Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/53
GAHC040001562025
2026:GAU-AP:810
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/49/2025
Smti Lupa Samon and 137 Ors
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Shri B CC Samon
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Chief Engineer
Water Resources Department
Chimpu
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
2: Hage Badal
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Hage Tanyo
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Chief Engineer
Water Resources Department
Eastern Zone
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
3: Yaba Rime
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Tumya Rime
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Superintendent Engineer
PHE
Aalo Circle
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 2/53
4: Karbin Kamduk
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Likar Kamduk
presently serving as Superintendent
PHE and Water Supply Department
Itanagar
Yachuli Circle
Arunachal Pradesh.
5: Tony Lollen
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Marto Lollen
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Chief Engineer
PHE and Water Supply Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6: Smti Mome Kato
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Vijum Yomgum
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Superintendent Engineer
PHE and WS
Circle Miao
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
7: Smti Subu Pubyang
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Shri Subu Tacho
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Superintendent Engineer
PHE and WS Circle
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
8: Roka Padu
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Bero Padu
presently serving as Superintendent
Page No.# 3/53
Office of the Chief Engineer
PHE and WS Eastern Zone
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
9: Kaling Borang
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late M Borang
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Fishery
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
10: Kishore Sen
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Kanyalal Sen
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Public Libraries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
11: Rubu Punung
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Rubu Mudo
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Land
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
12: Takhe Tana
Age: 47
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Takhe Tapu
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Land
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
13: Smti Tame Yape
Age: 53
Occupation :
Page No.# 4/53
Address:Wife of Shri Tarh Tabin
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Panchayat Raj
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
14: Debojit Pegu
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Siladhar Pegu
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Panchayat Raj
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
15: Omen Jamoh
Age: 59
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late B Jerang
presently serving as Superintendent
Rural Development Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
16: Aloke Chaudhary
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late G C Chaudhary
presently serving as Superintendent
Rural Development Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
17: Subhash Nimacho
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Lisang Nimacho
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Tourism
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
18: Millo Sanbyo
Page No.# 5/53
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Millo Chilyang
presently serving as Superintendent
Superintendent Engineer
WRD
Daporijo Circle
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
19: Pradeep Dutta
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late S B Dutta
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Directorate of Geology and Mining
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
20: Milo Lali
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Milo Guro
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Department of Town Planning
Mowb-II
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
21: Tapi Dorjee Youden
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Er Tapi Rai
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
22: T Y Sora
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Lama Wangchu
presently serving as Superintendent
office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Page No.# 6/53
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
23: Smti Tsering Chhojom
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Cherry
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
24: Rokin Megu
Age: 51
Occupation :
Address:Son of Osam Megu
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
25: Techi Ranchi
Age: 49
Occupation :
Address:Son of Techi Tazum
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
26: Babu Kunchandy
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Son of Koshy Kunchandy
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
27: Dao Yirang
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Jokit Yirang
presently serving as Superintendent
Page No.# 7/53
Office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
28: Smti Omen Yirang
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Apil Yirang
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
29: Smti Neena Tapak
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Talut Tamuk
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Directorate of Accounts and Treasuries
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
30: Koj Tami
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Koj Tagiang
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Labour and Employment
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
31: Taro Tallo
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Taro Tailyang
presently serving as Superintendent
Rural Work Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
32: Smti Ree Taipodia
Age: 52
Occupation :
Page No.# 8/53
Address:Daughter of Late Gunri Taipodia
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Director Horticulture
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
33: Miss Nyachi Ragi
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Shri Tanya Ragi
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Director Horticulture
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
34: Yomto Riba
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Karyom Riba
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Director Audit and Pension
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
35: Anthony Pertin
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Omak Pertin
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the Director Audit and Pension
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
36: Smti Mumtam Pertin
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Son of Kaku Pertin
presently serving as Superintendent
Director of Textile and Handicraft
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
37: Kago Omo
Page No.# 9/53
Age: 46
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Kago Donyi
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Industry
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
38: Takhe Muriyang
Age: 49
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Shri Takhe Laling
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Economics and Statistic
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
39: Smti Annu Pertin
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Promedra Regrom
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of IPR
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
40: Smti Hage Yamang
Age: 47
Occupation :
Address:Son of Radhe Tajum
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of IPR
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
41: Michi Jailang
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Michi Duma
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of IPR
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 10/53
42: Michi Challo
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Michi Tacho
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Urban Development
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
43: Jishu Deb
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late J K Deb
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Urban Developmet
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
44: Smti Tailyang Diming
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Tailyang Naku
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Urban Development
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
45: Smti Henpu Lollen
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Jondo Lollen
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Disaster Management
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
46: Smti Dawa Droima
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Sange Norbu
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Women and Child Development
Itanagar
Page No.# 11/53
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
47: Nani Talang
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Nani Talang
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Elementary Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
48: Gyati Lailang
Age: 46
Occupation :
Address:Son of Gyati Modi
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Elementary Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
49: Smti Phool Kumari Tanga
Age: 51
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Rungdo Tanga
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Elementary Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
50: Rebom Zirdo
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Taro Zirdo
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Secondary Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
51: Bini Tacha
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Bini Teshi
presently serving as Superintendent
Page No.# 12/53
Department of Secondary Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
52: Smti Gumken Basar
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Kargum Basar
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Secondary Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
53: Smti Jarbom Kayi
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Ijar Kayi
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Higher and Technical Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
54: Smti Bengia Yeri
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Bengia Kagam
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Higher and Technical Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
55: Nabam Arun
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Nabam Tapi
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Higher and Technical Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
56: Smti karmik Dabi
Age: 55
Occupation :
Page No.# 13/53
Address:Daughter of Chakar Dabi
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Higher and Technical Education
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
57: Smti Kime Riba
Age: 59
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Takhe Riba
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Animal Husbandry
Nirjuli
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
58: Karo Cheda
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Reda Cheda
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Animal Husbandry
Nirjuli
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
59: Smti G Kato Taba
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late D Kato
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Animal Husbandry
Nirjuli
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
60: Habung Tago
Age: 60
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Habung Tana
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Family Welfare
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
61: Koj Tapa
Page No.# 14/53
Age: 59
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Koj Hassang
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Health Service
Naharlagun
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
62: M T Abing
Age: 59
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Millo Tagyung
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Health Service
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
63: Tok Tadik Comder
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tok Tage Comder
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Family Welfare
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
64: Lukgum Romin
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late M Romin
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
65: W Lobakhow
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late R Lobakhow
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Page No.# 15/53
Arunachal Pradesh.
66: Miss N P Hina
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Nabam Tapin
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
67: Smti Karnya Kamdak
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Chikar Bam
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
68: Smti Toko Momen
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Toko Riba
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change Department
Banderdewa
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
69: N Kamgo
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Maryum Kamgo
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change (Wild Life) Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
70: T Songthing
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Samthok Songthing
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change (Wild Life) Department
Page No.# 16/53
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
71: V Kamcham
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late J Kamcham
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change (WP) Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
72: Payek Goi
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tagam Goi
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change (Wild Life) Department
Pasighat
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
73: Smti D Lego
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Dana Lego
presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change (Wild Life) Department
Deomali
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh.
74: K Modi
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:presently serving as Superintendent
Forest and Climate Change (Wild Life) Department
Pasighat
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
75: Smti Nyame Koyu
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Shri Taming Jomoh
presently serving as Superintendent
Page No.# 17/53
Directorate of Agriculture
Naharlagun
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
76: Smti Padi Yadi
Age: 59
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Late Kuru Hinda
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Agriculture
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
77: Puhoja Tangjang
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri P Tangjang
presently serving as Superintendent
Director General of Police
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
78: Smti Nang Narifa Chowpoo
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Chow Inde Chowpoo
presently serving as Superintendent
Director General of Police
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
79: Taro Talo
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Taro Chowpoo
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of CE
RWD (Coord)
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
80: Rajeet Tayeng
Page No.# 18/53
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late A Tayeng
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the CE
RWD (Coord)
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
81: Tajin Tayum
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Tajing Haglu
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the CE
RWD (E/zone)
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
82: Koj Tupe
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Koj Panyur
presently serving as Superintendent
Office of the CE
RWD (W/Zone)
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
83: Smti Aman Riba
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Shri Oten Jongkey
presently serving as Superintendent
RWD Division
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
84: Johny Matey Lowang
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late T Matey
presently serving as Superintendent
RWD Division
Page No.# 19/53
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
85: Smti Gitani Talom Tayeng
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Taplam Talom
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Research
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
86: Iba Koyu
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Bai Koyu
presently serving as Superintendent
Directorate of Research
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
87: Smti Hemm Loyi
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Shri R Loyi
presently serving as Superintendent
Hydro Power
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
88: Hibu Laling
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Hibu Ropo
presently serving as Superintendent
Hydro Power
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
89: Lod Tale
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Lod Tagia
Page No.# 20/53
presently serving as Superintendent
Hydro Power
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
90: Tage Ribya
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tage Tabin
presently serving as Superintendent
Hydro Power
Tezu
Lohit District
Arunachal Pradesh.
91: Nada Takey
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Nada Pilang
presently serving as Superintendent
Hydro Power
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
92: Kuru Gambo
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Kuru Neha
presently serving as Superintendent
Power Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
93: Smti Nani Yani
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Late Kago Rika
presently serving as Superintendent
Power Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
94: Dakkar Riba
Age: 56
Page No.# 21/53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Modak Riba
presently serving as Superintendent
Power Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
95: Smti Tilek Perme
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Agam Perme
presently serving as Superintendent
Power Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
96: Iken Nyodu
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Liyi Nyodu
presently serving as Superintendent
Power Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
97: Deyi Ori
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Binde Ori Eshi
presently serving as Superintendent
Power Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
98: Ms S C Musobi
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Pemo Musobi
presently serving as Superintendent
PWD
Central Zone (A)
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 22/53
99: Johng Tabing
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Gallong Tabing
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD Circle
Nobia
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
100: Smti R J Ragi
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Chumbi Butia
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD
Western Zone
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
101: Heli Tana Tara
Age: 59
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tana Teri
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD
Capital Circle
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
102: Anand Peei
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Heli Peei
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD
SID and P
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
103: Chow Ming Moungkang
Age: 58
Occupation :
Page No.# 23/53
Address:Son of Late Chow Mi Moungkang
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD
CE
(E/Z) Namsai
Namsai District
Arunachal Pradesh.
104: Nyamar Nyodu
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Lirik Nyodu
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD
Vigilance and Training
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
105: Tara Leya
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tapak Leya
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD Circle
Daporijo
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
106: Smti Tsewang Pemo
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Shri Pema Tsewang
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD Coordination
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
107: Tato Riram
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Take Riram
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD Circle
Boleng
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 24/53
108: Sushi Dorjee
Age: 59
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Chichu Norbu
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD Circle
Jairampur
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
109: Smti kago Yana
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Takhe Tajo
presently serving as Superintendent
Department PWD
YCC
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
110: Dawa Dorjee
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Laida Tsering
presently serving as Superintendent
PWD Department
Tezu Division
Lohit District
Arunachal Pradesh.
111: Balok Teng
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Pelom Teng
presently serving as Superintendent
PWD Department
CE (HW) Zone
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
112: Yorter Hali
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tayor Hali
presently serving as Superintendent
Page No.# 25/53
PWD Department
CE (NW) Zone
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
113: Tajar Nilo
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Lone Nijo
presently serving as Superintendent
PWD Department
Yachuli Circle
Keyi Panyor District
Arunachal Pradesh.
114: Smti oken Jini
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of late Tepi Apang
presently serving as Superintendent
PWD Department
CE (CZ-B)
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
115: Smti Bani Taku
Age: 51
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Shri Tacham Taku
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Sports and Youth Affairs
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
116: Smti Anju Riju
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Khollong Riju
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Registrar of Cooperative Society
Naharlagun
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 26/53
117: Smti Yater Mize
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Shri Doge Kamduk
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Legal Metrology
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
118: Smti Hage Kaku
Age: 42
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Shri H K Shala
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Legal metrology
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
119: Nangram Wangsa
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late C Wangsa
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Transport
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
120: Smti Oman Tatak
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Tallom Tatak
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Printing
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
121: Smti Jasinta Nabam
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Tana Nabam
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Printing
Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Page No.# 27/53
Arunachal Pradesh.
122: Smti Neelam Yabin
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Shri Joram Tayam
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of APEDA
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
123: Bengia Tara
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Bengia Lelly
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Women and Child Development
Yupia
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
124: Kesang Ngenda
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Sange Wangchu
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Women and Child Development
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
125: Ela Linggi
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Enga Linggi
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Women and Child Development
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
126: Smti Sangeeta Lowang
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late P C Bura Gohain
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of State Transport
Page No.# 28/53
Pappu Nallah
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
127: Smti Chrismai Tasar
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Tanya Tasar
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of State Transport
Papu Nallah
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
128: Hae Tanio
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Tage Phussang
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of State Transport
Papu Nallah
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
129: Lomkar Ete
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Mellom Ete
presently serving as Superintendent
Power Department
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
130: Atan Ering
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Kunu Ering
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
131: Gyati Koyang
Page No.# 29/53
Age: 56
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Gyati Lento
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
132: Hage Takha
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Hage Rambo
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
133: T L Tamin
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tatum Gadi
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
134: Smti Koj Rillung
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Koj Buda
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
135: Smti Gyati Pudu
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Tailyang Ekha Rambo
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 30/53
136: Tapak Nayam
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tagia Nayam
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
137: Hamnyok Tayeng
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:Son of Tulsam Tayeng
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
138: Dagge Riba
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of M Riba
presently serving as Superintendent
Department of Civil Supplies
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 3 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:through the Chief Secretary
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
2:The Chief Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Secretary (Finance)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 31/53
Itanagar.
4:The High Level Standing Committee (Pay Anomaly)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:through the Chief Secretary-cum- Chairman High Level Standing Committee
(Pay Anomaly) Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
-----------Advocate for : Dicky Panging
Sr. Adv
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and 3 Ors: Advocate ,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4, respectively.
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 30.07.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 19.08.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
Page No.# 32/53
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Ms. R. Takam,
learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. R. H. Nabam, learned
Additional Advocate General for the State respondents.
2.
Challenge made in this writ petition is to the Order dated 06.09.2024,
passed by the Chief Secretary-cum-Chairman, High Level Standing Committee
(Pay Anomaly), whereby the claim of the petitioners, who are serving as
Superintendents under various Directorates of the Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, for grant of pay and allowances at par with the Section Officers serving
in the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat has been rejected. The petitioners
seek a direction upon the respondent authorities to upgrade their scale of pay at
par with that of the Section Officer of the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat
with effect from 01.01.2006, along with all consequential benefits.
3.
The petitioners are presently serving as Superintendents in various
Directorates under the Government of Arunachal Pradesh. The petitioners have
entered the Arunachal Pradesh Ministerial Service at different grades and, in due
course, were promoted to the post of Superintendent. The petitioners claim that
the ministerial establishments in the various Directorates, District Administration
and the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat comprise substantially similar
hierarchical posts, namely, Lower Division Clerk, Upper Division Clerk, Assistant
and Superintendent. It is stated that, initially, the posts of Superintendent in the
Civil Secretariat as well as in other departments were governed by the common
Group-C Recruitment Rules, 1982 and carried the same scale of pay.
Page No.# 33/53
Subsequently, separate Recruitment Rules were framed for the Secretariat
ministerial service, being the Arunachal Pradesh Secretariat Sub-ordinate
Service Rules, 1989, and for the Superintendent cadre in other departments,
being the General Arunachal Pradesh Superintendent Group-B Non-Gazetted
(Ministerial) Common Recruitment Rules, 2011. However, despite such separate
Rules, the method of appointment to the post of Superintendent continued to
be substantially similar, namely, by promotion from the grade of Assistant after
completion of five years of regular service.
4.
Subsequently, by order dated 14.01.1998, issued by the Chief Secretary to
the Government of Arunachal Pradesh,the Superintendents, Assistants and
Upper Division Clerks serving in the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat were
granted the revised scales of pay pursuant to the recommendations of the
5thCentral Pay Commission with effect from 01.04.1998 and the post of
Superintendent in the Civil Secretariat was re-designated as Section Officer and
the
pay
and
allowances
were
revised
to
Rs.
6500-200-10500
per
month.However, the corresponding benefit was not extended to the ministerial
employees serving in other departments. Accordingly, the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh constituted a Cabinet Sub-Committee to look into the issue
and pursuant to the recommendation of a Cabinet Sub-Committee, the
Secretary
(Finance),
Government
of
Arunachal
Pradesh,
issued
Office
Memorandum dated 28.08.2002 extending the pay and allowances of the
ministerial employees of other departments, from UDC to Superintendent, at par
with
their
counterparts
in
the
Civil
Secretariat.
Consequently,
the
Superintendents in the Directorates and the Section Officers in the Civil
Secretariat continued to receive the same pay and allowances of 6500-105004600 Grade Pay following implementation of the 6th Central Pay Commission
Page No.# 34/53
with effect from 01.01.2006.
5.
However, by an order dated 31.03.2010, issued by the Commissioner
(General Administration), in pursuance of an Office memorandum dated
30.08.2008, issued by the Ministry of Finance, Government of India, the scale of
pay of Section Officers/SRA of the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat was
enhanced to higher pay scale of 8000-13500 PB 3-5400 Grade Pay on
completion of four years of service, whereas the Superintendents serving in the
various Directorates continued in the earlier scale of payof 6500-10500-4600
Grade Pay. The disparity further continued after implementation of the
7thCentral
Pay
Commission
with
effect
from
01.01.2016,
when
the
Superintendents serving in the other departments were granted a minimum
basic pay of Rs. 44,900 by placing at Level 7, whereas the Section Officers of
the Civil Secretariat were granted minimum basic pay of Rs. 47,600 by placing
at Level 8 and on completion of four years of regular service,the basic pay
increased to Rs. 53,100 at Level 9.
6.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid disparity, four Superintendents and five
Administrative Officers had approached this Court by filing a writ petition, being
WP(C) No. 146/2017, seeking parity in pay with the Section Officers and Under
Secretaries, respectively, of the Civil Secretariat. This Court, by judgment and
order dated 24.08.2022, directed the High Level Standing Committee on Pay
Anomalies, headed by the Chief Secretary, to examine whether the employees
working in departments/directorates other than the Secretariat Administration
Department were entitled to the same scale of pay or whether there existed
overwhelming, good and acceptable reasons for retaining the disparity. The
Committee was further directed to take note of the observation of this Court
Page No.# 35/53
that there did not otherwise appear to be any difference in the nature of work
performed by the employees of the other departments and those of the
Secretariat Administration Department, unless some tangible, acceptable and
reasonable difference was found to exist.
7.
Pursuant thereto, the High Level Standing Committee on Pay Anomaly held
a meeting on 04.07.2024 and thereafter, the impugned order dated 06.09.2024
was issued by the Chief Secretary-cum-Chairman, High Level Standing
Committee (Pay Anomaly), rejecting the claim of the petitioners. The Committee
mainly relied upon the alleged differences in the nature of work, transferability,
Recruitment Rules, mode of recruitment and promotional avenues of the
Directorate/District Ministerial Cadre vis-à-vis the Secretariat Service Cadre.
Hence, this writ petition has been filed by the petitioners challenging the said
order on the ground that the Committee failed to undertake the exercise
directed by this Court in its judgment dated 24.08.2022 and also failed to
consider the effect of the Office Memorandum dated 28.08.2002.
8.
Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners, submits that the
impugned order dated 06.09.2024 has been passed mechanically and without
properly examining the question which was required to be considered pursuant
to the judgment and order dated 24.08.2022. He submits that the Committee
was required to identify a tangible, acceptable and reasonable distinction in the
nature of duties and responsibilities of the Superintendents serving in the
Directorates vis-à-vis the Section Officers serving in the Civil Secretariat which
could justify the continuing disparity in their pay. Instead, the Committee has
merely referred to the fact that the two cadres’ function under different
establishments, Civil Secretariat staffs work at highest level of Government
establishment hierarchy, are governed by different Recruitment Rules, have
Page No.# 36/53
different modes of recruitment and promotional avenues and are subject to
different posting conditions. He submits that such distinctions, by themselves,
do not establish any rational basis for prescribing different scales of pay for
posts which had earlier enjoyed parity and involve considerably similar
ministerial functions.
9.
Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the Committee has failed to
consider the Office Memorandum dated 28.08.2002 issued by the Secretary
(Finance), Government of Arunachal Pradesh, whereby, pursuant to the
Government's decision, the ministerial employees of the other departments,
from UDCs to Superintendents, were specifically granted pay and allowances at
par with their counterparts in the Civil Secretariat.The said policy decision
continued to operate and the petitioners and the Section Officers of the Civil
Secretariat were, in fact, receiving the same pay and allowances even after
implementation of the 6thCentral Pay Commission with effect from 01.01.2006.
He submits that the subsequent enhancement granted to the Section Officers,
without extending the corresponding benefit to the Superintendents, has
resulted in an unjustified and discriminatory disparity.
10. Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the impugned decision
is also vitiated by non-consideration of the relevant materials and the specific
direction issued by this Court. He submits that the Committee has not
demonstrated any tangible difference in the actual nature of duties performed
by the two categories of employees and has proceeded merely on the basis that
they function in different establishments. Such a distinctioncannot by itself
constitute a valid basis for differential pay. He submits that the action of the
respondents in continuing the disparity, despite the earlier policy decision
Page No.# 37/53
embodied in the Office Memorandum dated 28.08.2002, is therefore arbitrary,
unreasonable and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
11.
In support of his submission, Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, has
relied on the following judgments:
(i)
Bharat Singh & Ors. Vs. State of Haryana & Ors., reported in
(1988) 4 SCC 534
(ii)
Commissioner of Police, Bombay Vs. Gordhandas Bhanji,
reported in 1951 SCC 1088
12. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has also relied on a judgment
of this Court dated 01.11.2016, passed in WP(C) No. 495(AP)/2015, Shri Taking
Talom & 2 Ors. Vs. The State of Arunachal Pradesh & 5 Ors., to contend that
this Court had directed enhancement of the grade pay of the Administrative
Officers (Judicial) of the Itanagar Bench of the Gauhati High Court at par with
the Superintendents/Section Officers of the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat.
He submits that the post of Administrative Officer (Judicial) in the Itanagar
Permanent Bench is analogous to the post of Superintendent in the Directorates
and pursuant to the said judgment, the grade pay of the Administrative Officers
(Judicial) was accordingly enhanced at par with the Section Officers of the Civil
Secretariat.
13. On the other hand, Mr. R. H. Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General,
for the State respondents, submits that the ministerial staff of the Arunachal
Pradesh Civil Secretariat and those serving in the Directorates/Districts
constitute separate cadres governed by distinct Recruitment Rules and
therefore, no comparison can legitimately be drawn between the two. The Civil
Secretariat is the highest office of the Government where policy decisions are
Page No.# 38/53
formulated and having regard to the nature and importance of the functions
discharged therein, the Secretariat Service has been provided with separate
Recruitment Rules, including mandatory level training. He submits that the
Assistant Section Officers, who constitute the feeder grade for Section Officers,
are recruited through different modes, including direct recruitment through the
Arunachal
Pradesh
Public
Service
Commission,
Limited
Departmental
Competitive Examination and promotion, whereas the ministerial staff of the
Directorates/Districts are recruited at the level of UDCs and LDCs and thereafter
promoted through the respective hierarchy of Assistant, Superintendent and
Administrative Officer.
14.
Learned Additional Advocate General further submits that the framing or
amendment of Recruitment Rules, re-designation of posts and upgrading of
posts are matters of policy within the prerogative of the Government, which
may take such decisions from time to time having regard to the exigencies of
administration and the requirement of efficient functioning of the Government.
He submits that the Government has consciously provided separate and fair
treatment to the staff and officers functioning at the highest level of the
Government establishment. The fact that the two cadres may have enjoyed
similar status or pay in the pastcannot constitute a basis for determining their
present status, particularly when the Recruitment Rules governing the
Secretariat cadre have subsequently been amended/framed.
15.
Learned Additional Advocate General submits that the subsequent
enhancement of the pay of the Section Officers/SRAs in the Civil Secretariat was
made in accordance with the Government of India Office Memorandum dated
30.08.2008, the corresponding notification and the Office Memorandum dated
05.01.2009 issued by the Government of Arunachal Pradesh, and that the State
Page No.# 39/53
Government follows the Central Secretariat and Central Pay Commission pattern
with such modifications as may be considered necessary. He submits that the
Section Officers are Group-B Gazetted Officers and the Under Secretaries are
Group-A Officers, and therefore their posts cannot be treated as analogous to
the posts of Superintendents and Administrative Officers in the Directorates.
16.
Learned Additional Advocate General submits that the distinction is not
merely formal but relates to the nature and level of functions discharged by the
two cadres. The staff and officers of the Secretariat assist in formulation of
Government policies and in taking various administrative decisions, whereas the
staff and officers of the Directorates and District Administration mainly
implement the policies and orders so formulated. He also submits that,
whenever any clarification or interpretation of Government policies, rules or
notifications is required, the same is undertaken at the Secretariat level.
Therefore, the two sets of employees, functioning at different levels of the
Government establishment and governed by different Recruitment Rules, cannot
be treated as identical or as counterparts of each other.
17. As regards the reliance placed by the petitioners on the judgment dated
01.11.2016 passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 495(AP)/2015, learned Additional
Advocate General submits that the said judgment itself made it clear that the
enhancement granted to the Administrative Officers (Judicial) of the Itanagar
Bench of the Gauhati High Court would not be construed as a precedent for
granting similar benefits to Administrative Officers serving under the State
Government. The said decision, therefore, cannot be relied upon as a basis for
claiming parity with the Secretariat employees, particularly when the
determination of pay scales and the structure of the Secretariat Service are
matters of policy.
Page No.# 40/53
18.
Mr. Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General, submits that the High
Level Standing Committee, pursuant to the direction issued by this Court, had
examined the relevant aspects, including the difference in the level and nature
of work, Recruitment Rules and designations, and had rightly concluded that the
Superintendents of the Directorates/District Administration and the Section
Officers of the Secretariat are not counterparts of each other. He, therefore,
submits that the impugned order does not suffer from any infirmity warranting
interference in exercise of the writ jurisdiction of this Court and the writ petition
deserves to be dismissed.
19.
In support of his submissions, Mr. R. H. Nabam, learned Additional
Advocate General, has placed reliance on the following judgments:
(i)
Assam Ayurvedic Doctors Service Association & Ors. Vs.
State of Assam & Ors., reported in 2023 (4) GL 593 (Gauhati
High Court)
(ii)
Delhi Medical Technical Employees Vs. Union of India & Ors.,
passed in WP(C) No. 12205/2019 (Delhi High Court)
(iii)
ITGOA & Ors. Vs. Union of India & Ors., passed in WP(C) No.
1144/2026 (Delhi High Court)
20.
While rejoining, Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners,
submits that the respondents' contention that the ministerial staff of the Civil
Secretariat and those serving in other departments constitute separate cadres
governed by distinct Recruitment Rules does not, by itself, justify the disparity in
pay. He submits that the relevant consideration is the actual nature of duties,
responsibilities and functional roles discharged by the employees, which, in the
present case, are considerably similar. He submits that merely describing the
Page No.# 41/53
Civil Secretariat as the “highest office” of the Government cannot constitute a
rational basis for denying parity in pay and service conditions to employees
performing comparable functions in other departments.
21. Learned Senior Counsel submits that the existence of different modes or
channels of recruitment cannot also defeat the claim for parity, particularly when
the grievance relates to the discriminatory treatment of employees after their
entry into service. The respondents have failed to place any cogent material to
demonstrate that the nature and responsibilities of the duties discharged by the
Secretariat staff are qualitatively different so as to justify the disparity in pay.
22.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that the petitioners, while serving as
ministerial staff in various departments, discharge multifaceted responsibilities,
including field-related coordination, implementation of Government schemes,
maintenance of records, public dealing and time-bound administrative functions.
He submits that that, in several instances, the duties performed by the
petitioners are more demanding and extensive than those performed by the
ministerial staff of the Secretariat, particularly having regard to the resource
constraints, field pressures and direct public interface involved in their work.
23.
Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the respondents'
statement that the enhancement of standards in the Secretariat justifies the
disparity is unsupported by any material demonstrating that the duties of the
Secretariat staff have undergone such qualitative transformation as would
warrant differential treatment of the petitioners. Therefore, he submits that the
respondents have failed to establish any rational or tangible basis for continuing
the disparity in the scales of pay between the petitioners and the Section
Officers of the Civil Secretariat.
Page No.# 42/53
24. Due consideration has been extended to the rival submissions advanced by
the learned counsel for the parties and perused the materials available on
record.
25.
Essentially, the issue which arises for consideration in the present writ
petition is whether the decision taken by the High Level Standing Committee on
Pay Anomaly, pursuant to the judgment and order dated 24.08.2022, passed by
this Court in WP(C) No. 146/2017, rejecting the claim of the petitioners, who are
serving as Superintendents under various Directorates of the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh, for parity in pay and allowances with the Section Officers
serving in the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat, for parity in pay with the
Section Officers of the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat, calls for interference
in exercise of the power of judicial review.
26.
The claim of the petitioners is that the ministerial establishments of the
Secretariat and the various Directorates have similar hierarchical posts and that,
initially and over the years, the posts of Superintendent in the Secretariat as
well as in the other departments were governed by the common Group-C
Recruitment Rules, 1982 and carried the same scale of pay. It is also not in
dispute that, pursuant to the Office Memorandum dated 28.08.2002, the
ministerial employees of the other departments from the grade of UDC to
Superintendent were granted pay and allowances at par with their counterparts
in the Civil Secretariat and such parity continued even after implementation of
the 6thCentral Pay Commission.
27. The aforesaid historical background, however, has to be considered along
with the subsequent evolution of the service structure of the two cadres.
Though the two categories initially formed part of a common service structure
Page No.# 43/53
under the Group-C Recruitment Rules, 1982, separate Recruitment Rules were
subsequently framed for the Secretariat ministerial service and for the
Superintendent cadre in the other departments. The Arunachal Pradesh
Secretariat Sub-ordinate Service Rules, 1989 govern the Secretariat ministerial
service, whereas the Superintendent cadre in the other departments is governed
by the General Arunachal Pradesh Superintendent Group-B Non-Gazetted
(Ministerial) Common Recruitment Rules, 2011. It is true that the method of
appointment to the post of Superintendent under the respective Rules continued
to be substantially similar, namely, by promotion from the grade of Assistant
upon completion of five years of regular service. However, the existence of a
common or similar promotional qualification at one stage of the service cannot,
by itself, establish that the two cadres are identical in all other material respects
or that they must necessarily carry the same scale of pay.
28. It is in the aforesaid background that the earlier judgment and order dated
24.08.2022, passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 146/2017 requires to be
considered. This Court, while disposing of the said writ petition, did not direct
grant of parity in pay to the petitioners therein. Instead, having noticed the
grievance relating to the disparity in pay, this Court directed the High Level
Standing Committee on Pay Anomalies, headed by the Chief Secretary, to
examine whether the employees working in departments/directorates other than
the Secretariat Administration Department were entitled to the same scale of
pay as the employees of the Secretariat Administration Department or whether
there existed overwhelming, good and acceptable reasons for retaining the
disparity. The Committee was further directed to take note of the observation
that there did not otherwise appear to be any difference in the nature of work
Page No.# 44/53
performed by the employees of the other departments and those of the
Secretariat Administration Department, unless the Committee was of the view
that some tangible, acceptable and reasonable difference did exist.
29.
The aforesaid direction, therefore, cannot be construed to mean a
determination by this Court that the Superintendents serving in the Directorates
and the Section Officers serving in the Civil Secretariat were identically situated
or were entitled, as a matter of right, to parity in pay. The exercise that was
directed to the High Level Standing Committee was to examine the claim and
ascertain whether there existed tangible, acceptable and reasonable differences
between the two cadres which would furnish a basis for parity or disparity in
their scales of pay. It is, therefore, necessary to examine whether the
Committee, pursuant to the aforesaid direction, considered the relevant aspects
and whether the conclusion arrived at by it suffers from such arbitrariness or
infirmity as would warrant interference by this Court.
30.
It is noticed that pursuant to the aforesaid direction, the High Level
Standing Committee on Pay Anomaly considered the matter in its meeting held
on 04.07.2024. The Committee appears to have considered, amongst others,
the difference in the nature of work of the ministerial staff of the
Directorate/District establishments and the Civil Secretariat; the fact that the
Directorate Ministerial Cadre and the Secretariat Service Cadre are governed by
different Recruitment Rules; the difference in the mode of recruitment; and the
difference in the promotional avenues available to the respective cadres. The
Committee also considered that the two cadres function in different institutional
establishments and have different posting and transfer arrangements. Upon
Page No.# 45/53
consideration of the aforesaid aspects, the Committee concluded that the
Directorate/District Ministerial Cadre and the Secretariat Service Cadre are not
similarly situated and that tangible, acceptable and reasonable differences do
exists.
31.
The main contention of the petitioners is that the aforesaid distinctions
considered by the Committee do not establish any tangible difference in the
actual nature of duties and responsibilities discharged by the two categories of
employees. According to the petitioners, the duties performed by the
Superintendents in the various Directorates are substantially similar and in some
respects, even more onerous than those performed by the Section Officers in
the Civil Secretariat. The petitioners have also placed reliance upon the Charter
of Duties of the ministerial staff of various departments in support of such
contention.
32. It is, however, significant to notice that the burden in the present case is
upon the petitioners to establish that the posts with which they seek parity are
comparable in all material respects so as to justify judicial intervention in the
matter of pay fixation. The mere fact that both categories discharge ministerial
or administrative functions, or that there may be some similarity or overlapping
in their day-to-day duties, cannot by itself establish equivalence of the two
posts. The question has to be examined having regard to the nature and level of
the functions, the service structure, Recruitment Rules, method of recruitment,
promotional avenues and other relevant conditions governing the respective
cadres.
Page No.# 46/53
33.
Upon anxious consideration ofthe present case, this Court finds that the
petitioners have not been able to demonstrate that the nature of work
performed by the Superintendents in the Directorates is the same as that
performed by the Section Officers in the Civil Secretariat. The materials placed
on record may establish that the petitioners discharge important and
complicated ministerial functions in their respective departments, including
coordination, implementation of Government schemes, maintenance of records
and public dealing. However, the discharge of such functions, by itself, does not
establish equivalence with the functions and responsibilities attached to the post
of Section Officer in the Secretariat. The petitioners have also not been able to
demolish the distinction considered by the Committee in the institutional role
and level at which the two cadres function.
34.
The distinction in the Recruitment Rules is also a relevant consideration.
As noticed above, although the two cadres had a common origin and the
promotional qualification for the post of Superintendent remained substantially
similar, the two services are presently governed by separate Recruitment Rules
and form part of distinct service structures. The Secretariat Service has its own
hierarchy
and
recruitment
mechanism,
whereas
the
Directorate/District
Ministerial Cadre has a different hierarchy and service progression. The
difference in the promotional avenues is also material. The Directorate
Ministerial Cadre proceeds through the hierarchy of LDC, UDC, Assistant,
Superintendent and Administrative Officer, whereas the Secretariat Service
Cadre has a distinct promotional structure leading from JSA, SSA and ASO to
Section Officer and thereafter to higher posts. The petitioners have not
demonstrated that these differences in the service structure are irrelevant to the
Page No.# 47/53
question of equation of the two posts.
35.
Likewise, the fact that the mode of appointment to the post of
Superintendent in the two cadres may, at a particular stage, be substantially
similar cannot obliterate the other differences in the respective service
structures. Equivalence of posts cannot be determined by isolating one factor
while ignoring the totality of the conditions governing the two cadres. The
petitioners have, therefore, failed to establish that the duties and responsibilities
or nature of work, Recruitment Rules, promotional avenues and other relevant
service conditions of the two cadres are substantially the same so as to entitled
them to grant of parity in pay.
36. The reliance placed by the petitioners upon the Office Memorandum dated
28.08.2002 also would not lead to a different conclusion. The said Office
Memorandum is undoubtedly relevant in appreciating the earlier position over
the years, as pursuant thereto the ministerial employees of the other
departments from UDC to Superintendent were granted pay and allowances at
par with their counterparts in the Civil Secretariat. It is also not disputed that
such parity continued for a period of time. However, the said Office
Memorandum cannot be construed as an irrevocable guarantee that the pay
structure of the two cadres could never thereafter be altered or that the
Government was permanently precluded from making a distinction between the
two services on the basis of subsequent changes in their service structure,
Recruitment Rules, functions and promotional avenues. Historical parity, by
itself, does not create an indefeasible right to parity for all times to come.
Page No.# 48/53
37. It is a settled proposition of law that equation of posts and determination
of pay scale/salary is a complex matter, which should ordinarily be left to the
expert body and the Court cannot interfere lightly. Grant of pay parity by the
Court may result in a cascading effect and have adverse consequences,
particularly if the limitations governing the applicability of the doctrine of equal
pay for equal work are not kept in view. The equation of posts and
determination of pay scale is primarily a function of the executive and not of the
judiciary. Therefore, ordinarily, the Court will not enter upon the task of job
evaluation. Reliance in this context may be placed on the decisions of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Secretary, Finance Department & Ors. Vs. West Bengal
Registration Service Association & Ors., reported in 1993 Supp(1) SCC
153, and Rajesh Pravinchandra Rajyaguru Vs. Gujarat Water Supply &
Sewerage Board & Ors., reported in (2021) 19 SCC 128.
38. The aforesaid principle assumes greater significance and is applied in the
facts and circumstances of the present case. The High Level Standing
Committee on Pay Anomaly, headed by the Chief Secretary, was specifically
entrusted with the examination of the grievance of the petitioners by the
direction of this Court. The Committee is seen to have considered the nature of
work, the Recruitment Rules, the mode of recruitment and the promotional
avenues of the two cadres and upon such consideration, appears to have fairly
concluded that the two cadres are not similarly situated. In the absence of any
material demonstrating that the said conclusion is arbitrary, based on wholly
irrelevant considerations, this Court would not be justified in undertaking an
independent exercise of job evaluation and substituting its own assessment for
that of the expert body.
Page No.# 49/53
39. The fact that the petitioners may discharge onerous duties or that some of
their duties may overlap with those performed by the Section Officers cannot, in
the absence of a complete and established equivalence of the two posts, be a
sufficient ground for directing parity in pay. The doctrine of equal pay for equal
work cannot be applied mechanically on the basis of isolated similarities in
duties. The totality of the relevant factors governing the two services has to be
considered, and in my view the petitioners have failed to establish such
equivalence in the present case.
40. The earlier judgment dated 24.08.2022 also does not assist the petitioners
to the extent contended. The observation therein that there did not otherwise
appear to be any difference in the nature of work was expressly subject to the
Committee examining whether any tangible, acceptable and reasonable
difference exist. The said observation cannot, therefore, be treated as a final
adjudication that the two cadres are identical in nature or function. The
Committee was expressly permitted to examine the matter and arrive at a
conclusion on the basis of the relevant service-related distinctions. The
Committee having undertaken such exercise and having recorded its conclusion,
the same cannot be interfered with merely because another view on the
comparative nature of the posts may also be possible.
41. The reliance placed by the learned Senior Counsel on the judgment dated
01.11.2016, passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 495(AP)/2015, is also of no
assistance to the petitioners. The said decision concerned the pay structure of
Administrative Officers (Judicial) of the Itanagar Bench of the Gauhati High
Page No.# 50/53
Court in the context of the service conditions applicable to that particular
category. The said decision cannot be treated as laying down a general principle
that the post of Superintendent in the Directorate is necessarily equivalent to
the post of Administrative Officer (Judicial), or that every category performing
ministerial or administrative functions is entitled to parity with the Secretariat
Service. The decision has to be understood and applied in its contextual facts
for which it was rendered.
42. The reliance placed by the learned Senior Counsel on the decision of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Gordhandas Bhanji(supra), also does not advance
the case of the petitioners. The said decision lays down the principle that a
public order made by a statutory authority has to be construed objectively with
reference to the language employed therein and cannot be supplemented by
subsequent explanations as to what the authority intended or had in mind.
There can be no quarrel with the aforesaid proposition. In the present case,
however, the reasons for rejection of the claim are discernible from the
impugned order itself. The High Level Standing Committee has expressly noticed
the distinctions in the nature of the establishments, Recruitment Rules, mode of
recruitment and promotional avenues and, upon consideration thereof,
concluded that tangible, acceptable and reasonable differences exist between
the two cadres. This Court is, therefore, not required to supplement the
impugned order by importing any new or additional reason from the affidavit-inopposition.
43. The decision in Bharat Singh(supra), relied upon by the learned Senior
Counsel, also does not assist the petitioners. The said decision emphasises that
Page No.# 51/53
where a contention depends upon facts, the factual foundation thereof must be
properly pleaded and supported by material on record. In the present case, in
my view,the factual distinctions relied upon by the respondents have been
specifically pleaded and are also reflected in the reasons recorded by the High
Level Standing Committee.
44.
As regards the authorities relied on by the learned Additional Advocate
General, this Court finds it unnecessary to discuss the same as the authorities
are settled proposition of law and have hardly advance the case of the
respondents. Thus, this Court refrained from discussion.
45.
This Court takes note that the petitioners have relied upon the parity in
pay over the years and have also sought to demonstrate similarity in the duties
performed by the two categories. However, the question before this Court is not
whether some similarity exists between the two posts, but whether the
petitioners have established such equivalence as would render the continuing
difference in pay arbitrarily or constitutionally impermissible. On the materials
placed, this Court finds that the petitioners have failed to establish that the
nature of work, Recruitment Rules, promotional avenues and other relevant
service conditions of the two cadres are the same or substantially equivalent.
Since the existence of relevant differences having been considered by the expert
body, the Court would not be justified in undertaking its own exercise of
equation of posts.
46. It is also not the function of this Court, while exercising judicial review, to
determine what ought to be the appropriate pay scale for the petitioners or to
Page No.# 52/53
direct the Government to adopt a particular pay structure merely because such
structure may appear to be more equitable. The determination of pay scales
involves consideration of several factors, including the nature and complexity of
duties, qualifications, recruitment, responsibilities, promotional avenues, service
conditions and the overall administrative structure. Such matters are ordinarily
within the domain of the executive and the expert bodies constituted for the
purpose.
47. On consideration of the materials available on record, this Court is of the
considered view that the High Level Standing Committee has undertaken the
exercise entrusted to it by the judgment and order dated 24.08.2022. The
Committee has considered the relevant service-related distinctions and has
recorded reasons for concluding that the Directorate/District Ministerial Cadre
and the Secretariat Service Cadre are not similarly situated. The petitioners have
failed to establish that the differences considered by the Committee in the
nature of work, Recruitment Rules, mode of recruitment and promotional
avenues are non-existent, irrelevant or incapable of furnishing a reasonable
basis for treating the two cadres differently.
48.
In view of what has been discussed hereinabove, this Court finds no
ground to hold that the impugned Order dated 06.09.2024, passed by the Chief
Secretary-cum-Chairman, High Level Standing Committee (Pay Anomaly), is
arbitrary or otherwise suffers from any infirmity warranting interference by this
Court. Consequently, the grievance of the petitioners for a direction to grant pay
and allowances at par with the Section Officers of the Arunachal Pradesh Civil
Secretariat with consequential benefits cannot be acceded to.
Page No.# 53/53
49. Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed. No order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review