Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
Mat. App. No.35 of 2024
1.
Smti. Susmita Pal (Sen).
…..Appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
Sri Sankhasubhra Sen
….. Respondent.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing and delivery of
judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. V. Poddar, Advocate.
Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. D. K. Deb, Advocate.
09.04.2025
YES/NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
[T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard Ms. V. Poddar, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
also heard Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. D. K.
Deb, learned counsel appearing for the respondent.
[2]
The present appeal has been filed under Section-19(1) of the
Family Courts Act, 1984 read with Section-28 of the Hindu Marriage Act,
against the impugned judgment dated 16.11.2024 passed by the learned
Addl. Judge, Family Court, Agartala, West Tripura in T.S. (Div) 488 of
2022 whereby and whereunder, the prayer of the petitioner-respondent for
decree of divorce under Section-13(1) (i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act has
been allowed and the decree of divorce was granted by the learned Addl.
Family Court.
[3]
The facts of the case are that The marriage between the
Respondent herein and the Appellant was solemnized on 27.01.2019 as per
Hindu rites and Customs in the presence of the parental house of the
appellant and the marriage was negotiated in response to the advertisement
given by the parents of the petitioner in local newspaper. On 20.11.2020
the petitioner Respondent Husband joined at Ambassa ICDS Project on
being transferred from Kumarghat and since then both the parties have
been staying separate from each other. After taking the evidences and also
hearing both the parties the learned Addl. Family Court, Agartala, West
Tripura below decided the matter against the appellant illegally and
arbitrarily and allowed the decree of divorce Therefore, appellant has filed
this instant appeal challenging the impugned order dated 16.11.2024 passed
by the learned Addl. Family Judge, Agartala, West Tripura.
[4]
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Court below has
observed as under:
“73.In the result, the petition dated 22.09.2022 lodged by the husbandpetitioner for dissolution of marriage between himself and respondent is
allowed as per Section-13(1) (i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The suit
is hereby decreed with declaration that the marriage and marital tie between
the petitioner Sri Sankhasubhra Sen and respondent Smt. Susmita Pal (Sen)
stands dissolved henceforth. The parties will no longer be husband and wife.
74. Prepare decree accordingly and place it for signing immediately.
75. Supply a copy of decree to both parties at free of cost. Thus, the suit is
disposed of on contest….”
[5]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the same, the
respondent-appellant has preferred the present appeal before this Court for
redress.
[6]
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that
the wife appellant was always ready to reside with the respondent but the
respondent was not agreed to lead conjugal life and started cruelty upon the
appellant. There is no evidence on record which shows that the respondent
herein put his effort to bring back the appellant herein or to stay with her
after his transfer from Kumarghat to Ambassa in November, 2020. It is
relevant to mention that all the belongings of the couple are still lying in
the rented house, but the learned Court below failed to appreciate the same.
[7]
PW-4 is not acceptable as she cited beyond pleadings story
and so the evidence of putting cut marks by nail and injury is no believable.
It has been further contended that on so many occasions’ efforts of
reconciliation was made during the divorce proceeding but the husband
respondent always denied for leading conjugal life. It is the husband who
left appellant herein at Kumarghat and never tried to contact her.
[8]
The plea of the petitioner-respondent herein about the
Obsessive Compulsion Disorder of respondent appellant is baseless and has
no corroboration by any medical evidence. But the learned Court below has
failed to appreciate the same and passed the impugned judgment which
needs to be set aside. In case of desertion there must be permanent
abandonment or withdrawn of the conjugal society of petitioner respondent
by respondent appellant without any justification. It also requires the
cessation of martial obligations for considerable period and as per statute,
for a period of not less than two years preceding the date of presentation of
petition for divorce. It has been mentioned that pre-condition of statutory
requirement to constitute the desertion is not proved. Therefore, the finding
of the learned Court below is totally illegal and arbitrary.
[9]
Learned senior counsel appearing for the respondent-husband
in support of his case has submitted that he sought for the decree of divorce
on the ground of suffering cruelty and desertion. He argued that the trauma
with mental cruelty and humiliation upon petitioner, the respondent herein,
had started since their honeymoon trip. The respondent, the appellant
herein, has the habit of putting her periodic napkins under bed and on the
rack of bathroom without disposing them that generates nauseating stench
and discomfort to the petitioner to stay.
[10]
The respondent has no sense of honour and respect towards
petitioner and her in-laws as often she was found to appear naked after
bathing from washroom which caused immense awkward situation and
mental cruelty to the petitioner. During the occasion of puja suddenly the
respondent opened her Sankha-pola with erasing of vermilion from her
forehead and that being unjustified conduct cannot be tolerated by an
educated husband of Hindu family. This incident also put him to suffer
mental trauma and agony. The respondent also refused to cohabit with
petitioner on several occasions and even refused to take the medicine
prescribed by Dr. Bhubaneshwar Roy, a Psychiatrist.
[11]
It is further pointed out that the respondent has no respect and
care towards her parents in law as they were also humiliated during their
visit to the rented house. The misbehaviour and humiliating conduct of the
respondent and the mental cruelty caused had reached to such an extent and
degree that the petitioner cannot be expected to bear with or further stay
with his wife. From the chronological incident occurred in the short span of
conjugal life since the honeymoon trip, it is the petitioner who has suffered
a lot and it would be harmful for him to cohabit with such delinquent and
insensible wife and so prayed for passing decree in his favour.
[12]
In view of above and after observing the findings arrived at by
the learned Court below, for a definite conclusion, let us revisit the
evidences once again. It is admitted fact that soon after marriage both the
petitioner and the respondent went to Andaman via Kolkata on 04.02.2019
for honeymoon trip for five days and returned to Agartala on 10.02.2019.
At the time of marriage respondent being posted at Khowai used to stay in
the rented house there while petitioner was posted at Kumarghat, Unakoti
District. With the persuasion of both the parties respondent got transferred
to Pabiacherra TGB Branch at Kumarghat from Khowai on 19.08.2019.
The petitioner joined at Ambassa ICDS project on being transferred from
Kumarghat and since then both the parties have been staying separate from
each other. It is also admitted fact that on 25.10.2021 on meeting held in
the house of one Bidhu Bushan Deb of Ramnagar-8 where parents of
petitioner along with respondent, her father and uncles with other
respectable well-wishers were present but no settlement could be arrived in
that meeting.
[13]
PW-1 Sri Sankha Subhra Sen (Petitioner, the respondent
herein,) in order to establish his contention of cruelty deposed categorically
that the respondent during the honeymoon trip at Andaman on each
occasion of fixed journey by tourist bus, made undue delay in the
washroom that resulted to the delayed boarding of them in the tourist bus,
that also put the petitioner to bear with annoyance of co-travelers. the
respondent has the abnormal and objectionable habit of coming out from
the wash room in full naked condition after birth followed by roaming
around the hotel room in that condition that was not befitting for her
personality.
[14]
After return from the honeymoon trip, respondent continued
her ugly practice of coming out from the wash room in fully naked
condition and roaming in the room just like a lunatic person. According to
PW-1 respondent is completely swallowed by Obsessive Compulsion
Disorder with terribly grumpy personality. During the stay of petitioner
with respondent in her rented house at Khowai for 14 days after the
honeymoon trip, he was also humiliated and abused by the respondent
without any reason.
[15]
She also uttered that she had spent Rs. 6.72 lakhs in her
marriage and that her marriage being an unsuccessful and failed she can
proceed for mutual divorce if the same money was repaid to her. She also
expressed on numerous occasions that PW-1 has no match for her and she
deserves much better groom.
[16]
During the 2nd trip of the parents of PW-1 to the rented house
of respondent at Khowai, she has humiliated and abused then with slang
and filthy language and did not behave properly. Even in June, 2019
respondent also behaved in a discourteous and insulting way with one
customer of her bank for which that customer also lodged a complaint
against her and then she had to seek pardon to the bank ombudsmen. With
the persuasion of PW-1 and respondent, she was transferred to the
Pubiacherra, TGB, Kumarghat Branch on 19.08.2019 and started living
together at Kumarghat where PW-1 was also posted.
[17]
PW-1 has also made effort for proper treatment of respondent
who was suffering from multiple diseases like polycystic ovarian
syndrome, acute Gastroenteritis with obsessive compulsion disorder but she
never consumed the dosses of medicine prescribed by doctors despite
repeated request of PW-1. The respondent had also shifted her all golden
ornaments in her bank locker and uttered that she had no problem in giving
divorce to PW-1 as she successfully shifted her ornaments to the Bank
locker. The respondent has also changed seven cooks three in Khowai and
four in Kumarghat till January, 2020 over very minor issues and she used
to quarrel with them and blame them for lack of cleanliness.
[18]
Sustaining all such ill-treatment together PW-1 had fallen ill
just after few months of marriage and had to take high powered medicine
for hyper tension. Enduring all kinds of physical, psychological, mental and
emotional tortures by respondent, he continued the conjugal life with a
hope of her change in attitude and habit and under compelling
circumstances, one year of marriage he divulged everything to her parents
with request to inform her parents about the incidents and torture. The
respondent was also neglectful in disposing her period blood stain napkins
and used to accumulate this under bed and rack of bath room for months
that would release nauseating stench in the house. Even during her periods
she used to scold and scars PW-1 under the influence of superstitions.
[19]
Almost every day she fought with PW-1 during the stay of his
parents at Kumarghat and also shouted on him to give her divorce. Despite
repeated request of PW-1, respondent did not consume single medicine
prescribe by Dr. Bhubaneswar Roy (Psychiatrist) who diagnosed her with
obsessive compulsion disorder. On 19.05.2020 during the stay at
Kumarghat, respondent scratched and pinched PW-1 severely with nails on
the pretext of asking her to have dinner with him. Similar incident also
occurred on 22.05.2020 and thereafter on 25.05.2020; she also insulted
PW-1 for receiving phone call of his Sr. colleague at round 8.30pm at
night.
[20]
On 28.06.2020, when the parents of PW-1 visited Kumarghat
along with Prashad of Goddess Bipadnashini for both the spouses she
became furious seeing her parents in law and also thrown away their Prasad
and also removed her Sakha and Pola from her hand followed by erasing
her vermilion from her forehead. On 20.11.2020 PW-1 joined at Ambassa
ICDS project on transfer from Kumarghat after that no communication
made between him and the respondent though he tried to contact with her
over mobile phone but she never received. Before his joining at Ambassa,
respondent also abused, mentally tortured and humiliated PW-1.
[21]
On 25.10.2021 one meeting held in the residence of one Bidhu
Bushan Deb at Ramnagar Road No-8 in presence of the parents and other
relatives of both the parties to resolve the matter but no solution came up.
According to PW-1 respondent was always disrespectful towards her
parents in law and always misbehaved with them. Even she also denied
having physical relation with PW-1 for prolong time that also adversely
affected his mental condition.
[22]
The respondent treated PW-1 with physical and mental cruelty
by her refusal to have sexual relation, cruel behaviour ill-treatment to her
parents in-law, physical assault to PW-1 apart from her irritative, autocratic
habits. That due to such adamant conduct, the respondent was reluctant to
live and cohabit with PW-1 and thereby deliberately deserted PW1 from
her company. PW-2 Smt. Ratna Datta Sen (73 years), PW-4 Shital Rn. Sen
(74 years) who are parents of PW-1 as well as PW-4 Sri Sujit Das (Sr.
colleague of PW1), PW-5 Smt. Gita Rani Debnath who is the maid servant
in the house of PW-1 and PW-6, Sri Pradip Chakraborty also categorically
narrated almost the above relevant facts in their affidavit in chief at the
same tune with PW-1. So for the sake of brevity narration of their
statements is not repeated here.
[23]
In cross-examination of PW-3 replied that the respondent is a
government employee and posted at Champak Nagar Branch of TGB as
Assistant Manager. He admitted that a patient of psychopathic disorder
cannot perform job in Bank. He replied that he did not see any scope of
reunion between his son and his wife owing to their past incident and that
maid servant Smt. Gita Rani Debnath used to do part time work in their
house since Durga Puja 2017. He replied that presently his son is not
willing to lead conjugal life with the respondent and it would be impossible
for him to stay together with her.
[24]
From the oral evidence of PWs.1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 it is revealed
that the grievance of odd behavior of respondent started since the
honeymoon trip of PW-1 & DW-1 to Andaman and Nikobor Island via
Kolkata in February, 2019 soon after marriage. It is consistently revealed in
the evidence that their honeymoon trip was not happy due to dilatory habit
of the respondent in the wash room that resulted to their delayed boarding
to the tourist bus leading to annoyance to the co-travellers. Apart from this
PW-1 is also corroborated by PWs.2, 3 and 5 that respondent has odd habit
of coming out from the wash room in fully naked condition and roaming in
the room just like a lunatic person.
[25]
It is un-rebutted that PW-5 used to work as maid servant in the
house of PW-1 since October, 2017 till date. As such, she has the
opportunity to see and observe the conduct and behaviour of the respondent
inside the matrimonial house. PW-5 straightway deposed that respondent
used to come out from wash room in fully naked condition and was found
roaming in the room just like a lunatic. The testimony of PW-1 that he also
found the respondent in coming out from the wash in fully naked condition
during his honeymoon trip at Andaman Hotel, is also not disproved by the
respondent. PW-1 also tried to convince respondent to give up such habit
for the reason that it was not decent or suiting to her personality. Despite
such effort of PW-1 respondent continued her such act of exposing her
naked physique in the matrimonial house without caring its consequence
and impact upon her in-laws.
[26]
It is also convincingly revealed in the evidence of PWs that
respondent has another ugly habit of putting and accumulating her period
blood stain sanitary napkins under bed and on the rack of bathroom without
disposing them properly. Respondent being an adult woman was fully
aware of the consequence of such un-disposed rotten period napkins.
Obviously, it would release nauseating stench and also affect the
cleanliness of the house. This could be a serious issue in the woman sphere.
This unusual practice of respondent regarding disposal of her period
sanitary napkins also reflect her ill mental state. Such irrational and
reckless nature of respondent could be rectified through counseling and
other suitable treatment by a psychiatrist.
[27]
So, in our considered view, the prescribing of some medicine
by a psychiatrist for the respondent in course of her other treatment of
gynecological problem cannot be treated to be unjust or with ulterior
motive of her in-laws. Having viewed this, we find no force on the
contention of learned counsel of appellant that the evidence of PWs are not
credible in absence of medical evidence. Here the question of fact is
whether the respondent wife refused to take the medicine prescribed by the
psychiatrist despite request of PW-1 or not. PW-1 in the evidence
categorically deposed that respondent refused to take such medicine and
thereby made non-cooperation with him. Such conduct of respondent could
be painful for the husband who had thought of her better treatment but it
was not accepted. This conduct of refusal of respondent to consume the
medicine can be treated as mental cruelty to the husband.
[28]
Moreover, it is also revealed in the evidence of PWs that
during the 2nd visit of the parents of PW-1 in the rented house of
respondent they were misbehaved and humiliated by her. PW-2 and PW-3
are now aged 73 years and 74 years respectively and both are pension
holder. Thus they are senior citizens and being retired they have the desire
and aspiration to give company to their newly married daughter in law in
her rented house at Khowai. Certainly, PWs-2 and 3 were not the enemy of
respondent and they being the in-laws deserve he minimum respect,
dignity, regard and car form their daughter-in-law.
[29]
So the testimony of PW2,3,&5 cannot be discarded from
consideration, rather, they are the vital witnesses of the events taken place
in front of their eyes. So, the contention of respondent that oral evidence of
PWs depicted false story due to non-lodging of any complaint before any
forum cannot be sustainable. The persistent odd, incidents behavior and
misdeeds of respondent as experienced during the stay in the matrimonial
house, in the rented houses at Khowai and Kumarghat can be treated to be
the compelling circumstances for PW-1 to refuse to stay with the
respondent, the appellant herein.
[30]
Mere omnibus statement of torture by in-laws without any
supporting material is not credible and cannot be acted upon. Even no
medical document of any injury and treatment is exhibited by respondent to
support her plea of torture and strangulation. Therefore, the evidence of
DWs No. 1 to 6 about the atrocity and torture caused by petitioner, the
respondent herein, and his parents upon DW-1 is not trustworthy and not
believable. Rather, it is convincingly established in the evidence that it was
the respondent wife who has treated the petitioner with mental cruelty
constantly in every places of their stay in between the period of their
honeymoon trip till 20.11.2020.
[31]
Moreover, PW-1 categorically deposed in his oral evidence
that there was no relation between himself and respondent like husband and
wife except for 15 to 20 days as she denied to have physical relation with
him for prolong time. PW-1 also mentioned that due to her prolong refusal
to have sexual intercourse, his mental and physical condition got adversely
affected. From this evidence of PW-1 together with his assertion that
respondent has delinquent nature, disrespect towards her husband and inlaws and irritative attitude it is highly probable to believe that the physical
relation between the parties was not smooth and cordial. The continuous
refusal to have sexual relation by one spouse would certainly lead to mental
and physical dissatisfaction, discomfort and disturbance to the conjugal
relation. The veracity of PWs particularly PW-1 could not be impeached in
his cross-examination. Thus, the refusal of respondent to cohabit and have
sexual relation with PW-1 for a prolong period prior to their separation will
amount to mental cruelty towards him.
[32]
Moreover to establish legal cruelty it is not necessary that
physical violence should be used. Concept of cruelty defers from person to
person depending upon his upbringing, level of sensitivity, educational
family and cultural background, financial position, social status, customs,
traditions, religious belief, human values, etc. Apart from this, the concept
of mental cruelty cannot remain static; it is bound to change with the
passage of time, impact of modern culture through print and electronic
media and value system etc. What may be mental cruelty now may not
remain mental cruelty after a passage of time or vice versa. There can never
be any straight jacket formula or fixed parameters for determining mental
cruelty in matrimonial matters.
[33]
Therefore, in the light of the forgoing analysis of evidence,
proposition of laws, and reasoning cited, it can be concluded without
hesitation that petitioner has discharged his onus of prove by
preponderance of probability that after marriage and prior to 20.11.2020
respondent wife has treated the petitioner with cruelty by her irrational and
unjustified conducts. The respondent is found to be guilty of committing
conducts. The respondent is found to be guilty of committing mental
cruelty upon her husband that attracts Section-13(1) (i-a) of the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955.
[34]
Accordingly, all the allegations made against the wife on the
point of cruelty and other issues are set aside and however, the divorce
granted is confirmed. It is seen from the record that after marriage almost
they are staying separately and several allegations and counter allegations
have made against each other. At point of time it becomes impossible for
them to lead the conjugal life and there is no emotional bondage. This
Court feels that the marriage has become dead and there is no chance or
benefit of reunion and therefore, it is a fit case for dissolution of marriage.
[35]
In that view of the matter, the findings as arrived at by the
learned Court below need no interference and consequently, the order of
dissolution of marriage between the appellant and the respondent stands
confirmed. However, it is made clear that since all the allegations against
the wife appellant are expunged by this Court; she is at liberty to start her
new life.
[36]
With above observations and directions, the appeal stands
disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous application, pending if any, shall
stand closed.
B. PALIT, J
A.Ghosh
signed by ANJAN GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.04.23 14:45:20 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review