Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010639402018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3596]
THURSDAY, THE 9th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2453/2018
Between:
1. SMT.TRIVENI NELLI, OCC.HOUSEWIFE,
R/O.FLAT NO.508, C
CBLOCK, KALKRITHI APTS., NEAR VIJAY DAIRY, TARNAKA
TARNAKA-500017
...AP
...APPELLANT
AND
1. THE STATE OF AP AND 4 OTHERS, REP. BY THE SHO, PS.,
KAKINADA TOWN CIRCLE, THROUGH PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF AP., HYDERABAD.
2. NELLI GOWTHAM KUMAR, R/O.D.NO.3
R/O.D.NO.3-73,
73, NAAGICHERUVU,
UPPADI (V), KATRENIKONDA MANDAL.
3. NELLI
PALLA
RAO,
R/O.NAAGICHERUVU,
UPPUDI
(V),
KATRENIKONA MANDAL.
4. KOLAGANTI BALAYYA, R/O.D.NO.70
R/O.D.NO.70-2-161/A,
161/A, RAMANAYYAPETA,
RAMANAYYA
KAKINADA.
5. PANDU VEERA VENKATA SATYA NARAYANA, R/O.NEAR
SARADAMBA TEMPLE, KONDAYYAPALEM, KAKINADA.
...RESPO
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying that the High
Court may be pleased to to convict the respondents/accused by setting aside
the judgment passed by the Honourable IV Additional District and Sessions
Judge at Kakinada in SC.No. 275 of 2014 dated 29
29-06-2018.
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
circum
stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
leave the petitioner in preferring the criminal appeal against the judgment in
SC.No. 275 of 2014 dated 29
29-06-2018,
2018, pending disposal of the criminal
appeal.
ellant:
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. NARAPARAJU AVANEESH
Counsel for the Respon
ndent(S):
1. K DEVANATH
2. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
3. V NITESH
4. JADA SRAVAN KUMAR
The Court made the following JUDGMENT:
(Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K.Suresh Reddy)
Questioning the judgment of acquittal passed by the learned IV
Additional District & Sessions Judge, Kakinada (for short, ‘the learned
Additional Sessions Judge’), in Sessions Case No.275 of 2014 dt. 29.06.2018,
wife of the deceased – PW.1 filed the present appeal.
2.
The respondents 2 to 5 / A.1 to A.4 were tried by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge under the following three charges:
(i) 1st charge was under Section 302 IPC against A.1
(ii) 2nd charge was under Section 380 IPC against A.1; and
(iii) 3rd charge was under Section 302 r/w 109 IPC against A.2 to A.4
3.
Substance of the charge is that, on 08.03.2011, A.1, having conspired
with A.2 to A.4, entered into the house of one Nelli Veeraiah Naidu
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the deceased’) situated at Venkat Nagar, Kakinada,
and beat him with a pestle on the left side of the head, causing his death
instantaneously, and in the same process, committed theft of gold and silver
articles, cash and mobile phones, marked as M.Os 1 to 31, thereby committed
offences punishable under Sections 302 & 380 r/w 109 IPC.
4.
After completion of trial, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, holding
that there was no legal evidence to connect the respondents 2 to 5/A.1 to A.4
with the alleged offence, acquitted them. Aggrieved by the same, P.W.1, wife
of the deceased, preferred the present appeal under Section 372 Cr.P.C.
5.
Case of the prosecution, briefly, is as follows:
(i) The accused and the material prosecution witnesses are residents of
Kakinada Town. The deceased was also resident of the same town. P.W.1 is
the wife, P.W.2 is the daughter and P.W.3 is the son of the deceased
respectively. P.W.4 was working as a maid servant in the house of deceased.
P.W.5 is the neighbour of the deceased. P.W.6 is friend of the deceased.
P.Ws.7 and 9 are the tenants of the deceased, whereas P.W.11 was also
residing in the same locality. A.2 is none other than the younger brother of the
deceased. A.4 was working as the car driver of the deceased. A.3 is a friend
of the deceased. Every morning, the deceased used to go for walk along with
his friends, A.3, P.W.6 and others. He was residing in his house at Kakinada
along with P.W.1, whereas their two daughters and two sons were residing
elsewhere. One week prior to date of incident, P.W.1 went to the house of her
eldest daughter to take care of her newborn child. P.W.4 used to cook food for
the deceased in his house. Every evening, the deceased used to consume
liquor in the company of A.3 and his friends. A.1 is the son of A.2. A.3 and A.4
are close associates of A.1 and A.2. A.1 is B.Tech. graduate and, at the
relevant point of time, was working as a Software Engineer at Chennai.
(ii) According to the prosecution, the deceased had acquired
considerable wealth while serving as an R.T.O. It is further case of the
prosecution that he had purchased several properties in the names of A.2 to
A.4 and was insisting upon them to transfer the said properties in favour of his
children. Since A.2 to A.4 were unwilling to transfer the properties, they
entered into a criminal conspiracy with A.1 to eliminate the deceased with a
view to retain the properties for themselves. In furtherance of the said
conspiracy, on the night of 08.03.2011, A.3 and A.4 visited the house of the
deceased, made him intoxicated with liquor and thereafter left the house
without closing the doors. They informed A.1 about the prevailing situation.
During the same night, A.1 entered into the house through back door and beat
the deceased with a chutney pounder (M.O.33) on his head while he was
sleeping, causing his instantaneous death, and thereafter committed theft of
M.Os.1 to 31 before leaving the house.
(iii) On the next day morning, A.4, who was working as the car driver of
the deceased, went to the house and found the front door locked from inside.
Then, he went to the backside of the house, peeped through the window and
noticed the deceased lying on the cot. Entertaining suspicion, he immediately
informed A.2, the younger brother of the deceased. Thereafter, A.2, along with
P.W.4, entered the house through the rear side, opened the door and found
the deceased lying dead on the cot. They also noticed bloodstains on the bed
sheet and chutney pounder lying beside the head of the deceased.
Immediately, A2 informed P.W.1 and others.
(iv) Thereafter, A.2 proceeded to the Police Station and lodged a report
on the same day at about 1.30 p.m. P.W.23, Inspector of Police, II Town
Police Station, Kakinada, received the said report and registered a case in
Crime No.43 of 2011 under Section 302 IPC. Report given by A.2 was marked
as Ex.P24, and the First Information Report was marked as Ex.P25. He
issued copies of FIR to all the concerned. FIR is marked as Ex.P25.
Immediately, at about 3.00 p.m., P.W.23 visited the scene of offence. He
summoned Dog Squad and Clues Team. Clues Team, headed by P.W.20,
developed chance prints at the scene of offence. P.W.23 prepared an
Observation Report, Ex.P7, in the presence of P.W.16 and another. He also
seized M.Os.34 to 42, besides Ex.P1-letter, under the cover of Panchanama,
Ex.P7. The scene of offence was photographed through P.W.14 and the
photographs were marked as Ex.P6. He also prepared Rough Sketches,
Exs.P26 and P27, and recorded statements of A.2 and P.Ws.3 to 7.
(v) On 10.03.2011 at about 10.00 a.m., P.W.23 again visited the scene
of offence after securing the presence of P.W.16 and another, held inquest
over the dead body and prepared the Inquest Report-Ex.P8. During the
course of inquest, he recorded statements of P.Ws.1 to 10. Thereafter, he
sent the dead body for post-mortem examination.
(vi)
P.W.17,
Associate
Professor,
Rangaraya
Medical
College,
Kakinada, conducted autopsy over the dead body. He opined the cause of
death was due to "cranio-cerebral injury" (head injury) caused by the impact of
a hard, blunt, medium to heavy-sized object or weapon. He issued Postmortem Certificate- Ex.P15, and the Final Opinion- Ex.P17.
(vii) On 11.03.2011, P.W.23 again visited the house of the deceased
and recorded statements of P.Ws.1, 3 and A.1. In the said statement, P.W.1
informed P.W.23 about the missing of M.Os.1 to 31. On the basis of the said
statement, P.W.23 altered the section of law by adding Section 380 IPC
through Memo- Ex.P28.
(viii) On 12.03.2011, P.W.23 once again visited the scene of offence
and recorded statements of P.Ws.11 to 15. On 18.03.2011, he made a
requisition to the Medical Officer requesting him to forward the viscera to the
Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Vijayawada, under a Letter of AdviceEx.P29. On 30.03.2011, P.W.23 received Finger Print Report- Ex.P20, from
P.W.20.
(ix) On 07.04.2011, P.W.23 apprehended A.1 near Railway Gate,
Kakinada. A.1 said to have confessed about the commission of offence.
Pursuant to the said confessional statement, P.W.23 seized M.Os.1 to 32 from
the possession of A.1 in the presence of P.W.16 under a cover of
Panchanama-Ex.P10. He also seized M.Os.44 to 47. On the basis of the
confessional statement of A.1, P.W.23 arrested A.2 to A.4 in the presence of
mediator, P.W.16, under a cover of Panchanama- Ex.P12. Thereafter, all the
four accused were remanded to judicial custody.
(x) On 01.05.2011, P.W.24, Inspector of Police, Kakinada Town Circle,
took up further investigation. On 28.05.2011, he obtained the specimen
signatures of A.1, marked as Ex.P32, and forwarded the same to the Forensic
Science Laboratory, Hyderabad, for comparison. However, the said authority
returned the same with an opinion that comparison of the handwriting was not
possible. After collecting all the relevant documents and after completion of
investigation, P.W.24 filed charge-sheet.
6.
In support of its case, the prosecution examined PWs 1 to 24, marked
Exs.P1 to P37 and exhibited MOs.1 to 47. On behalf of the defence, DW.1
was examined and Exs. D.1 to D.5 were marked.
7.
As there was no evidence incriminating the respondents 2 to 5/A.1 to
A.4 in the alleged offence, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, by
judgment dated 29.06.2018, acquitted them. The said judgment is impugned
in the present Criminal Appeal.
8.
As the learned counsel for the appellant did not appear on several
occasions, we requested the learned Additional Public Prosecutor to assist the
Court.
9.
Heard Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional Public Prosecutor
representing 1st Respondent-State; Sri Challa Ajay Kumar, learned counsel
appearing for Sri Jada Sravan Kumar, learned counsel for 2nd respondent /
A.1; Sri V.Nitesh, learned counsel for A.3; and Sri K.Devanath, learned
counsel for A.4.
10.
When notice was issued to A.2, the same was returned with an
endorsement that 3rd Respondent / A.2 died on 06.08.2025. Registry has
annexed the Death Certificate of A.2 along with returned notice. Accordingly,
the appeal against the 3rd respondent/A.2 stands dismissed as abated.
Hence, the present appeal is concerned only with regard to the respondents 2,
4 & 5 / A.1, A.3 and A.4.
11.
We have perused the entire material on record.
12.
There are no eyewitnesses to the occurrence in the present case. The
prosecution rests its case entirely on circumstantial evidence. The first
circumstance relied on by the prosecution is the motive attributed to the
accused. The second circumstance relied on by the prosecution is the "last
seen" theory. The third circumstance relied upon by the prosecution is the
recovery of M.Os.1 to 32 from the possession of A.1.
13.
So far as the first circumstance is concerned, the prosecution relies on
the evidence of P.W.1. In her evidence, P.W.1 stated that the deceased had
purchased certain properties in the names of A.2 to A.4. She further stated
that, when the deceased insisted A.2 to A.4 to transfer the said properties in
favour of his sons and daughters, they hatched a plan to eliminate him so as
to avoid transferring the properties in favour of the children of the deceased.
Except the oral testimony of P.W.1, there is absolutely no material on record
to establish that the deceased had purchased the properties in the names of
A.2 to A.4. No documentary evidence was produced by the prosecution in
support of the alleged motive attributed to A.2 to A.4 for committing the
murder of the deceased. As such, the prosecution could not prove the said
motive attributed to the accused.
14.
So far as the second circumstance, namely, the "last seen" theory, is
concerned, the prosecution examined P.W.9. In his evidence, P.W.9 stated
that he was a tenant of the deceased and had taken a shop on the ground
floor on rent from the deceased. He was running Kirana shop under the name
and style of “Sankar Kirana and General Stores” at Pragathi College Centre,
Venkata Nagar, Kakinada. He further stated that he used to pay monthly rent
of Rs.5,000/- to the deceased. In his evidence, he stated that on the morning
of 09.03.2011, between 4.30 a.m. and 5.00 a.m., he saw A.1 proceeding from
the northern side of the building carrying two bags. He further stated that A.1
boarded an auto-rickshaw and proceeded towards R.T.C. Complex.
Thereafter, he returned to his house and, at about 8.00 a.m., came to know
about the death of the deceased. He also admitted that he was present at the
time of inquest held on the morning of 10.03.2011. But, curiously, Inquest
Report does not contain any reference about he witnessed A.1 proceeding
from northern side of the building carrying two bags. Further, it is not the case
of P.W.9 that he had seen A.1 in the company of the deceased soon before
the occurrence. Moreover, according to the evidence of the prosecution
witnesses, the house of A.1 and A.2 is situated opposite to the house of the
deceased. Therefore, mere presence of A.1 in front of his own house at the
relevant point of time cannot, by itself, be treated as an incriminating
circumstance against him. Consequently, the prosecution has also failed to
establish the second circumstance.
15.
Coming to the third circumstance, i.e. recovery of M.Os.1 to 32 from the
possession of A.1, the prosecution relies on the evidence of the Investigating
Officer, P.W.23, coupled with the evidence of the mediator, P.W.16. According
to the prosecution, A.1, who had obtained a B.Tech. degree and was working
as a Software Engineer at Chennai. After committing murder of the deceased,
committed he theft of M.Os.1 to 32 from the house of the deceased and took
the said articles to Chennai. It is the evidence of P.W.23 that A.1 was
apprehended on 07.04.2011 near Railway Gate, Kakinada. P.Ws.23 and 16
deposed that, at the time of his apprehension, A.1 was found in possession of
M.Os.1 to 32. If, as alleged by the prosecution, A.1 had taken M.Os.1 to 32 to
Chennai immediately after the occurrence, there is absolutely no explanation
forthcoming from the prosecution as to why he would have brought the said
articles back to Kakinada. Added to it, no Test Identification Parade was
conducted in respect of M.Os.1 to 32 to establish their identity. More
importantly, P.W.1 did not lodge any complaint regarding the theft of M.Os.1
to 32 at the earliest point of time. According to P.W.1, she returned from
Hyderabad at about 9.00 p.m. on 09.03.2011. The evidence of P.W.23 further
discloses that inquest over the dead body was conducted at about 8.00 a.m.
on 10.03.2011, and P.W.1 was very much present during the said
proceedings. Even then, P.W.1 did not state that M.Os.1 to 32 had been
stolen from the house. It was only subsequently the prosecution introduced
the theory of theft of M.Os.1 to 32 and, on that basis, added the offence under
Section 380 IPC. Therefore, the alleged recovery, effected nearly one month
after the date of occurrence, does not inspire confidence. Apart from that,
there is absolutely no evidence on record to establish that M.Os.1 to 32
belong to the deceased. In the absence of any satisfactory evidence
identifying the said articles as the properties of the deceased, no reliance can
be placed on the alleged recovery.
16.
All the three circumstances relied on by the prosecution have not been
established by any cogent and convincing evidence. The chain of
circumstances is, therefore, incomplete and falls short of establishing the guilt
of the accused beyond all reasonable doubt.
17.
Further, this is an appeal against an Order of acquittal. In dealing with
the appeals against acquittal, though this Court has full power to
re-appreciate the evidence, at the same time, it would be slow in interfering
with the order of acquittal. Because there is a presumption under law that
accused is presumed to be innocent unless contrary is proved and that
presumption is further strengthened by the order of acquittal, unless there are
substantial or compelling reasons, this Court will not ordinarily disturb the
findings of the trial Court. If the trial Court has given any perverse finding, then
it can be a ground to interfere with the order of acquittal. Similarly, if
admissible evidence has not been taken into consideration or inadmissible
evidence has been looked into for the purpose of arriving at a particular
finding, then also it can be said to be a compelling reason to interfere with the
same.
18.
It is well settled that the scope of interference with an order of
acquittal in an appeal is limited. In ‘Vimal Singh v. Khuman Singh &
anr.1’, the apex Court held as follows:
“…..Coming to the ambit of power of High Court under Section 401 of
the Code, the High Court in its revisional power does not ordinarily
interfere with judgments of acquittal passed by the trial Court unless
1998 (8) Supreme l
there has been manifest error of law or procedure. The interference
with the order of acquittal passed by the trial Court is limited only to
exceptional cases when it is found that the order under revision
suffers from glaring illegality or has caused miscarriage of justice or
when it is found that the trial Court has no jurisdiction to try the case
or where the trial Court has illegally shut out the evidence which
otherwise ought to have been considered or where the material
evidence which clinches the issue have been over looked. These are
the instances where the High Court would be justified in interfering
with the order of acquittal.”
19.
In ‘C.Antony V. K.G.Raghavan Nair2’ while dealing with an order of
acquittal, the power of High Court to interfere with the same, the Apex Court
held thus:
“Unless the findings of trial Court are perverse or contrary to the
material on record, High Court cannot, in appeal, substitute its
findings merely because another contrary opinion was possible
on the basis of material on record.”
20.
In ‘State of Goa vs. Sanjay Thakran3’, the Apex Court held as follows:
“While exercising the powers in an appeal against the order of
acquittal the court of appeal would not ordinarily interfere with the
order of acquittal unless the approach of the lower Court is vitiated by
some manifest illegality land the conclusion arrived at would not be
arrived at by any reasonable person and, therefore, the decisions is
to be characterized as perverse. Merely because two views are
possible, the court of appeal would not take the view, which would
2003(1) SCC 1
(2007) 2 SCC (Crl.)162
upset the judgment, delivered by the Court below. However, the
appellate court has a power to review the evidence if it is of the view
that the view arrived at by the court below is perverse and the court
has committed a manifest error of law land ignored the material
evidence on record. A duty is cast upon the appellate court, in such
circumstances, to re-appreciate the evidence to arrive at a just
decision on the basis of material placed on record to fine out whether
any of the accused is connected with the commission of the crime he
is charged with.”
21.
In ‘Rupesh Manger (Thapa) Vs. The State of Sikkim45’, the Apex
Court held as follows:
It is settled that the judgment of acquittal can be reversed by the
Appellate Court only when there is perversity and not by taking a different
view on re-appreciation of evidence. If the conclusion of the Trial Court is
plausible one, merely because another view is possible on re-appreciation of
evidence, the Appellate Court should not disturb the findings of acquittal and
substitute its own findings to convict the accused.
22.
In view of facts and circumstances of the case, in view of the above
findings arrived at by the trial Court and in view of catena of decisions, we
have no hesitation to come to the conclusion that there are no merits in the
present Appeal. Therefore, the judgment of acquittal passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge does not suffer from any perversity and illegality
and as such no interference is required.
2023 (3) ALT (Crl.) 129 (SC)
(2007) 2 SCC (Crl.)162
23.
In the result, this Criminal Appeal is dismissed confirming the judgment
of acquittal recorded by the learned IV Additional District & Sessions Judge,
Kakinada in Sessions Case No.275 of 2014 vide judgment dt. 29.06.2018.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications pending, if any, shall also stand
closed.
__________________
K.SURESH REDDY, J
09.07.2026
MVA
____________________
SUMATHI JAGADAM, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review