Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010490892025
2026:CGHC:28454
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRR No. 1416 of 2025
Smt. Susmita Deb, W/o. Phalguni Deb, Aged About 44 Years R/o 1689/8,
Sector-2, Jhanda Chowk, Shivanand Nagar, Ps Khamtarai, District Raipur
(C.G.)
---Applicant(s)
versus
Phalguni Deb, S/o Deepak Deb, Aged About 44 Years Permanent R/o Flat No.
2-B, Sudha Apartment, 197 J.N. Bose Road, Subhas Gram Near Railway
Gate, Post- Kodalia, Ps Sonarpur Kolkata (W.B.) Pin Code 700146 (Correct
Detailed Address Has Been Mentioned Which Was Not Mentioned In
Impugned Order) Also At- Overlook At Bear Creek, 800 E Ash Lane,
Apartment- 2123, Euless Texas (U.S.) Zip Code 76039-4700
--- Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. Kamlesh Patel, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Hemant Kesharwani, Advocate.
Hon’ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Order on Board
09/07/2026
1. Heard Mr. Kamlesh Patel, learned counsel for the applicant as well as
Mr. Hemant Kesharwani, learned counsel for the respondent. Challenge
in this revision petition filed under Section 19(4) of the Family Courts Act,
1984, is to the order dated 08.10.2025 passed by the First Additional
Principal Judge, Family Court, Raipur, in M.C.C. No. 229/2020, by which
the application filed under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code,
1973, by the revisioner seeking maintenance to the tune of Rs. 2 Lacs
per month, has been rejected.
2. Mr. Kamlesh Patel, learned counsel for the applicant, submits that the
marriage between the applicant and the respondent was solemnized on
30.01.2019 according to Hindu rites and customs. At the time of
marriage, the applicant's parents allegedly gave sufficient gold and silver
jewellery, furniture, household articles, cash and other customary gifts.
Soon after the marriage, the applicant started residing at her matrimonial
home in Kolkata, where she was allegedly subjected to cruelty and
persistent demands for dowry by the respondent and his family. It is
submitted that during the reception held at Raipur, the respondent and
his family expressed dissatisfaction with the articles given in marriage
and demanded additional items such as an AC, LED television and a
car, besides insisting that the applicant disclose details of her parental
properties and finances. It is further submitted that although the
applicant was employed at Pune and the respondent was working in
Dallas, Texas (USA), the respondent's family repeatedly pressured the
applicant to part with her salary, retained a substantial portion thereof
and compelled her to bear household expenses whenever she stayed at
Kolkata. The demands for dowry and harassment allegedly continued
during subsequent visits of the parties to Kolkata and Raipur.
3. Mr. Patel submits that the applicant ultimately resigned from her
employment and accompanied the respondent to the United States on
19.07.2019 in order to reside with him. However, even in the USA, she
was allegedly subjected to physical and mental cruelty, including
assault, verbal abuse, confinement, denial of household expenses and
continuous pressure to secure employment. It is further alleged that on
08.12.2019, the respondent physically assaulted the applicant and
thereafter abandoned her. During her illness and hospitalization, the
respondent neither provided financial assistance nor cared for her. Left
with no support, the applicant returned to her parental home at Raipur on
21.12.2019. The applicant was continuously subjected to domestic
violence and cruelty by the respondent and his family in connection with
unlawful demands for dowry at Kolkata, Raipur and even during her stay
in Texas, USA. Consequently, she has been residing at her parental
home at Raipur since 21.12.2019. On her complaint, a criminal case
under Section 498-A read with Section 34 IPC was registered against
the respondent and his family members. The applicant is suffering from
serious medical ailments.
Medical investigations
conducted
on
26.04.2024 revealed ailments including adenomyoma and other
gynaecological complications, for which she has been undergoing
expensive treatment. Despite repeated demands, the respondent and his
family have neither returned her stridhan nor provided any financial
assistance or maintenance, leaving her with insufficient means to meet
her day-to-day and medical expenses.
4. It is submitted that, having no sufficient independent means to maintain
herself, the applicant filed an application under Section 125 Cr.P.C. on
11.02.2020 before the Family Court, Raipur, claiming maintenance. The
respondent contested the proceedings by denying the allegations and
filing an affidavit regarding his income and assets. According to the
applicant, the respondent deliberately concealed his actual income and
financial status. The applicant, on the other hand, filed affidavits along
with medical records and treatment expenses to demonstrate her
financial condition and serious health issues, including spinal ailments
and cancer-related treatment requiring substantial expenditure.
5. Mr. Patel submits that the learned Family Court erroneously dismissed
the application under Section 125 Cr.P.C. solely on the ground that the
applicant is employed, without considering whether her income is
sufficient to maintain herself in a manner commensurate with the
respondent's standard of living. It is contended that the Court failed to
appreciate the evidence regarding the applicant's medical condition,
treatment expenses, and the cruelty suffered by her, which constitute
sufficient cause for residing separately from the respondent. It is further
submitted that the applicant earns approximately Rs.60,127/- per month,
whereas the respondent is employed in the USA and earns substantially
more, besides possessing considerable assets and investments. The
learned Family Court failed to consider the vast disparity in the financial
status of the parties and the settled principle that mere employment of
the wife does not disentitle her from claiming maintenance if her income
is insufficient to maintain the standard of living enjoyed by the husband. It
is, therefore, prayed that the impugned order be set aside and the
revision petition be allowed.
6. On the other hand, Mr. Hemant Kesharwani, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent submits that the applicant has not come in clean hand
before this Hon'ble Court. The applicant herself is an employed lady and
is having sufficient means to meet her expenses. She was never
subjected to any cruelty rather she had filed false cases of dowry and
domestic violence against the respondent and his family members. The
ground mentioned in the instant revision is never been submitted by the
applicant before the learned Court below, the document submitted in the
instant revision is required to examined by the trial court, the authenticity
of the document required to examined, the respondent had no
opportunity to cross examine of applicant on aforesaid document
therefore the document with not produce before the court below cannot
consider for adjudication of instant revision. The applicant filed medical
document before this Hon'ble Court which do not reflect the cancer
diseases, the document reflected that no aliment of cancer found. The
medical document dated 14.04.2026 reflected the history of the patient
that pain of left breast last for 2 months noticed pre-menopausal status,
no possibility family history for breast cancer. The perusal of the
aforesaid document it is clear that only last 2 month pain of left breast
notice by the applicant. The applicant failed to produced any treatment in
respect of the cancer antigen, if cancer antigen test is high it does not
suffer for cancer, the applicant failed to produce any evidence of breast
cancer or any suspicious lesion seen, for the determination of the cancer
test of harmonal profile is necessary but herein, the applicant not
produced any harmonal profile test. After lodging of the case under
Section 498-A of the IPC against the respondent and his family
members, the applicant deliberately did not appear before the trial court
for recording her evidence. The applicant has sufficient income to
maintain herself her maintained herself, the applicant filed an application
under Section 12 of Domestic Violence Act bearing No. MJC No.
27/2020 wherein the learned Court below has rejected the interim
maintenance vide order dated 01.11.2023 on the ground that the
applicant has suppress the her income, the applicant preferred appeal
against the dismissal of interim maintenance, however her appeal
bearing Criminal Appeal No. 243/2023 has been dismissed vide order
dated 20.03.2024, the applicant preferred revision before this Hon'ble
Court which has been rejected on dated 12.06.2025.
7. I have considered the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel for
the parties and have perused the material available on record.
8. The scope of interference in a revision against an order passed under
Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is limited. However,
where the findings recorded by the Family Court are based on an
incomplete consideration of the material or where subsequent
developments having a bearing on the entitlement of the parties are
brought to the notice of the Court, the revisional jurisdiction can be
exercised to ensure that substantial justice is done. In the present case,
the learned Family Court has recorded a categorical finding that the
applicant had sufficient cause to reside separately from the respondent.
The only ground on which the application under Section 125 Cr.P.C. has
been rejected is that the applicant was found to be earning sufficiently to
maintain herself. While arriving at the said conclusion, the Family Court
has observed that the applicant failed to establish that she was suffering
from any serious spinal ailment or that she was incurring substantial
medical expenses. Before this Court, the applicant has placed reliance
upon certain medical documents to contend that she is presently
suffering from serious gynaecological ailments and other medical
complications
requiring
continuous
treatment
and
substantial
expenditure. The respondent, on the other hand, has disputed the
genuineness and evidentiary value of the said documents and has
contended that the documents were never produced before the Family
Court and, therefore, he had no opportunity to cross-examine the
applicant or lead rebuttal evidence. It has further been contended that
the medical documents do not establish that the applicant is suffering
from cancer or any life-threatening disease. The respondent has also
contended during the course of arguments that after the outbreak of the
Covid-19 pandemic, he lost his employment in the United States and is
presently not earning as alleged by the applicant. Though there is no
specific pleading, the said submission indicates that the financial
position of the respondent is also a disputed question requiring
adjudication on the basis of proper evidence. It has also been brought to
the notice of this Court that the respondent has filed an application under
Section 340 Cr.P.C. alleging suppression of material facts by the
applicant regarding her actual income.
9. While determining a claim for maintenance, the Court is required to
ascertain not merely whether the wife is employed, but whether she
possesses sufficient independent means to maintain herself having
regard to her reasonable needs, medical expenses, income, liabilities
and the financial capacity of the husband. Likewise, the actual earning
capacity and financial status of the husband are equally relevant
considerations. Such issues are essentially questions of fact and ought
to be decided on the basis of complete evidence.
10.
In the facts of the present case, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the controversy regarding the applicant's present medical condition
and the extent of expenditure incurred by her on treatment, as also the
actual income and financial capacity of both the parties, cannot
appropriately be adjudicated in the present revisional proceedings on
the basis of documents produced for the first time before this Court.
Since these documents were admittedly not before the Family Court, the
respondent has not had an opportunity to test their authenticity or
correctness by way of cross-examination or by leading rebuttal
evidence. Similarly, the respondent's plea regarding his present financial
condition also requires appropriate pleadings and evidence.
11.
Having regard to the aforesaid facts and in the interest of justice, this
Court is of the view that the matter deserves to be remitted to the
learned Family Court for a fresh adjudication on the limited issues
relating to (i) the applicant's present medical condition and the effect
thereof on her capacity to maintain herself, including the medical
expenses incurred by her; (ii) the actual income, assets and financial
capacity of the applicant; and (iii) the present income, employment
status, assets and financial capacity of the respondent.
12.
Accordingly, the impugned order dated 08.10.2025 passed by the
learned First Additional Principal Judge, Family Court, Raipur in M.C.C.
No.229/2020, insofar as it rejects the claim for maintenance, is set aside
and the matter is remanded to the learned Family Court for fresh
consideration on the aforesaid issues. The learned Family Court shall
afford adequate opportunity to both parties to amend their pleadings, if
so advised, and to adduce additional oral as well as documentary
evidence with regard to their respective income, assets, liabilities,
employment status and the applicant's medical condition and treatment
expenses. The parties shall also be afforded full opportunity to crossexamine the witnesses produced by the opposite side. Consequently,
the revision petition stands allowed.
13.
It is clarified that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits
of the rival claims regarding the applicant's entitlement to maintenance
or the quantum thereof. All issues are left open to be decided
independently by the learned Family Court on the basis of the evidence
that may be adduced by the parties and in accordance with law. Since
the proceedings arise out of an application under Section 125 Cr.P.C.,
which is intended to provide speedy relief, the learned Family Court shall
make an endeavour to decide the matter expeditiously, preferably within
a period of two months from the date of appearance of the parties before
it, without granting unnecessary adjournments. The parties are directed
to appear before the learned First Additional Principal Judge, Family
Court, Raipur on 17.07.2026 or on such date as may be fixed by the
learned Family Court.
14.
A copy of this order be sent to the concerned Family Court for necessary
information and compliance, forthwith.
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Amit
AMIT
KUMAR
DUBEY
AMIT KUMAR
DUBEY
Date: 2026.07.13
17:44:35 +0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review