The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. 06.2025 passed by this Court in B.A. No.12 of 2025 by this time has attained finality and the accused persons-in-custody did not challenge the said order to any other appropriate forum. Considered. In the case at hand, the prosecution was set into motion that on the basis of an FIR laid by one Badal Saha to O/C Amtali P.S. alleging interalia that on the day of Bishwakarma Puja, after watching Bishwakarma Puja, his son Subankar Saha was returning back to home alongwith his friend by riding his scooty in the late night and when said Subankar and his friends reached in between Loknath and Rajib Chowmuhani, that time two groups were involved in quarrel with each other. Suddenly, persons of one of the groups attacked his son with deadly weapons from the front and cut his face, mouth and throat, resulting which his son sustained severe bleeding injuries on his person and fell down on the earth and his accompanied friends were also tried to rescue his son and further, they also sustained injury. Immediately, thereafter, his son was referred to Hapania Hospital and from (9) there he was further referred to GBP Hospital and from the report of x-ray, it appears that his son sustained fatal injuries. On the basis of the said FIR, the O/C, Amtali P.S. on 18.09.2024 at about 1325 hours registered Amtali P.S. case No.118 of 2024 under Section 127(1)/118(2)/109/3(6) of BNS, 2023 and in course…
29. 11.2025 which in the considered opinion of this Court was not proper and this type of practice should be stopped henceforth. It is always to be kept in mind that the accused persons are lodging in jail and they have not yet been convicted by the Learned Trial Court and trial is to be conducted accordingly at an earliest for every proper and fair justice. It is also on record that although by order dated
01. 09.2025 Learned Trial Court ordered for supplying the copy of the supplementary chargesheet but as submitted by Learned Counsel for the accused persons-in-custody, the same has not been supplied to them. It is the duty of the Learned Trial Court to ensure supply of copies of chargesheet to the accused persons or (11) to their engaged Learned Counsels under Section 207 of Cr.P.C. corresponding to Seciton 230 of BNSS. Without supplying of the same it is quite natural that it would be difficult on the part of the accused persons to conduct their defence properly. At the time of hearing, Learned Counsels for the accused persons-in-custody submitted that the electronic evidence and other relevant documents including the report of SFSL were not provided to them. Accordingly, it is directed that before recording evidence, Learned Trial Court shall ensure supply of the copies of supplementary chargesheet either to the accused persons or to their engaged Learned defence Counsel in-accordance-with law after obtaining their signatures on the margin of order sheet. I have also gone through the case diary properly. It appears to this Court that considering the materials on record, this Court by order dated 23.06.2025 has cancelled the bail granted to the accused persons-in-custody. So, before this Court, at this stage, there is no new materials for considering bail to the accused persons-in…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A.No.93 of 2025
Smt. Jyoti Rani Banik,
W/o: Late Dhirendra Chandra Banik,
Resident of: Rajib Chowmuhani, A.D. Nagar
Road No.14, Badharghat, P.O.: Badharghat,
P.S.: Amtali, District: West Tripura.
---- Applicant (s)
On behalf of1. Sri Dilip Banik @ Suman,
S/o: Late Dhirendra Chandra Banik,
Resident of: Rajib Chowmuhani Road No.14,
P.O.: Badharghat, P.S.: Amtali,
District:West Tripura.
2. Sri Dipen Banik,
S/o: Late Sri Dhirendra Chandra Banik,
Resident of: A.D. Nagar Road No.14,
Rajib Chowmuhani, P.O.: Badharghat,
P.S.: Amtali, District: West Tripura.
3. Sri Jayanta Debnath,
S/o: Sri Rajani Debnath,
Resident of: A.D. Nagar Road No.14,
Chowrangi Para, P.S.: Amtali,
District: West Tripura.
---- Accused Person (s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
Along with
B.A.No.96 of 2025
Smt. Lipa Das (Sen),
W/o: Sri Santanu Sen @ Rupan, aged about 32 years,
Resident of A.D. Nagar Road No.14, Rajib Chowmohani,
P.O.: S.D. Mission, P.S.: Amtali, Agartala,
District: West Tripura.
---- Applicant (s)
Sri Santanu Sen @ Rupan,
S/o: Sri Swapan Kumar Sen,
Aged about 39 years,
Resident of A.D. Nagar Road No.14,
Rajib Chowmohani, P.O.: S.D. Mission,
P.S.: Amtali, Agartala, District: West Tripura.
(2)
The accused person being lodged in judicial custody,
the present petition is preferred and presented
by the wife of accused person.
---- Accused Person (s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
[---
_________________________________________________________
In BA No.93 of 2025
For Applicant (s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Adv.
Mr. Ankan Tilak Paul, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
:
Mr. Sankar Lodh, Adv.
In BA No.96 of 2025
For Applicant (s)
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
_________________________________________________________
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
28/10/2025
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Ratan Datta appearing on
behalf of the applicants-accused-in-custody namely, Sri Dilip Banik
alias Suman, Sri Dipen Banik, and Jayanta Debnath in connection
with B.A. No. 93 of 2025 and also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S.
Lodh appearing on behalf of the accused-in-custody namely Sri
Santanu Sen alias Rupan in connection with B.A. No.96 of 2025.
Further, heard Learned Additional P.P., Mr. Rajib Saha appearing
on behalf of the State-respondent. Both these bail applications
have been filed under Section 483 of BNSS, 2023 for granting bail
to the aforesaid accused persons in custody.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel, Mr. Ratan
Datta appearing on behalf of the accused persons-in-custody first
of all drawn the attention of the Court that on the basis of an FIR
laid by one Badal Saha this case was registered against the
aforesaid accused persons and two others. The accused Papan
Chakraborty and Piklu Sen alias Suman are presently on bail and
(3)
the other accused persons are in custody. It is further submitted
by Learned Counsel, Mr. Datta that during investigation the
aforesaid accused persons surrendered before the Court and they
were granted bail, but thereafter, challenging their bail the State
of Tripura preferred an application under Section 483(3) read with
Section 528 of BNSS for cancellation of the order of bail dated
07.01.2025 passed by Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court
No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with ST(T-1)-03 of
2025 and this Court after hearing both the sides by order dated
23.06.2025 passed in B.A. No.12 of 2025 cancelled the bail
granted to the accused persons-in-custody namely Santanu Sen
alias Rupan, Jayanta Debnath, Dilip Banik alias Suman, Dipen
Banik alias Kenchu and since from the month of July they are
lodging in custody. It was further submitted that before the
Learned Trial Court the petition was moved for discharging
accused
Papan
Chakraborty
under
Section
of
Cr.P.C.
corresponding to Section 250 of BNSS but the Learned Trial Court
without proper application of mind has rejected the same. It was
also submitted that in this case, supplementary chargesheet was
submitted by I.O. and the Learned Trial Court by order dated
01.09.2025
ordered
for
supplying
supplementary
copy
of
chargesheet to the accused persons but that was not complied
with
and
surprisingly,
without
furnishing
the
copy
of
supplementary chargesheet by order dated 12.09.2025 Learned
Trial Court mechanically framed charge against all the accused
persons and more interestingly, on that date no calendar was
fixed, rather after a considerable long period, Learned Trial Court
(4)
has fixed the date for fixing of calendar on 29.11.2025 which was
not permissible in the eye of law. So, Learned Counsel urged for
granting bail to all the accused persons stating that they are all
family persons and languishing in jail without any valid cause.
Further, Learned Counsel Mr. S. Lodh appearing on
behalf of accused, Santanu Sen alias Rupan also reiterated the
same submission and further submitted that the copies of
supplementary charge-sheet were not supplied to the accused
persons by the Learned Trial Court and without supplying the copy
charge has been framed by order dated 12.09.2025 which has
caused
injustice
to
the
accused
persons-in-custody
and
considering the long incarceration of the accused persons-incustody Learned Counsel also urged for releasing his accused on
bail in any condition.
Learned Counsel, Mr. Datta at the time of hearing
relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Manish Sisodia vs. Directorate of Enforcement reported in
(2024) 12 SCC 660, wherein in para Nos.47, 50, 51 and 52,
Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“47. We find that, on account of a long period of
incarceration running for around 17 months and the trial
even not having been commenced, the appellant has been
deprived of his right to speedy trial.
50. The Court observed thus: (Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh
case [Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra,
(2024) 9 SCC 813 : (2025) 1 SCC (Cri) 222] , SCC p. 820,
para 17)
“17. If the State or any prosecuting agency
including the court concerned has no wherewithal
to provide or protect the fundamental right of an
accused to have a speedy trial as enshrined under
Article 21 of the Constitution then the State or
any other prosecuting agency should not oppose
the plea for bail on the ground that the crime
committed is serious.
Article 21
of the
Constitution applies irrespective of the nature of
the crime.”
(5)
51. The Court also reproduced the observations made in
Gudikanti Narasimhulu [Gudikanti Narasimhulu v. High
Court of A.P., (1978) 1 SCC 240 : 1978 SCC (Cri) 115] ,
which read thus: (Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh case [Javed
Gulam Nabi Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra, (2024) 9 SCC
813 : (2025) 1 SCC (Cri) 222] , SCC p. 816, para 8)
“8. In the aforesaid context, we may remind the
trial courts and the High Courts of what came to
be observed by this Court in Gudikanti
Narasimhulu v. High Court of A.P. [Gudikanti
Narasimhulu v. High Court of A.P., (1978) 1 SCC
240 : 1978 SCC (Cri) 115] We quote (SCC p. 243,
para 5):
„5. … What is often forgotten, and therefore
warrants reminder, is the object to keep a
person in judicial custody pending trial or
disposal of an appeal. Lord Russel, C.J., said
[R. v. Rose [R. v. Rose, (1898) 18 Cox CC
717]]:
“I observe that in this case bail was
refused for the prisoner. It cannot be too
strongly impressed on the magistracy of
the country that bail is not to be
withheld as a punishment, but that the
requirements as to bail are merely to
secure the attendance of the prisoner at
trial.” ‟ ”
52. The Court in Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh case [Javed
Gulam Nabi Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra, (2024) 9 SCC
813 : (2025) 1 SCC (Cri) 222] further observed that, over
a period of time, the trial courts and the High Courts have
forgotten a very well-settled principle of law that bail is
not to be withheld as a punishment. From our experience,
we can say that it appears that the trial courts and the
High Courts attempt to play safe in matters of grant of
bail. The principle that bail is a rule and refusal is an
exception is, at times, followed in breach. On account of
non-grant of bail even in straightforward open-and-shut
cases, this Court is flooded with huge number of bail
petitions thereby adding to the huge pendency. It is high
time that the trial courts and the High Courts should
recognise the principle that “bail is rule and jail is
exception”.”
Again, Learned Counsel referred another citation of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh vs. State
of Maharashtra & Anr. reported in (2024) 9 SCC 813 wherein
in para Nos.16, 17, 18 & 19 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as
under:
“16. Criminals are not born but made. The human potential
in everyone is good and so, never write off any criminal as
beyond redemption. This humanist fundamental is often
missed when dealing with delinquents, juvenile and adult.
Indeed, every saint has a past and every sinner a future.
When a crime is committed, a variety of factors is
responsible for making the offender commit the crime.
Those factors may be social and economic, may be, the
(6)
result of value erosion or parental neglect; may be,
because of the stress of circumstances, or the
manifestation of temptations in a milieu of affluence
contrasted with indigence or other privations.
17. If the State or any prosecuting agency including the
court concerned has no wherewithal to provide or protect
the fundamental right of an accused to have a speedy trial
as enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution then the
State or any other prosecuting agency should not oppose
the plea for bail on the ground that the crime committed is
serious. Article 21 of the Constitution applies irrespective
of the nature of the crime.
18. We may hasten to add that the petitioner is still an
accused; not a convict. The over-arching postulate of
criminal jurisprudence that an accused is presumed to be
innocent until proven guilty cannot be brushed aside
lightly, howsoever stringent the penal law may be.
19. We are convinced that the manner in which the
prosecuting agency as well as the Court have proceeded,
the right of the accused to have a speedy trial could be
said to have been infringed thereby violating Article 21 of
the Constitution.”
Further, Learned Counsel referred another citation of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Arvind Kejriwal vs.
Central Bureau of Investigation reported in 2024 SCC OnLine
SC 2550, wherein in para Nos.38 & 39 Hon’ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“38. This Court in Gudikanti Narasimhulu v. Public
Prosecutor (1978) 1 SCC 240), had highlighted that bail is
not to be withheld as a punishment. The requirement as to
bail is merely to secure the attendance of the prisoner at
trial. This Court in Manish Sisodia referred to and relied
upon the aforesaid decision and reiterated the salutary
principle that bail is the rule and jail is the exception. This
Court has observed that even in straightforward open and
shut cases, bail is not being granted by the trial courts and
by the High Courts. It has been held as under:
53. The Court further observed that, over a period
of time, the trial courts and the High Courts have
forgotten a very well-settled principle of law that
bail is not to be withheld as a punishment. From
our experience, we can say that it appears that the
trial courts and the High Courts attempt to play
safe in matters of grant of bail. The principle that
bail is a rule and refusal is an exception is, at
times, followed in breach. On account of non-grant
of bail even in straight forward open and shut
cases, this Court is flooded with huge number of
bail petitions thereby adding to the huge
pendency. It is high time that the trial courts and
the High Courts should recognize the principle that
“bail is rule and jail is exception”.
39. Bail jurisprudence is a facet of a civilised criminal
justice system. An accused is innocent until proven guilty
by a competent court following the due process. Hence,
(7)
there is presumption of innocence. Therefore, this Court
has been reiterating again and again the salutary principle
that bail is the rule and jail is the exception. As such, the
courts at all levels must ensure that the process leading to
and including the trial does not end up becoming the
punishment itself.”
Referring all those citations, Learned Counsel, Mr.
Datta drawn the attention of the Court that on bare perusal of the
record, it will appear that the Learned Trial Court without
application of proper mind dealt with the case and for that the
accused persons are unnecessarily languishing in jail and urged
for releasing the accused persons on bail in any condition in view
of the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
aforenoted cases.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. P.P., Mr. R. Saha
appearing on behalf of the State-respondent strongly opposed the
bail application filed by the accused persons-in-custody and
submitted that all though initially bail was granted by the Learned
Trial Court and thereafter, the State challenged the bail granted to
the accused persons and this Court after elaborate hearing of both
the sides by order dated 23.06.2025 cancelled the bail granted to
the present accused persons-in-custody and confirmed the bail
granted to the rest two accused persons, namely, Sri Piklu Sen
alias Suman and Sri Papan Chakraborty with certain observation
and since in this case charge has been framed, so, the matter may
be remanded back to the Learned Trial Court with a direction to
dispose
of
the
case
ensuring
supplying
copies
of
the
supplementary chargesheet with further direction to dispose of the
case giving top priority on the ground that the accused persons
are languishing in jail. It was also submitted that there are direct
(8)
incriminating materials against all the accused persons-in-custody
showing their implication with the alleged offence and as such
chargesheet was submitted against them and the Learned Trial
Court by the order dated 12.09.2025 framed charge against all of
them under Section 127(1)/118(2)/109/3(6) of BNS, 2023 and if
at this stage they are released on bail then the trial of the case
will be hampered and urged for dismissal of the bail application. It
was further submitted by Learned Addl. P.P. that the order dated
23.06.2025 passed by this Court in B.A. No.12 of 2025 by this
time has attained finality and the accused persons-in-custody did
not challenge the said order to any other appropriate forum.
Considered.
In the case at hand, the prosecution was set into
motion that on the basis of an FIR laid by one Badal Saha to O/C
Amtali P.S. alleging interalia that on the day of Bishwakarma Puja,
after watching Bishwakarma Puja, his son Subankar Saha was
returning back to home alongwith his friend by riding his scooty in
the late night and when said Subankar and his friends reached in
between Loknath and Rajib Chowmuhani, that time two groups
were involved in quarrel with each other. Suddenly, persons of
one of the groups attacked his son with deadly weapons from the
front and cut his face, mouth and throat, resulting which his son
sustained severe bleeding injuries on his person and fell down on
the earth and his accompanied friends were also tried to rescue
his son and further, they also sustained injury. Immediately,
thereafter, his son was referred to Hapania Hospital and from
(9)
there he was further referred to GBP Hospital and from the report
of x-ray, it appears that his son sustained fatal injuries. On the
basis of the said FIR, the O/C, Amtali P.S. on 18.09.2024 at about
1325 hours registered Amtali P.S. case No.118 of 2024 under
Section 127(1)/118(2)/109/3(6) of BNS, 2023 and in course of
investigation the I.O. produced accused Papan Chakraborty before
the Court on 19.09.2024, accused Dilip Banik and Dipen Banik
surrendered before the Court of Learned Jurisdictional Magistrate
on 25.09.2024. Accused Jayanta Debnath and Santanu Sen alias
Rupan were produced before the Court on 26.09.2024 and
accused Suman Sen alias Piklu Sen surrendered before the Court
of Learned Jurisdictional Magistrate on 30.09.2024 and after
completion of investigation IO submitted charge-sheet within time
and accordingly, by order dated 13.12.2024 Learned CJM took
cognizance of offence against all the accused persons and
thereafter in due course of time the case was committed to the
Court of Sessions for holding trial of all the accused persons. As
already stated challenging the order of bail granted to all the
accused persons by the Learned Trial Court State challenged the
same before this Court and this Court by order dated 23.06.2025
in B.A. No.12 of 2024 cancelled the bail granted to the accused
namely Santanu Sen alias Rupan, Jayanta Debnath, Dilip Banik
alias Suman and Dipan Banik alias Kenchu and confirmed the bail
granted to the accused Piklu Sen alias Suman and Sri Papon
Chakraborty after detailed hearing of both the sides and also after
perusal of the materials collected by IO during investigation in the
(10)
Case Diary and that order still stands good. Now the case is
pending for trial before the Learned Trial Court.
I have also gone through the record of the Learned
Trial Court. It appears that by order dated 12.09.2025 Learned
Trial Court has framed charges against all the accused persons of
this case and fixed the next date on 29.11.2025 for production of
accused persons from J/C and for making calendar. From the said
order, it appears that Learned Trial Court also rejected the
discharge application filed by one of the accused Sri Papon
Chakraborty. It is surprising that on that date i.e. on 12.09.2025
Learned Trial Court could fix the calendar of this case or on the
following day also Learned Trial Court could fix the calendar of the
case for recording evidence of prosecution witnesses but without
fixing any calendar Learned Trial Court has deferred the matter till
29.11.2025 which in the considered opinion of this Court was not
proper and this type of practice should be stopped henceforth. It
is always to be kept in mind that the accused persons are lodging
in jail and they have not yet been convicted by the Learned Trial
Court and trial is to be conducted accordingly at an earliest for
every proper and fair justice.
It is also on record that although by order dated
01.09.2025 Learned Trial Court ordered for supplying the copy of
the supplementary chargesheet but as submitted by Learned
Counsel for the accused persons-in-custody, the same has not
been supplied to them. It is the duty of the Learned Trial Court to
ensure supply of copies of chargesheet to the accused persons or
(11)
to their engaged Learned Counsels under Section 207 of Cr.P.C.
corresponding to Seciton 230 of BNSS. Without supplying of the
same it is quite natural that it would be difficult on the part of the
accused persons to conduct their defence properly. At the time of
hearing, Learned Counsels for the accused persons-in-custody
submitted
that
the
electronic
evidence
and
other
relevant
documents including the report of SFSL were not provided to
them. Accordingly, it is directed that before recording evidence,
Learned
Trial
Court
shall
ensure
supply
of
the
copies
of
supplementary chargesheet either to the accused persons or to
their engaged Learned defence Counsel in-accordance-with law
after obtaining their signatures on the margin of order sheet.
I have also gone through the case diary properly. It
appears to this Court that considering the materials on record, this
Court by order dated 23.06.2025 has cancelled the bail granted to
the accused persons-in-custody. So, before this Court, at this
stage, there is no new materials for considering bail to the
accused persons-in-custody. The citations as referred by Learned
Counsel for the accused persons-in-custody cannot be applied in
this case at this stage. Hence, both the bail applications filed on
behalf of the accused persons stands rejected. The accused
persons are to remain in J/C as before.
Further, on perusal of the case record, it appears that
in this case probably the I.O. has cited 24 nos. of witnesses in the
chargesheet. So, all endeavour should be made by the Learned
Trial Court to dispose of the case giving top priority, fixing short
(12)
dates, keeping it in mind that the accused persons are lodging in
jail and their valuable rights should not be curtailed. However,
since there is provision in the erstwhile Cr.P.C. or in the BNS for
alternation of the charge if required, so it is open for the Learned
Court below to alter the charge if the situation so demands or
requires. Since this is a case of murder, so, no specific timeline is
given to the Learned Trial Court to dispose of the case. However,
it should be kept in mind that the accused persons are lodging in
jail, so, at the time of disposal of the case, every attempt should
be made on the part of the Learned Trial Court to dispose of the
case by ensuring attendance of the witnesses in-accordance-with
law.
With this observation, both the bail applications stands
rejected and thus disposed of. Send down the record to the
Learned Trial Court alongwith a copy of this order. Return back
the Case Diary to I.O. through Learned Additional P.P. along with
a copy of this order.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.10.29 17:45:33
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review