The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
09. From the relevant documents submitted with the memo of appeal, it appears that on the day of alleged accident, the offending vehicle of the present appellant was duly insured with the respondent-Insurance Company. From the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below, it appears that before the Learned Tribunal, the present appellant failed to produce the original Insurance Certificate to substantiate her defence. So, Learned Tribunal below rightly fastened the liability of payment of compensation upon the present appellant herein. But since the present appellant had valid Insurance Certificate on the day of alleged accident of the offending vehicle, so, for the sake of justice, an opportunity be given to the appellant to adduce her valid Insurance Certificate for marking exhibit before the Learned Tribunal below. So, after hearing the contesting parties, it appears that this is a fit case which be remanded back to the Learned Tribunal below with a direction to provide an opportunity to the present appellant O.P. No.1 to adduce her original Insurance Certificate for marking exhibit. Since, no other points raised by Learned Counsels of the parties, so, this appeal is decided only to the extent of shifting the liability of payment of compensation.
10. In the result, the appeal filed by the present appellant, O.P.No.1 is hereby partly allowed. The judgment and award dated 07.04.2018 of the Learned MAC Tribunal No.1, West Tripura Agartala in connection with case No. T.S.(MAC) 42 of 2013 is hereby set aside with a direction to the Learned Tribunal below to give an opportunity to the present appellant to adduce her original Insurance Certificate for marking exhibit after affording opportunity to the other parties for cross-examination of the said appellant at the time of recording of evidence if necessary and thereafter to deliver a fresh judgment regarding liability of payment of compensation by the Insurance Company, if the document, so adduced by the appellant is found to be valid. The appellant shall appear before the Learned Tribunal below on
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
M.A.C. App. No.56 of 2024
Smt. Manimala Das,
Wife of Shri Manir Kumar Das,
of Kuchainala,
P.O. Kuchainala, P.S.-Kamalpur,
District- Dhalai Tripura.
(Owner of T.R-04-A-1642-TATA Ace)
......Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Shri Bivash Nath,
Son of Shri Banka Bihari Nath,
of Makumchara,
P.O. Laljuri, P.S.- Kanchanpur,
District- North Tripura 799270
2. The Divisional Manager,
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited,
Central Road, Kaman Chowmohani, Agartala,
P.O Agartala, P.S.- West Agartala,
District- West Tripura
(Insurer of T.R-04-A-1642-TATA Ace).
…...Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Alik Das, Adv,
Mr. B. Majumder, Adv.
Date of Hearing &
Judgment and Order :
20.09.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
This appeal is directed challenging the judgment
and award dated 07.04.2018 delivered by Learned Member,
MAC Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with
case No.T.S.(MAC) 42 of 2013. By the said judgment and
award, Learned Member, Tribunal No.1, West Tripura,
Agartala has awarded a sum of Rs.1,66,800/- (Rupees one
lakh sixty six thousand eight hundred only) in favour of the
respondent-claimant and fastened the liability of payment of
compensation upon the O.P. No.1, Smt. Manimala Das, i.e.
the appellant herein for payments. Feeling aggrieved and
dissatisfied with the judgment/award, this present appeal is
preferred by the appellant O.P. No.1.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Chakraborty for
the appellant and also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Alik Das
for the respondent-claimant and Learned Counsel, Mr. B.
Majumder for the respondent- Insurance Company.
03.
In
course
of
hearing
of
argument,
Learned
Counsel for the appellant submitted before this Court that
before the Learned Tribunal, after receipt of notice, the
present appellant appeared and filed her written statement
denying the claim of the claimant-petitioner and also took
the plea that on the alleged day of accident, the offending
vehicle of the present appellant, i.e. the O.P. No.1 was
insured with the Oriental Insurance Company Limited, i.e.
the respondent No.2 herein. But at the time of adducing
evidence, the present appellant could not produce her
original Insurance Certificate in support of her defence
before the Learned Tribunal, for which at the time of delivery
of judgment, the Learned below was pleased to fasten/fix the
liability of payment of compensation upon the present
appellant herein. It was further submitted that if the appeal
is not allowed and the appellant is not given the scope to
adduce her relevant document for marking exhibit, in that
case the present appellant would be seriously prejudiced and
being an Anganwadi worker, she would face severe financial
hardships, as she is not in a position to compensate the
claimant. So, Learned Counsel for the appellant fairly
submitted before the Court to allow this appeal and to remit
back this case to the Tribunal below for adducing the
Insurance Certificate for marking exhibit, so as to exonerate
her from the liability of payment of compensation.
04.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel, Mr. Alik Das
appearing for the respondent-claimant-petitioner supported
the submission made by Learned Counsel for the appellant
and submitted that before the Tribunal, although the
appellant took the plea that she had got valid Insurance
Certificate of the offending vehicle on the day of accident,
but she could not produce her original Insurance Certificate
before the Tribunal for marking of exhibit, for which the
Learned Tribunal below was compelled to fasten the liability
of payment of compensation upon the present appellant and
prayed for passing appropriate order.
Learned
Insurance
Counsel,
Company
Mr.
submitted
B.
Majumder
that
the
for
the
respondent
Insurance Company contested the case before the Tribunal
by filing W.S., but before the Tribunal, the present appellant
as O.P. No.1 failed to produce her original Insurance
Certificate for marking exhibit for which the liability was
fastened upon the present appellant by the Learned Tribunal
and the present respondent-Insurance Company had no
negligence in this regard and urged for dismissal of this
appeal.
05.
In the case at hand, the respondent-claimant filed
one claim-petition before the Learned Tribunal under Section
166 of M.V. Act alleging inter alia that on 29.05.2012 when
the
claimant-petitioner,
after
purchasing
some
articles
(Dhari, made of bamboo) from Kulai market was proceeding
towards Kachuchara TSR Camp by hiring a vehicle bearing
No.TR-04-A-1642. On the way, the driver was running the
vehicle in high speed in rash and negligent manner for which
the vehicle overturned near Kachuchara TSR Camp. As a
result of which, the claimant-petitioner sustained grievous
injuries
and
became
50%
disabled.
As
the
petitioner
sustained injuries in a vehicular accident, so, he filed the
claim-petition before the Tribunal for allowing compensation.
The present appellant as O.P. No.1 appeared before the
Tribunal
and
filed
her
written
statement
and
further
submitted that on the day of alleged accident, the offending
vehicle
was
duly
insured
with
the
Oriental
Insurance
Company and as such, if any compensation is required to be
paid, then the Insurance Company, being the insurer of the
offending
vehicle
be
directed
to
pay
the
same.
The
respondent-Insurance Company also contested the case by
filing written statement and took the plea that the claimpetition of the petitioner was exorbitant and he was not
entitled to such compensation and further took the plea that
the claim-petition was subjected to strict proof.
06.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, the following
two issues were framed by the Learned Tribunal below:
1. Did the claimant petitioner sustain any
injury on 29.05.2012 at about 10-30 a.m. at
Kachuchara near 3rd. Bn. TSR Camp under
Kachuchara P.S. in a road traffic accident
involving the vehicle bearing registration
No.TR-04-A-1642 (TATA Ace) due to rash
and negligent driving of the driver of the
said vehicle;
2. Is the claimant petitioner entitled to
compensation under the provision of M. V.
Act, 1988? If so, who is liable to pay
compensation and to what extent?
07.
The claimants adduced their evidence, but the
OPs failed to adduce any oral/documentary evidence on
record in support of their defence. Finally, on conclusion of
the proceeding, the Learned Tribunal below allowed the
claim-petition but fastened the liability of payment of
compensation upon the present appellant on the ground that
before the Tribunal below, the present appellant failed to
produce her relevant document to substantiate that the
offending vehicle was duly insured with the respondentInsurance Company on the day of alleged accident. For the
sake
of
convenience,
the
operative
portion
of
the
judgment/award of the Tribunal is mentioned herein under:
10. In the result, the petition under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act is hereby
allowed on contest. The claimant is
awarded a sum of Rs.1,66,800/- (Rupees
one lakh sixty six thousand eight hundred)
only as compensation in this case for the
injuries sustained by him in a vehicular
accident.
Opposite
party
No.1
Mrs.
Manimala Das being the owner of TR-04-A1642 is hereby directed to pay the said
amount of compensation to the claimantpetitioner within a period of 30 (thirty)
days from the date of judgment. This
amount shall carry interest @ 6% (six per
cent) per annum from the date of
presentation
of
the
petition,
i.e.,
24.01.2013 before the Tribunal till the
payment is made.
The amount be released to the claimant by
transmitting it directly from the Court to
the individual Bank Account of the
claimant. It shall not be transmitted to a
Joint Bank Account held by the claimant
with any other member of his family or any
other person.
The claimant is directed to furnish a
photocopy of the Pass Book duly certified
by the Bank having IFSC Code & MICR
Code.”
Challenging the aforesaid judgment and award,
this present appeal is preferred by the appellant-O.P. No.1,
i.e. the owner of the offending vehicle.
08.
I have heard arguments of Learned Counsels at
length and also gone through the judgment and award of the
Learned Tribunal below dated 07.04.2018. It appears that
there is no dispute on record regarding date and time of
accident on 29.05.2012 and also regarding sustaining injury
by the respondent-claimant due to accident of the vehicle
bearing No.TR-04-A-1642 by its driver through rash and
negligent driving. After taking evidence on record, the
Learned Tribunal below allowed the claim-petition of the
respondent-claimant-petitioner.
09.
From the relevant documents submitted with the
memo of appeal, it appears that on the day of alleged
accident, the offending vehicle of the present appellant was
duly insured with the respondent-Insurance Company. From
the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below, it appears that
before the Learned Tribunal, the present appellant failed to
produce the original Insurance Certificate to substantiate her
defence. So, Learned Tribunal below rightly fastened the
liability of payment of compensation upon the present
appellant herein. But since the present appellant had valid
Insurance Certificate on the day of alleged accident of the
offending vehicle, so, for the sake of justice, an opportunity
be given to the appellant to adduce her valid Insurance
Certificate for marking exhibit before the Learned Tribunal
below. So, after hearing the contesting parties, it appears
that this is a fit case which be remanded back to the Learned
Tribunal below with a direction to provide an opportunity to
the present appellant O.P. No.1 to adduce her original
Insurance Certificate for marking exhibit. Since, no other
points raised by Learned Counsels of the parties, so, this
appeal is decided only to the extent of shifting the liability of
payment of compensation.
10.
In the result, the appeal filed by the present
appellant, O.P.No.1 is hereby partly allowed. The judgment
and award dated 07.04.2018
of the Learned MAC Tribunal
No.1, West Tripura Agartala in connection with case No.
T.S.(MAC) 42 of 2013 is hereby set aside with a direction to
the Learned Tribunal below to give an opportunity to the
present appellant to adduce her original Insurance Certificate
for marking exhibit after affording opportunity to the other
parties for cross-examination of the said appellant at the
time of recording of evidence if necessary and thereafter to
deliver a fresh judgment regarding liability of payment of
compensation by the Insurance Company, if the document,
so adduced by the appellant is found to be valid. The
appellant shall appear before the Learned Tribunal below on
30.09.2024. Learned Counsels for the other parties shall also
appear before the Learned Tribunal on that date and the
Learned Tribunal may record evidence of the said appellant
on the same date or any other suitable date subject to
convenience of the Learned Tribunal below and thereafter,
shall deliver a fresh judgment, regarding fixing liability of
payment of compensation in favour of the respondent-
claimant within a period of three months from the date of
delivery of this judgment.
Send down a copy of this order/judgment to the
Learned Tribunal below for information and compliance and
also supply a copy of this order/judgment to Learned
Counsels of the parties immediately.
With this observation, this appeal is disposed of.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
is
accordingly
stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.09.21 15:18:27
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review