Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010257492017
2026:GAU-AS:3694
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : MACApp./890/2018
SMTI BHABANI BORO and 2 ORS
W/O LATE PRASANTA BORO, R/O VILL. SILAKOROIBARI, P.O. CHANGSARI,
P.S. KAMALPUR, DIST. KAMRUP (R) ASSAM
2: MISS RISHITA BORO
D/O LATE PRASANTA BORO
R/O VILL. SILAKOROIBARI
P.O. CHANGSARI
P.S. KAMALPUR
DIST. KAMRUP (R) ASSAM
3: MISS TULIKA BORO
D/O LATE PRASANTA BORO
R/O VILL. SILAKOROIBARI
P.O. CHANGSARI
P.S. KAMALPUR
DIST. KAMRUP (R) ASSAM (APPELLANT NOS. 2 AND 3 BEING MINOR ARE
DULY REPRESENTED BY THEIR MOTHER APPELLANT NO. 1
VERSUS
M/S NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED and 2 ORS
HAVING ITS REGIONAL OFFICE AT BHANGAGARH, GUWAHATI 781005
(INSURER OF VEHICLE NO. AS-01/DC-9740)
2:MBL INFRASTRUCTURE LTD.
DR. R.P. BARUAH ROAD
NEAR DURAG RESIDENCY
LAST GATE
DISPUR
GUWAHATI 7810006
KAMRUP (M)
ASSAM. (OWNER OF VEHICLE NO. AS-01/DC-97040
Page No.# 2/13
3:SRI TUTUMONI GHARPHALIA
S/O SRI TUKESWAR GHARPHALIA
R/O MOUTHONIGAON
P.O. NAHARZAR KHOWANG
PIN 785676
DIST. DIBRUGARH
ASSAM (DRIVER OF THE VEHICLE NO. AS-01/DC-9740
Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr. H Das, MR. P HAZARIKA, MR.P HAZARIKA,MR. T K
MISRA,MR A BARMAN,MR D SAIKIA
Advocate for the Respondent : Mr. R.C Paul, MRS. S ROY (R1),
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR SHARMA
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 05.03.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 13.03.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
: No.
operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been
: Yes
pronounced?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, J)
Heard Mr. P Hazarika, learned counsel for the appellant and Ms. S Roy,
learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 Insurance Company. None appears for
the remaining respondents i.e. the owner and driver of the offending vehicle.
2.
This appeal is directed against the judgment & award dated 06.03.2017
passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No. 1, Kamrup in
MAC Case No. 1747/2011, whereby the claim petition of the present
Page No.# 3/13
appellant was allowed but the Insurance Company was absorbed of the liability,
which was thrust upon the owner of the offending vehicle.
3.
The facts of the case may be briefly stated. On 20.09.2011 the husband
/father of the appellants namely, Prasanta Boro was travelling on a motor cycle
from Sonapur side towards Guwahati along with one Babul Sonowal on the left
side of the road. At the time when they reached Kamarkuchi on National High
Way, suddenly a Tata Dumper Tipper Truck bearing registration No. AS-01-DC9740 coming from the opposite side driven in very high speed in rash and
negligent manner knocked down the deceased. Due to the accident, Prasanta
Boro died on spot. The other rider of the motor cycle namely, Babul Sonowal
died in hospital on the next date. A corresponding case being Sonapur Police
Station Case No. 211/ 2011 was registered under Section 279 / 33 / 304 (A) IPC
against the driver of the Truck and after completion of the investigation police
filed charge sheet against the driver of the Truck.
4.
The appellant herein filed a MAC case being MAC Case No. 1747/2011
under Section 166 of the MV Act, 1988 praying for compensation for death of
their Husband/ father Prasanta Boro. The said case was taken up by the learned
MАСТ No. 1, Kamrup (M).
Another MAC case was filed by the dependants of Babul Sonowal who was cоpassenger of Prasanta Boro. The case said was registered as MAC Case No.
2257 / 2011 and the said case was also taken up by the learned MACT No. 1,
Kamrup (M).
Page No.# 4/13
5.
The insurer of the offending vehicle i.e. Tata Dumper Tipper Truck bearing
registration No. AS-01-DC-9740 i.e. National Insurance Company appeared in
MAC Case No. 1747/2011 and filed written statement. By filing a additional
written statement the insurance company pleaded that the vehicle AS-01-DC9740 was involved in the accident but it was not insured with National Insurance
Company at the relevant time.
6.
The learned Tribunal after closure of evidence in MAC Case No. 1747 /
2011, by Judgment and Award dated 06.03.2017 held that the accident
occurred due to sole negligence of the driver of vehicle No. AS-01-DC-9740
(issue No. 1 and 2 at page 33 of the Memo of Appeal) but the learned Tribunal
held that the said vehicle was not insured with National Insurance Company and
insurance policy mentioned in the claim petition pertains to another vehicle,
therefore, insurance company is not liable to pay the compensation and thereby
fastened the liability upon the owner of the vehicle by awarding Rs. 11,90,000/along with interest @6% from the date of the filing of the claim.
7.
On the other hand the same Insurance company appeared in the other
MAC Case No. 2257/2011 arising out of the same accident by filing written
statement and did not state that the vehicle bearing registration No. AS-01-DC9740 was not insured with National Insurance Company. The insurance
company only took the plea in MAC Case No. 2257 / 2011 to the effect that the
accident took place due to rash and negligent driving of the vehicle No. AS-01DC-9740. The same officer of National had filed the written statement in both
the cases.
Page No.# 5/13
8.
The said learned Tribunal by judgment and award dated 03.06.2016
passed in the other MAC Case No.2257 / 2011 arising out of same accident held
that the offending vehicle No. AS-01-DC-9740 was solely responsible for the
accident and also held that the offending vehicle was insured with National
Insurance Company, hence the insurance company is liable to pay the
compensation at the tune of Rs. 15,17,500/- along with interest @6% from the
date of the filing of the claim. Both the cases were taken up by the same
Tribunal and by the same Presiding Officer.
9.
It is submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that the impugned
Judgment and Award dated 06.03.2017 is vitiated in view of the contradictory
and misleading stand taken by the insurance company and thereby the learned
Tribunal had arrived at an erroneous finding. In paragraphs 4 and 5 of the
Additional Written Statement of the National Insurance Company, it has been
pleaded that the vehicle No. AS-01-DC9740 was involved in the accident but
was not insured with National Insurance Company, which is absolutely
misleading, taking into account the stand taken by the same insurance company
in the other MAC Case No. 2257/2011 arising out of same accident. In the said
case, the same insurance company and the same officer of the insurance
company who filed the written statement had taken a contradictory stand and
did not take the said plea that the said vehicle was not insured with them at the
relevant point of time. It was only pleaded in the said case that accident had
not occurred due to rash and negligence driving of the vehicle No. AS-01-DC9740. It is pertinent to mention that vide Judgment and Award dated
03.06.2016 passed in the other MAC Case No.2257 / 2011, the insurance
company was fastened the liability to pay the award and the insurance company
Page No.# 6/13
did not prefer any appeal against the said Judgment and satisfied the award.
10.
It is further submitted that it is a settled position of law that the litigants
cannot take contradictory stands in the same case. On the same facts a party
cannot be permitted to approbate and reprobate and take inconsistent and
shifting stands. It is further submitted that both the MAC Case No. 1747/ 2011
and MAC case No. 2257 / 2011 were taken up by the same Tribunal
simultaneously and also rendered judgment simultaneously. The same Presiding
Officer had taken up both the cases and both the records were before the said
Presiding Officer. In MAC Case No. 2257/ 2011, Judgment was delivered on
03.06.2016 wherein liability to pay the compensation was cast upon the
Insurance company, whereas, judgment in MAC Case 1747/2011 involving the
present appeal was delivered subsequently i.e. on 06.03.2017. The Presiding
Officer of the Ld. Tribunal overlooked the said fact which renders the impugned
Judgment and Award dated 06.03.2017 as unreasonable and unsustainable in
the eye of law.
11. The second ground of challenge in the present appeal is the compensation
awarded by the learned Tribunal is not "just and reasonable" award. The
deceased was a carpenter and his age was considered above 30 years, i.e. age
group of 31-35 years. The Ld. Tribunal in absence of proof of income had taken
the notional income of Rs.5,000/-per month. The Apex Court held that when no
evidence are available regarding income of a self employed person, taking note
of the nature of employment, the principle of minimum wages fixed under the
Minimum Wages Act can be applied. The deceased was a carpenter and a 'semi
skilled' worker considering his nature of work. At the relevant time, as per
Page No.# 7/13
Notification dated 15.03.2012 of the State of Assam during the years 20112012, the monthly income of 'Semi Skilled" worker was Rs.7,875/-.
12.
According to the appellant, by taking note of the pronouncement of the
Hon'ble Apex Court, the total compensation may be calculated as follows:
The monthly income of Semi-Skilled worker during the year 2011-12
under Minimum Wages Act (Assam) stands at= Rs. 7875.00/- [2022
(6) GLT 811 , paragraph 20]
Accident took place on 20.09.2011 and the deceased was a
carpenter and therefore, by taking the wage of semi-skilled worker
during the period 2011-2012:
Monthly Income of deceased =Rs.7,875.00/- Future prospect @50%
(as the deceased was below 40 years) = Rs.3,937.50/- 5
Total Monthly income = (Rs. 7,875.00 + Rs. 3,937.50) = Rs.
11,812.50
Total Annual Income =Rs. 11, 812.50 x 12 =Rs. 1,41,750.00
After deducting one third of income as personal expenses of the
deceased total Annual Income = Rs. 94,500.00
(As per Sarala Verma's case, the learned Tribunal has taken
multiplier of 16 considered by taking the age group of 31-35 years,
Page No.# 8/13
the age of the deceased was as above 30 years)
Loss of dependency Rs. 94,500 x 16
= Rs. 15,12,000.00
Funeral Expenses
= Rs. 25,000.00
Loss of Estate
= Rs. 5,000.00
Loss of care and guidance for
minor Children
= Rs. 1,00,000.00
Loss of Consortium
= Rs. 1,00,000.00
Total Compensation = Rs. 17,42,000.00 alongwith interest @6%
from the date of filing of the claim petition.
13.
At this stage it is important to revisit the stand taken by the Insurance
Company before the learned Tribunal by way of an additional written statement
therein, which is as follows:
“3.
It is stated that the clalmants in their claim petition mentioned
that the policy No.101800/31/11/6300002124 against the vehicle
bearing registration No. AS01/DC-9740 (Tata Dumper Tipper) issued
by M/s. National Insurance Company Ltd, Kolkotta. But after proper
Page No.# 9/13
verification of the said policy, it was found that the policy
No.101800/31/11/6300002124 was issued against the vehicle
bearing registration No.MP-19-HА-1203 (ТATA TIPPER LPK2518/38)
not the vehicle No. AS-01/DC-9740 (Tata Dumper Tipper). As such
the opposite party No.1 is not liable to pay the compensation to the
claimants under the provisions of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as the
said vehicle was not insured with the opposite party No.1. 4.
4.
After verification of the police report, it was found that the
said Tata Dumper Tipper No.AS-01/DC-9740 was involved with the
accident and a police case was registered against the said vehicle as
Sonapur P.S.Case No.211/11 U/Setion-279/338/304(A) IPC. 5.
5.
As the said Tata Dumper Tipper bearing No. AS-01/DC-9740
involved with the accident was not insured with M/s. National
Insurance Company Ltd, i.e. opposite party No.1 and the said Tata
Dumper Tipper was not covered under the said policy. As such the
opposite party No.1 is not liable to pay the compensation to the
claimants under the provisions of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as the
said vehicle was not insured with the opposite party No.1 and if any
liability arises against the said Tata Dumper Tipper No. AS01/DC9740, the opposite party No.1 is to be exonerated from any
liabilities.”
17. On this aspect of the matter, the learned tribunal found as follows:
Page No.# 10/13
“Sri Tapan Chakraborty, Administrative Officer, is examined as
DW-1. He has stated that they sent mail to the Division Office,
Kolkotta, and the said office sent policy to them. As per policy, the
vehicle no. MP-19-HA-1203 Tata Tipper. In the claim-petition the
vehicle no. is AS-01/DC-9740. As per policy given to them, the
vehicle was not insured with National Insurance Co Ltd. Ex-A is the
insurance policy.
During cross-examination he has admitted that as per the
claim-petition, the policy no. is matching with the policy no. given in
Ex-A. As per seizure list, the engine no. and chasis no. are similar
given in Ex-A. The type of vehicle mentioned in the claimpetition is
Tipper Dumper is same in Ex-A. He has admitted that he has no
knowledge if Kolkatta office made contact with the owner regarding
policy. As per R/C copy, the vehicle no., chasis no. and engine no.
are same mentioned in claim-petition.
So, from the above evidence as well as documentary evidence,
particularly, copy of insurance policy, it is found that the vehicle
bearing no. MP-19/HA-1203 (Tata Tipper LPK2518/38) and not the
vehicle no. AS-01/DC-9740 (Tata Dumper Tipper). Hence, the OP
No. 1 is not liable to pay compensation to the claimants under the
provisions of MV Act, 1988 as the said vehicle was not insured with
the OP No. 1.
From the evidence of DW-1 as well as policy, leaves no room
Page No.# 11/13
for doubt that the company cannot be saddled with any liability to
indemnify the owner of the vehicle. It is the owner who is liable to
pay compensation to the claimant. The issues are accordingly
decided in favour of the claimants."
21. A perusal of Exhibit-3, the seizure list, would show that the engine number
and chassis number mentioned in the said seizure list are the same as the ones
mentioned in Exhibit A, the insurance policy, which pertains however to a
different vehicle number being MP-19-HA-1203. The type of vehicle i.e. tipper
dumper is also the same as mentioned in the seizure list as well as in Exhibit A,
the insurance policy. Therefore, it is quite inexplicable as to why there is a
mismatch between the registration number of the vehicle as mentioned in the
seizure list and in the insurance policy.
22. However, it is pertinent to note that in the seizure list, the insurance policy
number
has
been
mentioned
as
National
Insurance
Policy
No.
101800/1/11/0300002174 (which is different from the Policy Number mentioned
in the claim petition) against vehicle number AS-01-DC-9740, valid up to
30.08.2012. However, this aspect of the matter appears not to have been
noticed by the learned Tribunal. The inquiry by the learned Tribunal ought to
have been directed towards clearing up the aforesaid discrepancies and more
specifically to inquire as to whether the aforesaid policy number was issued by
the National Insurance Company against any vehicle, and if so, the registration
number of the said vehicle.
23. As already noticed above, the policy number mentioned by the claimant in
the claim petition is different from the one mentioned in the seizure list and it is
on that basis that the insurance company denied having issued the said
Page No.# 12/13
insurance policy, as mentioned in the claim petition, against the vehicle bearing
registration number AS-01-DC-9740, which is mentioned in the seizure list as
well as in the claim petition. The fact cannot be lost sight of that the insurance
company in MAC Case No. 2257/2011, arising out of the same accident and
involving the same vehicle, did not deny that the said vehicle AS-01-DC-9740
was covered by a valid insurance policy. Therefore, while making the award in
that case, the learned Tribunal fastened liability upon the insurance company. In
that view of the matter, this is a fit case for remanding the matter back to the
learned Tribunal for making further enquiry in the light of the aforesaid
observations and thereafter to take a fresh decision as to whether the insurance
company would be liable for satisfaction of the award.
25.
In the present case, prayer has also been made for enhancement of the
compensation amount. Since the matter is being remanded back, I would refrain
from undertaking that exercise and leave it to the Tribunal to revisit the said
aspect as well. Needless to say, in the event any party is aggrieved by any order
that may be passed by the learned Tribunal, it would be open for the aggrieved
party to take recourse to law. Accordingly, the impugned judgment & award is
set aside and the matter stands remanded. Send back the TCR.
26.
It is expected that since the matter is long pending, the learned Tribunal
would make an endeavour to dispose of the matter within a short period,
preferably within a period of three months from the date of receipt of the TCR.
27. The appeal stands disposed of accordingly.
JUDGE
Page No.# 13/13
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review