsel
refers to the case history of the deceased
appearing in the clinical documents issued
from Tripura Medical College and Dr. B. R.
Ambedkar Memorial Teaching Hospital
where it has been recorded that she was of
irrational conduct and abnormal behaviour
and she was aggressive to her mother and
non-cooperative to her friends and hospital
staff. Counsel submits that the medical
documents go to show that she had been
suffering from such mental illness from
before 2009. It is contended by the counsel
of the petitioners that her chronic mental
depression led her to commit suicide for
which no one including the petitioners can
be held responsible. It is also contended by
Mr. Lodh, learned advocate that applicants,
Ashish Das is a decorator by occupation and
his wife Smt. Putul Deb is a government
employee. If accused Ashish Das is arrested
and detained in custody, his business
during the festive season will be spoilt and
in the event of arrest of his wife Smt. Putul
Deb, her service career will be jeopardized.
Counsel also submits that they have a
minor daughter at home and in the event of
their arrest there will be none at home to
look after the minor daughter. Counsel
submits that abatement has a wider
meaning which involves a mental process of
instigating a person or intentionally aiding
such person for doing a thing for which
evidence is necessary to show that a very
active role was played by the applicants in
instigating or aiding the deceased to
commit suicide. Counsel submits that there
is no such evidence against the applicants
that they had played such role leading to
the commission of suicide by the deceased.
Counsel therefore, urges the court for
granting pre-arrest bail to the applicants.
[8]
Heard
Mr.
S.
Debnath,
learned
Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for
the State respondent. Mr. Debnath refers to
the suicidal note of the deceased contained
in the case diary and submits that in her
suicidal note, the deceased has held the
applicants responsible for her suicide.
Counsel submits that in her suicidal note,
she has clearly stated that applicants made
her life miserable by abusing her, as a
result of which she finished her life. It is
also contended by Mr. Debnath that she has
clearly stated in her suicidal note that
present applicant Smt. Putul Deb and bailed
out accused Smt. Panna Deb used to treat
her as a maid servant for which she
finished her life. Counsel therefore, submits
that Smt. Putul Deb, one of the applicants
herein is not entitled to the extra ordinary
relief of pre-arrest bail. Counsel further
submits that Smt. Panna Deb was granted
bail by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge under Section 439 Cr. P.C in view of
her prolonged detention in custody. The
other accused was granted bail by the
learned Sessions Judge mainly on the
ground of his critical illness who preferred
bail application after he was admitted in a
hospital at Kolkata for surgery. Counsel
therefore, submits that the principle of
parity will not apply in the case of the
present applicants. Counsel urges the Court
to take into consideration the seriousness
of the offence and involvement of the
applicants in the said offence and reject
their bail applications.
[9] Considered the submissions of the
counsel of the parties. Perused the case
diary particularly, the statements of the
mother and brother of the deceased. There
is nothing on record that the deceased ever
attempted commission of suicide even
though
she
was
undergoing
mental
depression and receiving treatment from
psychiatrist. In the alleged suicidal note
she has clearly stated that Smt. Panna Deb
and Smt. Putul Deb used to treat her as a
maid servant and made her life miserable.
The investigating agency is verifying the
authenticity
of
the
suicidal
note.
Examination of the witnesses acquainted
with the facts of the case is also in
progress. As observed by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the judgment relied on by the
counsel of the petitioners, the principle of
parity as pointed out by learned counsel
would apply only when the similarly
situated accused booked under similar
charges are granted bail. In the present
case, the suicidal note of the deceased as
well as the statement of the witnesses
particularly those of the mother and brother
of the deceased have made out a strong
prima facie case against applicant Smt.
Putul Deb. Though the charge is same
against
her,
incriminating
materials
collected during investigation are heavier
against her. The materials demonstrate that
the deceased was her brother’s daughter.
Since the family of the deceased had no
income, they were dependent of the
applicant who is an earning woman and, as
such, the applicant Smt. Putul Deb had
control over the whole family of the
deceased. In this situation, the role of
applicant Smt. Putul Deb in the commission
of suicide of the deceased has to be verified
by a full and fair investigation of the case. I
am convinced that her release on pre-arrest
bail is likely to affect a full and fair
investigation because witnesses are her
relatives and vulnerable to her influence.
The suicidal note and statements of the
witnesses recorded during investigation
cannot be ignored simply for the reason
that the victim was a patient of mental
depression. This is a case in which a young
and helpless woman committed suicide
under miserable circumstances. Therefore,
a thorough investigation in the case is
necessary.
[10] Considering all these aspects, bail
application of Smt. Putul Deb is rejected. In
view of the materials available on record,
pre-arrest bail is granted to Ashish Das. In
the event of his arrest or surrender Sri
Ashish Das shall be released on bail on his
furnishing a bail bond of Rs.20,000/- with
one surety of the like amount to the
satisfaction of the Investigating Officer or
the Court, as the case may be, subject to
the following conditions:
(i) He will not meet any member of
the family of the deceased or try to
influence any of the witnesses of this
case in any manner directly or
indirectly.
(ii) He will meet the Investigating
Officer as and when called for.
(iii) He will not leave the State
without
prior
approval
of
the
Investigating
Officer
during
investigation of this case.
[11] In terms of the above, the bail
application is partly allowed and disposed
of. Return the Case diary.”
[7]
Perused the entire record. Considered the
submissions made at the bar.
[8]
The medical certificate produced on behalf of
the petitioner would demonstrate that she has been
diagnosed with Gall Bladder stone and date of her
operation has been fixed on 20.11.2021. Therefore,
considering the medical grounds it would be
appropriate to provide custodial immunity to her for a
period of at least 3 weeks from today so as to enable
her to undergo surgery as advised by her doctors.
[9]
Therefore, in the event of her arrest, the
petitioner may be released on bail on her furnishing
bail bond of Rs.20,000/- with 01 surety of the like
amount till 03.12.2021.
List the matter on 03.12.2021.
Inform the IO accordingly.
Return the CD.”
[3]
At the expiry of the period of her interim bail,
petitioner moved this Court for confirmation of her bail by filing a
petition on 03.12.2021 and by an order dated 03.12.2021 the
period of petitioner’s interim bail was extended till 07.01.2022.
[4]
Today, Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner contends that the petitioner has meticulously complied
with the conditions of her bail. Counsel therefore, submits for
confirmation of her bail on any condition whatsoever.
[5]
Mr. S. Debnath, learned Additional Public Prosecutor
contends that there is no adverse report from the side of the
investigating agency against the petitioner. She never misused
the liberty granted to her under the bail order. Counsel therefore,
submits that Court may pass order as the Court may deem fit and
proper in the given facts and circumstances of the case.
[6]
Perused the updated case diary and the entire facts
and circumstances of the case. Considered the submissions of
learned counsel of the parties,
particularly the submission
advanced on behalf of the prosecution to the effect that the
petitioner has meticulously complied with the bail conditions and
extended her co-operation to the investigating agency. It is also
stated that the investigation of the case is at the matured stage
and confirmation of bail of the petitioner is not likely to obstruct
the course of the remaining part of the investigation. Therefore,
bail granted to her for an interim period is hereby confirmed. In
the event of her arrest, she will be enlarged on bail on her
furnishing a bail bond of Rs.20,000/- with one surety of the like
amount to the satisfaction of the Investigating Officer.
[7]
In terms of the above, the bail application stands
allowed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Dipankar
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review