The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_ MAC. App. No.95 of 2022 Smti. Pranati Majumder Chowdhury and 2 Others .....Appellants V_E_R_S_U_S Sri Swapan Das and Another .....Respondents For Appellant(s) For Respondent(s) : : Mr. M.S. Dey, Advocate. Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), Advocate. HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD _F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_ 02/05/2023 Heard Mr. M.S. Dey, learned counsel appearing for the appellants and Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing for the respondents. [2] This is an appeal filed under Section-173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 by the appellant, challenging the judgment and award and final order dated 19.08.2019 in favour of the claimant-appellants for death of late Bikram Chowdhury passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, No.3, West Tripura, Agartala, in connection with T.S. (MAC) 210 of 2017 under Section166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 for granting compensation of Rs.16,03,000/-. [3] The fact of the case in the version of claimant appellants in short is that on 25.10.2017 at about 5/5-15 p.m. victim Bikram Chowdhury was proceeding towards Nandannagarat his house by riding a motor bike bearing registration No. TR-01AH-6374 from Banikya Chowmuhani and when he reached at West Noabadi near Amtali Hospital suddenly one Truck vehicle bearing No. TR-01-1798 coming from the opposite direction with high speed and in rash and negligent manner dashed the victim…
5. 12.2013 passed in MAC Appeal No. 36 of 2006.” [7] Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and award dated 19.08.2019, passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.3, West Tripura Agartala in T.S.(MAC) 210 of 2017, the present appeal has been preferred by the appellants herein. [8] Mr. M.S. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the appellants has submitted that the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal misconceived the scope of Section-166 of the MV Act and ignoring the above crucial consideration by directing its attention to irrelevant factors where the accident case was covered by Section-166 of the MV Act. The learned tribunal ought to have considered the salary certificate of the deceased and considered his monthly income accordingly. The quantum of amount as awarded by the learned tribunal was not adequate enough nor could have compensated the wholesome earning which would have been earned by the deceased. The appellants have no other alternative remedy and the remedy sought for in the present appeal is completely justifiable. [9] Learned tribunal has failed to make proper appreciation of the matter that the appellants herein are the only dependents of the deceased and as such the learned tribunal’s decision to consider only 50% of the deceased’s salary to calculate the compensation is arbitrary and hackneyed. It has also been failed…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
MAC. App. No.95 of 2022
Smti. Pranati Majumder Chowdhury and 2 Others
.....Appellants
V_E_R_S_U_S
Sri Swapan Das and Another
.....Respondents
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. M.S. Dey, Advocate.
Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
02/05/2023
Heard Mr. M.S. Dey, learned counsel appearing for the appellants
and Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This is an appeal filed under Section-173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 by the appellant, challenging the judgment and award and final order
dated 19.08.2019 in favour of the claimant-appellants for death of late Bikram
Chowdhury passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, No.3, West
Tripura, Agartala, in connection with T.S. (MAC) 210 of 2017 under Section166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 for granting compensation of
Rs.16,03,000/-.
[3]
The fact of the case in the version of claimant appellants in short
is that on 25.10.2017 at about 5/5-15 p.m. victim Bikram Chowdhury was
proceeding towards Nandannagarat his house by riding a motor bike bearing
registration No. TR-01AH-6374 from Banikya Chowmuhani and when he
reached at West Noabadi near Amtali Hospital suddenly one Truck vehicle
bearing No. TR-01-1798 coming from the opposite direction with
high speed and in rash and negligent manner dashed the victim a result of
which the victim fell down on the spot and his bike was fully damaged.
Immediately after the accident local people shifted the victim to GBP Hospital
here the attending doctor declared him as dead. It is further stated in the claim
petition that deceased was a bachelor and the family members were fully
dependent on him and at the time of accident deceased was 25years of age. At
the time of accident deceased was a driver by profession and his monthly
income was Rs.15,000/- per month. As the victim died due to a vehicular
accident, claimant petitioners being her parents and brother filed the instant
claim petition.
[4]
An FIR was lodged by the appellant No.2 i.e. the brother of the
victim and accordingly a case was registered at Bodhjungnagar P.S. and same
was numbered as Case No.047 of 2017 dated 25.10.2017 under Sections279/304(A) of IPC the police conducted the investigation and consequently,
filed a charge sheet against one Sri Shyamal Debbarma, the driver of the
offending vehicle under Sections-279/337/304(A) of IPC and Section-187 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
[5]
On 06.12.2017 the appellants herein approached before the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal under Section-166 of the MV Act for adequate
compensation. The victim was sole bread winner of the family and died at the
young age of 25 years. He was a driver by occupation and his monthly salary
was Rs.12,000/- along with other expenditure such as fooding and
commutation of Rs.3,000/- which comes to Rs.15,000/- per month.
[6]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Court bellow has
observed as under:
“18. In the result, the petition filed by the claimant
petitioners u/s 166 of MV Act is hereby allowed on contest. The
claimant petitioner Nos. 1, 2 and 3 being mother, brother and
father of the deceased are entitled to get Rs. 16,03,000/(Rupees sixteen lacs three thousand only) as compensation in
this case.
Now,
it
is
to
be
determined
who
shall
be
held
responsible for making compensation in this case. It reveals from
the case record that on the relevant date of accident the
offending vehicle was insured with OP No.2,the New India
Assurance Company Ltd. and the insurance policy coverage was
also within the stipulated period.
The OP No. 1 being the owner of offending vehicle
has exhibited some document, i.e., Driving license standing in the
name of Shyamal Debbarma (Ext.A), Registration certificate of
the vehicle bearing No. TR 01-1798, Truck (Ext.B), Insurance
policy two sheets [Ext.C to C(i)], Tax token (Ext.D), Fitness
certificate (Ext.E), Route permit (Ext.F).
So, OP No.2, the New India Assurance Co. Ltd. is
liable to indemnify the compensation being the insurer of the
vehicle of the OP No.1 vide No. TR-01-1798. So, the OP No.2
being the insurer of the aforesaid vehicle shall be solely
responsible for making payment of compensation in this case to
the claimant petitioner No.1 as per this judgment. This amount
shall have to paid by the OP No.2 within sixty days from today.
This amount shall carry interest @ 9% per annum from the date
of presentation of the application on 06.12.2017 before this
Tribunal till payment is made.
Out of total awarded amount, Rs. 1,00,000/- as loss of
love and affection is given to petitioner No. 1 and 3 equally. So
this amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- be released directly to the bank
account of the claimant petitioner Nos. 1 & 3. Rest awarded
amount of compensation, i.e., Rs. 15,03,000/- (Rs. 16,03,000/- Rs. 1,00,000/-) inclusive of interest shall be divided equally
among the claimant petitioner Nos. 1, 2 and 3. Out of the share of
the petitioner Nos. 1, 2 and 3, 50% each of their share shall be
kept in fixed deposit in their respective name at the UCO Bank,
District Court Branch, Agartala for a period of five years and the
balance amount shall be paid to their individual bank account.
However, the petitioner No.1, 2 and 3 are entitled to
withdraw monthly interest therefrom to meet their expenses, if
needed.
The claimant petitioner No.1, 2 and 3 are directed to
furnish a photocopy of the pass book duly certified by the bank
having IFSC & MICR Code for opening of their F/D certificates.
No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted from the fixed
deposit accounts without prior permission of the Tribunal in
pursuance of the judgment of our Hon’ble High Court dated
5.12.2013 passed in MAC Appeal No. 36 of 2006.”
[7]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment
and award dated 19.08.2019, passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Court No.3, West Tripura Agartala in T.S.(MAC) 210 of 2017, the
present appeal has been preferred by the appellants herein.
[8]
Mr. M.S. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the appellants has
submitted that the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal misconceived the
scope of Section-166 of the MV Act and ignoring the above crucial
consideration by directing its attention to irrelevant factors where the accident
case was covered by Section-166 of the MV Act. The learned tribunal ought to
have considered the salary certificate of the deceased and considered his
monthly income accordingly. The quantum of amount as awarded by the
learned tribunal was not adequate enough nor could have compensated the
wholesome earning which would have been earned by the deceased. The
appellants have no other alternative remedy and the remedy sought for in the
present appeal is completely justifiable.
[9]
Learned tribunal has failed to make proper appreciation of the
matter that the appellants herein are the only dependents of the deceased and as
such the learned tribunal’s decision to consider only 50% of the deceased’s
salary to calculate the compensation is arbitrary and hackneyed. It has also
been failed to appreciate that the MV Act itself is a beneficial legislation and
has been brought into force relaxing several stringencies of procedural law only
for the benefit of the victims. The learned tribunal has failed to understand the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court on the matter of compensation under the
MV Act.
[10]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
after gone through the observation made by the learned tribunal, now, the main
crucial point is that whether the present appellants are entitled to get
compensation and if so what would be the amount of compensation and who
shall be held responsible for making compensation in this case.
[11]
The claimant appellants in their claim petition stated that the
deceased was 25 years at the time of his death and he used to earn Rs. 15,000/per month by driving. From the evidence of PW-2, Dr. Saibal Kanti Nandi it
revealed that he issued a salary certificate to the deceased that his monthly
income was Rs. 15,000/-. From the Exhibit 3 it appears that the deceased was
23 years old at the time of his death. PW-1 has exhibited a salary certificate
issued in the name of deceased by him. But PW-1 has not filed any document
in form of ITR deduction or monthly pay slip issued in the name of deceased.
So, Exhibit-1 cannot be taken into consideration in full but Exhibit
5 driving licence of deceased proves that deceased was a skilled labour. So, this
court can presume the deceased as a skilled labour. Accordingly, his income is
assessed as Rs. 9,000/- per month.
[12]
Now, considering the future prospects in pursuance of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Special leave petition Civil
No. 25590 of 2014 dated 31.10.17, this Court like to add 50% of the income as
future prospect with his monthly earning. So, the yearly loss of income of the
deceased comes to Rs. 9,000/- + 50% of Rs. 9,000/- X 12 which comes
toRs.1,62,000/- per annum. Deceased Bikram Chowdhury died bachelor and
the 50% would be deducted from the said amount on calculation which comes
to Rs. 81,000/- (Rs. 1,62,000/- – Rs. 1,62,000/- x 50%). So, after deduction
yearly income of the deceased comes to Rs. 81,000/-. Deceased Bikram
Chowdhury died at the age of 23 years. So, here in this case multiplier will be
18 in pursuance of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Civil
Appeal No. 3483 of 2008 (arising out of SLP (C) No.8648 of 2007) in Sarala
Verma & Ors. vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. Dated 15.04.2009).
So, after calculation it comes to Rs. 81,000/- x 18= Rs. 14,58,000/-.
[13]
The claimant appellants must have expended some amount for
transportation of deceased in emergency section. So, the Tribunal awards Rs
5,000/-to the claimant appellants. Further, with the aforesaid amount , this
Court also add an amount of Rs. 15,000/-towards loss of estates and further Rs.
25,000/- towards funeral expenses in pursuance of the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in Special Leave Petition Civil No. 25590 of 2014
(National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Pronoy Shetty & Ors. Dated31.10.17). The
Tribunal also awards Rs. 1,00,000/- for loss of love and affection of their son to
his parents. Thus, in total the claimant appellants are entitled to get Rs.
16,03,000/- (14,58,000/- + Rs. 5,000/- + Rs. 15,000/- + Rs, 25,000/+1,00,000/-) as compensation for the death of the deceased.
[14]
Hence, this Court is of the considered view that the order
passed by the learned Court below needs no interference. Thus, the
present appeal stands dismissed consequently, the judgment and award as
passed by the learned tribunal stands affirmed. As a sequel, miscellaneous
applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review