Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3448 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUqUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETIT ION NO: 2940 OF 2023
Petition under Article 227 Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the order dated
01-08-2023 passed in 1.A.No.1908 ot2021 in O.S.No.64 of 2019 on the file of the
Court of the Junior Civil Judge-cum-Mekopolitan Magistrate at Chevella, Ranga
Reddy District.
Between:
Smt. M. Sridevi died per LR, Reddy Gokul Kumar s/o Late.Praveen Kumar,
aged 24 years, Occ: Pvt.employee rlo 87 , Barry Circle, Bloomfield, CT-06002
USA rep.by Power of Attomey Holder T.Mallikarjuna Reddy s/o Late.Venka
Reddy, aged about 53 years, Occ: Business rlo 821A, Vengal Rao Nagar
Hyderabad.
...PETITIONER/PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF
AND
Sri Divi Satya Sayee Babu, s/o Divi Madhusudhana Rao, aged 41 years' Occ:
Business Executive r/o 51-1-19 Jagannadharaiu Nagar, Venkojipalem
Mrs.B.Sujatha, Mo Narsimha Reddy, aged 62 years, Occ: Housewife r/o 1-8115, Road No.1, Vidyutnagar P and T Colony, Dilsukhnagar Hyderabad.
...RESPON DENTS/RESPONDENTS'DEFENDANTS
l.A. NO: 1OF 2423
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all
further proceedings in OS.No.64l2O19 on the file of the court of Junior Civil Judge
cum Metropolitan Magistrate, Chevella, R.R.District, pending disposal of CRP.No.
t2023.
Counsel for the Petitioner: Sri Pumima Singh
Counsel for the Respondents: Sri Lohit Sannapaneni
The Court made the following: ORDER
THT} HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF. TELANGANA AT
ITYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO.294O OF 2023
DATED: 27th FEBRUARY ?O26
Between:
Smt.M.SriCevi died per LR
Reddy Gollul Kumar S/o. Late. Praveen Kumar,
Aged 24 y<:ars, Occ:Prt.employee
R/o.87, B:rrry Circle, Bloomfield, CT-O6002
USA rep.b7 Power of Attorney Holder
T.Mallika{una Reddy S/o.Late Venka Reddy
Aged about 53 years, Occ: Business
R/o 821A, Vengal Rao Nagar.
... Petitioner - Petitioner - Plaintiffs
And
l.Sri Divi tiatya Sayee Babu and another
... Respondents - Respondents - Defendants
ORDER
1.
This memorandum of Civil Revision Petition is filed under
Article 227 of the constitution of India assailing the order passed by
the learnerl Junior civil Judge - cum - Metropolitan Magistrate,
Chevella, Ranga Reddy District, in I.A.No.1908 of 2021 in O.S.No.64
of 2019, dated 01.08.2023.
\\ \
B
I
2lt3
BRMR,J
CRP.No.29aO of 2023
2.
The petitioner is the petitioner - plaintiff and respondents are
the respondents - defendants in I.A.No.1908 of 2021 in O.S.No.64 of
20t9.
3.1 The petitioner - plaintiff has filed I.A.No.1908 of 2021 in
O.S.No.6 4 of 2019 under Sections 195 and 340 of Cr.P.C to make a
preliminary enquiry into the offences under Sections 193, 196, 199
and 2OO of IPC which appears to have been committed in respect of
verification which has been solemnly affirmed and annexed to the
written statement dated O8.O7.2O19 and subsequently filed and
submitted in the proceedings of the above said suit.
3.2 Respondents - defendants have filed counter and opposed the
application.
4.
The learned Trial Court uide order dated 01.08.2023 has
dismissed the application which is impugned in the present Civil
Revision Petition.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner - plaintiff submits that the
learned Trial Court could not have adjudicated the disputed questions
on merits which precluded the rights of the parties at the preliminary
stage and could have postponed adjudication of the petition to be
decided along with the suit upon evidence or relegated the parties to
work out their remedies separately and independently. The Trial
Court failed to appreciate the scope and ambit of Sections 195 and
'/
/
"/
3/ 13
CRP.No.294O
BRMR,J
of 2023
34o of cr.P.c, where under the petitioner sought for a preliminary
enquiry for the offences under Sections 193, 196, 199 and 200 of lpc.
Preliminary enquiry is required to be held into the offences referred to
under Section 195 of [PC, it is not a mere case of sufferance of injury
but is interference with due course of justice. tt is a case of deliberate
falsehood and the trial court overlooked the same. The Trial Court
ought to have seen that by pressing documents the respondents
sought to establish their possession and managed to get the same.
Counsel to substantiate her contention has relied on the decisions in
the cases ,rf (i) chandra shashi Vs. Anil Kumar Vermal, (ii) sachida
Nand singh and another vs. State of Bihar and another2, (iii) Surya
Dev Rai Vs. Ram Chander Rai and Others3, (iv) Shalini Shyam Shetty
and anothr:r Vs. Rajendra Shankar Patila and (v) union of India vs.
Haresh V.lUilani and anothers.
6-
Learned senior counsel appearing for the respondents
defendants contended that cRP itself is not maintainable, even
otherwise l,shrned Trial Court has gone into the matter in detail and
rightly disrnissed the application filed by the petitioner - plaintiff.
Counsel to substantiate his contention has relied on the decisions in
the cases of (i) Iqbal singh Marwah and another vs. Meenakshi
'(rggs) 1 scc 421 *:- -..
'(rsga) 2 scc 493
'1zoo:y G scc G7s
o
t
lzoro; 8 scc 329
(zorg) Scc onLine Bom 2080
4/13
BRMR,J
CRP.No.294O of 2023
Marwah and another6, (ii) Jose Kuruvinakunnel Vs. A.T.Jose7, (iii)
Darastul Khalif Vs. The State of Jharkhand and Others8, (i")
V.A.Roclry Vs. Pavunni and Otherse and (v) V.Ramesh Babu,
Advocate, Khammam Vs. State of A.P. Rep.by P.P., High Court of A.P.,
HYderabadto.
7.
Counsels on record have filed their written submissions in
support of their contentions.
8.1 It is apt to note here that the Registry has returned the CRP on
22.09.2023. The endorsement of the Registry is as under:
"QRP.SR. No. 36911 12923
Please verify and clarify how this CRP.SR is entertainable U/Art 227 of
Constitution of India against the order dated 01.08.2023, passed in
I.A.No.l9O8l2021 in O.S.No.64l2Ol9 in the Court of JGI - Metropolitan
Magistrate, R.R.District since the said IA was frled U/s 195 & 340 of
Criminal Procedure Code."
8.2 On 25.09.2023learned counsel for the petitioner - plaintiff has
resubmitted the bundle as under:
"Resubmitted
The petition was filed before the Honble Junior Civil Judge, seeking for
lodging of complaint to the concerned as it is the Court before which the
offence took place is to lodge the complaint. This is an order of a Civil
Court and hence Revision under Article 227 of C.O.t is maintainable."
u
(zoos) 4 scc
.n' *
' 1995 srpreme (ker) 411
t (zooa)
ScC onLine Jhar
2014 Supreme (Ker) 758
'o 2019 supreme (Telangana) 351
t
s/ 13
BRMR,J
CRP.No.294O of 2023
9.1 Section 195 of Cr.P.C., reads as under:
195. Prosecrtion for contempt of lawful authority of public servants, for offences
against pubtic justice and for offences relating to documents giver in evidence.-(1)
No Court sh;lll take cognizance-
(a)
of any offence punishable under sections 172 to 188 (both
(i)
inclusive) of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), or
(ii)
of any abetment of, attempt to commit, such offence, or
(iii)
of any criminal conspiracy to commit such offence,
except on the complaint in writing of the public servant
concerned or of some other public servant to whom he is
administratively su bordi nate;
(b)
(il
of any offence punishable under any of the following
sections of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), namely,
sections 193 to 196 (both inclusive), l99,2OO,2OS to 2ll
(both inclusive! and 228, when such offence is alleged to
have been committed in, or in relation to, any proceeding
in any Court, or
(ii)
of any offence described in section 463, or punishable
under section 47 1, section 475 or section 476, of the said
Code, when such offence is alleged to have been committed
.
in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a
proceeding in any Court, or
(iii)
of any criminal conspiracy to commit, or attempt to
commit, or the abetment of, any offence specified in subclause (i) or sub-clause (ii),
[except on the complaint in writing of that court or by such officer of the
court as t.rat court may authorise in writing in this behalf, or of some other
Court to which that Court is subordinatel.
(2) where a complaint has been made by a public servant under crause (a)
of sub-sect:ion (1) any authority to which he is administratively subordinate
may order the withdrawal of the complaint and send a copy of such order to
the court; and upon its receipt by the court, no further proceedings shall be
taken on ttre complaint:
Providr:d that no such withdrawal shall be ordered if the trial in the Court
of first instreqe has been concluded.
\
6/ 13
BRMR,J
CRP.No.2940 of 2O23
(3) In clause (b) of sub-section (1), the term "Court" means a Civil,
Revenue or Criminal Court, and includes a tribunal constituted by or under a
Central, Provincial or State Act if declared by that Act to be a Court for the
purposes of this section.
(4) For the purposes of clause (b) of sub-section (1), a Court shall be
deemed to be subordinate to the Court to which appeals ordinarily lie from the
appealable decrees or sentences of such former Court, or in the case of a Civil
Court from whose decrees no appeal ordinarily lies, to the principal Court
having ordinary original civil jurisdiction within whose local jurisdiction such
Civil Court is situate:
Provided that-
(a) where appeals lie to more than one Court, the Appellate Court of
inferior jurisdiction shall be the Court to which such Court shall be
deemed to be subordinate;
(b) where appeals lie to a civil and also to a Revenue Court, such Court
shall be deemed to be subordinate to the Civil or Revenue Court
according to the nature of the case or proceeding in connection with
which the offence is alleged to have been committed.
9.2
Section 34O of Cr.P.C reads as under:
340. Procedure in cases mentioned in section 195.-(1) When upon an
application made to it in this behalf or otherwise, any Court is of opinion that
is expedient in the interests of justice that an inquiry should be made into any
offence referred to in clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 195, which
appears to have been committed in or in relation to a proceeding in that Court
or, as the case may be, in respect of a document produced or given in evidence
in a proceeding in that Court, such Court may, after such preliminar5r inquiry,
if any, as it thinks necessary,(a) record a finding to that effect;
(b) make a complaint thereof in writing;
(c) send it to a Magistrate of the first class having jurisdiction;
(d) take sufficient security for the appearance for the accused
before such Magistrate, or if the alleged offence is non-bailable
and the Court thinks it necessary so to do, send the accused in
custody to such Magistrate; and
/t3
BRMR,J
CRP.No.294O ot2023
..//
(,:) bind over any person to appear and give evidence before such
I
I
Magistrate.
I
I
(2) The power conferred on a Court by sub-section (1) in respect of an
offence ma,, in any case where that Court has neither made a complaint
under sub-section (l) in respect of that offence nor rejected an application for
the making,rf such complaint, be exercised by the Court to which such former
Court is subordinate within the meaning of sub-section (4) of section 195.
(3) A complaint mad.e under this section shall be signed,-
(a) where the Court making the complaint is a High Court, by such
cfficer of the Court as the Court may appoint;
(b) in any other case, by the presiding officer of the Court or by such
'rfficer of the Court as the Court may authorise in writing in this
rehalf.l
(4) In this section, "Court" has the same meaning as in section 195.
9.3 Sectron 341 of Cr.P.C reads as under:
341. .\ppeal. (1) Any person on whose application any Court other than
a High Court has refused to make a complaint under sub-section (l) or
Section (2) ot section 34O, or against whom such a complaint has been made
by such Corrrt, may appeal to the Court to which such former Court is
subordinate within the meaning of sub-section (a) of section 195, and the
superior Court may thereupon, after notice to the parties concerned, direct the
withdrawal of the complaint or, as the case may be, making of the complaint
which such frrmer Court might have made under section 340, and if it makes
such complaint, the provisions of that section shall apply accordingly.
(2) An order under this section and subject to any such order, an order
under sectior 34O, shall be final, and shalt not be subject to revision.
10.1 [n Su:rya Dev Rai3, Supreme Court observed as under:
"38(7) ?') The power to issue a writ of certiorari and the supervisory
jurisdicr.ion are to be exercised sparingly and only in appropriate cases
where t,re judicial conscience of the High court dictates it to act lest a
gross failure of justice or grave injustice should occasion. Care, caution
and cirr:umspection need to be exercised, when any of the above said
two jurisdictions is sought to be invoked during the pendency of any suit
or proce edings in a subordinate court and the error though calling for
a/ 13
BRMR,J
CRP.No.2940 of 2O23
correction is yet capable of being corrected at the conclusion of the
proceedings in an appeal or revision preferred thereagainst and
entertaining a petition invoking certiorari or supervisory jurisdiction of
the High Court would obstruct the smooth flow and/or early disposal of
the suit or proceedings. The High Court may feel inclined to intervene
where the error is such, as, if not corrected at that very moment, may
become incapable of correction at a later stage and 5efusal to intervene
would result in travesty of justice or where such refusal itself would
result in prolonging of the lis.
39. Though we have tried to lay down broad principles and working
rules, the fact remains that the parameters for exercise of jurisdiction
under Articles 226 or 227 of the Constitution cannot be tied down in a
strait-jacket formula or rigid rules. Not less than often, the High Court
would be faced with a dilemma. [f it intervenes in pending proceedings
there is bound to be delay in termination of proceedings. If it does not
intervene, the error of the moment may earn immunity from correction.
The facts and circumstances of a given case may make it more
appropriate for the High Court to exercise self-restraint and not to
intervene because the error of jurisdiction though committed is yet
capable of being taken care of and corrected at a later stage and the
wrong done, if any, would be set right and rights and equities adjusted
in appeal or revision preferred at the conclusion of the proceedings. But
there may be cases where "a stitch in time would save nine". At the end,
we may sum up by saying that the power is there but the exercise is
discretionary which will be governed solely by the dictates of judicial
conscience enriched by judicial experience and practical wisdom of the
judge."
LO.2 In Shalini Shyam Shettyo, Supreme Court held as under:
"48. The jurisdiction under Article 227 is exercised by the High Court for
vindication of its position as the highest judicial authority in the State.
In certain cases where there is infringement of fundamental right, the
relief under Article 226 of the Constitution can be claimed ex debito
justitiae or as a matter of right. But in cases where the High Court
exercises its jurisdiction under Article 227, such exercise is entirely
discretionary and no person can claim it as a matter of right. From an
order of a Single Judge passed under Article 226, a letters patent appeal
/)
./
,/
e /13
BRMR,J
CRP.No.294O
of 2023
or an intra-court appeal is maintainable. But no such appeal is
f
I
main&rinable from an order passed by a Single Judge of a High Court in
I
I
I
exercir)e of power under Article 227. ln almost all the High Courts, rules
have heen framed for regulating the exercise of jurisdiction under Article
226. llo such rule appears to have been framed for exercise of High
Court'rr power under Article 227 possibly to keep such exercise entirely
in the domain of the discretion of High Court.
49 (k) The power is discretionary and has to be exercised on equitable
princip,le. In an appropriate case, the power can be exercised suo motu.
(l) On a proper appreciation of the wide and unfettered power of the High
Court ,tnder Article 227, it transpires that the main object of this article
is to kcep strict administrative and judicial control by the High Court on
the adrninistration of justice within its territory."
1. It is the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner -
plaintiff that suit schedule property is within the jurisdiction and
under HMDA region, house permission cannot be granted by village
authorities namely Sarpanch/Panchayat but only by the HMDA and
the respondent - defendant has presented certain documents which
are fake, feilse, spurious and dubious, which is established by virtue
of the report of the Tahsildar, shankarpally, allegedly claiming that he
is in possession of land in survey No.692 to an extent of Ac.3-12
guntas in Janwada Village, Shankarpally Mandal, Ranga Reddy
District. These are the matters which are to be gone into while
deciding th,: main CRP itself. The primary question is whether CRp is
maintainable under Ar.ticle 227 of the Constitution of India?
l2.L Any person being aggrieved by an order passed under Section
340 of the code of criminal procedure either refusing to make a
\\
\
-l
lol l3
BRMR,J
CRP.No.2940 of2023
complaint or making a complaint, may prefer appeal to the court to
which the court passing the order is sub-ordinate. Thus, against an
order dismissing an application under Section 340 of the code of
criminal Procedure, revision is not maintainable due to the bar, as
provided under Section 34L(21 of the Code of 'Criminal Procedure.
Likewise if an order is passed under Section 341 of the code of
Criminal Procedure by the appellate Court the same is not revisable
by the High court. However, the High court can invoke its inherent
power under Section 482 of the Code of criminal Procedure in an
appropriate case, which has been, accordingly, upheld in the case of
Lalit Mohan v. Binoyendra Nath, as reported in (L98213 SCC 219: AIR
1982 sc 785. Likewise when the order challenged in the appeal is one
passed under Section 34o of the code of Criminal Procedure by the
sub-Court directing a complaint to be made to the concerned lst
class Magistrate court, then in view of {irst part of sub-section (4) of
Section 195 of the Code of Criminal Procedure read with Section 341
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the appeal will lie to the District
Court and, thus, an appeal directly presented to the High Court in
such cases is not maintainable. See: Darastul Khalifs.
12.2 This original petition cannot be entertained under Article 227 of
the constitution of India. The petitioner wrongly liled an appeal before
the wrong forum and obtained a judgment of dismissal. Though
authorised under Section 340 of the code of criminal Procedure
r1l13
BRMR,J
CRP.No.294O of 2O23
I
enquiry r'/as conducted and decision was taken by the civil court.
II
Section 340 of the code of criminal Procedure empowers any court
I
I
i
I
:
including civil court to conduct enquiry as provided therein and to
make conrplaint before the proper court. A criminal Appeal can be
brought before the sessions court under section 341 of the code of
criminal Procedure only against an order passed by the criminal
court un<ler section 340 of the code of criminal Procedure. when
such order is passed by the civil court, the proper remedy is to file
appeal agrinst the said order before the appellate court on the civil
side. lnste,ad of filing a civil Miscellaneous Appeal (cMA) before the
civil appellate forum the petitioner wrongly filed a criminal Appeal
before the Sessions court. True, it is, that the person functioning in
both the c,rurts is the same. But the two forums are different. one is
District cc,urt and the other is court of Session, though handled by
the same person. The petitioner cannot find justification by saying
that he has preferred appeal before the same person. Appeal should
be filed before the court and not before the person. In this case appeal
will have tr be filed before the court to which appeals ordinarily lie
from the appealable decrees of the Munsiffs court, Iringalakkuda. I
Iind that this Original Petition cannot be entertained, and it is liable
to be dismissed without admission. However, it is made clear that the
petitioner r:an file a proper civil appeal before the proper court,
subject to the law of limitation. If not filed in time, he will have to file
\ \
\
.,
12/ L3
BRMR,J
CRP.No.2940 ot 2023
application to condone the delay, and such application will be
considered on merits by the appellate court, and appropriate decision
will be taken. See: V.A.Rocky'.
13. On careful reading of Section 341 of Cr.P.C which reads that
any person on whose application any Court other than a High Court
has refused to make a complaint under sub-section (1) or sub-section
(2) of Section 34O, or against whom such a complaint has been made
by such Court, may appeal to the Court to which such former Court is
subordinate within the meaning of sub-section (4) of Section 195.
14. The impugned order is passed by the learned Junior Civil Judge
Metropolitan MagisllaL at Chevella, Ranga Reddy District, the
appellate Court is the Principal District Court at Ranga Reddy, appeal
lies before the learned Principal District Court as per the decision
cited by the learned counsel for the respondents - defendants stated
supra in paragraph Nos.12.1 and L2.2.
15. The decisions cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner plaintiff stated supra at paragraph Nos.10.1 and lO.2 are
distinguishable from the facts of the case hence they are not
applicable. This Court is not discussing the other contentions raised
by the learned counsel on record apart from the decisions cited
thereon in view of the fact that the CRP itself is not maintainable
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
/
./
l3/ 13
BRMR,J
CRP.No.294O of 2O23
16' CR'l filed by the petitioner - plaintiff is not maintainable in view
of the sp,ecific bar under Section 341 of cr.p.c. The petitioner
plaintiff c,rn avail remedies by firing the appeal before the
_
appropriate
Court subject to the law of limitation.
17.
with the above said observation, cRp is disposed of. There shafi
be no orde r as to costs
Interim orders if any stands
vacated, miscellaneous
applicatiorr/s shall stand closed.
Sd/. P.PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
,/TRUE
COPY"
G
SEGTION OFFICER
To,
l.TheJuniorCivilJudge.curn-MetropolitanMagistrateatChevella,Ranga
ReddY District'
tOPy-C]..^
2. one CC to sripurnima Singh' Advocate
Advocate
[OPUCI
Sannapaneni'
3. One CC to Sri Lohit
.4. Twc CD CoPies
Kam/BA
N,
,
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2710212026
( oB
ORDER
CRP.No.2940 ot 2023
o
1tt ES
1/ ll! fl i0ffi
z
.*
DISPOSING OF THE
CIVIL REVISION PETITION
\1
\6
\
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review