Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010216172025
2026:GAU-AS:13996
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5981/2025
SMTI MOUCHUMI CHETIA BORA
W/O LATE PRAFULLA BORA, R/O JOKAI PALUWA NO. 1, BIHPURIA,
LAKHIMPUR, ASSAM-784161
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM, ELEMENTARY EDUCATION DEPARTMENT,
DISPUR, GUWAHATI-6
2:THE DIRECTOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI-19
3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR
AXOM SARBA SIKSHA ABHIYAN MISSION
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI-19
4:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
BISWANATH
PIN-784176
5:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
BISWANATH
PIN-784176
6:HE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
CHAIDUAR EDUCATION BLOCK
CHAIDUAR
Page No.# 2/13
BISWANATH-78416
A– B E F O R E –
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SOUMITRA SAIKIA
Advocate for the petitioners
: Mr. I Amin, Advocate
Advocate for the respondents : Mr. P.K. Borah, SC, Elementary Education
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: NA
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 22.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
: No
·
·
Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Heard Mr. I Amin, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. P. K.
Borah, learned Standing Counsel for the Elementary Education.
2. The writ petitioner herein is the widow of Late Prafulla Bora, who died in
harness on 21.11.2024 by leaving behind the writ petitioner and two minor
children as his dependent. According to the writ petitioner, after the premature
death of her late husband, the petitioner was entitled to the benefit of
compassionate family pension under the special scheme notified by the
Page No.# 3/13
Government of Assam vide notification dated 14/09/2017. As such, the
petitioner had submitted representation before the authorities on 10.02.2025
seeking the benefit of Compassionate Family Pension. However, despite receipt
of the said representation, no action whatsoever has been taken by the
respondents till date.
3. The facts and circumstances of the case, briefly stated, are that the
petitioner’s husband late Prafulla Bora was initially appointed as an Assistant
Teacher under the Axom Sarba Siksha Abhiyan Mission, Assam vide appointment
order dated 12.08.2012. While he was in continuous service as a Contractual
Assistant Teacher under the Axom Sarba Siksha Abhiyan Mission, the Director of
Elementary Education, Assam issued an Advertisement dated 05.08.2024, titled
“Advertisement for Special Recruitment Drive” inviting online applications from
eligible Contractual and State Pool Contractual Teachers working under Samagra
Shiksha Assam for regular appointment as Assistant Teachers in Lower Primary
and Upper Primary Schools. The said advertisement, inter alia, stipulated that
the candidates, as on 31st July, 2024, must be working as Contractual and State
Pool Contractual Teachers under SSA and must have completed 5 years of
continuous service as on the said date. The petitioner’s late husband having
fulfilled the eligibility criteria, applied the same within the prescribed time and
got selected. Consequently, his service was regularized vide appointment order
Page No.# 4/13
dated 02.09.2024. Thereafter, after being declared medically fit, the petitioner’s
late husband submitted his joining letter on 16.09.2024 before the Pub Miri
Pathar L.P School under the Biswanath Education Block and thereafter
discharged his duties as a regular Assistant Teacher.
4. While the petitioner’s late husband was working as an Assistant Teacher, he
unfortunately expired on 21.11.2024. The core question arising for adjudication
by this Court in the present writ petition is as to whether, under the scheme of
Compassionate Family Pension (CFP) notified by the Government of Assam on
14/09/2017, the writ petitioner would be entitled to receive CFP.
5. In the above context, it would be pertinent to mention herein that on
14/09/2017, the Government of Assam had notified the scheme for CFP in lieu
of the scheme of Compassionate Appointment by laying down the terms and
conditions for extending the benefit of Compassionate Family Pension.
Apparently, by relying upon clause 5.3 of the CFP scheme, the respondent
authority has rejected the prayer of the petitioner towards her claim for
payment of CFP allegedly on the ground that the petitioner’s deceased husband
had not completed the minimum period of 1(one) year of continuous service.
6. By referring to the documents available on record, Mr. I Amin, learned
counsel for the writ petitioner has argued that proviso to Clause 5.3 does not
require the deceased Government servant to have completed 1(one) year of
Page No.# 5/13
continuous service as a regular employee. The scheme requires is that he must
be in employment under the Government continuously for a period more than 1
(one) year without any break so as to come within the purview of the CFP
scheme. Considering the fact that the deceased husband of the petitioner was in
continuous service since the year 2012 till the time of his death, hence, submits
Mr. I Amin, that he had evidently fulfilled the criteria laid down by proviso to
Clause 5.3 so as to enable the writ petitioner to get the benefit of the CFP.
7. The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the petitioner’s
husband was initially appointed as Contractual Assistant Teacher under the
Axom Sarba Siksha Abhiyan Mission, Assam vide appointment order dated
12.08.2012 and he duly submitted his joining report. By referring to the
advertisement notice dated 05.08.2024 as well as the order of appointment
dated 02.09.2024, the learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the said
advertisement was issued inviting applications from eligible Contractual and
State Pool Contractual Teachers working under the Samagra Shiksha Assam for
regular appointment as Assistant Teachers in Lower Primary and Upper Primary
Schools. It is also mentioned in the advertisement that the candidates, as on
31st July, 2024, must be working as Contractual and State Pool Contractual
Teachers under SSA and must have completed 5 years of continuous service as
on the said date. The petitioners’ late husband having fulfilled the eligibility
Page No.# 6/13
criteria, applied for the same and was duly selected in the said process. In that
view of the matter, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that husband of
the petitioner, having served under the respondents continuously for more than
1 (one) year, the service rendered by the writ petitioner’s late husband is
entitled to be conferred the benefit under the scheme of compassionate family
pension.
8. Mr. P. K. Borah, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the Education
Department submits that the claim of the writ petitioner is not maintainable.
The respondents have contested the case of the petitioner by filing their
affidavit-in-opposition.
9. I have considered the arguments advanced at the Bar and have also carefully
gone through the materials available on record.
10. A bare reading of the notification dated 14/09/2017 goes to show that the
CFP scheme was introduced by the Government of Assam in the Finance
Department, so as to replace the existing scheme of “compassionate
appointment” for the family members of the deceased Government employee
who had lost the sole bread earner. The objective of the said scheme was to
provide immediate succour to the family members of the deceased Government
servant which had lost the sole bread earner. It was felt that due to several
operational reasons, the scheme for “compassionate appointment” had failed to
Page No.# 7/13
serve its purpose, which was to provide immediate relief to the family members
of the deceased employee. Taking note of such ground realities, the CFP
scheme was introduced in the year 2017 with a view to give immediate relief to
the family members of the deceased Government employee(s). The operative
part of the scheme, as contained in para 5, which has 12 sub-paragraphs, are
reproduced herein below for ready reference:“5. The detailed guidelines as provided below shall be followed by all the
departments in the State Government.
5.1 The applicable definition of family of the employee dies-in harness will be the
definition of family that is given in the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 (as
amended from time to time).
5.2 CFP scheme is not applicable for Voluntary retirement/resignation or any other
cases and “an employee diesin-harness” is the sole criteria. The cause for the death
of the employee-in-harness can be anything, either natural or unnatural.
5.3 Where the employee dies before superannuation, the family pension equal to
100% of the last pay drawn by the deceased employee be paid for a period upto
the date of ‘deemed superannuation’ of the deceased employee i.e. the date on
which the employee would have superannuated had he been alive. This would
compensate the loss of family income to a large extent and fulfill the requirement of
compassionate conditions arising out of the death of the serving employee.
However, the Govt. servant must complete minimum 1 (one) year of continuous
service without break before death while in service.
[Emphasis Supplied]
5.4 The last pay drawn for this purpose is the last basic pay (pay in the pay band
plus grade pay). Over and above, the Compassionate. Family Pensioner will get the
applicable Dearness Relief and other Relief amounts as admissible in the normal
family pension.
5.5 The CFP fixed at 100% of the last pay drawn will be revised periodically as and
when normal pension/family pension are revised.
5.6 On attaining the date of deemed Superannuation, the CFP will be converted into
normal Family Pension. This normal family pension shall be fixed at 50% of CFP
from the date of deemed superannuation till 67 years of age of the deceased
employee. During this period of 7 years, the normal family pension will be revised
periodically as and when normal pension is revised.
Page No.# 8/13
5.7 Further, on completion of above period of 7 years, the normal family pension will
be reduced from 50% to 30% till the applicable eligibility as per the Assam Services
(Pension) Rules, 1969 (as amended from time to time).
5.8 But, in case of CFP, the Compassionate Family Pensioner ceases to get the CFP
at 100% of the last pay drawn if the Compassionate Family Pensioner happens to
be ineligible for normal family pension as per Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969
(as amended from time to time).
5.9 This will be applicable to all employees of State Government, provincialised
employees and all others as eligible under Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 (as
amended from time to time), all State Government employees under NPS category
and All India Services officers borne on Assam cadre.
5.10 It is also provided that if the parents or other eligible family members are not
looked after by the Compassionate Family Pensioner, on receipt of such complaint
from them, the competent authority will issue orders apportioning the
Compassionate Family Pension appropriately among the other eligible family
members.
5.11 The scheme is applicable to those employees who died/die in harness on or
after 01/04/2017. However, the relevant OMs related to the Compassionate
appointments will be applicable to those who died on or before 31/03/2017.
5.12 The Pension and Public Grievances Department and Personnel (B) Department
will take further necessary action accordingly by amending/issuing necessary
rules/guidelines.”
11. In the above context, it will be pertinent to note herein that in paragraph
5.1 of the scheme, it has been mentioned that the definition of family of the
employee who dies in harness will be the same as that given in the Assam
Services (Pension) Rules, 1969. In para 5.2, it has been categorically laid down
that
the
CFP
scheme
would
not
be
applicable
for
voluntary
retirement/resignation but in all other cases, the sole criteria would be that “an
employee dies in harness”. Even the cause of death of the employee would not
be of any relevance. Paragraph 5.3 lays down the rate at which family pension
Page No.# 9/13
would be payable to the family of the deceased employee. However, the
Government servant must complete 1 year of continuous service without break
before death while in service. From paragraph 5.9, it is further clear that a
Government employee coming under NPS category would also be covered under
the scheme, meaning thereby that those employees who do not come within the
purview of Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969, would also come within the
ambit of the CFP scheme.
12. From a careful examination of the various clauses of the CFP scheme, it is
thus apparent that the scheme has a benevolent object of providing immediate
relief to the family members of the deceased employee who had lost the sole
bread earner. Therefore, the question of eligibility to receive the benefit under
the CFP scheme will have to be adjudicated strictly with reference to the criteria
laid down in the scheme itself and not by relying upon any other Rules including
the Pension Rules of 1969. There is no expressed provisions under the CFP
scheme that claims thereunder will be payable only subject to the Rules of
1969. Nothing prevented the State to amend the said Rules or to make an
expressed provision to such effect in the CFP scheme itself, which has evidently
not been done in this case.
13. In the present case, there is no doubt or dispute about the fact that the
deceased husband of the petitioner was selected and appointed for engagement
Page No.# 10/13
as Assistant Teacher on Contractual Basis under Assam Sarba Siksha Abhiyan
Mission, Government of Assam vide appointment letter dated 12.08.2012.
Subsequently, by order dated 2 nd September, 2024, the petitioner’s late husband
was appointed as Assistant Teacher in Lower Primary on purely temporary basis
in the Pay Band-2 at Rs. 14,000-70,000 plus Grade Pay and other allowances as
admissible under the Assam Services (Revision of Pay) (Amendment) Rules,
2019 subject to final outcome of the writ petition, being WP(C) No. 4031/2024
and other writ petition. His appointment was against the personal post which
will get abolished as and when the person superannuates. Since then, he has
been in continuous service under the Government of Assam without any break
until the date of his unfortunate demise on 21.11.2024.
14. It appears that since after the initial appointment as a Contractual Assistant
Teacher under the Government of Assam, the petitioner’s husband was not
subjected to any further selection prior to his appointment as Assistant Teacher,
therefore, it is evident that the appointment of late Prafulla Bora as Assistant
Teacher was not only pursuant to the same selection process but it was also in
continuation of his initial appointment as Contractual Assistant Teacher vide
appointment order dated 12.08.2012. Though the appointment was Contractual
Assistant Teacher, but the selection process so conducted by the authority was
also meant for filling up vacant posts on regular basis. No separate selection
Page No.# 11/13
process was undertaken prior to bringing him into the regular cadre.
15. There are several precedents laid by this Court as well as by the Apex Court
where Courts have held that service(s) rendered prior to regularization can be
counted towards grant of pensionary benefits.
16. In Kabiram Rajbangsi Vs. State of Assam & Others, reported in 1997 (1) GLT
589, the Co-ordinate bench of this Court held that services rendered prior to
regularization can be taken into account for consideration of the pensionary
benefits of the employee.
17. Similar view was rendered by another Co-ordinate Bench in Sh. Abdul
Hannan Vs. State of Assam & Others in W.P(C) No. 2821/2009.
18. The Apex Court in Prem Singh Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Others, reported
in (2019) 10 SCC 516 held that period of service of an employee prior to his
regularization, was also to be counted as qualifying service for the purposes of
pension.
19. Similar views have been held by the Apex Court in The State of Gujarat &
Ors. Vs. Talsibhai Dhanjibhai Patel, reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 187 as well as
in Habib Ali Barbhuiya Vs. State of Assam & Ors passed by this Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in W.P.(C) No. 1777/2015.
20. The law laid down by the Apex Court as well as this Court is that services
rendered by any employee prior to their regularization should be counted
Page No.# 12/13
towards their pensionary benefits if there is any shortfall in their services
rendered after being regularized. Under such circumstances, when there is no
dispute that the petitioner’s husband had rendered services in ad-hoc capacity
continuously against valid sanctioned posts without any break in service and he
came to be subsequently regularized by the Government and at the time of his
superannuation, the employee did not have qualifying services from the date of
his regularization, then in the opinion of this Court and as has been held by
several decisions as discussed above, the period of services rendered prior to
regularization, if they are continuous and without any break till such services are
regularized can also be counted for the purposes of satisfying the qualifying
period of service prescribed for grant of pension under the relevant Rules.
21. After considering in detail the facts and circumstances of the case and the
various provisions of the Act, and upon carefully perusal of the various clauses
contained in the notification dated 14.09.2017, this Court holds that if there is
any shortfall in qualifying service after being regularized, then the services
rendered by any employee prior to their regularization can be counted towards
their pensionary benefits.
22. Under such circumstances, applying the law expanded by this Court and the
Apex Court as discussed above, when there is no dispute that the petitioner’s
late husband had rendered service continuously without any break in service
Page No.# 13/13
and was subsequently regularized by the Government, therefore, he had
evidently completed more than 1 year of service, this Court is of the considered
view that the period of service rendered as a Contractual Teacher can be
counted for the purpose of satisfying the qualifying period of service for claiming
the benefits of Compassionate Family Pension (CFP) Scheme introduced by the
notification dated 14.09.2017. Therefore, this Court directs the respondents to
forthwith process the claim of the petitioner for grant of CFP and release the
amount within a period of 45 (forty five) days from the date of receipt of
certified copy of this order.
23. It is made clear that if the amount, as directed by this Court, along with
arrear dues, if any, be released to the writ petitioner within 60 (Sixty) days from
the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
24. Writ petition stands allowed to the extent indicated above.
25. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review