Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA 42 of 2019
1. Smt. Sunanda Banik,
daughter of late Birendra Lal Banik, wife of Sri Pradip kumar Banik,
resident of Town Pratapgarh, P.S. East Agartala, District- West Tripura
2.a. Smt. Bibha Banik,
wife of late Bidhan chandra Banik @ Bidhan Banik, resident of 11/A
Thakurpalli Road, Krishnanagar, Kadamtali, P.S. West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura
2.b. Sri Bijan Banik,
son of late Bidhan chandra Banik @ Bidhan Banik, resident of 11/A
Thakurpalli Road, Krishnanagar, Kadamtali, P.S. West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura
2.c. Sri Bikash Banik,
son of late Bidhan chandra Banik @ Bidhan Banik, resident of 11/A
Thakurpalli Road, Krishnanagar, Kadamtali, P.S. West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura
2.d. Sri Bipul Banik,
son of late Bidhan chandra Banik @ Bidhan Banik, resident of 11/A
Thakurpalli Road, Krishnanagar, Kadamtali, P.S. West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura
2.e. Smt. Sheli Banik,
daughter of late Bidhan chandra Banik @ Bidhan Banik, wife of Sri
Rakhal chandra Banik, resident of Joynagar, P.O. Birendranagar,
P.S. Jirania, District- West Tripura
2.f. Smt. Mili Banik,
daughter of late Bidhan chandra Banik @ Bidhan Banik, wife of Sri
Suman Dey, resident of Bhati Abhoynagar, Cantonment road, Agartala,
P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura
3. Smt. Bela Rani Banik,
daughter of late Brajendra Lal Banik, wife of Sri Makhan Lal Banik,
resident of Banik Nivas, Shantipara, near Sreeram Oil Mills, P.S. East
Agartala, District- West Tripura
4. Smt. Ava Banik @ Ava Chakraborty @ Ava Banik Chakraborty,
wife of late Sadhan Chakraborty, resident of Banik Nivas, Shantipara,
near Sreeram Oil Mills, P.S. East Agartala, District- West Tripura
5. Smt. Sandhya Banik, wife of Sri Milan Kanti Banik, resident of Old
Kalibari Lane, near Skylark Club, Krishnanagar, Agartala, P.S. West
Agartala, District- West Tripura
Page 2
6. Smt. Sova Banik, wife of Sri Swapan Banik, resident of Shantipara,
behind Mayur Hotel, P.S. East Agartala, District- West Tripura
7. Smt. Sagarika Banik (Das), daughter of late Maya Banik, wife of Sri
Ramu chandra Das, resident of 4/6 no. Para, Anandanagar, P.S. Sreenagar,
District- West Tripura
.... Appellants
VERSUS
Sri Bimal Banik, son of late Bidhan chandra Banik @ Bidhan Banik,
resident of Thakur Palli Road, opposite TVS Showroom, Krishnanagar,
P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura
... Respondents
For Appellant (s )
For Respondent (s)
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
None
Mr. B. Saha, Advocate
:
:
11.03.2022
No.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(Arindam Lodh, J.)
1.
As we had heard Mr. K. Datta, learned counsel representing the appellants
substantially on 04.02.2022, we proceeded to hear Mr. B. Saha, learned counsel for
the respondent.
2.
This is an appeal filed under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
against the judgment dated 29.08.2019 and decree dated 07.09.2019 passed by the
learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court no.1 in case No. Title Suit (Partition) 36
of 2018.
3.
Considering the arguments, as advanced by Mr. Datta, learned counsel, we
have perused the judgment passed by the learned trial court. The present suit
instituted by the plaintiffs is a suit for partition concerning the suit land measuring
Page 3
0.0830 acres. It is a very small piece of land, but, sharers are more compared to the
land. Here we find there are eight co-sharers. Having considered the land in question
and the number of co-sharers, the learned trial court had observed thus:
“So the situation as it prevails now is that there is a piece of land measuring
0.0830 acres which converted to square feet comes to 3615.48 squarefoot. As the
gift deeds went off, this land is required to be partitioned in eight shares. One
share is of late Rajabala Banik(W/O Late Brajendra Lal Banik) which will be again
distributed equally amongst the remaining seven as she is no more. One share
will be given to plaintiff no 1(A) and 1(B) being heirs of Birendra Lal Banik.
Similarly plaintiff no 2(A) to 2(F) and the defendant will be entitled for one share
being heirs of Bidhan Banik. Plaintiff No.7 being the only legal heir of Maya Banik
will get one share. Remaining plaintiff Nos. 3, 4,5 and 6 will get one share each. So
each of the share will come to 516.4 square foot approximately which in case of
plaintiff no 1 , 2 and the defendant will again get further divided. The defendant
and plaintiff no 2(A) to (F) willget one-seventh share of 516.4 square foot which
will stand around 73 square foot approximately.
The partition of the suit land will certainly lead to fragmentation of the
suit land which is otherwise not permitted under the local law of Tripura Land
Revenue and land Reforms Act, 1960. The relevant section 181 of the Act runs:
Partition of holding.(1) No holding shall be partitioned in such manner as to
create a fragment. (2) A fragment shall not be partitioned unless as a result of
such partition its portions get merged in holdings of two standard acres or more
or in fragments so as to create holdings of two standard acres or more.
In this regard I have also travelled through the judgment reported in
SHASIDHAR & OTHERS VERSUS ASHWINI UMA MATHAD & ANR. 2015 STPL(LE)
49921 SC) in which the principles upon which a suit for partition can be
adjudicated has been discussed intricately .
Para 24 of the judgment requires to be reproduced for the sake of
discussion which is going on.
'24. We may consider it apposite to state being a well settled principle of law
that in a suit filed by a co-sharerer, coparcener, co-owner or joint owner, as the
case may be, for partition and separate possession of his/her share qua others,
it is necessary for the Court to examine, in the first instance, the nature and
character of the properties in suit such as who was the original owner of the suit
properties, how and by which source he/she acquired such properties, whether
it was his/her self-acquired property or ancestral property, or joint property or
coparcenery property in his/her hand and, if so, who are/were the coparceners
or joint owners with him/her as the case may be. Secondly, how the devolution
of his/her interest in the property took place consequent upon his/her death on
surviving members of the family and in what proportion, whether he/she died
intestate or left behind any testamentary succession in favour of any family
member or outsider to inherit his/her share in properties and if so, its effect.
Thirdly whether the properties in suit are capable of being partitioned
effectively and if so, in what manner? Lastly, whether all properties are included
Page 4
in the suit and all co-sharerers, coparceners, co- owners or joint-owners, as the
case may be, are made parties to the suit? These issues, being material for
proper disposal of the partition suit, have to be answered by the Court on the
basis of family tree, inter se relations of family members, evidence adduced and
the principles of law applicable to the case.
So the first point to be determined is nature and character of the property.
The court is to find out whether the property is such that it can be partitioned.
As discussed above the gift deeds can no more be taken into consideration
which resulted in determination of possibility of partition of the suit land in
between all the legal heirs equally .
In this regard it is found that the plaintiff 1(A) herself admitted that
partition of the suit land in seven shares will make it insufficient for any
homestead. The discussion made above clearly establises that the suit land is so
small in area that it is incapable of being partitioned amongst so many legal heirs.
Section 2 of the Partition Act, 1893 runs :2. Power to court to order sale
instead of division in partition suits.—Whenever in any suit for partition in which,
if instituted prior to the commencement of this Act, a decree for partition might
have been made, it appears to the court that, by reason of the nature of the
property to which the suit relates, or of the number of the shareholders therein, or
of any other special circumstance, a division of the property cannot reasonably or
conveniently be made, and that a sale of the property and distribution of the
proceeds would be more beneficial for all the shareholders, the court may, if it
thinks fit, on the request of any of such shareholders interested individually or
collectively to the extent of one moiety or upwards, direct a sale of the property
and a distribution of the proceeds.
In the present case no such request is made. However the parties are
appraised of their right given under the above provision.
To sum up it is held that the considering the area of the suit land and
number of shareholders the division of property can not be made conveniently
and accordingly the suit land is found to be not capable of being partitioned as
per the prayer of the plaintiffs.
The issues are decided accordingly.
Issue no. iv and v
iv. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get a decree as prayed for ?
v. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get any other relief or reliefs ?
Both the issues are taken up together.
Above it is discussed that the suit land is not found to be capable of being
partitioned amongst so many share holders. Accordingly, the plaintiffs are found
to be not entitled for a decree of partition as prayed for.
They are also found to be not entitled for any other relief or reliefs.
Both the issues are decided accordingly against the plaintiffs.
8.
ORDER
“In the result, the suit of the plaintiffs is dismissed opining that the suit
land is not capable of being partitioned amongst the parties to the suit as it will
create fragment.
The suit is disposed of on contest with cost.
Make necessary entry in the relevant Trial Register.
Page 5
Prepare decree accordingly and put up before me for signature within 14
(fourteen) days from today
Pronounced in the open court.””
4.
We, further have noticed that the learned trial court has disbelieved the gift
deed. After perusal of the gift deed and the evidences let in by the beneficiaries of the
gift deed, we also cannot disagree with the findings of the learned trial court. After
consideration of the findings of the learned trial court, we find no infirmity in the
findings of the learned trial court and the doctrine arrived at by the learned trial court
on the basis of the aforesaid findings is hereby approved.
5.
Accordingly, the suit of the plaintiff is dismissed. The judgment and decree
passed by the learned trial court stand upheld and affirmed.
Draw the decree accordingly.
Pending application (s) if any, also stands disposed.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
Saikat
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review