Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally signed
KHOIROM by KHOIROM
BIPINCHAN BIPINCHANDRA
SINGH
DRA SINGH Date: 2025.10.07
06:37:16 +05'30'
Serial No. 4
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(CRL) No. 21 of 2025
Smt. Tongbram Ichan Devi
… Petitioner
- Versus State of Manipur & 2 Ors.
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
O R D E R
06.10.2025
[1]
[M. Sundar, CJ]
Mr. Ph. Sanajaoba, learned counsel for petitioner; Mr. Th.
Vashum, learned Public Prosecutor for respondent Nos. 1 & 2 and Mr. S.
Kaminikumar, learned Central Government Standing Counsel (CGSC) for
respondent No. 3 are before this Court.
[2]
Captioned habeas corpus petition has been filed assailing an
order of preventive detention dated 13.05.2025 made by second
respondent (The Additional District Magistrate, Bishnupur District)
whereby, Shri Angom Ibochouba @ Lanchaba @ Lanchiba @ Punshiba @
Muba @ Chingkheinganba spouse of writ petitioner who shall be referred
to as ‘detenu’, for the sake of convenience and clarity has been detained.
To be noted, impugned preventive detention order has been made under
P a g e 1 | 10
the ‘National Security Act, 1980 (65 of 1980)’ [hereinafter ‘NSA’ for the sake
of brevity].
[3]
On 18.09.2025 when the matter was listed, the following
proceeding was made:
‘Mr. Ph. Sanajaoba, learned counsel for the petitioner; Mr.
Th. Vashum, learned Government Advocate for respondent Nos. 1
& 2; and Mr. S. Kaminikumar, learned CGSC for respondent No. 3;
are present before us in the physical Court.
In the captioned Habeas Corpus Petition, Mr. Ph.
Sanajaoba, learned counsel for the petitioner, makes two points
and they are as follows:
(i)
The impugned detention order has been made by
R2 , who is the Additional District Magistrate,
Bishnupur, [L/A (which denotes ‘Look After’) District
Magistrate, Bishnupur]. There is no delegation of
power to pass detention order in favour of R2. This
is the admitted position of the State vide paragraph
11 of the affidavit-in-opposition.
(ii)
The grounds of detention has not been forwarded to
the State Government ‘forthwith’ along with the
detention order.
In support of this contention, learned counsel pressed into
service Hetchin Haokip case of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
reported in (2018) 9 SCC 562 and drew our attention to paragraph
13-15 thereof.
The term ‘State Government’ is defined vide 2(e) of National
Security Act, 1860 but that pertains to Union Territory.
The position regarding States which are not Union Territory
is not within the statutory perimeter of the definition.
Learned counsel for the petitioner sought for time to
examine this position and revert to this Court. List one week hence.
List on 25.09.2025.’
P a g e 2 | 10
[4]
Before we delve into matter, it is deemed appropriate to
record that the impugned detention order is predicated on as many as 4
(four) cases, details of which are as follows:
(i)
FIR No. 19(3)2011 BPR-PS, U/S 20/17 UA(P)Act &
25(1-C) A. Act.
(ii)
FIR No. 95(11) 2012 PSI-PS, U/S 364-A/400/34 IPC,
16-B/17/20 UA(P) Act & 25(1-C) A. Act.
(iii)
FIR No. 10(4) 2023 HLM-PS U/S 20 UA(P) Act.
(iv)
FIR No. 17(04)2025 MRG-PS, U/S 17/20 UA(P) A Act.
To be noted, ‘FIR’ denotes ‘First Information Report’ and
‘UA(P) Act’ denotes ‘The Unlawful Activities (Preventive) Act, 1967 (37 of
1967)’.
[5]
Today, learned counsel for writ petitioner elaborated on both
points captured in afore-referred 18.09.2025 proceedings.
[6]
The first point was reiterated and elaborated by saying that
there is no delegation of powers to make preventive detention order qua
second respondent under Section 3(3) of NSA.
[7]
The affidavit-in-opposition, in Para – 11, no doubt says that
there is no delegation in favour of second respondent. Nonetheless, today
learned State counsel drew our attention to an order of State Government
dated 08.05.2025 bearing reference No. TRNGE-1/12021-DP-DP. This order
has been placed by the learned State counsel as Annexure, X-1 before us.
A careful perusal of this 08.05.2025 order, made by the State Government,
makes it clear that duties of certain officers who have been deputed to
P a g e 3 | 10
participate in 22nd Round of Phase – III training of Mid-Career Training
Programme (MCTP) for IAS Officers schedule from 12.05.2025 to
06.06.2025 at LBSNAA, Mussoorie have been conferred on certain other
officers for ‘looking after’ (‘L/A’ is the abbreviation used by State) the
affairs. It has been mentioned that 7 (seven) officers would be attending
MCTP. Out of 7 (seven) officers, duties of 3 (three) officers have been
conferred/assigned on 3 (three) other officers to look after their work. A
careful perusal of Annexure, X-I makes it clear that second respondent is
one of the officers who has been conferred/assigned powers of District
Magistrate, Bishnupur who undisputedly is an officer to whom detention
powers have been conferred by State Government.
[9]
To be noted, second respondent is Additional District
Magistrate, Bishnupur, he is looking after (L/A) duties of the District
Magistrate, Bishnupur and second respondent is not lower in hierarchy qua
District Magistrate. As there is no contestation as regards Annexure X-I, it
is not necessary to dilate on definition of State Government. In this view of
the matter, the argument that the second respondent has not been vested
with powers to make the impugned preventive detention order pales into
insignificance. Therefore, the first point does not find favour with us.
[10]
This takes the legal drill at hand to the second point. The file
placed before us by the learned State counsel makes it clear that impugned
detention order has been sent by the second respondent to the State
Government on the same day i.e. 13.05.2025 (to be noted, the same day
P a g e 4 | 10
on which the impugned detention order was made) albeit without the
grounds, however, the grounds have been sent subsequently by second
respondent to the State Government on 17.05.2025 and the State
Government has thereafter made an order of approval on 23.05.2025,
which is also placed before us. This order of approval is within the meaning
of sub-Section (4) of Section 3 of NSA. Subsequently, an order of
confirmation vide Section 12(1) of NSA has also made by the State
Government on 16.06.2025. This proceedings reads as follows:
‘GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
SECRETARIAT: HOME DEPARTMENT
ORDERS BY THE GOVERNOR: MANIPUR
Imphal, the 16th June, 2025
No.H-14/12/2025-HD-HD: Bishnupur District, Manipur vide his
order vide No.Cril-1/NSA/DM-BPR/2025 dated 13.05.2025 passed
Whereas, the Addl. District Magistrate, Bishnupur, (L/A District
Magistrate, under Sub-section 3 of Section 3 of the National
Security Act, 1980 (hereinafter referred to as the said Act). made a
detention Shri Angom Ibochouba Lanchaba Lanchaiba Punshiba
Muba Chingkheinganba (44 yrs), s/o Late A. Ibocha Singh of
Moirang Khoiru Mayai Lambi Ward No. 10, PS Moirang. DistrictBishnupur, Manipur (hereinafter referred to as the said person);
And whereas, after examination of the report, the detention
order, grounds of detention and other relevant papers furnished by
the Addl. District Magistrate, Bishnupur, (L/A District Magistrate,
Bishnupur) District, Manipur under Section 3(2) of the said Act, the
Government has approved the said detention order made by the
District Magistrate, Bishnupur, (L/A District Magistrate, Bishnupur
District, Manipur, vide Government order No. H-14/12/2025-HD-HD
dated 23 May, 2025.
And whereas, the Advisory Board constituted under Section
19 of the said Act has carefully considered the case of the said
penson in its sitting held on 05.06.2025 and submitted the report
on 10.06.2025 and unanimously held that there are grounds and
sufficient causes for detention of the detenu under the provision of
the said Act.
P a g e 5 | 10
And whereas, the Governor of Manipur after considering the
proximate past of the detenu being an underground worker of the
banned organization, namely KCP(PWG) which are prejudicial to the
security of the State and maintenance of public order and there is
apprehension of his continuing to commit similar prejudicial
activities, unless his activities are prevented by preventive
measures under the provision of NSA 1980, and therefore is of the
opinion that the said person should be detained for the maximum
period of 12 (twelve) months as provided under Section 13 of the
said Act.
Now, therefore, in consonance with the opinion expressed
by the Advisory Board and in exercise of the powers conferred
under Section 12(1) of the said Act, the Governor of Manipur is
pleased to order that the detention of Shri Angom Ibochouba
Lanchaba Lanchaiba Punshiba Muba Chingkheinganba (44 yrs), s/o
Late A. Ibocha Singh of Moirang Khoiru Mayai Lambi Ward No. 10,
PS-Moirang. District-Bishnupur, Manipur vide his order vide Mo.
Cril-1/NSA/DM-BPR/2025 dated 13.05.2025 is hereby confirmed
and further fix the period of detention for a period of 12 (twelve)
months from the date of detention.
By orders & in the name of Governor,
Sd/(A. Subhash Singh)
Additional Secretary (Home).
Government of Manipur’
[11]
This means that State Government has approved the
detention order within 12 (twelve) days and confirmation order has been
made well within 3 (three) months vide Section 3(4) and 12(1) of NSA
respectively.
[12]
This Court carefully and respectfully perused Hetchin
Haokip [(2008) 9 SCC 562] which was pressed into service by learned
counsel for petitioner for the proposition that detaining authority not
forthwith sending detention order with grounds to State Government is fatal
qua detention order. Learned State counsel contends that Hetchin Haokip
is clearly distinguishable on facts as that is a case, where the detaining
P a g e 6 | 10
authority had not communicated even the factum of detention to the State
Government for 5 days whereas in the case on hand, the factum of
detention (to be noted detention order itself) has been communicated to
the State Government on the same day albeit without the grounds.
[13]
We agree and accept the argument of learned State counsel
that Hetchin Haokip is clearly distinguishable on facts. The reason as to
why we agree with the State counsel is declaration of law made by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Padma Sundara Rao reported in (2002) 3 SCC 533.
Padma Sundara Rao declares law as to how precedents are and
Paragraph 9 reads as follows:
‘9.
Courts should not place reliance on decisions without
discussing as to how the factual situation fits in with the fact
situation of the decision on which reliance is placed. There is
always peril in treating the words of a speech or judgment as
though they are words in a legislative enactment, and it is to
be remembered that judicial utterances are made in setting
of the facts of a particular case, said Lord Morris in
Herrington v. British Railways Board (1972) 2 WLR
537, (1972) 1 All ER 747 (HL). Circumstantial flexibility,
one additional or difference fact may make a world of
difference between conclusions in two cases.’
[14]
On facts, Padma Sundara Rao is one where land acquisition
proceedings under Central Act (Land Acquisition Act, 1894) was assailed
and the question as to whether a fresh period of one year would be
P a g e 7 | 10
available arise for making declaration under Section 6 of Central Act was
examined.
[15]
In the light of Padma Sundara Rao principle, which is
declaration of law made by a Constitution Bench, we have no difficulty in
accepting the argument that Hetchin Haokip is clearly distinguishable on
facts. In addition to Hetchin Haokip placed before us, an order of a
Division Bench of this Court being order dated 11.07.2022 made in
W.P.(Crl) No. 6 of 2022, (Ruhida case) was pressed into service. In
Ruhida case, Division Bench of this Court while applying Hetchin Haokip
had no occasion to resort to Padma Sundara Rao principle as the
argument that Hetchin Haokip is distinguishable on facts was not raised
in Ruhida . To be noted, in Ruhida sending detention order alone without
grounds (to be noted, grounds also sent later but before approval in instant
case) was held to vitiate detention order in the light of Hetchin Haokip
principle.Therefore, this Court has not difficulty in writing that we would
respectfully follow Constitution Bench declaration of law in Padma Sudara
Rao and hold that the argument that Hetchin Haokip is distinguishable
on facts is accepted.
[16]
There are other reasons as to why Hetchin Haokip does not
come to the aid of the writ petitioner in the case at hand and the same are
as follows:
(i)
In Ameena Begum reported in (2023) 9 SCC 587,
Honb’le Supreme Court made it clear that the State
P a g e 8 | 10
Government need not review an order of detention every
3 (three) months, after confirmatory order is made as it
was
noticed
in
Ameena Begum that Pesala
Nookaraju [(2023) 14 SCC 641] overruled Cherukuri
Mani [(2015) 19 SCC 722] on this point.
(ii)
In the case on hand, we find that the approval order
under Section 3(4) of NSA has been made by the State
Government (after receipt of grounds) within 12
(twelve) days and the confirmation order under Section
12(1) of NSA has been made well within 3 (three)
months. Therefore, it cannot be gain said that fair
procedure has been violated.
(iii) The grounds of detention have been served to the
detenu well within 5 (five) days provided vide Section
8(1) of NSA. There is no disputation about this aspect of
the matter and therefore, this buttresses the position
that there is no infraction of Constitutional rights of the
detenu.
(iv) Notwithstanding the above, second respondent sent the
grounds
of
detention
to
the
State
Government
subsequent to sending the detention order forthwith
(same day), approval and confirmation by State
Government was after receipt of grounds.
P a g e 9 | 10
[17]
Ergo, sequitur is, the two points which have been canvassed
in the hearing (notwithstanding myriad grounds raised in the writ petition)
fail and further sequitur is, captioned writ petition perishes and the same is
dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Bipin
P a g e 10 | 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review