Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
SIDDHANT
TAMRAKAR
SIDDHANT
TAMRAKAR
Date: 2026.07.30
14:41:37 +0530
CGHC010411782022
2026:CGHC:32698
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 9192 of 2022
• Smt. Vimala Bai Sori W/o Late Ganesh Ram Sori Aged About 58 Years R/o
Village And Post Dumali, District - Uttar Bastar Kanker Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner
versus
1. State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Water Resources Department,
Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur, District Raipur
Chhattiagarh
2. State Of Madhya Pradesh Through The Secretary, Water Resources Department ,
Mantralaya Vallabh Bhawan Bhopal Madhya Pradesh
3. Engineer In Chief Water Resources Department Mahanadi Godawari Kachhar,
Raipur, Distrcit Raipur Chhattisgarh
4. Chief Engineer Water Resources Department Mahanadi Godawari Kachhar,
Raipur, District Raipur Chhattisgarh
5. Executive Engineer Water Resources Department Division Kanker District Uttar
Bastar Kanker Chhattisgarh
6. Joint Director Treasury, Accounts And Pension, Department, Jagadalpur District,
Baster Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner
For State
:
Mr. Swapnil Keshari, Advocate holding the
brief of Mr. Hemant Kesharwani, Advocate
: Mr. Vivek Siddharth Ojha, Panel Lawyer
Hon'ble Shri Justice Rakesh Mohan Pandey
Order on Board
29.08.2025
1) The petitioner, widow of Late Shri Ganesh Ram Sori, has approached this Court
-2-
seeking the grant of family pension.
2) Brief facts of the present case are that the husband of the petitioner was appointed
as a Jeep Driver under respondent No. 5 as daily wage employee in the year 1977.
He was regularized in the Work-Charged and Contingency Paid Establishment on
03.03.1988 and unfortunately passed away on 26.03.1996. After his death, the
petitioner applied for the family pension and made a representation before the
respondent authorities, but till date no action has been taken.
3) Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the deceased was initially
appointed as a daily-rated employee in the year 1977, and his services were
regularized on 03.03.1988, therefore, the services of the husband of the petitioner
ought to have been considered while computing the qualifying service for
pension. It is further contended that on the date of the death, the deceased had
already completed more than 8 years of regular service and, therefore, the
petitioner is entitled to the family pension. He would pray to allow this petition.
He has placed reliance on the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the matters of S.D. Jayaprakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. (Civil Appeal
Nos. 5671-5672 of 2025, decided on 29.04.2025, MANU/SC/0589/2025) and
State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors. v. Sheela Devi (MANU/SCOR/113671/2023).
He further placed reliance on the decision of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh
rendered in Smt. Kusum Chourasia v. State of M.P. & Ors. (W.P. No. 2796/2023,
decided on 18.11.2024), wherein a similar issue was considered.
4) On the other hand, learned counsel for the State would submit that, as per Rule 4A
of the Chhattisgarh Work-Charged and Contingency Paid Employees Pension
Rules, 1979, the husband of the petitioner had not completed the qualifying
-3-
service; therefore, the claim of family pension has not been considered by the
department.
5) Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents placed in the file.
6) The facts of the case are not in dispute.
7) The Hon’ble Supreme Court in S.D. Jayaprakash (supra), after considering
Sheela Devi (supra), held that though Rule 2(g) of the Pension Rules excludes
contractual employees, Rule 17 expressly provides that upon regularization, the
past service rendered as a contractual employee is to be counted for pensionary
benefits. The Hon’ble Supreme Court further clarified that such employees must
be given the option either to retain the government’s contribution towards CPF or
to refund/forgo the same in order to have their past service counted. The relevant
para-8 & 9 are reproduced as under:“8. This rule fell for consideration and interpretation in Sheela
Devi (supra), where this Court held that although Rule 2(g) of
the Pension Rules excludes contractual employees from their
application, Rule 17 applies once such contractual employee is
regularised on a later date. The effect is that upon
regularisation, the Pension Rules become applicable and Rule
17 requires that past service as a contractual employee is to be
taken into account for calculating pension. 6 In this light, and
considering that Rule 17 requires the regularised employee to
exercise an option to either retain the Government’s
contribution to Contributory Provident Fund, or to refund such
amount or forgo the same if they have not been paid in lieu of
counting the service period for which such benefits may have
been payable, this Court in Sheela Devi (supra) issued the
following directions:
“11. In view of the above reasoning, this court is of
the opinion that there is no merit in the appeal
however, the following directions are issued:(i) The state shall take immediate steps to indicate
-4-
the mode and manner of exercising option by all
the employees concerned (who had been
regularized after spells of contractual employment)
regardless of the dates on which they were
engaged i.e. prior to the year 2003 or
subsequently, within a time frame, of within eight
weeks from today.
(ii) After receiving the options within the time
indicated in the notice, the concerned employee(s)
who exercise the relevant options should be
notified about the amounts they would have to
remit in case any amount towards contribution is
required, clearly.
(iii) The options should be processed and
completed within eight weeks from the last date of
receiving options.
(iv) Time limit for payment too should be indicated
and entire process should be completed within four
months and all orders fixing pensions or family
pension as the case may be, shall be issued.”
9. In light of the clear language of Rule 17 of the
Pension Rules as well as its interpretation in
Sheela Devi (supra), the contractual service period
rendered prior to the appellants’ regularisation in
2015 must be counted towards the payment of their
pensionary benefits in accordance with the
mechanism set out in Rule 17. In line with the
directions issued in Sheela Devi (supra) extracted
hereinabove, we direct the respondent Union of
India to take immediate steps and indicate the
mode and manner for the appellants to exercise the
option provided under Rule 17 of the Pension
Rules as well as to notify the amounts that the
appellants would have to remit in case they opt for
grant of pension under the Rules.
8) In Sheela Devi (supra), the Court emphasized that exclusion under Rule 2(g)
cannot nullify the substantive provision of Rule 17, which specifically caters to
situations where contractual employees are subsequently regularized. The relevant
para-9 is reproduced as under:-
-5-
“9. The Learned Advocate General is correct in his
interpretation, inasmuch as a facial reading of Rule 2(g) would
indicate that contractual employees are excluded from the pale
of Pension Rules. However, what is significant is that the rule
itself in its opening terms saves the application of other
provisions of the pension rules: “Save as otherwise provided in
these rules”. If the opening phrase of Rule 2 were to be
understood in this context, any interpretation of Rule 17 as is
urged by the State would render such substantive provision
redundant. Rule 17 was engrafted essentially to cater to the
eventuality, where the employees working on contract basis
were regularized at a later stage. It is only for the purposes of
pension that the past service as a contractual employee is to be
taken into account.”
9) Similarly, the Madhya Pradesh High Court in the matter of Smt. Kusum
Chourasia (supra) dealt with identical circumstances. In this case, the Court held
that once an employee has been brought into the regular Work-Charged
Establishment, even if he dies without completing 10 or 15 years of qualifying
service, his family is still entitled to the family pension under Rule 4A of the Rules
of 1979, read with Rule 47 of the M.P. Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976. It was
held that the object of Rule 4A is to protect the family of a deceased employee who
dies in harness, and therefore, even one day’s service after regularization is
sufficient to extend the benefit of family pension. The relevant para-5 is
reproduced as under:"5. The petitioner is wife of late Shri Anandilal Rajak
whowas working in the respondents department. Late Shri
Anandilal Rajak was initially appointed as a daily wages
employee on 1.3.1978. He was posted as Chowkidar and
subsequently he was regularized on the work charged and
contingency paid employee in the establishment on
10.6.1996/18.6.1996 vide Annexures P/2 and P/3
respectively. After working for a period about 9 years work
charged and in contingency paid establishment the
petitioner's husband late Shri Anandilal Rajak died on
20.02.2005. After his death the petitioner claimed pension
and other benefits in accordance to the Madhya Pradesh
-6-
Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 and the Madhya
Pradesh (Worked charged and Contingency Paid
Employees) Pension Rules, 1979. The claim of the
petitioner for grant of family pension and other benefits
have been rejected only on the ground that the petitioner's
husband has not completed 10 years regular services in
the work charged and contingency paid establishment and
therefore pension can not be granted vide impugned order
Annexure P/8 dated 7.2.2007. The question with regard to
period of service to be rendered in the work charged and
Contingency Paid Establishment for grant of pension has
been considered by this Court in Bal Kishan Patel v. State
of MP and others (WP No.4357/2004) and after taking
note the requirement of the provisions contained in
Madhya Pradesh (Worked charged and Contingency Paid
Employees) Pension Rules, 1979 and the Provisionary
Rule 2(c) and Rule 4 A of the said Rules the matter is so
decided.
"14. It is apparent that for the purpose of family pension
Rule 4-A of the Pension Rules of 1979 read with Rule 47 of
the Rules of 1976 makes it clear that if an Incumbent has
rendered not less than 7 years continuous service, family of
incumbent is entitled for the family pension. It is not in
dispute that deceased Jabmohan Singh Gond had rendered
the contentious service for more than 7 years. Rule 6 (3) of
the Pension Rules of 1979 clearly provides that without
interruption for not less than 6 years such services shall be
counted for pension as if such services has rendered on
regular post, qualifying service has to be given effect to
while considering the length of the service, as specified in
Rule 2 (c) of the Rules of 1979 otherwise the purpose of
fiction created of Rule (3) stands defeated. Thus the
submission raised by the respondents that Rule 6(3),
services cannot to be computed towards qualifying service,
cannot accepted. The services which has beem rendered,
as qualifying service, under Rule of the Pension Rules of
1979 has to be counted, as rendered on a regular post.
Thereafter entitlement has to be determined by the
respondents in accordance with law."
In the case at hand the petitioner's husband was engaged
on daily wage basis in the Work-charged Establishment of
Rani Avantibai Sagar Project. Thereafter, by order dated
26.06.1996 was bought on regular Work Charged
Establishment in grade 825-900-20-1220 as Time Keeper.
The late husband of the petitioner while in service expired
on 12.2.2001. The petitioner after death of her husband
approached the authorities for grant of family pension.
-7-
The said request was turned down by letter dated
13.09.2006 on the ground that petitioner's husband since
has not rendered 10 years of service in the Work-charged
establishment she was not entitled for the family pension.
It is this denial which has forced the petitioner to prefer
the instant-writ petition.
A "Work-charged employee" is defined under Rule 2 (b) to
mean 'a person employed upon the actual execution, as
distinct from general supervision of a specified work or
upon subordinate supervision of the departmental labour,
store, running and repairs of electrical equipment and
machinery in connection with such work, excluding the
daily paid labour and muster- roll employee employed on
the work.' Whereas, "permanent employee as defined
under clause (c) of Rule 2 of Rules 1979 means "a
contingency paid employee or a work-charged employee
has completed fifteen years of service or more on or after
the 1st January, 1974:
Provided that in respect of a contingency paid employee or
a work charged employee who has attained the age of
superannuation on or after the First April 1981,
permanent employee means an employee who has
completed 10 years of service on or after 1st January,
1974.
Rule 4A which was inserted vide notification dated
13.9.1982, pub. in M.P. Rajpatra. Pt. IV (ga), dated
26.12.1982, page 133; stipulates:
"4A. Notwithstanding anything contained in Rule 4 the
family of a permanent employee who dies while in service
or after retirement on pension on or after the 1st April,
1981 shall be entitled to family pension at the rate of 30%
of his/her pay drawn at the time of death/retirement subject
to minimum of Rs.40/- per month and maximum of Rs.
100/- per month subject to other conditions of rule 47 of
the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976
except sub-rule (3) of the said rule.
Admittedly the aforesaid provisions have an overriding
effect over Rule 4 wherein the stipulations have been laid
down as to the minimum qualifying service which a person
engaged on work-charged establishment should have at his
credit, i.e., 10 years, before he is held entitled for grant of
pension on his retirement. In other words the bar as
created under Rule 4, in the considered opinion of this
Court will not be attracted in case a member of a regular
-8-
Work- chared establishment dies in harness; meaning
thereby that even a day's service rendered by a workman
brought on regular work-charged establishment in case if
he dies thereafter would entitle the family of such workman
for a family pension as per stipulations contained in
Section 4A. The only guiding factor while applying Rule
4A. of Rules of 1979 would be the conditions stipulated in
Rule 47 of M.P. Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1979 Subrule (2) of Rule 47 of the Rules, 1976 stipulates;
"(2) Without prejudice to the provisions contained in subrule (3), where a Government servant dies(a) While in service provided he had been medically
examined and found fit for appointment under the
Government.
(b) after retirement from service and was on the date of
death in receipt of a pension or compassionate allowance,
referred to in Chapter V on the date of death, the family of
the deceased shall be entitled to contributory family
pension (hereinafter in this role referred to as Family
Pension) the amount of which shall be determined as
follows:
Pay servant of Amount of month family Government
servant pension (i) Below Rs.400 30 per cent of pay
subject to a minimum of Rs.60 and maximum of Rs.100.
(ii) Rs.400 and 15 per cent of pay subject to above but not
a minimum of Rs.100 and exceeding Rs. 1200. maximum of
Rs. 160.
(iii) Above
Rs. 12 per cent of pay subject to
1200/- a minimum of Rs.160 and maximum of Rs.250.
In the present case also the claim of the petitioner was
rejected only on the ground that the petitioner's husband
has not completed 10 years regular service in work
charged and contingency paid Establishment. This could
not be done. The petitioner is entitled to get pension in the
head indicated in the aforesaid table even if he has not
completed 10 years service. In this view of the matter
rejection of petitioner's claim by the impugned order is
unsustainable Accordingly the order Annexure P/8 dated
7.2.2007 is quashed, the respondents are directed to fix
family pension of the petitioner within a period of 60 days
and pay all arrears to the petitioner alongwith interest at
the rate 6% per annum from the date of entitlement till
-9-
payment.
The petition stands allowed and is disposed of with the
aforesaid."
10) In view of the discussion and proposition of law rendered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the matters of S.D. Jayaprakash (supra) and Sheela Devi
(supra), as well as the consistent view taken by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in
the matter of Kusum Chourasia (supra). The writ petition is hereby allowed.
11) Respondent No. 3 is directed to grant family pension to the petitioner with effect
from the date of death of her husband i.e. 26.03.1996. The entire exercise shall be
completed within a period of two months from today.
Sd/(Rakesh Mohan Pandey)
Judge
$iddhant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review