Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010453992024
2026:CGHC:37160
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 15 of 2025
1. Smt. Neha Piplva Wd/o Late Hitesh Aged About 30 Years R/o Kapil
Nagar Sarkanda, Police Station- Sarkanda, District- Bilaspur, C.G.
2. Ansh Piplva, Janhavi Sahu S/o Late Hitesh Aged About 7 Years
Minor Through The Mother (Natural Guardian) Smt. Neha Piplva
(Appellant No. 01), R/o Kapil Nagar Sarkanda, Police StationSarkanda, District- Bilaspur, C.G.
3. Kavyansh Piplva S/o Late Hitesh Aged About 5 Years Minor Through
The Mother (Natural Guardian) Smt. Neha Piplva (Appellant No. 01),
R/o Kapil Nagar Sarkanda, Police Station- Sarkanda, DistrictBilaspur, C.G.
4. Shyam Sundar S/o Late Prahlad Aged About 70 Years R/o Kapil
Nagar Sarkanda, Police Station- Sarkanda, District- Bilaspur, C.G.
5. Shakuntala Piplva W/o Shyam Sundar Aged About 52 Years R/o
Kapil Nagar Sarkanda, Police Station- Sarkanda, District- Bilaspur,
C.G.
6. Chetan Piplva S/o Shyam Sundar Aged About 35 Years R/o Kapil
Nagar Sarkanda, Police Station- Sarkanda, District- Bilaspur, C.G.
... Appellants
versus
1. Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vyapar Vihar
Road, Bilaspur, Police Station- Civil Line, District- Bilaspur, C.G.
(Insurer Of The Vehicle Capsule No. – C.G.12/a.R./9462).
2. Fool Singh S/o Ramcharan R/o Village- Chiraipani, Police StationPodi, District- Korea, C.G. (Driver Of The Vehicle Capsule No. –
C.G.12/a.R./9462).
Digitally
DEEPTI signed
by
JHA
DEEPTI
JHA
3. Pal Transport Compay R/o T.P. Nagar, District- Korba, C.G. (Owner
Of The Vehicle Capsule No. - C.G.12/a.R./9462)
... Respondents
For Appellant
:
Mr. Anand Kesharwani, Advocate.
For Respondent No.1
:
Mr. Prasanjeet Dutta, Advocate.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput
Order on Board
18/08/2026
1.
Heard.
2.
This is an miscellaneous appeal filed by the appellants/claimants
under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 (for short ‘M.V.
Act’), assailing the legality, correctness and validity of the impugned
award dated 25.09.2024 (Annexure-A/1) passed by the learned
Second Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (for short ‘Claims Tribunal’),
Bilaspur, District Bilaspur (C.G.) in Claim Case No.1434/2022.
3.
By the award impugned, against a claim of Rs.36,22,500/-, the
learned
Claims
Tribunal
has
awarded
compensation
of
Rs.21,27,060/- in favour of the appellants/claimants on account of
death of deceased/Hitesh Pipalva in an accident, which took place
on 31.08.2022 by rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle
‘Capsule’ bearing Registration No.C.G.-12-AR-9462 driven by the
respondent No.2/driver, owned by the respondent No.3/owner and
insured with the respondent No.1/insurance company.
4.
As per the pleadings made in the claim application filed under
Section 166 of the M.V. Act by the appellants/claimants, inter alia
pleaded that the appellant No.1 is the wife of the deceased,
appellants No.2 to 3 are children, appellants No.4 & 5 are parents
and appellant No.6 is the brother of the deceased, who died in the
said accident was aged about 38 years; and was working as regular
employee of Prithu Mill and Machinery Stores, Janjgir Mod, Balaji
Rice Mill Chawl Akaltara, District Janjgir-Champa (C.G.) and was
earning
Rs.18,000/-
per
month.
Thus,
the
above
stated
compensation was claimed.
5.
Respondents No.2 & 3 remained ex parte before the learned Claims
Tribunal and did not filed any written statement.
6.
Respondent No.1/insurance company filed the written statement and
denied the averments made in the claim application filed by the
appellants/claimants. It was pleaded that the offending vehicle was
driven without valid fitness permit and driving license of the driver,
thus, the insurance company is not liable to pay the amount of
compensation. It has also been pleaded that the accident has
occurred on account of rash and negligent driving by the deceased
himself.
7.
The learned Claims Tribunal framed issues on the basis of above
brought pleadings and decided the same after appreciation of
evidence available on record in favour of the appellants/claimants
and awarded the above stated compensation by the impugned
award, which led to filing of this appeal.
8.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellants/claimants submits that
the learned Claims Tribunal erred in assessing the monthly income
of the deceased on the basis of minimum wages to Rs.9,540/- only.
The proprietor of the firm, in which the deceased was working, was
examined and he has proved the salary certificate of the deceased,
which would indicate that the monthly salary of the deceased was
Rs.18,000/- per month. The learned Claims Tribunal committed an
error in not placing the reliance upon the said document. Apart from
this, he submits that the compensation on other admissible heads
are also on the lower side, which requires suitable enhancement by
this Court.
9.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.1/insurance
company supports the impugned award and submits that no other
documents except the salary certificate and GST Registration of the
firm was placed on record. No return, filed on behalf of the said firm
to substantiate that salary of Rs.18,000/- was being paid to the
deceased. The assessment of the learned Claims Tribunal is based
upon the proper appreciation of the evidence available on record
and it does not call for any interference by this Court and the same
deserves to be dismissed.
10.
I have heard learned counsel for the respective parties and perused
the material available on record with utmost circumspection.
11.
The only question arose before this Court, as to whether the learned
Claims Tribunal has awarded just compensation and whether it
requires suitable enhancement by this Court ?
12.
As per the pleadings made in the claim application, deceased was
working as a regular employee of said Prithu Mill and Machinery
Stores and was earning Rs.18,000/- per month. The proprietor of
that firm has been examined as AW-2, who stated that he is the
proprietor of the firm and has a GST Registration of the firm, which is
marked as Ex.P/18. He has exhibited the salary certificate of the
deceased as Ex.P/17, which indicates that the monthly income of
the deceased was to Rs.18,000/- per month. In cross-examination,
according to this witness, the deceased was working in the said firm
for the last 3 years, as a manager and was paid Rs.18,000/- per
month cash salary. In the cross-examination, he admits that Ex.P/17
(salary certificate), but how many persons are working in a firm is not
mentioned. He further admits that he has not filed any documents
relating to the income and expenditure of the firm. Though, he has
denied that such document has not been filed, as there is no income
of this firm. He also admits that Ex.P/17 (salary certificate) is not
written by him, however, he himself stated that it is written according
to his instructions and after reading it, he put his signature upon it.
He admits that return of his firm is filed through channeled account,
he also admits that he has not filed any voucher with regard to the
per month payment to the deceased. However, he denied the
suggestions in order to facilitate the higher compensation to the
claimants, the false salary certificate has been prepared.
13.
The claimant No.1 was examined as AW-1, who was the wife of the
deceased has also stated that her husband was working with the
said firm and was earning Rs.18,000/- per month.
14.
The learned Claims Tribunal has disbelieved the salary certificate
holding that no other documents like Register and documents with
regard to the payment of employees has been filed, thus, while
admitting to the fact that deceased was working in the firm, however,
it is observed that working of the deceased in the said firm cannot be
ruled out. However, on the basis of salary certificate only, Ex.P/17,
the deceased was being paid Rs.18,000/- per month salary cannot
be presumed. The learned Claims Tribunal treated the deceased to
be an unskilled labour and on the basis of prevailing minimum
wages on the date of incident and at the place of residence of the
deceased, held his monthly income to Rs.9,540/-.
15.
Learned counsel for the appellants/claimants submits that the
learned Claims Tribunal has erred in disbelieving the salary
certificate, whereas the learned counsel for the respondent
No.1/insurance company submits that the learned Claims Tribunal
has rightly disbelieved the salary certificate.
16.
The learned Claims Tribunal has held that it cannot be ruled out that
the deceased was working in the said firm. However, the Claims
Tribunal held the deceased to be an unskilled labour.
17.
The deceased was said to be aged about 37 years as per claim
application, young widow, two minor children and parents were
found to be dependent upon the income of the deceased. Argument
for appellant No.6, who is the brother of the deceased may not be
dependent upon the income of him, however, only 5 persons can
severally be dependent upon the income of the deceased. Ofcourse,
no other supporting documents like return, register appointment
order and documents to suggest the payment of salary are not
placed on record, however, the finding of the learned Claims
Tribunal is with regard to that the deceased was working in the said
firm.
18.
Under these circumstances the findings of the learned Claims
Tribunal that deceased was an unskilled labour does not appear to
be based on proper appreciation of evidence available on record.
Even if the salary of the deceased cannot be assessed on the basis
of the salary certificate issued in light of the above stated facts, but it
cannot be said to be that deceased was earning Rs.9,540/- being an
unskilled labour. Particularly, looking to the large number of
dependents depended upon the income of the deceased.
19.
Taking into consideration the above stated facts and the evidence
available on record; the nature of job; age of the deceased and;
number of dependents upon him, it can be safely said that deceased
was a salaried employee, his salary may not be Rs.18,000/-, but it
can be assessed to Rs.15,000/-. Hence, this Court can safely
assess the monthly income of the deceased to Rs.15,000/-, as this
Court has to see the young widow aged about 30 years, minor
children who are aged about 7 & 5 years respectively and old
parents, who all have long life to live without the support, affection
and income of the deceased. The deceased on the basis of
evidence can be said to be a salaried employee.
20.
In the light of the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered
in the matters of National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680, Sarla Verma and others v. Delhi
Transport Corporation and others, (2009) 6 SCC 121 and
Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram
and others, (2018) 18 SCC 130, this Court recomputes the
compensation in the following manner :Serial No.
Particulars
Amount(Rs.)
Annual Income
1,80,000
(Rs.15,000 x 12)
Income with Future Prospects
2,70,000
(Rs.1,80,000 x 50% Future
Prospects = Rs.90,000; 1,80,000 +
90,000 = 2,70,000
Income after Deduction towards
2,02,500
Personal Expenses of the
Deceased (Rs.2,70,000 / 4 =
Rs.67,500; 2,70,000 – 67,500 =
Rs.2,02,500)
Loss of Dependency after applying
30,37,500
Multiplier
(Rs.2,02,500 x 15 = Rs.30,37,500)
Funeral Expenses
16,500
Loss of Estate
16,500
Consortium to wife
44,000
Filial and Parental Consortium
1,60,000
(Rs.40,000 x 4 = Rs.1,60,000)
Total Compensation =
32,74,500
(-) Compensation Awarded by the
21,27,060
Claims Tribunal =
Enhancement in Compensation
11,47,440
=
21.
In view of the aforesaid analysis, the appellants/claimants are held
to be entitled to an additional amount of compensation of
Rs.11,47,440/-. The enhanced amount of compensation shall carry
simple interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of the instant
appeal, i.e., 20.12.2024 till its realisation of the enhanced
compensation. Respondent No.1/insurance company is directed to
deposit the amount of compensation as enhanced by this Court
within a period of 60 days from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
22.
Out of the enhanced amount of compensation, a sum of
Rs.2,50,000/- each shall be deposited as fixed deposit in the names
of appellants No.2 & 3 in a nationalized bank till attaining the age of
majority; Rs.3,00,000/- shall be deposited as fixed deposit in the
name of appellant No.1 in a nationalized bank for 3 years and;
Rs.1,00,000/- each shall be disbursed in the account of appellants
No. 4 & 5. Remaining amount shall be disbursed in the account of
appellant No.1 through bank transactions / account payee cheque.
23.
Accordingly, the instant appeal filed by the appellants/claimants is
partly allowed to the extent as indicated hereinabove.
24.
Interlocutory application(s), pending if any, also stands disposed of.
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
Deepti Jha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review