Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA NO.18 OF 2019
1. Smti Amiya Prabha Roy
W/O Late Satya Ranjan Roy,
Daughter-in-law of Late Srish Chandra Roy.
2. Sri Shyamlal Roy,
S/O Late Satya Ranjan Roy,
Grandson of Late Srish Chandra Roy.
Both are residents of 20 Hariganga Basak Road,
P.O. Agartala-799001, P.S. West Agartala, District West Tripura.
……….. Defendant-Appellant(s)
Versus
On the death of Late Monoranjan Roy, his legal heirs and
representatives:1(a) Sri Gobinda Ballab Roy
S/O Late Monoranjan Roy, Resident of Biswanath Apartment,
(First Floor), 1074, Phakir Chand lane, Purba Sinthi Road,
Kolkata-30.
1(b) Sri Partha Roy,
S/O Late Monoranjan Roy,
1(c) Sri Dhiman Roy
S/O Late Monoranjan Roy,
All are residents of Gangail Road, Netaji Chowmuhani, P.O.
Agartala, PIN-799001, P.S. West Agartala, District West Tripura.
1(d) Smti. Gouri Rani Roy,
W/O Late Parimal Saha,
D/O Late Monoranjan Roy,
Resident of B.C. 233, Samar Pally, Kestapara, Kolkata, West
Bengal, Pin-700 102.
……….. Plaintiff-respondent(s)
2. Sri Priya Ranjan Roy
3. On the death of Nityananda Roy, his legal heirs and
representatives:3(a) Sri Tarun Roy
3(b) Sri Jayanta Roy
3(c) Sri Sushanta Roy
4. Sri Pran Krishna Roy
All are sons of Late Srish Chandra Roy,
All are residents of 20 Hariganga Basak Road (Khoshbagan),
P.O. Agartala, PIN- 799001, P.S. West Agartala, District- West
Tripura.
5. Sri Gouranga Chandra Roy
6. Sri Bijoy Krishna Roy
Both are sons of Late Srish Chandra Roy,
Both are residents of 20 Hariganga Basak Road, P.O. Agartala,
Pin-799001, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura.
7. Smti Mira Roy Choudhury
W/O Sri Pramath Mohan Roy Choudhury, D/O. Late Srish
Chandra Roy, Resident of 18/3/10 Kumud Ghoshal Road,
Ariyadasa, Dakshineswar, Kolkata-700057, North 24 Parganas,
West Bengal.
8. Sri Mrinal Kanti Roy
Son of Late Satya Ranjan Roy, grandson of Late Srish Chandra
Roy, Resident of 20 Hariganga Basak Road, P.O. Agartala, PIN799001,
P.S.
West
Agartala,
District
West
Tripura.
……….. Defendant-respondent(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
For appellant(s)
:
Mr. P.K. Dhar, Sr. Advocate
Ms. S. Nag, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. H. Laskar, Advocate
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment & order
:
13.01.2022
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard
Mr.
P.K.
Dhar,
learned
senior
counsel,
assisted by Ms. S. Nag, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants and Mr. H. Laskar, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents.
This is an appeal under Section 97 read with Section
2.
96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 against the final decree
and
order
dated
28.03.2019,
passed
by
learned
Civil
Judge(Senior Division), Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in
Title Suit(Partition) No.112 of 1998.
3.
The present appeal revolves around very short
campus. The respondents No.1(b), 1(c), 1(d) and 2 had
instituted a suit for partition against the defendants being the
plaintiffs. There were as many as nine defendants when the suit
was filed by late Monoranjan Roy, the predecessor of the said
plaintiff-respondents. The present appellants, i.e. Smt. Amiya
Prabha Roy and Sri Shyam Lal Roy were impleaded as
defendants No.7 and 8 in the Title Suit. All the defendants had
received notices issued upon them by the learned Court. Some
of the defendants contested the suit.
4.
Issues were framed and evidences were recorded.
After conclusion of recording evidence, learned trial Court had
heard the arguments of the contesting parties. Thereafter,
judgment was passed and preliminary decree was drawn.
5.
Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf
of the appellants, Amiya Prabha Roy and Shyam Lal Roy(the
original defendants No.7 and 8 respectively in the title suit), at
the very outset, has submitted that the present appellants never
appeared and contested the suit.
Mr. H. Laskar, learned counsel appearing on behalf
of the plaintiff-respondents has submitted that the defendants-
appellant No.7 and 8, i.e. the present appellants were very
much present and contested the suit.
The above submission of Mr. Laskar, learned counsel
leads
me
to
peruse
the
written
statement
filed
by
the
defendants-appellant. It appears that the defendant No.7, Amiya
Prabha Roy, the appellant No.1 and defendant No.8, Shyam Lal
Roy, the appellant No.2, in this appeal, both appeared and
contested the suit by filing written statements and participated
in the further proceeding of the case.
The defendants-respondent No.4, 5, 6, 7 and 8,
6.
namely Sri Pran Krishna Roy, Sri Gouranga Chandra Roy, Sri
Bijoy Krishna Roy, Smt. Mira Roy Choudhury and Sri Mrinal
Kanti
Roy,
had
preferred
appeal
challenging
the
said
preliminary decree dated 03.07.2001. The said first appeal was
registered as RFA No.38 of 2001 before the High Court.
However, the appeal was dismissed vide judgment and order
dated 26.11.2013.
It is specifically submitted by Mr. Dhar,
learned senior counsel that the present appellants did not prefer
any appeal against the preliminary decree.
7.
drawing
Thereafter, the plaintiffs had filed an application for
up
final
decree.
The
Court
appointed
Survey
Commissioner. The Survey Commissioner had submitted report
firstly on 01.03.2019, which was rejected by the Court and
directed to resurvey the decretal land. In pursuance of such
direction, the Survey Commissioner again surveyed the land and
submitted another report on 18.03.2019, which also was
rejected by the Court vide order dated 25.03.2019. While
rejecting the report of the Survey Commissioner under the order
dated 25.03.2019, the learned trial Court had directed the
Survey Commissioner to again resurvey the decretal land
physically and the learned Court had fixed the next date on
28.03.2019. The Survey Commissioner had submitted his report
on 26.03.2019. According to learned senior counsel appearing
on behalf of the appellants, there was no change in the report
dated 18.03.2019 and 26.03.2019, and as such, the said report
was to be treated as perverse. On 28.03.2019, the Court had
accepted the Survey Commissioner’s report dated 26.03.2019,
and accordingly the learned Court had drawn up the final decree
vide order 28.03.2019.
8.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said
order and final decree dated 28.03.2019, the present appellants
who were the original defendant Nos.7 and 8 in the partition suit
have preferred the instant appeal before this Court.
9.
Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel has submitted that
the appellant-defendant Nos.7 and 8 were seriously prejudiced
since the learned Court did not allow any time to them to file
objection. To reinforce his submission, learned senior counsel
has submitted that the learned trial Court ought to have fixed a
date inviting objections from the defendants before drawing the
final decree. As such, the said order dated 28.03.2019 and the
final decree thereof are liable to be set aside and quashed.
10.
I have given my thoughtful consideration to the
submissions of the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of
the appellants. I have also gone through the contents of the
order dated 28.03.2019 passed by the learned trial Court in
TS(P) No.112 of 1998 which is impugned in the Memo of appeal.
It is necessary to reproduce the said order dated 28.03.2019,
for convenience, in extenso:
“Today
is
fixed
for
filing
objection
by
parties against the report of Survey Commissioner, if
any/hearing and order.
Ld.
Advocate
Mr.
H.
Laskar
on
behalf
of
D.
De
on
behalf
of
from
any
of
the
the plaintiff is present.
Ld.
Advocate
Mr.
defendants is also present.
No
objection
filed
parties
in the suit against the report of Survey Commissioner
dated 26-03-2019 nor made any verbal objection by
Ld. Advocates of the plaintiffs and defendants side.
Hence,
it
shall
be
presumed
that
parties
are satisfied with the report of Survey Commissioner
dated 26-03-2019 submitted in the suit.
Perused the record.
After
hearing
learned
advocates
for
the
parties and on perusal of the record and report of the
survey
commissioner
dated
26-03-2019,
it
appears
that , Survey Commissioner namely Sri Mihir Dey went
to the suit land for physical survey and demarcation of
the suit land and took fixed point for measurement
from North- East corner of the suit land, as agreed by
the parties. From the report it again appears that Survey
Commissioner took the help of helper along with him
for physical survey and demarcation of the suit land and
after
completion
book/partition
of
schedule
measurement,
of
the
prepared
field
measurement
of
demarcation by preparing a hand sketch map showing
the number of plots of every party as entitled against
their individual plots. Thereafter, obtained signatures
of the parties of the suit and people present as witness
during the physical survey and demarcation of the suit
land in the separate sheet. Report also reflects that
calculation was also made and verified and thereafter,
prepared hand sketch map of the present position of the
suit land by way of measurement.
The
above
contents
of
physical
survey
and demarcation of suit land report of the Survey
Commissioner in the suit, appears to be properly done
and executed as per preliminary decree and to the
satisfaction of the parties and also as per direction of
the court.
Hence,
the
report
of
Survey
Commissioner dated 26-03-2019 along with a copy of
the share of plots of each individual parties and the
hand
sketch
map
therein,
is
hereby
allowed
and
accepted in the suit and shall form as part of the final
decree.
Sheristadar
therefore,
of
hereby
this
directed
establishment
to
prepare
final
is,
decree
accordingly and place the same before me within 15
days
from
today,
latest
by
13-04-2019.
Thus, the suit is disposed of accordingly.
Make necessary entry in the relevant T.R.”
11.
The
striking
feature
of
the
said
order
dated
28.03.2019 is that neither the plaintiffs nor the defendants had
made any verbal objection to the report of the Survey
Commissioner dated 26.03.2019. Even the present appellants,
i.e. the defendants No.7 and 8 did not make any prayer even
verbally to accommodate them and fix another date for filing
objection. After considering this aspect, the learned trial Court
had reasonably presumed that the parties were satisfied with
the report of the Survey Commissioner dated 26.03.2019. In
view of the aforesaid fact, I do not find any merit in the
submission of learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellants that the defendants No.7 and 8 who are the
appellants of the present appeal had not been given any
opportunity to raise their objection against the report of the
Survey Commissioner. Accordingly, this submission of learned
senior counsel is repelled.
12.
Now, dealing with the submission of learned senior
counsel that the report of the Survey Commissioner dated
26.03.2019 had suffered from serious infirmity as there was no
change surfaced in the said report, if the said report is read with
the report dated 18.03.2019. Again, I cannot accept this
submission of learned senior counsel on the ground that though
the defendants were represented through their learned counsels
they did not raise any objection nor made any submission asking
for some accommodation to raise their objection. Furthermore,
from the order dated 20.03.2019 it is emanated that the learned
trial Court had gone through the reports and found the contents
of physical survey and demarcation of the suit land and report of
the Survey Commissioner are properly done and executed as per
preliminary decree and to the satisfaction of the parties and also
as per direction of the Court.
13.
In view of this, I find no merit in the present appeal,
and accordingly, the same stands dismissed.
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review