Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP No.56 of 2023
National Insurance Company Limited.
Represented by Its Divisional Manager (In Charge),
Agartala Division, 42, Akhaura Road,
P.O: H.P.O. Agartala, P.S: West Agartala,
Dist: West Tripura, Pin: 799001
(Insurer of the motor bike No. TR-01-X-8678/Super
Splendor)
………. Appellant
Versus
1.
Smt. Mampi Goswami (Banerjee),
W/O: Late Pallab Banerjee.
……Claimant/Respondent-1.
(Wife of the deceased)
2.
3.
Sri Pranay Banerjee.
S/O Late Pallab Banerjee.
…...Claimant/Respondent No-2.
(Minor son of the deceased
represented by his mother
at Sl.no. 1 above)
Smt. Minati Banerjee,
W/o: Lt. Probodh Chandra Banerjee.
…..Claimant/Respondent No-3.
(Mother of the deceased)
All the 3 above are residents of VillageMadhuman, Kathaltali, P.O: Madhuban,
P.S: Amtali, District: West Tripura,
Pin: 799003.
4.
Sri Parimal Das
S/o: Rudreswar Das
R/O: Gajaria, P.O: S.D. Mission, P.S: A.D. Nagar,
District: West Tripura, Pin: 799003
………(Owner of the offending
motor bike No.TR-01-X-8678/
Super Splendor).
5.
Sri Sumit Das,
S/O: Sri Parimal Das, R/O: Gajaria,
P.O: S.D. Mission, P.S: A.D. Nagar,
District: West Tripura, Pin: 799003.
………(Driver of the Offending
motor bike No:TR-01-X-8678/
Super Splendor, as shown in the
claim petition).
6.
Prasanjit Das,
S/O: Sri Tapan Das of Gajaria,
P.S: A.D. Nagar, West Tripura, Pin:799003.
………(Driver of the Offending
motor bike No:TR-01-X-8678/
Super Splendor, as shown in A.D.
Nagar
P.S.
Charge
Sheet
No:41/2021)
Along with CO(FA) No.22 of 2023
1.
Smt. Mampi Goswami (Banerjee),
W/O: Late Pallab Banerjee.
2.
Sri Pranay Banerjee.
S/O Late Pallab Banerjee.
3.
Smt. Minati Banerjee,
W/o: Lt. Probodh Chandra Banerjee.
(Petitioner-claimant respondent No.2 being minor son of the
deceased, represented by his mother i.e. petitionerClaimant-respondent No.1.)
All are resident of Vill- Madhuban, Kathaltali,
P.O. Madhuban, P.S. Amtali,
District- West Tripura, Pin 799003.
…..Appellants.
Versus
1.
Sri Parimal Das
S/o: Rudreswar Das
Resident of Gajaria, P.O. S.D. Mission,
P.S: A.D. Nagar, District: West Tripura,
Pin: 799003
(Owner of the offending motor bike No.TR-01-X-8678
Super Splendor).
2.
Sri Sumit Das,
S/O: Sri Parimal Das,
Resident of Gajaria, P.O. S.D. Mission,
P.S: A.D. Nagar, District: West Tripura,
Pin: 799003.
(Driver of the offending motor bike No.TR-01-X-8678
Super Splendor, as shown in the claim petition).
3.
National Insurance Company Limited,
Represented by its Divisional Manager (In Charge),
Agartala Division, 42 Akhaura Road, P.O. Agartala,
P.S: West Agartala, District: West Tripura,
Pin: 799001.
(Insurer of the motor bike No.TR-01-X-8678 Super
Splendor)
……….Respondents.
In MAC APP 56 of 2023:
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Kar Bhowmik, Sr. Adv,
Mr. E. Darlong, Adv,
Mr. N. Debnath, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. H.K. Bhowmik, Adv,
Mr. A.K. Pal, Adv,
Mr. T.K. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
In CO(FA) No.22 of 2023:
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. A.K. Paul, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Kar Bhowmik, Sr. Adv,
Mr. H.K. Bhowmik, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
25.04.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
07.05.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The
National
Insurance
Company
being
the
appellant has preferred this appeal under Section 173 of
M.V. Act challenging the award dated 06.04.2023 passed by
Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court
No.5, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with case No.
T.S.(MAC) 199 of 2021. On the other side, the claimantpetitioners of the original claim petition have also preferred a
cross-appeal
under
Order
Rule
of
CPC
for
enhancement of the award dated 06.04.2023 passed by
Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court
No.5, Agartala, West Tripura in connection with the aforesaid
case which was numbered as CO(FA) No.22 of 2023. Since,
both the appeals have arisen out of a common judgment, so,
by this judgment, both the appeals are taken up for disposal.
02.
Heard
Learned
Senior
Counsel,
Mr.
S.
Kar
Bhowmik assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. E. Darlong and Mr.
N. Debnath for the appellant Insurance Company. Heard
Learned Counsel, Mr. A. K. Pal appearing on behalf of the
respondent-claimant Nos.1 to 3 and also heard Learned
Counsel, Mr. H. K. Bhowmik, representing O.P. respondent
Nos. 4 and 5, being the owner and rider/driver of the
offending bike bearing No.TR-01-X-8678 in connection with
case No. MAC App 56 of 2023 and also heard the same
parties in the connected cross-appeal.
03.
Before conclusion of the appeal, let us project the
subject matter of the claim petition filed before the Claims
Tribunal. The respondent-claimants filed one application
under Section 166 of M.V. Act claiming compensation of
Rs.64,53,000/- due to the death of the deceased, Pallab
Banerjee, who succumbed to his death by a road traffic
accident on 16.04.2021 at about 13.45 hours at Drop Gate,
Agartala under A.D. Nagar P.S. The case of the respondentclaimants before the Tribunal was that on the alleged day,
the deceased Pallab Banerjee came out of his house with his
auto-rickshaw and went to Drop Gate to a garage of one
Guddu on 16.04.2021 at about 13.45 hours for the purpose
of repairing which is situated near S.T. Pauls School and
keeping the auto-rickshaw on the road side, infront of the
said garage, the deceased wanted to restart the auto, that
time suddenly one Sumit Das, respondent rider/driver, son of
Parimal Das of Gajaria came with another person behind
back seat of motor bike bearing No.TR-01-X-8678 rashly
dashed the deceased victim who fell down on the hard road
and sustained injuries and the local people and the pillion
riders shifted the deceased in A.G.M.C and GBP Hospital
where said Pallab Banerjee succumbed to his injury on
17.04.2021. Post-mortem examination was done over the
dead body of the deceased and according to the claimantpetitioners, the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving by the driver of the motor bike Sri Sumit Das. It was
further submitted that the local witnesses, who were present
to the P.O. also stated that the bike was actually driven by
Sri Sumit Das, S/o of Parimal Das and in its back seat one
Prasanta Das was taken his seat and to save the son of
Parimal Das(owner of the bike) the name of one Prasanta
was given as a driver, but said Prasanta Das did not ply the
bike on that particular time of accident. But the Investigation
Officer deliberately and intentionally concealed the name of
actual driver Sumit Das and accordingly, laid charge sheet in
the name of Prasanta Das against A.D. Nagar P.S. Case No.
2021/ADN/028 dated 17.04.2021 under Section 279/304A of
IPC. It was further submitted that the deceased Pallab
Banerjee was a young, energetic, fit and sound healthy
person of 41 years age and he was the only bread earner of
his family, who were entirely depending upon the income of
the deceased and the deceased used to earn money by
driving his auto rickshaw and also as rubber tapper and in
total he used to earn Rs.40,000/-/42,000/- per month.
Hence, the respondent claimant-petitioners No.1 to 3 filed
the claim petition. The claim was contested by the owner and
the rider of the bike and they submitted that the claimantpetitioners are to prove their case and the accident was
occurred not for any rash and negligent driving of the rider
of the bike and it was further submitted that on that relevant
point of time, the offending bike had all the valid documents
including the driving licence of the rider of the bike. So, the
owner and driver/rider by the W.S. prayed for dismissal of
the claim-petition. The appellant, Insurance Company as OP
No.3 contested the case by filing W.S. denying the claim of
the claimants and submitted that the accident occurred not
for rash and negligent driving of the bike bearing No.TR-01X-8678 and it was also submitted that the claimants are to
prove their case by producing all the relevant documents and
Insurance Company was not liable to pay any compensation
unless valid driving licence and other relevant documents are
produced
and
proved.
The
Insurance
Company
also
submitted that any breach of policy could disentitle the
Insurance Company to pay any compensation. So, the
Insurance Company also prayed for dismissal of the claim
petition.
04.
Upon
the
pleadings
of
the
parties,
Learned
Tribunal below framed the following issues:
(i) Whether the case is maintainable?
(ii) Whether deceased Pallab Banerjee died
due to road traffic accident due to rash and
negligent driving of bike TR-01-X-8678 on
16.04.2021 at about 1.15 pm at Drop Gate,
A.D. Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura?
(iii) Whether the claimants are entitled to
get compensation?
(iv) What should
compensation?
be
the
amount
of
(v) Who is liable to pay compensation?
05.
To
substantiate
claimant-petitioners
have
the
issues,
adduced
the
respondent-
oral/documentary
evidence on record and the owner of the bike, Parimal Das
was tendered for his examination by O.P.W1 and relied upon
some documentary evidence which were marked as exhibits:
APPENDIX
Claimant Witness:PW.1- Smt Mampi Goswami (Banerjee).
PW.2- Sri Sanjit Shil.
PW.3- Sri Swapan Kumar Goswami.
PW.4- Sri Nobel Dasgupta.
Claimant’ Exhibits:Ext.1:- Certified copy of printed FIR.
Ext.2:- Certified copy of FIR.
Ext.3:- Certified copy of computerized FIR.
Ext.4:- Certified copy of postmortem report.
Ext.5:- Certified copy of police statement.
Ext.6:- Certified copy of charge sheet.
Ext.7:- Certified copy of MVI report.
Ext.8:- Death certificate.
Ext.9:- Survival certificate.
Ext.10:- Rubber Board Certificate.
Ext.11:- Trade licence dated 03.11.2017.
Ext.12:- Income certificate.
Ext.13:- Cash memo.
Ext.14:- Postmortem certificate.
Ext.15:- Mark sheet.
Ext.16:- Admit card.
Opposite party’s Witness:OPW.1- Sri Parimal Das.
Exhibits by Opposite party No.1:Ext.A- Photocopy of Insurance Certificate.
Ext.B-Photocopy of Registration Certificate.
Ext.C- Photocopy of Tax token.
Ext.D- Photocopy of Driving licence.
06.
The Learned Tribunal after taking evidence and
also after hearing of arguments allowed the claim petition by
judgment dated 06.04.2023. The operative portion of the
order of the Tribunal runs as follows:
“The
OP No.3, The National Insurance
Company Ltd. is directed to deposit the
awarded compensation of Rs.22,65,000/(Rupees Twenty two lakh sixty five
thousand) only within 30 days from today
with interest thereon at the rate of 8% per
annum with effect from date of filing of the
claim application i.e., from 10.11.2021 to
till realization of the full.
Distribution of Compensation
The claimant No.1 being widow is
entitled to get 50% of the compensation
and claimant No.2 and 3 are equally
entitled to the rest compensation.
Protection Awarded Compensation
As claimant No.2 is minor the full amount
of him is to be fixed deposited for the
period till he attain 21 years or for five
years whichever is later.
Sixty percent (60%) of the
amount of compensation of claimant No.1
and 3 are to be fixed deposited for five
years and the rest amount are to be
released in their favour in their bank
account.
In case of necessity, the Tribunal
can be approached for withdrawal of fixed
deposited amount. On maturity of the fixed
deposits the Banker shall credit the
amounts to the sole SB Accounts of
claimants without any further order from
the Tribunal.
Furnish a copy of the award to
both sides.
The case stands disposed of on
contest.
Make necessary entry in the TR
and CIS.”
07.
Challenging the award the appellant Insurance
Company has preferred this appeal. At the time of hearing,
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. S. Kar Bhowmik, assisted by
Learned Counsel Mr. E. Darlong and Mr. N. Debnath for the
appellant Insurance Company submitted that before the
Tribunal, the actual driver who was charge-sheeted in the
connected A.D. Nagar P.S. case was not made as party, so,
the
claim
petition
was
not
maintainable.
He
further
submitted that said Prasenjit Das alias Prasanta Das had no
valid driving licence. Now only for gaining compensation, the
claimant-petitioners have excluded his name in the claim
petition rather impleaded the name of one Sumit Das as the
rider of the offending bike and made one Parimal Das, being
the father of said Subir Das as owner of the said offending
bike. As such, since the original owner has violated the terms
and conditions of the policy of the Insurance, so, the
Insurance Company was not liable to pay any compensation
but the Learned Tribunal below did not consider the same
and urged for allowing this appeal by setting aside the award
in this respect. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted
that Learned Tribunal below determined the amount of
monthly income of the deceased at Rs.15,000/- per month.
But in this regard, no cogent documentary evidence on
record is produced and proved by the respondent-claimantpetitioners before the Tribunal and as such in pursuance of
the judgment of Sarala Verma reported in (2009) 6 SCC
121 and also the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in National
Insurance Company vs Pranay Shetty and Ors., reported in
(2017) 16 SCC 680, Learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that the determination of calculation by the
Tribunal was not proper and lawful in the eye of law and
prayed for modifying the award. Learned Senior Counsel also
submitted that at the time of calculation of compensation,
additional Rs. 15,000/- was awarded but in this regard no
explanation was made by the Tribunal. So, in summing up,
Learned Senior Counsel urged for allowing the appeal,
setting aside the award/judgment of the Learned Tribunal.
08.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel, Mr. H. K.
Bhowmik, representing the respondent O.P. Nos.4 and 5
submitted that the submission of Learned Senior Counsel
cannot be accepted at this stage, because before the
Learned Tribunal at the time of filing of W.S. nothing was
submitted by the appellant Insurance Company in this regard
that the person who is charge-sheeted was not made as
party. Even the Insurance Company did not adduce any
oral/documentary
evidence
on
record.
Rather
Learned
Counsel submitted that in the written statement submitted
by the Insurance Company in Para No.4, it was specifically
mentioned that one Sumit Das was the driver/rider of the
bike and at this stage, there is no scope on the part of the
appellant Insurance Company to deviate from the said
statement. Learned Counsel further submitted that even in
the
claim
petition
the
respondent-claimant-petitioners
arrayed Sumit Das as the rider of the offending motor bike
and the witnesses of the claimant-petitioners including the
eye witnesses specifically whispered the name of the Sumit
Das as the rider of the offending bike and to discredit the
said evidence, there was no contrary evidence on record
from the appellant Insurance Company. Furthermore, before
the High Court also the prayer for making Prasanta Das was
rejected by this High Court by order dated 15.02.2024 in
connection with IA No.3 of 2023 arising out of MAC App
No.56 of 2023. Finally, Learned Counsel submitted that the
Learned Tribunal below rightly and reasonably awarded the
claim petition and there is no merit in the appeal and
submitted that for determination of compensation, Civil
Court is not binding by the order of the Criminal Court rather
the findings of MAC Tribunal would prevail over the findings
of Criminal Court and referred some citations which would be
discussed later on.
09.
Paul,
On the other hand, Learned Counsel, Mr. A. K.
representing
the
respondent-claimant-petitioners
submitted that the respondent-claimant-petitioners have
been able to prove the claim petition before the Learned
Tribunal both by oral/documentary evidence on record and
also submitted that the deceased had monthly income more
than Rs.40,000/- but the Tribunal without any basis assessed
the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.15,000/- per
month, which was insufficient and not satisfactory and urged
for enhancing the award/compensation by allowing the
cross-appeal and dismissing the appeal preferred by the
appellant Insurance Company.
10.
I have heard elaborate arguments of Learned
Counsels of the interested parties and gone through the
record of the Learned Tribunal below. It appears that the
Learned
Tribunal
at
the
time
of
determination
of
compensation assessed the monthly of the deceased at
Rs.15,000/- per month. Considering all aspects and relying
upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Sarala Verma and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation
and Another, determined the multiplier as 14 and thereafter,
in pursuance of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India in National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay
Sethi and Others reported AIR (2017) SC 5157 allowed
25% of the amount to be added as future prospect and
thereafter, deducted 1/3 amount towards personal expenses
of the deceased. Thus, determined the loss of income at
Rs.21,00,000/-(Twenty one lakhs) only. Thereafter Learned
Tribunal below awarded Rs.1,20,000/-(One lakh twenty
thousand) only as
consortium, Rs.15,000/-(Rupees fifteen
thousand) only as loss of estate and Rs.15,000/- as funeral
expenses and further added Rs.15,000/-(Rupees fifteen
thousand)
only
determined
the
as
loss
total
of
conventional
amount
of
head.
Thus,
compensation
as
Rs.22,65,000/- (Twenty two lakhs sixty five thousand) only.
From the record of the Learned Tribunal below and also from
the oral/documentary evidence on record, it appears that the
appellant Insurance Company before the Tribunal could not
raise any circumstance to disbelieve that said Sumit Das was
not the rider/driver of the offending motor bike on the
alleged day of accident, rather in the WS filed by the
Insurance
Company,
they
specifically
stated
that
rider/driver of the offending motor bike was Sumit Das.
the
11.
Furthermore, they made similar plea before this
Court and this Court in I.A. No.3 of 2023 dated 15.02.2024
discarded that plea of the Insurance Company. So, at this
stage, there is no scope to accept the submission made by
Learned Senior Counsel representing the appellant Insurance
Company.
12.
To counter his submission, Learned Counsel, Mr.
H. K. Bhowmik relied upon one judgment of this High Court
in connection with
MAC App No.07 of 2012
dated
14.10.2016 in para No.9, 10 and 11 observed as under:
“9. The question as to how far the decision
of a criminal case or the police report can
influence the decision of a civil case was
discussed by the Division Bench of Madhya
Pradesh High Court in Mahila Dhanwanti
and others v. Kulwan and others, AIR 1994
MP 44, and it was held therein:
10. Coming to the other contention
that the deceased was travelling as a
passenger
and,
therefore,
the
Insurance Company was not liable to
pay any compensation, it has also no
merit. True, the F.I.R. (Ex. D/2-C) and
the statement of the Investigating
Officer gives a version which support
the case of the Insurance Company,
but even assuming that the F.I.R. is a
public document, but it is the rule of
law that it is not a substantive piece of
evidence. It can be used only for the
purposes
of
corroboration
or
contradiction of the maker only. The
maker having not been examined by
either side, the statement of A. S.
Yadav carries no weight as he only
investigated the occurrence. He is not
an eyewitness to the occurrence. His
testimony is of hearsay evidence,
therefore, the conclusions which he
drew after investigation cannot be
taken
into
consideration
unless
supported by proper material, It is
well settled proposition of law that
evidence recorded in criminal Court
and the findings arrived at thereon
should not be used in claim cases.
Such evidence, for the purposes of
claim cases is inadmissible. (See
Shabbir Ahmad v. M.P.S.R.T.C., Bhopal,
AIR 1984 MP 173).”
10. In R.P. Gautam v. R.N.M. Singh and
another, AIR 2008 MP 68, the Madhya
Pradesh High Court lucidly summed up the
proposition of law in the following manner:
13. It is settled proposition of law that
every civil case is decided on it's own
facts and evidence without influencing
the papers and decision of the criminal
case. In such premises registration of
the offence and police investigation is
not
a
condition
precedent
for
awarding the claim. Besides this due
to one reason or another if the first
information
report
of
vehicular
accident is not lodged with the police
or the same was given at later stage
and police neither registered the
offence nor investigated the same, it
does not mean that right of the victim
for compensation who suffered the
vehicular accident is washed away.
The
victim
remains
entitled
for
compensation on proving the facts and
circumstances regarding such accident
and factum of injuries sustained by
him, he could not be deprived from
such right, provided by the Motor
Vehicles
Act,
although
such
compensation may be awarded only
on proving all relevant facts with all
probabilities.”
11. Motor accident claim case is in the
nature of a civil suit and certainly not a
criminal case. Therefore, the Tribunal has
grossly erred in law in relying on the
contents of the ejahar and the Police
investigation report to disbelieve and
discard the case of the claimant. The
claimant, on the contrary, is entitled to
prove her case on the basis of the evidence
adduced by her, which was corroborated in
material particulars by the evidence of PW2, who personally saw the accident
resulting in the death of the deceased, in
the course of trial. On my above findings, I
have no hesitation in holding that the
deceased was killed in the vehicular
accident on 2-4-2004 due to the rash and
negligent driving of the driver of the
respondent No. 1. Resultantly, the insurer,
who admittedly insured the vehicle in
question at the time of the accident, is
vicariously liable to satisfy the award.”
13.
From the principle of the said citation, it is crystal
clear that although the police charge-sheeted the name of
one Prasenjit Das, son of Tapan Das of Gajaria as the
driver/rider of the offending bike on the day of accident but
the Tribunal was not bound by the said decision in absence
of valid, cogent and documentary evidence on record.
Rather, I find force on the submission of Learned Counsel,
representing the O.P. owner and rider/driver of the offending
motor bike. More so, the appellant Insurance Company to
substantiate their contention could not raise any doubt to
disbelieve the evidence of the claimant-petitioners and their
evidence.
14.
Now, regarding the actual monthly income of the
deceased, the respondent-claimant-petitioners could not
adduce any documentary evidence on record. They relied
upon Exhibit-10 i.e. the certificate of Rubber Board, from
which it appears that the deceased had undergo training for
a period w.e.f. 01.12.2005 to 09.12.2005 as rubber tapper.
The claimant-petitioner also relied upon Exhibit-12 which
was issued by the Secretary and President of Tripura Auto
Ricksha Shramik Sangha, wherein it was stated that the
deceased used to earn Rs.40,000/-/42,000/- per month but
that certificate was not issued by any Authority of the
Government to place any reliance, even the Issuing Authority
was also not tendered for examination by the respondentclaimant-petitioners. But it is on record that he was an auto
driver and also he used to do some earning from rubber
tapping business but in this regard, no specific evidence on
record
could
be
adduced
by
the
respondent-claimant-
petitioners. So, in my considered view, Learned Tribunal
below rightly determined the amount of monthly income of
the deceased as Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand)only
per month. So, I find no scope to interfere with the judgment
of the Learned Tribunal below in this regard. It was the
admitted position that there was no dispute on record in
respect of the death of the deceased and also in respect of
age of the deceased as 41 years on the day of accident or
occurrence of offence.
15.
Learned Tribunal below admittedly could not give
any specific finding as to how he determined the monthly
income of the deceased as Rs.15,000/- per month. It is on
record that the deceased was a driver side by side he was
also a rubber tapper. So, considering the position and status
of the deceased, it can be safely concluded that the Tribunal
after considering all the factors in absence of cogent
evidence on record rightly determined the monthly income of
the deceased Rs.15,000/- per month. Because a auto-driver
easily can earn Rs.500/- per day. More so, he used to earn
some money as rubber tapper. So, even for 25 days if the
deceased used to ply his vehicle, i.e. auto-rickshaw for 25
days in that case also his earning comes to Rs.12,000/- and
the rest amount he could easily earn from rubber tapper.
16.
In course of argument, Learned Senior Counsel,
Mr. Bhowmik also submitted that the Learned Tribunal below
at the time of determination of calculation awarded 15,000/(Rupees fifteen thousand only) more without any basis for
which no specific head was mentioned. In this regard, I
would like to refer herein below the judgment of our Hon’ble
Supreme Court reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680, National
Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors.
in Para No.52 of the said judgment, Hon’ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“52. As far as the conventional heads are
concerned, we find it difficult to agree with
the view expressed in Rajesh: Rajesh v.
Rajbir Singh, (2003) 9 SCC 54. It has
granted Rs 25,000/- towards funeral
expenses, Rs 1,00,000/- loss of consortium
and Rs. 1,00,000/- towards loss of care and
guidance for minor children. The head
relating to loss of care and minor children
does not exist. Though Rajesh: Rajesh v.
Rajbir Singh, (2003) 9 SCC 54 refers to
Santosh Devi: Santosh Devi v. National
Insurance Co. Ltd.,(2012) 6 SCC 421, it
does not seem to follow the same. The
conventional
and traditional
heads,
needless to say, cannot be determined on
percentage basis because that would not be
an
acceptable
criterion.
Unlike
determination of income, the said heads
have to be quantified. Any quantification
must have a reasonable foundation. There
can be no dispute over the fact that price
index, fall in bank interest, escalation of
rates in many a field have to be noticed.
The court cannot remain oblivious to the
same. There has been a thumb rule in this
aspect. Otherwise, there will be extreme
difficulty in determination of the same and
unless the thumb rule is applied, there will
be immense variation lacking any kind of
consistency as a consequence of which, the
orders passed by the tribunals and courts
are likely to be unguided. Therefore, we
think it seemly to fix reasonable sums. It
seems to us that reasonable figures on
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate,
loss of consortium and funeral expenses
should be Rs. 15,000/-, Rs. 40,000/- and
Rs. 15,000/- respectively. The principle of
revisiting the said heads is an acceptable
principle. But the revisit should not be factcentric or quantum-centric. We think that it
would be condign that the amount that we
have quantified should be enhanced on
percentage basis in every three years and
the enhancement should be at the rate of
10% in a span of three years. We
are disposed to hold so because that will
bring in consistency in respect of those
heads.”
17.
From the aforesaid principle of law, it appears
that the Learned Tribunal below in delivering the judgment,
determined the compensation under conventional heads i.e.
the loss of estate, funeral expenses and loss of consortium,
Rs.1,50,000/-(Rs.1,20,000/- + Rs.15,000/- + Rs.15,000/-)
=Rs.1,50,000/- x 10% of the said amount= Rs.15,000/-.
18.
So, in my considered view, Learned Tribunal
rightly determined the said amount as the accident took
place on 16.04.2021. So, after prolong hearing of the
Learned Counsels of the contesting parties, it appears that
there is no merit in the appeal filed by the appellant
Insurance Company and at the same time the appellantclaimant-petitioner in the connected cross-appeal also could
not place any materials before this Court to enhance the
amount of compensation awarded by the Tribunal. Thus,
both the appeals filed by the appellant Insurance Company
and the respondent-claimant-petitioners fails being devoid of
merit.
19.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant
Insurance Company fails and accordingly, it is hereby
dismissed on contest and also the cross-appeal filed by the
respondent-claimant-petitioners stands rejected being devoid
of merit. The judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal
dated 06.04.2023 is hereby affirmed and accordingly, it is
upheld.
20.
From the record, it appears that the Insurance
Company has already deposited 50% of the amount before
the Registry of this High Court which has been disbursed in
pursuance of the order passed by this High Court on
15.02.2024 in connection with I.A. No.2 of 2023 arising out
of MAC App No.56 of 2023. So, the appellant Insurance
Company be asked to deposit the balance amount with
interest to the Registry of the High Court as per award given
by Learned Tribunal within a period of two months from the
date of passing this judgment/order. The disbursal of amount
to the claimant-petitioners would be made as per direction
given by the Learned Tribunal below vide judgment and
award dated 06.04.2023.
21.
cost
A copy of this judgment/order be furnished free of
to
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant
Insurance
Company and to the owner/rider of the offending motor bike
as well as to
the Learned Counsel, representing the
respondent-claimant-petitioners.
22.
With
this
observation,
these
appeals
stands
disposed of on contest. A copy of this judgment/order be
kept in the connected CO(FA) No.22 of 2023.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI BHATTACHARJEE
2024.05.09 17:11:08
BHATTACHARJEE Date:
+05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review