The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. 06.2023 Order Heard Mr. D.R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the appellant. This is a second appeal preferred by the original defendant against the judgment and decree dated 04.05.2023, passed by the learned first appellate court in case no. TA 27/2018 affirming the judgment and decree of recovery of possession of the suit land of the 2 nd schedule of the plaint of the plaintiff in case no.T.S.13/2017 dated 06.09.2018, passed by the learned trial court. At the time of admission, Mr. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel has tried to persuade this court to formulate substantial question of law on the issue of limitation. According to learned senior counsel, the issue of limitation framed by the trial court has not been properly dealt with or appreciated. This submission has led this court to go through the issue of limitation as framed under Issue No.II by the learned trial court. While dealing with the issue of limitation [Issue No.II], the learned trial court has held that the suit has been filed within limitation. Learned trial court had discussed the issue quite elaborately which should be reproduced here-inbelow: “[7] Both the issues are related to each other and connected with law points and hence we have decided to discuss both the issues conjointly. These issues are relating to maintainability of law of limitation. I…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 15 OF 2023
Smt. Niyati Das Vrs. Sri Chitta Ranjan Saha
Present:
For the appellant(s)
For the respondent(s)
: Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Sarkar, Advocate.
: None.
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
22.06.2023
Order
Heard Mr. D.R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. S. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the appellant.
This is a second appeal preferred by the original defendant
against the judgment and decree dated 04.05.2023, passed by the learned
first appellate court in case no. TA 27/2018 affirming the judgment and
decree of recovery of possession of the suit land of the 2 nd schedule of the
plaint of the plaintiff in case no.T.S.13/2017 dated 06.09.2018, passed by
the learned trial court.
At the time of admission, Mr. Chowdhury, learned senior
counsel has tried to persuade this court to formulate substantial question of
law on the issue of limitation. According to learned senior counsel, the
issue of limitation framed by the trial court has not been properly dealt with
or appreciated. This submission has led this court to go through the issue of
limitation as framed under Issue No.II by the learned trial court. While
dealing with the issue of limitation [Issue No.II], the learned trial court has
held that the suit has been filed within limitation. Learned trial court had
discussed the issue quite elaborately which should be reproduced here-inbelow:
“[7]
Both the issues are related to each other and connected
with law points and hence we have decided to discuss both the issues
conjointly.
These issues are relating to maintainability of law of
limitation.
In this case plaintiff Chittaranjan Saha has filed the suit
for declaration of title of u/s.34 of the S.R. Act, 1963 and for recovery
of the possession of land described in the 2nd schedule of the plaint.
This petition is filed u/s.5 of the S.R. Act.
As per Section 5 of the S.R Act we know that a person
entitled to the possession of Specific immovable property may recover
it in the manner provided by CPC. An owner of the property may
recover possession by virtue of his title. A person having possessory
title may also recover possession.
Possession does not only mean occupation of actual user.
This section thus recognizes actions for recovery of possession passed
on title either by ownership or possessory.
In this case the plaintiff has to prove his title to succeed
under this section.
A person remaining in peaceful possession can retain
such possession against anyone except the lawful owner. A prior
possession raises a presumption of title and this possession is
sufficient in an action in ejectment against wrongdoer.
In this case the plaintiff by virtue of registered sale deed
1-847 dated 27-02-1991, purchased the land from Thakurdhan Paul
and after the mutation the khatian was prepared vide No.846 of land
quantity 0.02 acre vide C/S plot No.837(P) corresponding to R.S plot
No.2372/7143(P).
According to plaintiff, the defendant illegally trespassed
into the suit land in the northern boundary in the first part of June,
2015. Plaintiff raised objections and raised protest for illegal
construction on the 2nd schedule land.
According to plaintiff defendant has/had never any title or
interest over the suit land. Plaintiff arranged for demarcation of the
land by the Survey knowing person of SDM, Kanchanpur. The
Teheshildar Kanchanpur demarcated the land on last 15-03-2016 and
found the possession of the suit land by the defendant. Plaintiff again
requested the defendant on last part of March, 2016 to handover the
possession of the suit land but defendant turn deaf ear.
On the other hand defendant side disclosed that on last
30-03-1998 she purchased land measuring 0.04 acre from owner
Thakurdhan Paul vide registered deed No.1-22 and another plot of
0.04 acre vide sale deed 1-23 dated 30-03-1998 in the Sub-Registry,
Kanchanpur. Khatian was prepared vide No.824 of Mouja,
Kanchanpur. In the khatian No.824 hal dag No. 2371/7199 and
2372/7120 which is not similar to the dag number of plaintiff vide hal
dag No.2372/7143 in khatian No.846 of plaintiff.
According to defendant, the owner Thakurdhan Paul
during his life time expressed willingness to sell 0.03 acre of land
situated in the eastern portion of land. Defendant paid Rs.25.000/- to
the vendor Thakurdhan Paul for his treatment intending to purchase
some land. In his opinion the vendor handed over possession of the
suit land to the defendant but sale could not be registered as because
unfortunately vendor Thakurdhan died during treatment. So, the
dispute still exists for 0.03 acre of land. The deed was not registered.
As per Article 65 of the Limitation Act, the limitation
period is 12 years for the suit for possession of immovable property or
any interest therein passed on title.
The time or each period begins to run is that when the
possession of the defendant cause adverse to the plaintiff. So, in this
case plaintiff has raised the point that defendant dispossessed him in
the year March, 2016 and case was filed on last 05-05-2017 and if we
calculate that date and time of March, 2016 about the dispossession,
the suit is within the period of limitation as per Article 65 of the
Limitation Act 1963.
According to defendant she was possessing the land since
1999 and so there is some bundle of facts whether the parties are at
variance.
The suit was filed to remove cloud in the title and
possession of the plaintiff as because there is allegation of
dispossession by the defendant and construction of boundary wall
over the land of plaintiff. Section 34 of the S.R Act deals with the
matter of title and to protect it from adverse attacks. The civil court
has discretion to make declaration of status or rise u/s.34 of the S.R
Act as because any person entitled to any legal character may
institute a suit against any person denying such right.
[13] We know that section 5 of the S. R. Act is connected with
recovery of possession where a person is entitled to get the
possession of the specific immovable property by Code of Civil
Procedure. The owner of a property may recover the possession
by virtue of his title. A person having possessory title may also
recover possession. Even a person may also recover possession
by virtue of his previous possession irrespective of absence of
title or an inferior interest. A suit for possessory title can be
filed under section 5 of the S. R. Act.
[14] As per Sec.34 of the Specific Relief act, if there is a cloud
cast upon the title and legal character of the plaintiff, the
plaintiff may seek relief under this Section to dispel the cloud.
Plaintiff can be entitled to a legal character or to any right as to
any property, and it warrants this kind of relief only under
certain special circumstances.
We know that “cause of action” is a set of fact sufficient
to justify a right to sue to obtain money, property, or the
enforcement of a right against another party. To pursue a cause
of action, a plaintiff pleads or alleges facts in a plaint, the
pleading that initiates a law suit. A cause of action generally
encompasses both the legal theory (the legal wrongs the plaintiff
claims to have suffered) and the remedy (the relief a court is
asked to grant).
Section 34 of the SR Act deals with declaration of status
or right of a person. The object of this section is to strengthen
testimony regarding title and protect it from adverse attack. If a
cloud is cast upon the title and legal character the plaintiff may
seek remedy under this section to dispel the cloud. The section
34 of the SR Act does not warrant every kind of declaration but
only a declaration that the plaintiff is entitled to a legal
character or to any right as to any property, and it warrants this
kind of relief only under certain special circumstances. The
plaintiff must have valid and subsisting interest in order to get a
declaration.
Thus from the above discussion, it is clear that the suit
was filed within limitation and there is every cause of action for
instituting the suit.
Thus issue Nos.(i) & (ii) are decided in positive i.e. in
favour of plaintiff.”
I have carefully perused the above findings and considered the
same.
The suit was instituted for declaration of recovery of
possession. According to plaintiff, the cause of action arose in the year
2016 when the defendant constructed a boundary wall over the suit land
which compelled the plaintiff to institute the present suit. According to
plaintiff, the defendant illegally trespassed into the suit land in the northern
boundary in the first part of June,2015 when the plaintiff raised objections
and raised protest for illegal construction on the 2 nd schedule land. The
plaintiff arranged for demarcation of land by the survey knowing person of
SDM, Kanchanpur. The Tehsilder of Kanchanpur Tehsil demarcated the
land on 15.03.2016 and found the suit land was being possessed by the
defendant. The plaintiff again requested the defendant on the last part of
March, 2016 to hand over the possession of the suit land, but, the defendant
turned deaf ear.
The finding of the learned trial Court as regards the point of
limitation has been affirmed by the first appellate court when the first
appeal being preferred by the defendant. Article 65 of the Limitation Act
prescribes that a suit for possession can be filed within 12 years of
dispossession and the claim of adverse possession can be claimed by the
opposite party. In the instant case, there is no counter claim filed by the
defendant claiming adverse possessory title. This is well-settled principle
of law that possession follows title. In the instant case, the plaintiff has
been able to prove his title since he purchased the suit land in the year 1991
and the defendant purchased the adjacent land in the year 1998 from the
same vendor. The issue of limitation is a mixed question of law and fact.
The point of limitation may be a substantial question of law if it goes into
the very root of the case and affects the fundamentals of a case, which is
absent in this case. In the present case, the plea of limitation raised by the
appellant is a pure question of fact which has been concurrently affirmed in
favour of the plaintiff by the Courts below.
I have carefully perused the findings and appreciation on the
point of limitation as discussed and held by the learned courts below. I find
no perversity in the findings. Accordingly, I do not find any merit to
formulate substantial question of law on the issue of limitation and to admit
this appeal.
In view of this, the appeal stands dismissed at this stage.
Pending application, if any, shall also stand disposed.
JUDGE
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2023.06.23 17:00:18 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review