Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010279582025
2026:GAU-AS:9950
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP(IO)/526/2025
SMT. NIBHA TALUKDAR AND 3 ORS.
RESIDENT OF SOUTH SARANIA 1ST BYELANE (RIGHT) OPP. KASTURBA
ASRAM, ULUBARI, GUWAHATI-781007, DISTRICT- KAMRUP METRO, P.O.ULUBARI, ASSAM
2: SMT. ARATI TALUKDAR
RESIDENT OF SOUTH SARANIA 1ST BYELANE (RIGHT) OPP. KASTURBA
ASRAM
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI-781007
DISTRICT- KAMRUP METRO
P.O.- ULUBARI
ASSAM
3: SMT. HIRA MONI TALUKDAR
RESIDENT OF SOUTH SARANIA 1ST BYELANE (RIGHT) OPP. KASTURBA
ASRAM
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI-781007
DISTRICT- KAMRUP METRO
P.O.- ULUBARI
ASSAM
4: KASYAP MEDHI
C/O- LATE BASANTA KUMAR TALUKDAR
RESIDENT OF SOUTH SARANIA 1ST BYELANE (RIGHT) OPP. KASTURBA
ASRAM
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI-781007
DISTRICT- KAMRUP METRO
P.O.- ULUBARI
ASSA
VERSUS
Page No.# 2/9
BIJOY TALUKDAR
C/O- KALPANA BHARALI AND SIMANTA,
RESIDENT OF WEST BORAGAON, NEAR MONI KANCHAN BIBAH
BHAWAN, GAKHIR CHOWK, SANTINGAR PATH, GOHAI GAON FIELD, SUBPOST- DEBKATA NAGAR, PIN- 781011, P.S.- GORCHUK, DISTRICT- KAMRUP
METRO, ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MRS. HIRAMONI TALUKDAR ROYCHOUDHURY,
Advocate for the Respondent : ,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
Date : 20.07.2026
Heard Ms. Hiramoni Talukdar Roychoudhury, the petitioner No. 3-inperson for all the petitioners. Also heard Mr. H.K. Sarma, learned counsel
for the respondents.
2.
In this petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioners have challenged the order dated 29.11.2025, passed by the
learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) No. 5, Kamrup, Guwahati (‘trial Court’,
for short), in Misc. (J) Case No. 331/2025, arising out of Title Suit No.
97/2025; and also prayed for dismissing the Title Suit No. 97/2025, as the
learned trial Court had violated the provision of Order 23 Rule 1(4) CPC.
3.
It is to be noted here that vide impugned order dated 29.11.2025, the
learned trial Court had rejected the petition filed by the petitioner for
rejection of suit.
4.
Ms. Roychoudhury, the petitioner No. 3-in-person, for all the
Page No.# 3/9
petitioners, submits that they are the owners of the suit property, bearing
Dag No. 75, Patta No. 508, on the strength of the Will No. 367/2018, dated
06.12.2018, registered before the Registration Authority, by their Late
father, namely, Basanta Kumar Talukdar and to grant probate of the said
will, one T.S. (L.A.) No. 1/2024, is pending before the Court of learned
Additional District Judge No. 2, Kamrup(M), Guwahati, wherein crossexamination of witnesses has already been completed and they have been
possessing the same and paying municipal taxes, revenue taxes of the said
property and they have also been spending lots of money for maintaining
the same. She also submits that the respondent is a disowned son of Late
Basanta Kumar Talukdar and he has no relation with his parents and other
siblings for last 30 years, and that he resides at West Boragaon in his own
property.
4.1. She further submits that in the year 2019, the respondent had filed
one T.S. No. 23/2019, before the Court of learned Civil Judge (Junior
Division) No. 1, Kamrup(M), Guwahati for injunction on the strength of
family settlement. But, suddenly, the respondent had withdrawn the said
title suit without any valid ground and without granting liberty to file a fresh
one. But, subsequently, he filed a new suit, being Title Suit No. 97/2025, on
the same subject matter, claiming same reliefs and also for injunction, on
the basis of family settlement before the Court of learned Civil Judge
(Junior Division) No. 5, Kamrup(M), Guwahati, and that the learned trial
Court had admitted the same in contravention to Order 23 Rule 1(4) CPC,
as the previous suit was withdrawn without granting liberty to file a fresh
one.
4.2. She also submits that in the case of Ramalinga Bajanai Madam v.
Page No.# 4/9
Gerart Pappammal And Ors., reported in 1998 (1) CTC 85, Madras
High Court has held that withdrawing of a suit without permission of the
Court to file a fresh one, bars the plaintiff from instituting any fresh suit, on
the same subject matter or part of the claim and stressed the need for
strict adherence to the rule. But, the learned trial Court, vide impugned
order, dated 29.11.2025, had dismissed the said petition.
4.3. The impugned order, according to Ms. Roychoudhury, is illegal and
also suffers from material irregularity and under such circumstances, she
has contended to allow this petition by setting aside the impugned order
dated 29.11.2025, and also to dismiss the suit.
5.
Per contra, Mr. Sarma, learned counsel for the respondent has
vehemently opposed the petition. He submits that the learned trial Court
has rightly passed the impugned order dated 29.11.2025, and dismissed
the petition filed under Order 7 Rule 11(d) CPC. Referring to the earlier
plaint in Title Suit No. 23/2019, and also the plaint of Title Suit No.
97/2025, he submits that the subject matter in both the suits are different
and also the cause of action of both the suits has arisen on two different
dates, and the earlier suit, he had prayed for permanent injunction
simpliciter and in the subsequent suit, he had sought for right, title and
interest on the basis of bona fide family settlement dated 10.07.2012, also
sought for and such settlement was engineered by his own father during
his lifetime so that all the siblings can co-exist in a peaceful manner after
his demise, and that the parties in earlier suit and the present suit are also
different to some extent.
5.1. Mr. Sarma, also submits that the earlier suit was withdrawn while the
Page No.# 5/9
prayer for amendment of the plaint made by the respondent herein as
plaintiff, was rejected by the learned trial Court, vide order dated
07.02.2024, in Misc. (J) Case No. 179/2020. And the respondent herein
then had approached this Court, challenging the order dated 07.02.2024,
then vide order dated 15.05.2024, in CRP(IO) No. 155/2024, this Court had
allowed him to file a fresh suit, if otherwise permissible under the law, and
only thereafter, Title Suit No. 97/2025, was instituted. He further submits
that the impugned order dated 29.11.2025, passed by the learned trial
Court suffers from no infirmity, and therefore, it is contended to dismiss the
petition.
6.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties,
this Court has carefully gone through the petition and the documents
placed on record, and also perused the plaints of Title Suit No. 23/2019 and
Title Suit No. 97/2025, and also gone through the relevant provision under
Order 23 Rule 1(4) CPC and the decision referred by Ms. Talukdar, the
petitioner No. 3-in-person.
7.
It appears that the Title Suit No. 23/2019, was withdrawn on
17.03.2025, and the learned trial Court, had allowed withdrawal of the said
suit vide order dated 17.03.2025, without granting liberty to file a fresh
one. However, it appears that before withdrawing the said suit, the
respondent herein had filed one petition before the learned trial Court for
amendment of the plaint. But, the same was dismissed, vide order dated
07.02.2024, in Misc. (J) Case No. 179/2020. The respondent then
challenged the said order dated 07.02.2024, before this Court in CRP (IO)
No. 155/2024. From a perusal of the order dated 15.05.2024, in CRP (IO)
No. 155/2024, it appears that a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court had held
Page No.# 6/9
that withdrawal of the said suit being Title Suit No. 23/2019, would not
preclude the petitioner to file separate suit, if otherwise permissible under
the law, and this fact was duly taken note of in the impugned order, dated
29.11.2025, by the learned trial Court.
8.
It also appears that after hearing both the parties at length, the
learned trial Court had recorded a finding that for the cause of action stated
in the plaint, the plaintiff had claimed right, title and interest in the present
suit, which were not claimed at the earlier suit, and perusal of both the
plaints shows that the cause of action is completely different, and that the
earlier suit was withdrawn and it was not heard and finally decided by the
earlier Court, and cause of action, which has been provided in the plaint of
the present suit, states that the plaintiff has claimed right, title and interest
in the suit property along with mandatory injunction. But, in the previous
suit, the plaintiff had prayed for only the perpetual injunction and both the
plaints show that cause of actions are completely different, and thereafter,
it had rejected the petition.
9.
The contention of the petitioner appears to be centered around two
points. Firstly, the subject matter of T.S. No. 23/2019, and the
subsequent suit being Title Suit No. 97/2025, the relief(s) claimed in both
the suits are also same and that being so the subsequent suit is barred by
the principle of res-judicata.
Secondly, while the earlier suit was
withdrawn without liberty, the subsequent suit, being Title Suit No.
97/2025, is not maintainable in view of Order 23 Rule 1(4) CPC.
9.1. But, the issue of res-judicata is a mixed question of law and facts.
The law with regard to deciding an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC
Page No.# 7/9
is well settled in catena of decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court. In the case
of Srihari Hanumandas Totala vs. Hemant Vithal Kamat, reported
in(2021) 9 SCC 99, Hon’ble Supreme Court has laid down the guiding
principle as under: “25.
On a perusal of the above authorities, the
guiding principles for deciding an application
under Order 7 Rule 11(d) can be summarised as
follows:
25.1. To reject a plaint on the ground that the
suit is barred by any law, only the averments in
the plaint will have to be referred to.
25.2. The defence made by the defendant in the
suit must not be considered while deciding the
merits of the application.
25.3. To determine whether a suit is barred by res
judicata, it is necessary that (i) the “previous
suit” is decided, (ii) the issues in the
subsequent suit were directly and substantially in
issue in the former suit; (iii) the former suit
was between the same parties or parties through
whom they claim, litigating under the same title;
and (iv) that these issues were adjudicated and
finally decided by a court competent to try the
subsequent suit.
25.4. Since an adjudication of the plea of res
judicata requires consideration of the pleadings,
issues and decision in the “previous suit”,such a
plea will be beyond the scope of Order 7 Rule
11(d), where only the statements in the plaint
Page No.# 8/9
will have to be perused.”
9.2.
The aforesaid proposition is reaffirmed in subsequent decisions also.
In the case of Keshav Sood v. Kirti Pradeep Sood, Civil Appeal
No. 5841 of 2023, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:“6. Hence, in our view, the issue of res judicata
could not have been decided on an application
under Rule 11 of Order VII of CPC. The reason is
that the adjudication on the issue involves
consideration of the pleadings in the earlier
suit, the judgment of the Trial Court and the
judgment of the Appellate Courts. Therefore, we
make it clear that neither the learned Single
Judge nor the Division Bench at this stage could
have decided the plea of res judicata raised by
the appellant on merits.”
9.3.
Thus, it is well settled that adjudication of the plea of res judicata
requires consideration of the pleadings, issues and decision in the “previous
suit”, and such a plea will be beyond the scope of Order 7 Rule 11( d),
where only the statements in the plaint will have to be perused. In that
view of the matter, the issue cannot be decided in an application under
Order 7 Rule 11(d) CPC.
9.4. Further, it appears that the cause of action, relief(s) claimed and to
some extent parties in both the suit are visibly different. Besides, the earlier
suit was withdrawn and it was not heard and finally decided by the Court
on merits. The learned trial court had recorded a categorical finding in this
regard. That being res judicata, cannot stand in the way of proceeding the
subsequent suit.
9.5. Now, moving forward to the second point, this Court finds that earlier
Page No.# 9/9
suit was withdrawn without liberty to a file fresh one. But, it appears that
vide order dated 15.05.2024, in CRP (IO) No. 155/2024, a Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court had held that withdrawal of the said suit being Title Suit
No. 23/2019, would not preclude the petitioner to file separate suit, if
otherwise permissible under the law. In view of above, this Court afraid the
provision of Order 23 Rule 1(4) CPC, would not be applicable in this case.
10. Thus, the finding, so recorded by the learned trial Court, in the
impugned order dated 29.11.2025, while examined in the light of the facts
and circumstances on the record, and also in the light of the arguments
advanced by learned counsel for both the parties, this Court is of the view
that Ms. Roychoudhury, the petitioner No. 3-in-person for all the
petitioners, has failed to demonstrate any illegality or irregularity, so
committed by the learned trial Court in dismissing the petition for rejection
of the plaint vide impugned order dated 29.11.2025.
11. This Court has also carefully considered the ratio laid down in the case
referred by Ms. Roychoudhury, the petitioner No. 3-in-person for all the
petitioners, and it appears that the said case proceeds on its own facts and
clearly not applicable in the present case.
12.
In the result, this Court finds no merit in this petition and
accordingly, the same stands dismissed, leaving the parties to bear their
own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review