Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary
List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 74 of 2017
Date of Decision: 02.09.2022
Smti Dehila D. Sangma
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. P.T. Sangma, Adv.
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl. Sr. GA.
Mr. H. Kharmih, Addl. Sr. GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattarcharjee, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner has approached this Court with this petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking for issuance of a writ in
the nature of mandamus calling for re-survey of the land known as
Simsanggre A.king land/Ampangdamgre which has been acquired by the
respondent authorities for establishing Williamnagar Township.
2.
The petitioner claiming to be the Nokma of Simsanggre Dawa
A.king IV-56(5) land which is known as Ampangdamgre situated at
Williamnagar in the East Garo Hills District of Meghalaya has stated that
during the time of her predecessor-in-interest (L) Gosin Marak, the
Government of Meghalaya has expressed its view to acquire the land
falling within Simsanggre A.king along with the A.king land under 6(six)
other Nokmas, altogether 7(seven) Nokmas for the purpose of
establishing the Township of Williamnagar. In this regard, proceedings
under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was drawn up and
Notification No. RDA 45/78/179 dated 28.07.1983 was accordingly
published.
3.
The petitioner has also referred to an agreement entered by the
Government with the six Nokmas as indicated in the agreement, however
the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioner, (L) Gosin Marak was not
included in the said agreement dated 08.01.1972.
4.
It is also said that the Government has conducted a survey of the
land proposed to be acquired, but has never informed (L) Gosin Marak
about the same and till date no proper demarcation has been done and no
proper boundary has been set up by the respondents.
5.
The predecessor-in-interest of the petitioner, (L) Gosin Marak
was not given an opportunity to file any objection under Section 5A of the
said Land Acquisition Act and was also not called for personal hearing as
provided under Section 9 of the Act. However, the land acquired was
1618-0-11 bighas for which compensation of ₹ 80,90,550/- (Rupees
eighty lakhs, ninety thousand, five hundred and fifty) only was paid to
him without his consent.
6.
The petitioner having doubt about the fairness and transparency
of the acquisition proceedings, had filed an RTI application with some
queries about the same on 16.09.2008 and has received a reply on
16.10.2008 indicating to the extent that the total land acquired from
Simsanggre A.king land was 1618-0-11 bighas and payment was made at
₹ 5000/- (Rupees five thousand) only per bigha, the total amount of which
comes to ₹ 80,90,550/- (Rupees eighty lakhs, ninety thousand, five
hundred and fifty) only. However, the petitioner in her individual capacity
has caused a re-survey of the land under Simsanggre A.king acquired by
the Government and according to the map prepared by her, the total area
of land acquired by the Government was 1995-0-0-bighas, which has
resulted in an excess of 377 bighas being actually acquired.
7.
After receiving the RTI information, the petitioner has then filed
applications dated 18.10.2010 and 08.05.2012 requesting the State
respondent to cause re-survey/re-measurement of the land acquired under
Simsanggre Dawa A.king land and has also prayed for payment of
compensation for the excess area of 377 bighas. Though the said
applications were forwarded to the concerned authorities, yet till date, the
petitioner has not received any response or reply to the same. Even the
reminder dated 12.08.2013 has failed to evoke any response from the
authorities.
8.
Being aggrieved by the action of the authorities in not
responding to the said abovementioned applications of 18.10.2010,
08.05.2012 and 12.08.2013, the petitioner approached this Court by way
of a writ petition being W.P(C) No. 179(SH) of 2014. The said petition
was however withdrawn with a prayer to file a fresh petition which was
allowed by this Court vide order dated 26.02.2015.
9.
Thereafter, the petitioner filed another representation dated
17.06.2016 with the same prayer for re-measurement and to conduct a
joint survey of the total area of the land acquired by the Government. But
this representation was also not responded to.
10.
Thus, being aggrieved by the action of the respondents
authorities in not responding to the prayer of the petitioner, the petitioner
have come before this Court with this instant writ petition with the prayer
as aforesaid.
11.
It may be mentioned that this petition has come to be heard
before this Court the second time around, as on the first occasion, this
Court, upon hearing the parties have, vide order dated 18.04.2017 directed
that a joint survey by the petitioner and the respondents be carried out on
the land in dispute, but on appeal before a Division Bench of this Court in
W.A. No 13 of 2017, the said order was set aside vide order dated
06.12.2018 and the matter remanded to this bench to hear the parties after
affording an opportunity to the respondents to file their counter affidavit
which was done.
12.
Mr. P.T. Sangma, learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the petitioner has not approached the appropriate
authorities or this Court for enhancement of the compensation already
awarded, but has maintained that since there is no proper demarcation nor
was any boundary walls erected to differentiate the total land acquired by
the Government for the establishment of Williamnagar Township,
therefore, the respondent authorities may be directed to cause inspection
of the same and after proper measurement have been taken, to erect a
boundary wall for clear demarcation so as to avoid any dispute on
complaint of encroachment, etc.
13.
It is also submitted that the respondent authorities have failed to
address the issue of re-measurement and demarcation of the land in
question in their affidavit-in-opposition, and instead has referred to the
order of the learned Special Judicial Officer, Shillong, Land acquisition
cases wherein vide order dated 20.12.1993 the learned Special Judicial
Officer on consideration of the application for enhancement of the
compensation awarded for the land acquired which is the same land
referred to by the petitioner herein, has enhanced the compensation award
which has nothing to do with the prayer of the petitioner in this instant
petition.
14.
The petitioner therefore prays that this petition may be allowed
and the respondent authorities be directed to cause re-measurement and
proper demarcation of the said acquired land.
15.
Per contra, Mr. S. Sengupta, learned Addl. Sr. GA on behalf of
the respondents has submitted that the preference of this instant writ
petition is, but, a shocking case of abuse of the process of law and should
be dismissed with exemplary costs. The same is barred by the principles
of estoppel, waiver and acquiescence and also of delay and laches,
inasmuch as, for an acquisition proceeding which was concluded in the
year 1983, when the first acquisition proceedings took place by issuance
of a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and
which proceedings though not completed was finally concluded by fresh
notification and follow up process in the year 1983. Therefore, the
petitioner by approaching this Court in the year 2017 seeking relief on the
prayer made thereof, has not been vigilant and has slept over his rights as
there was no explanation on the aspect of delay. This petition is therefore
liable to be dismissed at the threshold. The case of State of Maharashtra
v. Digambar: (1995) 4 SCC 683, para 14, 18 to 24 was cited by the
respondent in this regard.
16.
On the factual aspect, Mr. Sengupta has submitted that at the
time when the notification under Section 4 was issued on 28.07.1983, the
petitioner along with others were given every opportunity to file their
objection, but has failed to do so. As part of the acquisition process, the
lands were duly surveyed and demarcated in the month of March, 1984.
A survey report in this regard was prepared and signed by all the interested
parties including the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioner herein and
such survey report has accurately described the schedule of properties
along with the boundaries thereof, but the predecessor-in-interest of the
petitioner has failed to raise any objection at the relevant period and on
this ground alone, this writ petition is liable to be rejected.
17.
Another limb of argument raised by the respondents is on the
issue of res-judicata, inasmuch as, a similar and identical writ petition was
filed by the petitioner before this Court in the year 2014, but the same was
dismissed by this Court vide order dated 26.02.2015 on the prayer of the
petitioner to withdraw the same with liberty to file a fresh one. However,
it is expected that the petitioner would correct the defects found in the
petition of 2014 and to file a fresh one as soon as possible, the petitioner
has instead once again approached the department with a representation
in April, 2016 and only after alleging that no response was forthcoming,
had preferred this instant petition in the year 2017, therefore, this petition
is hit by the law of constructive res-judicata.
18.
In support of his contention as regard the issue of res-judicata,
the petitioner has cited the following cases: (i)
Henderson v. Henderson: (1843) 3 Hare 100, 627 ER
313;
(ii)
Asgar & Ors v. Mohan Varma & Ors: 2019 SCC Online
SC 131, para 40;
(iii) Shri. Sohan Lal v. Union of India & Anr: AIR 1957 SC
529, para 5 & 6;
(iv) Thansingh Nathmal v. Superintendent of Taxes, Dhubri
& Ors: AIR 1964 SC 1419, para 7;
(v)
Parvatibai Subhanrao Nalawade v. Anwarali Hasanali
Makani & Ors: (1992) 1 SCC 414, para 10 and
(vi)
State of Rajasthan v. Bhawani Singh & Ors: 1993 Supp
(1) SCC 306, para 7.
19.
On appreciation of the submission made on behalf of the rival
parties, this Court would observe that on the factual aspect of the matter,
the acquisition proceedings of the land for the establishment of the
Township of Williamnagar was carried out in the year 1983 by the
issuance of the notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894. Within the total land proposed to be acquired, the land of the
petitioner measuring about 1618-0-11 bighas was included for which as
per records, compensation was awarded to the predecessor-in-interest of
the petitioner (L) Gosin Marak who has received a sum of ₹ 80,90,500/(Rupees eighty lakhs, ninety thousand, five hundred and fifty) only.
20.
It is also the stand of the respondents that the predecessor-in-
interest of the petitioner (L) Gosin Marak was present during the survey
of the land on 19.03.1984 and has appended his signature along with
16(sixteen) others. Annexure-III to the Affidavit-in-opposition has clearly
brought out this fact when it was shown that (L) Gosin Marak has
appended his signature to the Survey report dated 19.03.1984 wherein the
total area was shown as 5803 bighas while the land of the predecessor-ininterest was 1618-0-11 bighas.
21.
This Court would also agree with the respondent to say that the
petitioner only on whim and fancy has thought it fit to seek remeasurement and re-survey of the land and that too realising it only in the
year 2008 or 2010, after about 26(twenty-six) years or so after which the
first representation was filed on 18.10.2010. The argument of the
respondent that the principle of delay and laches is attracted in this case
has substance.
22.
The maxim “Vigilantibus Non Dormientibus Jura Subveniunt”
which means that the law assists those who are vigilant with their rights
and not those that sleep thereupon is very much applicable to the case of
the petitioner as regard the approach to the authority with the
representation for re-survey and re-measurement of the land acquired
considering the fact that there is a gap of almost 27(twenty-seven) years
from the year of acquisition which is 1983 to the year 2010 when the first
representation was made.
23.
In the case of State of M.P & Ors v. Nandlal Jaiswal & Ors:
(1986) 4 SCC 566, para 24, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as
follows:
“24. Now, it is well settled that the power of the High Court
to issue an appropriate writ under Article 226 of the
Constitution is discretionary and the High Court in the
exercise of its discretion does not ordinarily assist the tardy
and the indolent of the acquiescent and the lethargic. If there
is inordinate delay on the part of the petitioner in filing a
writ petition and such delay is not satisfactorily explained,
the High Court may decline to intervene and grant relief in
the exercise of its writ jurisdiction…”
24.
Again, in the case of Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply and
Sewerage Board & Ors v. T.T. Murali Babu: (2014) 4 SCC 108, para 16
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as follows:
“16. Thus, the doctrine of delay and laches should not be
lightly brushed aside. A writ court is required to weigh the
explanation offered and the acceptability of the same. The
court should bear in mind that it is exercising an
extraordinary and equitable jurisdiction. As a constitutional
court it has a duty to protect the rights of the citizens but
simultaneously it is to keep itself alive to the primary
principle that when an aggrieved person, without adequate
reason, approaches the court at his own leisure or pleasure,
the court would be under legal obligation to scrutinize
whether the lis at a belated stage should be entertained or
not. Be it noted, delay comes in the way of equity. In certain
circumstances delay and laches may not be fatal but in must
circumstances inordinate delay would only invite disaster for
the litigant who knocks at the doors of the court. Delay
reflects inactivity and inaction on the part of the litigant-a
litigant who has forgotten the basic norms, namely,
“procrastination is the greatest thief of time “and second,
law does not permit one to sleep and rise like a phoenix.
Delay does bring in hazard and causes injury to the lis”.
25.
The above has clearly illustrated the concept of delay and laches
and in the case of the petitioner, even though, she has first approached the
forum below after a gap of about 27(twenty-seven) years and on failure to
get a response, has approached this Court, this Court is of the considered
opinion that because of the inordinate delay and laches, the forum below
has rightly rejected to respond to the said application. By extension, this
Court would deem it proper to consider and take it that the petitioner is
guilty of approaching the proper forum, including this Court at a very
belated stage.
26.
This Court having come to the conclusion that the case of the
petitioner cannot stand on the ground that the principle of delay and laches
is attracted and the same having been decided, accordingly, the argument
of the respondents on the issue of res judicata need not necessarily be
discussed and the authority cited in this regard may not be elaborated.
27.
In view of the above, this petition is found to be devoid of merits
and the same is hereby dismissed.
28.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
02.09.2022
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review