The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. 07.2023 YES/NO JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL] Heard Mr. N. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellant also heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing for the respondents. [2] The present appeal has been filed under Section-54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 for enhancement of the award passed by the learned Land Acquisition Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in reference with the case No. L.A. (Ref.) 176 of 2019 passed on 15.02.2022 whereby the learned L.A. Judge has awarded a paltry compensation ignoring the evidence on record. [3] In accordance with provision of the L.A. Act, the respondent No.2 i.e. the L.A. Collector acquired some land for the requiring department, N.F. Railway, i.e. the appellant No.1 for the purpose of construction of new railway line from Agartala to Sabroom at mouja Sabroom under Sabroom Sub-Division vide notification dated 17.06.2013. Total land measuring 0.80 acres of land of the claimant-petitioner acquired by the government for the requiring department of Hal Plot No.512 under Khatian No.1348 classified as tilla class of land along with the standing rubber trees and other valuable trees on the land of the owner claimant petitioner, appellant herein claimed at the rate of 40,00,000/- per kani for the acquired land and also claimed the compensation for the trees damaged by the respondents for construction of New Railway line from Agartala to…
17. 06.2013. The claimant-appellant has submitted sale Deed No. I-357 of the year 2015, sale Deed No. I-310 of the year 2015, sale Deed No.I-66 of the year 2015 and sale Deed No. I-550 of the year 2014, registered with the Sub-Registrar, Sabroom. So, these sale deeds submitted by the claimant cannot be taken into consideration as because the land of all the sale deeds was executed after acquisition of the land of the claimant. Thus, in absence of cogent evidence these sale deeds cannot be the basis for determination of market value. [14] While determining the value of land, the L.A. Collector relied on the valuation chart regarding plot wise value of land as communicated by the SDM, Sabroom vide his No.4102, dated 30.10.2013 and awarded for the acquired land @ Rs.2,00,000/- per kani. Nothing was mentioned as to how they calculated the value of the acquired land. The petitioner in her examination-in-chief on affidavit has stated that the acquired land is situated adjacent to the NH-44 and Sabroom Nagar Panchayat and has got high commercial potentiality. The O.P. No.1 in his written objection has stated that the acquired land is situated approximately at Gram Panchayat /Nagar Panchayat area. However, the L.A. Collector awarded @Rs.2,00,000/- per kani for the acquired Tilla class of land and the award of the L.A. Collector is found to be based with no reasons. [15] The Government of T…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
L.A. App. No.36 of 2022
1.
Smti. Shibani Majumder, wife of Sri Samir Majumder of Anandapara,
Sabroom, P.O. Sabroom, P.S. Sabroom, District: South Tripura, Pin799145.
…..Claimant-petitioner-appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction-2), N.F. Railway, Agartala,
West Tripura, Badharghat Railway Station, P.O. Siddhi Ashram, P.S.
Amtali, District: West Tripura.
2.
The Land Acquisition Collector, South Tripura, Belonia, P.O. Belonia,
P.S. Belonia, District: South Tripura, Pin-799155.
…..Respondents.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. N. Majumder,, Advocate.
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI.
20.07.2023
YES/NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. N. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant also heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing for
the respondents.
[2]
The present appeal has been filed under Section-54 of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 for enhancement of the award passed by the learned Land
Acquisition Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in reference with the case No. L.A.
(Ref.) 176 of 2019 passed on 15.02.2022 whereby the learned L.A. Judge has
awarded a paltry compensation ignoring the evidence on record.
[3]
In accordance with provision of the L.A. Act, the respondent No.2
i.e. the L.A. Collector acquired some land for the requiring department, N.F.
Railway, i.e. the appellant No.1 for the purpose of construction of new railway
line from Agartala to Sabroom at mouja Sabroom under Sabroom Sub-Division
vide notification dated 17.06.2013. Total land measuring 0.80 acres of land of the
claimant-petitioner acquired by the government for the requiring department of
Hal Plot No.512 under Khatian No.1348 classified as tilla class of land along with
the standing rubber trees and other valuable trees on the land of the owner
claimant petitioner, appellant herein claimed at the rate of 40,00,000/- per kani for
the acquired land and also claimed the compensation for the trees damaged by the
respondents for construction of New Railway line from Agartala to Sabroom at
Mouja Sabrrom.
[4]
The learned L.A. Collector allowed compensation Rs.2,00,000/- per
kani for till class of land and awarded Rs.5,97,625/- for the acquired land
measuring 0.80 acre along with solatium and statutory interest and Rs.53,625/- for
destruction cost of rubber trees @ of Rs.325/-. The learned L.A. Collector did not
ascertain the proper market value of the acquired land and also not made proper
assessment and their claim for enhancement of compensation at the time of
hearing before him totally ignored.
[5]
It is has been submitted that the Rubber Board by reference
communication dated 28.03.2012 made out the guideline for computing for rubber
trees just tapped trees after 6 years completed and stepping to 7 years for yielding
the latex @ Rs.10,000/- per rubber trees and also @ Rs.15,000/- per rubber tree to
be added for the benefit of furniture wood, fire wood etc. of rubber trees. During
hearing under Section-11 of the L.A. Act, on behalf of the claimant produced
registered sale deed No.1-443 dated 05.12.2011 of till class of land @
Rs.8,00,000/- per kani and another sale deed No.1-183 dated 08.04.2011 of nal
class of land @ Rs.8,00,000/- per kani those deeds executed under un-revised
valuation chart of the SDM Sabroom only to get the valid registration.
[6]
To establish the claim, the claimant filed her examination in chief on
affidavit and proved the documents, though the documents filed after the date of
notification was not considered by the learned L.A. Judge. From the side of the
opposite party, the L.A. Collector one Sri Susanta Bhattacharjee, Revenue
Inspector attached to the office of the DM & Collector, South Tripura filed his
examination-in-chief on affidavit and also cross examined but no document is
proved.
[7]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
having gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Land
Acquisition, Judge has observed as under:
“12. The claimant shall get compensation for the acquired Tilla class of land
at the enhanced rate @ Rs.6,40,000/- (Rupees six lakh forty thousand) per
kani. The claimant shall get compensation @ Rs.5,000/- per Rubber tree for
165 Nos. of 6 years old Rubber tree. The claimant is also entitled to all other
admissible statutory benefits. The claimant will also get Rs.1000/- as cost
under section 27 of the Act. The Opposite Parties are liable to make the
payment.”
[8]
Mr. N. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the learned L.A. Judge, South Tripura has committed gross error in
awarding the compensation as referred to above to the claimant-appellant. The
learned L.A. Judge ought to have passed the award by perusing the relevant
documents as produced by the claimant-appellant which was exhibited in the
Court. The rate of the land ought to have considered @ Rs.40,00,000/- per kani
for the acquire land and Rs.25,000/- for each rubber trees as destroyed. The
learned L.A. Judge miserably failed to appreciate that the award passed by the
L.A. Collector for the till class of land belonging to the appellant was too meager
and low in comparison with the prevalent price of the said land.
[9]
The learned L.A. Judge also committed serious error while
calculating and determining the price of the rubber tree standing on the acquired
land and thus fixed Rs.5,000/- per tree instead of Rs.25,000/- for each rubber tree
for the life span of rubber trees considering all relevant factors associated with the
rubber trees with the assessment of Rubber Board, the value of tree, the value of
furniture wood and fire wood, timber etc. which are ignored by the learned L.A.
Judge. It has been further submitted that the at the time of acquisition the adjacent
land of the aforesaid mouja was at the rate of Rs.40,00,000/- per kani. Because of
unrevised valuation chart the collected deeds of Doulbari Mouja of Sabroom T.K.
are not reflected the correct market value.
[10]
The learned L.A. Judge ought to consider the aforesaid deeds
considering the circumstances that the deed of 2012 just before the acquisition
was according to unrevised valuation chart and in those deeds does not reflected
the correct market value of the land. The learned Judge considering the difference
of year for the reasons every year enhanced the value of the land, to that
calculation can deduct 10% per year from the aforesaid Rs.58,60,000/- per kani,
thus, stands @ Rs.46,88,000/- per kani.
[11]
In view of above discussion and observation, to come to a definite
conclusion, let us discuss the issues once again. The appellant examined herself as
PW-1 and for and on behalf of the L.A. Collector, Sri Susanta Bhattacharjee,
Revenue Inspector, attached to the Office of the D.M. & Collector, South Tripura,
Belonia examined himself as OPW-1. The appellant in this case relying on
comparable sale method relied on sale deed vide No. I-357 of the year 2015, sale
Deed No. I-310 of the year 2015, sale Deed No.I-66 of the year 2015 and sale
Deed No. I-550 of the year 2014 registered with the Sub-Registrar, Sabroom.
[12]
The Government of Tripura set up a land valuation assessment
committee for the purpose of collecting revenue from the sale transaction which is
in the lower side and cannot form the basis for determining the actual value of
land. The L.A. Collector consulted 04 Nos. of sale instances. The land of Sl. No.1
was sold on 13.01.2012 @ Rs.2,26,000/- per kani and class of land is Tilla, the
land of Sl. No.2 (Pukur, Pukurpar) was sold in the year 2012 @ Rs.6,00,000/- per
kani, the land of Sl. No.3 was sold in the year 2012 @ Rs.1,00,000/- per kani and
class of land is (Tilla, Bastu) and the land of Sl. No.4 was sold in the year 2011
@Rs.8,00,000/- per kani and class of land is Bastu (Tilla). But the sale deeds were
not taken into consideration as according to the L.A. Collector no land of sale
deed found to the considerable for fixing the actual land value. However, the L.A.
Collector relied on the valuation chart regarding plot wise value of land as
communicated by the SDM, Sabroom vide his No.4102, dated 30.10.2013 and
awarded for the acquired land @ Rs.2,00,000/- per kani.
[13]
The land of the claimant was acquired vide Notification dated
17.06.2013. The claimant-appellant has submitted sale Deed No. I-357 of the year
2015, sale Deed No. I-310 of the year 2015, sale Deed No.I-66 of the year 2015
and sale Deed No. I-550 of the year 2014, registered with the Sub-Registrar,
Sabroom. So, these sale deeds submitted by the claimant cannot be taken into
consideration as because the land of all the sale deeds was executed after
acquisition of the land of the claimant. Thus, in absence of cogent evidence these
sale deeds cannot be the basis for determination of market value.
[14]
While determining the value of land, the L.A. Collector relied on the
valuation chart regarding plot wise value of land as communicated by the SDM,
Sabroom vide his No.4102, dated 30.10.2013 and awarded for the acquired land
@ Rs.2,00,000/- per kani. Nothing was mentioned as to how they calculated the
value of the acquired land. The petitioner in her examination-in-chief on affidavit
has stated that the acquired land is situated adjacent to the NH-44 and Sabroom
Nagar Panchayat and has got high commercial potentiality. The O.P. No.1 in his
written objection has stated that the acquired land is situated approximately at
Gram Panchayat /Nagar Panchayat area. However, the L.A. Collector awarded
@Rs.2,00,000/- per kani for the acquired Tilla class of land and the award of the
L.A. Collector is found to be based with no reasons.
[15]
The Government of Tripura set up a land valuation assessment
committee for the purpose of collecting revenue from the sale transaction which is
in the lower side and cannot form the basis for determining the actual value of
land. In case No. L.A. (Ref.) 151 of 2019 vide Declaration
No.
F.9(06)REV/ACQ/XIII/2012, dated 06.07.2013 under Mouja-Doulbari and T.K.
Sabroom, Sabroom Sub-Division, the L.A. Collector awarded compensation for
the acquired Tilla class of land @ Rs.2,00,000/- per kani and that land was also
acquired for the same purpose and the award was given by this Court in that case
at enhanced rate for the acquired Tilla class of land @ Rs.6,40,000/- per kani since
the land of Deed No. I-443 submitted by the claimant in that case bears a value @
Rs.8,00,000/- per kani and it was the highest exemplar deed of that case in respect
of Tilla land.
[16]
According to this court, after deducting 20% thereof as deduction
then rate was reduced to Rs. 6,40,000/- per kani which was thus taken to be the
value of the acquired Tilla class of land at the time of acquisition (Relying the
decision in Chandrashekar (D) by LRs. and Ors. v. Land Acquisition Officer,
Gulbargo & Anr., 2012 AIR SCW 73). As such, I find no reason why the same
valuation should not be given to the claimant-petitioner in this case also.
Accordingly, the value of the acquired land of this case for Plot No.512 is raised
to Rs.6,40,000/- (Rupees six lakhs forty thousand) per kani.
[17]
In view of overall reasons given by the learned L.A. Judge and
having gone through the evidence on record and the arguments put forwarded by
the learned counsel appearing for the parties, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the learned Judge has decided the matter and calculated the amount in
a just and proper manner and on the basis of the relevant documents. Since, it is
already considered and the award has been passed, it is not a case for passing any
further order. Accordingly, the findings as arrived at by the learned L.A. Judge are
just and proper and do not require any interference and thus, affirmed.
[18]
Accordingly, the appeal preferred by the appellant, stands dismissed.
Consequently, the judgment and award passed by the learned L.A. Judge stands
affirmed. Draw the decree accordingly and thereafter, send down the LCRs
forthwith. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2023.08.01
17:50:13 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review