Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SA No. 547 of 2025
2026:CGHC:6232
NAFR
RAHUL
JHA
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally signed
by RAHUL JHA
Date: 2026.02.06
10:42:15 +0530
SA No. 547 of 2025
Smt. Lakeshwari Sinha W/o Shri Shivlal Sinha Aged About 30 Years R/o
Village Girola, Tehsil Kondagaon, District Kondagaon, Chhattisgarh
Appellant
Versus
1 - Smt. Rambati Baghel W/o Late Debra Aged About 70 Years R/o Village
Girola, Tehsil And District Kondagaon, Chhattisgarh
2 - The State Of Chhattisgarh Through Collector Kondagaon, District
Kondagaon, Chhattisgarh
Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant(s)
: Ms. Renu Kochar and Mr. Vaibhav Mittal, Advocates
For State
: Mr. Anand Gupta, Dy. GA
Hon'ble Shri Justice Bibhu Datta Guru
Judgment on Board
04/02/2026
1.
The present Second Appeal has been filed under Section 100 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 by the defendant, the appellant herein, assailing
the judgment and decree dated 10/09/2025 passed in Civil Appeal No.
11A/2025 (Smt. Lakeshwari Sinha v. Smt. Rambati Baghel & Anr.) by the
learned Additional District Judge, Kondagaon, District Kondagaon. By
SA No. 547 of 2025
the said judgment, the First Appellate Court dismissed the appeal
preferred by the defendant and affirmed the judgment and decree dated
13/12/2024 passed in Civil Suit No. 01-A/2020 (Smt. Ramvati Baghel v.
Smt. Lakeshwari Sinha & Anr.) by the learned II Civil Judge Senior
Division, Kondagaon (C.G.) whereby the suit filed by the plaintiff was
decreed.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties shall hereinafter be referred to as
per their status before the Trial Court.
3.
(a)
The plaintiff filed the suit for declaration of title, cancellation of
sale deed and permanent injunction in respect of the suit land situated at
Village Masora bearing Khasra Nos. 255/1, 411/1 and 411/2, total area
admeasuring 7.00 acres pleading, inter alia, that the suit land was
originally allotted in the year 1958 in favour of Pandu, son of Chandar,
caste Ganda, by order dated 23.10.1958 passed by the District Head,
Bastar, in Revenue Case No. 70/A-15/57-58, as Pandu was landless and
the allotment was made for the purpose of livelihood and maintenance.
After the death of Pandu, the suit land was mutated in the name of
Debra, son of Budhram, and his name was recorded in the revenue
records on 12.01.1971. Debra, along with his wife/the plaintiff Ramwati
remained in cultivating possession of the suit property. Due to old age
and physical infirmity, Debra had given the suit land on adhiya (sharecropping) basis to Shivalal Sinha, son of Uday Sinha, about two years
prior to his death, who used to pay half of the agricultural produce to
Debra and the plaintiff for their livelihood. It was further pleaded that
SA No. 547 of 2025
Debra died on 07.05.2018 at Village Girola. After his death, when the
plaintiff demanded her share of the crop from Shivalal Sinha, he refused
and claimed that he had purchased the suit land. Thereupon, the plaintiff
obtained certified copies of the sale deed and revenue records and came
to know that Shivalal Sinha had got an illegal, fraudulent and fabricated
sale deed executed in favour of his wife, Smt. Lakheshwari Sinha, in
respect of the suit land. The plaintiff pleaded that her husband Debra was
illiterate, used to put thumb impressions, had no knowledge of legal
formalities and, due to old age and illness, was not in a sound mental
condition. It was alleged that taking undue advantage of his condition,
the defendants fraudulently procured the sale deed. According to the
plaintiff, she came to know about the said sale deed only on 05.11.2019
upon receiving its certified copy.
(b)
The defendants filed their written statement denying all allegations
of fraud and illegality. It was contended that Debra was the absolute
owner of the suit land and his name was duly recorded in the revenue
records as landholder. It was further pleaded that the sale deed was
executed by Debra during his lifetime with full knowledge and free
consent and that the plaintiff had knowledge of the sale transaction from
the very date of execution. The defendants asserted that the sale deed
was lawful, valid and binding upon the plaintiff and prayed for dismissal
of the suit.
(c)
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial Court
framed issues on 03.07.2023 and, upon appreciation of the evidence on
SA No. 547 of 2025
record, allowed the suit. The learned Trial Court held that the registered
sale deed dated 04.02.2017 was obtained by playing fraud upon Debra,
who was an illiterate and aged person and was incapable of
understanding the nature and consequences of the transaction. It was
further held that the execution of the sale deed was not voluntary and
was vitiated by misrepresentation and deceit. The Trial Court also
recorded a finding that the plaintiff was the sole surviving legal heir of
Debra and, therefore, entitled to succeed to the suit property under
Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act. Consequently, the plaintiff was
held entitled to declaration of title and recovery of possession of the suit
land from the defendant. The valuation of the suit and payment of courtfee were also found to be proper and in accordance with law.
Accordingly, the suit was decreed by declaring the sale deed dated
04.02.2017 as illegal, null and void, and by granting declaration of title
and possession in favour of the plaintiff.
(d)
Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree, the defendant
preferred a first appeal, which came to be dismissed by the learned First
Appellate Court, affirming the findings recorded by the Trial Court.
Hence, the present second appeal has been preferred.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the present Second
Appeal raises substantial questions of law inasmuch as the plaintiff, who
was not an executant of the registered sale deed, could not have
maintained a suit challenging its validity on the ground of alleged nonpayment of consideration, particularly when the actual executant,
SA No. 547 of 2025
namely her husband, never disputed the transaction during his lifetime. It
is further submitted that the findings of fraud and non-payment of
consideration recorded by the both the Courts are based solely on the
contradictory testimony of the plaintiff’s witness (PW-2), who himself
was a witness to the sale deed, and such findings therefore amount to
perverse findings of fact, warranting interference by this Court under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the appellant on the question of
admission and have carefully perused the impugned judgments and
decrees passed by both the Courts as well as the material available on
record.
6.
At the outset, it is to be noted that the jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is confined to the
examination of substantial questions of law. Interference with concurrent
findings of fact recorded by both the Courts is permissible only where
such findings are shown to be perverse, based on no evidence, or
founded on an erroneous application of law. Upon consideration of the
submissions advanced, this Court does not find that the present appeal
satisfies the aforesaid parameters.
7.
The contention of the appellant/defendant that the plaintiff, not being an
executant of the registered sale deed, could not maintain the suit is
devoid of merit. The suit was not based merely on the allegation of nonpayment of consideration but was founded on specific pleadings of
fraud, misrepresentation and deceit practised upon the executant, who
SA No. 547 of 2025
was found to be an aged and illiterate person incapable of understanding
the nature and consequences of the transaction. The plaintiff, being the
sole Class-I legal heir of the deceased executant, was legally competent
to question the validity of the sale deed after his death. The mere fact
that the executant did not challenge the transaction during his lifetime
does not preclude the legal heir from assailing a transaction which has
been found, on evidence, to be vitiated at its inception.
8.
The submission that the findings of fraud and non-payment of
consideration are based solely on the testimony of PW-2 is also not
borne out from the record. Both the Courts have arrived at their
conclusions on a cumulative appreciation of the pleadings, oral and
documentary evidence, admissions elicited in cross-examination,
conduct of the parties and surrounding circumstances, including the age,
illiteracy and physical condition of the executant. The testimony of PW2 has been considered in conjunction with other material on record, and
cogent reasons have been assigned for accepting the plaintiff’s case and
rejecting the defence version. The concurrent findings do not suffer from
perversity nor can they be said to be based on no evidence.
9.
The arguments advanced on behalf of the appellant essentially seek reappreciation of evidence and substitution of this Court’s view for that
concurrently taken by both the Courts, which is impermissible in a
Second Appeal.
10.
It is well settled, as reiterated by the Supreme Court in State of
Rajasthan and Others v. Shiv Dayal and Another, (2019) 8 SCC 637,
SA No. 547 of 2025
that interference in second appeal with concurrent findings of fact is
permissible only when such findings are shown to be based on
misreading of material evidence, contrary to pleadings, or such as no
reasonable judicial mind could have arrived at. The appellant has failed
to demonstrate that the findings recorded by the Trial Court and the First
Appellate Court suffer from any such infirmity.
11.
In substance, the submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant
amount to an invitation to this Court to re-appreciate the entire evidence
and substitute its own conclusions for those concurrently reached by
both the Courts. Such an exercise squarely falls outside the permissible
scope of jurisdiction under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
12.
Upon an overall consideration of the matter, this Court is satisfied that
the findings recorded by the Trial Court and affirmed by the First
Appellate Court are reasoned, based on proper appreciation of evidence,
and in consonance with settled principles of law. No substantial question
of law arises for consideration in the present Second Appeal.
13.
Consequently, the appeal, being devoid of merit, is dismissed at the
admission stage.
Sd/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Rahul/Gowri
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review