Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP NO.44 OF 2021
1. Smt. Saraswati Das,
W/o. Lt. Jatan Das,
Village Khas Chowmohani, P.S.- Melaghar,
P.O.- Khas Chowmohoni, District- Sepahijala, Tripura.
2. Smt. Sagarika Das,
D/o, Lt. Jatan Das, Village- Khas Chowmohoni,
P.S. Melaghar, P.O. Khas Chowmohoni, District- Sepahijala,
Tripura.
3. Miss Diya Das(Minor daughter),
D/o. Lt. Jatan Das, Village- Khas Chowmohoni,
P.S. Melaghar, P.O.- Khas Chowmohoni,
District- Sepahijala Tripura.
4. Smt. Arati Das(Struck Out),
W/o- Lt. Rajmohan Das,
P.O.- Khas Chowmohoni, District- Sepahijala Tripura.
(The Claimant-Petitioner-Appellant No.3 being minor is
being represented by her natural guardian mother
Claimant-Petitioner-Appellant No.1, Smt. Saraswati Das)
……… Claimant-Petitioner-Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. Dr. Swapnil Rai,
S/o, Dr. Nalin Chandra Rai,
Of ILS Hospital, Agartala, Capital Complex Extn,
P.S.- New Capital Complex, P.O.- Kunjaban,
District- West Tripura.
(Owner of the offending motorcycle No.TR-01-E-5958)
2. The Oriental Insurance Company ltd.,
44/2 Central Road, P.S. West Agartala,
P.O- Agartala, PIN-799001.
3. New India Assurance Company Ltd.,
Ambagan Road, Bishalgarh
P.S.- Bishalgarh, District- Sepahijala, PIN-799102.
(Insurer of the Offending vehicle)
4. Dhananjoy Datta,
S/o Pranjit Datta
Resident of Taxapara, P.S.- Melaghar,
District- Sepahijala Tripura.
…… Opposite Parties -Respondent(s)
CO(FA) NO.10 OF 2022
The New India Assurance Compnay Ltd.
Agartala Division, 4, Mantri Bari Road,
P.S. West Agartala,
District- West Tripura,
Pin-799001,
Represented by its Divisional Manager.
………Respondent Petitioner/Cross Objector
1. Smt. Saraswati Das,
W/o Lt. Jatan Das,
Resident of Khas Chowmohani, P.S.- Melaghar,
P.O.- Khas Chowmohoni, District- Sepahijala, Tripura.
2. Smt. Sagarika Das,
D/o, Lt. Jatan Das, resident of Khas Chowmohoni,
P.S. Melaghar, P.O. Khas Chowmohoni, District- Sepahijala,
Tripura.
3. Miss Diya Das(Minor daughter),
D/o. Lt. Jatan Das resident of Khas Chowmohoni,
P.S. Melaghar, P.O.- Khas Chowmohoni,
District- Sepahijala Tripura.
(The claimant petitioner appellant No.3 being the minor is
represented by her mother as natural guardian).
….. Claimant-Petitioner-respondents.
4. Dr. Swapnil Rai,
S/o. Dr. Nalin Chandra Rai,
Resident of ILS Hospital, Agartala
Capital Complex Extension,
P.S. New Capital Complex,
P.O- Kunjaban, District- West Tripura.
Pin-799006.
5. The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
44/2, Central Road,
P.S. East Agartala,
P.O. Agartala, District-West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
6. Sri Dhananjoy Datta,
S/o, Pranjit Datta,
Resident of Taxapara,
P.S. Melaghar, P.O. Melaghar,
District- Sepahijala Tripura.
………… Opposite Party Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. D. Debnath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. G.S. Das, Advocate.
Mr. T Chakraborty, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 13.12.2022.
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
Both the present appeal and the cross objection
are clustered for disposal by a common judgment since it
raises
from
the
common
judgment
and
award
of
compensation dated 27.07.2021 passed in T.S.(MAC)256 of
2016.
2.
This present appeal has been filed under Section
173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 for enhancement of the
awarded compensation dated 27.07.2021 passed by the
learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.2,
West Tripura, Agartala, in Case No.T.S.(MAC) 256 of 2016, to
the extent of Rs.40,00,000/- as claimed by the claimantpetitioner-appellants
objection
has
been
in
their
filed
by
claim
the
petition.
The
cross
respondent-petitioner
Insurance Company against the present appeal filed by the
claimant-petitioner-appellants under Order XLI, Rule 22 of
Civil Procedure Code for reducing the awarded amount passed
on 27.07.2021.
3.
Brief facts leading to this instant appeal are that
on 15.10.2015 at about 04.00 p.m., Sri Jatan Das was
proceeding towards Taxapara Bazar from his house at Khas
Chowmohoni by riding his motorbike bearing registration No.
TR-01-Q-9592. On the way, suddenly one vehicle bearing
registration No. TR-01-E-5958, (hereinafter referred to as the
offending vehicle) came at high speed in a rash and negligent
manner and dashed the motorcycle of the said-Jatan Das
resulting which the victim received grievous head injuries
along with other multiple bleeding injuries. Immediately the
said-Jatan Das was shifted to Bisramganj Hospital first but
considering his serious condition, the victim, was shifted to
AGMC & GBP Hospital, wherein, the victim-Sri Jatan Das
(hereinafter referred to as the deceased) succumbed to his
injuries
on
the
same
day.
Accordingly,
Post
Mortem
Examination was held over the dead body of the deceased and
a specific case vide Melaghar P.S. Case No. 79 of 2016 was
also
registered.
The
claimant-petitioners,
therefore,
approached the learned Tribunal seeking compensation due to
the death of the deceased and quantified their claim to the
tune of Rs.40,00,000/4.
The learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, No.2, West Tripura, Agartala after going through the
pleadings, and evidences and after hearing the parties passed
the judgment and award dated 27.07.2021 and awarded a
sum of Rs.15,82,000/- (Rupees Fifteen Lakhs Eighty Two
Thousand only) along with interest on the compensation
towards the claimant-petitioner-appellants basing on the
following calculation:“I. Income per month= Rs.9,000/II. 40% of above to be added as future prospect:- Rs.3,600/only.
III. The total I & II works at:- Rs.12,600/IV. 1/3rd of above to be deducted as personal and living
expenses of deceased:- 12,600/- minus Rs.4200/-= Rs.8,400/only.
V. Compensation after applying multiplier of 15:- Rs.8,400 x 12
x 15= 15,12,000/VI. Loss of consortium = Rs.40,000/VII. Loss of estate = Rs.15,000/VIII. Funeral Expenses = Rs.15,000/-“
5.
The New India Assurance Company Ltd., in
compliance with the judgment and order passed by the
learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, No.2, West Tripura,
Agartala in Case No.T.S.(MAC) No.256 of 2016 had submitted
before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Agartala, the
award of compensation i.e. Rs.15,82,000/-.
6.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the
impugned
judgment
and
award
claimant-petitioner-appellants
dated
have
27.07.2021,
preferred
the
the
present
appeal before this Court.
7.
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel assisted by
Mr. D. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the appellants
as well as Mr. G.S. Das, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-New
India
Assurance
Company,
and
Mr.
T.
Chakraborty learned counsel for respondent No.4.
8.
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
claimant-appellants
submitted
that
the
learned
Tribunal
assessed the statutory deduction of 1/3rd from the monthly
income of the deceased towards his family. The learned
Tribunal ought to have considered that, on the date of the
accident said Lt. Jatan Das had four dependants including his
mother Arati Das. Said Arati Das was also one of the claimantpetitioners in case No.T.S.(MAC)256/2016. But subsequently,
only during the pendency of the case, she expired, hence on
the date of the accident, Lt. Jatan Das had four dependents
i.e. his wife, 2 daughters, and mother who died during the
pendency of the case. Therefore, the statutory deductions
would have been considered at 1/4th deductions instead of
1/3rd. To further strengthen his arguments in this regard, Mr.
Lodh, learned counsel referred to Paragraphs Nos.9 & 10 of
the Hon‟ble Apex Court Judgment reported in (2021) 2 SCC
166 titled as Kirti and anr. Vs. Oriental Insurance
Company Ltd., dated 05.01.2021 which is reproduced herein-under:“9. We have thoughtfully considered the rival submissions. It
cannot be disputed that at the time of death, there in fact were four
dependents of the deceased and not three. The subsequent death of the
deceased’s dependent mother ought not to be a reason for reduction of
motor accident compensation. Claims and legal liabilities crystallise at
the time of the accident itself, and changes post thereto . ought not to
ordinarily affect pending proceedings. Just like how appellant claimants
cannot rely upon subsequent increases in minimum wages, the
respondent insurer too cannot seek benefit of the subsequent death of a
dependent during the pendency of legal proceedings. Similarly, any
concession in law made in this regard by either counsel would not bind
the parties, as it is legally settled that advocates cannot throwaway legal
rights or enter into arrangements contrary to law.
10 . Any compensation awarded by a Court ought to be just, reasonable
and consequently must undoubtedly be guided by principles of fairness,
equity, and good conscience. 3 Not only did the family of the deceased
consist of septuagenarian parents, but there were also two toddler girls,
aged merely 3 and 4 years; each of whom requires exceptional care and
expenditure till they reach the stage of self dependency. Tragically, in
addition to the married couple, the negligence of the driver also
extinguished the life of the family’s third child who was a foetus in
Poonam’s womb at the time of the accident. Thus, the appropriate
deduction for personal expenses for both Vinod and Poonam ought to be
1/4th only, and not 1/3rd as applied by the Tribunal and the High Court,
more so when there were four family members dependent on the
deceased.
9.
Learned counsel appearing for the claimant-
appellants
further
submitted
that
the
learned
Tribunal
awarded Rs.40,000/- on the head of loss of consortium, on
Loss of estate, Rs.15,000/- was given and for funeral
expenses Rs.15,000/- was given. But the same amount
should be enhanced by 10% every 3(three) years in terms of
the Hon‟ble Apex Court Judgment reported in (2017) 16 SCC
680 titled as National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs.
Pranay Sethi and ors., dated 31.10.2021 which is again
reiterated in Para-32 of the Hon‟ble Apex Court Judgment
reported in 2021 SCC Online SC 967 titled as N. Jayasree
and ors. Vs. Cholamandalam MS. General Insurance
Company Ltd. dated 25.10.2021 which is reproduced herein-under:“32. In Pranay Sethi2, this Court has awarded a total
sum of Rs.70,000/ (Rupees seventy thousand only) under
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of consortium and
funeral expenses. It was held that the said sum should be enhanced
at the rate of 10% in every three years. It was held thus:
“59.8. Reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely, loss of
estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs
15,000, Rs 40,000 and Rs 15,000 respectively. The aforesaid
amounts should be enhanced at the rate of 10% in every three
years.
33. The judgment in Pranay Sethi was rendered in the year 2017.
Therefore, the claimants are entitled for 10% enhancement. Thus, a
sum of Rs.16,500/- each is awarded towards loss of estate and
funeral expenses.”
10.
Learned
counsel
further
submitted
that
the
learned Tribunal below granted consortium to the widow but
the claimant-appellant Nos.2 & 3 being the daughters of the
deceased were also legally entitled to get the consortium of
Rs.40,000/- each. To support his argument in this regard,
learned counsel placed his reliance upon paragraphs No.36,
37, and 38 of the Apex Court Judgment reported in (2020)
9 SCC 644 titled New India Assurance Company Ltd. Vs.
Somwati and ors., dated 09.07.2020 which is reproduced
herein-below:“36. The Magma General Insurance Company Ltd. (Supra) as
well as United India Insurance Company ltd.(Supra), Three-Judge Bench
laid down that the consortium is not limited to spousal consortium and it
also includes parental consortium as well as filial consortium. In
paragraph 87 of United India Insurance Company Ltd. (supra),
„consortium‟ to all the three claimants was thus awarded. Paragraph 87
is quoted below:"87. Insofar as the conventional heads are concerned, the deceased
Satpal Singh left behind a widow and three children as his dependants.
On the basis of the judgments in Pranay Sethi (supra) and Magma
General (supra), the following amounts are awarded under the
conventional heads:i) Loss of Estate: Rs. 15,000
ii) Loss of Consortium:
a) Spousal Consortium: Rs.
40,000
b) Parental Consortium: 40,000 x 3 = Rs. 1,20,000
iii) Funeral Expenses: Rs. 15,000”
37. Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that Pranay Sethi
has only referred to spousal consortium and no other consortium was
referred to in the judgment of Pranay Sethi, hence, there is no
justification for allowing the parental consortium and filial consortium.
The Constitution Bench in Pranay Sethi has referred to amount of
Rs.40,000/- to the „loss of consortium‟ but the Constitution Bench had
not addressed the issue as to whether consortium of Rs.40,000/- is only
payable as spousal consortium. The judgment of Pranay Sethi cannot be
read to mean that it lays down the proposition that the consortium is
payable only to the wife.
38. The Three-Judge Bench in United India Insurance Company Ltd.
(Supra) has categorically laid down that apart from spousal consortium,
parental and filial consortium is payable. We feel ourselves bound by the
above judgment of Three Judge Bench. We, thus, cannot accept the
submission of the learned counsel for the appellant that the amount of
consortium awarded to each of the claimants is not sustainable.
11.
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellants
further
submitted that the deceased husband was dealing in the
business of fish and dry fish and his income were Rs.15,000/-
per month. The testimony of P.W.1 and P.W.-2 testifies the
same but the learned Tribunal below has awarded only
Rs.9,000/- per month. To support his argument, learned
counsel referred to para-7 of the Judgment of this High Court
bearing Case No.MAC APP No.18 of 2019 titled Smt.
Kusum Kali Tripura and ors Vs. Md. Ajmir Uddin and
anr.,
dated
05.12.2019
relevant
portion
of
which
is
reproduced here-in-under:“From the record, it thus emerges that the insurance company had not
disputed the fact that the deceased was a meson at the time of his accident. Being a
34 years old able bodied person, as a skilled worker, at the relevant time in the year
2015, he could be expected to earn at least a sum of Rs.10,000/- per
month………………………….”
Learned counsel further submitted that the deceased
herein was dealing in the business of fish and dry fish but in
Kusum Kali Tripura(supra), the deceased, in the year 2015
was a mason. So deceased must be earning much more than
the deceased in said Kusum Kali Tripura(supra). Stating
thus, learned counsel urged to allow this appeal.
12.
Mr. G.S. Das, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-New India Assurance Company Ltd., and who is
also the cross objector in the Cross Objection petition has
submitted that the learned Tribunal assessed the age of the
deceased as 39 years of age but at the time of the accident,
the deceased was 42 years of age. So the appropriate
multiplier would be 14 but the learned Tribunal has considered
it as multiplier 15. Further, the future prospect would be 25%
but the learned Tribunal considered it 40%.
13.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence of
record.
14.
The
learned
Tribunal
below
has
awarded
consortium only to the widow of the deceased but in terms of
the argument of Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
claimant-appellants, this Court is of the opinion that the two
children and the mother of the deceased are also entitled to
the parental and filial consortium in terms of the Hon‟ble
Supreme judgment reported in (2018) 18 SCC 130 titled as
Magma General Insurance Company Ltd vs Nanu Ram
Alias Chuhru ram and ors., dated 09.18.2017 reiterated in
New
India
Assurance
Company
Ltd.
Vs.
Somwati(supra). As such 2(two) children and the mother of
the deceased are awarded Rs.40,000/- each on the head of
filial and parental consortium. Further, in view of the above,
1/4th is to be deducted as personal and living expenses of the
deceased instead of 1/3rd in term of the Pranay Sethi
(supra).
its
recent
judgment passed in N. Jayasree and ors.,(supra)
relied
15.
The
Hon‟ble
Supreme
Court
in
upon the Pranay Sethi(supra) with regard to the increase of
10% every 3(three) years on the loss of estate, funeral
expenses and also loss of consortium. The same is taken into
consideration.
Accordingly,
Rs.40,000/-,
Rs.15,000/-
and
Rs.15,000/- is enhanced by 10% every three years.
16.
The income of the deceased has been considered
by the Tribunal as Rs.9,000/-. But according to the evidence
of P.W.1 and P.W.2, it is categorically admitted that the
deceased
was
doing
dry
fish
business.
However,
no
documentary evidence was filed in regard to his income. In
the absence of filing of any proof before the learned Tribunal,
a notional income of Rs.9,000/- was fixed. This Court in terms
of the principles laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Ramachandrappa vs Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance
Insurance Company Ltd., reported in (2011) 13 SCC 236
dated 08.09.2011 also considers that fixing notional income
@ Rs.10,000/- per month for the deceased is reasonable.
17.
In the cross objection, the multiplier, which is
fixed at 15 is factually incorrect since the age of the deceased
as per his birth certificate document (Exbt-6) is 42 and
credence needs to be given to the Birth Certificate, not to the
death certificate which shows 39 as the age of the deceased.
Hence, considering the age of the deceased at 42, multiplier
of 14 is applied. Further future prospect is added as 25%
instead of 40%.
18.
Now, in view of the aforesaid discussion and
principles, this Court proceeds to calculate the appropriate
compensation in this instant appeal:(i) Monthly Income = Rs.10,000/(ii) 25% of the above to be added as future prospect
= Rs.2,500/(iii) The total of (i) and (ii) works at = Rs.12,500/(iv) One fourth (1/4th) of the above is to be deducted
as personal and living expenses of the deceased= Rs.12,500/minus Rs.3,125/- =Rs. 9,375/(v) Compensation after applying the multiplier of 14:Rs.9,375x12x14= Rs.15,75,000/(vi)
Loss of consortium:- Rs.40,000/- + Rs.40,000/-
+ Rs.40,000/- + Rs.40,000/- = Rs.1,60,000/(vii) Loss of Estate:- Rs.15,000/(viii) Funeral expenses:- Rs.15,000/-
In terms of the Pranay Sethi(supra), the sum
on the head of loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral
expenses would be enhanced @ 10% in every three years.
The case before the learned Tribunal was instituted in 2016.
(ix) Accordingly Rs.1,60,000/- + Rs. 15,000/- + Rs.
15,000/- = Rs.1,90,000/-.
(x) Rs.1,90,000/- + 10% = Rs.19,000/(xi) Rs.1,90,000/- + Rs.19,000/- = Rs.2,09,000/(xii) Rs.2,09,000/- +10% = Rs.20,900/(xiii) Rs.2,09,000/- + Rs.20,900/- = Rs.2,29,900/18.1.
Thus
the
total
compensation
stands
at
Rs.15,75,000/- + Rs.2,29,900/- = Rs.18,04,900/- only.
19.
In view of the above, the above observation and
direction, both the appeal and cross-objection are party
allowed to the extent indicated above.
20.
Consequently, this instant appeal and the cross
objection stand disposed of. Pending application(s), if any also
stand closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review