Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010406442023
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Judgment reserved on 08.07.2026
Judgment pronounced on 24.09.2026
Judgment uploaded on 24.09.2026
FA (MAT) No. 335 of 2023
Smt. Rajji Kaur @ Rajni W/o Jasmeet Singh Makkad D/o Shri Uttam Singh Tuteja
aged about 30 years R/o Ward No. 14, Pithoura, Thana and Tehsil- Pithoura, District
Mahasamund (C.G.)
... Appellant
versus
Jasmeet Singh Makkad S/o Shri Surendra Singh Makkad, aged about 33 years
Caste- Sikh, R/o In front of Uttam Cycle Stores, Station Road, Mahasamund, Tehsil
and District Mahasamund (C.G.)
For appellant
:
Ms. Kanchan Kalwani, Advocate
For Respondent
:
Mr. Navin Shukla, Advocate
... Respondent
DB: Hon’ble Shri Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
Hon’ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput
Per Sachin Singh Rajput, J
This is an appeal by the appellant/wife against the judgment and decree
dated 07.11.2023 passed by learned Family Court, Mahasamund, CG in Civil Suit
No. 50-A/2021 dissolving the marriage between the parties.
2.
Case of the respondent/husband in short: His marriage with appellant/wife
was solemnized on 10.12.2011 in a Gurudwara situated at Mahasamund as per the
Hindu rites and rituals prevailing in the society, and out of their wedlock a son was
born who at the time of instituting the suit was aged about 8 years. After some
months having passed by, she started picking up disputes over trivial matters and
also did not pay respect to her in-laws. She did not spend much time with him after
marriage and in every 15 days she used to visit her parents’ house, and that
whenever she returned to his house on being insisted for, her quarrelsome attitude
did not cease at the cost of peace and tranquility in the family. All efforts to make her
understand went in vain. This went on relentlessly. Six months after marriage when
she went to her parents’ house, she did not back for a long period of three months
in spite of his best efforts. Baseless excuses were given by her for not being back.
Once the aunt of appellant/wife brought her back to his house and sought for being
excused for her acts. After staying over there for some time, she again started
acting as earlier and 2-3 months thereafter she again left for her parents’ house
hurling a threat of implicating him and his family members in a false case. In a social
meeting held in a Gurudwara at his call on 09.09.2012 the appellant/wife was asked
to live peacefully with him and would not create any disturbance in the family, and if
anything to the contrary was done, she herself would be responsible for that.
Pursuant to this lesson from Gurudwara Head, she came back to his house and
lived with him for nearly one and half year, but her attitude during this period did not
exhibit any improvement. She always told him that she was with them not out of her
sweet will but in the honour of the words given at Gurudwara. After birth of the child,
her attitude worsened and was always in the mood of creating a scene. She also
pressurized him to live at her parents’ house, and that being educated cannot live in
his family as she was not needing him. All this made him mentally unstable. Mother
of the appellant/wife was instrumental in adding fuel to fire, which made the
appellant/wife more furious successively. She did not follow the religious norms and
was also in the habit of breaking the fast kept on Karawachouth in between saying
that since she did not want to live with him, what benefit the fast would fetch. This
conduct of the appellant/wife has brought disrepute to their status in the society. If
put succinctly, the appellant/wife is a woman of promiscuity, disrespectful to her inlaws and to the social norms governing the society, and has developed a habit of
somehow harassing him and his parents. She also lodged a report for an offence
under Section 498-A IPC, and sought maintenance by filing an application for that,
and this conduct on her part also amounts to cruelty to him. In a case relating to
Domestic Violence a compromise was arrived at by them, and pursuant to that she
lived with him for about nine months. However, on 03.07.2018 she again left for her
parents’ house without any reasonable excuse and is living there since then.
Domestic violence related matter is again said to be filed by her.
3.
In his evidence, the respondent/husband has admitted that the appellant/wife
was always persistent in visiting her maternal home and she did not want to live in
her matrimonial home. Over this, she also was in the habit of picking-up quarrel with
his parents, brother and sister. Not only this, the appellant/wife was also
pressurizing him to live in her parental house. According to the respondent/husband,
the appellant/wife was not even observing the sacramental rituals being performed
in his family and also shown disrespectful attitude to his parents. The
respondent/husband has further admitted that the appellant/wife had also instituted
a case against him and his family members under section 498-A I.P.C. and thus
caused cruelty to him.
4.
Case of appellant/wife in short: Appellant/wife denied that she ever
misbehaved or disrespected her in-laws in any manner whatsoever and thus
created tension or discord in her matrimonial home. She did not leave her
matrimonial home or stayed at her parental home without any sufficient cause.
There is a plain denial that she was unwilling to maintain a peaceful matrimonial
relationship or that she refused to cooperate with the respondent/husband, rather
she herself was subjected to physical and mental cruelty on account of dowry
demands, and was abused and assaulted by him and his family members, which
compelled her to seek shelter at her parental home. She has stated that with the
intervention of relatives and elderly persons, a settlement was arrived at on
09.09.2012, pursuant to which she returned to her matrimonial home and continued
to reside there for about one and a half years. She has admitted that a male child
was born from the wedlock on 06.08.2013. The allegations that she was
quarrelsome, extravagant, disrespectful, unwilling to follow family or religious
customs, desirous of living separately, or accustomed to threatening the
respondent/husband and his family with false cases has been straightaway denied.
She has stated that such allegations have been made falsely and only to create
grounds for seeking dissolution of the marriage. According to her, after the birth of
the child she was subjected to dowry-related demands, physical assault and mental
cruelty. She is also stated to have initiated legal proceedings under Section 498-A
IPC and also for maintenance. She has stated that certain earlier proceedings were
disposed of pursuant to a settlement between the parties, but after the settlement
and on her return to the matrimonial home, the harassment and dowry demands
again started. She has stated that on 02.07.2018 she was assaulted by the
respondent/husband and his family members and was even confined in a room, and
somehow she manged to get out and reach the Gurudwara,
from where she
telephonically informed her parents and thereafter approached the police. She is
stated to have sustained injuries and received medical treatment for that. She is
denied to have deserted the respondent/husband on 03.07.2018 or that she has
been living separately out of her own free will without sufficient cause. She rather
has stated that she was residing at her parental home for her safety and because of
the alleged cruelty and dowry harassment suffered at the matrimonial home. The
allegation that there is no possibility of reconciliation between the parties and that
dissolution of the marriage solemnized on 10.12.2011 is necessary, is also denied.
5.
In her evidence she has stated that she is always ready and willing to live
with the respondent/husband so that her future is not put at stake. She has stated
that when showed her willingness to live with him, he and his family members asked
her and her parents to sign a paper and only then he would keep her. The
respondent/husband always asked her to bring money from her parents which was
spent at the time of birth of her child. She has stated that demand of dowry including
cash of Rs. 2 lacs from her husband and that her mother-in-law assaulted her and
caused injury on her head. She is stated to have utmost love and affection towards
her husband, the in-laws and the son, and she always has been mindful to her
duties towards her in-laws. On 02.07.2018 when she was cooking, her mother-inlaw and sister-in-law (Devrani) came there, asked her to get money from her father
and on her refusal to do so they assaulted her with fist-blows. Meanwhile, her
husband came and dragged her to the room by hair, confined her there and did not
provide her food. The assault by her husband led to fracture of her tooth and she
took treatment for that. She has reiterated that on account of immense love and
affection towards her husband, she is ready and willing to live with him and thus
discharge the matrimonial obligations.
6.
On the basis of these pleadings of the parties, the issues with regarding to
cruelty, desertion on the part of the appellant/wife and that of his entitlement for a
decree of divorce have been decided in positive, and consequently the suit filed by
the respondent/husband has been decreed in his favour. Hence this appeal by the
appellant/wife.
7.
Learned counsel for the appellant/wife submits that the learned Family Court
has ignored the material available on record and has erroneously granted decree of
divorce in favour of the respondent/husband. She submits that the appellant/wife
was living in her parents’ house just because of the tortuous attitude of the
respondent/husband and not out of her sweet will, and for that the finding of the
Family Court in this regard is perverse and liable to be set aside. She further
submits that the findings recorded by learned Family Court are not based on facts
and circumstances of the case and therefore liable to be struck down. She submits
that by virtue of utmost love and affection, the appellant/wife has consistently stated
that she had been always ready and willing to live in the company of the
respondent/husband. She submits that learned Family Court committed a gross
illegality in believing the version of the respondent/husband reading between the
lines. According to her, the respondent/husband has examined himself and one
other witness but they both have utterly failed to prove his case. She further submits
that the respondent/husband once assaulted her to the extent that her tooth got
fractured, which shows his cruel mental frame. In support of his submissions,
reliance is placed on the decision of the Supreme Court in the matter of Adhyatma
Bhattar Alwar vs. Adhyatma Bhattar Sri Devi reported in (2002) 1 SCC 308 and
on a decision of High Court of Delhi in the matter of Kamlesh Sharma Vs.
Yogendra Kumar Sharma reported in 2023 SCC OnLine Del 4779.
8.
On the other hand, counsel for the respondent/husband supports the
impugned judgment and decree and submits that little after marriage, the
appellant/wife started mentally harassing him by several possible ways including
frequent squabbling, quarrel with him and also with his family members, and
deserted him without any reasonable cause. He submits that keeping in view all
these things, learned Family Court granted decree of divorce in his favour, and
therefore, no interference with the well reasoned conclusion recorded in the
impugned judgment is called for. Appeal thus is prayed to be dismissed. In support
of his submission, reliance is placed on the decisions of the Supreme Court in the
matter of Narendra vs. K. Meena reported in (2016) 9 SCC 455 and that of this
Court in the matter of FAM No. 94 of 2013 (Dr. Ramkeshwar Singh vs. Smt.
Sheela Singh @ Madhu Singh delivered on 13.07.2022. Debananda Tamuli vs.
Smti Kakumoni Kataky reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 167, in the matter of Rani
Narasimha Sastry vs. Rani Suneela Rani rendered on 19.011.2019 in Civil
Appeal No. 8871 of 2019.
9.
We have considered the rival submissions, the pleadings of the parties, the
evidence referred to before us as also the decisions relied upon by learned counsel
for the parties. It is an admitted fact that the marriage between the parties was
solemnized on 10.12.2011 and a male child was born out of the wedlock on
06.08.2013. The record shows that pursuant to the decision taken in the meeting
held in the Gurudwara, the appellant/wife returned to the matrimonial home and
lived there for about one and a half year.
10.
The first question which falls for consideration is whether the conduct
attributed to the appellant/wife constitutes cruelty within the meaning of Section
13(1)(ia) of the Act of 1955. Cruelty, in matrimonial jurisprudence, is not to be
inferred merely from ordinary occasional skirmishes between the spouses coupled
with difference of opinion or incompatibility of temperament, rather to establish the
cruelty the conduct complained of by either party must be of such a nature and
intensity that the aggrieved spouse cannot reasonably be expected to continue
matrimonial life with the other. This assessment has to be based on the cumulative
effect of the entire matrimonial relationship and not merely on stray and isolated
incidents.
11.
So far as the case in hand is concerned, the respondent/husband has alleged
that the appellant/wife used to quarrel on trivial matters; did not respect his parents;
frequently visited her parental home; insisted upon living separately; did not observe
the rituals such as related to the occasion of Karwachouth undertaken in the family
and occasionally threatened to implicate him and his family members in criminal
cases. Even assuming that some of these allegations are established, they cannot,
in the absence of further cogent evidence demonstrating their gravity automatically
constitute cruelty. Likewise, the fact that the appellant/wife went to her parental
home on different occasions also cannot, by itself, constitute cruelty because in
order to decide the cruelty, the surrounding circumstances in which she left the
matrimonial home have to be examined. The wife’s consistent case is that she was
subjected to dowry demands, assault and mental cruelty and that she went to her
parental home to find out the security and safety cover to her life. This fact gets
strengthened by her statement where she has specifically set out that on
02.07.2018 she was assaulted, confined in a room and thereafter managed to reach
a Gurudwara and informed her parents and the police, and that she received
medical treatment on account of the injuries suffered by her. As regards the plea of
the respondent/husband that the act of appellant/wife in initiating criminal
proceedings against him under Section 498-A IPC and also seeking maintenance
constitute cruelty, it cannot be accepted in the abstract. Mere institution of criminal
or maintenance proceedings by a spouse does not necessarily constitute cruelty. If
the proceedings are shown to be demonstrably false, reckless and malicious and
the allegations are proved to have been deliberately fabricated, the matter may
stand on a different footing. The Supreme Court in Rani Narasimha (supra) has
observed that it is open for anyone to file complaint or launch prosecution for
redressal for his or her grievances and mere lodging of complaint or FIR cannot
ipso facto be treated as cruelty.
12.
In the case in hand, the material indicates that after intervention by the
elderly people in the meeting held at Gurudwara on 09.09.2012 the appellant/wife
returned to the matrimonial home and lived with the respondent/husband for about
one and a half years. Thereafter, pursuant to another settlement in the domestic
violence proceedings, she again returned and admittedly lived with the
respondent/husband for about nine months. This period of resumed cohabitation
shows that the matrimonial relationship was not treated by the appellant/wife as
permanently terminated. As regards the allegation that the appellant/wife repeatedly
threatened to implicate the respondent/husband and his family members in a false
case would certainly be relevant if established by reliable evidence. It however is
not the case here. Of course, the Supreme Court in Narendra v. K. Meena (supra)
has observed that the persistent effort of the wife to constrain the husband to be
separated from the family would be torturous for the husband and may constitutes
an act of ‘cruelty’, but in the case in hand the respondent/husband has utterly failed
to prove that the appellant/wife has been persistent in making such demand for
living separately from his parents, and therefore this judgment of the Supreme Court
would not stand to the rescue of the respondent/husband. On the contrary, the
appellant/wife had been and has been always stated to be ready and willing to be in
the company of the respondent/husband as she and her son both have utmost love
and affection for him. Thus the cruelty on the part of appellant/wife towards the
respondent/husband remains unproven by a substantive piece of evidence.
13.
We now turn to the allegation of desertion under Section 13(1)(ib) of the Act
of 1955. Section 13 requires desertion to continue for a period of not less than two
years immediately preceding the presentation of the divorce petition. More
importantly, desertion involves two essential elements: (i) factum of separation and
(ii) animus deserendi - the intention to bring cohabitation permanently to an end.
The law holding the field mandates that the deserted spouse must establish
absence of consent and absence of conduct giving reasonable cause to the other
spouse to live separately. This position has been authoritatively reiterated by the
Supreme Court in plethora of decisions. As regards the facts present in the case in
hand, the evidence and circumstances narrated before us do not satisfactorily
establish such animus deserendi. On the contrary, the appellant/wife has
consistently asserted that she has been always ready and willing to resume
matrimonial obligation driven by her immeasurable love and affection to the
respondent/husband, forgetting the assault by him leading to fracture of her tooth
which is evident from the medical papers.
14.
The analysis made above thus shows that the Family Court has proceeded
substantially upon the allegations made by the respondent/husband without
examining closely whether the appellant/wife had a reasonable cause to live
separately. The finding of cruelty and desertion in these circumstances narrated
before us, cannot be sustained. Consequently, the appeal deserves to be allowed
and the findings recorded by the learned Family Court that the appellant/wife treated
the respondent/husband with cruelty and deserted him within the meaning of
Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Act of 1955 are set aside.
15. Decree be drawn accordingly. No costs.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Jyotishi/Pawan
Digitally signed
by AVANISH
AVANISH JYOTISHI
JYOTISHI Date:
2026.09.24
14:50:23 +0530
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review