Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 2080 OF 2025 (DEC/INJ)
BETWEEN:
1 . SMT. N RAMA RANI,
W/O LATE H.S. SHIVAKUMAR,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
2 . SRI SATVIK SUNDRESH M.S.,
S/O LATE H.S. SHIVAKUMAR
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS,
BOTH APPELLANT NOs.1 & 2
ARE RESIDING AT HANAKERE,
SIDDAPPA FARM HOUSE,
VALAGEERHALLI ROAD,
Digitally signed KASABA HOBLI,
by ANUSHA V MADDUR TALUK,
Location: High MANDYA DISTRICT - 571 428.
Court of
Karnataka
&APPELLANTS
[BY SRI T.SHESHAGIRI RAO, ADVOCATE]
AND:
1 . SMT. V K TEJA,
D/O KARADIGOWDA,
W/O MASTIGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
R/AT THYLOOR VILLAGE,
ATHAGUR HOBLI,
-2NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
MADDUR TALUK,
MANDYA DISTRICT - 571 428.
2 . VIJAYA BANK
MADDUR BRANCH,
REPRESENTED BY ITS
BRANCH MANAGER,
MADDUR, MADDUR TALUK,
MANDYA DISTRICT - 531 428.
&RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI S.M. CHANDRASHEKAR, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI MURALI N., ADVOCATE FOR C/R1)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC,
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 20.11.2025
PASSED IN RA.NO.4/2020 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDITIONAL
SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, MADDUR, DISMISSING THE
APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 28.11.2019 PASSED IN OS.NO.339/2011 ON THE FILE
OF THE C/C. IV ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE AND
JMFC,
MADDUR.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI
-3NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
Challenging judgment and decree dated 20.11.2025
passed by I Additional Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Maddur, in
RA no.4/2020 dismissing appeal and confirming judgment and
decree dated 28.11.2019 passed by IV Additional Civil Judge
and JMFC, Maddur, in OS no.339/2011.
2.
Sri T Seshagiri Rao, learned counsel for appellants
submitted,
appeal
was
filed
by
legal
representatives
of
defendant no.1 in OS no.339/2011 seeking relief of declaration
of ownership and for permanent injunction in respect of
agricultural wet land bearing Sy.no.19/2, measuring 4.03
guntas
(including
0.4
guntas
of
kharab)
situated
at
Mobbalagere village, Maddur Taluk (hereinafter referred to as
'suit property', for short).
3.
In plaint, it was stated suit property was absolute
property of plaintiff. Land measuring extent of 6 Acres 12
guntas was granted by Land Tribunal, Maddur, in proceedings
no.KIRF.840/74-75 on 04.03.1976. On 16.01.1984, Tahsildar,
Maddur, had issued Form no.10 and name of plaintiff was
mutated
in
revenue
records.
In
year
1984-85,
plaintiff
-4NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
consented for change of Khata in respect of portion of said land
i.e. suit property in favour of defendant no.1 for purpose of
further processing of revenue proceedings, payment of taxes,
etc., as plaintiff was an illiterate and defendant no.1 was
worldly wise. It was stated, defendant no.1 had collected
money for payment of taxes from plaintiff. But, in first week of
August, 2011, concerned Village Accountant informed about
plaintiff being in arrears of land revenue. On obtaining copy of
Record of Right ('RoR'), plaintiff noticed that defendant no.1
had not only failed to remit taxes, but also encumbered
property by raising loan from defendant no.2-Bank, which was
without authority or knowledge of plaintiff, who was rightful
owner of land. He also noticed illegal mutation entries in
collusion with revenue officials. Evasive reply by defendant no.1
on enquiry gave rise to cause of action for suit.
4.
On
service
of
suit
summons,
defendant
no.1
appeared and filed written statement denying plaint averments
in toto and specifically stating that plaintiff was tenant under
one HK Veerannagowda in respect of 7 Acres 6 guntas
comprising
Sy.no.17/1c,
17/2,
19/a
and
19/5
in
LRF
-5NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
no.840/74-75. It was stated, since plaintiff was maternal uncle
of father of defendant no.1, he had paid upset price on grant of
occupancy rights. Thereafter, plaintiff had executed Form no.20
transferring extent of 5-03 Acres in favour of defendant no.1.
Out of same, he had sold extent of 1 Acre in favour of
Shivaramu S/o Chennegowda under registered Sale Deed dated
29.11.1996. Remaining 2 Acres 3 guntas, plaintiff transferred in
favour of his wife Smt.Jayalakshmamma, who in turn, sold it to
brother of defendant no.1. Thus, plaintiff did not retain any
extent of land, but had sought to lay claim after much delay. It
was stated, in order to improve land, defendant no.1 had
obtained financial assistance from defendant no.2, dug borewell, installed irrigation pump-set raised sugarcane crop apart
from planting coconut, teak and silver oak trees. It was
asserted that since 1984, defendant no.1 was in lawful and
settled possession over suit property to knowledge of whole
world i.e. for more than 30 years and perfected title by way of
adverse possession. Thus, suit claim is time-barred and
unsustainable.
5.
Based on pleadings, trial Court framed following:
-6NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
ISSUES
1)
Whether the plaintiff proves that, he is
the absolute owner in possession and
enjoyment of the suit schedule
property as on the date of institution
of the suit?
2)
Whether the plaintiff
alleged
interference
defendants?
3)
Whether the suit of the plaintiff is
barred by limitation?
4)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the
reliefs as claimed?
5)
What order or decree?
proves
by
the
the
ADDITIONAL ISSUE
6.
1)
Whether defendant proves that he
perfected his title over the suit
schedule property by way of law of
adverse possession?
To
substantiate
his
case,
plaintiff
examined
Smt.Meena (Power of Attorney Holder) as PW.1 and got
marked Exhibits P1 to P12. In rebuttal, defendant no.1
examined himself and four others as DWs.1 to 5 and got
marked Exhibits D1 to D84. On consideration, trial Court
answered issues no.1, 2 and 4 in affirmative, issue no.3 and
additional issue no.1 in negative and issue no.5 by decreeing
suit.
-7NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
7.
Aggrieved defendant no.1 filed RA no.4/2020 on
various grounds, based on which appellate Court framed
following point for its consideration:
"Whether the impugned judgment and
decree is illegal, perverse and requires
interference by this Court?"
8.
And answering point in negative, it dismissed
appeal, leading to file this second appeal.
9.
It was submitted, Ex.D13 - Sale deed dated
29.11.1996 and Exs.D15 to D31 - RoRs disclosed defendant's
possession over suit property from 1984 onwards. Said entries
attracted presumption in law under Section 133 of Karnataka
Land Revenue Act, 1961 ('KLR Act', for short). During crossexamination, PW.1 admitted delivery of possession of suit
property to defendant no.1. Further first appellate Court noted
submission of counsel for plaintiff that defendant was in
permissive
possession
of
suit
property.
These
materials
substantiated possession of defendant over suit property.
Despite same, relief sought by plaintiff in suit was for
declaration
of
title
and
permanent
injunction
against
-8NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
interference with possession, instead of seeking consequential
relief of possession.
10.
It was submitted, Hon'ble
Vasantha
(Dead)
Thr.
Legal
Supreme
Court in
representatives
v.
Rajalakshmi @ Rajam (dead) Thr. Lrs. reported in (2024)
5 SCC 282, held suit for bare declaration without consequential
relief of possession, when plaintiff was out of possession would
be barred under Section 34 of Specific Relief Act, 1963, ('SR
Act', for short). Said ratio was followed by this Court in case of
Somayya
Belchada
v.
Santhosh
&
Ors.
reported
in
2025:KHC:20332. It was submitted, both Courts had ignored
said
material
while
arriving
at
respective
conclusions.
Consequently, findings were contrary to material on record and
perverse. On said ground submitted, following substantial
questions of law arose for consideration of this Court:
"i. Whether both Courts erred in not noticing
that plaintiff's suit was barred under
Section 34 of SR Act for failure to seek
consequential relief?
ii. Whether both Courts erred in ignoring
presumption in favour of revenue entries
under Section 133 of KLR Act?
-9NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
11.
Learned counsel sought for answering same in
favour of defendant and allow appeal.
12.
On other hand, Sri SM Chandrashekar, learned
Senior counsel appearing for Sri Murali N, advocate for plaintiff
opposed appeal. At outset, it was submitted, appeal was
against concurrent findings on facts and did not involve any
substantial question of law. Therefore there was no scope for
interference.
13.
It was submitted, there was no dispute about
plaintiff being owner of suit property by virtue of order of grant
of occupancy by Land Tribunal. It was submitted, plaintiff was
an illiterate, while defendant was his relative, educated and
worldly-wise. Therefore, plaintiff had permitted defendant to
perform required processes for confirmation of grant such as
payment of Land Revenue etc. There was never transfer or
assignment of any right over suit property and plaintiff
continued in possession and cultivation of land. It was
submitted, all acts done by defendant were for and on behalf of
plaintiff and defendant could not claim about accrual of any
right by virtue of same. It was submitted, defendant was
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
claiming right under alleged signature of plaintiff on application
in Form no.20 submitted to village accountant for entry of
name of defendant over suit property. It was submitted,
without execution of any deed validly conferring any right over
suit property, entry of name of defendant in revenue records
would be contrary to law. Thus, plaintiff as owner of suit
property was entitled to maintain suit for declaration of title
and for permanent injunction restraining defendant from
interfering with his title/possession and there would be no need
for seeking possession.
14.
And when plaintiff noticed that defendant had acted
beyond authorisation, got his name mutated in revenue
records, obtained loan from defendant no.2 and encumbered
suit property, he issued notice to defendant and thereafter filed
suit. In support of his submissions, learned Senior counsel
relied on ratio in Sham Lal v. Rajinder Kumar, reported in
1994 SCC OnLine Del 476, laid down by High Court of Delhi
and by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Maria Margarida Sequeira
Fernandes v. Erasmo Jack de Sequeira, reported in
(2012) 5 SCC 370, that possession of servant or caretaker at
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
instance of owner would not amount to actual possession. It
would be possession of owner. Hence, defendant's claim to be
in possession would be contrary to law and sought for
answering substantial questions of law against defendant and
dismiss appeal.
15.
Heard
learned
counsel,
perused
impugned
judgment and copies of pleadings
and deposition
available
counsel
for
perusal
by
learned
for
made
defendant
(appellant).
16.
This appeal is by defendant against concurrent
findings in suit for declaration of title and permanent injunction.
Substantial questions of law proposed to arise for consideration
are, when plaintiff admitted defendant to be in possession
(permissive possession), whether suit for declaration of title
without seeking consequential relief of possession and instead
seeking for permanent injunction restraining interference would
be barred under Section 34 of SR Act and whether entries in
revenue records in favour of defendant for more than 12 years
(i.e. from 1984 till filing of suit in 2011) would attract
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
presumption under Section 133 of KLR Act and confer title by
adverse possession in favour of defendant.
17.
At outset, it is seen that there is no dispute about
plaintiff having been conferred with occupancy rights in respect
of 7 Acres 6 guntas of land bearing Sy.no.19/2 of Mobbalagere
village, Maddur Taluk, by Land Tribunal by order in LRF
no.840/1974-75, and about suit property being a part of
granted land. Thus both Courts would be justified in granting
decree of declaration of title in favour of plaintiff.
18.
While plaintiff claims that due to his illiteracy, he
had asked defendant to take care by paying land revenue etc.
and had not authorized defendant to encumber land or borrow
loan on it; defendant claims that after grant of occupancy rights
by Land Tribunal, father of defendant had contributed money
for payment of premium of land and therefore, plaintiff had
executed Form no.20 transferring 5 Acres 3 guntas of land to
defendant. Though, plaintiff had sold extent of 1 Acre out of
said land in favour of Shivaramu on 29.11.1996, remaining
land i.e. suit property had remained with defendant, which he
was cultivating, made improvements borrowing loan from
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
defendant no.2, planted valuable trees etc. As such he was in
settled possession and therefore, suit for bare declaration
without consequential relief of declaration would not be
maintainable.
19.
While passing impugned judgments, both Courts
held defendant was at best in permissive possession of suit
property and without any independent right over suit property
and therefore, plaintiff was entitled for relief sought for in suit.
Though, learned counsel for defendant seeks to rely on ratio
laid down in Somayya and Vasantha's cases (supra), it is
seen, claim of possession in Vasantha's case (supra), was
based on a deed of settlement, while in Somayya's case
(supra), claim was based on bequeathal, unlike in present case,
where it is based on mere signing of Form No.20 of KLR Act.
20.
Form 20 prescribed under Rule 62 and 64 of
Karnataka Land Revenue Rules, 1966, is for seeking mutation
of entries in revenue records on acquisition of rights in land as
provided in Section 128 of KLR Act. Section 128 of KLR Act
specifically
mentions
succession,
survivorship,
inheritance,
partition, purchase, mortgage, gift, lease or otherwise any right
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
as holder, occupant, owner, mortgagee, landlord or tenant of
land or assignee of rent or revenue thereof being recognized for
effecting mutation.
21.
In other words, filing of Form no.20 would be
consequential to transfer of any of rights enlisted above and
cannot be a document of transfer by itself. Claim of transfer of
ownership right under Form no.20, would run counter to
Section 54 of Transfer of Property Act, 1882. On same,
analogy, Form no.20 cannot be said to grant/confer right of
possession. As contended by learned counsel for defendant as
well as noted by both Courts, defendant may, at best be held to
be in permissive possession as would entitle any protection.
Consequently, both Courts would be justified in granting decree
of injunction against interference on noticing acts of defendant
claiming
ownership/possessory
right
over
suit
property
amounted to interference.
22.
Further, it is settled law that presumption under
Section 133 of KLR Act is rebuttable. By virtue of defendant's
claim for acquisition of title by adverse possession, there is
deemed admission of ownership right of plaintiff. In absence of
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:2022
RSA No. 2080 of 2025
HC-KAR
defendant establishing acquisition of any right over suit
property, presumption would stand rebutted. In view of above
neither
substantial
questions
of
law
would
arise
for
consideration.
Consequently, Appeal being devoid of merit is dismissed
at stage of admission itself.
Sd/(RAVI V HOSMANI)
JUDGE
Psg,AV
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 52
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review