The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
3. 5.2013 (|Exbt.3) that the wife submitted Exbt.4 at the Airport P.S claiming that she remarried Rajib Ghosh on 25.03.2013 and she had no grievance against her former husband (Atunu Debnath). The extract of the G. D. Entry (Exbt.3) also reveals that parents of the wife requested the Officer-in-charge not to proceed with their complaint against Atunu Debnath (the husband). Even though Smt. Mitali Choudhury (DW-2), mother of the wife denied any relationship between her daughter and Rajib Ghosh, she admitted that when she had gone to the Airport P.S to withdraw her complaint against Atunu Debnath (husband of her daughter), her daughter along with Rajib Ghosh also appeared together at the police station to supplement her proposal. [28] The evidence discussed hereinabove clearly demonstrates that the wife has, in fact, admitted her adulterous relationship with Rajib Ghosh. In cross examination, the wife could not impeach the evidence of PW-4 to any extent who stated that he rented a room in his house to the wife who lived there with Rajib Ghosh as his wife continuously from June, 2013 to July 2013. When they were pursuing such adulterous relationship, the husband filed the petition in the Family Court seeking dissolution of marriage with his wife by a Page - 16 of 18 decree of divorce on the ground contemplated under Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. [29] Under Section…
27. 05.1976. Before amendment the aggrieved spouse was required to prove that the offending spouse was “living in adultery”. After the amendment in 1976, Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 reads as under: “13. Divorce.- (1) Any marriage solemnised, whether before or after the commencement of this Act, may, on a petition presented by either the husband or the wife, be dissolved by a decree of divorce on the ground that the other party--(i) has, after the solemnisation of the marriage, had voluntary sexual intercourse with any person other than his or her spouse; or]*******” Page - 17 of 18 Therefore, in order to establish the ground under Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the petitioner spouse is required to prove that the offending spouse had, after solemnisation of marriage, voluntary sexual intercourse with any person other than his or her spouse. [30] There can hardly be any direct evidence to prove such fact, unless the erring spouse is caught by someone during the commission of the actual act. The Madras High Court in the case of Subharama Reddiar Vrs. Saraswathi Ammal; reported in AIR 1967 Madras 85 held that adultery can very rarely be proved by direct evidence and in most cases, the evidence must be circumstantial in character. The observation of the Court is as under: “8. ****** It has been recognised in a catena of decisions that do not requi…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAT App No.17/2018
Smti Dipanjita Datta,
wife of Sri Atanu Debnath,
daughter of Sri. Pramotosh Datta,
resident of Vill- Natunnagar Dighalia,
P.O - Agartala Airport, P.S. - Airport,
Dist- West Tripura PIN 799009
…………… Appellant(s)
Versus
Sri Atanu Debnath,
Son of Sri Jagadish Debnath,
Vill- Chhinaihani, P.O - Agartala Airport,
P.S.- Airport, District- West Tripura.
…………… Respondent(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
For Appellants(s)
:
Ms. Sarama Deb, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. K. Pal, Advocate
Date of hearing
:
12th November, 2021.
Date of Judgment
and Order
:
28th February, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
:
NO
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(S. G. Chattopadhyay,J)
This is wife‟s appeal against the judgment and decree dated
14.06.2018 passed by the Family Court, West Tripura, Agartala in TS(Divorce)
No.119 of 2013 dissolving the marriage between the spouses on the ground of
wife‟s having voluntary sexual intercourse with another person after
solemnisation of her marriage with the respondent.
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 2 of 18
[2]
The pleaded case of Atunu Debnath, husband hereinafter, is that
his marriage with Dipanjita Datta, wife hereinafter, was solemnised on 30th
April, 2005 according to Hindu rites. After marriage, the wife accompanied her
husband to his place where they lived together and led conjugal life. The
husband who was unemployed at the time of his marriage got a job in Goa in
2008. At Goa, he started living with his friend Rajib Ghosh (respondent No.2 at
the Family Court) in a rented house named „Goa Villa‟. 15 days thereafter he
rented a separate house. He however, continued having friendship with said
Rajib Ghosh. After staying alone at Goa for about three years, he brought his
wife to Goa. After his wife came to Goa, his friend Rajib Ghosh used to visit
him frequently in his rented house. During such visit, Rajib developed intimacy
with his wife. Even during their visit to Agartala, Rajib used to meet his wife in
his in-laws‟ house. Gradually, Rajib and his wife developed an illicit relationship.
While at Goa, the husband had seen his wife talking to Rajib on mobile phone
even at late hours at night. Ultimately, on 25.03.2013 his wife eloped with
Rajib Ghosh leaving a letter at his place. Thereafter on 08.04.2013 he received
a registered letter written by his wife where she stated that she married Rajib
Ghosh. After this incidence in April, 2013, the husband filed an application for
divorce in the Family Court at Agartala on the ground of his wife‟s having
voluntary sexual intercourse with Rajib Ghosh.
[3]
The wife filed her response to the petition of her husband
contending that her husband brought false allegations against her with a view
to get a decree of divorce. According to the wife, three years after their
marriage, her husband left for Goa leaving her alone at her parental home. He
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 3 of 18
did not even keep any contact with her during that period of their separation.
Therefore, she visited Goa in 2009 along with her parents where she was
treated with enormous cruelty by her husband. She denied to have any kind of
relationship with Rajib Ghosh. She stated in her reply that she met Rajib Ghosh
for the first time in Goa where he used to visit her husband in their rented
house. As a result of cruelty of her husband, she left Goa and started living
alone in a rented house at Buddhamandir area at Agartala. Since she was not
supported by her husband, she started taking private tuition to maintain
herself. The wife pleaded in her written statement that the cruelty of her
husband having crossed the limit of her tolerance, divorce was the only
solution.
[4]
In an additional written statement filed by her, the wife
reaffirmed that allegation of her husband with regard to her having illicit
relationship with his friend Rajib Ghosh was entirely false. She also denied to
have written to her husband that she eloped with Rajib Ghosh and married
him. She further stated in her additional written statement that she was willing
to live with her husband in marital tie.
[5]
Despite receiving notice of the case, Rajib Ghosh (respondent
No.2 at the Family Court) did not participate in the proceeding before the
Family Court. As a result, the suit was heard ex parte against him.
[6]
In view of the pleadings of the parties, the trial Court framed the
following issues in the suit.
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 4 of 18
(i)
Whether the wife after solemnisation of her marriage had
voluntary sexual intercourse with any person other than her
husband.
[7]
(ii)
Whether the husband was subjected to cruelty by his wife.
(iii)
Whether the husband was entitled to a decree of divorce.
The husband who was the petitioner before the Family Court
adduced the oral evidence of himself as PW-1, his father Jagadish Ch. Debnath
as PW-2, his neighbour Subhajit Bhattacharee as PW-3, one Subrata Biswas as
PW-4 who rented his house at Abhoynagar to his wife and Rajib Ghosh, his
uncle Haradhan Debnath as PW-5 and his neighbour Shyamal Baiswas as PW6. Apart from adducing such oral evidence, the husband also relied on several
documents which were marked as Exbt.1 to Exbt.7.
[8]
The wife on the other hand relied on the evidence of herself as
DW-1, evidence of her mother Smt.Mitali Choudhury as DW-2 and the evidence
of Sri Biplab Saha, one of her neighbours as DW-3. She did not adduce any
documentary evidence.
[9]
The Family Court on appreciation of evidence came to the
conclusion that the wife, after solemnisation of her marriage with the husband,
had voluntary sexual intercourse with Rajib Ghosh (respondent No.2 in Family
Court) who was a friend of her husband and such conduct of her entitled the
husband (Petitioner in the Family Court) to dissolution of his marriage with his
wife by a decree of divorce. Accordingly, the Judge Family Court, decreed the
suit for divorce in favour of the husband viewing as under:
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 5 of 18
“39. In the above under Issue no.1, it has been decided
that after solemnization of marriage, the respondent wife
fled away with the respondent No.2 who had been other
than her husband and started living together and thereby
led voluntary adultery life. However, under Issue No.2, it
has been decide that the respondent-wife did not treat the
petitioner husband with cruelty. The petitioner husband
has established that after solemnization of marriage the
respondent wife had voluntary sexual intercourse with
respondent No.2 who was other than her husband
petitioner which was in fact the foundation for seeking
divorce. Therefore, I conclude and hold that the petitioner
husband is entitled to a decree of divorce under the
provision of Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955.
40.
In view of the foregoing detailed discussion and
analysis and findings arrived at under aforementioned
issues, the suit/petition of the petitioner is hereby decreed
on contest against the respondent No.1 (wife respondent)
and ex parte against the respondent No.2 (Rajib Ghosh).
The marriage of the petitioner husband namely Sri Atunu
Debnath and Respondent wife namely Smt. Dipanjita Datta
is hereby dissolved by a decree of divorce with effect from
the date of preparation of the decree. No order as to the
costs of the suit, the parties shall bear costs of their
respective case. Considering the peculiarity of the case, no
order as to other relief sought by the parties. Decree sheet
be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to records.”
[10]
We have heard Ms. Sarama Deb, learned counsel appearing for
the wife and Mr. A. K. Pal, learned Counsel appearing for the husband.
[11]
We have also perused the pleadings, evidence, the impugned
judgment passed by the Family Court and the written arguments which have
been submitted by the counsel of the parties.
[12]
Learned counsel appearing for the wife mainly contended as
under:
(i)
The trial court did not appreciate the fact that the husband
filed a vague petition in the Family Court and failed to make out
any ground of divorce.
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 6 of 18
(ii)
The Trial Court erroneously granted divorce in favour of
the husband on the ground of adultery without any proof of
adultery.
(iii)
The Family Court did not also appreciate the fact that the
husband brought false allegations of cruelty and adulterous
relationship against his wife only with a view to cover up his
misdeeds particularly the atrocities meted out by him to his wife.
(iv)
The Family Court should not have believed the story of
adulterous relationship between the wife and respondent No.2
without hearing respondent No.2.
(v)
The Family Court failed to appreciate the fact that in a
divorce proceeding on the ground of adultery, the adulterous
relationship
of
the
offending
spouse
has
to
be
proved
satisfactorily.
[13]
In the course of her arguments, Ms. Deb, learned counsel of the
wife having relied on the decision of the Punjab and Hariyana High Court in the
case of Bhagwan Singh Sher Singh Arora Vrs Amar Kaur, W/o.
Bhagwan Singh and Another; reported in AIR 1962 PUNJAB 144
contended that in a case where one of the spouses has sought for divorce on
the ground of adultery, it has to be proved by the petitioner spouse that the
offending spouse was living in a continuous course of adultery.
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 7 of 18
[14]
Counsel of the wife further contended that in the present case
the Family Court granted a decree of divorce on the basis of its inference of
adulterous relationship between the appellant wife and respondent No.2 which
is not permissible in law. According to learned counsel law requires that for
granting decree of divorce on the ground of adultery, there must be
satisfactory proof of adultery carrying a high degree of probability. To buttress
her submission counsel has relied on paragraph-12 of the decision of the
Rajasthan High Court in Smt. Pushpa Devi Vrs. Radhey Shyam; reported in
AIR 1972 Rajasthan 260 which reads as under:
“12. As regards the question whether the adultery on
the part of the wife has been established the learned
Additional District Judge is, no doubt, right in saying,
that it is not necessary to prove the fact of adultery
by direct evidence. It would be unreasonable to
expect direct evidence and such evidence, if
produced, would be normally suspect and is likely to
be discarded. Normally the matrimonial offence of
adultery is expected to be established by
circumstantial evidence, but in that event the
circumstances must be such as lead to the necessary
conclusion that adultery was committed by the
spouse concerned. It would not be possible to lay
down as a rule of the thumb as to what
circumstances would be sufficient to establish
adultery, because circumstances may be diversified
by the situation and character of the parties, by the
state of general manners and by many other
incidental circumstances, apparently slight and
delicate in themselves, but they may have important
bearing on the particular case. The only general rule
upon the subject is that the circumstances must be
such as would lead to a guarded judgment of a
reasonable and just man to the conclusion. Proof
beyond reasonable doubt means such proof as it
precludes every reasonable hypothesis except that
which it tends to support. It need not reach certainty,
but must carry a high degree of probability. The Court
would not as a general rule infer adultery from
evidence of opportunity alone, but: would require
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 8 of 18
some more satisfactory proof (vide Mulla's Hindu Law,
13th Edn., pages 671 to 672).”
[15]
Counsel of the petitioner further argued that none of the
documents relied on by the husband was proved before the Family Court. The
wife categorically denied to have made any written communication to her
husband saying that she eloped with Rajib Ghosh and married him. Family
Court ignored such denials of the wife and without taking into consideration
her pleadings and evidence decreed the suit against her. Counsel contends that
the judgment and decree of the Family Court is completely erroneous which is
based on no evidence at all and therefore, Ms. Deb, learned counsel has urged
for setting aside the impugned judgment and decree passed by the Family
Court.
[16]
Mr. A. K. Pal, learned counsel appearing for the husband, having
referred to the findings recorded by the Family Court contends that under
Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 even a single act of voluntary
sexual intercourse by the offending spouse with any person other than his or
her spouse shall constitute a ground for divorce. It has been argued by Mr. Pal
learned advocate that the husband (Petitioner before the family court) proved
the letters of his wife admitting her adulterous relationship with respondent
No.2. Counsel contended that even the landlord(PW-4) in whose house the
wife lived with Rajib Ghosh in an adulterous relationship also came forward and
supported the case of the husband by giving evidence in the trial court, whose
evidence could not be impeached in cross-examination. Counsel therefore,
argues that the judgment of the Family Court is based on evidence and sound
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 9 of 18
reasoning which cannot be faulted with for any reason. Counsel therefore,
urges for dismissing the appeal.
[17]
The question which falls for our reconsideration in this case is
whether the husband has been able to make out a case under Section 13(1)(i)
of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 on the ground of which divorce has been
granted in his favour by the Family Court. To find out an answer, we have
examined the entire evidence led by the contesting spouses and considered the
arguments advanced by their counsel.
[18]
The husband actually adduced the examination in chief on
affidavit of seven witnesses. Since PW-7, Ujjwal Dey, was not produced for
cross examination, trial court did not rely on his evidence. Among the PWs who
have been examined and cross-examined, PW-1, as stated above, is the
husband who brought the suit for divorce. In his examination-in-chief on
affidavit he asserted that at the time of solemnisation of his marriage with the
appellant, he was unemployed. Three years thereafter, he got a job in Goa. He
went to Goa alone leaving his wife at his home. In Goa, he started living in a
rented house named „Goa Villa‟ along with his friend Rajib Ghosh who is the
alleged adulterer. After six months, his wife came to Goa. After his wife came,
he rented a separate house at a place called Suncoale in Goa for living with his
wife. At that time Rajib Ghosh was also living in a rented house at Suncoale
who used to visit them regularly. In June, 2012 when the husband came to
Agartala along with his wife, Rajib Ghosh also came to Agartala. After he
returned to Goa on 30.05.2012 leaving his wife at home, his wife left his home
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 10 of 18
and started living at her parental home along with Rajib Ghosh (alleged
adulterer). Thereafter, his wife wrote a letter to him where she stated that she
wanted to spend the rest of her life with Rajib Ghosh. The said letter of his
wife was admitted into evidence and marked as Exbt.1. Few days thereafter,
his wife went to Puri in Orissa along with Rajib Ghosh where they lived
together in the house of one Narayan Maharam at Mangala Mandi Chhak, Puri.
By a letter dated 31.3.2013 his wife informed him that she married Rajib Ghosh
on 25.03.1013 and she was happy with Rajib Ghosh. She also begged for
pardon of her husband. The said letter was marked as Exbt.2 at the trial
court. His wife and Rajib Ghosh returned to Agartala together on 3.5.2013 by
an Indigo flight. They appeared before the Airport P.S and informed the
Officer-in-charge of the police station in writing that they married on
25.03.2013. She also informed the Officer-in-charge of the police station in
writing that she had no complaint against her former husband (present
respondent). Her mother also appeared at the police station and wanted to
withdraw the complaint lodged by her against the husband of her daughter
(present respondent). The husband in his examination-in-chief on affidavit
further asserted that after she left his company, his wife continuously lived with
Rajib Ghosh as his wife at Abhoynagar in the rented house owned by Subrata
Biswas (PW-4) from June, 2013 to July 2013.
In his cross-examination he admitted that he did not lodge any
complaint at the police station after his wife eloped with Rajib Ghosh (alleged
adulterer).
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 11 of 18
[19]
PW-2, Jagadish Chandra Debnath is the father of the husband
who stated that after hearing from his wife that his son and daughter-in-law
developed matrimonial discord at Goa he asked his son and daughter-in-law to
came back to Kolkata where the PW was living at that point of time. He also
sent two railway tickets to them for travelling from Goa to Kolkata via Mumbai.
But his son returned alone and showed him a letter of his wife whereby his
wife informed that she eloped with Rajib Ghosh. The PW stated that he did not
inform the matter to police in fear of scandal. The PW informed the matter to
the parents of his daughter-in-law who requested the PW not to divulge it to
anybody. They advised the PW to ask his son to file a suit for divorce against
his wife. Accordingly, his son filed a divorce cse against his daughter-in-law.
In his cross-examination, the PW denied to have made a false
statement.
[20]
Subhajit Bhattacharjee, PW-3 is a neighbour of the spouses. He
stated that he heard that the wife eloped with Rajib Ghosh from Goa. The PW
further stated in his examination in Chief that on 3.5.2013 he along with 30/40
neighbours of him appeared at Airport P.S where the wife also appeared along
with Rajib Ghosh. She admitted in writing that she left her former husband and
married Rajib Ghosh. In his cross examination, the PW denied to have made a
false statement. He also denied the suggestion of the counsel of the wife that
the wife did not elope with Rajib Ghosh.
[21]
Subrata Biswas, PW-4 stated in his examination-in-chief that the
wife lived in his house at Abhoynagar on rent along with Rajib Ghosh from
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 12 of 18
May-2013 to the first part of July, 2013 as husband and wife. In his cross
examination, he denied that he made a false statement before the Court.
[22]
PW-5 is Haridhan Debnath who is the uncle of the husband. He
stated that his nephew (the husband) told him that his wife eloped with Rajib
Ghosh and married him. In cross-examination he denied the suggestion of the
cross examiner that mother of the wife was forced by them to withdraw her
complaint against the husband.
[23]
PW-6. Shyamal Baishya also stated in his examination-in-chief
that he heard that the wife eloped with Rajib Ghosh and married him in a
temple. In cross examination, he denied the suggestion of the counsel of the
wife that his evidence was untrue.
Wife’s Evidence:
[24]
The wife appeared in the witness box as DW-1. In her
examination-in-chief she asserted that her husband made false and baseless
allegations against her. She stated that after staying alone for three years at
Goa along with his friend in a rented house, her husband brought her to Goa.
She denied to have any relationship with Rajib Ghosh. She asserted that her
husband intentionally and motivatedly involved her in a scandal which had no
foundation. She expressed her willingness to live with her husband and
opposed his petition for divorce.
She was subjected to incisive cross examination. In cross
examination, she admitted that Exbt.1 whereby she informed her husband
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 13 of 18
about her relationship with Rajib Ghosh was of her own hand writing. She
explained that she wrote it under the coercion of her husband. She also
admitted that Exbt. 2 whereby she informed her husband that she married
Rajib Ghosh on 25.03.2013 was also of her hand writing. She volunteered
before the Court to say that she was forced by her husband to write this letter.
She also admitted that she along with Rajib Ghosh purchased the air ticket
(Exbt.7) and returned together to Agartala. In answer to a question of the
cross-examiner, she categorically asserted that after she was forced to write
Exbt.1 and Exbt.2 she did not lodge any complaint at the police station. She
denied all other suggestions of the counsel of the husband.
[25]
Her mother Smt. Mitali Chowdhury has been examined as DW-2,
who denied all allegations of her son-in-law. She categorically denied to have
seen any objectionable relationship between her daughter and Rajib Ghosh.
She asserted in her examination-in-chief that she lodged two complaints
against her son-in-law at the Airport P.S which were letter withdrawn by her on
the understanding that after withdrawal of her complaints her daughter would
be taken back to her matrimonial home. But she was disappointed to see that
her son-in-law filed a divorce case against her daughter. In cross-examination
she denied the suggestion of the counsel of her son-in-law that she had
withdrawn her complaints from the police station after she came to know that
her daughter married Rajib Ghosh. She further admitted that on 3.5.2013 when
she went to Airport police station she found her daughter with Rajib Ghosh at
the police station.
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 14 of 18
[26]
DW-3 is Biplab Saha, a neighbour of the wife who supported the
case of the wife and stated that the wife never maintained any illicit
relationship with Rajib Ghosh and her husband brought false allegations
against her with a view to malign her in her society. In his cross-examination
the DW denied the suggestion of the counsel of the husband that he gave false
evidence.
[27]
From the pleadings and evidence discussed above, it would
appear that apart from relying on the oral evidence of his witnesses, the
husband has also relied on the letters of his wife which are Exbt.1, Exbt.2 and
Exbt.4. During cross-examination of the wife, counsel of the husband invited
her attention to those documents. Among those documents Exbt.1 is her letter
whereby she informed her husband that she decided to spend rest of her life
with Rajib Ghosh. The wife admitted that the letter (Exbt.1) was written by her.
Similarly, by her letter (Exbt.2) she informed her husband that she married
Rajib Ghosh in a temple on 25.03.2013 and she was living a happy conjugal life
with him and she requested her husband not to curse her.
The wife also
admitted that the writing and signature of Exbt.2 were of her. Her husband
produced these documents at the trial Court which were taken into evidence
and marked as exhibits. The wife never disowned those documents when she
was encountered by the cross examiner with those documents (Exbt.1 and
Exbt.2). Rather, she admitted that she authored those documents. She
however, volunteered to explain that she wrote those letters under the
pressure of her husband. Her explanation is not acceptable because she never
made any complaint to any one that she was subjected to pressure or coercion
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 15 of 18
by her husband for writing those letters. Husband also relied on
Exbt.4
whereby his wife informed the Officer-in-charge of Airport Police Station that
she willingly married Rajib Ghosh on 25.03.2013 and she did not have any
grievance against her former husband. The wife did not deny Exbt.4 either
during cross examination of her husband or in her own statement as DW-1. It
would appear from the extract of the Airport P.S G. D. Entry No.90 dated
3.5.2013 (|Exbt.3) that the wife submitted Exbt.4 at the Airport P.S claiming
that she remarried Rajib Ghosh on 25.03.2013 and she had no grievance
against her former husband (Atunu Debnath). The extract of the G. D. Entry
(Exbt.3) also reveals that parents of the wife requested the Officer-in-charge
not to proceed with their complaint against Atunu Debnath (the husband).
Even though Smt. Mitali Choudhury (DW-2), mother of the wife denied any
relationship between her daughter and Rajib Ghosh, she admitted that when
she had gone to the Airport P.S to withdraw her complaint against Atunu
Debnath (husband of her daughter), her daughter along with Rajib Ghosh also
appeared together at the police station to supplement her proposal.
[28]
The evidence discussed hereinabove clearly demonstrates that
the wife has, in fact, admitted her adulterous relationship with Rajib Ghosh. In
cross examination, the wife could not impeach the evidence of PW-4 to any
extent who stated that he rented a room in his house to the wife who lived
there with Rajib Ghosh as his wife continuously from June, 2013 to July 2013.
When they were pursuing such adulterous relationship, the husband filed the
petition in the Family Court seeking dissolution of marriage with his wife by a
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 16 of 18
decree of divorce on the ground contemplated under Section 13(1)(i) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
[29]
Under Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 a decree
of divorce can be granted when it is proved that the offending spouse had
voluntary sexual intercourse with any person other than his spouse. From the
evidence discussed hereinabove, it is crystal clear that the wife had been
continuously living with Rajib Ghosh in an adulterous relationship in the house
of PW-4 when the divorce petition was filed by her husband. As noted, counsel
of the petitioner contended that for granting divorce on the ground of adultery,
the party applying for divorce must prove the charge of adultery against the
offending spouse satisfactorily. Before we comment on the merit of such
argument of the petitioner‟s counsel it would be appropriate to refer to the
relevant provision of law. The ground contemplated under Section 13(1)(i) of
the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 stood differently prior to its amendment by
Marriage Laws (amendment) Act 68 of 1976 which came into force w.e.f
27.05.1976. Before amendment the aggrieved spouse was required to prove
that the offending spouse was “living in adultery”. After the amendment in
1976, Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 reads as under:
“13. Divorce.- (1) Any marriage solemnised,
whether before or after the commencement of this
Act, may, on a petition presented by either the
husband or the wife, be dissolved by a decree of
divorce on the ground that the other party--(i) has, after the solemnisation of the
marriage, had voluntary sexual intercourse
with any person other than his or her spouse;
or]*******”
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 17 of 18
Therefore, in order to establish the ground under Section 13(1)(i)
of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the petitioner spouse is required to prove that
the offending spouse had, after solemnisation of marriage, voluntary sexual
intercourse with any person other than his or her spouse.
[30]
There can hardly be any direct evidence to prove such fact,
unless the erring spouse is caught by someone during the commission of the
actual act. The Madras High Court in the case of Subharama Reddiar Vrs.
Saraswathi Ammal; reported in AIR 1967 Madras 85 held that adultery
can very rarely be proved by direct evidence and in most cases, the evidence
must be circumstantial in character. The observation of the Court is as under:
“8. ****** It has been recognised in a catena of
decisions that do not require separate analysis here,
since the matter is beyond doubt, that adultery can
very rarely, if ever, be proved by the direct evidence
of witnesses who saw the parties in flagrante delicto
and witnessed the act. In most cases, the evidence
must be circumstantial in character and must depend
upon the situation spoken to in regard to which the
act is alleged and the probabilities relating to that
situation. But they(the circumstances) must satisfy
the test that, regarded together, they lead to an
irresistible inference that adultery must have been
committed.*****”
[31]
From the facts and circumstances of the case and evidence
discussed hereinabove, the only inference which can be drawn is that the wife
continuously lived in an adulterous relationship with Rajib Ghosh who was not
her husband. Having observed thus, we are of the view that the husband has
successfully discharged his burden in proving the case against his wife.
Therefore, the Family Court rightly snapped the matrimonial relationship
MAT App No.17/2018
Page - 18 of 18
between the husband and wife by a decree of divorce. Resultantly, the appeal
stands dismissed. Prepare the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCR.
JUDGE
Dipankar
MAT App No.17/2018
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review