Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.87 of 2024
Smt. Swapna Chakraborty (Ghosh)
W/O- Sri Amit Ghosh
R/O- Maharanipur, Ward No.-3
P.S. Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura
..…Applicant
On behalf of:
Sri Amit Ghosh
S/O- Rabindra Ghosh
R/O- Maharanipur, Ward No.-3
P.S. Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura
….Accused person
Versus
The State of Tripura
...Respondent
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. P. K. Biswas, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Pujan Biswas, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
13/12/2024
This bail application under Section 483 of BNSS,
2023 is filed for releasing the accused-in-custody namely Sri
Amit Ghosh who is lodging in jail in connection with case
No.S.T.(T-1) 24 of 2024 arising out of Teliamura P.S. case
No.48 of 2024 under Section 103(1)/61(2)/238 of BNS.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P. K. Biswas
assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. Pujan Biswas appearing on
behalf of the accused-in-custody and also heard Learned P.P.,
Mr. R. Datta representing the State-respondent.
As per earlier order, Learned P.P. has produced the
Case Diary and also we have received the LCR by this time.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P. K.
Biswas first of all drawn the attention of the Court, the contents
of the FIR and submitted that the FIR was unknown and in
course of investigation, the present accused was arrested and
taken into custody along with another accused and save and
except confessional statement of the accused, there is no
evidence
on
record
against
the
accused-in-custody
and
furthermore, the alleged statement of the accused was also not
recorded
as
per
the
prescribed
procedure
of
law
and
furthermore, referring the final report of I.O., Learned Senior
Counsel submitted that the accused himself appeared before the
Police Station being called for and there is no chance of his
absconsion or tempering the evidence on record, since the I.O.
by this time has laid charge-sheet against the accused. Learned
Senior Counsel further referred citation of a Division Bench of
this High Court in Crl.A.(J) 12 of 2023 reported in (2024) 2
TLR 359 wherein in para No.34, this High Court observed as
under:
“34. Learned Senior Counsel also in course of
hearing referred the provision of Sections 25
and 26 of the Evidence Act and submitted that
if for argument sake the alleged statement of
the
accused
appellant
is
treated
as
confessional statement under Section 25 and
26 of the Evidence Act, in that case the same
also cannot be taken into consideration as per
law. In this regard, Learned Senior Counsel has
relied upon another citation of Hon‟ble Gauhati
High Court in Kartik Chakraborty and Others
versus State of Assam reported in (2018) 2
GLR 1 which reads as under :
“33. This has also been the view of the
Madras High Court and it finds its
expression
in
several decisions.
In
Palanisamy alias Kunjupaiyan Vs. State,
Criminal Appeal No.541/2005, decided on
22.03.2013, Madras High Court has held
that the Evidence Act was enacted before
the commencement of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973. In view of
Section 3(3) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973, the term "Magistrate"
referred to in Section 26 of the Evidence
Act does not refer to Executive Magistrate.
Consequently,
the
expression
"Magistrate" as appearing in Section 26 of
the Evidence Act would mean only a
Judicial Magistrate. Therefore, confession
recorded or videographed by police in the
presence of Executive Magistrate would
be hit by Sections 25 and 26 of the
Evidence Act. Again, in the case of Kalam
@ Abdul Kalam Vs. Inspector of Police,
reported in MANU/TN/07588/2011, the
Madras
High
Court
examined
the
provisions of Section 26 of the Evidence
Act vis-à-vis Section 3(3) of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 and after
observing that the Evidence Act was
enacted before the commencement of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, held
that the term "Magistrate" as referred to
in Section 26 of the Evidence Act will
mean only a Judicial Magistrate.”
Referring the above, Learned Senior Counsel
submitted that the statement was recorded in
presence of Executive Magistrate, not before
any Judicial Magistrate as interpreted by the
Hon‟ble Gauhati High Court. So, there was also
no scope to place any reliance upon the
evidence of PW-1, Shri Santanu Dutta DCM in
whose presence the disclosure statement was
recorded by IO on the alleged date and time.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
submitted that since there is want of procedural defects, so, at
the end of trial this present accused would be acquitted. So, no
purpose would be served by keeping the accused in J/C.
Learned Senior Counsel also referred another citation
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in reported in (2012) 1
SCC 40 in para Nos.40 and 46 the Hon’ble Supreme Court
observed as under:
“40. The grant or refusal to grant bail lies
within the discretion of the court. The grant or
denial is regulated, to a large extent, by the
facts and circumstances of each particular
case. But at the same time, right to bail is not
to be denied merely because of the sentiments
of the community against the accused. The
primary purposes of bail in a criminal case are
to relieve the accused of imprisonment, to
relieve the State of the burden of keeping him,
pending the trial, and at the same time, to keep
the accused constructively in the custody of the
Court, whether before or after conviction, to
assure that he will submit to the jurisdiction of
the Court and be in attendance thereon
whenever his presence is required.
46. We are conscious of the fact that the
accused are charged with economic offences of
huge magnitude. We are also conscious of the
fact that the offences alleged, if proved, may
jeopardize the economy of the country. At the
same time, we cannot lose sight of the fact that
the investigating agency has already completed
investigation and the charge sheet is already
filed before the Special Judge, CBI, New Delhi.
Therefore, their presence in the custody may
not be necessary for further investigation. We
are of the view that the appellants are entitled
to the grant of bail pending trial on stringent
conditions in order to ally the apprehension
expressed by CBI.”
He further referred another citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in (2024) SCC OnLine SC 3526
wherein in para Nos.5, 6 & 7, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed
as under:
“5. Accordingly, we direct that the appellant
shall be produced before the Trial Court within
one week from today. The Trial Court shall
enlarge the appellant on bail till the conclusion
of the trial on appropriate terms and
conditions, including the condition of regularly
and punctually attending the Trial Court and
cooperating with the Trial Court for expeditious
conclusion of the case.
6. Before we part with this order, every day we
notice that in several orders passed by
different High Courts while rejecting the bail
applications, in a routine manner, the High
Courts are fixing a time bound schedule for the
conclusion of the trials. Such directions
adversely affect the functioning of the Trial
Courts as in many Trial Courts, there may be
older cases of the same category pending.
Every court has criminal cases pending which
require
expeditious
disposal for
several
reasons, such as the requirement of the penal
statutes, long incarceration, age of the
accused, etc. Only because someone files a
case in our Constitutional Courts, he cannot get
out of turn hearing. Perhaps after rejecting the
prayer for bail, the Courts want to give some
satisfaction to the accused by fixing a timebound schedule for trial. Such orders are
difficult to implement. Such orders give a false
hope to the litigants. If in a given case, in law
and on facts, an accused is entitled to bail on
the ground of long incarceration without the
trial making any progress, the Court must grant
bail. Option of expediating trial is not the
solution.
7. In paragraph 47.3 of the decision of a
Constitution Bench of in the case of „High Court
Bar Association, Allahabad v. State of Uttar
Pradesh‟1, this Court has held that in the
ordinary course, the Constitutional Courts
should refrain from fixing a time-bound
schedule for the disposal of cases pending
before any other Courts. Paragraph 47.3 reads
thus:
“47.3.
Constitutional courts,
in
the
ordinary course, should refrain from fixing
a time-bound schedule for the disposal of
cases pending before any other courts.
Constitutional courts may issue directions
for the time-bound disposal of cases only
in exceptional circumstances. The issue of
prioritising the disposal of cases should be
best left to the decision of the courts
concerned where the cases are pending;”
(underline supplied)
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel urged
for releasing the accused on bail in any condition.
On the other hand, Learned P. P., Mr. R. Datta
appearing on behalf of the State-respondent strongly objected
the submission made by Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P. K.
Biswas and submitted that at this stage, there is no scope to
release the accused-in-custody on bail, since, the I.O. has laid
charge-sheet within time. Learned P. P. further drawn the
attention of the Court referring the statement of the accused-incustody and also the post-mortem examination report and
submitted that there are strong materials showing involvement
of the accused with the alleged crime. Further, Learned P. P.
also submitted that the citations as referred by Learned Senior
Counsel for the accused-in-custody relates to trial, not for
consideration of the bail application. So, these principles cannot
be applied at this stage and urged for dismissal of this bail
application.
Heard both the sides at length.
Considered.
The present prosecution was set into motion on the
basis of an FIR laid by one Sekhar Debnath to O.C., Teliamura
P.S. alleging inter alia that on 18.07.2024 around 10.15 p.m.
during night, his younger brother Kinkar Debnath left his house
situated near Korailong, infront of Sishu Bihar School stating to
this wife that one of his friends had called him, but when he did
not return back to his house in the late night, his wife called him
and informed him that her husband did not return back and he
was not responding any phone call. The informant also made
several phone calls in his mobile but he did not receive any of
the calls. The other villagers also made call to Kinkar but those
calls were not responded. After that they started searching him
and thereafter, on 19.07.2024 at about 5.30 a.m. in the
morning, the dead body of his younger brother was found lying
at South Pulinpur near the National Highway and his nose was
found to be bleeding and his tongue was protruding out. He
immediately rushed to P.O. and found his brother lying dead.
Hence, he laid the FIR. On the basis of his FIR, this case was
registered and in course of investigation, the I.O. caused arrest
of this present accused-in-custody and the wife of the deceased
Purnima Debnath who are also lodging in custody in connection
with this case.
It is the admitted position that the I.O. by this time
has laid charge-sheet against this present accused and another
within time and the case by this time has been committed to the
Court of Sessions for holding trial of accused persons. The
accused is lodging-in-custody on and from 21.07.2024 and the
I.O. within time has laid charge-sheet and the case is now
posted for framing of charge. On perusal of the Case Diary, it
appears to this Court that there is direct allegation against the
accused showing his involvement with the offence as alleged.
So, considering the facts and circumstances of this
case, at this stage, I find no scope to release the accused-in-
custody on bail. Hence, the bail application filed on behalf of the
accused-in-custody stands rejected being devoid of merit. The
citations as referred by Learned Senior Counsel for the accusedin-custody cannot be applied at this stage. The accused is to
remain in J/C as before. Since, the charge-sheet is already been
submitted and the case is now posted for framing of charge, so,
Learned Court below be asked to make all endeavour to
complete the trial of the case at an earliest convenience giving
top priority.
A copy of this order be communicated to the Learned
Court below along with the LCR. Also return back the Case Diary
to I.O. through Learned P. P. along with the copy of this order.
With this observation, this bail application stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.12.13 16:46:20
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review