The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
33. In the complaint that was filed on 16 October 2019 it is alleged that at about 1400 hours on 26 March 2019, information was received that between 1500-1700 hours on the same day, the three accused persons would be reaching Uttar Pradesh. The complaint states that the information was immediately reduced to writing. Therefore, the contention that Section 42 of the NDPS Act was not complied with is prima facie misplaced. The question is one that should be raised in the course of the trial.” Referring the same Learned submitted that the submission as raised by the Learned counsel for the accused in custody cannot be accepted at this stage rather the same can be raised in course of trial. He also referred another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court that in Rizwan Khan vs. State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2020) 9 SCC 627 wherein in para Nos.12 and 14 Hon’ble the Apex court observed as under: “12. It is settled law that the testimony of the official witnesses cannot be rejected on the ground of noncorroboration by independent witness. As observed and held by this Court in catena of decisions, examination of independent witnesses is not an indispensable requirement and such nonexamination is not necessarily fatal to the prosecution case [see Pardeep Kumar]:(2018) 13 SCC 808.
14. Applying the law laid down by this Court on the evidence of police officials/police witnesses to the facts of the case in hand, referred to hereinabove, we are of the opinion as the police witnesses are found to be reliable and trustworthy, no error has been committed by both the courts below in convicting the accused relying upon the deposition of the police officials.” Referring the same Learned P.P. drawn the attention of the court even if it is found that the independent witnesses did not support the case of the police officials in that case also there is no scope to disbelieve the prosecution story if during trial evidence reveals against the accused in custody showing implication with the alleged crime. Learned P.P. also referred another citation of the coordinate Bench of this High Court in State of Tripura vs. Mahabul Alam and Ors. reported in 2023 SCC OnLine Tri 777 wherein in para No.17 this High Court observed as under: “17. From the aforesaid enunciations of law on the subject, it is abundantly clear, that the Courts while considering the application for bail must strictly adhere to the two conditions embodied in Section 37 of the NDPS Act, and must record its reason of satisfaction that there are substantial probable causes for believing that the accused is not guilty of committing such offence and that there is no likelihood of repetition of committing such offenc…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
BA No.84 of 2024
Smt. Rina Bhowmik
Wife of Ranjit Bhowmik,
Ghilatali, Boxonagar, P.O. Kalamchowra,
P.S. Kalamchowra,
Sepahijala Tripura, 799 102, aged about 49 years,
for and on behalf of accused
Raju Bhowmik,
Son of Late Ranjit Bhowmik,
Ghilatali, Boxonagar, P.O. Kalamchowra,
P.S. Kalamchowra,
Sepahijala Tripura, 799 102, aged about 30 years
---Appellant(s)
Versus
Non-Applicant
The State of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. S. Mahajan, Adv.
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. R. Saha, Addl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
17/12/2024
This application under Section 439 of Cr.P.C. is filed for
releasing of the accused Raju Bhowmik on bail who is lodging in
custody in connection with GRP PS Case No.14/2023 under
Section 20(b)(ii)(c)/29 of NDPS Act.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. S. Mahajan appearing on behalf
of the accused in custody and also heard Mr. R. Datta, Learned
P.P. along with Mr. R. Saha, Learned Addl. P.P. appearing on
behalf of the State-respondent.
As per earlier order of the court Learned P.P. has produced
the CD today and also we have received the LCR.
Taking part in the hearing Learned counsel for the accused in
custody first of all drawn the attention of the court that in this
case the contraband item of lesser quantity than commercial
quantity was recovered from the possession of the accused in
custody and there was total non-compliance of the provisions of
Section 41 and 42 of NDPS Act. So Learned counsel considering
the period of detention of the accused in custody urged for
releasing the accused on bail in any condition. Learned Counsel
also referred one citation of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in
connection
with
Bail
Application
No.3148/2021
dated
28.02.2024 and referring the same citation Learned counsel drawn
the attention of the court that in that case the contraband item
was segregated and the accused was granted bail. Learned
counsel further submitted that initially in this case the accused in
custody was released on interim bail by the Learned Court below
by the order dated 22.03.2023 and he was on interim bail till
06.06.2024, but on 07.06.2024 his bail application was cancelled
and the accused was taken into custody and since then he is
lodging in jail. Learned counsel further submitted that without any
basis in absence of materials on record Learned court below has
rejected the bail application. So Learned counsel relying upon the
judgment of Delhi High Court urged for releasing the accused in
custody on bail in any condition.
On the other hand, Learned P.P. appearing on behalf of the
State-respondent first of all drawn the attention of the court that
initially the interim bail was granted to the accused in custody on
the ground of illness of his wife which continued for a certain
period. But later on, the I.O. submitted chargesheet showing his
implication with the alleged crime and the case is at the stage of
recording evidence. So at this stage Learned P.P. strongly opposed
the bail application and submitted that if the accused is released
on bail then there is every chance of escaping of the accused and
the trial will be vitiated. Learned P.P. further submitted that the
submission as made by the Learned Counsel for the accused in
custody cannot be accepted at this stage as the said submission is
applicable in respect of trial of the case but not in respect of
hearing of bail application. So Learned P.P. urged for rejection of
the bail application of the accused in custody.
Heard both the sides.
Considered.
In this case the FIR was set into motion on the basis of a
Suo-moto complaint laid by one SI Pankaj Kr. Das of Agartala
GRPS to OC, Agartala GRPS, West Tripura alleging inter alia that
on 23.02.2023 he received one secret information that few
individuals will go by Agartala-Tripura Sundari Express train
carrying contraband items. Accordingly the fact was entered in GD
and the matter was reported to the superior authority and the
SP(GRP) and thereafter the complainant along with OC and other
staff and Deputy SP(GRP) along with other PS and RPF officer
proceeded to Agartala rail station to conduct search in connection
with the above mentioned information. On arrival at Agartala rail
station they deployed the officer and staff in front of railway main
gate and parcel gate and at about 1420 hours they found two
persons were entering into the platform together through railway
parcel gate suspiciously carrying their shoulder bags with them.
Seeing their suspicious movements they detained them and being
asked they stated their name as Raju Bhowmik and Jayanta Shil
and on asking they agreed their bodies and bags to have
searched. Accordingly the informant issued them notices under
Section 50 of NDPS Act individually for checking of their bodies
and bags and obtained their signatures and prepared pre-search
memos and the detainees also checked their body and clothing in
presence of witnesses and the Deputy SP, GRP and later on he
searched their bodies and bags and recovered total 12 packets of
suspected dry Ganja from their bags. On search, Raju Bhowmik
possessed seven packets inside the black colour shoulder bag and
Jayanta Shil was found possessing total five packets inside his
black colour shoulder bag wrapped with brown colour adhesive
tapes and after search of both of them they recovered two nos. of
mobile phones out of which one smart phone, one key pad mobile
and Indian currency Rs.1380/-. Accordingly they arranged for
weighing of the above noted suspected dry ganja from railway
parcel office and found total 21 kgs of suspected dry ganja inside
their two bags. After that the informant arrested them and seized
the alamats and laid the FIR and in course of investigation the
accused on custody was produced under arrest before the court.
It is the admitted position that initially the accused on
interim bail by the Learned Court below on the ground of illness of
his wife and later on his bail application was rejected and he was
taken into custody on 07.06.2024 and since then he was lodging
in custody.
I have heard both the sides at length, produced the FIR and
other relevant prosecution papers including the case diary. Also I
have perused the citation referred by the Learned counsel
appearing for the accused-petitioner of Delhi High Court. On
perusal of the said citation of Hon’ble Delhi High Court it appears
that in the said case bail was considered by the Hon’ble High Court
on perusal of the evidence on record. But here in the case at hand
recording of evidence is not yet been commenced and process has
been issued for recording evidence of witnesses. So the said
citation as referred by the Learned counsel for the accused in
custody cannot be applied in this case.
On the other hand, Learned P.P. appearing on behalf of the
State-respondent drawn the attention of the court by referring few
citations. In Union of India vs. Md. Nawaz Khan reported in
(2021) 10 SCC 100 Hon’ble the Apex Court in para Nos.32 and
33 observed as under:
“32. Further, it was held that the issue of whether there
was compliance of the procedure laid down under Section
42 of the NDPS Act is a question of fact. The decision
in Karnail Singh (supra) was recently followed by this
Court in Boota Singh v. State of Haryana: (2021) 19 SCC
606.
33. In the complaint that was filed on 16 October 2019 it is
alleged that at about 1400 hours on 26 March 2019,
information was received that between 1500-1700 hours
on the same day, the three accused persons would be
reaching Uttar Pradesh. The complaint states that the
information
was
immediately
reduced
to writing.
Therefore, the contention that Section 42 of the NDPS Act
was not complied with is prima facie misplaced. The
question is one that should be raised in the course of the
trial.”
Referring
the
same
Learned
P.P.
submitted
that
the
submission as raised by the Learned counsel for the accused in
custody cannot be accepted at this stage rather the same can be
raised in course of trial.
He also referred another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court that in Rizwan Khan vs. State of Chhattisgarh reported
in (2020) 9 SCC 627 wherein in para Nos.12 and 14 Hon’ble the
Apex court observed as under:
“12. It is settled law that the testimony of the official
witnesses cannot be rejected on the ground of noncorroboration by independent witness. As observed and
held by this Court in catena of decisions, examination of
independent
witnesses
is
not
an
indispensable
requirement and such nonexamination is not necessarily
fatal to the prosecution case [see Pardeep Kumar]:(2018)
13 SCC 808.
14. Applying the law laid down by this Court on the
evidence of police officials/police witnesses to the facts of
the case in hand, referred to hereinabove, we are of the
opinion as the police witnesses are found to be reliable
and trustworthy, no error has been committed by both the
courts below in convicting the accused relying upon the
deposition of the police officials.”
Referring the same Learned P.P. drawn the attention of the
court even if it is found that the independent witnesses did not
support the case of the police officials in that case also there is no
scope to disbelieve the prosecution story if during trial evidence
reveals against the accused in custody showing implication with
the alleged crime.
Learned P.P. also referred another citation of the coordinate
Bench of this High Court in State of Tripura vs. Mahabul Alam
and Ors. reported in 2023 SCC OnLine Tri 777 wherein in para
No.17 this High Court observed as under:
“17. From the aforesaid enunciations of law on the
subject, it is abundantly clear, that the Courts while
considering the application for bail must strictly adhere to
the two conditions embodied in Section 37 of the NDPS
Act, and must record its reason of satisfaction that there
are substantial probable causes for believing that the
accused is not guilty of committing such offence and that
there is no likelihood of repetition of committing such
offence by the accused while on bail. It is re-iterated
that while considering the bail application filed by the
accused arrested under the penal provisions of the NDPS
Act, learned Special Judges should be confined within the
limits embodied in Section 37 of the NDPS Act. Procedural
violations, if any, shall be taken into consideration during
the course of trial, and not at the stage of consideration of
bail application.”
Referring the same Learned P.P. further drawn the attention
of the court that if any procedural violation occurs with the case
the same may be taken into consideration during the course of
trial not during the stage of consideration of the bail application
and finally Learned P.P. urged for dismissal of the bail application.
On perusal of the relevant prosecution papers as well as the
CD and after hearing the submission of the Learned Counsels of
both the sides and also after going through the provision of
Section-37 NDPS Act, at this stage I find no scope to segregate
the contraband items alleged to be recovered from the possession
of the accused in custody to be of lesser quantity than commercial
quantity. Moreover, from the record of the Learned court below it
appears that the case is at the stage of recording of evidence. So
for the sake of justice and also for fair trial of the case at this
stage I find no scope to release the accused on bail. Hence the
bail application filed on behalf of the accused in custody stands
rejected being devoid of merit. The accused has to remain in JC as
before. On perusal of the case record it appears that the case was
at the stage of recording evidence of witnesses of the prosecution.
So Learned court below be asked to take immediate steps for
recording evidence of the witnesses of the prosecution at an
earliest convenience on the ground that the accused persons are
lodging in jail.
With this observation the bail application is disposed of.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this order and also
returned back the CD to the I.O. through Learned P.P. along with
a copy of this order.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.12.18
00:15:16 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review