The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. 03.2017 under Section-174 of the Cr. P.C. and an investigation was carried on which revealed that the death of the husband of the appellant No.1 was caused due to electrocution. [5] The appellant No.1 also stated to have served a notice upon the respondents claiming compensation for causing death of victim due to gross negligence on the part of the respondents. The respondent No.4 though issued one letter dated 21st September, 2017 addressing to the appellant No.1 to submit relevant documents in respect of her claim. Accordingly, the appellant No.1 submitted her application annexing all the relevant documents but, the respondents did not pay any compensation. Thereafter, finding no other alternatives, the appellants have filed a suit before the Court below. It is also alleged that at the time of occurrence, deceased was aged about 35 years and his monthly salary was Rs.5,000/and in addition to that, he used to earn Rs.15,000/- per month as a motor mechanic. In total, his monthly income was Rs.20,000/- and used to contribute his total income towards the livelihood of his wife and son i.e. the other appellants in this appeal. But due to sudden death of deceased, the appellants have lost the said financial contribution from the side of the deceased. [6] After institution of the suit before the Court below, summons were duly served upon the respondents but, did not turn up and cont…
4. According to the respondents, under Article-82 of the Limitation Act, 1963, the claim should have been presented within two years from the date of death of the person. The contention was upheld and the claim petition was dismissed. The decision was upheld by the High Court as well, and thus, the appellants are before this Court.” [14] Mr. N. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the respondent has also opposed on the issue that the appeal is already barred by limitation in terms of the filing of the original suit. [15] In view of above arguments made by the learned counsel appearing for the parties, for come to a definite conclusion, let us revisit to the depositions of the PWs. [16] PW-1, Smti. Pappi Debnath (Bhattacharjee) @ Papiya in her oral evidence stated that on 16th day of March, 2017 at about 11:15 hours when her husband was trying to operate the water supply pump of West Lalcheri Gram Panchayat at that time her husband found fault in the power supply. Thereafter, when her husband tried to fix the fuse fitted on the coconut, he got electrocuted. It is further stated that the entire coconut tree was charged with electric energy of high voltage and when her husband came in contact with the coconut tree, he received burn injuries on his body. Thereafter, the matter was informed to the local fire service authority. On receipt of that information, the staffs of the fire s…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
RFA. No.06 of 2022
1.
Smti. Pappi Debnath (Bhattacharjee) @ Papiya, wife of late Prbal
Bhattacharjee, 30 years.
2.
Master Tamal Bhattacharjee, son of late Prbal Bhattacharjee, 07
years.
Both are residents of West Lalchari, P.O. Kulai Bazaar, P.S.
Ambassa, District: Dhalai Tripura.
[The plaintiff-appellant No.2 being minor is represented by his
natural guardian mother namely Smt. Pappi Debnath (Bhattacharjee)
@ Papiya, the plaintiff- appellant No.1]
-----Plaintiff-appellant(s)
-V-E-R-S-U-S-
1.
The State of Tripura, represented by Principal Secretary,
Department of Power, Govt. of Tripura. Secretariat Bhawan, New
Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2.
The Chief Managing Director, Tripura State Electric Corporation
Ltd., Bidyut Bhawan, Bodhjung Chowmuhoni Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN-799001.
3.
The Deputy General Manager, Ambassa Electrical Division,
TSECL, Ambassa, Dhalai Tripura, PIN-799289.
4.
The Senior Manager (Elect.), Ambassa Electrical Sub-Division,
TSECL, Ambassa, Dhalai Tripura, PIN-799289
-----Defendant-respondent(s)
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE [ACTING]
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Dipak Deb, Advocate
Mr. P. Gautam, Advocate.
Mr. N. Majumder, Advocate.
YES/NO
Judgment and Order dated 29th March, 2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. D. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellants. Also heard
Mr. P. Gautam, learned counsel and Mr. N. Majumder, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Section-96 of the CPC
against the judgment dated 14.09.2021 passed by the learned Civil Judge,
Sr. Division, Court No.2, Dhalai Judicial District, Ambassa in connection
M.S.03 of 2019.
[3]
The brief facts, leading to this appeal are that the husband of
plaintiff No.1, the appellant No.1 herein, was the water supply pump
operator. He was engaged in the water supply pump of West Lalchari
Gram Panchayat under the Sub-Division Officer (DWS), Drinking Water
Sanitation Sub-Division, Ambassa which was run by electricity. The
husband of the appellant No.1 used to operate the side electric pump very
sincerely and used to supply drinking water in the area regularly. It has
been alleged that the power department had installed a transformer at the
adjacent site of the water supply pump hose and the fuse of the power line
was installed with a coconut tree and the deceased had repeatedly
requested the concerned person of the power department to shift the same
and to install it within the pump house premises, but the power department
negligently did not take any steps in this regard.
[4]
Thereafter, on 16th day of March, 2017 at about 11.15 hours
when the husband of the appellant was trying to operate the said water
supply pump, he found fault in the power supply. Thereafter, when the
husband of the appellant tried to fix the fuse fitted on the coconut tree, he
got electrocuted. It is further alleged that the entire coconut tree was
charged with electric energy of high voltage and when the husband of the
appellant No.1 came in contact with the coconut tree, he received burn
injuries on his body. Thereafter, the matter was informed to the local fire
service authority. On receipt of that information, the staffs of the fire
service went to the spot and took the deceased to kulai District Hospital
where medical officer declared him brought dead and the matter was
entered in the GD book of Ambassa P.S. vide G.D. no. 21 dated
16.03.2017 under Section-174 of the Cr. P.C. and an investigation was
carried on which revealed that the death of the husband of the appellant
No.1 was caused due to electrocution.
[5]
The appellant No.1 also stated to have served a notice upon
the respondents claiming compensation for causing death of victim due to
gross negligence on the part of the respondents. The respondent No.4
though issued one letter dated 21st September, 2017 addressing to the
appellant No.1 to submit relevant documents in respect of her claim.
Accordingly, the appellant No.1 submitted her application annexing all the
relevant documents but, the respondents did not pay any compensation.
Thereafter, finding no other alternatives, the appellants have filed a suit
before the Court below. It is also alleged that at the time of occurrence,
deceased was aged about 35 years and his monthly salary was Rs.5,000/and in addition to that, he used to earn Rs.15,000/- per month as a motor
mechanic. In total, his monthly income was Rs.20,000/- and used to
contribute his total income towards the livelihood of his wife and son i.e.
the other appellants in this appeal. But due to sudden death of deceased,
the appellants have lost the said financial contribution from the side of the
deceased.
[6]
After institution of the suit before the Court below, summons
were duly served upon the respondents but, did not turn up and contested
the suit. Hence, the suit proceeded ex-parte against all the respondents and
the case was fixed for ex-parte hearing. During hearing of the suit ex-parte,
the appellant No.1 has examined herself as PW-1 and also examined
another witness as PW-2 and exhibited 10 numbers of documents to prove
her case. The respondents have remained absent throughout the trial and
did not adduce any evidence either documentary or oral.
[7]
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
D. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellants has submitted that the
judgment and decree of dismissal of the suit of the plaintiff-appellants
passed by the learned Court below is bad in law and not warranted by facts
and circumstances of the case.
[8]
The learned Court below committed wrong and illegalities in
deciding the case dismissing the suit as barred by limitation deciding the
case under Article-82 of the Limitation Act where, the suit for damage is
instituted for compensation for the loss of life by electrocution even by
fatal accident limitation should be considered and followed under Article137 of the Limitation Act being prescribed as three years from the date of
death.
[9]
He has further submitted that the learned Court below while
decided all the questions and considered the evidences adduced by the
appellants regarding the death of husband of the appellant No.1 and the
father of the appellant No.2 though decided the entitlement of
compensation of the appellants but very wrongly dismissed the suit of the
plaintiff-appellants but very wrongly dismissed the suit of the plaintiffappellants finding that the suit is barred by limitation as per provisions of
Section-82 of the Limitation Act.
[10]
The learned Court below while followed the methodology of
M.V. Act following multiplication of income and the age of the deceased
etc, in assessment of compensation but very wrongly ascertained the
amount of compensation by wrong consideration of the age and
multiplication and thereby very wrongly and illegally assessed the
compensation in the lower side.
[11]
The learned Court below ought to have considered that as per
the fatal Accident Act the application for compensation while is not being
made to District Judge and where there is no Tribunal formed for
entertaining the application for compensation under Indian Fatal Accident
Act, 1855 made by institution of a Civil Suit in the Civil Court of
jurisdiction then option is to be considered and limitation should be
followed as per provision of Section-137 of the Limitation Act as three
years from the date of death on ascertainment of cause of death by
electrocuted.
[12]
The learned Court below ought to have considered that the
suit of the appellants was very much within limitation period as per
provision of Section-137 of the Limitation Act. The learned Court below
ought to considered that the suit for damages and compensation for the loss
of life and the estate due to the death of husband of the appellant No.1 by
electrocution for the negligence of the staff of the department under Senior
Manager (Electric) the respondent No.4 would be not less than the amount
as claimed as compensation as claimed by the appellants in consideration
of the age and income by all sources of the husband of the appellant No.1.
[13]
Mr. Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
vehemently opposed and in support of his case has placed reliance upon a
decision of the Apex Court in Damini and Another v. Managing Director,
Jodhpur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited and Another, reported in (2017) 9
SCC 443, wherein, the Apex Court has held thus:
“3. The appellants filed an application under Section-1-A of the Fatal
Accidents Act, 1855 before the District Judge, Jaisalmer, Rajasthan
claiming Rs.22,68,000/- towards damages. The claim was resisted on the
ground of limitation among other grounds.
4. According to the respondents, under Article-82 of the Limitation Act,
1963, the claim should have been presented within two years from the date
of death of the person. The contention was upheld and the claim petition
was dismissed. The decision was upheld by the High Court as well, and
thus, the appellants are before this Court.”
[14]
Mr. N. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent has also opposed on the issue that the appeal is already barred
by limitation in terms of the filing of the original suit.
[15]
In view of above arguments made by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties, for come to a definite conclusion, let us revisit to
the depositions of the PWs.
[16]
PW-1, Smti. Pappi Debnath (Bhattacharjee) @ Papiya in her
oral evidence stated that on 16th day of March, 2017 at about 11:15 hours
when her husband was trying to operate the water supply pump of West
Lalcheri Gram Panchayat at that time her husband found fault in the power
supply. Thereafter, when her husband tried to fix the fuse fitted on the
coconut, he got electrocuted. It is further stated that the entire coconut tree
was charged with electric energy of high voltage and when her husband
came in contact with the coconut tree, he received burn injuries on his
body. Thereafter, the matter was informed to the local fire service
authority. On receipt of that information, the staffs of the fire service went
to the spot and took her husband to Kulai District Hospital where medical
officer declared him brought dead.
[17]
PW-2 Shri Bimal Debnath is one of the co-villagers of the
appellants and he narrated the same story in his affidavit-in-chief and
thereby corroborated the testimony of the appellants regarding the cause of
death of the victim.
[18]
It has already been stated that the respondents did not adduce
any documentary or oral evidence to take a contrary view. Therefore, there
should not be any hesitation to bold that the deceased, the husband of the
appellant No.1 and the father of the appellant No.2 has died on 16.03.2017
out of electrocution.
[19]
The Hon'ble Apex Court in M.P. Electricity Board Vs. Shail
Kumar and others, reported in AIR 2002 SC 551 held that “the defence
that electrocution was due to clandestine pilferage committed by stranger
is not available to electricity board. It is no defence on the board of the
management of the board that somebody committed mischief by siphoning
such energy to his private property and that the electrocution was from
such diverted line. It is the look out of the managers of the supply system to
prevent such pilferage by installing necessary devices. At any rate, if any
live wire got snapped and fell on the public road the electric current
thereon should automatically have been disrupted. Authorities manning
such dangerous commodities have extra duty to chalk out measures to
prevent such mishaps”.
[20]
In the present case, there is also no such claim is made from
the side of respondents. On the other hand, as pointed out above, the PW-1
and PW-2 in their affidavit-in-chief categorically stated that the deceased
Prabal Bhattacharjee has died due to negligence and actionable wrong on
the part of the defendants. The Final Report (Exbt.8) submitted by the
investigating
officer
in
Ambassa
police
station
UD
case
No.
2017/ABS/004 and the postmortem report (Exbt.10) of the deceased also
indicates that the deceased Prabal Bhattacharjee has died out of
electrocution. There is no re-vital evidence in this regard. Hence, it can be
safely held that the deceased Prabal Bhattacharjee has died due to
negligence and actionable wrong of the defendants.
[21]
Now, the question is how to calculate the quantum of
compensation? In this regard, guidance may be taken from the decision of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court, in a very recent decision namely, Santosh
Devi Vs. National Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors., reported in 2012 (6)
SCC 421, after referring to the decision in Sarla Verma & Ors. v. Delhi
Transport Corporation & Anr., reported in 2009 (6) SCC 121 wherein the
formula under different headings including the one relating to selection of
multiplier was quoted with approval. The said formula has been set out in
Sarla Verma (supra) in para 42 which reads as under:“42. We therefore hold that the multiplier to be used should be as mentioned
in Column (4) of the table above (prepared by applying Susamma Thomas,
Trilok Chandra and Charlie), which starts with an operative multiplier of 18
(for the age groups of 15 to 20 and 21 to 25 years), reduced by one unit for
every five years, that is M-17 for 26 to 30 years, M-16 for 31 to 35 years,
M- 15 for 36 to 40 years, M-14 for 41 to 45 years, and M-13 for 46 to 50
years, then reduced by two units for every five years, that is, M-11 for 51 to
55 years, M-9 for 56 to 60 years, M-7 for 61 to 65 years and M-5 for 66 to
70 years.”
[22]
In view of above observations and discussions, this Court is of
the opinion that the accident took place on 16th March, 2017 and thereafter,
the appellants persuaded their claim before the respondents by way of
notice and subsequently, a letter has been issued to the appellants on
September, 2017 asking the appellants herein, to furnish certain documents
in respect of their claim to which, on October, 2017 the appellants have
submitted their documents to the satisfaction of the respondents with an
impression that the legitimate expectation of the appellants the respondents
would consider the case of the appellants. But the respondents instead
acting upon the same have not taken any decision.
[23]
However, on sensitizing on the issue of limitation, this Court
draws a conclusion that there was no willful delay committed on the part
of the appellants more so, when it amounts to awarding of any
compensation against a fatal accident and when it is a beneficial legislation
which has overriding effect on certain technicalities, this Court gives
weight age to the pain and sufferings which has been suffered by the
family members of the deceased person and accordingly, the finding given
by the learned Court below on the issue No.1 i.e. rejecting the case of the
appellants on the ground of delay and laches, stands set aside.
[24]
The other issues, wherein the learned Court below has given
computation, the Court below has drawn a conclusion that the family
members of the deceased i.e. the appellants herein, is otherwise entitled for
Rs.5,56,168/- as per computation made by the learned Court below is
appreciated and accordingly, the same needs no interference. However, the
judgment as cited by Mr. P. Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent has no applicability in the facts and circumstances of case.
[25]
In the light of the above, the appeal stands allowed. The
observation made in issue No.1 stands set aside declaring that the
appellants are entitled for the amount which has been calculated by the
learned Court below i.e. Rs. 5,56,168/-. The respondents shall deposit the
same within a period of two months from the date of receipt of the copy of
this order. It is made clear that, on such deposit, the appellants are at
liberty to withdraw the same un-conditionally.
[26]
The appeal stands allowed, draw the decree accordingly and
send down the LCRs thereafter. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications
pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
CHIEF JUSTICE [ACTING]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review