Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.6 of 2021
Smti. Bijali Sinha
D/o Lt. Bashudev Sinha,
Resident of Vill- Ichabpur,
P.S. Kailashahar, P.O.- Ichabpur,
District-Unakoti Tripura
---Defendant No.1 Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Md. Chalek Miah
S/o Lt. Noor Miah
Resident of Vill- Pakhirbadar,
P.S. Kailashahar, P.O.- Ichabpur,
District- Unakoti Tripura
---Plaintiff Respondent
2. Sri Surajit Sinha
S.o Lt. Surendra Sinha,
Resident of Vill- Ichabpur,
P.S. Kailashahar,
District- Unakoti Tripura
3. Md. Kanachir Ali,
S/o Lt. Makchud Ullah,
Resident of Vill- Bongao,
P.S. Kailashahar,
District- Unakoti Tripura
4. Md. Askar Ali,
S/o Lt. Siddek Ali,
5. Md. Amjad Ali,
S/o Lt. Siddek Ali,
6. Md. Takdir Ali,
S/o. Lt. Siddek Ali,
Resident of Vill- Pakhirbadar,
P.S. Kailashahar, P.O.- Ichabpur,
District- Unakoti Tripura.
---Defendant Performa Respondents
For the Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
Date of hearing &
Delivery of Judgment & Order
:
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Sarkar, Advocate
Mr. H. Deb, Advocate
:
20.03.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
This is a second appeal preferred by the original
defendant against the judgment and decree dated 17.02.2021, passed
by the first appellate court in Title Appeal No.23 of 2019, whereby
and whereunder the appeal preferred by the original plaintiff was
allowed and decreed accordingly.
2.
Facts:
2.1
Plaintiff’s case, in brief, is that the suit land along with
some other land, in total 2.27 acres originally belonged to one
Dhanamoni Sinha as an allottee. During his lifetime Dhanamoni Sinha
transferred the land measuring 1.07 acres to one Kukileswar Sinha by
registered deed no. I-1278, dated 14.04.1982 and land measuring 1.20
acres were transferred to one Ratna Sinha vide registered deed no. I1279 dated 14.04.1982. Subsequently, Ratna Sinha again transferred it
to Kukileswar Sinha by registered deed no. I-2672, dated, 09.02.1986.
Accordingly, the said land was mutated in the name of Kukileswar
Sinha. After expiry of Kukileswar Sinha, the said land including the
suit land was owned by his legal heirs and was also mutated in their
name vide Khatian no.287. The said legal heirs of Kukileswar Sinha
after obtaining the sale permission from the District Collector
transferred the suit land to the plaintiff, Chalek Miah vide registered
deed no.I-959, dated 16.06.2004 and since then plaintiff has been
possessing the suit land.
2.2
But recently, the defendants, having no right title, interest
or possession over the suit and just to harass the plaintiff, filed a case
under Sections 145/146 of Cr.P.C. before the SDM Kailashahar in
respect of the suit land and, accordingly, the SDM has attached it.
Hence, by filing the case under 145 of Cr.P.C. in respect of the suit
land, defendants disturbed the plaintiff’s peaceful possession and legal
right, title over the suit land. Hence, the instant suit is filed by the
plaintiff with the following prayers:"(a)Granting declaration to the effect that, the plaintiff is the
rightful owner and he has right, title and interest in the suit
land.
(b) Granting declaration to the effect that the plaintiff is entitled to
get the restoration of possession of the suit land.
(c) Granting all other relief deemed fit & proper.
(d) Granting full cost of litigation.”
2.3
After institution of the suit, process was served and
accordingly defendants appeared and contested the suit by filing
written statement.
2.4.
In the written statement, all the defendants denied the
plaintiff’s case and defendant no.3, Kanachir Ali, stated that the suit
land is owned and possessed by him on the strength of registered
kawala bearing No.1-1551, dated 03.06.1992 executed in his favour
by Dhanamani Sinha and he was possessing the said suit land by
growing segun and betel nut trees thereon.
2.5
On the other hand, defendants no.1, 4, 5 and 6, inter alia,
stated that actually there were two numbers of fisheries within the suit
land and one of the fisheries was owned and possessed by defendant
no.1 with her co-sharers and heirs of deceased brother of defendant
no.1. But, none of them was made party to the instant suit. Hence, the
suit is liable to be dismissed for non-joinder of necessary parties. It is
also stated that plaintiff is trying to grab the fishery of defendant no.1
wrongfully and earlier also he tried to dispossess the defendant no.1
therefrom. Hence, the suit is liable to be dismissed with cost.
3.
During the course of trial, the following issues were
framed:“(i)
Has there any cause of action for the instant suit?
(ii)
Whether the suit is maintainable or not?
(iii) Is the plaintiff entitled to get the decree/relief as prayed
for?
(iv) What other relief the parties are entitled to get?”
4.
Before institution of the present suit, due to apprehension
of serious breach of peace the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar
in a proceeding under Section 146(1) Cr.P.C. had passed an order of
attachment dated 13.04.2007. This order of attachment forced the
plaintiff to institute the present Civil Suit and gave rise to the cause of
action. The plaintiff in support of his right, title and interest had
brought into record the allotment order issued by the DM and
Collector, North Tripura, at present Unokoti District.
5.
Thus, the plaintiff (Chalek Miah) in support of his right,
title interest over the suit land had brought into record the sale deed
dated 16.06.2004 being deed no.1-959. He also brought into record
the Khatian, i.e., record of right prepared in his name. The suit land
was originally belonged to Dhanamoni Sinha as an allottee. He
transferred the entire land to one Kukileswar Sinha and Ratna Sinha
vide registered deed No.1-1278 dated 14.04.1982 and deed No.1-1279
dated 14.04.1982, respectively.
6.
Thereafter, Ratna Sinha had transferred the land by way
of sale to Kukileswar Sinha. All those sale deeds were brought into
record and were duly executed in accordance with the relevant
provisions of the Indian evidence Act.
7.
After hearing learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff
and the defendants, the learned trial court had came to a finding that
record of rights (Khatian), being created in favour of the allottee and
in favour of subsequent purchasers including the plaintiff which have
raised the presumption that the plaintiff which along with his venders
have been possessing the suit land since the order of allotment.
8.
On consideration of the materials on record and the
evidence thereof, and after hearing the arguments of learned counsels
appearing for the parties, learned trial court had dismissed the suit by
judgment dated 29.03.2019 and decree dated 02.04.2019.
9.
The plaintiff preferred first appeal before the learned
Addl. District Judge, Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar. The said
first appeal filed by the plaintiff was allowed by the first appellate
court setting aside the judgment dated 29.03.2019 and decree dated
02.04.2019.
10.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said
judgment and decree passed by the first appellate court, the defendant
no.1 i.e. the appellant, herein has presented the present second appeal
before this Court. At the time of admission of this appeal, following
substantial questions of law were formulated by this Court:“(i)
When the defendants were in possession over the suit
land before the land was allotted in the name of the
predecessor of the plaintiff, can such allotment have any
force in law?
(i)
Whether the interpretation in respect of the condition of
allotment emanating straight under Rule 12 of the
Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms (allotment of
Land) Rules, 1980 can be sustained, inasmuch as a
statutory prohibition which provides that without prior
permission of the collector allotted land cannot be
transferred or can it be interpreted that for violation of
the Rule 12 of the said Rules the transaction cannot be
held void?”
11.
On the basis of aforesaid substantial questions of law, I
have heard Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. S. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the appellant and Mr. H.
Deb learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents.
12.
The first contention of Mr. Choudhury, learned senior
counsel is that whether the Collector has committed an error in
allotting the land in favour of Dhanamoni Sinha when defendants
were in possession of the land allotted.
13.
I find that at no point of time that there was any such
issue in this regard. So, it will not be proper for this court to exercise
its jurisdiction under Section 100 of CPC and should not enter into
this aspect. However, being pressed by learned senior counsel
appearing on behalf of the appellant, in the opinion of this court, this
point could have been raised by the appellant (the defendant) at the
very initial stage when the allotment order was issued by the DM &
Collector, North Tripura in favour of Dhanamoni Sinha, the original
allottee of the suit land. It is pertinent to mention herein that the suit
land was allotted before the year 1980 in favour of Dhanamoni Sinha
and the allotment order was not challenged at any point of time.
Hence this submission of learned senior counsel is not taken into
account while deciding this appeal being devoid of any substance.
14.
Secondly, the learned senior counsel has emphatically
submitted that Rule 12 of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land
Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules, 1980 has been breached by
Dhanamoni Sinha while transferring the suit land to Kukileswar Sinha
and Ratna Sinha.
15.
In the opinion of this Court, this plea only could have
been agitated by the Collector itself and not by the defendant. The
Collector allotted the land in favour of Dhanamoni Sinha before the
year 1980, who transferred the suit land in favour of said Kukileswar
Sinha and Ratna Sinha in the year 1982. Presumption is that, Collector
did not think it necessary to cancel the said sale deeds which were
executed without prior permission of the collector. This is also
established principle pronounced by this Court in a catena of
judgments that the Collector may cancel any allotment order issued by
him within a reasonable period in case of any breach of the conditions
mentioned in the Allotment Rules, 1980 and said reasonable period
must be within 3 years of the date of allotment.
16.
The relevant part of Rule 12 may be reproduced here-in-
below, for convenience, in extenso:“12. Conditions of allotment
(1) Any allotment of land under sub-section (1) of section 14 and
in accordance with these rules, shall be further subject to the
following conditions and also the condition specified in the
allotment order which shall be, as nearly as possible, in the
form at Appendix- „B‟:(i)
The land will be heritable but not alienable without the
written
consent
of
the
Collector
granted
on
the
recommendation of the Advisory Committee that may be set
up by the Government:
Provided that the land may be mortgaged to the Government,
or a co-operative society or a bank or such institution as may be
noticed in the Official Gazette by the State Government from time to
time ;
(ii)
****
****
****
****
(iii)
****
****
****
****
(iv)
****
****
****
****
(v)
****
****
****
****
(vi)
The allotment will be liable to be cancelled for breach
of any of the provisions of the Act, the rules or any of the
conditions of allotment.”
17.
On plain reading of the above provisions, it becomes
apparent that Allotment Rules, 1980, nowhere provides that the sale
without the permission of the Collector would be ipso facto invalid
and non est.
(emphasis supplied)
18.
In my opinion, it is merely a condition that allotted land
cannot be sold or alienated without the written consent of the
Collector. The consequence of breach of any of the conditions of Rule
12 is also provided. Clause (vi) of Sub Rule 1 of Rule 12 clearly
provides that for violation of any of the provisions of the Act, the
Rules or any of the conditions mentioned in the allotment order,
competent authority can cancel the allotment. Rules do not provide
that sale in violation of condition of allotment, without permission of
Collector would be ipso facto ab void initio and non est.
19.
In the instant case, the suit land was transferred by way
of “sale” by Dhanamoni Sinha to Kukileswar Sinha and Ratna Sinha
on receipt of determined consideration money mentioned in the sale
deed. As soon as the execution and registration of the sale deed is
complete the ownership of the suit land was transferred to the buyer.
Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 provides sale of
an immovable property having value more than Rs. 100/- must be
registered.
“Sale” is defined under Section 54 of Transfer of
Property Act, 1882, which reads as under:
“Sale”, is a transfer of ownership in exchange for a price
paid or promised or part paid or part/promised.
20.
From the sale deeds, it comes to fore that sale deeds were
transacted on payment of consideration of money and there were no
disputes in this regard. According to sale deeds, the buyers of those
deeds came into possession and consequent to their possessions over
the suit land, Khatians i.e. record of rights were also prepared by the
Government following relevant provisions under the Tripura Land
Revenue & Land Reforms Act, 1980.
21.
It will be useful to mention herein that before final
preparation of record of right in the name of a person, the authority
concerned had to follow different stages. These are “Khanapuri”,
“Bujharat”, “Attestation” and “Final Publication”. At no stage the
defendant had raised his objections and on due enquiry having found
the purchasers of the sale deeds, that is, Kukileswar Sinha and Ratna
Sinha in possession, records of right (Khatian) were created in favour
of them.
22.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, upon Rule 12 of
Allotment Rules, 1980 it can clearly be held that sale without
permission of Collector will not be void ab initio and non est unless
such allotment is cancelled by the Allotment Authority within a
reasonable period of time, i.e. within 3(three) years of the sale
transaction. A sale deed cannot automatically be said to be void for
violating a condition mentioned in the Allotment Rules or any of the
conditions mentioned in the allotment order. In other words, if an
allottee breaches any of the terms and conditions of allotment or any
rule governing the allotment, in that case, it is absolutely within the
domain of the Allotting Authority to cancel the allotment, but, for
such reason, it will not be wise to hold that the sale deed executed and
registered in accordance with the law of the land should be treated as
void and non est.
23.
In the light of above analysis on law coupled with the
facts, the substantial questions of law formulated by this court have
been answered and decided.
As a sequel, the instant second appeal stands dismissed.
However, there shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review