Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.242 of 2021
WA No.243 of 2021
WA No.244 of 2021
IN WA No.242 of 2021
SMT. Parul Rani Barman,
D/o Shri Sunil Barman, resident of village- Bhuiyar Tilla, PO
& PS Melaghar, District- Sepahijala Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. THE STATE OF TRIPURA.
represented by the Secretary-cum-Commissioner to the
Health & Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, P.O.- Kunjanban, P.S.- New Capital Complex,
District- West Tripura.
2. THE DIRECTOR,
Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, PO- Agartala, P.S.- West Agartala, District- WEST
Tripura.
---- Official respondent(s)
3. SMT. RITA RABI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
4. SMT. BASANTI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
5. SMT. SMRITI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
6. SMT. LALITA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
7. SMT. MITALI RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
8. SMT. CHAMPA MAJUMDER,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
9. SMT. MAMPI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
10. SMT. PUJA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
11. SMT. SHOBHA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
12. SMT. BARNALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
13. SMT. SOUMI SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
14. SMT. DIPALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
15. SMT. SOMA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
16. SMT. SAMPA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
17. SMT. TAPASHI NATTA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
18. SMT. GITA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
19. SMT. PRIYANKA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
20. SMT. DIPASREE DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
21. SMT. MANTI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
22. SMT. RENUKA BALA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
23. SMT. RUMA RANI SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
24.SMT. PANCHALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
25. SMT. MAMPI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
26. SMT. ARCHANA NAMASUDRA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
27. SMT. JAYASREE DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
28. SMT. PAPIYA BHOWMIK,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
29. SMT. PAYEL DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
30. SMT. MIRA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
31. SMT. RINKU BARMAN,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
32.SMT. PRABHA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
33. SMT. TULI NAMASUDRA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
34. SMT. MINATI BARMAN,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
35. SMT. ARPITA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
36. SMT. SUPRIYA NAMA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
37. SMT. SHIPRA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
38. SMT. PRATIMA MALAKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
39. SMT. SUKLA SUKLADAS
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
40. SMT. MIRA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
41. SMT. RATNA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
42. SMT. SUPRIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
43. SMT. MITHU DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
44. SMT. RUPA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
45.SMT. RUPA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
46. SMT. RITA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
47. SMT. ANITA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
48. SMT. MAMATA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
49. SMT. PAPIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
50. SMT. SUPRIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
51. SMT. RAKHI SUKLA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
52. SMT. SHIULI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
---- Private respondent(s)
IN WA No.243 of 2021
SMT. PIYALI DAS,
W/o- Sri Pinak Deb, R/o - P.O. and Vill- Marachara, P.S.Kamalpur, District- Dhalai Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. THE STATE OF TRIPURA.
represented by the Secretary-cum-Commissioner to the
Health & Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, P.O.- Kunjanban, P.S.- New Capital Complex,
District- West Tripura.
2. THE DIRECTOR,
Health AND Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, PO- Agartala, P.S.- West Agartala, District- WEST
Tripura.
---- Official respondent(s)
3. SMT. RITA RABI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
4. SMT. BASANTI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
5. SMT. SMRITI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
6. SMT. LALITA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
7. SMT. MITALI RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
8. SMT. CHAMPA MAJUMDER,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
9. SMT. MAMPI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
10. SMT. PUJA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
11. SMT. SHOBHA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
12. SMT. BARNALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
13. SMT. SOUMI SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
14. SMT. DIPALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
15. SMT. SOMA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
16. SMT. SAMPA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
17. SMT. TAPASHI NATTA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
18. SMT. GITA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
19. SMT. PRIYANKA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
20. SMT. DIPASREE DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
21. SMT. MANTI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
22. SMT. RENUKA BALA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
23. SMT. RUMA RANI SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
24.SMT. PANCHALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
25. SMT. MAMPI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
26. SMT. ARCHANA NAMASUDRA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
27. SMT. JAYASREE DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
28. SMT. PAPIYA BHOWMIK,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
29. SMT. PAYEL DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
30. SMT. MIRA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
31. SMT. RINKU BARMAN,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
32.SMT. PRABHA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
33. SMT. TULI NAMASUDRA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
34. SMT. MINATI BARMAN,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
35. SMT. ARPITA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
36. SMT. SUPRIYA NAMA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
37. SMT. SHIPRA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
38. SMT. PRATIMA MALAKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
39. SMT. SUKLA SUKLADAS
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
40. SMT. MIRA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
41. SMT. RATNA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
42. SMT. SUPRIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
43. SMT. MITHU DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
44. SMT. RUPA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
45.SMT. RUPA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
46. SMT. RITA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
47. SMT. ANITA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
48. SMT. MAMATA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
49. SMT. PAPIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
50. SMT. SUPRIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
51. SMT. RAKHI SUKLA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
52. SMT. SHIULI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
---- Private respondent(s)
IN WA No.244 of 2021
SMT. SAMPA DAS,
D/o Shri Krishnadhan Das, resident of Joynagar, POAgartala, PS-West Agartala, District – West Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. THE STATE OF TRIPURA.
represented by the Secretary-cum-Commissioner to the
Health & Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, P.O.- Kunjanban, P.S.- New Capital Complex,
District- West Tripura.
2. THE DIRECTOR,
Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, PO- Agartala, P.S.- West Agartala, District- West
Tripura.
---- Official respondent(s)
3. SMT. RITA RABI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
4. SMT. BASANTI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
5. SMT. SMRITI DAS,
D/O- unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
6. SMT. LALITA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
7. SMT. MITALI RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
8. SMT. CHAMPA MAJUMDER,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
9. SMT. MAMPI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
10. SMT. PUJA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
11. SMT. SHOBHA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
12. SMT. BARNALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
13. SMT. SOUMI SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
14. SMT. DIPALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
15. SMT. SOMA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
16. SMT. SAMPA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
17. SMT. TAPASHI NATTA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
18. SMT. GITA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
19. SMT. PRIYANKA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
20. SMT. DIPASREE DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
21. SMT. MANTI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
22. SMT. RENUKA BALA SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
23. SMT. RUMA RANI SARKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
24.SMT. PANCHALI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
25. SMT. MAMPI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
26. SMT. ARCHANA NAMASUDRA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
27. SMT. JAYASREE DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
28. SMT. PAPIYA BHOWMIK,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
29. SMT. PAYEL DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
30. SMT. MIRA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
31. SMT. RINKU BARMAN,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
32.SMT. PRABHA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
33. SMT. TULI NAMASUDRA,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
34. SMT. MINATI BARMAN,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
35. SMT. ARPITA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
36. SMT. SUPRIYA NAMA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
37. SMT. SHIPRA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
38. SMT. PRATIMA MALAKAR,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
39. SMT. SUKLA SUKLADAS
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
40. SMT. MIRA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
41. SMT. RATNA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
42. SMT. SUPRIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
43. SMT. MITHU DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
44. SMT. RUPA BISWAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
45.SMT. RUPA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
46. SMT. RITA RANI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
47. SMT. ANITA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
48. SMT. MAMATA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
49. SMT. PAPIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
50. SMT. SUPRIYA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
51. SMT. RAKHI SUKLA DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
52. SMT. SHIULI DAS,
D/O- Unknown, Notice to be served through Respondent
NO.2.
---- Private respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Samarjit Bhattachajee, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
:
12.03.2024
Date of delivery of
:
18.03.2024
Judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The three writ petitions are arising out of the common
question and seeking common relief and accordingly arguments are
heard by way of common judgment.
02.
The original writ petitions were filed seeking for the
following reliefs:
i) Admit this Writ Appeal;
ii) Call for the relevant records, pertaining to the impugned Judgment and
Order (Oral) dated 01.04.2021, passed in W.P.(C) No.1471 of 2017, W.P.(C)
No.1472 of 2017 and W.P.(C) No.1475 of 2017;
iii) After hearing the parties, in terms of the GROUNDS set forth above, be
pleased to quash/set aside the impugned Judgment & Order (Oral) dated
01.04.2021, passed in W.P.(C) No.1472 of 2017, passed by the Learned
Single Judge, and thereafter, allow this Writ Appeal, thereby granting the
reliefs, as sought for in the Writ Petition [W.P.(C) No.1471 of 2017, W.P.(C)
No.1472 of 2017 and W.P.(C) No.1475 of 2017];
iv) And pass any other Order(s) as may be deemed fit and proper for ends of
justice.
03.
By the common judgment and order dated 01.04.2021
the writ petitions are dismissed and thereafter the present writ
appeals are filed by the present appellants seeking redressal from
the court.
04.
The facts of the case are that the petitioners completed
3 years & 6 months Diploma Course in General Nursing & Midwifery
(GNM for short) from the East West School of Nursing, Bangalore,
under the Karnataka State Diploma in Nursing Examination Board,
within the period with effect from 01.09.2009 to 31.08.2012 and
from 01.09.2012 to 28.02.2013. The result of internship was
published on 28.02.2013 but the marksheet issued
by the
concerned Board after verification was in the month of May, 2013.
Thereafter, the Director of Health Services, Government of Tripura
issued an employment notification by way of newspaper publication
vide Advertisement No.ICA/O/131/16 stating that a Walk-ininterview would be held for selection of candidates for filling up of
vacant post of staff nurse under the Health and Family Welfare
Department, Government of Tripura on fixed pay basis. The
essential qualifications were HS(+2) Examination passed and
Diploma in GNM course or degree in Nursing (B.Sc. in Nursing)
from the institution recognized by the Indian Nursing Council.
Thereafter, the appellant herein being eligible for the said post
went for Walk-in-Interview in the said exam as aforestated.
05.
The selection to the post of Staff Nurse is made on the
basis of seniority and the seniority has to be drawn up on the basis
of the date of publication of the result of internship. On the other
hand, the respondent had considered the seniority on the basis of
the date of issuance or publication of marksheet of internship which
is illegal. The Director of Health Services had issued two orders
dated 04.05.2016 and 13.05.2016 where the detailed description of
the Board members was mentioned who had conducted the
interview. Due to mistake in determining the seniority the private
respondents in the writ petition who completed their internship
posterior to the date of completion of internship by the present
appellants were selected and appointed and the appellants herein
were deprived. Thereafter on 05.01.2017 the appellants submitted
an application to the Health Minister, Government of Tripura
seeking for rectification of the mistake done in the recruitment
process where the candidates those who were selected were on the
basis of seniority and thus the appellants inspite of being passed
out in the month of February, 2013 were not recruited and the
private respondents who passed out in the month of May, 2013
were recruited.
06.
In
terms
thereof,
one
Smt.
Satarupa
Majumder
enforced the RTI Act seeking for information from the office of the
Director of Health Services, regarding the recruitment procedure.
In response to that RTI reply dated 30.01.2017 it was mentioned
that the determination of seniority was made from the date of
publication of final year marksheet for B.Sc. Nursing candidates
and date of publication of internship marksheet for GNM passed
candidates and thus for determining the seniority the date of
publication of the result was overlooked by the official respondents.
07.
The petitioners contended that the respondents did not
select the petitioners and their names are not found in the selection
list. Hence, the writ petition is filed.
08.
It is the case of the petitioners that despite their
eligibility and criteria as qualified persons and being completed
their
Nursing
course
prior
to
the
private
respondents,
the
petitioners were deprived of their selection. It is also contended
that by way of an RTI, the mode of selection was obtained and one
of the criteria was that the seniority of the candidates was also
taken into account. For the purpose of seniority, it is the date of
issuance or publication of mark-sheet of internship and the
certificate was issued accordingly.
09.
Since the petitioners have completed their nursing
course much prior to the private respondents, their candidature
cannot be denied and as a sample case the petitioner Piyali Das in
WP(C)No.1471 of 2017 completed her course from 01.09.2009 to
31.08.2012 (for theoretical and practical training) and from
01.09.2012 to 28.02.2013 (for 6 months internship training) and
certificate was issued in the month of May, 2013 and whereas one
of the private respondents completed the course from 31.08.2009
to 13.04.2013 and the certificate was issued on 25.06.2013. Hence
the procedure adopted was not justified and prayed to set aside the
selection procedure and provide the petitioners’ employment.
10.
The counsel for the appellants relied on the following
citations in Dr. (Major) Meeta Sahai versus State of Bihar &
Ors. [Civil Appeal No.9482 of 2019 arising out of Special Leave
Petition (Civil) No.12245 of 2017].
11.
Learned
respondents
Addl.
contended
G.A.
before
appearing
this
court
for
that
the
the
official
selection
procedure was in a fair and transparent manner and there is no
violation in the procedure and the question of setting aside the
order in writ, does not arise. He also contended that the procedure
of Walk-in-interview was duly notified and the documents were
verified and also in the interview the selection committee has duly
interacted with the candidates and finalized the selection list. He
also contended that the petitioners have approached before this
court with delay and on the ground of laches also. The appellant
does not have any basis to claim relief and the same needs to be
dismissed.
12.
In support of his submission, Learned Addl. G.A. has
relied upon few citations regarding the present context in D.
Sarojakumari vs. R. Helen Thilakom and Others reported in
(2017) 9 SCC 478 and Ashok Kumar and Another vs. State of
Bihar and Others reported in (2017) 4 SCC 357.
13.
The counsel for the appellant-petitioners in reply to the
submission of Learned Addl. G.A. has contended that there is no
delay in dismissing the ground on laches. Since, the petitioners had
updated through RTI enclosing the copies and the procedure as to
how the interview was conducted before this court.
Heard both the sides.
14.
Having perused the records and the submissions made
by the Learned counsel for the parties we are of the considered
opinion that admittedly, there are laches. In so far as the facts are
concerned the Director of Health Services, Government of Tripura
issued an Employment Notification by way of newspaper publication
vide Advertisement No.ICA/O/131/16 notifying that a Walk-inInterview would be held for selection of candidates for filling up
vacant posts of Staff Nurse under the Health & Family Welfare
Department, Government of Tripura on fixed pay basis on
16.05.2016. For the sake of convenience, the said notification is
herewith extracted:
EMPLOYMENT NOTIFICATION
A walk-interview will be held for selection of candidates for filling up
vacancies in the post of staff nurse under the health & family welfare
department, government of Tripura on purely temporary and fixed pay
basis@10,130/- being 75 % of the minimum slab of entry level pay in
the pay band-2 along with Grade pay of 4200/- plus additional
remuneration increased by the government from time to time.
Vacancies:300[SC-46,ST-85,UR-161,Ex-Serviceman(SC)1,Ex-serviceman(ST)-3,Ex-Serviceman(UR)-4,
Essential Qualification:A. HS(+2stage) Examination Passed
And
B. Diploma in General Nursing & Midwifery course or degree
in nursing (B.Sc in Nursing) course from the institution
recognised by the Indian Nursing Council.
Venue of interview:Office Of The Deputy Drugs Controller, Government Of
Tripura, Pandit Nehru Complex, Gurkhabasti PO:-Kunjaban
Agartala.
Date and time Of Interview:16th may 2016 from 11.00 AM to 2.00PM [for the candidates
of west & Shipahijala Tripura District.]17th may 2016 from
11.00 AM to 2.00PM [for the candidates of Khowai & Dhalai
District] 18th may 2016 from 11.00 AM to 2.00PM [for the
candidates of Gomati & South Tripura District]19th may 2016
from 11.00 AM to 2.00PM [for the candidates of North and
Unakoti District.]
The eligibility willing candidates (male and female) residing
permanently in the state of Tripura within the age limit of minimum 18
yrs and maximum 40 yrs as on the date of interview (relaxable for 5
years ST, SC and in service candidate) and having registration
certificate of Tripura nursing counselling may appear before the
interview board on scheduled date time and venue all original
testimonials and attested/self attested copies of relevant documents
along with application plain papers stating all the particulars as
mentioned below:1.Name of the post applied for. 2. Name of the candidate (in Block
letters) 3.Fathers/Husbands name, 4. Parmanent address, 5. Present
address to which the communication is to be made 6. Contact no.
7.Whether ST SC or ex Serviceman, 8.Whether belongs to BPL,AAY,
9.Date of Birth, 10. Educational and other qualification (mentioning
year of passing total marks obtained and percentage of marks
obtained), 11.Expirence if (any), 12. Employment Exchange Reg. No,
13. Nationality, 14. Religion, 15, Monthly family income of all source,
16. Co-curricular activity(Cultural, Sports,etc if any).
The candidates not having registration of Tripura Nursing counselling
are not entitled to appear before the interview board .No TA & DA is
admissible for appearing before the interview board .the number of
vacancies may increase or decrease at any time before or after
interview.
S/D
(Dr.J.K.varma)
Director of Health Services,
Government of Tripura.)
15.
Considering the arguments of the appellants that the
appellant-petitioners
were
qualified
and
have
completed
the
nursing course from 01.09.2009 to 31.08.2012 (for theoretical and
practical training) and from 01.09.2012 to 28.02.2013 (for 6
months internship training) and certificate was issued in the month
of May, 2013 and the private respondents completed her course
from 31.08.2009 to 13.04.2013 and the certificate was issued on
25.06.2013. During argument before the Court, Learned counsel
has taken one of the private respondent as a sample case, all
though, there are number of private respondents in all other
related cases. It is the case of the petitioners that the official
respondents did not consider their appointment as Staff Nurse in
terms of seniority but only considered the private respondents who
have
completed
their
course
and
obtained
the
certificate
subsequent to the petitioners and thus they are juniors to the
petitioners and they cannot be appointed and the petitioners
cannot be rejected.
16.
To the above argument it becomes necessary to say
that no doubt the petitioners obtained the certificate is much prior
to the private respondents but this is not the only criteria in terms
of the notification. The very purpose of the appointment of the
candidates for selection is by way of Walk-in-interview and before
taking interview, the credentials of the candidates would be
scrutinized and once the candidate comes out of the interview
board successfully, then only they would be selected.
17.
Mere possessing the certificate by the petitioner prior to
the private respondents is not the only criteria for providing the
appointment to the petitioners and not to find their name in the
merit/selection list. No arguments is advanced and no mistakes
have been pointed out in so far as the interview is concerned.
Unless any malafides are attributed and they are proved, it cannot
be said that the selection committee acted malafide and deprived
the eligible candidates. It is not a case of malafides.
18.
During the course of arguments this court has enquired
with regard to the available vacancies and in all fairness it was
reported that in spite of Walk-in-interviews all posts are not filled
and there were still vacancies.
19.
Learned Addl. G.A. has strongly objected the contention
as raised by the appellant. He has stated that the appellants herein
have participated in the fresh selection process and if the
appellants were aggrieved by the decision to hold a fresh process,
they did not adopt their remedy. Instead, they participated in the
fresh process of selection and it was only upon being unsuccessful
that they challenged the result in the writ petition.
20.
Dr. Alak Dewan, Joint Director, Health Services present
in court has assisted on the issue of filling up the further vacancies
and submitted that the subject matter involved in these writ
petitions pertains to 2016 selection and the writ petitions came to
be
filed
in
2017.
Thereafter,
the
Government
has
issued
recruitment rules and selection procedure in 2018 and accordingly,
the official
respondents
have taken
steps
for issuing
fresh
notification and the present selection procedure includes (i)written
test and (ii) interview, apart from verification of credentials. The
selection process has commenced and shortly the list of selected
candidates would be released.
21.
The
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
of
India,
in
D.
Sarojakumari vs. R. Helen Thilakom and Others reported in
(2017) 9 SCC 478 in paras 5-9 and 11, held as under:
“5. In Dr. G. Sarana vs. University of Lucknow: (1976) 3 SCC 585
the petitioner after appearing in the interview for the post of
Professor and having not been selected pleaded that the experts
were biased. This Court did not permit the petitioner to raise this
issue and held as follows:15.We do not, however, consider it necessary in the present
case to go into the question of the reasonableness of bias or
real likelihood of bias as despite the fact that the appellant
knew all the relevant facts, he did not before appearing for
the interview or at the time of the interview raise even his
little
finger
against
the
constitution
of
the
Selection Committee. He seems to have voluntarily appeared
before the committee and taken a chance of having a
favourable recommendation from it. Having done so, it is not
now open to him to turn round and question the constitution
of the committee……
6. In Madan Lal & Ors. vs. State of J&K : (1995) 3 SCC 486, the
petitioner laid challenge to the manner and method of conducting
viva-voce test after they had appeared in the same and were
unsuccessful. This Court held as follows:9…….Thus the petitioners took a chance to get themselves
selected at the said oral interview. Only because they did
not find themselves to have emerged successful as a result
of their combined performance both at written test and oral
interview, they have filed this petition. It is now well
settled that if a candidate takes a calculated chance and
appears at the interview, then, only because the result of
the interview is not palatable to him, he cannot turn round
and subsequently contend that the process of interview was
unfair
or
Selection
Committee
was
not
properly
constituted……
7. In Manish Kumar Shahi vs. State of Bihar : (2010) 12 SCC 576 ,
this Court held as follows :23…….Surely, if the petitioner’s name had appeared in the
merit list, he would not have even dreamed of challenging
the selection. The petitioner invoked jurisdiction of the High
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India only
after he found that his name (1995) 3 SCC 486 (2010) 12
SCC 576 does not figure in the merit list prepared by the
Commission. This conduct of the petitioner clearly
disentitles him from questioning the selection and the High
Court did not commit any error by refusing to entertain the
writ petition.
8. In the case of Ramesh Chandra Shah and others vs. Anil Joshi :
(2013) 11 SCC 309 the petitioners took part in the process of
selection made under the general Rules. Having appeared in the
interview and not being successful they challenged the method of
recruitment itself. They were not permitted to raise such an
objection. This Court held as follows:24. In view of the propositions laid down in the above noted
judgments, it must be held that by having taken part in the
process of selection with full knowledge that the recruitment
was being made under the General Rules, the respondents
had waived their right to question the advertisement or
methodology adopted by the Board for making selection and
the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High
Court committed grave error by entertaining the grievance
made by the respondents.
9. The same view has been taken in Madras Institute of
Development Studies and Another vs. Dr. K. Sivasubramaniyan and
others : (2016) 1 SCC 454.
11. As far as the present case is concerned an advertisement was
issued by Respondent No.6 inviting applications for the post of
Music Teacher in Samuel LMS High School. Respondent No.1 did not
raise any objection at that stage that the post could not be filled in
by direct recruitment and she should be considered for promotion.
Not only that, she in fact, applied for the post and took part in the
selection process. After having taken part in the selection process
and being found lower in merit to the appellant, she cannot at this
stage be permitted to turn around and claim that the post could not
be filled in by direct recruitment. The reasoning of the learned
Single Judge in rejecting the objection is not in consonance with
the law laid down by this Court. In view of this, we need not go into
the other issues raised.”
22.
In Ashok Kumar and Another vs. State of Bihar
and Others reported in (2017) 4 SCC 357 the Hon’ble Supreme
court observed as under:
“12. The appellants participated in the fresh process of selection. If
the appellants were aggrieved by the decision to hold a fresh
process, they did not espouse their remedy. Instead, they
participated in the fresh process of selection and it was only upon
being unsuccessful that they challenged the result in the writ
petition. This was clearly not open to the appellants. The principle
of estoppel would operate.
15. In Manish Kumar Shah v. State of Bihar: (2010) 12 SCC 576,
the same principle was reiterated in the following observations :
16. We also agree with the High Court that after having
taken part in the process of selection knowing fully well
that more than 19% marks have been earmarked for
viva voce test, the Petitioner is not entitled to challenge
the criteria or process of selection. Surely, if the
Petitioner's name had appeared in the merit list, he
would not have even dreamed of challenging the
selection. The Petitioner invoked jurisdiction of the High
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India only
after he found that his name does not figure in the merit
list prepared by the Commission.
This conduct of the Petitioner clearly disentitles him
from questioning the selection and the High Court did
not commit any error by refusing to entertain the writ
petition. Reference in this connection may be made to
the Judgments in Madan Lal v. State of J. and K.: (1995)
3 SCC 486, Marripati Nagaraja v. Government of Andhra
Pradesh and Ors.: (2007) 11 SCC 522, Dhananjay Malik
and Ors. v. State of Uttaranchal and Ors.: (2008) 4 SCC
171, Amlan Jyoti Borooah v. State of Assam: (2009) 3
SCC 227 and K.A. Nagamani v. Indian Airlines: (2009) 5
SCC 515.”
In
the
present
context
in
Union
Public
Service
Commission versus M. Sathiya Priya & Ors. reported in (2018)
15 SCC 796 which the apex court has observed as under:
“16. The learned counsel for UPSC, drawing the attention of the
Court to the contents of the affidavit filed by UPSC before CAT,
submits that the Selection Committee also reviews and determines
the overall grading recorded in the Annual Confidential Reports to
ensure that the overall grading in the Annual Confidential Reports
is not inconsistent with the grading/remarks under various specific
parameters or attributes. It is brought to the notice of the Court
that the Selection Committee takes into account orders regarding
appreciation for meritorious work done by the officers concerned
and also keeps in view orders awarding penalties or any adverse
remarks duly communicated to the officers, which even after due
consideration of their representation by the suitable forum, are not
expunged. The aforementioned norms are uniformly applied to all
the States/Cadres in the matter of induction into the All India
Services.
19. No doubt, the Selection Committee may be guided by the
classification adopted by the State Government but, for good
reasons, the Selection Committee may evolve its own classification
which may be at variance with the grading given in the Annual
Confidential Reports. As has been held by this Court in the case of
UPSC v. K. Rajaiah, and others (2005) 10 SCC 15, the power to
classify as “Outstanding”, “Very Good”, “Good” and “Unfit” is
vested with the Selection Committee. That is a function incidental
to the selection process. The classification given by the State
Authorities in the Annual Confidential Reports is not binding on the
Selection Committee. Such classification is within the prerogative
of the Selection Committee and no reasons need be recorded,
though it is desirable that in a case of grading at variance with that
of the State Government, reasons be recorded. But having regard
to the nature of the function and the power confined to the
Selection Committee under Regulation 5(4), it is not a legal
requirement that reasons should be recorded for classifying an
officer at variance with the State Government’s decision. It is
relevant to note that no allegations of malice or bias are made by
the
first
respondent
at
any
stage
of
the proceedings
against the Selection Committee or UPSC.
23. In the matter on hand, we find that neither the decision nor the
decision-making process was actuated with malice, and no grave
mistake was committed by the Selection Committee leading to
arbitrariness. We find that it is not a case of pick and choose, but
the
selection
has
been
made
rationally. The
applicant
respondent no.1 was duly considered by the Selection
Committee. However, on an overall assessment of her service
records, her name was not included in the select list due to the
statutory limit of its size and as officers with higher grading were
available for inclusion in the select list as per the provisions of
Regulation 5(5) of the Regulations.”
23.
In view of the above discussion and the circumstances,
this court feels that the petitioners have not made out the case to
consider their prayer and to set aside the selection procedure also
the court does not find any relevance with the citations as
aforestated by the counsel for the petitioners. Thus, writ petitions
are devoid of merit and the order of the Learned Single Judge
stands confirmed and the writ appeals stands dismissed.
Pending application/s, if any, also stands dismissed.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
JUDGE
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.07.11 04:33:24
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review