Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 19th January, 2026
Pronounced on: 10th March, 2026
RSA 11/2026, CM APPL. 3654/2026 (delay)
+
SMT. VEERWATI
Wife of Late Sh. Rajbir Singh,
R/o 25, Jyoti Apartments, Parvana Road,
Pitampura, Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Counsel for Appellant (appearance
not given).
versus
1.
UNION OF INDIA
Through - Land Acquisition Collector,
Patel Nagar, Raja Garden, New Delhi.
2.
HON'BLE LT. GOVERNOR
Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Raj Niwas, Delhi.
3.
SLUM & JJ DEPARTMENT
Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board,
Rehabilitation Centre,
Indraprastha Estate, New Delhi.
4.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI
Through its Commissioner,
Dr. S. P. Marg, Civic Centre,
Minto Road, Delhi.
5.
THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
Tata Power Delhi Distribution Limited,
Cencare Building, Opposite C-2 Block,
Keshav Puram, Delhi.
6.
THE DEPUTY SECRETARY (L.A.)
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
Land & Building Department,
Vikas Bhawan, I.P. Estate, New Delhi.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Sanjay Kumar Pathak, Standing
Counsel with Ms. K. Kaomudi Kiran,
Mr. Sunil Kumar Jha & Ms. Joohu
Kumari, Advs. for R-1, R-2 & R-6.
Mr. Anuj Chaturvedi, Ms. Richa
Dhawan, Ms. Yashita Jain, Advocates
for R-3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Second Regular Appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure 1908 (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’) has been filed on behalf
of the Appellant against the Order dated 04.08.2025 of the Ld. District
Judge-06, New Delhi in RCA DJ 48/2025, whereby the Order of Rejection
of Civil Suit filed by the Plaintiff/Appellant for Declaration, Mandatory
Injunction, Possession, Damages, mesne Profits, for use & occupation, and
Permanent Injunction against Union of India and MCD., under Order VII
Rule 11 of CPC by learned Civil Judge vide Order dated 22.03.2025, has
been upheld.
2.
The facts in brief are that the Plaintiff claimed that she is recorded
lawful owner of land falling in Khasra No.380/44, total area measuring 01
Bigha 10 Biswas and other land, situated in the Revenue Estate of Village
Shadi Pur, Delhi, now known as Abadi of Ranjit Nagar, Gali No.10, New
Delhi. According to the Plaintiff, this land was neither acquired by the
Government/Defendant No.1 for Public purpose by any Notification, nor
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
was it ever sold by the Plaintiff or her predecessor, at any point of time.
Moreover, no compensation was ever paid to the Plaintiff or her father or
fore-fathers in respect of this Suit land. Revenue Record reveal that the said
land still stands in the name of the Plaintiff.
3.
Plaintiff further asserted that land measuring about 250 sq. yards, is
located near the boundary wall of the Pusa Institute, which has been
encroachedby Defendant Nos.4 and 5 (MCD). Defendant No.4 has
constructed Sulabh Shauchaalya and also a Room thereon. Defendant No.5
has also installed an electricity Transformer.
4.
Plaintiff claimed that consequent to aforesaid encroachment, an entry
in the Revenue Record has been made regarding the possession of the
aforesaid land to the extent of 05 biswas (i.e. 250 sq. yards)in the name of
the Municipal Corporation of Delhi, whereas in the column of ownership,
the name of the Plaintiff has been mentioned in respect of the aforesaid suit
land. Remaining land pertaining to the aforesaid Khasra, is in exclusive
possession of the Plaintiff.
5.
Plaintiff has further explained that this land of Khasra No.380/44,
Village Chandipur was owned by her father Late Sh. Sehju Ram, who also
owned lands in Khasra Nos.49, 55, 61, 62, 73/1 and 384/80 within the
Revenue Estate of Village Shadi Pur, Delhi. The names of forefathers of the
Plaintiff including the Plaintiff’s father, were duly recorded in the Revenue
Record of Village Shadi Pur, Delhi. After demise of her father, on
15.03.1976, his wife Smt. Bakhtawari Devi and Plaintiff, the daughter,
were the only Legal Hirs her name and and their names were mutated in the
Revenue Records. Smt. Bakhtawari Devi also expired intestate on
02.12.2001. Plaintiff is thus only successor / representative of her father and
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
mother and she is absolute owner of the Suit Property by operation of law
and her name was duly mutated in the Revenue Record.
6.
Notification No.F.15(111)/59-L&B dated 13.11.1959 was issued
under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act for acquisition of the land of
Village Shadi Pur, Delhi. Certain Khasras so owned by the father of the
Plaintiff, were acquired vide Award No.1714dated 28.07.1964 of Village
Shadi Pur, Delhi and the possession of Khasra No.380/44 was also taken
over at the relevant time, but Khasra No.380/44, so owned by the father of
the Plaintiff, wasneither mentioned in the said Notification nor in the Award
of the Village Shadi Pur, Delhi. Consequently, no compensation was ever
paid to the father of the plaintiff in respect of Khasra No.380/44.
7.
Earlier the aforesaid area of Village Shadipur and RanjitNagar were
declared as Slum Area vide Notification dated05.06.1963, but it was denotified vide Notification dated 02.04.1987. During that period, the Slum
Department had takenover the possession of the aforesaid land, for
development. Areas of Village Shadipur and Ranjit Nagar, Delhi were
urbanized before the Delhi Land Reform Act was enforced in Delhi and the
provisions of this Act, never became applicable to the land of Village
Shadipur and Ranjit Nagar and they continued to be governed by the Punjab
Land Revenue Act.
8.
In order to ascertain the boundaries of Khasra No.380/44, Village
Shadi Pur, Delhi, Plaintiff moved an Application for demarcation of the
boundaries of the aforesaid Khasra, in the Revenue Department. In response
to that Application, Revenue Department carried out demarcation by TSM
method on 25.02.2011, through their officials.
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
9.
The Plaintiff claimed that Defendant Nos.3 to 5 have encroached
upon the Suit Property and illegally raised construction on the same. A
Legal Notice dated 13.10.2020, was sent to Defendant No.5 through the
Counsel, on account of which, the Department dropped the plan of
installation of second Transformer in the Suit Property.
10.
Thereafter, Plaintiff moved an RTI Application dated 25.08.2017 to
the concerned Authority, to know whether the aforesaid Khasra No.380/44
of Village Shadi Pur, Delhi was ever acquired for public purpose and
whether its possession was ever handed over after acquisition, to some
Government Agency / Department, such as Slum, MCD or Electricity Board
or to the other Departments.
11.
In Reply to the RTI, vide Letter dated 18.09.2017, it was disclosed
that there was no acquisition of the aforesaid Khasra No.380/44of Village
Shadipur, Delhi by the Union of India / LAC, i.e. Defendant No.1. Since the
land was never acquired, there was no question of its possession being
handed over to Defendants Nos.3 to 6, by Defendant No.1.
12.
The Plaintiff claimed that the possession of Electricity Department
and MCD, is illegal and they are liable to handover the vacant and physical
peaceful possession of the Suit Property to the Plaintiff, after removal of the
structure so raised by them on the aforesaid land.
13.
Without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the Plaintiff, if the
Suit Property is still required by the Defendants, they may acquire the same
as per law, by issuing appropriate Notification for acquisition and pay the
compensation at the market value, to the Plaintiff.
14.
It was further claimed that since Defendant Nos.3 to 5 were in
unauthorized occupation of the Suit Property, which is causing loss to the
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
Plaintiff to the tune of Rs.1,00,000/-per month, which is the prevailing
market rate of rent for the entire Suit Property, Damages @ Rs.1,00,000/per month for the last three years, be granted till vacant possession is
handed over to the Plaintiff along with the interest. Plaintiff has, thus sought
the following reliefs:
I.
Declaration that Khasra No.380/44 of Village Shadipur, Delhi has
never been acquired by the Union of India / Government;
II. Mandatory Injunction directing the Defendants, their officials,
employs, representatives, attorneys etc. or any other person acting on
their behalf to vacate and deliver the vacant and peaceful physical
possession of the Suit Property, i.e. land admeasuring 250 sq. yard
comprised in Khasra No.380/44 of Village Shadipur, Delhi;
III. Mandatory Injunction to direct the Defendant to issue Notification
for the acquisition of the aforesaid land and to made a Award for the
acquisition of the aforesaid land in favour of the Plaintiff;
IV. Decree of Damages/mesne profits @ Rs.8,000/- per month, even
though the prevalent market rent of rent is about Rs.1,00,000/- per
month from 01.10.2021 to 31.09.2024with interest till its realization;
and
V. Permanent Injunction restraining the Defendants, their officials,
employs, representatives, attorneys etc. or any other person acting on
their behalf from creating any third party interest in the Suit
Property.
15.
Learned Civil Judge considered the averments made in the Plaint
and exercised its jurisdiction under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC, to reject the
Plaint. It was noted that according to the Plaintiff, possession of the Suit
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
land was taken by Defendant Nos.3 to 5 at the time of passing of acquisition
Award No.1714 dated 27.07.1964. Therefore, Plaintiff’s claim seeking
possession of Suit Land, is patently barred by limitation. It was further
observed that there cannot be any Declaration in negative that the land was
never acquired by the Defendants.
16.
Moreover, Suit was barred under Section 80CPC and Sections
477/478 of Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957, for not giving the
mandatory Notice to the Department, before filing the present Suit.
17.
Plaintiff preferred RCA DJ No. 48/2025, whereby the learned
District Judge, after appreciation of the Order, concurred with the
observations of the learned Civil Judge and upheld the Order of rejection
of the Plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC.
18.
Aggrieved by the said Judgment, present Appeal has been preferred,
wherein the questions of law and grounds to challenge the Order have
been raised to claim that the Plaintiff’s Suit could not have been rejected
without giving the Notice to the Defendants under Order V CPC.
19.
The sole ground of limitation, on which the Suit has been rejected, is a
mixed question of law and facts and requires full fledged trial of the case, to
adjudicate the controversies raised in the Plaint. The issue of limitation has
not been appreciated correctly and the Plaint is liable to be remanded, for
adjudication on merits.
20.
The Service of Notices under Section 80 of CPC and Sections
477/478 of Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957, was not mandatory,
especially when a Notice, even though without mentioning the provisions of
law, was served.
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
21.
Reliance is placed on Sukh Dutt Ratra &Anr. vs. State of Himachal
Pradesh & Others, Civil Appeal No.2773/2022.
22.
Therefore, it is submitted that the Order dated 04.08.2025 of learned
District Judge, be set aside.
Submissions heard and record perused.
23.
It is the case of the Plaintiff herself that the possession of the Suit
Land, admeasuring 250 sq. yard comprised in Khasra No.380/44 of Village
Shadi Pur, Delhi had been taken by the Defendants at the time of passing of
Acquisition Award No.1714 on 27.07.1964. Plaintiff may have been the
recorded owner of Khasra No.380/44, but as per her own submissions, the
possession was taken away way back in the year 1964 and therefore, learned
Civil Judge as well as District Judge were right in observing that the Suit
was patently barred by limitation.
24.
Therefore, the Plaintiff’s Suit dated 07.10.2024, i.e. after about 60
years, seeking Declaration and Mandatory Injunction, is patently barred by
limitation.
25.
Plaintiff / Appellant has vehemently contended that her name has
been continued to be reflected in the Revenue Record. However, she may be
the Owner, but the possession, which was admittedly taken away in the year
1964, could have been retrieved by her by filing Suit for Possession, only
within 30 years under Article 112 of the Limitation Act, 1963. Therefore,
her ownership, cannot save her from limitation period, which bars her right
to claim the possession.
26.
It is also pertinent in this context, to observe that the Plaintiff /
Appellant herself had moved an Application for getting the boundaries of
Khasra No.380/44 demarcated, but she has failed to disclose the
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
Demarcation Report. Therefore, she has not even been able to show that the
Suit Land was ever part of Khasra No.380/44, of which she claims to be the
owner.
27.
Plaintiff further claimed that she had no objection if the Suit Land is
acquired by the Defendants. However, it has been rightly observed by the ld.
District Judge that it is not for the Plaintiff to direct the Government to
acquire any particular property. It is a matter of Public Policy and no
direction can be given to the Government, to acquire any particular property.
28.
Moreover, Civil Suit can only be filed to enforce existing Civil and
Legal Rights and cannot be filed seeking directions to create new Rights or
for compelling Legislative / Statutory action. Moreover, such negative
Declaration to the effect that Suit Land had not been acquired by the
Defendants, was not maintainable under the law.
29.
There is no substantial question of law raised, nor is there any merit in
the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed.
30.
Pending Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MARCH 10, 2026/R
KUMAR BHATT
16:30:06
RSA 11/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review