Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:570
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 287 of 2014
Smti. Faluda Biswas
Vs.
W/o Samiul Islam Mondal
R/o Village:Rajpur,
PO: Bhaitbari.
Dist: West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
Date of Order: 25.06.2024
1.State of Meghalaya, represented
by the Commissioner and
Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya
Education Department, Shillong.
2. The Director of Elementary
Education, Meghalaya, Shillong.
::::PETITIONER
3. The Deputy Commissioner cum
Chairman, SSA, West Garo Hills
District, Tura.
4. The District Mission co-Ordinator,
SSA, West Garo Hills, Tura.
5. The Superintendent of Police,
West Garo Hills, Tura.
6.The Deputy Inspector of Schools,
Dadenggiri, Dist.: West Garo Hills.
7. The Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil)
Cum Chairman SSA, Dadenggiri
Sub – Division, Dadenggiri.
Dist.: West Garo Hills.
8. The Officer-in Charge, Phulbari,
Police Station, Phulbari,
Dist.: West Garo Hills.
2024:MLHC:570
9. Boleman Hoque, Es President of
Rajpur Girls UP School, Rajpur
R/O Village-Rajpur, PO: Bhaithari
Dist West Garo Hills.
10. Saidul Hussain
Ex- Member Rajpur Girls' UP School
S/O late Moktal Hussain
R/O Village-Rajpur
PO: Bhaitbari
Dist. West Garo Hills
11. Moinul Hoque
Ex-Member, Rajpur Girls' UP School
S/O Late Moktal Hussain
R/O Village – Rajpur
PO: Bhaitbari
Dist. West Garo Hills
12. Nur Hussain, Ex- Member, Rajpur
Girls' UP School
C/O Late Moktal Hussain
R/O Village Rajpur
PO: Bhaitbari
Dist. West Garo Hills
13. Hafizur Rahman
C/O Late Moktal Hussain
Ex-Member, Rajpur Girls' UP School
R/O Village-Rajpur
PO: Bhaitbari Dist. West Garo Hills
14. Rajpur Girls' Upper Primary School
Represented by its Head Master
Miss Tanuja Begum
D/O Late Moktal Hussain
R/O Vill. Rajpur PO: Bhaitbari
Dist. Meghalaya, Assam.
::::RESPONDENTS
2024:MLHC:570
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. B. Kharwanlang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl. Sr. GA. (R: 1 – 8)
Mr. S. Dey, Adv. (R: 9)
Mr. B. Khyriem, Adv. (R: 10-14)
(JUDGMENT & ORDER)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner for issuance of
necessary directions to the respondents for recovery of salaries of the teaching
and non-teaching staffs of the petitioner’s school for the period of March 2002
to February, 2003 from the then Managing Committee of the school and also
for release of current salaries, arrear salaries and other Government benefits in
favour of the petitioner’s school, namely, Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School
and for stopping the benefits given to false school in the same name.
1.
The case pleaded by the petitioner in her writ petition is that the Rajpur
Girls’ Upper Primary School was established in the month of January, 1999
and the petitioner was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in the said school
where she joined her duties on 20-01-1999. After some days the petitioner was
appointed as the Headmistress of the school by the Managing Committee and
since then she has been discharging her duties continuously in that position.
Subsequently, the school was brought under the SSA (Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan)
2024:MLHC:570
Scheme in the month of February, 2002 and the respondent No.6, Dadenggiri,
West Garo Hills vide order dated 07-05-2023 constituted a new Managing
Committee of the School for a period of three years w.e.f. 01-01-2003 to 3112-2005. By the said order, the Secretary of the Managing Committee was
authorized to operate the bank account in respect of deposits and withdrawal of
money relating to the school.
After the constitution of the Managing
Committee of the school, the District Mission Co-Ordinator, SSA, West
Garo Hills District released an amount of Rs. 78,000/- as salaries of the
teachers for the months of March, 2002 to February, 2003. The said amount
was withdrawn by the then Secretary of the Managing Committee of the
school, but was not paid to the petitioner and others which resulted in filing of
an FIR before the Officer-in-Charge Phulbari police station on 26-03-2003 by
the petitioner and others. A complaint was also filed by the petitioner and
others to the respondent No.6 with a request to make an enquiry in the matter
and take necessary action. Thereafter, a spot enquiry was made by the
respondent No.6 wherein it was held that the payment of salaries was made to
persons who were not actual teachers of the school and the Secretary of the
school was directed to release the salary of the petitioner and other staffs of the
school. On 20-04-2024 a General Meeting was held in the resident of the
Headman of the village which was presided over by the president of the Rajpur
Girls’ Upper Primary School, whereby, vide resolution No.1, it was
unanimously decided to shift the school from its existing location to a new
location in order to avoid clash in the school affairs. The said resolution was
duly approved by the respondent No.6 on 23-04-2004 and soon thereafter, the
school was shifted to a new place and since then the school has been running
continuously with the petitioner discharging her duties as Headmistress.
2024:MLHC:570
2.
It is also pleaded in the writ petition that when the petitioner did not get
any fruitful result even after several approaches to the official respondents, she
along with three other teachers filed WP(C) No.5320/2004 before the High
Court which was disposed by order dated 18-03-2005 whereby respondent
No.4 was directed to make an enquiry and take necessary steps to remedy the
grievances of the petitioner. Although, the said order was submitted to the
respondent No.4 but no action was taken. Having no alternative, the petitioner
with three other teachers of the school again approached the High Court with
WP(C) No. (SH) 347 of 2005 with a prayer to direct the then Secretary of the
school to release arrear of salaries of the petitioners and other staffs of the
school from March, 2002 to February, 2003.
The said writ petition was
disposed of by Judgement and Order dated 24-09-2013 by directing the
respondent No.3 herein to conduct an enquiry to find out who had
misappropriated the sum of Rs. 78,000/-.
It was also directed that the
respondent No.3 shall file complaint/criminal case against those culprits with
the O/C, West Garo Hills District within a period of 3 months from the date of
the receipt of the certified copy of the order. The O/C concerned was further
directed to register an FIR on the receipt of the complaint and arrest the culprit
without any delay. The compliance report was also directed to be submitted by
the respondent No.3 herein to the Registry of this Court. Consequently, the
Phulbari PS Case No. 7 (1)/2014 u/S 409/34 IPC was registered. In the FIR of
the said case, it was reflected that though the then Secretary of the Managing
Committee of the school had expired, the other members of the Managing
Committee and the president of SMC were also liable, but the Officer-inCharge, Phulbari Police Station had not arrested any member of the then
Managing Committee of the school.
2024:MLHC:570
3.
The writ petitioner also averred that though the Rajpur Girls’ Upper
Primary School was shifted pursuant to the resolution adopted in the General
Meeting dated 20-04-2014, but the Secretary (Late) Muktal Hussain of the then
Managing Committee of the School with the help of official respondent
established another school in the name of Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School
and appointed new teachers including his daughter, Ms. Tanuja Begum, and
has been receiving the benefits sanctioned by the Government thereby
depriving the petitioner and other genuine teachers of the school. In this
respect, the petitioner and other staffs had submitted several representations
before the respondent No.3 and respondent No.4 praying for release of salaries
including arrears and other Government benefits to the genuine teachers of the
Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School and stop the benefit given to the fake
teachers and the school. The writ petitioner contended that the petitioner’s
school is the genuine/original school but the respondent authorities have not
taken any step against the false school. The action of the respondent authority
is absolutely illegal, arbitrary, whimsical and with mala-fide intention for
extraneous consideration and in violation of principle of natural justice and
administrative fairness.
4.
Against the writ petition, the State-respondents No.1 – 5 filed their
affidavit-in-opposition and denied the claim of the writ petitioner and stated
that in compliance of the Judgement and Order dated 24-09-2013 passed in
WP(C) No.347/2005, an enquiry was conducted by calling all the parties
concerned to ascertain the truthfulness of the allegation of non-payment of
salary and alleged misappropriation of fund. An order dated 17-12-2013 was
also issued directing the Officer-in-Charge of Phulbari Police Station to
register a case and investigate the matter whereupon the Phulbari P.S. Case
2024:MLHC:570
No.7 (1)/14 u/S 409 IPC was registered. During the course of the investigation
of the matter it was found that salary amounting to Rs.50,000/- had been
disbursed to the teachers appointed by the Managing Committee of Rajpur
Girls’ Upper Primary School and had been duly approved by the Joint District
Coordinator, Dadenggiri, West Garo Hills District. The statements of the
teachers were also recorded wherein they confirmed the receipt of salary
except for one teacher who had left the school after her marriage and settled
abroad.
The remaining salary of Rs.28,000/- had been withdrawn by the
Administrator of the school who was also the then Deputy Inspector of the
schools, Dadenggiri Sub-Division, and was paid to all the teachers. The writ
petitioner was the only teacher who did not receive her salary amounting to Rs.
9,400/- as she demanded that she be appointed as Headmistress of the Rajpur
Girls’ Upper Primary School. The State-respondent also asserted that the
school of the petitioner has no approval from any authority and the Rajpur
Girls’ Upper Primary School, recorded and reflected as per the records
maintained by the District Information System for Education, is the school
headed by Smt. Sobeda Khatun as Headmistress. The school claimed by the
petitioner is seemingly a fictitious school whose existence is unknow to the
authority.
5.
In addition to the affidavit-in-opposition, the additional affidavits dated
10-06-2019, 27-02-2020 and 29-08-2022 were filed on behalf of the Staterespondents. By the additional affidavits dated 10-06-2019, a copy of the spot
enquiry reported dated 08-03-2019 is brought into the record and it is asserted
that the school operated by Smt. Sobeda Khatun as Headmistress of Rajpur
Girls’ Upper Primary School is the school which is approved by the Project
Approval Board, Government of India and the same is receiving all the funds
2024:MLHC:570
from the Government. By the additional affidavit dated 27-02-2020, it is
asserted that the writ petitioner was appointed by the Managing Committee of
the school vide resolution No. 1 dated 20-01-1991 and was approved by the
Joint District Mission Coordinator by putting signature and seal on the body of
the resolution itself without any formal order. Similarly, the service of the
petitioner was terminated vide resolution No.2 dated 15-07-2004 which was
approved by the Joint District Mission Coordinator by putting signature and
seal on the body of the resolution without issuing any formal order and
thereafter the termination order was issued by the school Managing Committee
on the basis of the approval.
The additional affidavit dated 29-08-2022
brought into record the detailed enquiry report which was made in compliance
of the order dated 21-07-2022. Besides an affidavit dated 01-12-2020 was also
filed on behalf of the State as an affidavit-in-reply to the affidavit filed by the
writ petitioner.
6.
The writ petitioner also responded to the additional affidavit filed on
behalf of the State by filing various affidavit-in-reply dated 23-08-2019, 04-112020 and 14-12-2022 whereby she refuted the contentions made on behalf of
the State in the above-mentioned additional affidavit and asserted that she is
the Headmistress of Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School.
7.
The private respondents No.9 – 14 have filed a joint affidavit-in-
opposition whereby they denied the claim made by the writ petitioner in her
writ petition. In the said affidavit-in-opposition it is stated that the petitioner
was removed from the post of Assistant Teacher of the school after which she
established another rival school under the same name in the year 2004 and the
said school is running without any student. The private respondents denied
that the petitioner was appointed as the Headmistress of the school and stated
2024:MLHC:570
that Smt. Sobeda Khatun is the Headmistress of the Rajpur Girls’ Upper
Primary School. It is also stated that the real and genuine school is running in
the building constructed under the grant-in-aid by the authorities of the District
Coordinator, SSA. In addition to the above joint affidavit-in-opposition, the
respondent No.9 has filed a separate individual affidavit-in-opposition in the
matter whereby he supported the claim of the petitioner that the Rajpur Girls’
Upper Primary School was shifted from its original location. He stated that
(Late) Moktal Hussain due to his political influence appointed one Sobeda
Khatun as Headmistress and other teachers and made payments. He also stated
that he had not authorized the respondent No.11 to file any affidavit on his
behalf and the purported signature appearing on the authorization letter was not
put by him.
The respondent No.9 filed another additional affidavit in
compliance with the order dated 12-02-2021 of this Court wherein he reiterated
the statement made by him in his individual affidavit-in-opposition.
The
respondents No. 10 - 14 have also filed a response to the affidavit filed by the
respondent No.9.
8.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
that the petitioner was appointed as Assistant Teacher in the Rajpur Girls’
Upper Primary School just after its establishment in the year 1999 and after
sometimes she was appointed as the Headmistress of the school by the
Managing Committee of the school. He submits that the petitioner was a part
of the Managing Committee which was constituted for a period of 3 (three)
years w.e.f. 01-01-2003 to 31-12-2005. He submits that inspite of the fact that
the petitioner is discharging her duties in the school continuously, she has not
been paid salary without any valid cause or justification. The school in which
the petitioner is serving is the original/real Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School
2024:MLHC:570
which was shifted to a new location consequent to the adoption of a valid
resolution and approval by the state authority. He submits that the then
Secretary of the Managing Committee of the school had withdrawn a sum of
Rs 78,000/- sanctioned for payment of salaries of the teachers and staffs for the
months of March, 2003 to February,2003 but did not pay the salaries and
misappropriated the entire amount. The petitioner along with others had to
approach the High Court by filing WP(C) No. (SH) 347 of 2005 wherein vide
order dated 24-09-2013 the respondent No.3 herein was directed to conduct an
enquiry to find out who had misappropriated the amount of Rs.78,000/-. The
OC concerned was further directed to registered an FIR and arrest the culprit
without any delay. The learned Senior Counsel submits that inspite of the
directions of the High Court, no action has been taken by the respondent. He
submits that though the then Secretary of the Managing Committee of the
school is not alive, it is the collective duty of the entire Managing Committee
to ensure that the salaries are released. The State-respondents are also not
paying current salary to the petitioner inspite of the fact that the petitioner was
found to be a genuine teacher by report of enquiry dated 06-05-2004
(Annexure-4 to the writ petition) and no action has been taken against the fake
school which is running under the name of Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary
School. He prays that necessary direction be issued directing the respondent
authorities to recover the salaries of petitioner for the period of March, 2002 to
February, 2003 from the then Managing Committee and also for release of
current salaries and arrears including all other benefits.
9.
Mr. S. Sengupta, learned Addl. Sr. GA. appearing for the State
respondents No. 1 – 8 on the other hand submits that the petitioner is not a
teacher of the Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School and her service was
2024:MLHC:570
terminated vide letter dated 16-07-2004 issued by the Managing Committee of
the school on the basis of the resolution dated 15-07-2004 which was approved
by the then Joint District Mission Coordinator, Dadenggre, West Garo Hills.
He refers to the additional affidavit dated 10-06-2019 wherein the said
termination letter and the resolution are appended.
He submits that the
petitioner has not challenged her termination and, hence, cannot raise any
grievance in this matter. He submits that the order dated 24-09-2013 passed in
WP(C) No. (SH) 347 of 2005 was fully complied with by holding an enquiry
and by registration of police case as required. He submits that the investigation
of the Phulbari P.S. Case No. 7(1)/14 u/S 409/34 IPC, which was launched as
per the order dated 24-09-2013, revealed that the entire amount of Rs.78,000/was paid to the persons concerned except for an amount of Rs.9,400/- which
the petitioner refused to accept as she demanded to be appointed as the
Headmistress of the Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School. He submits that the
school where the petitioner claims to be serving is not a recognized school.
The genuine Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School is functioning from the
location where the school building was constructed by utilizing the amount of
sanction made by the Government. He further submits that there is no question
of diverting the sanctioned amount of grant-in-aid to a fake school as the
amount is transferred to the bank account of the school which has been in
operation since after the inclusion of the school under the SSA scheme. He
submits that the petitioner’s claim is not made on any legal basis and the writ
petition is liable to the dismissed.
10.
Mr. S. Dey, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No.9 submits
that the respondent No.9 had approached the High Court by filing Misc. Case
No. 101(SH) of 2004 in WP(C) No. 99(SH) of 2004 seeking release of salary
2024:MLHC:570
of the teachers of the school wherein by order 18-03-2005 a direction was
issued to the State-respondents to take necessary step for payment to the
teachers. He submits that the respondent No.9 has no more liability in the
matter and no direction is required to be passed against him. The learned
Counsel further submits that though the petitioner has contended that there
exists a fake school and the Government funds are diverted to that school, the
alleged fake school is not made a party to this writ petition and hence no
effective direction can be passed in the writ petition.
11.
Mr. B. Khyriem, learned Counsel appearing for the respondents No.10-
14 submits that the petitioner is not serving in the Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary
School and she has no legally tenable claim against the school. He submits
that actual Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School is the school which is
recognized by the State Government and the school which the writ petitioner is
running has no recognition.
He further submits that the actual school is
function in the building which is constructed by utilizing Government fund.
He refers to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the State-respondents and
submits that it has been specifically stated therein that the investigation
conducted by the police revealed that the entire amount of Rs.78,000/- has been
paid to the concerned teachers except an amount of Rs.9,400/- which the
petitioner refused to accept by demanding the post of Headmistress of the
school. He submits that the petitioner’s service was terminated in the year
2004 and thereafter she never remained a part of the school and hence, the
grievance expressed in the writ petition is not genuine.
12.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior Counsel in his reply submits that the fact of
termination of the service was not known to the petitioner and the documents
pertaining to her termination have been brought into record by the State by
2024:MLHC:570
filing additional affidavit during the pendency of the writ petition.
He
contends that the termination of the petitioner is not valid as the same has been
done in utter disregard to the established provision of law. He submits that
though separate challenge has not been made against the termination of the
petitioner, the petitioner in her reply affidavit dated 04-11-2020 has brought
into record a copy of the registration dated 24-10-2017 showing the fact that
the petitioner, being in service, was registered with the National Institute of
Open Schooling (NIOS) for 18 months Diploma Elementary Education
(D.El.Ed) programme for untrained teachers issued under the seal of the SubDivisional Education Officer, Daddenggiri, West Garo Hills. He contends that
the above fact clearly establishes that the petitioner is continuing her service.
13.
Per contra, the learned Additional Senior GA draws attention of this
Court to the affidavit dated 01-12-2020 filed in response to the above-reply
affidavit to the petitioner and submits that claim of the petitioner that she is a
teacher in Government aided school on the basis of the document of
registration bearing the signature of the Government official is totally
untenable as the form is for registration of untrained elementary school
teachers irrespective of being private or Government aided school. He, thus,
maintains that the petitioner’s termination stands and the registration of the
petitioner to undergo D.El.Ed programme has no bearing in the claim made by
the petitioner.
14.
Heard learned Counsels for the parties and perused the materials
available on record.
15.
There is no dispute to the fact that the writ petitioner was appointed in
the Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School in the year 1999 and the school was
brought under the SSA scheme w.e.f. the month of February, 2002. Her name
2024:MLHC:570
also figured as a member of the Managing Committee of the school which was
constituted for a period of 3 years w.e.f. 01-01-2003 to 31-12-2005. During
that period, a dispute arose between the teachers and some members of the
Managing Committee with which resulted in adoption of resolution dated 2004-2004 by which it was decided to shift the school from its existing place to a
new location. However, there is nothing on record to show whether the said
school was at all shifted from its original location or not. If the claim of the
petitioner is to be accepted that the school was shifted to a location where she
is running the school at present, then the question arises as to how a new school
building came to be constructed on a different land by utilizing the
Government fund. In addition, how the petitioner could run and manage a
school from the year 2004 till date, i.e. almost for two decades, without any
funding from any authority, remains a mystery. During the course of hearing,
the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner also could not give any
satisfactory reply to the query of the Court with regard to the constitution of the
managing committee of the school run by the petitioner and the identity of the
members therein. In such a situation, the contention that the petitioner is
running a government aided school cannot be accepted.
16.
Insofar as, the claim of the petitioner with regard to the non-payment of
Rs.78,000/- meant for salary for the period of March, 2002 to February, 2003 is
concerned, it is seen that the WP(C) No. (SH) 347 of 2005 was disposed of by
order dated 24-09-2013 by the High Court upon being informed that there exist
two schools by the name of Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School. No specific
order was passed to release any amount to the petitioner. The direction therein
to conduct an enquiry and register an FIR was made to find out the culprit
involved in the misappropriation of the said amount of Rs.78,000/-.
The
2024:MLHC:570
investigation conducted by the police thereafter revealed that the entire amount
was paid to the concerned person except for Rs. 9,400/- which was not
accepted by the petitioner as she wanted to be appointed as the Headmistress of
the school. There is nothing on record to doubt the outcome of the said
investigation.
17.
The contention of the petitioner that the termination of her service by
order dated 16-07-2004 by the Managing Committee of the school consequent
to passing of a resolution thereof was not known to her, appears to be factually
incorrect. A perusal of the record of the WP(C) No. (SH) 347 of 2005, which
is tagged together with this case by virtue of order dated 29-07-2015 passed in
the present proceeding, indicates that the WP(C) No. (SH) 347 of 2005 was
amended and an amended writ petition was filed on 02-02-2010 by
incorporating fresh prayer at page -28 which reads as follows: “In the premises above it is therefore prayed that your lordship be
graciously be pleased to admit the writ petition call for record and issue
rule as to why a writ in a nature of certiorari and/or mandamus and or
any other appropriate writ, or order or direction of like nature should
not be issued directing the respondent authorities and after hearing the
parties be pleased to direct the state respondent to make payment of the
salary from February 2002 forthwith and also to make payment monthly
salary and also be pleased to set aside and quash the termination letter
dated 16-07-2004 passed by Secretary Rajpur Girl’s upper Primary
school and make the rule absolute and or pass to pass such order as
your lordship may deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.
And for this your petitioner as in duty bound and shall ever pray.
The termination letter dated 16-07-2004 was also enclosed as Annexure P – 22
in the aforesaid amended writ petition.
It is clear from the order dated 24-09-2013, by which the WP(C) No. (SH) 347
of 2005 was disposed of, that the prayer for setting aside and quashing of
2024:MLHC:570
termination order dated 16-07-2004 was not granted. The contention of the
petitioner that she had no knowledge of passing of termination order is,
therefore, totally incorrect. Furthermore, since the specific prayer for quashing
and setting aside of the termination of the petitioner was not granted, it has to
be taken as rejected. There is nothing on record to show that the petitioner reagitated the matter before any higher authority by challenging the order dated
24-09-2013.
18.
On the question of existence of two schools under the same name, this
Court during the proceeding of the instant matter has passed an order dated 2107-2022 which is reproduced herein below: “In course of hearing, Mr. K. Paul, learned Sr. counsel for the
petitioner has pointed out that the State respondent in their
affidavit-in-opposition dated 22.05.2015 at page-3 in the last
paragraph has made an averment that there is a school named
and styled as Rajpur Girls Upper Primary School in existence
which records are maintained by the Department of Education.
However, as far as the school also named and styled as Rajpur
Girls Upper Primary School supposedly headed by the petitioner
herein as the Headmistress, it is stated that the same is not in
existence and it is a fictitious school not known to the authorities.
Mr. K. Paul, has further submitted that to this extent, the
issue of the actual school going by the same name which is duly
recognised by the Government has to be identified so as to
proceed with this matter, for if the school headed by the petitioner
is found to be actually not in existence this petition would
eventually become futile and would be rendered infructuous. It is
again submitted that the said respondent may be directed to
clarify on this point.
Mr. S. Sengupta, learned Addl. Sr. GA has submitted that
on being directed the relevant information will be submitted
before this Court by way of an additional affidavit.
Accordingly, the Director or the appropriate authority is
hereby directed to file the said affidavit confirming the status of
the actual school in existence.
2024:MLHC:570
The State affidavit should be filed within the next date fixed.
List this matter after 3(three) weeks.”
It is evident from the above that a categorical submission was made that the in
the event the school headed by the petitioner is found to be not in existence,
this writ petition would eventually become infructuous.
19.
Pursuant to the above order, the State-respondents have filed an
additional affidavit dated 29-08-2022 bringing into the record the copy of the
report on the existence of Rajpur Girls’ Upper Primary School in terms of the
order dated 21-07-2022 along with the relevant annexures.
The report is
signed by the Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Education Dept. &
State Project Director, SEMAM – SSA, Shillong. The conclusion recorded in
the said report reads as follows: “5. Conclusion - In conclusion and as elaborated above, it is
hereby clarified and confirmed that the original and existing
school or Rajpur Girl’s Upper Primary School headed by Smti.
Subeda Khatun, Headmistress is functioning normally and
documents and records are maintained under the different offices
under the Education Dept. whereas the breakaway school
established by Smti. Faluda Biswas (Petitioner), the self-styled
Headmistress in the same name Rajpur Girl’s Upper Primary
School do not exist in the record of all offices under the Education
Dept.
Submitted to the Govt. Advocate for information of the Hon’ble
High Court of Meghalaya and further necessary action.”
The above conclusion made in the report establishes beyond reasonable doubt
that the petitioner’s school does not exist in the Government record. Even
though the petitioner has filed an affidavit in response to the report, the same is
without any material having bearing in the conclusion arrived therein. That
apart, the order dated 21-07-2022 of this court has binding effect on the
2024:MLHC:570
petitioner as the order was passed on the basis of the submission made on her
behalf.
20.
The petitioner in her writ petition has not made any disclosure of
challenge made to the termination letter dated 16-07-2004 by amendment made
in WP(C) No.(SH)347 of 2005. On the contrary, when the respondents raised
the plea of termination of the service of the petitioner, it was argued on behalf
of the petitioner that the fact of termination of service was not within her
knowledge and the related documents were brought into the records by the
state respondents at a later stage by an additional affidavit. This amounts to
suppression of material fact by the petitioner. Moreover, the enquiries made by
the state and the reports prepared thereof undoubtedly indicate that the
petitioner is running a school of her own without any recognition or approval
from any authority. The petitioner is also not in a position to disclose who are
the other persons involved in running the management of her school. Hence,
her version of the case is not worth acceptance by this court.
21.
In view of the discussion made above, this writ petition is devoid of
merit and the same is dismissed with a cost of Rs.10,000/- (rupees ten
thousand) to be paid to the Shillong Bar Association by the petitioner. The
proof of payment be filed before the registry within 30 days.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
25.06.2024
“N. Swer, Stenographer Gr-11”
NATHANIEL
SWER
SWER
Date: 2024.06.25 18:45:52
+05'30'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review