Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:9601
NAFR
AVINASH
SHARMA
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally signed
by AVINASH
SHARMA
Date: 2026.03.02
16:16:02 +0530
WPS No. 9131 of 2023
1 - Smt. Sakuntala Singh W/o Late S. N. Singh Aged About 64 Years.
2 - Somia Singh D/o Late S.N. Singh Aged About 40 Years.
Both R/o Gali No. E-3, Shanti Nagar, Bilaspur, District Bilaspur (C.G.).
...
Petitioners.
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Water Resources
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, Raipur
(C.G.).
2 - The Engineer-In-Chief Water Resources Department, Sector-19, Shivnath
Bhawan,
Atal
Nagar,
The
Collector
-
Nawa
Raipur,
Bilaspur,
District
District
Raipur
(C.G.)
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
4 - The Chief Engineer Water Resources Department, Mahanadi Project,
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
5 - The Executive Engineer (E/m) (H.E.M.) Water Resources Department,
Sakri, Bilaspur, District Bilaspur (C.G.).
...
Respondents.
For Petitioners
: Shri Aniket Verma, Advocate.
For State/Res.
: Shri Arpit Agrawal, PL.
Hon’ble Shri Amitendra Kishore Prasad, Judge
Order on Board
24/02/2026
1. The present Writ Petition has been filed against the inaction on the part
of respondent authorities in not accepting the claim of petitioners for
grant of compassionate appointment to Petitioner No.2 due to death of
her father and husband of Petitioner No.1.
2. Petitioners have prayed for the following reliefs:i. To kindly direct the respondent authorities to
reconsider the case of the petitioners for grant of
compassionate appointment to the petitioner no. 2 in
the place of the deceased husband of the petitioner
No.1 petitioner's husband with all consequential
benefits.
ii. To kindly direct the respondent authorities to grant
the petitioner No.02 compassionate appointment
with all consequential benefits.
iii. To kindly make any other order/s that may be
deemed fit and just in the facts and circumstances of
the case including awarding of the costs to the
petitioner.
3. Brief facts of the case are that on 19.07.2006, husband of Petitioner
No.1 and father of Petitioner No.2 namely Shri SN Singh who was
working as Deputy Engineer (Water Resources Department) died in
harness. On 18.18.2006 (Annexure P/1), Son of Petitioner No.1 namely
Shri Shashank Singh applied for compassionate appointment and
made the requisite application. On 18.18.2006 (Annexure P/2),
application was forwarded to the Superintendent Engineer (E/M)
Division. On 02.07.2011 (Annexure P/3), letter was forwarded to the
Chief Engineer intimating that case for compassionate appointment on
the post of Shiksha Karmi Grade III was forwarded and requested to
provide details. On 30.09.2011 (Annexure P/4), Petitioner No.1
intimated the Executive Engineer, that the compassionate appointment
not be given to the son but her daughter i.e. Petitioner No.2, as the son
was living separately and was not providing any help to Petitioner No.1
and her daughter. On 18.11.2011 (Annexure P/5), application/consent
of the Petitioner No.1 was forwarded to Superintendent Engineer. On
23.01.2012 (Annexure P/6), application of Petitioner No.2 was again
forwarded to Collector by the Chief Engineer so that Petitioner No.2
could either be appointed compassionately to the post of Assistant
Grade III or Peon. On 12.03.2012 (Annexure P/8), Joint Collector
informs that the application of Petitioner No.2 is time barred. On
04.07.2012 (Annexure P/8), Chief Engineer informs the petitioner that
her application cannot be considered for being time barred. On
04.09.2012 (Annexure P/9), petitioners again submitted application for
considering the Petitioner No.2 for compassionate appointment. On
17.10.2012 (Annexure P/10), Chief Engineer forwarded the application
of the petitioners and recommended that on compassionate grounds
the time limitation may be exempted. On 01.09.2018 (Annexure P/11),
Chief Engineer sought information regarding the pending case of
Petitioner No.2, for consideration of compassionate appointment. On
17.04.2018 (Annexure P/12), Petitioner No.2 again submitted an
application so that her case be considered for grant of compassionate
appointment. On 25.10.2019 (Annexure P/13), Petitioner No.2 was
informed that since the brother Shri Shanshank has refused, therefore,
Petitioner No.2 cannot be considered. On 11.10.2019 (Annexure P/13),
the same information was provided again without any rhyme or reason.
On 21.08.2023 (Annexure P/14), Petitioner No.2’s husband also
passed away unfortunately. On 27.09.2023 (Annexure P/15), Petitioner
No.2 again submitted a detailed representation for consideration of her
case and also referred to her previous representations dated
30.09.2011, 04.09.2011, 17.04.2018 and 17.08.2020. Hence this
Petition.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the petitioner no. 01's
son had applied for the compassionate appointment in the year 2006
itself, the same year his father passed away, however, after the delay
of about 5 years, the respondent department initiates to consider the
case for compassionate appointment. During this period, the petitioner
no. 01's son had started living separately and was not supporting his
mother (Petitioner No.1) and sister (Petitioner No.2), therefore very
specifically the petitioner informed the same to the respondent
authorities on 30/09/2011 which was forwarded to the Superintendent
Engineer on 18/11/2011. Vide communication dated 23/01/2012, the
collector was informed that petitioner no. 02 can be granted
compassionate appointment to any of such posts such as Assistant
Grade-III or Siksha Karmi Grade-III. He submits that vide letter dated
17/10/2012, the Chief Engineer has recommended that looking into the
case of the petitioner no. 02, the time limitation must be exempted and
the petitioner no. 02's case must be considered for compassionate
appointment. The Department vide letter dated 01/09/2018 again
sought information about consideration of petitioner no. 02's case as
also on 09/08/2018. However, on 25.10.2019, petitioner No.2 was
informed that since brother Shashank Singh has not given consent for
compassionate appointment on the post of Shikha Karmi Grade III, the
matter has become invalid and Petitioner No.2 cannot be considered
for compassionate appointment. The said reasoning was again given
vide letter dated 11.10.2019. Thereafter, on 21.08.2023, husband of
Petitioner No.2 also died. On 27.09.2023, Petitioner No.2 again
submitted a detailed representation for consideration of her case citing
her previous representations. However, the same is pending before the
respondent authorities.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the respondent
authorities have in an arbitrary manner vide letter dated 25.10.2019
and 11.10.2019 informed the petitioners that since brother Shashank
Singh has not given consent for compassionate appointment on the
post of Shiksha Karmi Grade III, the matter has become invalid and as
such, case of petitioner No.2 for grant of compassionate appointment
has not been considered by the respondent authorities. The said act of
respondent authorities is morally wrong as in the year 2011 itself it was
brought to the knowledge of respondent authorities that brother
Shashank Singh be not given compassionate appointment and
Petitioner No.2 be considered for grant of compassionate appointment.
Since then, respondent authorities are considering Petitioner No.2 for
grant of compassionate appointment. Hence after a lapse of about
more than 8 years, respondent authorities cannot refuse to consider
the case of Petitioner No.2 as brother Shashank Singh has not been
considered. As regards the question of approaching this Court with
delay, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that before
respondent authorities, first communication was made to them in 2006
and they replied in the year 2011 and since then case of Petitioner
No.2 was under consideration by them, therefore, there is no delay on
the part of petitioners in approaching this Court.
6. Lastly, learned counsel for the petitioner prays for issuance of direction
to Respondent Nos.4 and 5 to consider the case of compassionate
appointment of Petitioner No.2 in an objective manner.
7. On the other hand, learned State counsel submits that the present Writ
Petition has been filed with a delay of about 17 years since father of
Petitioner No.2 died in the year 2006 and this petition has been filed in
year 2023. Further, respondent authorities considered the case of son
(brother of Petitioner No.2) of deceased of employee for grant of
compassionate appointment on the post of Shikha Karmi Grade III,
however, he did not give his consent for the same and as such, case of
the petitioner No.2 has not been considered.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available with the petition.
9. In the case at hand, on 19.07.2006, husband of Petitioner No.1 and
father of Petitioner No.2 namely Shri SN Singh 1 who was working as
Deputy Engineer (Water Resources Department) died in harness. On
18.8.2006, son of Petitioner No.1 and brother of Petitioner No. 2
namely Shri Shashank Singh applied for compassionate appointment
by making requisite application. On 30.09.2011 (Annexure P/4),
Petitioner No.1 intimated Executive Engineer, that compassionate
appointment may not be given to her son namely Shri Shashank Singh
1 deceased employee
as he is living separately and not taking care of her and her daughter,
rather it be given to Petitioner No.2. Thereafter on 18.11.2011, a letter
was addressed to Superintendent Engineer by the Executive Engineer
informing that earlier Petitioner No.1 had given consent and proposed
the name of her son namely Shashank Singh for compassionate
appointment, however, as her son is living separately, Petitioner No.1
gave consent that Petitioner No.2 who is her daughter be given
compassionate appointment. Thereafter, on 12.03.2012 (Annexure
P/8), Joint Collector concerned informs that the application of Petitioner
No.2 for grant of compassionate appointment is time barred. The said
fact was thereafter informed to the petitioners by Chief Engineer,
Mahanadi Pariyojna, Raipur C.G. vide letter dated 04.07.2012 stating
that since the petitioners have not given their consent to be
compassionately appointed on the post of Shiksha Karmi Grade III,
State has refused to give the petitioners necessary exemption.
Thereafter on 04.09.2012, the petitioners again applied for grant of
compassionate appointment. On 17.10.2012 (Annexure P/10), Chief
Engineer Mahanadi Pariyojna Raipur C.G. forwarded the application of
the petitioners to the Under Secretary, C.G. State Jal Sanshadhan
Vibhag Mantralaya requesting that since Petitioner No.2 has given her
consent to be appointed on the post of Shiksha Karmi Grade III,
therefore, on compassionate grounds, her case be exempted from time
limitation. However, on 25.10.2019 (Annexure P/13), respondent
authorities refused the application of the Petitioner No.2 for
compassionate appointment by assigning reason that son of deceased
employee namely Shri Shashank Singh has not given consent for
compassionate appointment on the post of Shikha Karmi Grade III and
therefore, case has become invalid, and as such, case of Petitioner
No.2 for compassionate appointment is not accepted.
10. Since the deceased employee in the present case died on 19.07.2006
and the son of Petitioner No.1 applied for compassionate appointment
before the authorities concerned on 18.08.2006, question of limitation
to approach the respondent authorities stands satisfied. However, the
objection advanced by leaned State counsel that the present petition
being time barred is of some substance as upon refusal of claim of
compassionate appointment on 25.10.2019, the petitioners after a
lapse of more than 3 years, approached this Court belatedly. Hence,
the present petition suffers from delay.
11.In the matter of State of West Bengal vs. Debabrata Tiwari and
Others (2023 SCC OnLine SC 219), after taking into consideration the
various decisions which relate to compassionate appointment, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has summarized principles at para 32 which
reads thus:“32. On consideration of the aforesaid decisions of this
Court, the following principles emerge:
i. That a provision for compassionate appointment
makes a departure from the general provisions providing
for appointment to a post by following a particular
procedure of recruitment. Since such a provision
enables appointment being made without following the
said procedure, it is in the nature of an exception to the
general provisions and must be resorted to only in order
to achieve the stated objectives, i.e., to enable the family
of the deceased to get over the sudden financial crisis.
ii. Appointment on compassionate grounds is not a
source of recruitment. The reason for making such a
benevolent scheme by the State or the public sector
undertaking is to see that the dependants of the
deceased are not deprived of the means of livelihood. It
only enables the family of the deceased to get over the
sudden financial crisis.
iii. Compassionate appointment is not a vested right
which can be exercised at any time in future.
Compassionate employment cannot be claimed or
offered after a lapse of time and after the crisis is over.
iv. That compassionate appointment should be provided
immediately to redeem the family in distress. It is
improper to keep such a case pending for years.
v. In determining as to whether the family is in financial
crisis, all relevant aspects must be borne in mind
including the income of the family, its liabilities, the
terminal benefits if any, received by the family, the age,
dependency and marital status of its members, together
with the income from any other source.”
12.It has been observed in the aforesaid judgment that the object
underlying a provision for grant of compassionate employment is to
enable the family of the deceased employee to tide over the sudden
financial crisis due to the death of the bread-earner which has left the
family in penury and without any means of livelihood. It has been also
observed that, in a case where, for reasons of prolonged delay, either
on the part of the applicant in claiming compassionate appointment or
the authorities in deciding such claim, the sense of immediacy is diluted
and lost. As a matter of fact, inheritance based on a line of succession
which is contrary to the Constitution, the relevant paras 33 to 35 of
State of West Bengal(supra) read as under:“33. The object underlying a provision for grant of
compassionate employment is to enable the family of
the deceased employee to tide over the sudden crisis
due to the death of the bread-earner which has left the
family in penury and without any means of livelihood.
Out of pure humanitarian consideration and having
regard to the fact that unless some source of livelihood
is provided, the family would not be in a position to make
both ends meet, a provision is made for giving gainful
appointment to one of the dependants of the deceased
who may be eligible for such appointment. Having
regard to such an object, it would be of no avail to grant
compassionate appointment to the dependants of the
deceased employee, after the crisis which arose on
account of death of a bread-winner, has been overcome.
Thus, there is also a compelling need to act with a sense
of immediacy in matters concerning compassionate
appointment because on failure to do so, the object of
the scheme of compassionate would be frustrated.
Where a long lapse of time has occurred since the date
of death of the deceased employee, the sense of
immediacy for seeking compassionate appointment
would cease to exist and thus lose its significance and
this would be a relevant circumstance which must weigh
with the authorities in determining as to whether a case
for the grant of compassionate appointment has been
made out for consideration.
34. As noted above, the sine qua non for entertaining a
claim for compassionate appointment is that the family
of the deceased employee would be unable to make two
ends meet without one of the dependants of the
deceased employee being employed on compassionate
grounds. The financial condition of the family of the
deceased, at the time of the death of the deceased, is
the primary consideration that ought to guide the
authorities’ decision in the matter.
35. Considering the second question referred to above,
in the first instance, regarding whether applications for
compassionate appointment could be considered after a
delay of several years, we are of the view that, in a case
where, for reasons of prolonged delay, either on the part
of the applicant in claiming compassionate appointment
or the authorities in deciding such claim, the sense of
immediacy is diluted and lost. Further, the financial
circumstances of the family of the deceased, may have
changed, for the better, since the time of the death of the
government employee. In such circumstances, Courts or
other relevant authorities are to be guided by the fact
that for such prolonged period of delay, the family of the
deceased was able to sustain themselves, most
probably by availing gainful employment from some
other source. Granting compassionate appointment in
such a case, as noted by this Court in Hakim
Singh[(1997) 8 SCC 85] would amount to treating a
claim for compassionate appointment as though it were
a matter of inheritance based on a line of succession
which
is
contrary
to
the
Constitution.
Since
compassionate appointment is not a vested right and the
same is relative to the financial condition and hardship
faced by the dependents of the deceased government
employee as a consequence of his death, a claim for
compassionate appointment may not be entertained
after lapse of a considerable period of time since the
death of the government employee.
13. In light of the principles rendered in the matter of State of West
Bengal(supra), this Court is of the view that after a prolonged delay of
considerable time, sense of immediacy for compassionate appointment
is diluted and lost as the petitioners were able to sustain themselves for
such time period. It is also noteworthy to mention that petitioners have
also not given their consent to be compassionately appointed on the
post of Shikha Karmi Grade III which any person claiming to overcome
financial crisis and emotional hardship caused due to loss of a family
member would not do.
14.For the foregoing reasons, I do not find any good ground to issue any
positive direction for grant of compassionate appointment in favour of
the petitioners.
15. Accordingly, this Writ Petition is dismissed.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Avinash
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review