Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NAFR
Digitally signed
INDRAJEET
INDRAJEET by
SAHU
SAHU
Date: 2026.02.02
13:28:35 +0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ACQA No. 463 of 2025
1 - Smt. Sushma Kothari W/o Om Kothari Aged About 53 Years R/o Ward No.
17, Patel Ward Near Jain Mandir Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh DistrictRajnandgaon.
--- Appellant
versus
1 - Sikandar Ali S/o Naamdaar Khan Aged About 72 Years R/o Solhapara
Ward No. 17, Dongargarh Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, District- Rajnandgaon
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Akbar Ali S/o Sikandar Ali Aged About 42 Years R/o Solhapara Ward
No.17, Dongargarh Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, District- Rajnandgaon,
Chhattisgarh.
3 - Gopal Khemuka S/o Late Amarchand Khemukha Aged About 58 Years
R/o Ward No.17, Dongargarh Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh DistrictRajnandgaon Chhattisgarh.
4 - State of Chhattisgarh Through District- Magistrate, Rajnandgaon, DistrictRajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
ACQA No. 466 of 2025
1 - Smt. Sushma Kothari W/o Om Kothari Aged About 53 Years R/o Ward No.
17, Patel Ward, Near Jain Mandir, Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, District,
Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
--- Appellant
Versus
1 - Gopal Khemuka S/o Late Amarchand Khemukha Aged About 58 Years
R/o Ward No. 17, Dongargarh, Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, DistrictRajnandgaon (C.G.)
2 - Sikandar Ali S/o Naamdaar Khan Aged About 72 Years R/o Solhapara,
Ward No. 17, Dongargarh, Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, District-Rajnandgaon
(C.G.)
3 - Akbar Ali S/o Sikandar Ali Aged About 42 Years R/o Solhapara, Ward No.
17, Dongargarh, Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, District-Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
4 - State of Chhattisgarh Through District Magistrate, Rajnandgaon, District
Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
ACQA No. 467 of 2025
1 - Smt. Sushma Kothari W/o Om Kothari Aged About 53 Years R/o Ward No.
17, Patel Ward, Near Jain Mandir, Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, District
Rajnandgaon.
---Appellant
Versus
1 - Akbar Ali S/o Sikandar Ali Aged About 42 Years R/o Solhapara, Ward No.
17, Dongargarh, Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, District Rajnandgaon,
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Sikandar Ali S/o Naamdaar Khan Aged About 72 Years R/o Solhapara,
Ward No. 17, Dongargarh, Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh, District
Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh.
3 - Gopal Khemuka S/o Late Amarchand Khemukha Aged About 58 Years
R/o Solhapara, Ward No. 17, Dongargarh, Tehsil And P.S. Dongargarh,
District Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh.
4 - State of Chhattisgarh Through District Magistrate, Rajnandgaon, District
Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
For Appellant
:
For State
:
For RespondentGopal Khemuka
:
For Respondents:
Akabar Ali & Sikandar Ali
Shri B.P. Singh and Shri Roshan Singh
Lamba, Advocates.
Shri Vikhyat Arora and Shri Jai Prakash
Tiwari, Panel Lawyers.
Shri V. Jayant Kumar on behalf of Shri
Prakash Tiwari (in Acq. Appeal No.466 of
2025).
Shri M.P.S. Bhatia, Advocate.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Judgment on Board
29.01.2026
1.
Since all these Acquittal Appeals arise out of common judgment and
same Criminal Case, they are being heard and decided together by
this common judgment.
2.
All these appeals have been filed the appellant/complainant against
the impugned judgment dated 07.03.2024 passed by the Additional
Sessions Judge, Dongargarh, District Rajnandgaon, in Criminal
Appeal Nos. 04/2024, 02/2024 and 03/2024 respectively which were
arising out of judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated
11.12.2023 passed by Additional Chief Judgment Judicial Magistrate,
Dongarhgarh, District Rajnandgaon, in Complaint Case No.64/2015.
3.
Brief facts of the case are that, the appellant-Smt. Sushma Kothari
was complainant before the trial court who prosecuted a complaint
case for the offence under Sections 500,501,502 and 34 IPC against
six proposed accused persons with the allegation that the complainant
was an elected member of Ward No.15, Municipal Council Dongargarh
and having good reputation in locality and community. The proposed
accused No.1 to 3 started unauthorized construction near government
Well at Ward No.15 without obtaining due permission from the
Municipal Council Dongargarh. Being the elected ward member and
responsible person of the vicinity, she made a complaint on
11.05.2012 to the Chief Municipal Officer, Municipal Council
Dongargarha and SDO(Revenue) Dongargarh for which the proposed
accused No.1 to 3 were having grudge against her. In furtherance to
settle their grievance, the proposed accused persons got a news
published on 16.05.2012 in daily newspaper Dainik Bhaskar alleging
that the complainant, who is ward member of Ward No.15, is
demanding bribe. The said new item was circulated in public in
general due to which she felt defamed. The allegation against the
proposed accused No.4 is that, he being the local correspondent of
newspaper, without verifying the true facts, got it published in the
newspaper. The proposed accused No.5 helped him in doing so and
proposed accused No.6 was local publisher of Dainik Bhaskar
newspaper, and therefore, she filed a complaint case for punishing the
proposed accused persons for her defamation.
4.
The said complaint case was registered by the trial court, process was
issued and proposed accused No.1 to 4 appeared and defended their
case. The proposed accused No.5&6 did not make their appearance
before the trial court and vide order dated 25.08.2023, trial against
proposed accused No.5&6 namely Rajeev Singh and Kamalkant
Sharma were separated and warrant of arrest was issued against
them and trial against 4 accused persons were proceeded. On
02.09.2023 the details of offence under Section 500 IPC were framed
against four accused persons. All the four accused persons challenged
the order dated 02.09.2023 by which the details of offence were
explained before the Additional Sessions Judge Dongargarh in
Criminal Revision No.16/2023 which was decided on 04.11.2023 and
revision with respect to accused No.3-Apsari Begum was allowed and
she was discharged from the alleged offence, however, with respect to
accused No.1,2 & 4, the revision was dismissed and trial was
proceeded against three accused persons namely Sikandar Ali, Akbar
Ali and Gopal Khemuka. During trial, the parties led their evidence and
after conclusion of trial, all the three accused persons were convicted
for the offence under Section 500 IPC and sentenced S.I. for two
years with fine of Rs.1000/-, in default of payment of fine, additional SI
for six months. Out of the total amount of fine, an amount of Rs.3000/was ordered to be paid to the complainant as compensation. Against
the judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 11.12.2023, all
the three accused persons preferred three separate Criminal Appeals
before the Additional Sessions Judge Dongargarh vide Criminal
Appeal Nos. 04/2024, 02/2024 and 03/2024 respectively. Those
Criminal Appeals came up for hearing before the court on 07.03.2024
and after hearing the parties the Additional Sessions Judge,
Dongargarh, allowed their appeals and acquitted the accused persons
from the offence of Section 500 IPC by giving benefits of exception
1&2 of explanation-4 of Section 499 IPC. Against the said judgment of
acquittal, the complainant has filed these acquittal appeals separately,
however, the complainant has made all the three accused persons as
party respondent in these three appeals only to avoid any procedural
controversy.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant/complainant would
submit that the first appellate court has failed to consider the evidence
available on record in its proper perspective. Once the news item
published in daily newspaper defames the complainant, it affects her
reputation in the society as well as community. Without verifying the
true facts the news items were published. The well reasoned judgment
passed by the trial court has been reversed by the first appellate court
without adverting the entire evidence produced by the complainant.
Though there are certain exceptions provided under Section 499 IPC,
however, the act of accused persons duly satisfies the requirement of
Section 499 IPC and the act of accused persons do not come under
any exception, yet benefit of the same has been extended to them by
the revisional court. He would further submit that the complainant has
also filed a Civil Suit for compensation in which a decree has been
passed in her favour and appeal there-against filed by the accused is
pending consideration before coordinate Bench of this court. Once a
decree has been passed for compensation on the same subject matter
which prima facie satisfies the ingredients of defamation of the
complainant, these acquittal appeals may be allowed and the
respondents-accused persons may be held guilty for the alleged
offence.
6.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respective respondents
supported the impugned judgment passed by the revisional court and
submitted that after adverting the entire facts and circumstances of the
case as well as the provisions of Section 499 and 500 IPC they have
passed appropriate judgment acquitting them from the alleged offence.
There is no evidence available on record that the said news items
were published by the accused persons or published on their instance.
It is only apprehension of the complainant that such news items were
published on the instance of the accused persons. Though, by the said
news item, it may have differ the reputation of a person, but before
holding conviction, the complainant has to prove that the said news
item was published by the accused persons. In absence of any cogent
and clinching material and evidence they cannot convicted for the
alleged offence. The complainant has failed to prove her case beyond
reasonable doubt. Therefore, the judgment of acquittal passed by the
revisional court does not require any interference and all these
appeals are liable to be dismissed.
7.
I have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the record of trial
court.
8.
It is not in dispute that news items were published in daily newspaper
Dainik Bhaskar on 16.05.2012 with the heading “okMZ&15 dh ik"kZn ij
vuqefr ds fy, :i, ekaxus dk vkjksi”. It is also not in dispute that on
the same date i.e. on 16.05.2012 another article was published with
respect to same subject matter in Sabera Sanket daily newspaper,
Rajnandgaon Edition with the heading “ik"kZn
ds f[kykQ fey jgh
f’kdk;rsa”. Both these news articles have been reiterated in para 10 and
11 of the judgment dated 07.03.2024 passed by revisional court. From
perusal of these news article it transpires that it was alleged against
the present appellant/complainant, who is Ward Member of Ward
No.15, that she demanded illegal consideration for giving No Objection
Certificate to raise illegal construction and for other purposes.
Although, said news articles directly concern with the present
complainant/appellant, but it cannot be said that the said news articles
were published by the accused persons, or it was published on their
instance.
9.
The complainant has been examined before the trial court as PW-1.
She has admitted in her cross examination that when she received
complaint with respect to illegal construction in the vicinity, she made
no enquiry. She admits that one Ajay Thakur made a complaint against
her with respect to alleged publication of article in newspaper, but
neither she made any complaint nor took any action against Ajay
Thakur. She also admits that she did not know in how much area the
illegal construction was being raised by the person concerned. She
admits that she is prosecuting a Civil Suit against Dainik Bhaskar and
Sabera Sanket newspaper for compensation. In the said Civil Suit,
after passing of judgment, Sikandar Ali and Akbar Ali had deposited
the amount, which she has received. She also admits that Publisher
and Editor of Sabera Sanket newspaper apologized from her on the
issue of said article, which she accepted. She admits of her making
complaint to the Chief Municipal Council, Dongargarh with respect to
illegal construction raised by the accused Sikandar, but she did not
know what action has been taken thereof. Presently the construction
work of the house of Sikandar Ali is over. She admits that despite
publication of said news article in Ex.P/1, she has neither been
expelled from the political party from which she is the member, nor any
action has been taken by the community members. In Sabera Sanket
newspaper it is alleged that she demanded Rs.10,000/-from Ajay
Thakur as illegal consideration, but she admits that she has not made
any complaint against Ajay Thakur. In paragraph 45 of her cross
examination she further admits that rebuttal of the allegation of news
article was also published by Dainik Bhaskar Newspaper, but it was
not published as per her wish, but was published as per their own
choice.
10.
Despite lengthy and detailed cross examination from this witness, it
does not transpire any material that accused persons were involved in
publishing such news article in daily newspaper Dainik Bhaskar, or in
their instance the said news articles were published. Likewise, from
the evidence of PW-2, Omprakash Kothari and PW-3, Jarnail Singh
Kakkad, there is no clinching material which could be taken out to hold
conviction of the respondent-accused persons for the offence of
defamation of the complainant.
11.
The appellate court, considering exception 1&2 of explanation-4 of
Section 499 IPC and also considering the evidence produced by the
complainant, allowed the criminal revision and acquitted the accused
persons from the alleged offence. It is necessary here to notice
exception 1&2 of explanation-4 of Section 499 IPC, which reads as
under:
“499. Defamation. Whoever, by words either spoken or intended to
be read, or by signs or by visible representations, makes or publishes
any imputation concerning any person intending to harm, or knowing
or having reason to believe that such imputation will harm, the
reputation of such person, is said, except in the cases hereinafter
excepted, to defame that person.
XXXX
Explanation 4.—No imputation is said to harm a person's reputation,
unless that imputation directly or indirectly, in the estimation of others,
lowers the moral or intellectual character of that person, or lowers the
character of that person in respect of his caste or of his calling, or
lowers the credit of that person, or causes it to be believed that the
body of that person is in a lothsome state, or in a state generally
considered as disgraceful.
First Exception.—Imputation of truth which public good requires
to be made or published.—It is not defamation to impute anything
which is true concerning any person, if it be for the public good that
the imputation should be made or published. Whether or not it is for
the public good is a question of fact.
Second Exception.—Public conduct of public servants.—It is not
defamation to express in good faith any opinion whatever respecting
the conduct of a public servant in the discharge of his public functions,
or respecting his character, so far as his character appears in that
conduct, and no further.
XXX
12.
Applying the law governing the scope of interference in an appeal
against acquittal, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Rajasthan Vs. Kistoora Ram, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 984, has held
as under:"8. The scope of interference in an appeal against acquittal is
very limited. Unless it is found that the view taken by the Court is
impossible or perverse, it is not permissible to interfere with the
finding of acquittal. Equally if two views are possible, it is not
permissible to set aside an order of acquittal, merely because
the Appellate Court finds the way of conviction to be more
probable. The interference would be warranted only if the view
taken is not possible at all."
13. In Jafarudheen and Others Vs. State of Kerala, 2022 (8) SCC 440,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has considered the scope of interference
in appeal against acquittal in judgement at para 25, which reads as
under:“25. While dealing with an appeal against acquittal by invoking
Section 378 of the Cr.P.C., the Appellate Court has to consider
whether the Trial Court’s view can be termed as a possible one,
particularly when evidence on record has been analyzed. The
reason is that an order of acquittal adds up to the presumption of
innocence in favour of the accused. Thus, the Appellate Court
has to be relatively slow in reversing the order of the trial court
rendering acquittal. Therefore, the presumption in favour of the
accused does not get weakened but only strengthened. Such a
double presumption that ensures in favour of the accused has to
be disturbed only by thorough scrutiny on the accepted legal
parameters.”
14. Further, in case of Central Bureau of Investigation Vs. Shyam
Bihari & Others, 2023 (8) SCC 197, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held in para 27 of its judgment that :“27. It is trite law that in an appeal against acquittal, the power of
appellate court to re-appreciate evidence and come to its own
conclusion is not circumscribed by any limitation. But it is equally
settled that the appellate court must not interfere with an order of
acquittal merely because a contrary view is permissible,
particularly, where the view taken by the trial court is a plausible
view based on proper appreciation of evidence and is not
vitiated by ignorance/misreading of relevant evidence on
record.”
15.
After considering the material available on record as well as the
elaborate judgment passed by the learned revisional court and being
very much conscious of the existing legal position as held in case of
Kistoora Ram, Jafarudheen and Shyam Bihari (Supra) that in an
appeal against acquittal if two views are possible on the basis of the
evidence led by the prosecution and the trial court taking one view
favoured the accused, reversion of the findings of acquittal by the
appellate court taking the other possible view into consideration, is not
permissible in law. Therefore, I am of the considered opinion that the
judgment impugned acquitting the accused/respondents is just and
proper and does not call for any interference.
16.
Accordingly, all the acquittal appeals filed by the complainant against
the accused persons are hereby dismissed.
17.
Records of trial court along with copy of this judgment be sent back
immediately to the trial court concerned for compliance and necessary
action.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review