Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1/7
2026:CGHC:13841
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 13978 of 2025
Smt. Purnime Dhruw W/o Shri Kanhai Ram Dhruw Aged About 46 Years
Occupation- Rojgar Sahayak (M G N R E G A) At Village Panchayat
Nishtiguda Janpad Panchayat- Devbhog, R/o Ward No. 19 Village Fulimuda,
Post Nistiguda, Tahsil- Devbhog, District Gariyaband C.G.
... Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Panchayat
And Rural Development, Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Atal Nagar, Nawa
Raipur, District Raipur C.G.
2 - The Commissioner, M G N R E G A, Vikas Bhawan, 1st Floor, Sector-19,
North Block, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar, District Raipur C.G.
3 - The Collector District- Gariyaband C.G.
4 - The Chief Executive Officer, Zila Panchayat, Gariyaband, DistrictGariyaband C.G.
5 - The Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat Devbhog, DistrictGariyaband C.G.
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner
For Respondent No. 1 to 3
For Respondent No. 4 & 5
:
:
:
Mr. Jitendra Nath Nande, Advocate
Mr. Aditya Tiwari, P.L.
Ms. Ruchi Nagar, Advocate
HON'BLE SHRI PARTH PRATEEM SAHU, JUDGE
ORDER ON BOARD
23/03/2026
1.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking following reliefs.
2/7
“10.1 The Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ to
quash the impugned termination order
dated 11/09/2025 (Annexure-P/1) issued
by the Chief Executive Officer, of the of the
Janpad Panchayat Devbhog District
Gariyaband and declare the same as void
and inoperative, in furtherance of justice.
10.2 The Hon'ble court may kindly be
pleased to issue a writ of mandamus
directing the respondents to cancel the
impugned
termination
order
dated
11/09/2025 and reinstate the Petitioner in
her service, in the interest of justice.
10.3 The Hon'ble court may kindly be
pleased to issue a writ of mandamus and
quash the order dated 10/11/2025 passed
by the District Collector Gariyaband, in the
interest of justice.
10.4 Any other relief/relief's which this
Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper
may be granted, in furtherance of justice.”
2.
Counsel for petitioner submits that the petitioner was appointed as
Rozgar Sahayak, initially in the year 2007 on contract and since then
he is working continuously. The respondent authorities without
following due process of law granting opportunity of hearing has
passed an order Annexure-P/1 removing the petitioner from service.
He also contended that in the order, reasons assigned for removal of
petitioner from service is, her involvement in financial irregularities
which is perse wrong. In the show cause notice dated 28.07.2025 it is
only mentioned that the petitioner has entered the name of her
husband and son in the muster roll and made payment of Rs. 5,166/-.
It is contention of counsel for the petitioner that there is no mention of
any provision in the show cause notice, restricting petitioner to engage
her family member as labourer for working under the Pradhan Mantri
Awas Yojana and if it is a case of respondents that the petitioner has
fraudulently withdrawn the amount of Rs. 5,166/- mentioning the name
3/7
of family members of petitioner, no such enquiry was conducted. He
submits that if removal / termination of the petitioner / employee, even
if a contractual employee is made, alleging committed financial
irregularities is punitive in nature and therefore, the respondents are
under an obligation to conduct a detailed enquiry against the petitioner
granting opportunity of hearing and further the opportunity to examine
and cross-examine the witness in this regard. In support of his
contention he has placed reliance in the decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the decision of Swati Priyadarshini v. State of M.P. and Others
reported in 2024 SCC Online SC 2139 decided on 22.08.2024 and the
judgment passed by this Court in WPS No. 2515 of 2024 (Praveen
Goyal v. State of Chhattisgarh and Others) passed on 11.04.2025 by
the Coordinate Bench of this Court.
3.
Counsel for the State would submit that the grievance of the petitioner
is against the decision taken by respondent No. 4 and 5.
4.
Counsel for the respondent No. 4 and 5 would submit that the order
Annexure-P/1 was passed following due process of law. Petitioner was
issued show cause notice to which he submitted reply and upon
considering the reply submitted by the petitioner, order Annexure-P/1 is
passed, therefore, the submission of counsel for the petitioner that the
order impugned is passed without giving opportunity of hearing is not
sustainable. She also contended that on the complaint made against
the petitioner four member committee was appointed to enquire the
allegations headed by the Sub-Divisional Officer, (Revenue) and
according to the enquiry report, son and husband of the petitioner has
been shown to be a labourer in Muster Roll and a sum of Rs. 5,166/has been withdrawn against their names.
4/7
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and also perused
documents enclosed along with the writ petition and reply.
6.
It is not in dispute that the petitioner was engaged as Rozgar Sahayak
on contract basis in the year 2007. Petitioner was served with a show
cause notice on 28.07.2025 mentioning that the petitioner has entered
the name of her son and husband in the Muster Roll and have
withdrawn Rs. 5,166/-. It is also mentioned in the show cause notice
that the name of her husband and son has been fraudulently entered.
7.
In the aforementioned facts of the case where in show cause notice, it
is alleged that husband and son of the petitioner has been fraudulently
entered. Whether they have worked and thereafter payment has been
disbursed is a fact to be proved, in accordance with law and only
thereafter, adverse action like removal could have been taken against
the petitioner. The enquiry report which is stated to be submitted by
four member committee is placed along with the reply by respondent
No. 4 and 5. In the enquiry report it is only mentioned that name of the
husband and son of petitioner is found in muster roll, however, there is
no further averment that the name of the husband of the petitioner and
the son of the petitioner has been fraudulently entered and they have
not worked as labourer at any point of time. In the enquiry report
submitted by the four member team as also in show cause notice there
is no specific allegation against the petitioner that son and husband of
the petitioner had never worked under the Pradhan Mantri Awas
Yojana. In absence of specific allegation and full-fledged enquiry on the
allegations, granting opportunity to cross-examine witnesses and to
examine witness, order of removal in the opinion of this Court, is in
violation of principle of natural justice.
5/7
8.
In the facts of the case, respondents ought to have issued chargememo, with list of documents and witnesses to be examine in enquiry.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Swati Priyadarshini (supra) has
observed thus in Para 34 and 35 as under:
34. It is profitable to refer to what five learned Judges of this Court laid
down in Parshotam Lal Dhingra v Union of India, 1957 SCC OnLine SC 5:
“28. The position may, therefore, be summed up as follows:
Any and every termination of service is not a dismissal,
removal or reduction in rank. A termination of service brought
about by the exercise of a contractual right is not per se
dismissal or removal, as has been held by this Court in Satish
Chander Anand v. Union of India [(1953) 1 SCC 420: (1953)
SCR 655]. Likewise the termination of service by compulsory
retirement in terms of a specific rule regulating the conditions
of service is not tantamount to the infliction of a in the facts and
circumstances of the case establish that an enquiry into
allegations of serious and grave character of misconduct
involving stigma has been made in infraction of the provision of
Article 311 … ” “12. It is, therefore, now well settled that where
the form of the order is merely a camouflage for an order of
dismissal for misconduct it is always open to the court before
which the order is challenged to go behind the form and
ascertain the true character of the order. If the court holds that
the order though in the form is merely a determination of
employment is in reality a cloak for an order of punishment, the
court would not be debarred, merely because of the form of the
order, in giving effect to the rights conferred by law upon the
employee.” punishment and does not attract Article 311(2), as
has also been held by this Court in Shyam Lal v. State of Uttar
Pradesh [(1955) 1 SCR 26]. In either of the two
abovementioned cases the termination of the service did not
carry with it the penal consequences of loss of pay, or
allowances under Rule 52 of the Fundamental Rules. It is true
that the misconduct, negligence, inefficiency or other
disqualification may be the motive or the inducing factor which
influences the Government to take action under the terms of
the contract of employment or the specific service rule,
nevertheless, if a right exists, under the contract or the rules, to
terminate the service the motive operating on the mind of the
Government is, as Chagla, C.J., has said in Shrinivas Ganesh
v. Union of India [LR 58 Bom 673 : AIR (1956) Bom 455] wholly
irrelevant. In short, if the termination of service is founded on
the right flowing from contract or the service rules then, prima
facie, the termination is not a punishment and carries with it no
evil consequences and so Article 311 is not attracted. But even
if the Government has, by contract or under the rules, the right
to terminate the employment without going through the
procedure prescribed for inflicting the punishment of dismissal
or removal or reduction in rank, the Government may,
nevertheless, choose to punish the servant and if the
termination of service is sought to be founded on misconduct,
negligence, inefficiency or other disqualification, then it is a
punishment and the requirements of Article 311 must be
6/7
complied with. As already stated if the servant has got a right to
continue in the post, then, unless the contract of employment
or the rules provide to the contrary, his services cannot be
terminated otherwise than for misconduct, negligence,
inefficiency or other good and sufficient cause. A termination of
the service of such a servant on such grounds must be a
punishment and, therefore, a dismissal or removal within
Article 311, for it operates as a forfeiture of his right and he is
visited with the evil consequences of loss of pay and
allowances. It puts an indelible stigma on the officer affecting
his future career. A reduction in rank likewise may be by way of
punishment or it may be an innocuous thing. If the government
servant has a right to a particular rank, then the very reduction
from that rank will operate as a penalty, for he will then lose the
emoluments and privileges of that rank. If, however, he has no
right to the particular rank, his reduction from an officiating
higher rank to his substantive lower rank will not ordinarily be a
punishment. But the mere fact that the servant has no title to
the post or the rank and the Government has, by contract,
express or implied, or under the rules, the right to reduce him
to a lower post does not mean that an order of reduction of a
servant to a lower post or rank cannot in any circumstances be
a punishment. The real test for determining whether the
reduction in such cases is or is not by way of punishment is to
find out if the order for the reduction also visits the servant with
any penal consequences. Thus if the order entails or provides
for the forfeiture of his pay or allowances or the loss of his
seniority in his substantive rank or the stoppage or
postponement of his future chances of promotion, then that
circumstance may indicate that although in form the
Government had purported to exercise its right to terminate the
employment or to reduce the servant to a lower rank under the
terms of the contract of employment or under the rules, in truth
and reality the Government has terminated the employment as
and by way of penalty. The use of the expression “terminate” or
“discharge” is not conclusive. In spite of the use of such
innocuous expressions, the court has to apply the two tests
mentioned above, namely, (1) whether the servant had a right
to the post or the rank, or (2) whether he has been visited with
evil consequences of the kind hereinbefore referred to? If the
case satisfies either of the two tests then it must be held that
the servant has been punished and the termination of his
service must be taken as a dismissal or removal from service
or the reversion to his substantive rank must be regarded as a
reduction in rank and if the requirements of the rules and
Article 311, which give protection to government servant have
not been complied with, the termination of the service or the
reduction in rank must be held to be wrongful and in violation of
the constitutional right of the servant.” (emphasis supplied)
35. We would only be adding to verbosity by multiplying authorities. In
view of the above dictum, it is clear that the Respondents did not comply
with Clause 4 – either the first part or the second part thereof. The order
dated 30.03.2013 does visit the appellant with evil consequences and
would create hurdles for her re further employment.”
7/7
9.
In the facts of the case where removal of petitioner is punitive,
termination is on the alleged misconduct, the petitioner visited with civil
consequences, concerned authorities were required to conduct fullfledged enquiry giving opportunity to examine and cross-examine
witnesses, which has not been done and therefore the order AnnexureP/1 is passed in violation of principles of natural justice, as such is not
sustainable.
Accordingly,
order
Annexure-P/1
is
quashed.
Consequence to follow. Respondent will be at liberty to take decision
against petitioner following due process of law, if they so desire.
Sd/-
Saurabh
(Parth Prateem Sahu)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review