Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
RSA. No. 33 of 2018
1.
Smt. Lila Rani Deb Choudhury, wife of Shri Dhirendra
Chandra Deb Choudhury, C/o Dhrubajyoti Deb
Choudhury, NayaPara, P.O. Dharmanagar, North Tripura,
Pin-799250.
2.
Shri Bimal Shome Bhowmik, son of late Binode Behari
Shome Bhowmik, P.O. & Village-Noagaon Krishnanagar,
via Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
…..Plaintiff-Appellants
-V E R S U S-
1.
Shri Shyamal Shome Bhowmik, son of late Sunil Chandra
Shome Bhowmik, P.O. & Village- Noagaon Krishnanagar,
via Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
….. Defendant-Respondent
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
:
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mrs. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. A. Sengupta, Advocate.
18.02.2022
21.02.2022
NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mrs. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the appellants. Also
heard Mr. A. Sengupta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This second appeal, under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 is filed challenging the judgment dated 06.06.2018,
delivered in Title Appeal No. 33 of 2012 by the learned Additional District
Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala, where-under, the learned
Additional District Judge dismissing the appeal, affirming the judgment
dated 26.06.2012 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr.) Division, Court
No.1, Agartala, West Tripura in Title Suit No.64 of 2009.
[3]
The second appeal is preferred against the concurrent findings
of two Courts below. At the time of admitting the appeal, the following
substantial questions of law were formulated by this Court:
“1. Whether the non-appreciation of documentary evidence (Exbt.4)
and (Exbt.C) in accordance with law while passing judgment
renders the same unsustainable and perverse in the eye of law?
2. Whether the respondent after selling their respective shares in
respect of a particular plot of land, can again claim their right, title
and interest over the same plot of land and execute sale deed in
favour of others?
[4]
The case of the appellants, in short, is that, the appellants are
owners and in possession of the suit land described in schedule-A of the
plaint along with some other lands by purchase by two sale deeds vide
No.1-2595 dated 21.02.1969 and 1-5356 dated 16.05.1966 but, the suit
land was not recorded in the name of the appellants as the suit land was
classified as pukur class of land under the joint ownership of different
persons. Accordingly, the appellants filed an application for mutation of
their name in respect of the suit land on 24.11.2006 before the Indranagar
Teheshil Office but, no action was taken by the office and therefore, on
inquiry, the appellants came to learn that the respondent filed an
application for mutation of his name and submitted one registered sale
deed vide No.1-1422 dated 06.02.2006 allegedly executed by one Md.
Ismail Munsi and one Mst. Nurnessa which is described in schedule-B of
the plaint.
[5]
Thereafter, the appellants being surprised applied for certified
copy of the said sale deed and received the certified copy of the said sale
deed on 21.07.2007. The appellants alleged that Md. Ismail Munsi and
Mst. Nurnessa did not put their signature in the alleged sale deed and the
said sale deed is manufactured one as the said Md. Ismail Munsi and Mst.
Nurnessa left India more than 45 years ago after alienating all their
movable and immovable property and started to reside in erstwhile
Pakistan now Bangladesh.
[6]
It is also the case of the appellants that Md. Ismail Munsi and
Mst. Nurnessa never gave their thumb impression on the said sale deed of
the respondents and the impugned sale deed and thumb impressions were
executed and obtained from any third person and allegedly identified as
thumb impression of Md. Ismail Munsi and Mst. Nurnessa by practicing
fraud. Therefore, the appellants prayed for cancellation of the said sale
deed by filing the Title Suit No.64 of 2009.
[7]
However, the respondent contested the claim of the
appellants. It has been stated by the respondents that originally the suit
land was recorded in the name of the vendors of the respondent namely
Md. Ismail Munsi and Mst. Nurnessa and the respondent purchased the
suit land from them by registered sale deed No.1-1422 dated 06.02.2006
and got delivery of possession of the same and accordingly, the suit land is
recorded in the name of the respondent and the respondent has been
possessing the suit land since the date of purchase. The learned trial Court,
based on the pleading of both the parties, framed the following issues
(i) Whether the suit is maintainable in law and form?
(ii) Whether the execution of sale deed bearing No.1-1422 executed on
06.02.2006 is void?
(iii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the prayer of cancellation of
sale deed bearing No.1-1422 executed on 06.02.2006 before the subRegistrar, Sadar, Agartala?
(iv) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the decree as prayed for?
(v) Whether the parties are entitled to any other relief or reliefs in this
suit?
[8]
The learned trial Court has decided the primary issues against
the appellants and observed thus:
“Moreover, from Ext.1 and 2 the sale deeds of the plaintiffs vide No.12595 dated 21.02.1969 and 1-5356 dated 16.05.1966 respectively, it
cannot be said that plaintiffs purchased the same land which was also
purchased by the defendant because both the sale deed of the plaintiffs
are old one and does not bear any specific dag numbers of the
purchased land of the defendant. If the plaintiffs purchased the said
land in the year 1966/1963 why the record of right is not created in the
name of the plaintiffs.
So far as regards the plea of the plaintiffs that out of purchased land a
portion was classified as pukur class of land under the joint ownership
of different persons so no separate khatian for the said land was created
by the Revenue Authority. I am of the view that if it is so then how the
name of the Md. Ismail Munsi and Nurnessa was recorded in Ext.A the
khatian No.2465 issued on 08.11.2005 separately and how subsequently
the name of the defendant is recorded in Ext.D the khatian No.6770
separately in respect of the purchased land of the defendant. Therefore,
it can be concluded that either the purchased land of the defendants is
separate from the purchased land of the plaintiffs for the plaintiffs did
not purchase the purchased land of the defendant. Also the Ext.A the
khatian No.2465, issued on 08.11.2005 and Ext. D the khatian No.6770
has presumptive value of correctness.
Therefore, considering all this aspect, I find the plaintiffs failed to
prove the fact that the sale deed vide No.1-1422 dated 06.02.2006 is
void.”
[9]
Being aggrieved and dis-satisfied with the judgment passed
by the learned trial Court, the appellants filed an appeal before the learned
Additional District Judge and the learned Addl. District Judge dismissing
the appeal filed by the appellants observed as under:
“In absence of such clarification, the plaintiff-appellant clearly failed to
prove that the disputed sale deed No.1-1422 executed on 06.02.2006 is
void in the eye of law.
On appreciation of evidence on record and after hearing learned
counsels appearing for both the sides, I find that the plaintiff-appellant
has failed to prove the points which are necessary for cancellation of the
registered instrument.
Consequently, the points for determination are determined against the
plaintiff-appellant.
The appeal filed by the appellant fails.
The decision of the court of learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn), Court No.1,
West Tripura, Agartala is hereby affirmed.”
[10]
Let us analyze the evidence on record and discuss both the
factual and the legal aspect of the case, before determining the points for
decision. In the present case the appellants have taken an ambiguous stand
regarding the description of the suit land. In paragraph 14 of the amended
plaint, the appellants stated that “the alleged description of the land
purchased in the impugned sale deed has been either erroneously or
clearly given in discipline manner but from the schedule from the said land
so far its north, south, east and western boundaries are concerned, the
land is specifically identifiable as the land owned and possessed by the
plaintiffs.”
[11]
But, the plaintiffs have not set out in the plaint the specific
description of the land purchased by the defendant by the disputed sale
deed, as such, it is not possible for the Court to ascertain as to whether land
purchased by the plaintiffs and the land purchased by the defendant are
same and is identical. The appellant has stated that Ismail Munsi and
Nurnessa went away to East Pakistan (Bangladesh) in the late 1960s and
they could not have come back to India in the year 2006 to execute sale
deed in favour of the respondent. However, the respondent has submitted
that the appellants could not submit any documentary proof to support
their allegation that Ismail Munsi and Nurnessa had migrated to East
Pakistan in the late 1960s.
[12]
It is true that the respondent has stated that Ismail Munsi and
Nurnessa are residing in Bangladesh but, that does not mean that these two
persons were not residing in India in the year 2006. It has been further
averred that the manner in which the appellants have described their land
clearly reflects that it is in all probability a separate land.
[13]
In the instant case, this Court minutely perused the record and
scanned the evidence and taking into account both the legal as well as
factual aspect of the case. In the written argument the respondent has
specifically stated that the plaintiffs in paragraph No.5 of the plaint that six
annas share in the tank, originally belonging to Narayan Chandra Nag was
filled up and balance portion thereof was left as pukur and not yet filled up
as described in schedule A of the plaint. The defendant stated in paragraph
2 of his examination-in-chief by affidavit that the aforesaid filled up
portion of the tank was in permissive possession of Narayan Chandra Nag
and the respondent purchased the said land from the original owner Mr.
Ismail Munsi and Mossmt. Nurenessa by a registered sale deed dated
06.02.2006.
[14]
Accordingly, name of Ismail Munsi and Nurenessa were
recorded in the Khatian of the said land No.2465 (Exbt.A) OF Mouja
Indranagar as raiyat thereof and after purchase the said land was recorded
in the name of the respondent on mutation in the khatian No.6770 of mouja
indranagar (Exbt.D) with an area of 0.10 acre corresponding to 5 gandas
10 dhurs according to local measurement and as such the suit land
described in the schedule of the plaint and the land purchased by the
respondent by the disputed sale deed in Exbt. C, are not the same land and
the appellants having no cause of apprehension of serious injury because
of existence of disputed sale deed.
[15]
The appellants have stated that the disputed sale deed is
forged, fraudulent and manufactured one and the Ismail Munsi and
Mossmt. Nurenessa left India with bag and baggage more than 45 years
back after selling all properties in India and they became the citizens of
Pakistan now Bangladesh and when the said persons left India at that time,
the appellant No.2 was a school student and the thumb impressions
appearing in the disputed sale deeds are not the thumb impressions of the
above named Muslim executants and the sale deeds are forged and
fraudulent.
[16]
The plaintiff No.2 deposed as PW-1 and he cannot say
whether the thumb impressions appearing in the disputed sale deed are that
of Insmail Munsi and Mossmt. Nurenessa. Other PWs also stated in their
deposition that from the plaintiffs, the appellants herein, they came to
know that aforesaid disputed sale deed is forged and fraudulent and they
have no personal knowledge as to the genuineness of the aforesaid sale
deed.
[17]
The appellant in his cross-examination has stated that “I have
not mentioned in schedule of my plaint the class of land. I have filed this
suit on 23.12.2009. It is not a fact that to save the period of limitation, I
have stated a false story of getting information of the purported sale deed
on 31.01.2007. I have not stated in my plaint what damage would be
suffered by me if the purported sale deed is not cancelled. I was not
present at the time of execution of purported sale deed bearing No.1-1422,
dated 06.02.2006. I also cannot say whether the thumb impression in the
said sale deed is the thumb impression of Ismail Munsi and Nurenessa or
not. I cannot say where the Ismail Munis and Nurenessa are residing at
present but they are residing at Bangladesh. It is not a fact that at present
Ismail Munsi and Nurenessa are residing in India. it is not a fact that my
statement in the plaint and examination in chief as to the fact that the
purported sale deed is a false one is imaginary. It is not a fact that said
purported sale deed is valid. It is not a fact that through a valid sale deed
the defendant owned and is in possession of the suit land. It is not a fact
that I have filed a false suit.”
[18]
It is clear that in his cross-examination he has given a strange
answer regarding the thumb impression in the sale deed under challenge in
the title suit. PW-1 clearly stated that he cannot say whether the thumb
impression in the said sale deed is the thumb impression of Ismail Munsi
and Nurenessa, or not. It appears that by making this ambiguous statement,
PW-1 has reflected the probability that the thumb impression in the sale
deed challenged by him, may indeed be the thumb impression of Ismail
Munsi and Nurenessa. In a case of such nature, the appellant has to prove
his case and he has only damaged his own case by making such ambiguous
and contradictory statement in his cross-examination.
[19]
The respondent has clearly submitted that the appellants had
the burden to prove that the thumb impression in the sale deed No.1-1422
dated 06.02.2006 are not genuine. However, the appellants side gave a
contradictory and ambiguous statement before the Court and thus
destroyed their own case.
[20]
This Court minutely perused the evidence on record. The
appellants’ side had the burden to prove that the thumb impression
appearing in the disputed sale deed is not genuine. However, the
deposition of PW-1 clearly reflects that he is not sure as to whether the
thumb impression is genuine or not. Consequently, it is clear that the
appellants side failed to establish that the thumb impression appearing in
the disputed sale deed are not genuine.
[21]
It is also clear that the appellants have raised an important
question about the alleged fact that both Ismail Munsi and Nurenessa had
migrated to East Pakistan (Bangladesh). However, the evidence on record
only suggests that on the date of deposition of the respondent before the
Court, Ismail Munsi and Nurenessa were residing in Bangladesh. The
present residence of Ismail Munis and Nurenessa is not the subject matter
of this case. The appellants were required to prove that Ismail Munsi and
Nurenessa were not residing in India on 06.02.2006, the date on which the
disputed sale deed was executed and registered in India.
[22]
It is pertinent to mention herein that the appellants have not
exhibited a single document or adduced any evidence to prove that Ismail
Munsi and Nurenessa were not in India on 06.02.2006 or had migrated to
East Pakistan or Bangladesh prior to 06.02.2006. The appellants have not
produced any handwriting or thumb impression of Ismail Munsi and
Nurenessa to compare the same with the thumb impression in the disputed
sale deed. The appellants could not clearly explain the extraordinary delay
in applying for mutation of the suit land. The appellants claimed to have
purchased the suit land in 1966 and 1969, but they failed to provide a
reasonable justification for waiting for four decades to apply for mutation
of the said land in question.
[23]
The disputed sale deed was registered on 06.02.2006 and the
appellants prayed for mutation of the same land in the month of
November, 2006. The appellants have claimed that they were unaware of
the registration of the sale deed on 06.02.2006, but they failed to place a
reasonable justification for their reluctance to apply for mutation of the
land under their alleged ownership and possession for almost forty years.
The appellants prayed for mutation on 24.11.2006, more than nine months
after the sale deed No.1-1422 was registered on 06.02.2006. This conduct
of the appellants raises serious doubt about their claim.
[24]
On further appreciation of evidence on record, it is also clear
that the appellants could not clearly specify the suit land and could not
specifically relate the suit land vis a vis the disputed sale deed. In order to
succeed in this appeal, the appellants were required to prove beyond
preponderance of probability that the land sold on 06.02.2006 was the
specific land purchased by the appellants in the year 1966 and 1969.
However, the evidence on record does not clearly pinpoint to the claim of
the appellants that both the lands are in fact same and identical one.
[25]
Consequently, the appellants failed to prove beyond
preponderance of probability that the sale deed No.1-1422 dated
06.02.2006 specifically covered the land in question already sold by the
sale deeds No.1-2595 and 1-5356.
[26]
According to this Court, appellant have not acted diligently
because he allowed the respondent to occupy the land and construct the
dwelling hut for staying with his family, so he could have filed a suit for
declaration right, title and interest. The appellants have not taken any steps
for conducting survey of this property. At this juncture he sought for
cancellation of the sale deed of the respondent. Questioning the
cancellation of the sale deed, does not mean he is declared as owner. In the
Revenue record, the names of the appellants were not reflected but, the
names of the respondent and his LRs were there. The Courts below arrived
at a concurrent finding that the appellants cannot get the relief of recovery
of possession.
[27]
It cannot be believed that having purchased the property in the
year 1966-69 and the defendant in 2006, more so, when both plaintiffs and
defendant are related and are cousins, ignorance of the sale deed 2006
cannot be appreciated in favour of the plaintiffs. More so, when
constructions are made by the defendant in the suit land which is part of
plaintiff suit land, inaction on the part of the plaintiff to seek appropriate
relief against the defendant during the above period, speaks volumes about
the conduct of the plaintiff. The balance of convenience is in favour of the
defendant but not the plaintiff.
[28]
I find no reason at all to interfere with the concurrent finding
of the two Courts below. At the threshold the suit is liable to be dismissed
and the same is dismissed on one of such grounds. This Court has no
hesitation to confirm the orders passed by the lower Courts below
dismissing the present appeal filed by the appellants on the same ground.
[29]
In view of the discussions made above, the appeal is found to
be devoid of any merit and hence, stands dismissed. Draw the decree
accordingly and send down the LCRs thereafter.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review