Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA No.01 of 2023
Smti Debirung Aslong
wife of Sri Biranta Aslong, resident of
Padmarai Karbari Para, P.O. and P.S.
Chhamanu, Sub-Division- Longtarai Valley
District- Dhalai, Tripura, Pin-799273
……… Appellant(s)
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt.
of Tripura, Secretariat Building, New
Capital Complex, PS- NCC, P.O. Kunjaban,
Pin-799010, Agartala, West Tripura.
2.
The Secretary,
Department of Education, Govt. of Tripura,
Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
PS- NCC, P.O. Kunjaban, Pin-799010,
Agartala, West Tripura.
3.
The Chief Executive Officer,
Tripura Tribal Area Autonomous District
Council, Khumlwung, P.O. Jirania, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin-799035
4.
The Principal Officer, Education,
Tripura Tribal Area Autonomous District
Council, Khumlwung, P.O. Jirania, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin-799035
5.
The Inspector of Schools,
Chhamanu, P.O. Chhamanu, Pin- 799273,
Longtharai Valley, District- Dhalai, Tripura.
6.
The Head Master
Padmarai K.P. Junior Basic School, Manu
Sen
Karbari
Para,
Makar
Cherra,
Chhamanu, P.O. Chhamanu, 799273,
Longtharai Valley, District- Dhalai, Tripura.
……. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant (s)
:
Mr. T.D. Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Chakraborty, Adv.
For the Respondent (s)
:
Mr. P. Gautam, Adv.
Mr. B. Debbarma, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
26.09.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
13.12.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[S. Datta Purkayastha, J]
The appeal arises out of the judgment of dismissal dated
01.11.2022 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Court
No.1, West Tripura, Agartala in case No. Money Suit 30 of 2018 and
related decree thereof, whereby the claim of the plaintiff (hereinafter
referred to as the appellant) for Rs.12,00,000/- was rejected.
[2]
The plaintiff states that she is the mother of the deceased
Parendra Aslong who along with Hadajoy Aslong, Ranjit Kumar Tripura
and others, were playing football in the playground of Padmarai
Karbari Para J.B School on 08.04.2017 at about 5 pm. When Hadajoy
Aslong was running with the football, suddenly he fell into an
abandoned ring well, situated inside the said school compound and
did not come out therefrom. To save Hadajoy Aslong, Parendra Aslong
thereafter got down into the well and he also did not come out and
then their other friend, Ranjit Kumar Tripura went inside the well to
rescue his two friends and he also did not come out. Ultimately, Fire
Service authority was informed by the locals and they rescued the
dead bodies of all these three persons from the said well and all of
them died due to suffocation by methyl gas emitting from said well.
According to the plaintiff, the school authority or rather the
defendants were in charge of management and control of the said
abandoned ring well and they left it in an uncared condition without
any fencing or protection wherefor the said incident occurred. It is
further stated that at the time of death, Parendra Aslong was 19
years old, leaving his mother as a sole legal representative and he
used to earn Rs.6,000/- per month by collecting vegetables from the
cultivators and selling it in the market and also by rearing cows, pigs,
etc. Police investigated the incident under section 174 Cr.P.C. by
registering case bearing number Chhaomanu UD case No. 03 of 2017.
The plaintiff also sent notice dated 27.11.2017 under Section 80(1) of
the CPC through her Advocate to the defendants but the same fetched
no positive response and thereafter, the suit was filed.
[3]
All the defendants categorically denied their responsibility
to have any control and management of the said well and according to
them, the well was not inside the school complex. Therefore,
according to them, they were not responsible in any way to pay any
compensation for the said incident. Additionally, it was also claimed
that there was protective fencing around the said well and no one
could go inside the well without climbing that fence.
[4]
The main ground for dismissal of the suit by the learned
trial court was that first of all Hadajoy Aslong went inside the well and
did not come out and therefore, it was apparent that Parendra Aslong
did not accidentally fall into the well, rather consciously he went inside
the same and therefore, his death was not an accidental death and
hence, the plaintiff was not entitled to get any compensation.
[5]
Learned trial court framed total 5[five] numbers of issues
and the plaintiff adduced 5[five] witnesses including herself and also
proved certain documents into the evidence. From the side of the
defendants 2[two] witnesses were examined but they did not lead any
documentary evidence.
[6]
Mr. T.D. Majumder, learned senior counsel appearing for
the appellant argues on the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur and submits
that in the case of the claim in respect of Hadajoy Aslong, the said
court awarded compensation but in the case of claims in respect of
Parendra Aslong and Ranjit Kumar Tripura, same were rejected.
Therefore, the present appeal and another appeal bearing No.RFA 02
of 2023 were filed in this court. According to Mr. Majumder, learned
senior counsel, from the evidence it was established that the well was
inside the school complex and was under the management and control
of a school authority who kept the well completely in an insecured
condition, resulting to the death of three persons and therefore, they
are responsible to pay compensation to the plaintiff and other
claimants.
[7]
Mr. B, Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents No.3 to 6 argues that the ring well was constructed by
the State Government and not by his clients. More so, the death of
the deceased was not an accidental death. Next point of argument of
Mr. Debbarma, learned counsel is that even if it is presumed that the
well was inside the school complex, still the incident occurred after a
school hours and therefore, the school authority has no responsibility
or attribution in respect of said deaths.
[8]
Mr.
P.
Gautam,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondents No.1 to 3 submits that if any amount is awarded by the
Court, the same should be borne by the respondents No.3 to 6 and
not by the State Government inasmuch as the well was under the
management, control and supervision of the said respondents.
[9]
The bedrock of the claim of the plaintiff is on the basis of
doctrine of res ipsa loquitur. Said principle in law of Tort fastens the
liability upon the defendant(s) for damages when harm is caused to
the plaintiff due to negligent act or omission on the part of the
defendant(s) which would not have occurred in ordinary course except
for such negligent act or omission to take care of such object which
has caused the harm and which was solely under his/their control.
[10]
In Ravi Kapur vs. State of Rajasthan, (2012) 9 SCC
284, the Apex Court has observed that the court is required to adopt
one parameter of ‘reasonable care’ in determining the question of
negligence or contributory negligence. The doctrine of reasonable care
imposes an obligation or a duty upon a person (for example a driver)
to care for the pedestrian on the road and this duty attains a higher
degree when the pedestrians happen to be children of tender years. It
was also further observed that while driving a vehicle on a public way,
an implicit duty cast on the drivers to see that their driving does not
endanger the life of the right users of the road, may be either
vehicular users or the pedestrians.
[11]
While
describing
the
general
principles
of
law
of
negligence, the Apex Court in that case also cited reference of
Halsbury’s Laws of England (4th Edn.), Vol. 34, Para 1 (p.3) in
the following terms:
―9......1. General principles of the law of negligence.—
Negligence is a specific tort and in any given circumstances is
the failure to exercise that care which the circumstances
demand. What amounts to negligence depends on the facts of
each particular case. It may consist in omitting to do
something which ought to be done or in doing something
which ought to be done either in a different manner or not at
all. Where there is no duty to exercise care, negligence in the
popular sense has no legal consequence. Where there is a
duty to exercise care, reasonable care must be taken to avoid
acts or omissions which can be reasonably foreseen to be
likely to cause physical injury to persons or property. The
degree of care required in the particular case depends on the
surrounding circumstances, and may vary according to the
amount of the risk to be encountered and to the magnitude of
the prospective injury. The duty of care is owed only to those
persons who are in the area of foreseeable danger; the fact
that the act of the defendant violated his duty of care to a
third person does not enable the plaintiff who is also injured
by the same act to claim unless he is also within the area of
foreseeable danger. The same act or omission may
accordingly in some circumstances involve liability as being
negligent, although in other circumstances it will not do so.
The material considerations are the absence of care which is
on the part of the defendant owed to the plaintiff in the
circumstances of the case and damage suffered by the
plaintiff, together with a demonstrable relation of cause and
effect between the two.‖
[12]
The claim of the plaintiff has been generated on the basis
of the provision of Section 1(A) of the Fatal Accident Act, 1855 which
envisages that whenever the death of a person is caused by wrongful
act, neglect or default, and the act, neglect or default is such as would
(if death had not ensued) have entitled the party injured to maintain
an action and recover damages in respect thereof, the party who
would have been liable if death had not ensued, shall be liable to an
action or suit for damages, notwithstanding the death of the person
injured and although the death shall have been caused under such
circumstances as amount in law to felony or other crime. Every such
action or suit shall be for the benefit of the wife, husband, parent and
child, if any, of the person whose death shall have been so caused.
[13]
In the case in hand, when Hadajoy Aslong was not
returning from the said well, as per the evidence, Parendra Aslong
went inside the same to rescue Hadajoy Aslong without knowing the
consequence
thereof
and
ultimately
lost
his
life.
The
police
investigated the matter by registering said unnatural death case
bearing No.03 of 2017 and submitted the final report of the
investigation [Exbt.2] corroborating with said allegation. The postmortem report of Parendra Aslong [Exbt.4] also shows that the cause
of death was asphyxia as a result of suffocation. Both said
investigating officer and the medical officer who conducted the
autopsy, were examined by the plaintiff as PWs-4 & 5 and nothing
came out in their cross-examination to discredit such part of their
respective evidences and therefore, it is established that when
Hadajoy Aslong was not returning from the well, his other two friends,
one after another went inside the well to rescue him and ultimately,
they also lost their lives.
[14]
It appears from the evidence of PW-2, Sri Padma Ranjan
Chakma and PW-3 Barendra Tripura, two inhabitants of that locality
that they categorically stated that the said well was an abandoned
well situated inside the said school complex within the territorial
jurisdiction of Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council. PW-2
himself was the eyewitness of the occurrence. None of these two
witnesses could be discredited in their cross-examination with
reference to said part of their evidence. PW.2 even stated that he
alongwith other locals had requested the School authority for taking
protective steps for said ring well with proper covering but no such
step was taken by them.
The investigating police officer i.e. PW-4
mentioned in the related site map (Exbt.5) that the point ‘A’ was the
place of occurrence i.e. the well and the point ‘C’ was the school
building and also deposed that in his case diary, it was reflected that
the well was within the school boundary. In his cross-examination, he
also stated that there was no boundary fencing on the boundary of
the school campus.
[15]
The respondents No.3 to 6, in their written statement
asserted that the said school was under the TTAADC but the said ring
well was beyond the school complex and on that ground, they tried to
deny their responsibility.
[16]
Both DW-1, Smt. Rina Shil who discharged the duties of
Headmistress as an in-charge thereof and DW-2 Sri Debashis Barua,
another teacher of that school stated that there was a fencing of
about 3 feet to 5 feet height around the said well but during police
investigation, nothing as such came out about the existence of any
fencing around the said well. Even in the site map also, there is no
indication
of
existence
of
any
such
fencing.
The
independent
witnesses, as discussed earlier, have also stated that the said well
was lying in an uncared and in an abandoned condition. Therefore, the
evidence of DWs-1 & 2 in this regard is not convincing.
[17]
Considering all these materials as placed into the evidence,
it is established that said well was inside the said Padmarai Karbari
Para Junior Basic School compound and it was lying in an abandoned
and uncared condition without taking any protective measures
thereon, for which ultimately 3[three] innocent youths lost their lives
while going to play football. When the well was inside the school
complex, certainly it was the duty of the school authority to take
proper care and caution in maintaining said well in such a manner that
no such incident could occur, but the defendants No.3 to 6 have failed
in their such duties exhibiting their neglects and default. Therefore,
they are held responsible to pay damages to the plaintiffs.
[18]
The observations of the learned trial court that consciously
the deceased went inside the well despite knowing the fact that
Hadajoy Aslong was not coming from the said well and therefore, the
plaintiff was not entitled to get any compensation, are totally
perverse. Firstly, when Hadajoy Aslong went inside, it was not within
the knowledge of the deceased, an illiterate person, that there would
be methyl gas inside the same and that such methyl gas could be
fatal for his own life and also that already Hadajoy was under the grief
of such deadly gas. It is natural human instinct that when one friend
is in trouble, another friend will automatically go to save him and this
is the humanity for which all thrive at.
[19]
Now,
coming
to
the
determination
of
quantum
of
compensation, it is found that no birth certificate or any other
satisfactory document of date of birth of the deceased was proved into
evidence by the plaintiff. However, PW-1, the mother of the deceased
deposed that at the time of death, the age of her son was 19 years
old. The police investigation report as well as the post-mortem report
also reflects the age of the deceased to be 19 years. Considering thus,
for the purpose of calculation of compensation, his age is treated to
be 19 years at the time of alleged incident. Though PW-1 stated that
his monthly income was Rs.6000/- at that time by collecting and
selling vegetables in the market and also by rearing cows, pigs etc.,
but no satisfactory evidence has been led on that point. However, a
casual labour or a day labour in such a remote village area during the
year 2017 could be expected to earn Rs.250/- per day. If it is
presumed that he would get works for 22 days in a month, his
monthly income comes to Rs.5,500/-. Considering the age of the
deceased and to determine the loss of income vis-a-vis the loss of
dependency, multiplier 18 is required to be applied. For personal
expenses, if 50% is deducted therefrom considering that the plaintiff
alone was the only dependant family member, the compensation
comes to Rs.2750X12X18=Rs.5,94,000/- rounded off to Rs.6,00,000/-
[Rupees Six lakh only] inclusive of cost of funeral expenses and other
post death rituals which the plaintiff had to bear due to such death.
[20]
In view of the above discussions, the appeal is allowed.
The judgment and decree of the learned trial court are set aside. The
plaintiff-appellant
is
held
entitled
to
get
compensation
of
Rs.6,00,000/- [Rupees Six lakh only] along with interest @ 6% per
annum from the date of filing of the suit i.e. from 14.09.2018 till
payment. The respondents No.3 to 6 are held jointly and severally
liable to make the payment of said amount with interest as directed.
After such amount is paid or realised, 50% thereof shall be
kept in fixed deposit in the name of the plaintiff for 5 (five) years and
rest amount shall be disbursed to her through her bank account.
Return the trial court’s records.
Registry is to prepare the decree accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2024.12.17 13:35:07 +05'30'
Sujay
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review