Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP 80 OF 2024
1. Smt. Mamata Paul,
W/o Shri Rabindra Paul of Tulabagan, 1 No. Colony,
P.O. Tulabagan, P.S. Sidhai, Mohanpur Municipal Council,
Sidhai Mohanpur, West Tripura District.
2. Shri Rabindra Paul,
S/o Lt. Balaram Paul of Tulabagan, 1 No.Colony,
P.O. Tulabagan, P.S. Sidhai, Mohanpur Municipal Council,
Sidhai Mohanpur, West Tripura District.
….Appellants.
Versus
1. Dipak Das,
S/o Shri Dulal Ch. Das of West Chanmari, near Rubber Board,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. N.C.C., Agartala, Tripura (W).
M-7005165422.(Owner of vehicle No.TR01AW-0464, Maruti Eeco).
2. The Branch Manager,
United India Insurance Company Ltd.,
Agartala Division, R.M.S. Chowmuhani,
Opposite of Kiran Medical Hall,
Agartala Tripura (W), 799001.
(Insurer of vehicle No.TR01AW-0464).
….Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Samar Das, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Ms. R. Purkayastha, Advocate.
Date of hearing and date of
delivery of Judgment & Order : 27.01.2026
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard learned counsel of both sides.
2.
Both the appellants filed a claim petition before the learned
Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala bearing
No. TS(MAC) 3 of 2021 alleging, inter alia, that on 10.03.2020, at about
3:30 pm, when their son, Mithan Paul along with his friends were returning
from Simna by riding a motor cycle bearing Registration No.TR01H-0862,
at Nandalal Das Para on Agartala-Simna road one vehicle bearing
Registration No.TR01AW-0464 [Maruti Eeco] dashed the motorcycle from
behind. As a result, their son received multiple injuries and when he was
taken to Mohanpur Hospital, he was declared dead. Concerning the said
accident, Sidhai P.S.Case No. 24/2020, under Sections 279/304(A) of IPC
was also registered on the basis of an FIR lodged by Rabindra Paul, the
appellant-petitioner No.2. The investigating authority submitted the
charge-sheet against accused Dipak Das, driver of said Maruti Eeco
vehicle for commission of offence under Sections 279/304(A) of IPC and
also under Sections 184/187 of M.V. Act holding him prima facie
responsible for the said accident.
3.
The petitioners [appellants herein], thereafter submitted claim
petition before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal praying for an amount
of Rs.43,70,000/- as compensation from said Dipak Das and the insurer,
the United India Insurance Co. Ltd., the respondents herein.
4.
During trial, both the petitioners were examined as PW-1 and
PW-2 respectively. The respondent No.1 submitted his examination-inchief as OPW-1, but he did not face any cross-examination. However, the
learned Tribunal observed that the owner of the said Maruti Eeco vehicle
produced the photocopies of vehicular documents and the driving license
of the driver without producing the originals as in a connected case,
bearing No. TS (MAC) 165/2020 arising out of the same accident, the
owner had produced the originals. Therefore, learned counsel of the
insurance company did not oppose in taking into consideration the
photocopies of said documents in connection with this case.
5.
Learned Tribunal by the impugned award determined the
total compensation of Rs.15,38,000/- (Rupees fifteen lakh thirty eight
thousand) only but ultimately, reduced 10% of the said sum on the ground
of contributory negligence on the part of the deceased and finally awarded
an amount of Rs. 13,84,200/- [Rupees thirteen lakh eighty four thousand
two hundred] only to the petitioners along with interest @ 7.5% per annum
upon the said amount from the date of filing of claim petition till payment.
6.
Learned Tribunal also determines the compensation relying
on the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of National
Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi, AIR 2017 SC 5157; Sarla Verma
& Ors. vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr., AIR 2009 SC 3104 and
Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Nanu Ram, 2018 SCC OnLine
SC 1546.
7.
Learned counsel, Mr. Samar Das appearing for the appellant-
petitioners submits that the appellants have only a limited grievance
against the deduction of 10% of the amount on the ground of contributory
negligence, otherwise, the determination of compensation by the learned
Tribunal was just and proper and in accordance with law.
8.
Learned counsel, Mr. Das referring to the observations made
by learned Tribunal submits that without any evidence learned Tribunal
has made out a third case of contributory negligence by drawing certain
inference that just because of three persons were there on the said
motorcycle of the deceased at the time of accident, there was contributory
negligence on the part of the deceased. According to learned counsel,
such observations are totally based on conjectures and cannot sustain.
However, learned counsel, Mr. Das also submits that the insurance
company in their written statement raised the plea of riding of motorcycle
by the deceased with two other pillion riders and therefore they claimed
that it was a breach of specific conditions of a policy and the deceased
had contributed to the accident.
9.
Learned counsel, Ms. R. Purkayastha appearing for the
respondent-United India Insurance Co. Ltd. submits that it has come out
from the cross-examination of the father of the deceased [PW-2] that on
the date of accident, there were two pillion riders on the motorcycle of the
deceased and thus it was established in the evidence that the deceased
was responsible for the said accident by violating the Motor Vehicle Rules
and also the terms of the insurance policy, and therefore, the learned
Tribunal was justified in reducing 10% of the total amount as assessed as
compensation on the ground of contributory negligence. Learned counsel
also submits that no specific plea has been taken by the appellants in this
appeal challenging the said findings of learned Tribunal.
10.
During hearing, so far the question raised by learned counsel
Ms. Purkayastha that no specific plea was taken in the memo of appeal in
the matter of finding of learned Tribunal regarding reduction of 10% of
contributory negligence, is concerned, this Court finds no limitation in
exercising appellate jurisdiction to interfere in the matter of awarding of
less amount of compensation, even though, no such plea is specifically
raised by the appellants in the appeal. When they have preferred the
appeal challenging the award itself on the ground of inadequacy of
amount, and the provision being beneficial legislation, there is no bar in
enhancing the quantum of compensation in this appeal.
11.
Learned counsel, Mr. Das in this regard also relies on a
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ranjana Prakash &
Ors. vs. Divisional Manager & Anr., (2011) 14 SCC 639 and relevant
paragraph No.8 is extracted here-in-below for useful reference“8. Where an appeal is filed challenging the quantum
of compensation, irrespective of who files the appeal, the
appropriate course for the High Court is to examine the facts
and by applying the relevant principles, determine the just
compensation. If the compensation determined by it is higher
than the compensation awarded by the Tribunal, the High Court
will allow the appeal, if it is by the claimants and dismiss the
appeal, if it is by the owner/insurer. Similarly, if the
compensation determined by the High Court is lesser than the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal, the High Court will
dismiss any appeal by the claimants for enhancement, but allow
any appeal by owner/insurer for reduction. The High Court
cannot obviously increase the compensation in an appeal by
owner/insurer for reducing the compensation, nor can it reduce
the compensation in an appeal by the claimants seeking
enhancement of compensation.”
12.
This Court has also considered the submissions of learned
counsel of both sides on the facts of the case. As it appears, learned
Tribunal has drawn an inference in absence of any evidence in this regard
that just because, the deceased was riding the motorcycle having two
pillion riders behind him, he was responsible for the said accident to some
extent. This Court is constrained to hold that such observation made by
learned Tribunal is beyond the record. By taking two pillion riders on his
motorcycle, the deceased might have violated the Motor Vehicle rules for
which he could be penalized otherwise, if he would be alive. But just
because of three persons were there on the motorcycle, it cannot be said
that he was responsible for the accident, or that he had contributed in the
accident. Moreover, in the present case, his motorcycle was dashed from
behind by the offending vehicle.
13.
This Court is in total disagreement with the observations of
the learned Tribunal that as the deceased was travelling with two other
persons on the same motorcycle, it was difficult for him to ride the
motorcycle and so, there was contributory negligence on his part. Drawing
of such inference without any evidence on that point is impressible at law.
The insurance company though raised the plea of contributory negligence
in their written statement but they did not produce any evidence to
establish such plea. Moreover, the investigating officer after investigation
also did not find the deceased to be responsible, even partly, for the said
accident and for that reason, he submitted charge-sheet only against the
driver of the offending Maruti Eeco vehicle. There is no challenge of the
insurance company regarding submission of said charge-sheet by the
police authority.
14.
Considering this, the reduction of 10% of the compensation
amount on the ground of contributory negligence is totally erroneous and
is liable to be upset.
15.
In view of above, the appeal is allowed. The award passed by
learned Tribunal is modified accordingly. The appellant-petitioners will get
compensation of Rs.15,38,000/- along with interest @ 7.5% per annum
from the date of filing of claim petition till payment is made.
16.
The United India Insurance Company Ltd., the respondent
No.2 will now deposit the enhanced amount of Rs. 1,53,800/[Rs.15,38,000-Rs.13,84,200] only along with the above said interest in the
Tribunal below within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment. On such deposit, the same shall be equally apportioned
between the appellants and would be kept in fixed deposit scheme for
next five years. However, the appellants may approach the learned
Tribunal for pre-mature withdrawal of said amount on any reasonable
ground to be considered by the Tribunal.
17.
With such observations and directions, the appeal is disposed
of.
18.
Return the LCRs with a copy of this judgment.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.01.29 16:39:09 +05'30'
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review