Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
KABORAMBA Digitally
KABORAMBAM
M SANDEEP SANDEEP SINGH
Date: 2025.10.16
SINGH
18:45:52 +05'30'
Sl. No. 4
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Crl.) No. 19 of 2025
Smt. Leishangthem Dhanishwori Devi
State of Manipur; & Ors.
Petitioner
Vs.
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
(ORDER)
(Order of the Court was made by M. Sundar, CJ)
16.10.2025
[1]
Captioned ‘writ petition’ (‘WP' for the sake of brevity) has been filed
with a prayer seeking issue of a writ of habeas corpus.
[2]
In the hearing today, Mr. L. Okendro Singh, learned counsel for
writ petitioner and Mr. Th. Vashum, learned State counsel for all the three
respondents are before us.
[3]
This Court took up the main writ petition and heard out the same
with the consent of learned counsel on both sides.
[4]
Factual matrix in a nutshell is that the writ petitioner is spouse of
one ‘Shri Leiphrakpam Sanatomba Meitei @ Puremba, S/o L. Ibomcha Singh’
(hereinafter referred to as ‘detenu’ for the sake of convenience and clarity) who
was arrested on 24.04.2025 pursuant to FIR No. 28(4)2025 WGI-PS dated
24.04.2025 for alleged offences under Sections 308(2)(3)/351(2) of Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023 and Section 17/20 of Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Act, 1967 on the file of Wangoi Police Station in Imphal West; that while the
detenu remained incarcerated, a preventive detention order dated 20.05.2025
made by 2nd respondent (District Magistrate, Imphal West District) was clamped
on the detenu by resorting to Section 3(2) of ‘National Security Act, 1980 (Act
No. 65 of 1980’) [hereinafter ‘NSA’ for the sake of convenience and clarity]; that,
this ‘preventive detention order’ is referred to as ‘impugned preventive detention
order’ and the ‘2nd respondent’ who made the impugned preventive detention
order shall be referred to as ‘detaining authority’ (both for the sake of
convenience and clarity); that, the detenu was arrested (formal arrest as he was
already incarcerated) on 20.05.2025 at 4.00 pm pursuant to the impugned
preventive detention order; that, the detneu thereafter sent two representations
both dated 27.05.2025, one to the State Government and another to the
detaining authority; that, the representation sent to the State Government
appears to have been disposed of on 05.06.2025 but this was never
communicated to the detenu; that, the representation sent to the detaining
authority was not disposed of by the detaining authority, the detaining authority
sent it to the State Government and the State Government has disposed of the
same on 14.06.2025 and the same has been communicated to the detenu on
17.06.2025; that, in the interregnum, impugned preventive detention order
appears to have been approved by the State Government on 31.05.2025; that,
the impugned preventive detention order was confirmed by the State
Government on 02.07.2025; and that, the captioned habeas corpus petition is
before us.
[5]
The proceedings made in the listing on 06.10.2025 and 13.10.2025
read as follows:
‘06.10.2025
[1]
Mr. L. Okendro Singh, learned counsel for petitioner drew
our attention to ground No. 4 which reads as follows :
“(iv) Delay in communication of grounds: For that, the grounds
of detention were communicated only on 21/05/2025, a day after
the detention order, with no explanation for the delay. This
violates Section 8(1) of the NSA and the constitutional safeguard
under Article 22(5), which requires prompt communication.
(A.K. Roy v. Union of India, (1982) 1 SCC 271).
A true copy of the grounds of detention u/s 8(1) NSA, 1980 is
annexed as Annexure A/5.”
[2]
Section 8(1) of NSA Act, 1980 reads as follows :
“8. Grounds of order of detention to be disclosed to persons
affected by the order.—
(1)
When a person is detained in pursuance of a detention
order, the authority making the order shall, as soon as
may be, but ordinarily not later than five days and in
exceptional circumstances and for reasons to be recorded
in writing, not later than fifteen days from the date of
detention, communicate to him the grounds on which the
order has been made and shall afford him the earliest
opportunity of making a representation against the order
to the appropriate Government.”
[3]
On being pointed out that Section 8(1) itself makes it clear
that it shall ordinarily not be later than 5 (five) days, learned counsel
realized that the above ground is a non-starter.
[4]
The next ground urged is regarding delay in considering
representation. Learned counsel submits that representation was sent on
27.05.2025, the same was disposed of on 14.06.2025. It was also
submitted that the Advisory Board convened its sitting on 15.06.2025 and
the confirmation by the Government was on 02.07.2025. This
confirmation was communicated to the detenu on 04.07.2025, is learned
counsel say.
[5]
The above point on delay has not been articulated in the
petition and therefore, explanation (if any for the delay) has not been set
out in the affidavit-in-opposition.
[6]
Owing to the above, Mr. Th. Vashum, learned State
counsel requests for time to get instructions on the delay point and revert
to this court.
[7]
Request acceded to.
[8]
List on 10.10.2025.’
‘13.10.2025
[1]
Read this in conjunction with and in continuation of earlier
proceedings made in the previous listing on 06.10.2025.
[2]
Notwithstanding 06.10.2025 proceedings, today Mr. L.
Okendro, learned counsel for writ petitioner, wanted to raise three more
grounds and they are as follows:
(i)
Grounds of detention are not supported by documents as they
are based solely on Section 161 statements.
(ii)
Live and proximate link between arrest and grounds of
detention had snapped. [To be noted, this is Banik principle
[Sushanta Kumar Banik Vs. State of Tripura & others
reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 813 : 2022 SCC OnLine
SC 1333]. In this regard it is to be noted, the date of arrest
pursuant to ground cases is 24.04.2025 and the impugned
detention order has been made by the detaining authority on
20.05.2025.
(iii)
There is violation of Section 10 of ‘National Security Act, 1980’
(‘NSA’ for the sake of brevity) as the appropriate Government
(State Government in this case) has not placed before the
Advisory Board (Advisory Board constituted under Section 9
of NSA) the grounds of detention and the representation
(representation dated 27.05.2025 of the petitioner) within
three weeks from the date of detention of the detenu under
the detention order.
[3]
Mr. Th. Vashum, learned State counsel, has placed before
us the relevant files.
[4]
From the relevant files, it comes to light that the
appropriate Government has placed before the Advisory Board the
grounds of detention on 31.05.2025 but the representation dated
27.05.2025
has been placed before the Advisory Board only on
14.06.2025.
[5]
In this context, the date of detention of the detenu under
the impugned preventive detention order becomes relevant as Section
10 talks about ‘three weeks from the date of detention under the order.’
[6]
As regards delay in disposing of the representation by the
detaining authority, as the point has not been raised in the petition, Mr.
Th. Vashum, learned State counsel, sought further time to get details
and revert to this Court. To be noted, 27.05.2025 representation of the
detenu was disposed of by the detaining authority on 14.06.2025. This
period should be explained by the State counsel.
[7]
[6]
List on 16.10.2025.’
After adverting to the afore-referred proceedings, though multiple
points have been raised, in the hearing today, writ petitioner’s campaign against
the impugned preventive detention order was predicated on two points and the
two points are as follows:
(i)
There is non compliance qua Section 10 of NSA.
(ii)
There is unexplained delay in considering the detenu’s aforereferred representations dated 27.05.2025 by the detaining
authority.
[7]
As regards the 1st point set out supra, learned State counsel drew
our attention to paragraph 6 of the affidavit-in-opposition of 1st respondent,
which reads as follows:
‘6.
That, with reference to Para No. 7(v) of the Writ Petition, the
deponent begs to submit that the State Govt. had already sent the
detention order dated 20-05-2025 to NSA board on 31-05-2025 and
representation dated 27-05-2025 of the petitioner to NSA board on 1406-2025 for information and necessary action respectively.’
[8]
The files placed before us also buttress the aforementioned
position.
[9]
A careful perusal of the trajectory the matter has taken leaves us
with the view that there is infraction of Section 10 of NSA. The reason is Section
10 of NSA makes it clear that the appropriate Government shall, within three
weeks from the date of detention of a person under the Act, place before the
Advisory Board (a) the grounds on which the order has been made, (b)
representation, if any, made by the person affected and (c) when the order is
made by an officer under Sub-section (3) of Section 3 a report from the officer
under Sub-section (4) of Section 3.
[10]
A careful perusal of paragraph 6 of the affidavit-in-opposition of
respondent No. 1 (extracted and reproduced supra) as well as the files placed
before us bring to light that the detention order alone has been placed before
the Advisory Board on 31.05.2025 and the representation dated 27.05.2025 has
not been placed before the Advisory Board though the same was available with
the State Government on 31.05.2025. To be noted, the date of detention of the
detenu pursuant to the impugned detention order is 20.05.2025 and the time is
04:00 pm as (already alluded to supra) and three weeks therefrom elapsed on
10.06.2025. The representation dated 27.05.2025 has been placed before the
Advisory board only on 14.06.2025. In the case on hand, it may be possible to
lean in favour of compliance as the Advisory Board sat only on 15.06.2025 and
it had the benefit of perusing the representation dated 27.05.2025 but there is
no explanation for not placing the report from the detaining authority before the
Advisory Board.
[11]
A careful perusal of the files brings to light that there is no report
from the detaining authority and it is admitted that no such report was placed
before the Advisory Board. This means that the 3rd requirement qua Section 10
has not been complied with. This Court notices that there is no report from the
detaining authority at all. Therefore, in the facts and circumstance of the case on
hand, we find that there is no complete compliance qua Section 10 of NSA. This
would enure to the benefit of writ petitioner and therefore, we hold the 1st point
in favour of writ petitioner.
[12]
Though the 1st point is held in favour of writ petitioner, we deem it
appropriate to deal with 2nd point also as the same was heard out in the hearing.
[13]
The 2nd point, as would be evident from the narrative thus far, turns
on delay in considering detenu’s representation. As already alluded to supra, the
detenu has sent two representations both dated 27.05.2025, one to State
Government and another to the detaining authority. Though, it is contended that
the State Government disposed of the representation on 05.06.2025 and though
a short order in this regard is available in the file, there is nothing to demonstrate
that the same has been served on the detenu and what was served on the detenu
is only disposal of the representation on 14.06.2025 and this was served on the
detenu on 17.06.2025. In this, again, we find that the representation addressed
to the detaining authority has not been decided by the detaining authority but
the same has been forwarded to the State Government by the detaining authority
and the State Government has made an order. Be that as it may, learned State
counsel, adverting to 13.10.2025 proceedings (extracted and reproduced supra)
submits that he has since taken instructions and there is no explanation for delay
in considering the representation. In this regard, this Court deems it appropriate
to respectfully refer to Rajammal Vs. State of T.N. and another reported in
1999 (1) SCC 417. In this Rajammal case, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
if any delay is caused in disposal of the representation, owing to indifference or
lapse in considering the same, it will adversely affect further detention of the
prisoner. It was also held that length of delay is less important and what is of
significance is or in other words, the test is not the duration or length of delay
but as to how the same is explained by the authority concerned. In the case on
hand, we find that 21 days have been consumed from the date of representation
to the date of service of the disposal of the representation on the detenu. Though
vide our 13.10.2025 proceedings, time was granted for getting instructions to
explain the delay, no explanation is forthcoming and it is submitted that no
explanation is available. Therefore, this is a case where we are left with the lone
option of taking the view that there is unexplained delay in considering the
representation of the detenu and the same is fatal to the impugned preventive
detention order. This means that the 2nd point also enures to the benefit of writ
petitioner.
[14]
The narrative, discussion and dispositive reasoning thus far, leave
this Court with the considered view that the impugned preventive detention order
deserves to be dislodged in this habeas corpus legal drill at hand.
[15]
Ergo, sequitur is, captioned writ petition is allowed. impugned
preventive detention order dated 20.05.2025 made by 2nd respondent (District
Magistrate, Imphal West District), approval of the same by State Government on
31.05.2025 and confirmation of the same by the State Government on
02.07.2205 are set aside and the detenu, Shri Leiphrakpam Sanatomba Meitei
@ Puremba, aged about 34 years, S/o L. Ibomcha Singh of Langthabal Lep Makha
Leikai, PS-Singjamei, Imphal West Distrcit, is directed to be set at liberty
forthwith, if not required in connection with any other case/cases. There shall
be no order as to costs.
Sandeep
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will remain bound by this order as uploaded in
the official website of High Court
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review