Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:THC:715
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.18 of 2025
1. Smt. Tulsi Roy (Sarkar), D/O. Late Lal Mohan Roy, W/O. Sri Thakur
Charan Sarkar, Resident of Nischintapur, Ishanchandra Nagar, P.O.
Ishanchandra Nagar, P.S.-Amtali, District-West Tripura.
2. Smt. Manju Rani Roy (Majumder), D/O. Late Lal Mohan Roy, W/O. Sri
Krishnadhan Majumder, Resident of Kuripukur, P.O.-Amtali, P.S.-Amtali,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799130.
3. Sri Dulal Roy, S/O. Late Lalmohan Roy, Resident of Madhupur, P.O.Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, District-West Tripura, Pin-799130.
……… Appellant(s).
VERSUS
1. Sri Gouranga Chandra Roy, S/O. Sri Monmohan Roy, resident of
Madhupur, P.O.-Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, District-West Tripura, Pin-799130.
2. Sri Ranjit Chandra Roy, S/O. Sri Akhil Chandra Roy, resident of Ballavpur,
P.O.-Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, District-West Tripura, Pin-799130.
3. Sri Pradip Sarkar, S/O. Late Harendra Chandra Sarkar, resident of
Nischintapur, P.O.-Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, District-West Tripura.
4. Sri Nanda Lal Sarkar, S/O. Late Harendra Chandra Sarkar, resident of
Nischintapur, P.O.-Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, District-West Tripura.
5. (a) Smt. Mithu Sarkar, W/O. Late Dulal Sarkar,
(b) Sri Bijen Sarkar, S/O. Late Dulal Sarkar,
(c) Sri Papai Sarkar, S/O. Late Dulal Sarkar.
All are residents of Nischintapur, P.O.-Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, District-West
Tripura.
6. Sri Jyoti Lal Sarkar, S/O. Late Harendra Chandra Sarkar, resident of
Nischintapur, P.O.-Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, District-West Tripura.
……… Respondent(s).
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Agniva Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Dhruba Jyoti Saha, Advocate,
Mr. Samrat Sarkar, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
CAV reserved on
: 08.05.2026.
Judgment delivered on
: 25.05.2026.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
2026:THC:715
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. Agniva Chakraborty, counsel appearing for the appellants and Mr.
Dhruba Jyoti Saha, counsel appearing for the respondents.
2.
This RSA is filed under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure (CPC, for short) by the unsuccessful defendants challenging the
judgment dt.25.03.2025 of the Additional District Judge, Court No.2, West
Tripura, Agartala in Title Appeal No.25 of 2024 confirming the orders
dt.02.12.2024 and 11.12.2024 of the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.1,
Agartala, West Tripura in T.S.(P) No.66 of 1977.
3.
The respondent No.1/plaintiff had filed the said suit seeking a
preliminary decree for partition of the 'A' Schedule property by dividing the
same and allotting to him 8 annas share, for passing of a final decree of
partition of the said property by appointing a Survey Commissioner and for
recovery of possession of the said portion of the property. The plaint 'A'
Schedule consisted of 3(three) items - (i) land measuring 1.44 acres, (ii) land
measuring 0.19 acres, and (iii) land measuring 0.91 acres.
4.
In the said suit, he contended that the property was owned by one
Tripura Sundari Kapali, mother of the grandfather of the plaintiff and
defendants No.2 to 4 and by Banamali Roy and others, the grandfather of the
plaintiff.
5.
The plaintiff contended that Banamali Roy and his two brothers
Ramesh Roy and Mahesh Roy partitioned the same, that Mahesh Roy, who is
the grandfather of the plaintiff and defendants No.2 to 4 and father-in-law of
2026:THC:715
defendant No.1 got towards his share, the 'A' Schedule property; after his
death his two sons Man Mohan Roy and Lal Mohan Roy (since deceased)
inherited the property; on 09.01.1960 Man Mohan Roy and Lal Mohan Roy
repurchased certain land which was also included in the 'A' Schedule property;
and the father of the plaintiff gifted his 8(eight) annas share in the 'A'
Schedule by a document dt.06.02.1976 in favour of the plaintiff.
6.
He contended that he is the joint owner of the said properties
along with the defendants.
7.
According to him, in the pre-settlement operation, the land in
question was wrongly recorded in the name of only Lal Mohan Roy, the
predecessor-in-interest of the defendants; this was questioned by the plaintiff
by filing a petition under Section 95 of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land
Reforms Act, 1960 on 13.04.1976 and that the same is still pending. He also
contended that after the death of Lal Mohan Roy, the uncle of the plaintiff, the
plaintiff maintained a joint kitchen with the defendants for some time, but
later there were separate kitchens.
8.
According to the plaintiff, the defendants took advantage of the
wrong and erroneous preparation of the record of rights and are now trying to
claim the entire property and do not wish to partition the same and so he had
to file the suit.
9.
The defendants No.1 and 5 filed separate written statements, but
the other defendants were set ex parte.
10.
The defendant No.1 contended that the plaintiff and his father
Man Mohan Roy were not co-sharers in the suit properties and he had no
right, title, interest or possession and so the suit should be dismissed. They
2026:THC:715
denied that the land was ever owned by Tripura Sundari Kapali, Banamali
Roy and others and stated that there was no partition between Ramesh Roy,
Mahesh Roy and Banamali Roy. They also denied that Mahesh Roy got any
share in the 'A' Schedule property and pleaded that after his death, even the
plaintiff has no share therein. They denied the repurchase under the Sale Deed
dt.09.01.1960. They contended that their father was the absolute owner in
exclusive possession of the suit 'A' Schedule property and after his death, they
became full owners thereof, and the plaintiff or his father had no possession of
the suit Schedule properties.
11.
They also contended that the suit schedule properties were the
self acquired properties of their father Lal Mohan Roy, that he had acquired
the same with his own money and on his death, the defendants succeeded to
the property.
12.
Defendant No.5 filed a written statement supporting defendant
No.1.
13.
Before the trial Court, the plaintiff examined 7(seven) witnesses
and marked exhibits 1 to 9.
14.
Defendant No.1 got examined as DW-1 and marked as Exhibits-
A to C.
15.
After contest, preliminary decree was passed on 14.06.1993 in
the suit declaring that the plaintiff was having 50% share of the 'A' Schedule
property and that the plaintiff is also entitled to have a final decree for
partition of his share of 50% therein by metes and bounds by way of
appointing a Survey Commissioner.
16.
2026:THC:715
The same was also affirmed in T.A. No.51 of 1993 by judgment
dt.02.01.1997 and by this Court on 25.04.2019 in RSA No.10 of 2018.
17.
Thus the preliminary decree attained finality.
18.
Thereafter, the Survey Commissioner appointed in the final
decree proceedings, submitted his report on 06.07.2021 stating that he could
not demarcate the land because he was not able to locate it. According to him,
as per the decree, the land was supposed to be 77 gandas, but the defendants
had sold out the lands to different persons and Khatians had also been
prepared in their names.
19.
The trial Court asked him to again carry out survey work and he
submitted a report on 23.11.2021 and he held that the total decretal land was
127 gandas, in which 8 gandas were forcibly occupied and 78 gandas were
sold out by the defendants. He found only 41 gandas of land and in terms of
the preliminary decree he held that the plaintiff was entitled to the entire 41
gandas, though he is entitled to 63 gandas towards his half share.
20.
The trial Court, therefore, accepted the said report and passed
final decree on 21.12.2021 holding that it cannot adjudicate any claim of
forceful possession of the suit premises; and since the plaintiff has no
objection against the report of the Survey Commissioner, same was accepted
by granting liberty to both parties to institute further litigation regarding the
land which was forcefully occupied, or regarding the share of the defendants.
21.
This was challenged in T.A. No.03 of 2022 by the defendants
before the Additional District Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala. The
said T.A was allowed on 9.1.2024, the judgment of trial court /the final decree
2026:THC:715
dt.21.12.2021 was set aside and a direction was given to the trial Court to
appoint a Survey Commissioner again to do a fresh survey.
The said Court held that the Survey Commissioner had not
properly measured and done demarcation by metes and bounds and he did not
specify in his report from which plot number, the 41 gandas of land are left
vacant, and what plot numbers are forcibly occupied by which parties, and the
identification of the plot numbers which were sold, if any. It held that the
report of the Survey Commissioner has not given the correct division of the
share of the properties and the report did not conform to the judgment of the
High Court in the RSA.
22.
After the matter was remanded back, on 16.7.2024, the Survey
Commissioner was again asked to do a survey and submit a report. He
completed the survey and filed a report on 16.08.2024.
23.
The defendants filed objection thereto, inter alia, contending that
some portion of the suit land had been acquired by the Government of Tripura
for construction of National Highway and the report filed by the Survey
Commissioner did not reveal it.
24.
This objection was rejected by the trial Court which held that the
Survey Commissioner in his report dt.16.08.2024 had acted in conformity
with the direction of the Appellate Court and there was no merit in their
objection.
25.
After acceptance of the Survey Commissioner's report on
02.12.2024, the trial Court was informed by the plaintiff that the Survey
Commissioner had not demarcated the land of the plaintiff and post pillars
within the suit land as demarcated by him in his report dt.16.08.2024.
26.
2026:THC:715
The Court, therefore, on 11.12.2024 accepted the plaintiff's
contention and directed the Survey Commissioner to demarcate the decretal
land by posting pillars after noting that 78 gandas of the suit land had been
sold out by the defendants out of 127 gandas of land, i.e. more than 50% of
the suit land, and holding that the plaintiff would be entitled to the remaining
41 gandas of land.
27.
This was challenged by the defendants in T.A. No.25 of 2024
before the District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala. They also filed an
application under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC for amendment of the Appeal
memo, which was opposed by the plaintiff.
28.
On 17.03.2025, the lower Appellate Court rejected the
application under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC contending that when the case
was posted for orders/judgment, this application had been moved and
previously sufficient time was given to the defendants, but they did not take
steps.
29.
It also dismissed the T.A. No.25 of 2024 on 25.03.2025. It held
that the trial Court had rightly issued orders to the Survey Commissioner to
post pillars after demarcating the land of 41 gandas, which the plaintiff was
supposed to get as per the preliminary decree.
30.
It held that unless and until the suit schedule property is properly
identified by demarcation, it cannot be partitioned by metes and bounds. It
relied on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Shub Karan
Bubna alias Shub Karan Prasad Bubna v. Sita Saran Bubna and others 1,
wherein the Supreme Court emphasized that preliminary decree confers right
(2009) 9 SCC 689
2026:THC:715
of the parties interested in the property and gives a further direction as may be
required to effect the division, and the final decree is passed after the partition
is made by the Collector or a Commissioner and he divides the property by
metes and bounds. It also held that a partition suit continues to be pending
until the partition is made and final decree is passed.
31.
Challenging the same, this RSA is filed by the defendants.
32.
The principal contention of the counsel for the appellants is that
the land which had been acquired by the State Government has not been taken
note of by the Survey Commissioner and there is a grave error in the Survey
Commissioner's report.
33.
Counsel for the plaintiff pointed out that in the preliminary
decree dt.14.06.1993 in T.S.(P) No.66 of 1977, the plaintiff himself pleaded
that his father and the father of the defendants had got compensation jointly
from the Government of Tripura for their land which had been acquired by the
State Government. He contended that in the judgment of the trial Court, while
passing preliminary decree, it was already recorded that Exhibit-1 document
was issued by the State Government of Tripura while acquiring 2 gandas from
the Jote No.357 under Kayemi Taluk No.57, and the Government paid amount
of compensation for the said land acquisition to the father of the plaintiff and
to the father of the defendants on 18.11.1959. Thus he contended that, long
before the filing of the suit, the land had been acquired by the Government for
road widening, and the plaintiff has, therefore, not included that land in the
suit 'A' Schedule and he could not have done so either.
34.
2026:THC:715
I completely agree with the contention of the respondent. If the
land acquisition had happened and compensation was paid in 1959, the said
acquired land would not be part of suit schedule when it was filed in 1977.
35.
If the trial Court, while passing preliminary decree had itself
noted that the acquisition of the land was much before the filing of the instant
suit in 1977, i.e. it took place in 1959 and the said finding had attained finality
up to RSA, the defendants cannot be permitted to raise the issue during the
final decree proceedings again and seek to delay the passing of the final decree
in this manner. No other contention was raised by the appellants.
36.
Therefore, I do not find any merit in the RSA. It accordingly
dismissed. No costs.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
Pulak
PULAK BANIK
Date: 2026.05.25 16:28:13 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review