Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA 29 of 2019
Smti. Gita Shil
W/o, Late-Durlav Shil
1(b). Shri Madhav Shil
1(c). Shri Amarnath Shil
Both are sons of Late- Durlav Shil
All are residents of 34, Khosh Bagan,
Agartala, Post office- Agartala- 799001
Police Station- West Agartala
Dist- West Tripura
1(a).
---Plaintiff-appellants
Versus
1(a). Mrs. Anjali Nath (now deceased)
1(b) Sri Hirak Nath
S/o. Late Jnanendra Mohan Nath
The defendant No.1(a) is represented
by her attorney, the defendant No.1(b),
Shri Hirak Nath
2.
Shri Joydeep Nath
S/o. Lt. Sailendra Ch. Nath
Resident of Madhya Para,
RMS Chowmuhani
Police Station- West Agartala
Dist- West Tripura
---Defendant-respondents
For the Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. H. Laskar, Advocate
Mr. T. K. Chowdhury, Advocate
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate
Ms. Ankita Pal, Advocate
Mr. T. K. Deb, Advocate
Date of hearing & Delivery
of judgment and order:
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
24.06.2022
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(Arindam Lodh, J.)
Heard Mr. H. Laskar, learned counsel and Mr. T. K.
Chowdhury, learned counsel appearing for the appellants. Also heard
Mr. S.M Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. Ankita
Pal, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.1(b) and Mr. T.K.
Deb, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.2.
2.
Impugnment is the judgment and decree dated 30.03.2019,
passed by the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Court No.2, West
Tripura, Agartala in connection with Title Suit No.46 of 2011
dismissing the suit of the plaintiff/appellants.
3.
Shorn of unnecessary details, the facts, relevant to decide
the instant first appeal, may be narrated here-in-below:3.1.
The predecessor of the present plaintiff-appellants (here-in-
after referred to as the plaintiffs), namely Durlav Shil instituted the suit
for Specific Performance of Contract for sale of immovable property
valued at Rs.34,13,110/- (Rupees thirty four lakhs thirteen thousand one
hundred ten) only recorded in Khatian No.4924 of Sabek Dag No.13337
Hal dag No.1613 of land measuring 0.0253 ajutangsha under mouja-
Agartala, sheet No.15, Tehashil- Sadar East, Revenue Circle and SubDivision- Sadar under West Tripura District and Touji No.6842, more
particularly, described in the Schedule of the plaint (here-in-after
referred to as the “Suit Land”).
3.2.
Dipak Nath was the original defendant of the suit, who was
the owner of the above noted suit land. Both Durlav Shil and Dipak
Nath died during the pendency of the suit. Being his legal heirs, the
names of the present plaintiffs have been substituted as plaintiffs after
the death of said Durlav Shil and, similarly, Dipak Nath has been
substituted by the defendant nos. 1(a) and 1(b) as his legal heirs.During
the pendency of this appeal, defendant No.1(a) having died, the suit is
continued against 1(b), as the sole representative of late Dipak Nath.
4.
It is the case of the plaintiff that since the life time of his
deceased father, namely, Hari Pada Shil, Durlav Shil was a tenant of
Dipak Nath and he had been running his business under the name and
style “M/s Biswakarma Glass Supply Agency” in a portion of the suit
land and in the other portion of the suit land, the proprietors of “M/s
Ajanta Stores” and “Ashoka Restaurant” have been running their own
business in the suit land.
4.1.
In the month of first week of February, 2002 defendant
Dipak Nath expressed his willingness to dispose of the entire land i.e.
shop of the plaintiff and shops of the two other tenants by way of sale,
and made a proposal to the plaintiff to purchase the entire suit land
instead of making renewal of their existing tenancy agreement.
4.2.
Accordingly, the plaintiff accepted the said offer and on
22.02.2002 the original plaintiff, Durlav Shil and Dipak Nath, the
original defendant, entered into a contract for transfer of the suit land to
the plaintiff by way of sale at a consideration of Rs.1,00,00,000/(Rupees one crore) only.
4.3.
After getting mutation of the land in the name of the
plaintiff, it was agreed by the defendant, Dipak Nath that he would
transfer the said premises to the plaintiff within a period of 8(eight)
years from the date of such contract. In terms of the said agreement
dated 22.02.2002, the plaintiff paid Rs.6,00,000/-(Rupees six lakhs)
only to the defendant as an earnest money, and subsequently on
18.03.2002, the plaintiff paid Rs.50,000 (Rupees fifty thousand) only to
the defendant, and accordingly the plaintiff Durlav Shil was liable to
pay the remaining consideration money of Rs.93,50,000/- (Rupees
ninety three lakh fifty thousand) only to the defendant on or before
22.02.2010, and the defendant Dipak Nath was responsible to execute a
registered sale deed in favour of the plaintiff in respect of the suit land
on receipt of the remaining consideration money within the said period
of agreement.
4.4.
The original plaintiff, in his plaint further pleaded that he
made several attempts to contact with Dipak Nath in Kolkata with a
request to receive the balance consideration money and for execution of
a registered sale deed. But, one day the plaintiff had noticed that the
defendant Dipak Nath in violation of terms and conditions of the
agreement had published an advertisement in a local daily newspaper,
namely “Dainik Sambad” for sale of the suit land. The plaintiff then met
the defendant and wanted to know about the said advertisement, but,
defendant Dipak Nath could not provide any satisfactory reply, and
ultimately refused to execute any registered sale deed in favour of the
plaintiff relating to the suit land.
4.5.
Thereafter, plaintiff Durlav Shil served an advocate’s
notice upon the defendant on 25.12.2009, but defendant Dipak Nath
remained silent even after receipt of that notice giving rise to the cause
of action for the plaintiff to institute the present suit.
5.
Having received the notice of the suit, Dipak Nath being
the defendant appeared before the learned trial Court and contested the
suit by filing written statement.
5.1.
In the written statement, the defendant Dipak Nath denied
and disputed all the averments made by the plaintiff and raised the
question of maintainability of the suit on the point of limitation and
principles of estoppel, waiver and acquiescence and also on the ground
of non-joinder of necessary parties. The defendant also specifically
denied the execution of the agreement with the plaintiff on 22.02.2002
for transfer of the suit land to the plaintiff and regarding receipt of
consideration money from the plaintiff as per terms and conditions of
the alleged agreement for sale.
6.
During pendency of the suit, original plaintiff i.e. Durlav
Shil made a proposal for settlement of the subject matter of the suit out
of the court by transferring a part of the suit land in favour of the
plaintiff, measuring 0.0567 acres and the defendant would retain the
remaining land measuring 0.0253 acres. It was further decided that for
the time being and within one year thereafter, the defendant would
transfer the remaining land to the original plaintiff when the original
defendant would come to Agartala.
6.1.
According to plaintiff, he accepted the proposal and
consequent to this, the original defendant transferred a part of the suit
land measuring 0.056 acres to the original plaintiff by two registered
sale deeds dated 05.03.2012 and 04.05.2012 on receipt of the due
consideration money and delivered possession thereof.
6.2.
After registration of the sale deeds, the original plaintiff
filed an application for mutation of the purchased land before the
revenue authority and on receipt of notice from the Revenue
Department regarding mutation, the original defendant filed objection
against the mutation denying entering into the further agreement
between the parties as aforesaid giving rise to further cause of action for
amendment of the plaint for Specific Performance of Contract for the
remaining part of the suit land. Accordingly, application for amendment
was filed before the court which was allowed.
7.
Issues were framed and evidence of both the parties was
recorded. Ultimately, the suit was decreed in favour of the plaintiff vide
judgment dated 30.07.2012. The original defendant i.e. Dipak Nath
preferred appeal which was registered as RFA no.21 of 2012 before this
court and while disposing the appeal, this court vide order dated
15.05.2012 remanded the case to the trial court for de novo trial. In that
meanwhile, the original plaintiff i.e. Dipak Nath died and in his place
Smt. Anjali Nath and Sri Hirak Nath have been impleaded as
defendants, being the legal heirs of late Dipak Nath, and Shri Joydeep
Nath has been impleaded as defendant No.2 being the owner and
predecessor of the suit land under registered sale deed No.1-1290 dated
28.02.2013. After remand, the legal representatives of the deceased
defendant filed a written statement on 03.06.2017 stating inter alia in
paragraph 10 thereof that:
“It is also added herein that during the life time of the
original defendant, Dipak Nath, by executing a registered sale
deed dated 28.02.2013 registered on 01.03.2013 transferred
1078 Sq. ft. of Dokan ( Nal class of land) to one Sri Joydeep
Nath, S/o late Sailendra Ch. Nath where a restaurant in the
name and style “ New Ashoka Restaurant” has been in
existence for long.”
The aforesaid statement was confirmed by the original
plaintiff prompting him to challenge the said sale deed being No.1-1290
as illegal and void ab initio as it was transacted during the pendency of
the appeal and seek cancellation of the said sale deed besides other
reliefs.
8.
To deny the claim of the plaintiff, the defendants in their
written statement have stated that Dipak Nath, the original defendant
had never executed two numbers of registered sale deeds dated
05.03.2012 and 04.05.2012 for land measuring 0.0567 acres in favour
of the plaintiff, Durlav Shil, the predecessor-in-interest of the present
plaintiffs and it is asserted that land measuring 0.0248 ajutangsha i.e.
1017 Sq. feet of land with two storied building standing thereon was
transferred in favour of one Sri Asish Paul who is running a shop of the
stationary goods on the ground floor of the land in the name and style of
“Ajanta Stores” on 04.05.2012 vide sale deed No.1-3082 and another
portion of the property measuring 0.0319 ajutangsha of land within the
said two storied building to the original plaintiff i.e. Durlav Shil.
8.1.
It is further asserted by defendant nos. 1(a) and 1(b) that
such sale of the land to said Sri Asish Paul, who was a complete
stranger to the agreement dated 22.02.2012 was acknowledged and
accepted by the original plaintiff and there was no objection from any
corner.
8.2.
According to the defendants nos. 1(a) and 1(b), the
aforesaid sale transactions between late Dipak Nath and said Asish Paul
as well as late Durlav Shil, the original plaintiff, the alleged deed of
agreements became unenforceable having lost its original nature and
character for all purposes and in view of this, according to the
defendants the present suit for Specific Performance of Contract is bad
in law.
8.3.
It is the further case of the defendants 1(a) and 1(b) that the
original plaintiff was not at all inclined to purchase the balance quantum
of the suit land forcing the original defendant to sell the suit land to the
defendant No.2.
9.
The plaint being amended, the defendant No.2 appeared on
receipt of notice and contested the suit by filing written statement where
it is stated that he had no knowledge or information about the litigation
between the original plaintiff and the original defendant. He has further
stated that the original defendant had sold a part of the suit land to
Durlav Shil, the original plaintiff and Asish Paul, the owner of “Ajanta
Store” and they were found possessing their respective lands and
buildings by dint of transfer under the aforesaid registered sale deeds.
9.1.
It is further asserted by the defendant No.2 that he
purchased the suit land in presence of the original plaintiff (Durlav Shil)
and persons like Asish Paul, Jagabandhu Gope, Ranjit Paul and Bishnu
Ch. Rudra Paul. The original plaintiff had never raised any objection to
such purchase. Furthermore, according to defendant No.2, the original
plaintiff had never expressed his intention to purchase the suit land.
Even the original plaintiff did not inform the defendant No.2 that
litigation was going on between him and the original defendant, Dipak
Nath. The defendant No.2 has further stated in his written statement that
since the sale transaction made between him and late Dipak Nath, was
within the full knowledge of the original plaintiff, he never challenged
the said sale during his lifetime, and surprisingly the present plaintiffs
who are the legal heirs of the original plaintiff (Durlav Shil) challenged
such purchase of the suit land by way of filing an amendment petition
on 19.07.2017 i.e. after more than 4 years, which is barred by limitation.
10.
On the basis of the pleadings exchanged between the
parties to the lis, the learned trial court had framed the following
issues:“1. Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and
nature?
2. Whether plaintiff has cause of action for filing the instant
suit?
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for specific performance of
contract and complete transfer of the suit land through by way
of execution and registration of the sale deed over the suit land
free from all encumbrances by defendant on receipt of rest
amount of the consideration amount of money?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get executed and
registered sale deed over the suit land in the event of the
failure to make appropriate sale deed by defendant in terms of
the agreement for sale dated 22.02.2002 through the court?
5. Whether plaintiff is entitled to get decree as prayed for?
6. To what other relief/reliefs, the parties are entitled?”
11.
In order to substantiate the claims, the plaintiffs examined
four numbers of witnesses, namely Durlav Shil as PW-1, Sri Paresh
Chandra Paul as PW-2, Sri Chandan Kr. Shil as PW-3 and Sri Madhav
Shil alias Dhrubajoyti Shil as PW4. The following documents were
exhibited by the plaintiffs:1. Original agreement for sale dated 22.02.2002 and copy of
“Bharatiya Chuktipatra Dalil” dated 03.03.1998- marked as
Exbt. 1 series.
2. Copy of Khatian No.4924 of mouja-Agartala sheet No.15, copy
of advocate notice dated 25.12.2009, original receipt of DTDC,
photocopy of two demand drafts dated 18.03.2002, and
photocopy of deposit slips for UCO Bank-marked as Exbt. 2
series.
3. Two signatures of PW.1 on the original deed of agreement for
sale dated 22.02.2002- marked as Exbt. 3 series.
4. Signature of PW.2 (deed writer) on the agreement dated
22.02.2002- marked as Exbt. 4.
5. Signature of PW.3 on the agreement dated 22.02.2002marked as Exbt.5.
6. Registered sale deed bearing No.1290, consisting of 18 sheets,
on identification same was marked as Exbt.6.
The defendants side also examined three witnesses
namely, Sri Joydeep Nath (defendant no.2) as DW.1, Sri
Jagabandhu Gope as DW.2 and Sri Bishnu Ch. Rudra Paul as
DW.3.
The following documents were also exhibited by the defendant
No.1 in support of her claim in the suit:1. Original copy of sale deed bearing No.I -1290 dated 28.02.2013,
consisting of 15 sheets, on identification by witness was marked as
Exhibit-A.
2. Computer generated copy of Khatian No.1983 of Mouja-Agartala,
sheet No.15, Tahashil and Revenue Circle- Agartala East, SubDivision, Sadar, consisting of 1 sheet, on identification by witness
was marked as Exhibit-B.
12.
While deciding the issue nos. 1 and 2, the learned trial
court held the suit as maintainable having cause of action to institute the
instant suit.
12.1
The learned trial court has rightly taken up the issue nos. 3,
4 and 5 together for discussion and decision as the said issues are interrelated and overlapping to each other. Having discussed the said issues
the learned trial court came to a finding that the plaintiffs failed to
substantiate their claims and dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs holding
that “Evidence clearly manifest that it is the original plaintiff or the
plaintiffs who has deviated from the terms and conditions of agreement
for sale made in between late Durlav Shil (original plaintiff) and late
Dipak Nath (original defendant)”
13.
During the existence of the agreement dated 22.02.2002
(Exbt. 1 series) the original plaintiff (Sri Durlav Shil) purchased a
portion of the total land under the said agreement and permitted the
original defendant, Dipak Nath to sell another portion of the land under
the agreement to one Sri Asish Paul, the owner of Ajanta Stores. It is
further held that the plaintiffs have falsely stated in their plaint that they
purchased two plots of property by execution and registration of two
sale deeds which appears to be a misleading statement contrary to the
actual fact. Ultimately, the learned trial court held that the agreement
for sale dated 22.02.2002 (Exbt.1 series) has lost its validity and
enforceability.
14.
From the aforesaid facts, it comes to fore that the
agreement for sale dated 20.02.2002 is the genesis of the disputes
between the parties to the lis. After perusal of the said deed of
agreement, it is found that it is an unregistered instrument consisting of
two sheets admittedly made in between original plaintiff and original
defendant for sale of the suit land and other lands belonging to the
original defendant.
15.
On conjoint reading of the plaint and the deed of
agreement (Exbt.1series), it reveals that it is an agreement for sale of a
land measuring 0.0820 acres [3571 sq. feet (converted into sq. ft. for
convenience)], though recorded land is 4 gandas 1 kranta corresponding
to 3528 sq. fts.
16.
It is the case of the original plaintiff i.e. late Durlav Shil,
that the defendant transferred a portion of the land measuring 0.567
acres (2469 sq. ft. approx) to the plaintiff by two separate sale deeds
dated 05.03.2012 and 05.05.2012 out of total land measuring 0.0820
acres. That means, the land measuring 0.0253 acres was not sold to the
plaintiff by the original defendant Deepak Nath.
17.
Contrary thereto, it is the specific case of the defendant that
total land under his ownership/ possession was 5(five) gandas, though
the recorded area of land measures 4 gandas 1 kranta, i.e. 3528 sq. fts.
and it is clear from the recitals of the sale deed (Exbt.A) which was
executed by the predecessor of the defendant i.e. Dipak Nath in favour
of the defendant No.2 i.e. Joydeep Nath. The defendant has proved that
he sold land measuring 1380 sq. ft. to the original plaintiff, Durlav Shil
by registered sale deed bearing no. 1-3082 dated 04.05.2012 and by
another registered sale deed bearing no. 1-1511 dated 05.03.2012. He
transferred the land measuring 1070 sq. ft. in favour of one Shri Asish
Paul and further transferred a land measuring 1078 sq. ft. to the
defendant no. 2 i.e. Shri Joydeep Nath by registered sale deed bearing
no. 1-1290 dated 28.02.2013 which was registered on 01.03.2013.
18.
Curious enough is that the plaintiff has not produced the
sale deed under which he purchased the land measuring 0.0567 acres to
substantiate the said fact he has pleaded in his plaint, but, it has been
established from the registered sale deed issued in favour of the
defendant no. 2 that the defendant has sold only 1380 sq. ft to Durlav
Shil out of recorded land measuring 4 gandas 1kranta. In spite of
specific assertion of the defendants in their written statements
disclosing the aforesaid facts of sale to Shri Asish Paul for a land
measuring 1070 sq. ft, the defendant has not impleaded said Sri Asish
Paul in the plaint despite the fact that he has brought amendment of his
plaint subsequently. This has created serious mystery and doubt in the
mind of this court about the honesty and integrity of the plaintiff in
bringing the instant suit for recovery of possession of the land
measuring 0.0253 acres (suit land)
19.
Most interestingly, PW4, who is also the plaintiff no.1(b)
in the suit categorically admitted in his cross-examination that late
Dipak Nath (original defendant) had transferred a partition of the land
in favour of one Asish Paul by registered sale deed dated 05.03.2012
with the consent of his father i.e. the original plaintiff, namely, late
Durlav Shil. This statement made in the cross-examination aptly proves
that the contents of the pleadings made by the plaintiffs in the amended
plaint, appearing in sub-para of para no. 5 is false. It further reveals
from the cross-examination that the plaintiffs have not purchased the
portion of land measuring 0.0567 acres out of the alleged total agreed
sale of the land of original defendant as per the deed of agreement for
sale (Exbt.1 series).
20.
Furthermore, it is proved from the evidence of PW4 that
the said portion of land measuring 1070 sq. fts. acres was sold to Asish
Paul by original defendant, namely, late Dipak Nath with the consent of
the original plaintiff i.e. late Durlav Shil. That apart, most interesting
feature is that the plaintiffs have never challenged the sale of the land to
said Asish Paul, though, the said sale was transacted during the
existence of the deed of agreement for sale (Exbt.1 series) and in this
situation, the agreement, Exbt.1 series has lost all its force and makes
the instrument Exbt.1 series (agreement for sale) inoperative and
unenforceable.
21.
The plaintiffs have also made false averments in their
plaint when they have specifically pleaded that they purchased two plots
of land, but during their cross-examination the plaintiffs admitted that
they have not purchased another plot of the total property belonging to
the original defendant i.e. Dipak Nath, but, another portion of the entire
property of Dipak Nath was purchased by one Asish Paul who used to
carry his business in the name and style of “Ajanta Stores” and the sale
transaction was made with the consent of Durlav Shil, the original
plaintiff and father of the PW-4. Such conduct of the plaintiffs clearly
supports the evidence of the defendants.
22.
There is yet another aspect necessary to be considered in
the present case. The plaintiff has asserted that when he purchased the
land measuring 0.0567 acres out of the total land measuring 0.0820
ajutangsha i.e. 4 gandas 1 Kranta, both he and the original defendant i.e.
Deepak Nath orally settled the term that remaining portion of the land
would be transferred in favour of the plaintiff, Durlav Shil within a
period of 1(one) year. In this situation, in our considered view, heavy
burden lies upon the plaintiff to prove that there was consensus and ad
idem between the plaintiffs i.e. Durlav Shil and Dipak Nath, the original
defendant. To come to a finding that the said oral agreement was
concluded agreement for sale of the suit land the question being a
question of fact it has to be established by the plaintiffs as regards the
vital fundamental terms of the said oral agreement, which, in the facts
and circumstances of the case in hand, the plaintiff has miserably failed.
Here, I may profitably refer the case of K. Nanjappa Vs. R. A. Hameed
(2016) 1 SCC 762, where the Hon’ble Supreme Court had observed
thus :[ SCC P. 775 Paras 21 and 22].
“21. There is no dispute that even a decree for specific
performance can be granted on the basis of oral contract. Lord
Du Parcq in a case (AIR 1946 Privy Council 97l) observed, while
deciding a suit for specific performance, that an oral contract is
valid, binding and enforceable. A decree for specific performance
could be passed on the basis of oral agreement. This view of a
Privy Council was followed by this Court in the case of Koillipara
Sriramulu vs. T. Aswatha Narayana, AIR 1968 SC 1028, and held
that an oral agreement with a reference to a future formal
contract will not prevent a binding bargain between the parties.
22. However, in a case where the plaintiff come forward to seek a
decree for specific performance of contract of sale of immoveable
property on the basis of an oral agreement or a written contract,
heavy burden lies on the plaintiff to prove that there was
consensus ad idem between the parties for the concluded
agreement for sale of immoveable property. Whether there was
such a concluded contract or not would be a question of fact to be
determined in the facts and circumstances of each individual case.
It has to be established by the plaintiffs that vital and fundamental
terms for sale of immoveable property were concluded between
the parties.”
23.
On consideration of the evidence on record, it is found that
the plaintiff has failed to establish that he purchased the land measuring
0.0567 acres from the original defendant, Dipak Nath. Moreso, it is
established that the plaintiff had purchased only a land measuring 13080
sq. fts. out of 0.0820 ajutangsha i.e. 4 gandas 1 Kranta (3528 sq. fts.)
which is the total land under the deed of agreement for sale (Exbt. 1
series).
24.
According to us, exercise of jurisdiction under Section 20
of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 being discretionary, the plaintiff must
come forward and place his case with clean hands and in transparent
manner. For re-iteration, the plaintiff suppressed the sale deed under
which he purchased the land measuring 0.0567 acres of land. He has
bent upon unfounded oral agreement and that too is shrouded with
clouds. It is settled law that a vague, specious and unclear agreement is
not liable to be specifically enforceable for specific performance.
Furthermore, obligation casts upon the plaintiff to set in clear terms the
consequence and hardship he would suffer for non performance of the
contracts/ agreement, which, in the present case, are absent. It is settled
proposition of law that the jurisdiction to decree specific performance is
discretion of the court and it depends upon the facts and circumstances
of each case. The court would take into consideration circumstances of
each case, conduct of the parties, recitals in the sale deed and the
circumstances outside the contract have to be seen.
25.
In the Sardar Singh Vs. Smt. Krishna Devi & Anr., (1994)
4 SCC 18, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that the court has to see
the totality of the circumstances, conduct of the parties and respective
interest under the contract while granting/ revising such relief.
26.
In the case of K. Nanjappa (Supra), Hon’ble Supreme
Court has categorically held that in a suit of specific performance of a
contract the court has to keep in mind Section 20 of the Specific Relief
Act, 1963. This section preserves judicial discretion to grant decree for
specific performance. However, the court is not bound to grant specific
performance merely because it is lawful to do so. The court should
meticulously consider all facts and circumstances of the case and to see
that it is not used as an instrument of oppression to have unfair
advantage not only to the plaintiff but also to the defendant.
27.
In the instant suit, the plaintiffs have challenged the
subsequent sale transaction in favour of the defendant no.2 by the
original defendant i.e. Dipak Nath ,but, not challenged the former sale
transaction to Asish Paul, which also comprises the land under the deed
of agreement for sale i.e. Exbt.1 series. So, as we said earlier,
automatically the deed of agreement for sale cannot be executed in any
manner whatsoever and we reiterate that the said instrument i.e. Exbt.1
series becomes inoperative.
28.
In the above conspectus, in our considered view the present
case is not a case where the court will exercise its discretion in favour of
the plaintiff as provided under Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act,
1963, since its performance suffers from impossibility and would be
inconsistent to the doctrine of equity.
As a logical corollary, we find no infirmity in the findings
of the learned trial judge dismissing the suit of the plaintiffs.
Accordingly, the appeal stands dismissed.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
Rohit
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review