Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 724/2025
Smt. Kishni Devi W/o Late Sh. Chhitar Mal, Aged About
68 Years, R/o Ward No. 5, Near Ramdev Mandir, Dhani
Karigaran, Phulera, District Jaipur- 303338, Rajasthan
Smt. Pinki Devi Verma W/o Sh. Ratan Lal Verma, Aged
About 38 Years, D/o Late Sh. Chhitar Mal (Fitter C And W)
Phulera Grade C, R/o Ward No. 5, Near Ramdev Mandir,
Dhani
Karigaran,
Phulera,
District
Jaipur-
303338,
Rajasthan
----Petitioners/Applicants
Versus
Union Of India, Through General Manager, North Western
Railway, Hq Office, Jawahar Circle, Jagatpura, Jaipur 302017, Rajasthan
Chief Personnel Officer, North Western Railway, Hq Office,
Jawahar Circle, Jagatpura, Jaipur- 302017, Rajasthan.
The Divisional Rail Manager (E), Power House Road, N. W.
Rly, Jaipur- 302016, Rajasthan.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Satish Kumar Bhargava
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Bharat Vyas, Senior Advocate,
ASG assisted by Ms. Anushka
Khandelwal and Ms. Niti Jain Bhandari
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE INDERJEET SINGH
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK KUMAR JAIN
Date of conclusion of arguments
:
16.03.2026.
Date on which the judgment was reserved :
16.03.2026.
Whether the full order or only the
operative part is pronounced
Judgment
:
Full
Date of pronouncement
:
12.06.2026.
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
(2 of 10)
[CW-724/2025]
JUDGMENT
1.
Instant D.B. Civil Writ Petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is filed by the petitioners aggrieved from
order dated 21.10.2024 in original application No. 585/2024
(Jaipur) passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter
referred as "The Tribunal").
2.
The present D.B. Civil Writ Petition has been filed seeking the
following relief:"It is, therefore prayed that the present
D.B. Civil Writ Petition filed by the petitioner
may kindly be allowed. The order dated
21.10.2024 (Annexure-1) passed by the
learned Tribunal in OA No.585/2024 may
kindly be quashed and set aside. Prayer made
in the original application may kindly be
allowed. Any other order or direction which this
Hon'ble
Court
deems
fit
and
proper in the facts and circumstances of the
case may also be passed in favour of the
petitioners. Cost of this writ petition may also
be awarded in favor of the petitioners."
2. Submissions on Behalf of the Petitioners:2.1
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
husband of Petitioner No. 1 was in service of Railways and while in
service, he expired on 26.06.1998 due to prolonged illness. He
also submitted that at the time of death, the daughter of
Petitioner No. 1 was 4th passed and below 18 years of age, and
the respondents had communicated that for appointment, it was
required to have at least an 8th standard pass certificate and must
crossed age of 18 years. He further submitted that Petitioner No.
2 acquired the Secondary School Certificate in the year 2013 and
immediately applied for compassionate appointment, but the same
was not considered by the respondents, and the aggrieved
(3 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
[CW-724/2025]
petitioners filed an OA before the Central Appellate Tribunal, which
was dismissed on 21.10.2024 only on the ground that there was
delay
on
the
part
of
the
petitioners.
He further submitted that the petitioners had approached the
respondents on time, but the same was not considered at the
relevant time due to underage of petitioner No.2 and when the
petitioner No.2 has applied for compassionate appointment, her
case was not considered and was turned down on the ground of
delay. He also submitted that the purpose of compassionate
appointment is to help the family in harness and also to provide
financial support, but in the instant case, continuous refusal by
the respondents forced the petitioners to approach the Tribunal
and, further, after dismissal of OA by the Tribunal, instant writ is
filed before this Hon’ble Court. He also submitted that the
petitioners have made out a case for interference, as both are
females and not having any means of livelihood and only seeking
consideration
of
the
candidature
of
Petitioner
No.
for
appointment on compassionate grounds, in lieu of untimely death
of husband of petitioner No.1.
3. Submissions on Behalf of the Respondents :3.1
Aforesaid
contentions
were
opposed
by
the
learned
Additional Solicitor General (ASG) and submitted that after the
death of Chhitarmal, Petitioner No. 1 has filed an application for
consideration for appointment on compassionate grounds as the
daughter of Petitioner No. 1 has not attained the age of 18 years,
and same was returned with advice to submit when petitioner
No.2 attained age of 18 years. He also submitted that thereafter,
the application was filed on 01.01.2018 (30.12.2017), but there
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
(4 of 10)
[CW-724/2025]
was delay of more than 20 years and was not considered on the
ground of delay. He further referred Master Circular No. 16
(Annexure R-5) and submitted that due to delay in submission of
application i.e. beyond 5 years, the proposal cannot be considered
by the respondent(s), hence no case is made out in favoe of
petitioners. He also submitted that petitioners have not challenged
the provision, therefore, the O.A. was rightly dismissed by the
Tribunal.
4.
Heard learned counsel for petitioners and learned Additional
Solicitor General. Perused the material placed on record.
5. Facts of the Case :5.1.
Admittedly, the husband of Petitioner No. 1 and father of
Petitioner No. 2 expired on 26.06.1998, and an application for
compassionate
appointment
was
filed
by
Petitioner
No.
1,
(Annexure R/1), to which the respondents replied on 10.09.1999
(Annexure R/2). The Petitioner No. 1 was informed that the
daughter of Petitioner No. 1 can be considered for compassionate
appointment only if she passed Class VIII and attained the age of
18 years. Thereafter, an application was submitted on 01.01.2018
(30.12.2017). The respondents have replied vide letter dated
29.01.2020 (Annexure 4), stating that the application has been
filed after a substantial delay, i.e., 13 years after Petitioner No. 2
has attained the age of majority, and 20 years of the death of
employee.
5.2. The petitioners have filed O.A. No. 585/2024 before the
Central Administrative Tribunal, Jaipur, which dismissed the O.A.
on 21.10.2024, and the order is reproduced as under:-
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
(5 of 10)
[CW-724/2025]
"It is the case of the applicant that her father late Shri
Chhitarmal was working as Fitter in Carriage
Department of Western Railway till his death on
25.09.1998. Consequent upon his death, the widow
(mother of the applicant) applied for compassionate
appointment vide application dated 18.11.1998 and the
respondents vide their letter dated 10.09.1999
informed her that for appointment on compassionate
ground the minimum educational qualification is 8th
class pass and since the present applicant at that time
was only 4th pass, She will be eligible only after
attaining the age of 18 years and on passing 8th class.
So, after passing the 10th class applicant again applied
for compassionate appointment vide her application
dated 26.04.2014 and it was replied by the
respondents vide their letter dated 29.01.2020 stating
that "your application for compassionate appointment
20 years after the death of Shri Chhitar Mal and 13
years after attaining maturity is not justifiable
for the compassionate appointment"
Thereafter, applicant again submitted his application on
30.01.2023 attempting to explain that the delay was
on the part of the respondents. A legal notice was also
served on the respondents 01.08.2023 and in their
reply dated 04.09.2023, the respondents have stated
that letters/application dated 26.04.2018 & 19.05.2014
was not received by them and application dated
30.12.2017 which they have received was replied vide
their letter dated 29.01.2020. They further stated that
the deen or the come dro read deceased employee vide
letters dated 29.01.202 and 30.01.2023.
Shri Manu Bhargava, learned counsel for the applicant
reiterates the stand taken by the respondents in their
letter dated 04.09.2023 stating that the decision of
competent authority was communicated to the widow
of the deceased employee vide letters dated
29.01.2020 and 30.01.2023. He further states that
appointment on compassionate is not a legal right and
relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court of
Punjab Haryana in the case of Umesh Nagpal.
The father of the applicant died way back in 1998, the
application of the mother of the present applicant for
compassionate appointment was considered by the
respondents and being ineligible on account of
minimum educational qualification she did not succeed.
The present applicant at that time was only 4th class
pass and under 18 years of age. However, she applied
for grant of compassionate appointment in 2014 but
the same was rejected as more than 20 years had
passed since the death of her father. The learned
counsel for the applicant contented that the
respondents rejected her application in 2020 which was
filed in 2014 so there was no delay on the part of the
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
(6 of 10)
[CW-724/2025]
applicant, even if this argument is committed then also
there was ordinate delay as the employee died in 1998
and the applicant filed application for compassionate
appointment in 2014, even at that time 16 years had
passed whereas she attained the age of majority much
earlier as she was about 9-10 years old in 1998 as the
time of death of her father. Besides she remained mum
for about six years from 2014 to 2020 between the
period when she filed the application for compassionate
appointment
and
when
she
received
the
communication rejecting her application.
She has approached this Tribunal now in 2024 which is
about 26 years after the death of his father.
Compassionate appointment is not granted as
succession or inheritance, time is of utmost essence as
the compassionate appointment is given to help the
family of the deceased employee to tide over the
financial crisis suffered at the time of the death of the
breadwinner on his sudden demise. Any consideration
of the applicant 26 years after the death of her father
would defeat the very purpose of the scheme of
compassionate appointment.
It emerges that the respondents had considered the
case of the applicant and decided the same in a valid
and legal manner as such there is no infirmity."
6. Relevant Policy Governing Compassionate Appointment
6.1.
Learned Additional Solicitor General has referred the Master
Circular No. 16, (Annexure R/5), wherein the time limit for
seeking compassionate appointment is provided and same is
reproduced as under:-w
TIME LIMIT FOR MAKING COMPASSIONATE
APPOINTMENTS:
a. Normally all appointments on compassionate
grounds should be made within a period of five years
from the date of occurrence of the event entitling the
eligible person to be appointed on this ground. This
period of five years may be relaxed by the General
Manager, subject to the following conditions:
i. The powers shall be exercised personally by the
General Manager. It shall not be delegated to a lower
authority.
ii. The case should not be more than ten years old as
reckoned from the date of death.
iii.
The widow of the deceased employee should not
have
remarried.
iv.
The benefit of compassionate appointment
should not have been given at any time to any other
member of the family or to a near relative of the
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
(7 of 10)
[CW-724/2025]
deceased
employee.
v.
The circumstances of the case should be such as
to warrant relaxation of the time limit of five years.
vi.
The reasons for relaxing the time limit should be
placed on record.
vii. The request for compassionate appointment
should have been received by the Railway
Administration as soon as the son/ daughter to be
considered for compassionate appointment has
become a major, say within a maximum period of one
year.
The above delegation of powers is current upto
31.03.1992.
[No. E(NG)II/84/ RC-1/26 dated 18.04.1985 (RBE
112/1985 and E(NG)II/84/RC-1/26 dated 18.4.1990.
(RBE 68/1990)]
b. Where death occurred more than 10 years back
and also in cases where death took place between 510 years back but the conditions stipulated in para V
(a) above are not fulfilled, a compassionate
appointment is not within the competency of the
General Manager except in the case of loss of life in
course of duty or getting crippled in the course of
duty. However, in such cases, if compassionate
appointment is otherwise admissible and if after
careful examination of the case it is found that there
are special features or circumstances justifying
relaxation of time limit as also criteria, the cases
could be considered by the Railway Administration for
approaching the Railway Board for relaxation of as a
special case. Such a reference to the Railway Board
should be made by the Railway Administration only
with the personal approval of the General Manager.
[No. E(NG)II/87/RC-1/57 dated 21.8.1987. (RBE
218/1987)]
7. Issue for Consideration :7.1. The ground for dismissal of the petitioners’ claim is delay.
The very purpose of compassionate appointment is to provide
immediate relief to the bereaved family, and if such appointment
is sought belatedly, the object of the scheme stands defeated. It is
also settled that where an application is made after an inordinate
delay, the purpose for which the provision of compassionate
appointment exists already stands frustrated. The purpose of
compassionate appointment was recently considered by the
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
(8 of 10)
[CW-724/2025]
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Canara Bank v. Ajith Kumar G.K.,
reported in 2025 INSC 184, wherein reliance was placed upon
the observations made in case of Haryana State Electricity
Board v. Hakim Singh, reported in (1997) 8 SCC 85.
The policy to appoint a dependant family member
of an employee who has died-in-harness or has
been medically rendered unfit to perform further
job, thereby leaving the family in utter penury, is
not of too distant an origin. Going by law reports,
the policy seems to have originated during the
seventies of the last century and gained
momentum in the following decades with this
Court laying down guidelines from time to time for
grant of compassionate appointment. The rationale
for such appointment has been explained in
Haryana State Electricity Board v. Hakim Singh in
the following words:
“8. The rule of appointments to public service
is that they should be on merits and through open
invitation. It is the normal route through which one
can get into a public employment. However, as
every rule can have exceptions, there are a few
exceptions to the said rule also which have been
evolved to meet certain contingencies. As per one
such exception relief is provided to the bereaved
family of a deceased employee by accommodating
one of his dependants in a vacancy. The object is
to give succour to the family which has been
suddenly plunged into penury due to the untimely
death of its sole breadwinner. This Court has
observed time and again that the object of
providing such ameliorating relief should not be
taken as opening an alternative
mode
of
recruitment to public employment.
8. Findings :8.1. In the instant case, the death occurred in June 1998, and at
that time the application submitted by Petitioner No. 1 was only
for consideration of the candidature of Petitioner No. 2 after
attaining the age of majority. The Petitioner No. 2 attained
adulthood in the year 2002 or 2003, but no application was filed
till 2014 or 2017. After rejection of the petitioners’ claim on
(9 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
[CW-724/2025]
29.01.2020, the O.A. was filed only in the year 2024. The reason
for
the
delay
in
filing
the
OA
was
mentioned
that
last
communication was made on 30.01.2023.
9. Analysis and discussions9.1.
The material on record clearly indicate that despite the
communication dated 10.09.1999 issued by the respondents, the
application was made only in the years 2014 or in 2017. The
respondents have clearly taken a stand that they have not
received any application dated 26.04.2014 or 19.05.2014, thus it
is doubtful whether any application is submitted in year 2014. The
first application received by them was on 01.01.1998, (dated
30.12.2017).
Thus,
considering
the
entire
material,
the
respondents furnished a reply to the notice for demand of justice
on 04.09.2023, and the same has been submitted by the
petitioners with the writ petition. Admittedly, no application is filed
between
2002/2003
to
meaning
thereby
there
was
negligence in pursuing the candidature of petitioner No.2. The
material indicate that the respondents have acknowledged the
application dated 30.12.2017 and on basis of same considered the
case of petitioner. Thus, there is no justification part of the
petitioners,
so
as
to
consider
the
case
of
compassionate
appointment.
9.2. In Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana reported
in (1994) 4 SCC 138, the Hon’ble Supreme Court laid down that
compassionate appointment is not a vested right and it is meant
only to provide immediate financial relief and cannot be claimed
after lapse of time when crisis is over.
Identical issues were
considered in case of State of Haryana Vs. Rani Devi reported
[2026:RJ-JP:23131-DB]
(10 of 10)
[CW-724/2025]
in JT 1996 (6) 646, State Bank of India Vs. Raj Kumar AIR
ONLINE 2010 SC 93, Govt. of India Vs. P. Venkatesh AIR
ONLINE 2019 SC 363 and State of West Bengal Vs.
Debabrata Tiwari (2023) 5 SCC 712.
10. Conclusion:10.1. Having considered the legal position as referred hereinabove, the petitioners have no right to claim compassionate
appointment after lapse of a substantial period of time particularly
when the husband of Petitioner No. 1 died on 26.06.1998. The
present writ petition is being considered almost 28 years after
death of husband of petitioner No.1, and the entire emergency
arising from such death has already been over. Thus, the
petitioners have failed to make out a case for compassionate
appointment of Petitioner No. 2.
11.
In view of the discussion made herein above, the writ
petition preferred by the petitioners is hereby dismissed, along
with all pending applications, if any.
12.
No order as to costs.
(ASHOK KUMAR JAIN ),J
14-S/MONU
(INDERJEET SINGH),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review