Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC.APP.No.83 of 2024
1. Smt. Mina Das,
wife of Sri Dulal Chandra Das,
resident of Padmadepha, Melaghar,
P.S. Melaghar, District-Sepahijala, Tripura,
presently residing at Care of Smt. Krishna Bhowmik,
wife of Late Tushar Bhowmik of Badharghat, Matripalli,
P.S. Amtali, District-West Tripura
2. Sri Dulal Chandra Das,
son of late Dhirendra Chandra Das,
resident of Padmadepha, Melaghar,
P.S. Melaghar, District-Sepahijala, Tripura,
presently residing at Care of Smt. Krishna Bhowmik,
wife of Late Tushar Bhowmik of Badharghat, Matripalli,
P.S. Amtali, District-West Tripura
----Claimant-Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Tapan Saha,
son of late Sudhanshu Ranjan Saha,
resident of Shibnagar, College Road extension,
Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, District-West Tripura
2. The New India Assurance Company Limited,
Divisional Office at Old mantribari Road, RMS Chowmuhani,
Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District-West Tripura
----Opposite Party/Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. B. Debnath, Adv.
Mr. A. Das, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
Date of Judgment & Order :
18.09.2024
19.09.2024
Whether fit for reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act is
preferred challenging the judgment and award dated 03.06.2024 delivered by
Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.5, West Tripura,
Agartala in connection with Case No.T.S.(MAC)195 of 2022. By the said
judgment/award, Learned Tribunal below has awarded a sum of Rs.8,16,500/as compensation in favour of the claimant-petitioners appellants and fastened
the liability of payment of compensation to the O.P. No.2 i.e. the New India
Assurance Company Limited being the insurer of the offending vehicle bearing
registration No.TR-01-AC-1888(TATA Tripper Truck).
[2]
Heard Mr. B. Debnath, Learned counsel appearing for the
appellants/claimants and also heard Mr. A. Das, Learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the New India Assurance Company Limited i.e. the respondent No.2.
None appeared on behalf of the respondent No.1 in spite of service of notice.
[3]
In course of hearing of argument, Mr. B. Debnath, Learned
counsel appearing for the appellants/claimants confined his arguments only on
two points that the tribunal below determined the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs.10,000/- per month all though he was a student of Ram Thakur
College pursuing his studies in BA stream in English Honours, 4 th Semester as
an unskilled worker which according to Learned counsel for the petitioner
appellants/claimant the Learned Tribunal below committed an error which
actually
should
be
Rs.20,000/-
per
month.
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellants/claimants further submitted that by the said judgment, the Learned
Tribunal below in para No.33 determined the total amount of compensation at
Rs.16,33,000/- but the Learned Tribunal below decided that there was
contributory negligence on the part of the deceased. So, the Learned Tribunal
below deducted 50% of amount towards contributory negligence and awarded
only 50% of amount in favour of the present appellants as compensation which
according to Learned counsel for the appellants was perverse and the Learned
Tribunal below did not consider the oral and documentary evidence on record
adduced by the appellants properly.
[4]
Finally, Learned counsel for the appellants urged for allowing this
appeal by setting aside the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below and
further submitted before this Court to increase the amount of monthly income
from Rs.10,000/- to Rs.20,000/- and also to exclude the part of contributory
negligence and to direct the Insurance Company to pay the entire amount of
compensation in favour of the appellants/claimants.
[5]
On the other hand, Mr. A. Das, Learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the New India Assurance Company Limited i.e. the respondent No.2
submitted that before the Learned Tribunal the appellants relied upon the
charge-sheet
and
as
per
charge-sheet,
there
was
clear,
contributory
negligence on the part of the deceased at the time of accident. So, according
to Learned counsel for the Insurance Company there was no infirmity in the
judgment of the Learned Tribunal below. He further submitted that in support
of income, just by mere assertions that the deceased was a student there was
no scope on the part of the tribunal to determine Rs.20,000/- as monthly
income of the deceased. So, in summing up Learned counsel for the Insurance
Company submitted that since there was no any documentary evidence on
record regarding monthly income of the deceased. So, there was no perversity
in the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below and urged for dismissal of this
appeal with costs.
[6]
In
the
given
case,
the
appellants
as
claimant-petitioners
submitted one claim petition before the Tribunal below under Section 166 of
M.V. Act due to the death of the deceased Dipsmith Das who met with an
accident on 07.11.2021. According to the appellants on 07.11.2021 when the
victim Dipsmith Das (since dead) was proceeding towards Agartala from
Melagarh by riding his motorbike bearing No.TR-07-E-8589 (Bajaj Pulsar NS
200) in normal speed along the left hand side of the road and on the way
towards Agartala when he reached at Bishalgarh Forest Range Office near
Manu Fakir Dargah at Bishalgarh at that time one vehicle bearing registration
No.TR-01-AC-1888 (Tata Tripper Truck) being driven rashly and negligently by
its driver came from the opposite direction in dash and negligent manner and
dashed against the motor bike of the victim for which the victim fell down from
the motor bike and sustained fatal injuries on his person and succumbed his
injuries at the spot. Immediately, thereafter, the victim was shifted to
Bishalgarh Sub-Divisional Hospital with the help of Bishalgarh police where the
attending doctor declared him as dead. According to the appellants, the victim
was aged about 20 years at the time of accident and he was a student of Ram
Thakur College pursuing his studies in BA stream in English Honours, 4 th
Semester and he used to earn Rs.20,000/- per month from his profession as
private tutor. Further, according to the appellants, the accident occurred due
to the rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle bearing registration
No.TR-01-AC-1888 (Tata Tripper Truck). After the accident a police case was
registered at Bishalgarh P.S. vide Bishalgarh P.S. Case No.94/2021 dated
08.11.2021 under Section 279/304(A) of IPC and under Section 184 of the
M.V. Act. Hence, the appellants as claimants filed the claim petition.
[7]
The OP No.1, the owner of the Tata Tripper Truck contested the
case by filing written statement denying the assertions made by the claimantpetitioners in the claim petition. It was submitted that at the time of accident
the offending vehicle was being drive by Sri Samarjit Debbarma who had valid
driving license. But the OP No.1 denied the fact that accident occurred due to
rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending vehicle, rather,
according to the OP No.1 the accident occurred due to the fault of the
deceased rider and it was further submitted that at the time of accident the
vehicle was duly insured with the New India Assurance Company Limited and
the vehicle had valid Insurance policy. So, by the WS the said OP No.1 prayed
for dismissal of the claim petition.
[8]
The OP No.2, the Insurance Company also contested the case by
filing written statement denying the assertions made by the claimantpetitioners in the claim petition and further submitted that the claim petition
was subjected to strict proof by the claimant petitioners.
[9]
Upon the pleadings of the parties, the Learned Tribunal below
framed 3 (three) numbers of issues which are as follows :
“(i) Whether the claim petition is maintainable ?
(ii) Whether the deceased Dipsmith Das sustained injury on
07.11.2021 at about 1230 hours at Bishalgarh Range Forest
Office near Mano Fakir Darga under Bishalgarh PS in a road
traffic accident involving the vehicle bearing No.TR-01-AC1888 (Tata Triper Truck) due to rash and negligent driving of
the driver of said Triper Truck and resulting death of Dipsmith
Das who died on spot on the day of accident ?
(iii) Whether the petitioner is entitled to award as claimed for
and whether OP No.2 i.e. the Noticee be held liable to pay the
same ?”
[10]
To
substantiate
the
issues
the
claimant-petitioners
have
adduced 2(two) witnesses including the claimant No.1, Sri Dulal Chandra
Das and relied upon some documents which were marked as Exhibits in this
case. On the other hand, the OP No.1, i.e. the owner of the offending
Tripper Truck was examined as OPW-1 and relied upon some documents
which were also marked as Exhibits in the case. For convenience, the list of
witnesses of the parties and their Exhibits are mentioned below :
“LIST OF CLAIMANT’S WITNESSES
Sri Dulal Ch. Das PW.1
Sri Rahul Sarkar PW.2
LIST OF CLAIMANT’S EXHIBITS
Certified copy of Printed FIR Ext.1/1,1/2
Certified copy of FIR/ejahar Ext.2
Certified copy of seizure list Ext.3/1,3/2,3/3
Certified copy of PM Report Ext.4/1,4/2,4/3
Certified copy of charge sheet Ext.5/1,5/2,5/3,5/4
Birth certificate of Dipsmith Das Ext.6
Admit card of Dipsmith Das Ext.7
Certificate of registration
(Tripura University) Ext.8
ID card of Dipsmith Das Ext.9
Voter ID card of Dipsmith Das Ext.10
Adhar card of Dipsmith Das Ext.11
Driving license of Dipsmith Das Ext.12
Election ID and Adhar card of PW-1 Ext.13
Election ID and Adhar card of Mina Das (mother of deceased)
Ext.14
Copy of mark sheet of Dipsmith Das Ext.15
Driving license of PW.2 Ext.16
LIST OF OPPOSITE PARTY’S WITNESSES
Sri Tapan Saha OPW.1
LIST OF OPPOSITE PARTY’S EXHIBITS
Certificate of registration Ext.A
Certificate of insurance Ext.B
Driving license of Samarjit Debbarma Ext.C
Permit Ext.D
Vehicle Particulars Ext.E”
[11]
Finally, on conclusion of the proceeding, Learned Tribunal
below awarded compensation amounting to Rs.8,16,500/- and fastened the
liability of the payment of compensation upon the Insurance Company. The
operative portion of the judgment/award of the Learned Tribunal below is
mentioned here as under :
“40. The instant application under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 is hereby partly allowed and a sum of
Rs.8,16,500/- (Rupees eight lacs sixteen thousand five
hundred only) is awarded in favour of the claimant-petitioners
as compensation for the death of Dipsmith Das, in a road
traffic accident, as aforesaid and the opposite party No.2, the
New India Assurance Company Limited, being insurer of the
offending vehicle bearing registration No.TR-01-AC-1888(Tata
Tripper Truck) shall pay the entire amount of compensation
within a period of one month from today. The aforesaid
amount shall carry interest at the rate of 7% per annum to be
paid from the date of filing of the claim application i.e. from
12.07.2022 till the date of payment.
Distribution of Compensation
41. The claimant Nos. 1 and 2 being legal heirs of the
deceased are entitled to get compensation equally.
Protection Awarded Compensation
42. In the event of the deposit of the awarded amount with
interest, 50% of the amount shall be released in favour of
claimant-petitioner Nos.1 and 2 in their individual bank
accounts and the remaining 50% shall be kept in fixed deposit
scheme in any Nationalized Bank for five years in their name.
43. In case of necessity, the Tribunal can be approached for
withdrawal of fixed deposited amount. On maturity of the
fixed deposits the Banker shall credit the amounts to the sole
SB Accounts of the claimants without any further order from
the Tribunal.
44. Furnish a copy of the award to both sides.
45. The case stands disposed of on contest.
46. Make necessary entry in the TR and CIS.
47. Pronounced in the open Court.”
Challenging this judgment and award, this present appeal is before
this High Court.
[12]
I have heard arguments of both the sides and gone through the
record of the Learned Tribunal below including the judgment. Admittedly, in
this case, there is no dispute on record regarding the date and time of
accident and also the fact of death of the deceased due to the accident.
Here, in this appeal, we are to see whether the tribunal below rightly
determined the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.10,000/- per month
and whether the tribunal below rightly deducted 50% of the amount of
compensation towards contributory negligence or not. To substantiate the
case, the appellant claimant-petitioners relied upon the certified copy of the
charge-sheet which were marked as Ext.5/1 to 5/4. On perusal of the
same, it appears that the IO on conclusion of investigation, laid chargesheet against the driver of the offending Tripper Truck and also against the
rider of the bike (since dead).
[13]
In course of hearing of argument, Learned counsel for the
appellants submitted that no reliance can be placed upon the charge-sheet
because the tribunal below simply on the basis of charge-sheet ignoring the
evidence on record of the appellants decided that the accident took place
due to contributory negligence on the part of the deceased. As already
stated, the claimant petitioners, i.e. the appellants to substantiate the
claimant petition adduced two witnesses.
[14]
PW-1, the claimant petitioner No.1, Dulal Chandra Das filed
examination-in-chief in affidavit. In his examination-in-chief in affidavit in
para Nos.1,2 & 3 he asserted the following facts :
“1. That I am the Claimant Petitioner No.2 of the above noted
claim case bearing No.T.S.(MAC) 195 of 2022 before the
Learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Addl. District Judge,
Court No.5, West Tripura, Agartala. A tragic accident leading
to the death of my son deceased Dipsmith Das due to the
tragic road traffic accident which was occurred on 07.11.2021
at about 1230 hours at Bishalgarh Range Forest Office near
Mano Fakir Darga, under Bishalgarh Police Station, DistrictSepahijala Tripura. When my son Dipsmith Das was
proceeding towards Agartala side Melagarh by riding motor
bike bearing No.TR-07-E from Melagarh by riding motor bike
bearing No.TR-07-E-8589 (Bajaj Pulsar NS 200) very slowly
keeping himself in the extreme left side of the road and when
he reached at Bishalgarh Forest Range Office near Manu Fakir
Dargah of Bishalgarh in the mean time one vehicle bearing
Registration No.TR-01-AC-1888 (Tripper Truck) was coming
from opposite direction side and the said vehicle was being
driven very rashly and negligently at a very high speed by its
driver and dashed the motor cycle bearing No. TR-07-E-8589
(Bajaj Pulsar NS 200) driven by my son Dipsmith Das. As a
result of which my son Dipsmith Das fell down from the motor
cycle and sustained grievous injuries on his person and died at
spot.
That, my son died at the spot and thereafter Bishalgarh
police personnel came to the spot and taken the body of my
son Dipsmith Das to Bishaglarh Sub-Divisional Hospital where
the attending doctor declare that my son Dipsmith Das
succumbed to his injuries due to the aforesaid road traffic
accident and post mortem examination was held over the
body of my son Dipsmith Das by the doctor of Bishalgarh SubDivisional Hospital, Bishalgarh, Sepahijala, Tripura.
2. That, the said accident was occurred due to rash and
negligent driving by the driver of the offending vehicle bearing
Registration No. TR- 01-AC-1888 (Tripper Truck) and the said
accident was registered in the Bishalgarh Police Station, Dist.
Sepahijala Tripura, Bishalgarh P.S. vide Case No. 94 of 2021,
dated 08/11/2021, under Section 279/304 (A) of IPC & 184
of M.V. Act.
3. That my son Dipsmith Das was student of Ramthakur
College stream B.A. in English Honours, 4th semester. My son
also doing tuition in one rented room situated at C/O. Smti.
Krishna Bhowmik, W/O. Late Tushar Bhowmik, Badharghat,
Matripalli, P.S.-Amtali, District-West Tripura and was earning
Rs.20,000/- per month. He was aged 20 years at the time of
his death. His future prospect was very bright and it was
expected that he would make more and more contribution
towards his family and for himself had he not been died due to
the said road traffic accident in his prime age. It is pertinent
to mention here that my son Dipsmith Das was unmarried at
the time of his death.”
During cross-examination by the OP respondent No.1 he stated
that at the time of accident he was at Melagarh. Nothing more came out
relevant from his cross-examination by the said OP No.1. Similarly, in
course of cross-examination by OP No.2, i.e. the Insurance Company
following question was raised by the Learned Tribunal below :
“ Question-In the charge sheet it is mentioned that “it has
well been established against driver of the offending vehicle
bearing registration No.TR-01-AC-1888 (tripper truck), Sri
Samarjit Debbarma (34), S/o Lt Pradip Debbarma of
Champaknagar, Jangalia, PS-Radhapur, West Tripura and rider
of motor cycle bearing registration No.TR-07-E-8589 (bajaj
pulsar NS 200) namely Dipsmith Das (20), S/o Dulal Ch Das of
Padmadepha, PS-Melagarh” do you agree ?
In Reply Ans- When I received the information I came to the
spot and I found triper in the spot and I came to know from
local people that accident occurred due to negligent of triper
vehicle. At that time my son has already been removed to
hospital.”
[15]
PW-2, Rahul Sarkar is a para legal volunteer. His house is
situated nearby the place of occurrence. In his examination-in-chief in
affidavit he asserted the following facts :
2. That, I am the permanent resident of North Charilam
Puranbari near Mano Fikir Darga under Bishalgarh P.S.
Tripura. On 07/11/2021 at about 1230 hours when I was stan
Bishalgarh (Charilam) Forest Range Office near Mano Fikir
Darga at that time 1 saw that one person was proceeding
towards Agartala by riding motor bike bearing No.TR-07-E8589 (Bajaj Pulsar), very slowly and cautiously keeping
himself in the extreme left side of the road and when the said
motor bike reached at Bishalgarh (Charilam) Forest Range
Office near Manu Fakir Darga in the mean time one Tripper
Truck vehicle bearing No.TR-01-AC-1888 which was coming
from opposite direction and the very high struck vehicle was
being driven very rasiya direction and the very high speed by
its driver and dashed the said motor bike bearing No.TR-07-E8589 (Bajaj Pulsar). As a result of which the rider of the
motor bike fell down from the motor bike and he sustained
grievous injuries on his person and ultimately died on the
spot.
3. That, the said accident was occurred due to rash and
negligent driving by the driver of the offending vehicle bearing
Registration No. TR- 01-AC-1888 (Tripper Truck).
4. That the claimant petitioner of the instant claim petition
somehow got the information that I am one of the eye witness
of the incident of accident, as aforesaid. Thereafter, they
requested me to depose before the Ld. Tribunal on behalf of
them, to effect that what I have seen at the time of aforesaid
accident. Thereafter, I being agreed by me, the instant
examination in chief is prepared as per my version.”
During cross-examination by OP No.1 nothing came out
relevant save and except denial and during cross-examination by OP No.2
he stated that he came to the Court being requested by the claimant.
Further stated that after the accident he informed Fire Service and the
police also but he did not submit any written FIR to police station. Also
admitted that he gave his statement to the police whatever asked by police.
[16]
The OP No.1, Tapan Saha being the owner of the vehicle also
filed his examination-in-chief in affidavit and he relied upon the relevant
documents. But during cross-examination by the claimant-petitioner save
and except denial nothing more came out relevant and during crossexamination by the Insurance Company he stated that the accident
occurred due to fault of the bike and he came to know about the fact of the
accident from his driver and further stated that the police filed charge-sheet
against the driver of the tripper truck and driver of the motor bike. From
the evidence on record it appears that the OPW-1 was not present to the
PO at the time of accident. The Insurance Company to rebut the case of the
claimant petitioners did not adduce any oral/documentary evidence on
record nor by the style of cross-examination they could raise any cloud to
disbelieve the case of the appellants regarding involvement of the driver of
the OP No.1 with the alleged accident. Even the Insurance Company by the
trend of cross-examination PW-2 who is one of the eye witness of the
accident who was present to the PO at the time of accident and in his
examination-in-chief in para-2 he specifically stated how the accident
occurred. The Insurance Company in spite of cross-examination could not
demolish his evidence nor could raise any circumstance to disbelieve his
evidence, although, the IO laid charge-sheet against the driver of OPW-1
and also against the deceased.
[17]
In course of hearing of argument, Learned counsel for the
appellants fairly submitted that there was no scope to rely upon the chargesheet. But in the given case, the Learned Tribunal below overlooking the
oral evidence on record only relied upon the charge-sheet laid by the IO in
the criminal case and in support of his contention, Learned counsel for the
appellants referred one citation of this High Court in Smt. Kalpana
Majumder versus Sri Sankar Debnath [MAC.APP.No.16 of 2016 dated
08.05.2017] where this High Court observed as under :
“6. …………
11. Motor accident claim case is in the nature of a civil
suit and certainly not a criminal case. Therefore, the
Tribunal has grossly erred in law in relying on the
contents of the ejahar and the Police investigation
report to disbelieve and discard the case of the
claimant. The claimant, on the contrary, is entitled to
prove her case on the basis of the evidence adduced by
her, which was corroborated in material particulars by
the evidence of PW-2, who personally saw the accident
resulting in the death of the deceased, in the course of
trial. On my above findings, I have no hesitation in
holding that the deceased was killed in the vehicular
accident on 2-4-2004 due to the rash and negligent
driving of the driver of the respondent No. 1.
Resultantly, the insurer, who admittedly insured the
vehicle in question at the time of the accident, is
vicariously liable to satisfy the award.”
[18]
I have also perused the said judgment of this High Court. It is
the settled position of law that Motor Accident claim case is in the nature of
a civil suit. It is also well settled that the evidence recorded in criminal case
and the findings arrived therein should not be used in claim cases and such
evidence for the purpose of claim cases is inadmissible. The Hon’ble Madhya
Pradesh High Court in this regard in Shabbir Ahmad and Another versus
M.P.S.R.T.C., Bhopal and Others reported in AIR 1984 MP 173 wherein
in para No.8 it has been observed as under :
“8. We have gone through the award dt. 30-9-1981. The
learned Member of the Tribunal has disbelieved the evidence
of Sherinkhan (AW 2) mainly on the ground that he was at a
distance of about 225 feet from the place of the accident. For
this he has relied upon a copy of the judgment of the Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Jhabua, in Criminal Case No. 385 of 1980,
thereby acquitting the respondent 3 of the charge
under Section 304A, I.P.C. This judgment of the Criminal Court
contains a reference to the spot inspection made by the
Magistrate himself and on that basis the Tribunal has
discarded the testimony of Sherinkhan (AW 2) as unreliable.
Suffice it to say that this approach of the learned Member of
the Tribunal is palpably wrong. Firstly, the claimants were not
a party to the proceedings in which the spot map was
prepared and secondly the evidence in criminal case cannot be
used as a basis for discarding the testimony of a witness
recorded before the Tribunal itself. The spot map prepared by
the Magistrate has neither been produced nor proved before
the Tribunal by the respondents. Such evidence recorded
behind the back of the appellants cannot be used against
them. (See Ram Dulare Shukla v. M.P.S.R.T. Corporation, 1970
Jab LJ 626 : 1969 MPLJ 922). A mere production of a certified
copy of the judgment of the Criminal Court containing a
reference to such a spot-map having been prepared by the
Magistrate is no evidence by itself unless it is proved as a fact.
Therefore, this evidence should have been excluded from
consideration by the Tribunal. The fact that Nisar. Ahmed
(respondent 3) was acquitted in the criminal case is not itself
sufficient to absolve him of his liability as a respondent. In
claim cases, acquittal may have some bearing or relevance,
but that by itself would not be a proof of the fact that the
driver was not negligent. The learned Member of the Tribunal
has overlooked the numerous decisions that evidence
recorded in a criminal court and the findings arrived at therein
should not be used in claim cases. Such evidence for the
purposes of claim cases is inadmissible. Above all it is a
settled principle of law that any evidence recorded behind the
back of a party cannot be used against him. The learned
Member of the Tribunal should not have disbelieved
Sherinkhan (AW 2) merely because he is shown to be at a
distance of 225 feet from the place of accident, in the spotmap, which is inadmissible.”
[19]
Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in National
Insurance Company Limited versus Chamundeswari and Others
reported in (2021) 18 SCC 596 in para-8 it has been observed as under :
“8. It is clear from the evidence on record of PW–1 as well as
PW–3 that the Eicher van which was going in front of the car,
has taken a sudden right turn without giving any signal or
indicator. The evidence of PW–1 & PW–3 is categorical and in
absence of any rebuttal evidence by examining the driver of
Eicher van, the High Court has rightly held that the accident
occurred only due to the negligence of the driver of Eicher
van. It is to be noted that PW–1 herself travelled in the very
car and PW–3, who has given statement before the police,
was examined as eye–witness. In view of such evidence on
record, there is no reason to give weightage to the contents of
the First Information Report. If any evidence before the
Tribunal runs contrary to the contents in the First Information
Report, the evidence which is recorded before the Tribunal has
to be given weightage over the contents of the first
information report.”
[20]
In another case of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Rajwati alias Rajjo and Others versus United India Insurance
Company Ltd. and Others reported in 2022 SCC Online SC 1699 the
said Apex Court in paras Nos.18, 19 & 20 also observed as under :
18. Reference in this connection may also be made to the
observations made by this Court in the case of Sunita & Ors.
Vs. Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation & Ors. :
(2020)13 SCC 486 , wherein it was observed as under :“It is thus well settled that in motor accident claim
cases, once the foundational fact, namely, the actual
occurrence of the accident, has been established,
then the Tribunal’s role would be to calculate the
quantum of just compensation if the accident had
taken place by reason of negligence of the driver of
a motor vehicle and, while doing so, the Tribunal
would not be strictly bound by the pleadings of the
parties. Notably, while deciding cases arising out of
motor vehicle accidents, the standard of proof to be
borne in mind must be of preponderance of
probability and not the strict standard of proof
beyond all reasonable doubt which is followed in
criminal cases.”
19. Similarly, in the case of Kusum Lata & Ors. Vs. Satbir &
Ors. : (2011) 3 SCC 646, this Court observed that it is well
known that in a case relating to motor accident claims, the
claimants are not required to prove the case as it is required
to be done in a criminal trial. The Court must keep this
distinction in mind.
20. It is well settled that Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is a
beneficial piece of legislation and as such, while dealing with
compensation cases, once the actual occurrence of the
accident has been established, the Tribunal’s role would be to
award just and fair compensation. As held by this Court
in Sunita (Supra) and Kusum Lata (Supra), strict rules of
evidence as applicable in a criminal trial, are not applicable in
motor accident compensation cases, i.e., to say, “the standard
of proof to be borne in mind must be of preponderance of
probability and not the strict standard of proof beyond all
reasonable doubt which is followed in criminal cases”.
From the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court
of India in the aforenoted cases it appears that strict principles of evidence
and standards of proof like in a criminal trial are in applicable in MACT claim
cases. The standard of proof in such like matters is one of the
preponderance of probabilities, rather than beyond reasonable doubt.
[21]
Here in the given case, on perusal of the judgment of the
Learned Tribunal below it appears that at the time of delivery of judgment,
Learned Tribunal below only relied upon the charge-sheet but did not
consider the oral evidence on record of the appellants i.e. the claimants. It
is already discussed that to rebut the claim petition the contesting Ops
failed to adduce any contrary evidence on record to disbelieve the claim of
the claimant petitioners.
[22]
Situated thus, this Court is of the considered view that the
Learned Tribunal below committed error in passing award solely relying
upon the charge-sheet laid by the IO in the given case ignoring the oral
evidence on record for which interference of the Court is required. The
findings of the Learned Tribunal below that there was contributory
negligence on the part of the deceased was not based on any legal
reasoning and the same is contrary to the law for which in the given case,
the entire amount of compensation should be fastened upon the Insurance
Company because the Insurance Company by their defence have failed to
rebut/demolish/dismantle the claim of the appellant claimant-petitioners.
Regarding determination of the monthly income of the deceased on perusal
of the record nowhere I find that the claimant-petitioners could adduce any
strong supportive evidence to substantiate that the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs.20,000/- per month. Thus, it appears that the Learned
Tribunal below at the time of delivery of judgment rightly determined the
monthly income of the deceased at Rs.10,000/- per month in absence of
any cogent evidence on record, relying upon the notification of this High
Court.
[23]
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellants is hereby partly
allowed. The judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal below dated
03.06.2024 is hereby modified to the extent that as mentioned in para
No.33 of the award, the total amount of compensation as determined by
the tribunal below at Rs.16,33,000/- be awarded in favour of the appellant
claimant-petitioners in place of Rs.8,16,500/-. The appellant claimantpetitioners are entitled to get the aforesaid amount from the Insurance
Company with 7% interest from the date of filing of the claim petition i.e.
w.e.f. 12.07.2022 to till the date of payment. The aforesaid amount with
interest be released in pursuance of the judgment and award delivered by
the
Learned
Tribunal
below
dated
03.06.2024
in
favour
of
the
appellants/claimants. The amount would be disbursed as per the judgment
and award of the Learned Tribunal below on enhanced amount. The
respondent Insurance Company is hereby asked to deposit the amount with
interest either to the Registry of the High Court or to the Tribunal below
within a period of 2(two) months from the date of delivery of this judgment.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this judgment. Also
supply the copy of the judgment to the counsel for the parties for
information and compliance.
JUDGE
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.09.20 11:00:35 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review