The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
09. 02.2024 he was again taken into custody in connection with this case and since then he is languishing in jail. The I.O. by this time submitted charge-sheet against this accused and other accused Ranjan Dutta Chowdhury. In the report it is also submitted by I.O. that the accused is the authorized agent of M/S Sristhi Enterprise and M/S Maa Kali Enterprise since 2020 and it also revealed that the accused himself was the recipient of contraband goods at Agartala Station which were sent by M/S Sristhi Enterprise, Kolkata and this accused was also involved in connection with G.R.P.S. case No.07 of 2022 under Section 21(C)/29 of Act and also Agartala case No.30/2022 under Section 21(C)/29 of NDPS Act for possessing contraband items of commercial quantity. In course of hearing, Learned P.P. also submitted that the consignment was booked in the name of the accusedin-custody although the same was rebutted by Learned Counsel for the applicant. As already stated, in course of hearing few citations were referred by Learned for the applicant. The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Jammu in State of J & K vs. Sham Lal dated 26.04.2023 wherein in para No.16 the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh observed as under: “16. The prosecution has failed to prove that contraband recovered in the present case was kept in the safe custody and forwarded to FSL in accordance with law and wi…
21. The standard to be considered therefore, is one, where the court would look at the material in a broad manner, and reasonably see whether the accused's guilt may be proved. The judgments of this court have, therefore, emphasized that the satisfaction which courts are expected to record, i.e., that the accused may not be guilty, is only prima facie, based on a reasonable reading, which does not call for meticulous examination of the materials collected during investigation (as held in Union of India v. Rattan Malik19). Grant of bail on ground of undue delay in trial, cannot be said to be fettered by Section 37 of the Act, given the imperative of Section 436A which is applicable to offences under the NDPS Act too (ref. Satender Kumar Antil supra). Having regard to these factors the court is of the opinion that in the facts of this case, the appellant deserves to be enlarged on bail.” Referring those citations and others, Learned Counsel for the applicant submitted that since the accused is lodging in jail for a considerable long period of time and another accused is absconding and there is no immediate chance of his appearance before the Court as warrant has been issued against him, so, considering the period of detention, the accused may be released on bail in any condition. I have heard arguments of both the sides at length and gone through the relevant prosecution papers. Here…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.89 of 2024
Smt. Ritu Parna Sen
D/O- Sri Manash Sen
W/O- Sri Abhijit Nama
R/O- Siddhi Ashram, Agartala.
P.S.- Amtali, P.O.- Amtali, West Tripura
..…Applicant
On behalf of:
Sri Abhijit Nama
S/O- Sri Ajit Nama
R/O- Siddhi Ashram, Agartala.
P.S.- Amtali, P.O.- Amtali, West Tripura
….Accused person
Versus
The State of Tripura
Represented by the Principal Secretary to the Government of
Tripura.
...Respondent
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. D. Biswas, Adv,
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P,
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
18/12/2024
This bail application under Section 439 of Cr.P.C. is
filed for releasing of the accused-in-custody namely, Sri Abhijit
Nama in connection with G.R.P.S. case No.08 of 2021 under
Section 21(c)/29 of NDPS Act.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. D. Biswas along with
Learned Counsel, Ms. P. Chakraborty appearing on behalf of the
accused-in-custody and also heard Learned P.P., Mr. R. Datta
assisted by Learned Addl. P.P., Mr. Rajib Saha representing the
State-respondent.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Counsel for the
accused-in-custody first of all drawn the attention of the Court
that the said accused is in custody since last 314 days and by
this time, the I.O. has laid charge-sheet against this accused
and another but as the another accused is absconding, so, trial
could not be commenced and as such the said accused is
languishing in jail without any valid reason. In addition to that
Learned Counsel also submitted that there is non-compliance of
the relevant provisions of Section 42 & 55 of NDPS Act as the
search and seizure was not made in-accordance-with law and
furthermore, the seized contraband items were not sent to SFL
for examination within the stipulated period violating the
directions given by the Hon’ble Apex Court and furthermore,
there were huge procedural irregularities in this case. So, in
summing up Learned Counsel submitted that considering the
period of detention of the accused-in-custody and for huge
irregularities of the prosecution emerged from the record as the
I.O. by this time has laid charge-sheet against the accused-incustody, so, Learned Counsel for the applicant urged for
releasing the accused on bail in any condition. He also referred
few citations in support of his contention in course of hearing.
On the other hand, Learned P. P., Mr. R. Datta
appearing on behalf of the State-respondent strongly opposed
the bail application and submitted that against this accused,
apart from this case, two other cases are pending and he is a
habitual offender and furthermore, after furnishing fake medical
certificate he obtained bail from the Court, so his bail was
cancelled from the Lower Court and also by this Court by order
dated 05.12.2023 in connection with case No.B.A. 47 of 2023
arising out from G.R.P.S. case No.30/2022 (NDPS) under
Section 21(c)/29 of NDPS Act and referring the citations
referred by Learned Counsel for the applicant, Learned P.P.
submitted that in those cases the accused was languishing in jail
for more than 7 ½ years, so, considering the period of detention
in custody, Hon’ble Apex Court granted bail and Learned P.P.
also submitted that as referred by Learned Counsel for the
applicant that there were procedural irregularities in this case,
the same cannot be considered during hearing of bail application
rather those are the matters to be considered during trial and
finally, urged for dismissal of the bail application.
Considered.
In this case, the prosecution was set into motion on
the basis of an FIR laid by one Sri Jitendra Kumar Singh, S.I.,
RPF, N.F. Railway to O/C GRP Agartala alleging inter alia that on
27.09.2021 at about 1900 hours, he received telephonic
information
from
Sri
Aswani
Kumar,
Chief
Commercial
Clerk/Agartala that during unloading of the consignment from
R/SLR
No.ER-142722-D
Rear
compartment
attached
with
T/No.03173 Up (K.J. Express) which arrived at Agartala at about
18:10
hours at
Platfrom
No.2,
he
suspected
that
some
contraband goods were booked under the PW Bill no.370560 in
two bundles out of 07 bundles. Accordingly, he along with
ASI/B.P. Das and other staff under the supervision of IPF/AGTL
and OC/GRP/AGTL and his other officers attended at Platform
No.02 of AGTL station and started checking all the booked 07
numbers of bundles of PW Bill No.370560 Ex. SDAH-AGTL by
Sristi Enterprises 11/2/H/2 BG Road KOL-15 to Abhijit Nama of
AGTL and during checking out of 07 Nos. of bundles in which 02
bundles No.(1) & (2) could detected Eskuf cough syrup (Codeine
Phosphate & Chlorpheramine Maleate Syrup) 100 ml each of
Batch No.LESL-394, LESL-381 and LESL-345 respectively total
620 Nos. of bottles. It was also stated in the FIR that all the
recovers suspected contraband goods of 620 Nos. of bottles of
Eskuf cough syrup and other 05 Nos. bundles manihari
(stationeries) goods are seized at the spot as per seizure list in
presence of witnesses. On the basis of that information,
Agartala P.S. G.R.P.S. case No.8/2021 under Section 21(c)/29
of NDPS Act was registered and in course of investigation this
present accused, Abhijit Nama surrendered before the Court on
13.09.2023 and he was taken into custody and on the ground of
illness, he was granted interim bail till 13.10.2023. In the
meantime, the I.O. of the case submitted a prayer before the
Court for cancellation of his bail on the ground that he has
submitted fake medical papers and as such on and from
09.02.2024 he was again taken into custody in connection with
this case and since then he is languishing in jail. The I.O. by this
time submitted charge-sheet against this accused and other
accused Ranjan Dutta Chowdhury. In the report it is also
submitted by I.O. that the accused is the authorized agent of
M/S Sristhi Enterprise and M/S Maa Kali Enterprise since 2020
and it also revealed that the accused himself was the recipient
of contraband goods at Agartala Station which were sent by M/S
Sristhi Enterprise, Kolkata and this accused was also involved in
connection with G.R.P.S. case No.07 of 2022 under Section
21(C)/29
of
NDPS
Act
and
also
Agartala
G.R.P.S.
case
No.30/2022 under Section 21(C)/29 of NDPS Act for possessing
contraband items of commercial quantity.
In course of hearing, Learned P.P. also submitted
that the consignment was booked in the name of the accusedin-custody although the same was rebutted by Learned Counsel
for the applicant. As already stated, in course of hearing few
citations were referred by Learned for the applicant.
The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at
Jammu in State of J & K vs. Sham Lal dated 26.04.2023
wherein in para No.16 the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and
Ladakh observed as under:
“16. The prosecution has failed to prove that
contraband recovered in the present case was
kept in the safe custody and forwarded to FSL
in accordance with law and without any delay.
It is pertinent to note that in view of stringent
provisions regarding punishment and grant of
bail, the legislature in its wisdom enacted
section 55 of the NDPS Act to ensure that
officer Incharge of Police Station shall
immediately take charge and keep the alleged
contraband in safe custody, in order to rule out
any
possibility
of
tampering
with
the
contraband. Prosecution is obliged to prove
that the contraband after its recovery and
seizure from the accused was kept in safe
custody, in the Malkhana of the concerned
Police Station under proper entry in the
Malkhana register. The prosecution is also
obliged to prove that said sample of the
contraband was forwarded to FSL without any
delay.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
in this case the contrabands were not sent to the SFL within
time. As such the accused deserves to be released on bail.
Learned Counsel further referred another citation of
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench in Wahid
Ali vs. Narcotics Control Bureau Lucknow dated 12.07.2023
reported in (2023) SCC OnLine All 423 wherein in para
No.24, Hon’ble the High Court of Allahabad observed as under:
“24.
As
regards
the
second
condition
prescribed under Section 37(1) (b)(ii) that the
accused if enlarged on bail, he is not likely to
commit any offence while on bail, it is essential
to note that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
case of Ranjitsingh Brahmajeetsing Sharma
(supra) had clearly held that while forming a
view with regard to future conduct of the
accused, the court should consider keeping in
view the antecedents of the accused, his
propensity and the nature and the manner in
which he is alleged to have committed the
offence. In the present case, the accused has
no criminal antecedents and thus, I have
reasons to record satisfaction as is required in
the second part of Section 37(1)(b)(ii) of the
Act. Although, delayed trial in itself is a ground
for grant of bail in the cases under N.D.P.S. Act,
the court cannot ignore the fact that after
about two years of detention, only one witness
has been examined. This view has been
recently taken by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of Mohd Muslim @ Hussain (supra)
and the order passed by the Hon'ble Apex
Court in the Case of Rabi Prakash v. The State
of Odisha decided in the Special Leave to
Appeal (Crl.) No(s).4169/2023. I am not going
to the other arguments raised at the bar with
regard to the violation of Circular No. 1/88, the
factum regarding the conscious possession
which is to be analyzed after the evidence. Any
finding at this stage may have affect on the
outcome of the trial and the same are also not
required in view of my findings recorded above
pertaining to the violation of condition under
Section 50 N.D.P.S. Act. In view of the findings
recorded above, the accused-applicant is
entitled to be enlarged on bail. Thus, the bail
application is allowed.”
He further referred another citation of High Court of
Bombay in Shivraj Gorakh Satpute vs. The State of
Maharashtra dated 15.09.2023 reported in (2023) SCC
OnLine Bom 1996 wherein para No.9 the High Court of
Bombay observed as under:
“9. In the instant case, it is not in dispute that
the house of the Applicant was searched and
Ganja was seized between sunset and sunrise
without any warrant or authorization and that
there was no compliance of Section 42 of the
NDPS Act. It is sought to be projected that it
was a chance seizure and hence, compliance
with section 42 was not possible. In this
regard, it is relevant to note that the accused
no. 1 - Vinod Rajaram Shinde, who was
allegedly found in possession of two bags
containing 22 kgs of Ganja was arrested on
01/07/2021. It is the case of the prosecution
that on 02/07/2021, the accused no. 1 had
made a disclosure statement that he was
willing to show the place and the person from
whom he had purchased the contraband and
that pursuant to the said disclosure statement,
10 kgs of Ganja was recovered from the house
of accused no. 2 - Samadhan Tawde at Nashik.
The accused no. 2 allegedly made a disclosure
statement on 05/07/2021 that he had
purchased the contraband from the Applicant
herein, who was a resident of Sangamner,
Ahmednagar and that he was willing to show
his house. Pursuant to the said disclosure
statement, the NCB team proceeded to the
house of the Applicant at Ahmednagar and
allegedly recovered 50 kgs of Ganja from his
residence. The material on record reveals that
the co-accused had disclosed the name of the
Applicant as well as his address. Hence, prima
facie it was not a case of chance recovery or
seizure in the normal course of investigation
but it was on the basis of specific information
given by the co-accused. It is also pertinent to
note that the said information was given at
about 3.00 p.m. and the search and seizure
was conducted after sunset. It is not the case
of the prosecution that the empowered officer
did not have sufficient time to obtain warrant
or authorization without affording opportunity
to the Applicant to escape or conceal the
evidence. The concerned officer has not
recorded reasons for such belief in terms of
proviso to Section 42(1) of the NDPS Act.
Hence, prima facie the search and seizure,
which is in contravention of the mandatory
provisions of Section 42 of the NDPS Act prima
facie makes the recovery doubtful.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
since there was non-compliance of the provision of Section 42 of
NDPS Act, the accused deserves to be released on bail.
Learned Counsel again referred another citation of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Mohd. Muslim alias
Hussain vs. State (NCT of Delhi) dated 28.03.2023 reported
in (2023) SCC OnLine SC 352 wherein in para Nos.20 & 21
Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“20. A plain and literal interpretation of the
conditions under Section 37 (i.e., that Court
should be satisfied that the accused is not
guilty and would not commit any offence)
would effectively exclude grant of bail
altogether, resulting in punitive detention and
unsanctioned preventive detention as well.
Therefore, the only manner in which such
special conditions as enacted under Section 37
can
be
considered
within
constitutional
parameters is where the court is reasonably
satisfied on a prima facie look at the material
on record (whenever the bail application is
made) that the accused is not guilty. Any other
interpretation, would result in complete denial
of the bail to a person accused of offences such
as those enacted under Section 37 of the NDPS
Act.
21. The standard to be considered therefore, is
one, where the court would look at the material
in a broad manner, and reasonably see whether
the accused's guilt may be proved. The
judgments of this court have, therefore,
emphasized that the satisfaction which courts
are expected to record, i.e., that the accused
may not be guilty, is only
prima facie, based on a reasonable reading,
which does not call for meticulous examination
of the materials collected during investigation
(as held in Union of India v. Rattan Malik19).
Grant of bail on ground of undue delay in trial,
cannot be said to be fettered by Section 37 of
the Act, given the imperative of Section 436A
which is applicable to offences under the NDPS
Act too (ref. Satender Kumar Antil supra).
Having regard to these factors the court is of
the opinion that in the facts of this case, the
appellant deserves to be enlarged on bail.”
Referring those citations and others, Learned Counsel
for the applicant submitted that since the accused is lodging in
jail for a considerable long period of time and another accused is
absconding and there is no immediate chance of his appearance
before the Court as warrant has been issued against him, so,
considering the period of detention, the accused may be
released on bail in any condition.
I have heard arguments of both the sides at length
and gone through the relevant prosecution papers. Here in the
case
at
hand,
there
is
charge
against
the
accused
for
committing offence punishable under Section 21(C)/29 of NDPS
Act by the accused-in-custody. So, considering the facts and
circumstances of the case and the nature of allegation against
the accused and also the fact that the trial of the case is likely
to be commenced, I find no scope at this stage to release the
accused on bail. The matters of procedural irregularities as
submitted are requires to be dealt with during trial by the
concerned Trial Court, not at this stage. So, the bail application
deserves
no
consideration
and
accordingly,
the
same
is
rejected. The accused is to remain in J/C as before. From the
record it transpires that another accused is absconding, so, if
the Learned Trial Court thinks it prudent, in that case, the
Learned Trial Court may consider splitting up of the trial against
this accused and may proceed accordingly for disposal of the
case, considering the fact that the accused is lodging in jail for a
considerable long period and in that event all endeavours should
be made to dispose of the case giving top priority.
With these observations, this bail application stands
disposed of.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this order.
Also return back the Case Diary to I.O. through Learned P. P.
along with the copy of this order.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
DATTA
Date: 2024.12.19 16:01:54
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review